Ido Aharoni on: Nation Branding: Some Lessons from Israel

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

πŸ“‚ Marketing

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] thank you so much for joining us today thank you for having me it's a pleasure
  2. countries like companies have brands that need to be managed uh how is Israel's brand
  3. perceived today and why well 10 years ago when we embarked on this uh new uh Endeavor new
  4. Enterprise New Direction Israel's brand was solely defined by Israel's problems with its
  5. neighbors so when people think of Israel Israel's DNA almost universally was about the conflict specifically about
  6. the conflict with the Palestinians but also about the conflict with the rest of the Neighbors in the region and largely
  7. Israel was perceived as a Relentless producer of bad news whether you agree with Israel or not becomes irrelevant
  8. when you uh are not attracted to the context and what we did um about six years ago after we completed the first
  9. uh phase of research uh we uh started to communicate Israel's attractive Dimensions attractive facets to the
  10. World by engaging in very effective Niche conversations with influential audiences
  11. worldwide uh emphasizing quality over quantity and the results were almost immediate so today when you look even at
  12. independent um indexes such as the country brand index Israel made tremendous progress from uh uh you know
  13. we started way down there the very bottom of the list and then two years ago number 45 last year number 30 and
  14. this year number 28 highlighting uh primarily Israel as a Bastion of creativity and Innovation Israel is a
  15. place of tremendous uh resolve and resilience and creative spirit so the combination of Israeli Innovation and
  16. Israeli creative spirit I think is the new uh added Dimension to the existing Dimension and by the way we are more
  17. interested um today in broadening the existing conversation than anything it's the most important
  18. thing that we can do for isra and Israel's economic interest and Israel's image we'll come back a little in in a
  19. little bit to what you're doing today but let's go back to the time when you became the sort of the the head of
  20. Israel's brand management team in Jerusalem I believe that was in September 2007 uh how did you uh Define your
  21. challenge and what exactly was your mandate um The Challenge was defined earlier than that I started the program
  22. uh back in New York after 911 I see and in fact the process started with the creation of the brand Israel Group which
  23. is a a group of uh marketing Specialists based in New York that happened in 2002
  24. and the first thing that we did we actually did two things the first was we added Israel to the uh brand asset
  25. valuator which is the world's largest database on Brands maintained by Young and rubicam out of New York and the
  26. second thing that we do we conducted our own independent research and with the findings of those research
  27. with of those studies we uh came up with the with the strategy the number one um challenge that we had is to
  28. change the mindset among Israelis and Israel's will wishers Israel's friends mostly in the Jewish community that the
  29. task at hand is not necessarily to win a debate which is the conventional wisdom
  30. that our job is to win a debate some imaginary debate that is always out there around some
  31. crisis and we say that to win a debate is an important thing but it is no less important to build relationships so you
  32. Chang a whole different approach so instead of trying to win a debate using cold clinical historical arguments what
  33. we're trying to do today and that's the challenge is to build relationships that
  34. are meaningful to both sides and serve the interests of both sides the consumer and the country and I think it's a
  35. challenge that every city or country or County that is interested in improving its overall positioning is facing today
  36. so that to your question as to what was the main challenge the Mandate the Mandate was uh basically to broaden the
  37. conversation that was the Mandate and the Mandate was given to me by the foreign minister at the time uh and I
  38. have to say that all foreign ministers that I worked with five of them since 2001 since 911 Shimon peris Silvan
  39. Shalom uh TP Livy uh Victor liberman all all of them were extremely supportive of the
  40. concept of broadening the conversation bearing in mind that a broader conversation will communicate the full
  41. reality that exists in Israel and by definition will help Israel with its tourism industry will help Israel to
  42. attract more foreign investment will help Israel to expose its culture all over the world and obviously to improve
  43. its image and Garner more and more political support it's a very interesting strategy
  44. you know focusing on relationship building could you tell us a little bit about how you came up with the strategy
  45. and and how do you measure uh your progress along this strategy well we measure our progress using several
