New Findings on Immigration and Social Security Solvency

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

πŸ“‚ Public Policy 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. so Kent there's a lot of talk that Social Security just won't be there for younger people right so my question is
  2. will Millennials receive the same Social Security benefits as their parents under
  3. current law the answer is no in fact we're projecting that the trust fund will be exhausted by
  4. 2031 just 14 years so what the law actually says is that benefits across the board have to be cut um in order to
  5. Simply match the current payroll tax revenue that they're getting at the time so that's about 30% reduction and more
  6. that means 2034 or so in 2031 31 yeah if nothing changes then Social Security uh
  7. benefits payments monthly payments would have to be cut by 30% for everyone and that's the key it's not just for new
  8. retirees which could be a little less painful but your 90-year-old grandmother who's Maybe just surviving that Social
  9. Security the benefits would be cut for her as well okay so um so of course everyone's scrambling to figure out what
  10. are some things that could be done about this uh one of the uh common ideas is to
  11. raise the retirement age for Social Security how much does that help it doesn't help much for the short term in
  12. particular barely moves the trust fund exhaustion date um from 2031 um and the reason why why is that
  13. under current law Social Security retirement age is creeping up to age 67 even if you push it out to age 70 it
  14. this idea that's been battered around for a couple decades in Washington we just kind of waited too long to do it um
  15. and so it barely moves the trust fund exhaustion date over the long term it's actually has a a much bigger impact but
  16. for the immediate term on the Social Security trust fund it barely moves it simply because we waited too long to do
  17. it and what's the difference between the immediate and the long terms in other words at some point we'd be better off
  18. if if not fully whole but how long would would the lag time be so uh the Trust on
  19. exhaust in 2031 um because this we would phase in toward age 70 along the current path
  20. which is about two months per year it takes too long so um the trust fund barely moves um over what's called a
  21. 75-year window which is how so Security Act R typically look at this it helps by
  22. uh improve the uh finances by almost a third so it actually has a big impact over time is just that it takes a long
  23. time for it to phase in oh okay and the other solution often put forth is well how about if we increase taxes on people
  24. with high incomes because there's a cap right now on who on how much people pay that's right in particular you pay taxes
  25. up to the first $118,500 that's in index with wages so it it kind of grows over time and we
  26. call that the tax Max and it's the maximum that your uh income that your taxes are are are levied over and so if
  27. you increase that from 118,000 500 to all the way to 400,000 for example um it it basically moves the
  28. trust fund exhaustion date from 2031 to 2036 and going above 400,000 has almost no impact because there just not enough
  29. people there in fact going from 250,000 to 400,000 has very little impact so again it can be part of of a bigger
  30. solution but by itself it's not going to solve the problem what about um reducing
  31. benefits for high income people who presumably don't need the money as much as that that 90-year-old grandmother
  32. does right and that's another idea that's been um discussed in Washington a lot of people don't understand that that
  33. the benefit formula is actually extremely Progressive for poor people replace 90% of their average income
  34. before retirement and then then that decreases quite a bit um for Middle income and then higher income uh
  35. households and so the idea has been let's keep poor people kind of whole 90% replacement rate but lower it for middle
  36. class and kind of upper income households yeah even the uh very um aggressive uh across the board uh a
  37. change um is for the trust fund by itself it's it's basically too late I mean it barely moves the trust fund as
  38. far as the 70E fiveyear solvency it again has a much bigger impact in fact if you combine that with increase in the
  39. retirement age we actually solve the 75-year problem um with those two combinations however it we still would
  40. have to come up with a mechanism for the trust fund to somehow borrow against its
  41. future um to essentially be able to not just hold assets but be be uh in debt for a
  42. while and how many years would that have to cover it would uh so that covers 75 years which is uh the standard
  43. projection window right but you're saying there there'd be this interim when there would be a shortfall there
  44. would be a shortfall for depending exactly the policy combinations it could be between 10 and 25 years okay so it
  45. might might involve some borrowing before things kind of off a little bit uh the other item is the cost of living
  46. uh allowance or raise the cola that is provided each year although there wasn't one last year right um based on
  47. inflation uh and if that were adjusted how much would that help of course in a way that's cutting benefits if you cut
  48. that yeah it it is and so under current law what happens is that the uh Social Security benefits are adjusted every
  49. year for using What's called the CPI W which which was just what they happen to choose at the time and one of the
  50. concerns that economists have had is that that index doesn't uh account for what's called
  51. substitution um where you you might have a product price that goes up on you and
  52. you substitute toward lower prices we're seeing this with for for example with the Affordable Care Act as a lot of
  53. plans go more expensive people substitute toward cheaper plans and so a true measure of inflation would allow
  54. for that substitution that's called The Chain wited index that's been something that's been discussed a lot ever since
  55. the bosin commission and other groups um it actually turns out it doesn't have that big of an impact um even though the
  56. long term it has a positive impact on the trust fund not that big and another concern that sometimes people raise is
  57. that it's not even clear even the chain weighted is actually the right measure for older people in particular older
  58. people have a lot of out of-pocket Medical expenses that is not representative of the average person in
  59. the economy that the that the chain weighted cares about or even the CPI the current law so that that will be
  60. something that there's a lot going to be a lot of discussion about in terms of the numbers it doesn't really have a big
  61. impact um if Americans together paid more taxes uh would that save Social Security as we know it sure I mean if
  62. you increase taxes or cut benefits you know you're going to solve the problem and so if we just uh right now if we
  63. think about the tax side right now we currently Levy uh a a payroll tax rate of about
  64. 12.4% for Social Security and also the disability program and then an additional tax to cover Medicare so if
  65. we increase at 12.4% to say 14.4% um and that's 2% uh points but as a percent you know that's that's shared
  66. by the employer and the employee it's shared by the uh by both sides now truth be told most economists believe that
  67. ultimately the employees bear the the the brunt of even the employer side that the incidents get shifted through
  68. competitive labor markets um if we did that if we went from 12.4 to 14.4 we would um increase the life of the trust
  69. rund from about 2031 under our projections to about 2043 you would have to actually go all
  70. the way up to about 16.4% to actually have the trust fund U be solvent until about
  71. 2085 um and even then eventually it's going to uh it will go negative because benefits continue to rise but if you if
  72. you took some of the other measures you were talking about earlier and then also
  73. did this for the inter to say get over the hump yeah sounds like that might work yes yeah there there our policy
  74. simulator allows for 4,096 combinations and so lots of different combinations that people can
  75. try and they get instant feedback on that it's from a very sophisticated model but we've used advances of cloud
  76. computing to pre-calculate everything for you so you get instant feedback so there's lots of combinations even ones I
  77. haven't had time to explore yet that could potentially uh uh work here well we'll get to the model that you're
  78. talking about that you help develop soon or soon we'll get to it U and as a matter of fact that's going to be
  79. something that anyone can go on the web and use is that right everybody can use it polic policy ERS we're hope um we've
  80. had a lot of conversations with them they're excited about they want access to tools that they can use while they're
  81. actually writing legislation but the average person can use it and um we've been uh showing it to various professors
  82. around the country and they want to use it for their classroom just to give students tools that they can start to
  83. see these tradeoffs so an interesting new tool yeah so K the whole idea of immigration I guess illegal immigration
  84. and documented workers has been a big part of this presidential primary process and now the presidential race so
  85. uh I guess The $64,000 Question is uh will providing a path to to legalization for
  86. unauthorized workers immigrants uh in the US will that improve the economy or does it hurt the economy by hurting uh
  87. some lower wage workers yeah and it turns out and this is one of the surprises that uh we found and this is
  88. really one of the advantages of having this really detailed model is that the impact on economy from legalization is
  89. is basically a wash and here's what's going on when it comes to jobs legalization actually slightly reduces
  90. the number of jobs and the and what's number of people working and the reason why is that when you're illegal you
  91. pretty much have to be working because you're not you don't have access to unemployment insurance you don't have
  92. access to going to schooling like college and things like that we probably came here to work to begin with you came
  93. here to work and you pretty much have to work to eat um once we have legalization and we're able to track at
  94. the census level data the differences between uh undocumented and legal uh what we see is legal immigrants have a
  95. slow a little bit of a lower um labor force attachment rate and the reason why is because um they can uh uh spend more
  96. time looking for appropriate work they qualify unemployment insurance and they also can get a college degree and up
  97. their skills and so that that's the reason why they effect on GDP is basically a wash in particular less um
  98. employment but more at more skills and it's it has almost no impact so the implication is that
  99. deporting uh illegal immigrant workers isn't going to help the economy uh yeah in fact um some people on the
  100. other side say well deportation should be good for the economy that turns out not to be true either um in fact uh we
  101. we F calculate that deportation actually will substantially lower GDP and lower jobs and the intuition behind that is
  102. that native workers native born workers their labor force participation rate cannot possibly increase in enough to
  103. offset the loss of jobs and so the impact on GDP is actually uh fairly negative uh another question is can
  104. increasing the proportion of authorized immigrants uh with college degrees can that help our economy so where a lot of
  105. kids come here they get their degrees from other countries and um and they're not able to stay right and it's really
  106. critical as you just noted the The Sting between these are legal immigrants as opposed to illegal immigrants we have
  107. about 800,000 legal immigrants per year about 35% of them have a college degree so a lot of the proposals have been
  108. let's keep the 800,000 the same number but shift that 35% upward maybe make it half 55% and so forth to our surprise
  109. and then this the value of having these detailed models it actually has a positive impact by increasing the amount
  110. of college educated uh immigrants it has a positive impact but it's not that big
  111. and um and as you dig into the numbers what uh what you see is that first immigration itself as a legal
  112. immigration as a total is only about 1% of the US population and then when you go from 35% to 55% you're actually
  113. increasing the college educated Workforce in the United States by only about half of 1% so the impact again is
  114. positive but it's not a huge impact instead what you ultimately need to do is increase not just the uh the kind of
  115. the shift you don't just just change in the composition but actually increaseing
  116. in the number the the number of h-1bs without uh uh a change in the number of unskilled uh immigrants that that
  117. actually has a much bigger impact what about lifting the total number of immigrants yeah and so uh above 800,000
  118. yeah um so increasing more immigrants basically means more jobs and more uh GDP um in fact what we find that if we
  119. actually increase legal immigration from 800,000 uh by an additional 400,000 by roughly 50% um and by 2050 we'll have a
  120. GDP that's about 15% larger than what we see today what is that annually do you happen to know I'm just
  121. curious like how much would GDP go up per year if you if you increase by that number well it's over a trillion dollars
  122. um and so we're we're talking about a pretty significant uh and so in current dollars um I would have to do the
  123. exactly well that I'm sure yeah um what what effect would an increase uh in Immigration have on Social Security and
  124. say Medicare yeah um and that it used to be a very controversial issue there's those always this concern that
  125. immigrants are coming in right before they qualify for Social Security and and Medicare and that a lot of that debate
  126. is uh was not correct and a lot of changes have been made in the laws in the mean time um nowadays U increased
  127. immigration is actually a slight Improvement for Social Security and Medicare and the reason why is
  128. immigrants are coming in during their working years typically younger and as result that that the What's called the
  129. old age dependency ratio is improved and in particular we have more young people
  130. relative to old people and that helps improve uh the finances it's not it's not huge um but nonetheless it is
  131. positive so we've talked about this model that you've helped to develop why don't we go take a look at how it works
  132. great hi I'm Kent Smothers a professor here at the Wharton School and I'm going to give you a quick overview of the new
  133. social security policy simulator that's available at the pen Wharton budget model group and you can see from the uh
  134. screen here is that you have a choice of various graphs that you can be looking at things like trust fund reserves
  135. non-interest Surplus which is the difference between uh benefits paid and tax income receive uh Social Security
  136. taxes benefits uh interest income lots of other varieties and we also compare our results against those from the
  137. Social Security Administration and the Congressional budget office and first off before we do even think about any
  138. policy changes you can see that our model projects that we will um uh exhaust the trust fun exhaustion date
  139. will be about three and a half to four years earlier than the Social Security um trustees uh project in particular we
  140. uh uh see a deficits happening around 2031 and uh come 2031 we're we're seeing um projecting that we'll actually have a
  141. non-interest surplus of about $350 billion in today's dollars eventually growing to um over 1.2
  142. trillion dollars per every single year again in today's uh uh dollars and our 75e shortfall is about a third larger
  143. than what you see from the Social Security Administration and the understand why you can look at the uh
  144. Social Security tax revenue and we have a more pessimistic projection of tax revenue coming in over time and the
  145. reason uh behind that is that um our model starts with census level data and we construct these uh transition rules
  146. based on various big data sets across many different key attributes age uh race marriage divorce number of kids
  147. education and many other attributes across law population subgroups so we're really working kind of bottom up and as
  148. a result of that we can see how productivity in the economy is changing as you have these large labor force um
  149. composition changes as people uh are going into retirement um they're being replaced by younger people and average
  150. productivity per worker for example goes down as a result of that our benefits also go down um a little bit relative to
  151. Social Security um but there um our tax revenue is is uh is the main uh difference and our numbers line up a
  152. little bit closer to uh the cbo's own model on this all right so now let's consider some different policy changes
  153. and we have six options to pick from here um increase in the payroll tax uh increase in taxable maximum and lots of
  154. other options there's uh alt together there's uh six options each has uh uh four different combinations associated
  155. with it so there's actually 4 to the six power different combinations 4,096 policy combinations that you can run now
  156. our model you know it each one takes about 30 minutes to an hour to run so you might be wondering how you're
  157. getting instant feedback as as as you move things around in different policy changes and we the reason is we're using
  158. cloud computing to do all the computations ahead of time and so that gives you um instant feedback let's
  159. consider a couple policy changes that uh uh policy makers for years have been kind of talking about let's for example
  160. talk about raising the normal retirement age this one down here and we have a little tool tip here with it basically
  161. says um what the current law is uh in particular the retirement age is going up to age 67 uh roughly about two months
  162. per year and if you want more info it can give you even more expanded info information and so this would be a
  163. policy change to continue that increase if you wanted to do that say even to age
  164. 70 and now when we do that you'll notice here that the um impact on the trust fund exhaustion date from increasing
  165. their retirement age is basically less than one year it's it's a very small um uh change and by the way if you wanted
  166. to you could even kind of zoom in on a particular years and kind of get get more information you can you can
  167. actually uh uh look at particular years the values and so forth and it doesn't have a big impact however um over time
  168. uh increase in retirement age does have a much bigger impact on the non-interest
  169. Surplus um the big deficit uh over time goes down um and and what's going on here is essentially increasing the
  170. retirement age is uh is simply basically too late to solve the problem at least for the trust fund it can be part of a
  171. longer term solution um but it just simply phases in uh too slowly over uh a time and then we have some other uh uh
  172. things that you can consider here one is a progressive benefit reduction um and uh here it it explains the tool tip
  173. explains how benefits are currently calculated in particular the government um you uh currently uh calculates your
  174. benefits uh equal to 90% replacement rate up to a certain value called a bendo then 32% and then
  175. 15% um and so this is a policy where you you keep the 90% replacement rate for poor households constant but you
  176. decrease the replacement rate on richer households and you can see the impact on
  177. the trust fund is actually also uh fairly small um and the current policies are blue line the red policies kind of
  178. the new line and it it barely kind of moves uh the trust fund uh exhausting date
  179. and and the intuition behind that is again um it just it's a bit too late to have an impact on on things it phases in
  180. too slowly however again over time it has a much bigger impact and then you can start to do interactions like you
  181. know suppose I want to do a progressive benefit reduction increase the normal retirement age and you can now start to
  182. see that has a much bigger impact over time in terms of the trust fund reserves themselves again not a huge um impact at
  183. least in the the short run okay so now let's consider you know other things I mean you can um a lot of people have
  184. argued for like increase in the taxable maximum right now your uh payroll is being taxed up to
  185. $118,000 um 500 per year at at a 12.4% tax rate and so some people have argued that maybe we should Levy that tax over
  186. a larger um income base and what we can see is for example as we go to um uh uh the say increase the
  187. $250,000 it actually has an impact on on the trust fund as we go to 400,000 has a
  188. slightly bigger impact not much of a difference um going from 250 to 400,000 households there's just not enough
  189. households there and as you go above 400,000 house uh dollars it it has almost no impact going forward but again
  190. um uh we get some like life but you know over the long term it it starts to you know get a little bit bigger this is one
  191. of those policies that has a a much bigger impact in the short run because it's immediately happening then um but
  192. relative to the long term and so you can now start to think about different combinations I mean it's a 4,096
  193. combinations uh here to for you to explore I I haven't even explored every single combination and so you can um see
  194. the tradeoffs yourself especially between the long run and the short run by giving your own combinations a try
  195. thank you now I'm going to give you a quick overview of the new immigration uh reform policy simulator that's available
  196. at the pen Wharton budget model group notice that you have uh several different graphs that you can look at
  197. things like total population size and uh number of jobs the old age dependency ratio that's very useful for things like
  198. understanding how many young people that we have uh uh per older retiree and then of
  199. course gross domestic product GDP that people often care about so now let's consider different policy combinations
  200. each one dial control here um is has five selections and we have three uh policies Al together so that's 125
  201. different policy combinations that you can um uh get and and see yourself for each policy combination you know the the
  202. actual simulation model takes several hour hours to run in the case of immigration but we use advances and
  203. cloud computing to give you instant feedback on the results um because we've pre-computed everything for you all
  204. right let's go through the different policies um let's think about increasing the net amount of legal immigration
  205. right now from this tool tip you can see that uh net legal immigration to the United States currently amounts about
  206. 800,000 people per year and uh some of the policy ideas out there is to maybe increase that maybe 25% a year and not
  207. so so surprisingly population goes up total number of jobs are going to go up and um GDP um is also improved because
  208. of more um workers in the economy and the old age dependency ratio is slightly improved as well in particular we're
  209. going to have a fewer older people per worker because immigrants are coming in typically during working age and we are
  210. able to track that fairly precisely Us in census level data all right let's talk about some other um uh potential
  211. changes here and the first one is or the second one sorry is is is changing now the composition of the net legal
  212. immigration right now as you can see from this tool tip about 305% of the US adult legal immigrants have a bachelor's
  213. or Advanced degree so the idea here is that we can now increase that percentage without actually imp uh changing the
  214. 800,000 uh number of legal immigration immigrants per year and so we can look at a couple things like you know what
  215. happens to um uh GDP here suppose we go from 35% to 55% and notice it's a slight
  216. positive it's not huge and it's true that this the values here are in trillions of dollars but you can move
  217. your mouse over and see the the actual numbers or if you want to you can always zoom in on the particular set of years
  218. and get even more Precision there if you if you'd like and in particular the blue
  219. line is the current policy the red line is the effects of the new policy and the
  220. reason why it's it's not a big impact um is that uh legal imig immigration flow at 800,000 per year um is uh not that
  221. large of a fraction of the US uh population Workforce and so going from 35% to 55%
  222. uh uh of being college educated is only going to add around 160,000 college graduates per year and that's only about
  223. 1 half of 1% of all college educated worker workers in the economy and so it doesn't have a tremendously large impact
  224. all right now let's look at a couple other policies um and the one is to potentially increase deportation of a
  225. unauthorized immigrant so now we're really shifting from legal status to unauthorized uh immigrants and the other
  226. one is to offer legal status just the opposite um to unauthorized immigrants we can see from the tool tip that
  227. there's about 11.3 million unauthorized immigrants in the United States and so if you uh choose to go say this
  228. direction of legalization this is saying we're going to be legalizing roughly around 10% per year so within a decade
  229. we'll have uh legalized um everyone and so let's look at the impact on jobs and this may be really surprising to a lot
  230. of people as we legalize and notice um jobs actually slightly go down it's not a huge change but it does it's actually
  231. legalization actually leads to fewer um uh jobs again not a big change but it is
  232. technically negative and the intuition there is that if you're currently unauthorized you pretty much have to
  233. work and um in order to survive and so unauthorized workers actually have a higher labor force attachment M rate or
  234. participation rate than those that are authorized authorized workers are able to now go to school and therefore not be
  235. in the workforce for a period they're able to look for a better job a more appropriate job because they can qualify
  236. for unemployment insurance things like that and so that tends to reduce jobs the impact on GDP is basically a wash
  237. there's no particular theoretical reason this should be the case but in terms of
  238. the our rather detailed calculations it's it's basically a wash and and it has almost no impact on G GP and the
  239. intuition there is that even though the number of jobs has gone down a little bit um the once you are converted to
  240. legal status again you're able to go to school you're able to get more productivity and so as a result of that
  241. uh the impact on GDP is is uh next to nothing now let's think about what happens when we go the opposite
  242. direction where we start deporting it say 10% per year within a decade everybody would be all all the
  243. unauthorized illegal immigrants would be reported now notice the impact on employment is now much more negative and
  244. the the reason behind that is that we're losing um people it's like 100% Detachment now for the workforce for
  245. unauthorized immigrants um and the the native born um participation rate in the labor market cannot possibly rise enough
  246. to um uh uh meet that that Gap that that reduction in the number of jobs and GDP
  247. um also goes down uh uh pretty substantially you can see um by uh Within by 2035 um close to a trillion dollars um
  248. reduction in GDP and so you know both of these policies have been kind of advocated on both SIDS of saying that
  249. they're going to increase the the number of jobs or increase GDP in fact neither
  250. policy um uh works in the way that it's it's often been presented and so you can
  251. try try many other combinations yourself again you have uh about 125 different combinations to choose from and again
  252. many combinations I've even explored myself so try try it yourself and uh make up your own mind thank you
  253. [Music]

Brief Summary

Kent Smothers discusses Social Security's future, immigration's economic impact, and policy solutions for funding issues.

Key points

  • Social Security's Future at Risk. Younger generations may face reduced benefits as the trust fund is projected to be exhausted by 2031.
  • Impact of Immigration on Economy. Legalizing undocumented workers has a neutral effect on the economy, with surprising implications.
  • Increasing Immigration Benefits GDP. Raising the number of legal immigrants can significantly boost GDP and job creation.
  • Impact of Progressive Benefit Reduction. The policy reduces benefits for richer households while keeping them constant for poorer ones.
  • Legal Immigration Policy Changes. Increasing legal immigration could boost jobs and GDP, but the effects are nuanced.
  • Deportation vs. Legalization Effects. Deporting unauthorized immigrants has a more negative impact on employment than legalizing them.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes