How Social Security Impacts Wealth Inequality

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Wharton's Sylvain Catherine joins the Ripple Effect podcast to discuss how Social Security reshapes the picture of wealth inequality in America. He explains the coming 2033–2035 Trust Fund depletion, future reform options like tax increases, benefit cuts, or retirement age changes, and how these decisions could impact future generations.

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

#SocialSecurity #socialsecuritybenefits #WealthInequality #retirementpolicy #retirementsavings ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Sylvain Catherine: We have known for decades that at some point during the— around the year 2033 or 2035— this date has moved a
  2. little bit. At some point, the Social Security Trust Fund, which are the reserves of the Social Security system, is going
  3. to run out of money. When this happens, Social Security will not be able to pay the benefit in full. Based on the current
  4. estimate, it will be able to pay 75% of the benefits. So at this point, there will need to be a reform. Either you will have to
  5. raise the level of payroll taxes that form Social Security, or you will have to lower the benefits or to move the
  6. retirement age. - Welcome to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>, the podcast that takes you on a
  7. journey through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host, Dan Loney, and in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the
  8. inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have conducted and exploring how
  9. their findings resonate with the world today. When you think about retirement, there's no doubt that part of the
  10. discussion ends up being around Social Security and what it means for Americans. But when you factor it in when you're
  11. looking at wealth inequality, is there a difference in what it is now compared to, say, a few decades ago? That's part of the
  12. research done by our guest here today, Sylvain Catherine, who is an Assistant Professor of Finance here at the Wharton
  13. School. Sylvain, great to talk to you again. How are you? I'm great. Thanks for having me.
  14. Thank you. Let's start, I guess, with the back story on looking at this— these aspects of wealth
  15. inequality tied to Social Security. right? So as you mentioned, when people think of retirement, a
  16. big part of it is Social Security. Actually, for most Americans, most of their income during the retirement period
  17. does not come from the stock of wealth that they have at the beginning, but comes from the Social Security benefits that
  18. they receive. Now, all those promises that the government make, they have value. So you could think of it like, if you
  19. were to go on the private market, you could buy an annuity, and that annuity would basically offer exactly the same
  20. type of terms as Social Security. It would, like, provide a monthly payment until the end of your life. So there is a market value
  21. for what the government provides. And so one question is, once you try to value those benefits, the ones that you have
  22. already accrued because you have contributed into the system, what's the value of this? How does it change the level of
  23. inequalities that we see today, and does it change also the trends in wealth inequality? Because when we look at wealth
  24. excluding Social Security, we see a steady increase in wealth inequality since more or less the mid 1980s. But what we find
  25. in our paper is that once you factor in Social Security, this positive trend in wealth inequality basically disappears.
  26. So when you think about value for Social Security, how has that changed over the last several decades?
  27. So it has changed enormously, and this has implication both for households but also for the government.
  28. Because, of course, what we consider as an asset for households is going to be a liability for the government.
  29. But we are talking about, I think right now, something that is close to $50 trillion, where, like, the total stock of wealth
  30. excluding Social Security in the US would be slightly more than $100 trillion. So you have, like, 1/3 of the total that is Social
  31. Security, and which was not considered in inequality statistics before. And so when you talk about the different income brackets,
  32. there's probably much more of a reliance on Social Security as a component of support in your retirement years for lower-
  33. income families than it is for higher-income families. Exactly. So in general, as you move up in the income
  34. distribution, people receive higher benefits. But that slope, that relationship, is much less pronounced than if you look at
  35. wealth in general. And because there is much less inequality in Social Security benefits, adding it to the— to the— to the bucket
  36. of the things that you consider as wealth totally changes the picture that you— that you have when you trace the level of
  37. inequality over time. So then, with everything we've seen, especially in recent years, how then do we value Social Security benefits right
  38. now? And I guess maybe even more importantly, how, potentially, might we value them in the future? Because obviously, there
  39. are so many questions about what Social Security might be in the next decade or so.
  40. Right. So that's— that's an important consideration. So we have known for decades that at some point during the— around the
  41. year 2033 or 2035— this date has moved a little bit. At some point, the Social Security Trust Fund, which has the reserves of
  42. the Social Security system, is going to run out of money. When this happens, Social Security will not be able to pay the
  43. benefit in full. Based on the current estimate, it will be able to pay 75% of the benefits. So at this point, there will
  44. need to be a reform. Either you will have to raise the level of payroll taxes that form Social Security, or you will have to
  45. lower the benefits or to move the retirement age. Now, in our— in our paper, we take this into account. We have some— some tests
  46. like— what if, like, we pay the benefit in full, what if we cut them by 20%. And we look at how it changes the trends in wealth
  47. inequality. But you have to remember that this is not news. This we have known, if you look at the Social Security reports
  48. that, like, the Social Security Administration publishes every year about the health of the system, we have known that for
  49. decades. And so that was, in a sense, already known, 40 years ago. And so it doesn't change the trends that much.
  50. But the concept of inequality, though, has probably shifted over the last few decades as well.
  51. So what do you mean by this? Well, I mean, when you think about the impact of the
  52. inequality because of how Social Security has changed, we're seeing probably a much greater impact on inequality than we
  53. have in the past. - Right. Right. And so there are several reasons for that. So one is that
  54. you have many more workers that are, like, well-covered by Social Security, or, like, young retirees, than 40 years ago.
  55. Second, life expectancy has increased. So it has stagnated a little bit in— in more recent years. But over, like, a long
  56. period, it has increased. And, like, the third thing, which— which is, I think, the more interesting point, I think, from
  57. a finance point of view, is that the level of interest rate has declined enormously. And so when you try to buy an annuity from
  58. an insurance, for example, the level of the interest rate is going to affect the value of this annuity. The lower the
  59. interest rates, the higher the value of the— of the assets, such as Social Security— future Social Security benefits.
  60. Well, and even that level of interest rate, as you kind of alluded to, has shifted, what, over the last 30 years or so. We
  61. went for such a long period of time with interest rates basically at zero. Then we saw that rise in and around the
  62. pandemic. And we still are seeing a higher rate of inflation than we saw, say— - Right. - 20 years ago. So—
  63. so what really matters here is a level of real interest rates. That is a difference between the level of nominal interest rates
  64. That, like, you would see on a mortgage contract, and the level of inflation. Because Social Security benefits are indexed on
  65. inflation. So when— when— when— when inflation goes up, it doesn't really hurt retirees as much as it hurts the rest of the
  66. population, because they are protected against it. Now, the spread between the nominal interest rate and inflation is
  67. still very low relative to what it was in the '80s. We've obviously had a lot of policy discussion around Social
  68. Security, especially lately. One of the things, obviously, that the current administration brought forward was not taxing
  69. Social Security benefits. All of these kind of ideas kind of filter into the mix as to that component of inequality and
  70. Social Security benefits. - Yeah, this kind of policy has big redistribution effects,
  71. especially not so much between rich and poor people, but more so between different generations. So for example, if
  72. like— cutting what they call the Social Security tax is effectively increasing the Social Security benefits. Now
  73. there is no free lunch. Like, Social Security benefits in a pay- as-you-go retirement system, are paid by workers. And so if you
  74. decide that the current courts of retirees will receive more benefits, that means that the deal is mechanically getting
  75. worse for younger generations. And so that's where— that's the dimension on which the redistribution along this kind
  76. of policy operates. It's between generations. - And it's not a component of wealth that's transferable to that next
  77. generation as well. - Well, I mean, that's a choice for, like, your parents or your
  78. grandparents. If they decide that these additional benefits are like not having to pay the tax on Social Security taxes.
  79. Because just to be clear, the Social Security tax is not going to the federal government. It feeds back into the Social
  80. Security Trust Fund. - Right. And so it's it's really like— I think the right way to think about it is an increase in benefits. - Right.
  81. And so if your parents that are currently retired decide to save that money instead of spending it, then you as an individual,
  82. you would get it back for inheritance. - Right. - Now, not all Americans are equally situated on— on that dimension. Because,
  83. first of all, like, that Social Security tax is only going to go to— towards, like, high-income Social Security recipients.
  84. - Right. - And so effectively, what would happen is that you would have like— like, current workers whose parents have low Social
  85. Security benefits. So for them, it means that they will have to fund that increase in generosity for current retirees, but their
  86. parents will not be able to save that money to return it to them in the form of inheritance. So yes, it's a transfer from, like,
  87. young generations to older generation. And potentially that transfer is kind of like offset by the inheritance mechanism,
  88. but not equally for all young Americans. I found it interesting in reading through the paper, and
  89. you mentioned this a little bit earlier— is the impact, or lack thereof, of this component of Social Security benefits to
  90. inequality on the top 10%. Take us through why that's so important to this paper.
  91. So because— because, essentially, when you look at the bottom 90%— so the rest of the population, for them, Social
  92. Security is more or less half their wealth. Whereas for the top 10%, it's much smaller. And for the top 1%, it's like,
  93. totally insignificant. - Right. - And therefore, when you ignore Social Security, you kind of like totally overlook the
  94. biggest chunk of wealth that the bottom 90% has, and you fully count the wealth of the top 10%. Which is why including it really
  95. changes the picture. - I found it interesting. You also mentioned at the end of the paper,
  96. we're still kind of at a point where there's probably a lot more research to do in terms of looking into this and these
  97. impacts as we move forward, correct? Right. Because, like, our paper is mostly, in a sense, an
  98. accounting paper. We are just trying to measure how much wealth people have. - Right. - So it's not— it's not a measure of,
  99. like, the causal effect of Social Security on the distribution of wealth. Because if Social Security did not
  100. exist, the behavior of people would like totally change. Presumably, people, knowing that— so wages, net wages, would be
  101. higher because you wouldn't have to pay the Social Security tax. And there is a question of what people would do with the money.
  102. Would they have saved more privately, or would they have— would they have chosen to consume it? And so depending on the assumptions
  103. that you are making here, the causal effect of Social Security on wealth inequality could be very different. So our paper is
  104. just measuring things. It's just trying to get the accounting right, but it doesn't really tell you what Social Security is
  105. actually doing in terms of affecting inequality. - Is there, though, a natural next area that you would like to
  106. build off of this research to go look at next? Right. So as you— as you mentioned, one big source of
  107. concern for the next 10 years is this funding gap. And as I alluded to, there are several ways to solve that gap. Now,
  108. whether you solve it by reducing the benefit, changing the retirement age, or by increasing taxes, that does not affect all
  109. Americans in the same way. And since it's a big fraction of their wealth, the actual policy decisions will have a big effect
  110. on the way the cost, the burden, is, like, distributed among Americans. So that's, like,
  111. something that we are trying to do right now. And so that puts, as you kind of alluded to— that puts more
  112. emphasis on what's going to happen on the policy side. - Yes. - Over the next decade, to truly
  113. understand the path that we're gonna see. - Right. Once you get the accounting right, you can think of— okay,
  114. if I change the rule, who gets affected? Who benefits? Well, most of like— in net, it's going to be a burden, because there is
  115. this money that is— that is— that is just missing. - Yeah. But like, depending on the policy choice that you make to address
  116. this problem, the— who is going to be affected, in terms of which cohort— and we mean a cohort, whether it's high-income
  117. people or low-income people— that really depends on the way we decide to solve that problem.
  118. Is there enough of an understanding by the policymakers about the accounting side, so they can make the proper decisions on the
  119. policy side? - So in a sense, that's what we are trying to provide in our future
  120. research. I think a lot of policymakers know about this. Now, I think the problem is that Social Security has been
  121. described as like the third rail of American politics. - Yes. And so as long as long the trust fund still has money, in a sense, I
  122. don't think any of them will say anything about this, because it's just like— there is only, like, political cost. But we know
  123. that like— so we are in '25. So in eight years, I think, based on the latest estimate— - Yeah.
  124. there won't be any money left. And so at that point, policy makers will have to say, "Okay, we
  125. prefer to raise the retirement age, or we prefer to cut the benefit, or we prefer to raise the taxes."
  126. Those are going to be our choices. Sylvain, great to see you again. Thank you very much. Thank you.
  127. Thank you for having me. - Thank you. Sylvain Catherine, who is Assistant Professor of Finance here at the Wharton School.
  128. - Thank you for listening to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>. We hope you found this episode informative and engaging. Don't forget to
  129. subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best insight from the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Sylvain Catherine discusses Social Security's future, its impact on wealth inequality, and necessary reforms to sustain benefits.

Key points

  • The Future of Social Security. The Social Security Trust Fund is projected to run out of money by 2035, leading to potential reforms.
  • Impact on Wealth Inequality. Factoring in Social Security benefits changes the narrative on wealth inequality in America.
  • Generational Redistribution. Current policies may favor older generations at the expense of younger ones, raising concerns about fairness.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes