Social Security Could Face a 14% Benefit Cut

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Social Security’s main trust fund could be depleted by early 2033. Without congressional action, incoming payroll taxes may be enough to cover only about 86% of scheduled benefits.

Kent Smetters, Wharton Professor of Business Economics and Public Policy and Faculty Director of the Penn Wharton Budget Model, explains what is driving the funding shortfall, why waiting makes the problem harder to solve, and what policymakers can do to strengthen the system.

He also breaks down the role of birth rates, longevity, payroll taxes, retirement age, and why younger Americans may need more time to prepare for future changes.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. The solvency of the Social Security program continues to be an important question to be
  2. asked, one that is at the forefront of many Americans' minds. The latest reports coming
  3. out show that the system will deplete in early 2033, according to the Penn Wharton budget model.
  4. That counters a report by the Social Security trustees that projects depletion in the fourth
  5. quarter of 2032. Ken Smetter is his faculty director of the Penn Wharton budget model,
  6. and he joins us to go over their latest reporting on this topic. Ken, great to see you again. How
  7. are you, sir? Good. How about you, Dan? Great to have you with us. So it seems like we continue
  8. to inch slowly towards this depletion that could occur in the next several years,
  9. unless Congress does something about this, correct? Yeah, absolutely. It's true that
  10. we're a little more optimistic than the trustees, but only by a couple of months. And so,
  11. if you go back five years ago, everything was reversed. They worked several years out more
  12. than us. They were much more optimistic than us, and they brought their trust fund depletion date
  13. down. So we're only talking about, you know, a pretty short time period from now, you know,
  14. six, seven years before the trust fund, the main program, the OASI program, what most people call
  15. Social Security, is depleted. So what's the difference between the data brought out by the
  16. trustees and the data that Penn Wharton budget model has put together? Yeah, so our approaches
  17. are very different. They tend to take what's called a top-down approach, where they start
  18. with these aggregate numbers, and they do a fair amount of, you know, straight line projections and
  19. other sort of projections out from that. You know, they create some nuance there, but it's mostly
  20. aggregate protected for it. We're just the opposite. We're very bottom up. So we start
  21. with hundreds of thousands of different represent households, and we build our way up. But in this
  22. case, you know, for this year, finally, we're pretty much converging on a very similar outcome,
  23. at least in the short run. We're roughly around the same point of time in six, seven years in
  24. terms of trust fund depletion, and also cut in benefits at that point, if depletion were to
  25. happen. So when you talk about a topic like this, how much does what the birth rate will be in the
  26. future for Americans, as well as the longevity of life as well, how much will those two components
  27. play a factor? In the long run, definitely those are very, very important. And so neither of them
  28. are going to affect much for the trust fund depletion date. That's going to happen, you know,
  29. regardless if we get our birth rate up or it continues to fall. Over time, it definitely
  30. matters a lot. So where we differ with the trustees is that we believe that the, we've been actually
  31. projecting for a while that birth rates will continue to fall. And it will, you know, we've,
  32. we projected, you know, almost eight, nine years ago that we would join the European club of failing
  33. to replace ourselves. And so we, you know, do say it will level out, whereas the trustees,
  34. they're actually projecting on birth rates that they're actually going to bounce back.
  35. And so we have a different view on that. On the other hand, with longevity, they actually are
  36. straight lining a lot of their longevity over time. And so whereas, so they're actually more
  37. optimistic that people are going to live longer than we are. And that's actually more costly for
  38. the trust fund. So what happens is that you actually have these two offsetting, you know,
  39. effects. We were more optimistic in terms of, in terms of costs associated with longevity,
  40. that it's more pessimistic about longevity for us, you know, as people, but in terms of costs for the
  41. social security that we're saying people aren't going to live as long on average. So that's a
  42. little bit more optimistic for the finances, but we're a little bit more pessimistic when it comes
  43. to the fertility rates and that they're going to continue to fall. And as a result of that,
  44. you know, you can have fewer parents into this pay-as-you-go system. What then in the short term are the most addressable ways to look at securing the safety
  45. of social security beyond that window of late 2032 or early 2033? Right. And it really comes down to,
  46. I think, two tranches of policy that policymakers are going to have to grapple with. One is that
  47. the fund, the trust fund, the social security system needs money in the short run. And you're
  48. not going to get that simply by reducing benefits and controlling the growth for the benefits.
  49. So some form of additional funds in the short run, and that could take the form of maybe some
  50. adjustment to the payroll tax ceiling that could take a completely outside the system
  51. approach of infusion into the trust fund. There's lots of different approaches that could take
  52. some are more damaging than others to the economy. But over a longer period of time,
  53. the real bang for buck comes from basically saying, you know what, we can't necessarily
  54. continue to afford having benefits being paid out at even age 67. It sounds like it's a long age,
  55. but not. It's already 50 years from now when people are living a lot longer than that.
  56. Right. And I guess that extends that discussion of whether or not retirement should be pushed out to 72 as well. Correct?
  57. Sure. And that would, you know, going from 67 as the normal retirement age to 70 and then even a
  58. 72, you know, that might sound, wow, that's a long time, but that's for us today. But, you know,
  59. 50 years from now, that is going to look very different. And a lot of that is a very open
  60. question. For example, do the GLP-1 drugs, you know, especially if you take them during working
  61. age, that's where life extension seems to be most prominent. You know, how much are those
  62. going to be adopted by the populations in other life extending, you know, drugs and procedures
  63. and lifestyle changes. And so I think, you know, a lot of that is still very open,
  64. but there's no question people are going to be living longer in the future. This has been an issue that has been, it seems like, continuously a version of kicking the can
  65. down the road. So as we get closer to that late 2032, early 23 timeframe, does kicking the can
  66. down the road amplify the issues that are involved and make it even harder to continue to
  67. secure this system in the right manner for a longer period of time? It certainly does. The longer you wait, the less you plan, the larger the changes have to be at
  68. that point, whether that's increasing revenue in the form of tax increases or decrease of benefits.
  69. And so getting some action today is important for a couple of reasons. One is that you can
  70. smooth out some of the costs over time. And the second is that you give people time to prepare,
  71. especially, no one's going to really think about cutting benefits in the short run that, you know,
  72. anybody's above age 50 or something like that. But you still want to give, you know, the 20,
  73. 30, 40-year-old some time to prepare in terms of saving for retirement. And some of that could
  74. actually be, you know, helping Social Security with some type of, you know, other accounts that
  75. people can put money into to augment their saving and, you know, making that easier to get done.
  76. But giving younger people time to prepare for possible benefit changes in 20, 30, or 40 years
  77. would be very useful. Right. And so for those people watching or listening to this interview,
  78. if that does happen, worst-case scenario, then financially what occurs? Yeah. So in about six,
  79. seven years, you know, what happens is that when the trust fund depletes, they might be able to
  80. get another six months to a year from borrowing from another trust fund known as the disability
  81. trust fund. But that does, you know, left-hand borrow from the right hand. But when the trust
  82. fund depletes, basically it means an immediate cut in benefits by about 14% across the board.
  83. So only about 86% of the benefits will be payable at that point in about six, seven years. And so
  84. that benefit cut about 14% that happens, that's not just for new people coming into the Social
  85. Security system. If your grandma's 90 years old, she's getting a benefit 14% smaller at that point.
  86. And so, and by the way, that only gets worse over time by, you know, by 2100, then the 75 years,
  87. the payable benefits is only about 60% of what the current system is promising. And so
  88. the system definitely needs some type of fixing, whether it's more revenue or less benefits that
  89. are going to be paid, especially if policymakers do start to lean a bit more on increasing the
  90. retirement age. Kent, always great to get your insight on these topics. Greatly appreciate it.
  91. All the best. My pleasure. Kent Smetters, who is faculty director of the Penn Wharton budget model.
  92. By the way, you can see their work and their research by going to their website,
  93. which is budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu.

Brief Summary

Ken Smetters discusses Social Security's impending depletion and potential policy solutions to secure its future.

Key points

  • Social Security Depletion Timeline. Experts predict Social Security will deplete by early 2033, raising urgent questions about its future.
  • Diverging Projections. The Penn Wharton model and Social Security trustees have differing views on depletion timelines.
  • Impact of Birth Rates. Falling birth rates could significantly affect the Social Security system's sustainability.
  • Immediate Benefit Cuts. If the trust fund depletes, benefits could be cut by 14% across the board.

Tension

60/ 100Some tension

Related episodes