  46. research instruments as I mentioned before uh we're using a database very well-known database maintained by Yang
  47. and rubicam we're using our own independent research uh that is being conducted with funds raised by uh local
  48. Jewish organizations as well as the Israeli government most recently we conducted a global study by TNS which is
  49. a global company part of the wpp family uh in 14 different nations from China all the way to
  50. Mexico uh and we're looking at other independent resources uh that were not commissioned by us I mentioned the
  51. country brand index but there are other uh resources that we look at for the most part indexes that heavily rely on
  52. media coverage uh are very difficult for us to uh to use and because media coverage is
  53. not necessarily the criteria that we're looking for we're looking for something that will tell us more about what is it
  54. that people feel toward Israel it's about the emot tie the quality of the emotional tie I can tell you that at
  55. least uh as far as Israel is concerned the city of New York did a great job with when Israelis say I love New York
  56. they actually mean it Israelis have real relationship with the city of New York so we believe that every place has a DNA
  57. and a personality just like like just like a human being and Israel has won as well Philadelphia has won as well
  58. Wharton School of Business has won as well and it's all about about the quality of that
  59. interaction right now uh in addition to the strategy what do you think was some of the uh tactical steps that that you
  60. took to implement the strategy and and and uh what lessons have you learned about what works and what doesn't work
  61. well the one thing that we know for sure that doesn't work is a self- congratulatory
  62. message when you uh as an institution and I think that the internet and the rise of Facebook teach us a very
  63. important lesson that the media consumer nowadays is very suspicious of institutions in general and I think
  64. governments and and you know uh specifically governments and the reason is because the consumer is well well
  65. aware of the fact that we're trying to sell him something that's why we don't think the the the term Nation branding
  66. is a is an accurate uh depiction of what we're doing and we'd rather use the term
  67. uh Place positioning or country positioning uh which which is really what we're trying to do maximize our
  68. Competitive Edge communicate our relative advantage to relevant audiences and when you do that you realize that
  69. people that passionately care about something let's say wine architecture medicine um they set aside political
  70. differences and they're willing to listen to what you have to say there was a book that was published about two
  71. years ago called startup Nation startup Nation started a whole new conversation about Israel why because it was relevant
  72. to many Americans struggling with the economic crisis startup Nation talked about how for example Israel
  73. successfully incorporates military veterans into the hech sector so one of the ideas the Practical ideas that came
  74. out of that book is let's train Human Resources directors in America how to read a CV of a military veteran when in
  75. Israel Human Resources directors they see a CV of a military veteran they know exactly what it means they know the unit
  76. numbers they know the skills they know what to expect and there for the transition from military to high-tech is
  77. far smoother you know which countries do you think are doing a good job with country
  78. positioning as you called it and are there any lessons that Israel can learn from them I can tell you that in our own
  79. process which I started 10 years ago we studied no less than 80 case studies of cities and cities of cities and
  80. countries I would say that by far the most successful and I think the most well documented uh process is actually what
  81. the city of New York did from uh the early ' 70s more specifically 1972 1973 under mayor Lindsay they
  82. continued under mayor cootch and of course under Giuliani with the association for better New York Abney
  83. which is active until this very day with the involvement of the private sector uh
  84. most notably the real estate sector in in Manhattan but what the city of New York did is the most most remarkable
  85. thing they changed the overall position of a city that was synonymous with crime
  86. and police corruption only 25 years ago they completely overall the image of New
  87. York and they did it I think um very effectively with great deal of of of of uh pressure and and economic uh uh
  88. difficulties another great example of an extremely successful uh Place positioning effort
  89. is of course what happened in Spain post Franco I think that uh the Franco era ended in 1975 their country positioning
  90. process started somewhere in the early 80s with the Everything Under the Sun and by the
  91. mid90s Spain went from being the you know the most unattractive country in southern Europe to the most attractive
  92. country in Europe and a a a a a tourism magnet with 50 million tourists a year if not more so Spain is a great example
  93. another great example in Europe is Croatia uh and of course when you're talking about cities today in Asia you
  94. can look with admiration at what is being done in Shanghai and of course Hong Kong uh
  95. despite all the efforts that uh you know countries make to to improve their own Brands as it were some obstacles
  96. obviously uh continue in Israel's case what would you say are the principal obstacles that exist in helping the
  97. country burnish its brand and what can be done about them well obviously the geopolitical situation is the number one
  98. obstacle the good news is that um we can never assume that the entire world is interested in geopolitics you know we
  99. went to France and we conducted a study among the French Elite and we wanted to know where do they stand on the Israeli
  100. Palestinian conflict and what we discovered was something very interesting 16% of the fr Elite
  101. supported the Palestinians only 9% supported Israelis now traditionally what we tried
  102. to do was to convert people from the group of 16 and move them over to the group of nine change the inner balance
  103. between the two groups but branding people will look at it and say wait you have to do something else 9 and 16 put
  104. together give you 25 25% of the French Elite bother to take a stand on this issue now you have 75% of the people in
  105. the study that were given a chance to make to to take a position on this issue yet they chose not to they're not
  106. interested in the geopolitics of the Middle East what is it that you bring to them 75% is Israel's room to grow in
  107. France I would say it to my competition too it's probably the same number 75 80%
  108. is the Palestinians room to grow in France now what is it that you bring to them those 75% there's a lot that we can
  109. share with with them can talk to them about business there's a lot of money to be made in Israel we can talk to them
  110. about Innovation Israel is the number one producer of conceptual products in the world we produce more scientific P
  111. papers per capita than any other Nation we lead the world in the amount of money
  112. invested reinvested in research and development so there's a lot of stuff that we can talk to them about but we
  113. didn't do it and once you engage in such a conversation with those Elites you discover that they're very responsive
  114. why because it's relevant to them interesting that that's really interesting you know Dave rebstein is a
  115. marketing Professor here at Wharton and he's done a lot of work on uh Nation branding and also has thought deeply
  116. about Israel uh and and we interviewed him in knowledge at Wharton uh sometime ago on this issue and he said something
  117. very interesting to us he said that in his view Israel is a very self-confident nation and it has had to be for its own
  118. Survival uh but at the same time the self-confidence can sometimes get in the way of
  119. learning do you agree with that view well I wish we were as self-confident as Mr ribston uh
  120. describes us uh it is uh for sure um you know Israel has to do a better job communicating its assets to the world
  121. because to me country positioning is all about two things it's about the ability
  122. to identify your own compe comptitive Edge and then it's about the ability to communicate that Competitive Edge to
  123. relevant audiences and once you do that and we haven't done that for many many years we thought that our job was to
  124. convince the world that we are right and our adversaries are wrong now that's an
  125. important thing to do but there is new thing today especially in the age of Internet it's called The Power of
  126. Attraction if you're not attractive it is it it becomes very difficult for you to be competitive out there and the
  127. competition out there is tough It's vicious the competition is between cities now traditionally we thought of
  128. Jerusalem as a city in competition with Cairo now with all the respect Jerusalem's competition should not be
  129. Cairo and I have a lot of respect for Cairo Jerusalem's competition should be Paris and Tel aviv's competition is not
  130. ramala and I have a great deal of respect for ramala Tel aviv's competition should be Barcelona and
  131. Israel's competition should not be Syria or Lebanon or Jordan Israel's competition should be Spain
  132. or Korea and that's that's the new mindset that we need to introduce to the conversation you
  133. know we talked often about conversation and conversation implies both speaking and listening do you think Israel needs
  134. to become better at listening to World opinion I think we are getting better and most of those conversations are
  135. taking place today online although I can tell you that the foreign Ministry itself self is one of many agencies in
  136. the Israeli government that is hosting groups from all over the world on a regular basis not only Jewish groups we
  137. just had in Israel a group of very influential Latino leaders we had a group of very influential unor Union uh
  138. leaders a group of very influential Evangelical leaders and uh we're willing to listen to what they have to say we we
  139. we're engaged in a in a productive conversation with them and I can tell you that one of our strengths is the
  140. fact that the Israeli system is so open um it's so pluralistic and it's so eclectic um I think we're second only uh
  141. to the United States in terms of our uh immigration policy and our willingness to embrace various different uh ethnic
  142. groups and engage in conversation with them so when your DNA when a big part of your DNA is diversity and the Embrace
  143. Embrace of variety I think it's very easy for you to contain uh uh criticism and to effectively cope with it and I
  144. think that we're doing gradually better uh in this Department no I think you're you're absolutely right especially about
  145. Israel's immigration policy I I know that uh we spoke recently to Z exin the former uh Deputy Governor of the Bank of
  146. Israel and he has done amazing research on how uh Israel has done such a fabulous job of integrating the Russian
  147. immigrants uh who who came uh to the country in fact the US I think could learn from from from Israel's experience
  148. in this regard uh uh you referred to the fact of that that you did some work with reaching out to different groups of
  149. people specifically what has been your strategy in terms of reaching out to non-jewish populations in countries like
  150. the US and to other non-jewish uh uh populations elsewhere well our research showed that in the United States um
  151. Israel was all about conflict mostly conflict and a little bit of uh Orthodoxy religious Orthodoxy and um and
  152. we say you know Israel is is way more than that what what can we do in order to change that so the first thing that
  153. we did we identified the areas and again this was done through research what is it that Americans are interested what
  154. what is it that interest the American people and it was a big surprise to us that the American people contrary to the
  155. common belief in Israel until that time until that point the American people was
  156. not so interested in what we have to say about the geopolitical situation not because they're against us on the
  157. contrary they they support us overwhelmingly so the level of political support for Israel was very high but we
  158. discovered much to our surprise that at the same time that Americans are very supportive of Israeli policies they're
  159. not very attracted to Israel's personality so we said Okay the reason is because they don't know who we are
  160. all they know about us is that we're engaged in this bloody dispute with our neighbors they have no idea what else we
  161. can bring to the table so let's expose that to them while managing the crisis by the way we never suggested to ignore
  162. the need to manage The Crisis crisis management is a big part of what we do the only thing we said is it can never
  163. be the only thing we do and for 60 years it was the only thing we did so we started to identify the areas in which
  164. we possess a clear relative advantage that is relevant to the American people so for example the environment a huge
  165. ation is taking place online about the environment Israel has three areas under the environment that are clear relative
  166. advantages one is Desert agriculture Israel is a world leader in that field the other is water desalination which I
  167. know you deal with here and the third is of course renewable energy emphasizing solar energy then on after the
  168. environment we identified lifestyle and Leisure is a Israel is a Powerhouse when
  169. it comes to architecture product design fashion design the emerging Israeli Cuisine even here in Philadelphia you
  170. have one of the greatest Israeli restaurants in North America uh emerging Israeli uh wine industry and so on and
  171. so forth the third area that we identified you mentioned ethnicity before is the people and the Heritage uh
  172. Israel is a place that brings together many ethnic groups many languages many religions many beliefs and so on the
  173. fourth area was of course culture and the Arts Israel is a Powerhouse when it comes to uh literature and modern dance
  174. and there's a new emerging film industry we're having for a fourth year in a row
  175. an Israeli film uh a finalist for the Academy Award for the best uh foreign picture um and we have uh great music
  176. and we have uh uh great Visual Arts and so on and so forth we have uh of course uh uh the area that we call uh
  177. International aid program in Hebrew tun the efforts that Israel is making to fix
  178. problems all over the world to heal disease we have hundreds of Israeli experts traveling all over the world
  179. trying to help we heal disease yesterday I spoke at this event for an organization called save a child's heart
  180. it's an Israeli organization that saved over 2500 children most of them are not Jewish from all over the world that
  181. suffer from chronic heart disease you bring them to Israel for medical treatment and you send them back home
  182. after they recover and we have so many things of that nature uh to celebrate so we identified five six pillars
  183. under the banner of a celebration of the unique Israeli creative Spirit one of innovation and and perseverance and
  184. resilience and we started to promote them you know creating those Niche markets and those n conversations and
  185. it's been extremely effective for us one perfect example is our relationship with
  186. the uh uh lgbtq Community even here in Philadelphia we have uh this coming May a big uh LGBT Summit uh from May 3rd to
  187. May 5th co-sponsored by the um Israeli consulate here in Philadelphia and it's going to be a big celebration of
  188. Israel's openness in this area all this is very interesting as as you change your strategy uh and your
  189. approach to broaden the conversation Beyond just conflict uh how is your how is the
  190. changing uh perception of Israel affecting The Branding of Israeli companies sadly most Israeli companies
  191. for many many years shied away from the uh from the super brand so if you look at the most successful Israeli companies
  192. they have international names with the exception of tea that has a Hebrew name most of them shied away from it so you
  193. look checkpoint amdoc Converse these are all Israeli companies but you you you will never know the advantage that we
  194. have is that on the municipal level in Israel see when we started the process 10 years ago when I first came up with
  195. the idea of let's look at Israel the same way you look at the product um the number one sub brand of
  196. Israel was the Israel Defense Forces IDF I would say the second most recognized brand name was the mad and
  197. the third most recognized brand name was Uzi a submachine gun so everything everything all the beacon sub Brands
  198. under the super brand were all related somehow through the conflict they all supported the DNA of the brand Today
  199. part of the change part of that new not new but part of this reinvigorated narrative that is being celebrated by
  200. Israelis and people that go to Israel one of creativity and Innovation is the fact that the new emerging sub brand uh
  201. most of the come from the municipal level most notably the city of Tel Aviv that is emerging as the beacon sub brand
  202. today of Israel together with the city of Jerusalem that is doing a great great job and other places like hia the city
  203. of hon which happens to be my hometown that really changed its image in the last 15 years and emerged as a as a as a
  204. very powerful sub brand so the brands that redefine Israel today all come from the municipal level right uh and and the
  205. efforts that you have made over the past decade to to burnish Israel's brand are
  206. there any things that you would have liked to try but you haven't been able to try yet things that I would of course
  207. yeah I would have loved to bring the Olympic Games to Israel I don't think it will happen soon
  208. but we have to work on it well someone has to the some preliminary work was done about that but I think uh um more
  209. more realistically uh what we need to to do is to bring to Israel some major conferences uh you have to put Israel on
  210. the map in the area of wellness and uh and um business tourism we're not getting enough uh business
  211. people to come and and and uh work in Israel and have fun at the same time uh so this is an area that we have to
  212. improve and of course the most important thing that I think we need to do as a nation is to restore the kibuts as a
  213. point of Attraction not the old kibuts which is an old Collective communal agricultural farming Community but the
  214. new kibuts which is um a uh a center of wellness and I think that the new kibuts
  215. the kibuts of the future uh can be a great addition to the Israeli tourism industry which is thriving these days uh
  216. we just had a record year 2011 and hopefully 2012 will even break that record great well ID thank you so much
  217. for joining us today thank you for having me it's been a pleasure [Music]

Brief Summary

Israel's brand has evolved from conflict-focused to highlighting creativity and innovation through strategic relationship building.

Key points

  • Israel's Brand Transformation. Israel's brand has evolved from conflict-focused to highlighting creativity and innovation.
  • Engaging with Global Audiences. Israel aims to broaden conversations and engage with diverse audiences worldwide.
  • The Challenge of Brand Management. The main challenge was to change the mindset among Israelis and their supporters.
  • Measuring Progress in Branding. Progress is measured through various research instruments and emotional ties.
  • Learning from Successful Branding. Israel studied successful branding cases from cities like New York and countries like Spain.
  • Celebrating Israeli Creativity. Israel is promoting its unique creative spirit through innovation and resilience.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes