Immigration Reform Policy Simulator Overview

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hi I'm Kent Smithers a professor here at the Wharton School and now I'm going to
  2. give you a quick overview of the new immigration reform policy simulator it's available to Penn Wharton budget model
  3. group notice that you have several different graphs that you can look at things like total population size and
  4. number of jobs the old-age dependency ratio that's very useful for things like understanding how many young people that
  5. we have / older retiree and then of course gross domestic product GDP that people often care about so now let's
  6. consider different policy combinations each one a dial control here has five selections and we have three policies
  7. altogether so that's a hundred twenty five different policy combinations that you can get and see yourself for each
  8. policy combination you know the actual simulation model takes several hours to run in the case of immigration but we
  9. use advances in cloud computing to give you instant feedback on the results because we pre computed everything for
  10. you all right let's go through the different policies let's think about increasing the net amount of legal
  11. immigration right now from this tool tip you can see that net legal immigration to the United States currently amounts
  12. about 800,000 people per year and some of the policy ideas out there is to maybe increase that maybe twenty five
  13. percent a year and not so surprisingly population goes up total number jobs are going to go up and GDP is also improved
  14. because of more workers in the economy and the old-age dependency ratio is slightly improved as well in particular
  15. we're going to have a fewer older people per worker because immigrants are coming
  16. in typically during working age and we are able track that fairly precisely using census level data alright let's
  17. talk about some other potential changes here and the first one is or the second one sorry is changing now the
  18. composition of the net legal immigration right now as you can even those tooltip about thirty five
  19. percent of the US adult legal immigrants have a bachelor's or advanced degree so
  20. the idea here is that we can now increase that percentage without actually in painting they eat hundred
  21. thousand a number of legal immigration immigrants per year and so we can look at a couple things like you know what
  22. happens to GDP here if suppose we go from thirty five percent to fifty five percent and now that's a slight positive
  23. it's not huge and it's true that this the values here are in trillions of dollars but you can move your mouse over
  24. and see the actual numbers or if you want to you can always zoom in in a particular set of years and get even
  25. more precision there if you if you'd like and in particular the blue line is the current policy the red line is the
  26. effects of the new policy and the reason why it's it's not a big impact is that legal immigration flow at eight hundred
  27. thousand per year is not that large of a fraction of the US population workforce
  28. and so going from thirty five percent to fifty five percent of being college-educated it's only going to add
  29. around 160,000 college graduates per year and that's only about one half of one percent of all college educated
  30. worker workers in the economy and so it doesn't have a tremendously large impact
  31. all right now let's look at a couple other policies and the one is to potentially increase deportation of a
  32. unauthorized immigrants so now we're really shifting from legal status to unauthorized immigrants and the other
  33. one is to offer legal status just the opposite to unauthorized immigrants we can see from the tool tip that there's
  34. about 11.3 million unauthorized immigrants in the United States and so if you choose to go say this direction
  35. of legalization is the same we're going to be legalized in a roughly around ten percent per year so within a decade will
  36. have legalized everyone and so let's look at the impact on jobs and this may be a surprising to a lot of people as we
  37. legalize and notice jobs actually slightly go down it's a huge change but it does it's actually legalization
  38. actually leads to fewer I jobs again not a big change but it is technically negative and the intuition there is that
  39. if you're currently unauthorized you pretty much have to work and in order to survive and so unauthorized workers
  40. actually have a higher labor force attachment rate or participation rate than those that are authorized
  41. authorized workers are able to now go to school and therefore not be in the workforce for a period they're able to
  42. look for a better job a more appropriate job because they can qualify for unemployment insurance things like that
  43. and so that tends to reduce jobs to the impact on GDP is basically a wash there's no particular theoretical reason
  44. this would be the case but in terms of the art rather detailed calculations it's basically a wash and it has almost
  45. no impact on GDP and the intuition there is that even though the number of jobs has gone down a little bit the once you
  46. are converted to legal status again you're able to go to school you're able to get more productivity and so as a
  47. result of that the impact on GDP is next to nothing now let's think about what happens when we go the opposite
  48. direction where we start deporting it's a ten percent per year within a decade everybody would be all the unauthorized
  49. illegal immigrants would be deported now notice the impact unemployment is now much more negative and the the reason
  50. behind that is that we're losing people it's like a hundred percent detachment now for the workforce for unauthorized
  51. immigrants in the the native-born participation rate in the labor market cannot possibly rise enough to meet that
  52. that gap that or that reduction the number of jobs and GDP also goes down are pretty substantially you can see by
  53. within by 2035 close to the trillion dollars reduction in GDP and so you know both these
  54. policies have been kind of advocated on both sides of saying that they're going to increase the number of jobs or
  55. increase GDP in fact neither policy I works in the way that it's often then presented and so you can try many other
  56. combinations yourself again you have about 125 different combinations to choose from and again many combinations
  57. I've explored myself so try they try it yourself and it make up your own mind thank you

Brief Summary

The episode covers a new immigration policy simulator and its impact on jobs and GDP.

Key points

  • Immigration Policy Simulator Overview. Kent Smithers introduces a new simulator for exploring immigration reform policies.
  • Impact of Legal Immigration Increase. Increasing legal immigration by 25% improves jobs and GDP, but the effect is modest.
  • Legalization vs. Deportation Effects. Legalizing unauthorized immigrants may slightly reduce jobs, while deportation has a significant negative impact.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes