Understanding NFL Performance Variance Through Predictive Metrics

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Kevin Cole reveals why win-loss records are often misleading and how predictive analytics uncovers a different hierarchy of NFL team strength. Cole explains how adjusted scores, turnover variance, and quarterback stability help separate sustainable performance from short-term noise. He also discusses the surprising rises and inconsistencies across teams this season, emphasizing why some results don’t align with underlying metrics. The episode highlights why elite quarterbacks and structural factors still anchor long-run projections, even in an unusually volatile year.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? The Moneyball podcast explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#NFLAnalytics #NFLPowerRankings #FootballData #NFLInsights #SportsAnalytics #NFLPredictions ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Welcome, welcome to Wharton Moneyball here on the Wharton podcast network. This is Eric Bradler, professor of
  2. marketing, statistics, and data science here at the Wharton School. Some combination of myself, Cade Massie, Audi
  3. Winer, and Shane Jensen are here every week on Wharton Moneyball. Um, for me, uh, the best part of the last 11 and a
  4. half years have been our interviews with, you know, if you'd like, they're now friends, but colleagues that are
  5. working in industry that are actually applying statistics, data science to all kinds of interesting sports. Today is a
  6. returning guest. I I'm going to guess 20 times he's been on the show, but it could be more over the last 11 plus
  7. years. Well, we're happy to welcome back Kevin Cole. Kevin Spider of Unexpected Points newsletter Substack if you'd like
  8. formerly of uh PFF and he's an NFL data analyst and also I'm sure we've talked to Kevin about
  9. this before but as a former bond and equity analyst. So Kevin, welcome back to Wharton Moneyball.
  10. >> Well, thanks for having me back. I might I might take the under on 20. That that
  11. sounds like rarified air, but I I consider myself more of a fan. More of a fan than anything.
  12. >> Neil Kane might be the only one that's a 20. So there there we go. But either
  13. way, it's good to have you back on the show. >> It's good to be back. Like I said, I
  14. consider myself a fan. More more of a fan and an occasional guest and a uh a perennial fan.
  15. >> Ah, well, we appreciate that. Um, so let me start with the following. One of the
  16. things since you sent us some notes about one you wanted to talk about. One of the the first topic here is one that
  17. people I think love, which is, you know, Kevin, why do we need fancy analytics? Can't we just look at the win loss
  18. record of teams? You know, it's kind of like in baseball. Can't I just look at someone's batting average and see who's
  19. best? You know, why do I need this war and all these other fancy stats? So, what can you first explain why you think
  20. we need something different between record and team strength? And then secondly, which teams do you see so far
  21. this year that there's the biggest disconnect? >> Yeah. Yeah. You know, I I get a little
  22. lesson in public perception versus maybe what my numbers are telling me. Every every week I put out my my power
  23. rankings. You got to put out the power rankings. So, every week I do this and you know, I'm trolling a little bit
  24. because I call them my 100% correct, the only 100% correct power rankings that come out each week.
  25. >> You mean in an anchor man type of way, like 100% of the time they're right half
  26. the time? >> Yeah. Yeah. 60% of the time it works every time for my from from my rankings
  27. and that would be pretty good in the betting market, right? Um so yeah, I mean I think it's really just getting at
  28. an issue that we're all we're all trying to discover the truth through prediction
  29. is is a good way of kind of being able to discover the truth. I mean no matter no matter who we're talking about here,
  30. whether it's a an analyst, you know, it's it's Dan Orlovski or even if it's Stephen A. Smiths. Maybe someone who's
  31. doing more of the uh the talk radio type. >> Kevin, we don't use his name on this
  32. podcast. >> You don't? >> You [laughter] don't? Oh, I don't know. Oh, okay. I I could have used his name,
  33. but Okay, let's go ahead. Yeah. >> Okay. Or or whoever you want to interject into there. I mean, at the end
  34. of the day, I think everyone is making at least an implicit prediction on on what's going to happen. And if they tell
  35. you this quarterback is better than this other quarterback, I mean, I think they're telling you they're probably
  36. going to perform better. I mean, maybe they'll they'll have adjustments to that. May, you know, after the fact, I'm
  37. sure they'll tell you why the guy they said was better didn't perform better because of the the offensive coordinator
  38. or the line or other things like that. Um, but everyone's kind of making at least an implicit prediction. So, it's
  39. really just translating that explicitly in into a prediction. And I think it's useful, although it's confusing to some
  40. people because I think some people view the rankings and things like that being more like an AP college football type of
  41. poll in the past where I saw some instructions. I was just looking this up today for for for AP voters. And you
  42. know, they're explicitly told that you should you should judge by performance. So, you know, also kind of known as
  43. results and you should judge by headtohead. You should judge by these sort of things. And of course, I'm not
  44. judging by those things. I mean, those are factored in, but they're not going to be part of an additional adjustment
  45. for trying to figure out how good these teams are going to be in the future. And
  46. I think that's where the disconnect that's where the disconnect comes is number one and kind of how people feel
  47. like is deserving or not, a sense of fairness maybe as to where they may be ranked. And then the second thing is
  48. probably just overvaluing what's happened win and loss-wise because it's hard it's hard to differentiate after
  49. you watch a game who was better or not based upon anything but the final result. So Kevin, before I turn things
  50. back over to Kade to lead this discussion, let me just ask you. So do you view your power ranking on
  51. unexpected points? Do you view it as something that's backwardlooking, which is how much did team A perform compared
  52. to team B, or do you look it as more forwardlooking, like if team A and team B were to play each other in the future,
  53. this would be something about the expected outcome? How do you how do you see it?
  54. >> Yeah. No, it's it's the latter. So it's it's it's done the same way that you know um Massie Peabody and others have
  55. have kind of the standard formula which is the expected point differential versus an average team on a neutral
  56. field. Um and then and then you build the rankings there. And what's also funny about the rankings because when
  57. you just without the context of these team strength numbers that are underlying them if someone is ranked you
  58. know 17th versus 12th it's like oh my god I can't believe it. where the reality is we're talking about maybe
  59. less than a half a point difference in team strength that could flip oh so easily. So that that's another it's kind
  60. of a comical thing uh to put into it. But I have to put I have to put out the rankings every week because that the
  61. people love it. And plus, you know, it gets me like 10 bucks from X or something like that. So I'll take it.
  62. >> The first part of my question just so and then I'll turn it over to Kate would
  63. be so which teams do you think there might be a disconnect between you know what's I don't know maybe you don't
  64. think the Broncos are any good. they're 10 and two or whatever they are and maybe their team strength is lower than
  65. that or you know I don't know the Jaguars eight and four maybe they're not actually very good. I don't know what
  66. which teams do you see the disconnect between? >> Yeah. Yeah. I think I I I hear a little
  67. bit more uh noise from people who who believe their teams are are underrated and um you named two of the top teams. I
  68. mean, the Panthers I mean, the Panthers may be the the number one team right now
  69. for people coming after me because I didn't really move them that much based upon a win against the the Rams who
  70. according to my rankings are actually the best the best team in the NFL. Um, and that kind of goes that goes another
  71. layer and I try to link to that and explain in my write up when I'm talking about these teams about how I actually
  72. analyze each individual game. And it was one of the bigger swings of saying the Rams lost by three points. But I I put
  73. together this thing called adjusted scores where I try to make a bunch of adjustments based upon um you know the
  74. the variance in high leverage situations, the things that have less less stickiness like special teams play
  75. or fumble recoveries or things like that. And I actually had the Rams being 10 points better which is really a huge
  76. a huge shift. So, so again, they're looking at this and in their assessment week over week, what should be happening
  77. is Panthers won against a great team, yes, at home, but against a great team by three points. And my assessment week
  78. over week is um at home the Panthers really kind of lost by 10 points and and and that that's a big loss for me
  79. because again, I would be kind of stripping out some of these high variance things. So, so very often if a
  80. team wins by 20 or 25 points, my my calculation is is not that big because normally, you know, winning or winning
  81. by that much is a combination of two things. It's normally good luck and and good play. So, so, so, so that's the
  82. disconnect basically in people's minds between between what they're thinking and then what my rankings are saying.
  83. >> So, uh, with all that talk about deserving versus power rankings, I thought you were talking college
  84. football. I was so excited. I thought, "Wow, Eric shocked me by not only Eric >> off off air." Kevin and I decided we
  85. were only going to talk NFL. >> Yeah, exactly. Well, that was the that was the intention of bringing Kevin on.
  86. And I've just rarely felt more um in need of a Kevin Cole to explain to me the the NFL. I think there's some
  87. combination between I've been a little distracted and also this is a nonsensical season. Um, I mean, I was
  88. sitting with someone in sports, a different sport last night and he asked me who, so who's the best team in the
  89. NFL? I'm like, I have no idea. I don't think anybody does have any idea. Um, he's like, is it Seattle? I'm like, can
  90. Sam Darnold be quarterbacking the best team in the NFL? I I kind of doubt it, but Kevin Cole's going to tell me
  91. tomorrow. I'm going to understand better at the end of that conversation. So, can
  92. you clarify? You just did a whole bunch of methodology and throw clearing. I just want to know, Kevin, who's the best
  93. team in the NFL? Yeah. Well, I mean, I have the Rams is the best team in the NFL, so that points
  94. back to to to what I was saying where it being off by what happened last week versus what had happened in the past.
  95. Um, and a decent gap between them and a number of teams in a, you know, second tier or a 1B sort sort of tier after
  96. that. And, and I agree with you. I although I think I think we're we're probably biased to thinking this more so
  97. than what it is every year to be like whoa it's crazy what's going on this year just because you know we're we're
  98. always late of course updating uh what's happening based upon the evidence but I
  99. do think there is a lot going on this season where I was looking at my preseason rankings versus win loss
  100. records right now um and it is a dramatic difference. I mean, there's none of the teams that are that are up
  101. at the top with these nine wins and over teams um were really top five teams for
  102. me coming into the season. Um but it doesn't but but then if I compare that to my go forward rankings, there are
  103. some of these top five teams who were still really really near the top. So it kind of shows you how that disconnect
  104. between results and and team strength. >> Okay, but hold on. probably have your prior still in your go forward
  105. prediction predict predict power rate >> very very very little only about 5% right now in in in what's in what's
  106. going forward so it's really more so that the the performance and I think I I especially mentioned to you guys
  107. pre-show talking about the Chiefs I think Chiefs are just are probably the most interesting because there's no
  108. nothing we could count on more than the than the Chiefs being good but it is one
  109. of those things where by most metrics they're better a lot better than they were last year and they had um 11 wins
  110. at this point in the season last >> Yeah. But you know the stat also Kevin how many one score or close games they
  111. won last year and this year if you don't want to count outcomes if you want to count true strength we can't count
  112. outcomes and they won every close game last year. I think they they set the NFL record for the most close game wins in a
  113. row and this year I think they're one and six or they've lost every close game. >> Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. The one score game
  114. and then and then also last year I mean I I wasn't very high on them going into the season. actually had them fifth
  115. coming in coming into to this season which is relatively low than than where they may have been perceived. So they've
  116. outperformed in some ways by expectations but their record is a lot worse than than you would have thought.
  117. >> So can you give it walk us through your power rankings um a little bit. I'm I'm
  118. digging through your substack. I hope I hope you were you were you were promoted
  119. sufficiently because Kevin runs >> I promote I promoted I promoted the substack to start with. So give us give
  120. us tears or give us something help us consume the NFL with some with some more sense. Though I think one one question
  121. is you know could we look at if if the scores if the outcomes have been so unrelated to under underlying
  122. power then that should we should be able to operationalize that in some way. So at this point in the season what measure
  123. could we use to ask is it truly more volatile and unexpected this year than typical? you know, I tried to figure
  124. that out and sometimes it's hard to some when you're looking at things in in in aggregate or across the entire sample.
  125. Um, a lot of what is driving the kind again, this is what you're trying to do a lot in Seth. You're trying to kind of
  126. like a a feeling in a way, a theoretical feeling, and then trying to figure out,
  127. well, what's the right, you know, target variable for figuring out >> that's the business we three are in.
  128. Well, well, what that feeling is, but then often what we're doing though is you're looking at the sample of 32
  129. teams. So, I looked at it, I said, "Okay, let's look at how much is point differential." Because I I I I I I
  130. mention that sometimes is a very easy intuitive type of stat to say, you know, the Broncos are ninth, I think, in in in
  131. best point differential this year. So, that kind of aligns better with where I have them versus where their their
  132. record may say they are. So, I looked at point differential versus wins at this point in the season versus prior
  133. seasons. Pretty similar. Like, there's not really um a big difference there. So, then I said, "Okay, well, let's look
  134. at, you know, offensive efficiency. Let's look at offensive passing efficiency. Let's look at all these
  135. different things that I think might be um normally the drivers of performance." And everything seemed pretty good. So, I
  136. think it's more a team by team um surprise that are that that's going on. and maybe the marquee team names
  137. that are not um withstanding some of this variance this year that we've seen in the past. So if we look at like the
  138. >> Can we ask a quick question just like wouldn't I mean maybe we're just maybe we're taking this for granted but it'd
  139. be nice to operationalize it >> the relation between your power rankings and the
  140. this the realized score differential to this point. So that would be less related this year if our intuition is
  141. right. That should be that correlation right now as we sit here today be lower than it is in
  142. >> No, that's correct. No, that that that is a bit lower. Um but I was also interested in maybe if just the results
  143. were were weird if there was more of this um you know one score game type of situation that's flipping a different
  144. way. Um, so I think from from that perspective, um, it's really that the the the top teams in the NFL, let's say
  145. since 2020, which is kind of when Josh Allen had his breakout and everything, it's probably the the teams with the
  146. most wins are the, you know, the Chiefs, the the Eagles, the Ravens, the Bills are are right up there. Um, so if you
  147. look at all all those and then you start to get into some other teams, the Packers are up there, but that's a lot
  148. of Aaron Rogers sorts of years that are in there. The Bengals are kind of wroy are are extremely good. So they fit into
  149. that into that bucket. >> The NFC South champion for the last four years. >> Yes. Well, again, you have some Tom
  150. Brady in there, I guess, a little bit a little bit a little bit too. So, um maybe I'm putting them aside as as being
  151. as being seen on that same sort of level, but I think those teams have just generally been disappointing either by
  152. records or if they have decent results like the Eagles. I don't think anyone I mean every other week, you know, they
  153. want Nick Serriani fired for for even if their their record seems to be okay. There there's a there's a high level of
  154. dissatisfaction I think with maybe how those teams are doing. And then on the flip side, you have this quarterback
  155. driver for a few teams. One, the secondyear breakout of of Drake May where I think there's still some
  156. disbelief as to whether or not that's real despite the fact that I think he's leading MVP odds at this point because
  157. of the strength of schedule. There's some you'll see we'll see about that. they're going to play the Bills and the
  158. Ravens coming out of the buy. So, I think that'll maybe answer some questions there. And then Sam Darnold
  159. going to Seattle, which is pro just, you know, excellent results there. I think DVOA and maybe if you have if you talk
  160. to Aaron Shots, they might have the the Seahawks being the best team in in the NFL so far this year. And then Daniel
  161. Jones going to the Colts is another team where their results have been really really good. So, it's not a fluky thing
  162. um for that those teams are playing so well, but it does seem fluky versus what we expected in the preseason. What we
  163. expect from veteran quarterbacks who have been around a long time where in the case of Darnold, this is the second
  164. year of his kind of massive breakout that he had in in Minnesota. But still, you don't normally see see that sort of
  165. thing for a veteran quarterback elite type of play. Sometimes you get above average, but this type of elite play is
  166. a little bit beyond what we're expecting. Just thinking maybe Kevin building on what you just said maybe one interesting
  167. measure of uncertainty would be you know how much deviation is there from the prior like we know what the prior was
  168. and like if I had told you after week 13 here's the division leaders the Patriots
  169. the Ravens the Jaguars the Broncos maybe the Eagles the Bears maybe the Bucks the
  170. Rams maybe Half of those you would have said yes. Maybe the other half you would
  171. have said no. So I like this idea if you think about it. What is the posterior? It's the deviation from the prior. And
  172. so we could think about, you know, let's compare today versus the prior. There's
  173. lots of measures of differences between distributions. And we could just say the
  174. kind of surprise of a season or the uncertainty could be some measure of the distance like how much updating has
  175. happened. And you could call that a measure of uncertainty. It's not a bad way to think about it. You could call it
  176. a measure of learning. Also, >> the one one it one that thing that's it's confounding or not capturing is if it's
  177. just the prior and the posterior on your power ranking, you're not capturing all
  178. the volatility in the one loss records. And so you might play with the power the
  179. you might play with like some some some probability of success because that's what's really different than expected.
  180. Even if you're power even because of because of the results even good teams I mean the Chiefs might still be one of
  181. the best two or three teams in the AFC but they might not make the playoffs and odds must be against them making the
  182. playoffs at this point. Yeah, I mean they, for example, they have the fourth best point differential right now in the
  183. AFC, better than the Broncos and Chargers in their own division. Um, the only teams that are better are the
  184. Patriots, the Colts, and barely the Bills. >> Yeah. And Kevin, where do you have them
  185. on your power records? >> I mean, I still have uh I have I still have the Chiefs at number four. I mean,
  186. I had him at number two going into this this last week. So, trust me, I'm hearing about that. Um um also so I from
  187. my investigation that I've that I've done and again I haven't done enough investigation the kind of variance of
  188. results versus observed strength this this season just from what they've done. Forget about
  189. priors or anything else. I don't think there's anything there's actually nothing really there's nothing really
  190. there. I think it's just happened to certain teams. Now, no, has it happened to certain teams like the Chiefs that we
  191. notice a lot. Whereas, if it happened to another team that we didn't really believe in, if they were
  192. underperforming, we it wouldn't register because we would say, "Oh, well, you know, they're underperforming." Or if
  193. you're underperforming in a way, we're not expected to be a top five team, but if you're expected to be, you know, the
  194. eighth team and you end up the 18th team or something like that, that it doesn't
  195. register as much. So, so I think that's sticking out. And then the other part that we we've discussed, I do think
  196. there is this this disconnect between on a week- toeek basis of what the power rankings my power rankings would be
  197. versus the results in particular um the the the Chiefs when for it comes to win loss. But then also again these
  198. quarterback situations, Seattle, New England, and and Indianapolis really jumping up in a way that that you know
  199. was was probably if of any team it was probably the Patriots where you would have that in their range of outcomes a
  200. little bit more because of the you'd have a higher uncertainty with what's going on with the quarterbacks, but
  201. probably not as much elsewhere despite the fact that Sam Darnold had a had a pretty good year last year.
  202. >> Kevin, are you buying or selling the um Texans? I'm telling you, I saw that almost all of that game they just played
  203. against the Colts. And I mean, they're the number one defense in the NFL by so many different measures. Um, they're now
  204. seven and five. I think I think they were one and four at one point or one and I don't know. They've won four
  205. straight. That much? I know. Are you buying the Texans or you're not? You're just uh No, they're about where they
  206. should be. I mean, I I think they're about where they should be, but it's it's hard when
  207. you have, you know, rules that are or assumptions that are just baked into everything. And one of the assumptions
  208. is always going to be, you know, fading defense a little bit more versus offense
  209. and a go forward type of of projection that so that makes it a bit more difficult. I mean, I have them being a
  210. slightly above average sort of team, and I know that probably doesn't comport with where
  211. people see them right now. Um, for for a couple different reasons. U one, they've
  212. had some, you know, higher profile wins and the recency is factored in to mine, but not nearly as much. That was my
  213. question. >> Let's stay with that division because it's a good race and you have fair
  214. questions about three of the four teams. So, they're one game behind both the Colts and the Jaguars. What do you think
  215. about those two teams? And in the end, with five games left, what do you expect to happen in that division?
  216. >> Well, so the the Jags I have being slightly worse than the Texans and then the Colts I have being pretty materially
  217. better um of a team. And again, it's going to be looking at recency maybe in the opposite direction where do you know
  218. when the Colts were rip roaring to start to start the season, especially offensively if you were going to kind of
  219. plot out, you know, expected points added per play offensively, even with adjustments for for strength
  220. of schedule and things like that. The Colts were almost head and shoulders above the rest of the NFL when we were
  221. four or five weeks into the season. and now they've faded back to still be pretty good, to still be, you know,
  222. easily a top 10 team as far as that's concerned, but not nearly as good. So, I think I think for for me, I'm probably
  223. still weighting those early performances higher than what other perceptions may be on that. They still have a very
  224. strong like, again, if we want to just simplify it, like yards per play, I think they're still number one in the
  225. NFL right now um for what they've been able to to do with with um with Daniel Jones. So, so I'm a bit higher on them.
  226. I would be I would be predicting them to to go ahead and follow through uh on winning the division. But, you know,
  227. again, it really just depends on on whether or not this level of quarterback performance that we've gotten from
  228. Daniel Jones, if you're putting that in a bucket with quarterbacks who normally perform on this level, those
  229. quarterbacks are probably a lot more reliable for the rest of the season than Daniel Jones is.
  230. >> This is fun and relevant. So, let's stay with this schema for a bit. is like, you
  231. know, up to eight times. AFC West, Broncos and Chargers. Let's let's just kind of ignore the Chiefs world because
  232. they more or less have to win out and get some luck somewhere else. But it's I still don't believe in Bo Knicks. Am I
  233. wrong? I mean, I must be wrong at this point. No. >> Um I mean, you can you can have varied
  234. belief, [laughter] I guess, in how much you are. I mean, I I'm I think he's proving he's proving more and more that
  235. he could be that he that he is, let's say, um a franchise quarterback. Now, is he an elite franchise quarterback? I
  236. would also say he's doing two things at the same time, which is which they seem they seem to be um you know, at at odds
  237. with each other, but maybe they're not really, which is he's proving more and more that he's not going to be someone
  238. they move on from in a year or two or three. But he's also proving at least to me in my numbers you're as he goes on
  239. and on that he's not necessarily going to be an elite quarterback at the same point in time which is maybe where where
  240. the disconnect is. You combine that with a great defense and a good win loss you
  241. know that's where where that can make the difference right like an average quarterback with a great defense is
  242. viewed much differently than an average quarterback with a poor defense. >> I would be pretty sure to follow up on
  243. Boon Knicks Kevin if I was going to look at this but if let's pretend the Broncos
  244. win the Super Bowl this year. It's not impossible the Broncos could win. >> Definitely not impossible.
  245. >> No, no. They have a great coach. They have a great defense. They could win the
  246. He wouldn't be the worst quarterback to ever win the Super Bowl. >> No, no, not even not even close. Um,
  247. >> that's what I'm saying. So, he's good enough. I'm just saying he's good enough
  248. to win the Super Bowl with the defense, the Bronco. Look, Pton Manning was a worse quarterback when they won the
  249. Super Bowl with him in his se last Super Bowl. I mean, Pton Manning wasn't any good at in his last season. I mean, come
  250. on. He was he was he was kind of the ghost of paid bank at at that point. And I think I think one thing another thing
  251. that's maybe a little bit more on the >> you can qu you can have quantitative measures for it but it's a little bit on
  252. the on the qualitative side with Nicks is he can move. He can you know he's got a little gunslingerish sort ofness to
  253. him and he has thrown the ball a lot like he is his volume is not low. He's not someone they're hiding as as a
  254. quarterback. And you could say that their scheme isn't the most uh you know downfield in that way, BUT IT'S NOT THAT
  255. bad actually. It's not like when they had Russell Wilson there or something like that. That type of or so maybe even
  256. a Drew Brees type of scheme. They are pushing it a little bit. Drew Brees late career Drew Brees. I don't want to
  257. burmer Drew Brees early in his career. >> Um >> so I do think he has those elements
  258. which puts you into the ability to win in different game states. Um which is more useful in the playoffs even if you
  259. have a great defense. Sometimes your great defense is going to be trumped by an even better offense and you have to
  260. have someone who can throw you out of it even if they aren't, you know, uh on some sort of average uh per play metric
  261. that great that they can give you some upside in those situations. >> I didn't realize he was so I just looked
  262. he's ranked 20th in QBR. That ain't good. >> No, no, no. That never mind. >> Never mind everything I just said. Bon
  263. Nicks is terrible. [laughter] >> Well, I don't think he's terrible. I I I haven't ranked a little bit higher. I
  264. haven't looked a little bit higher, but you know, by the way, I think that's fair.
  265. >> He's right next to Jaylen Herz. >> Well, Jaylen Herz, I mean, Jayen Herds is making like 90 million a year or
  266. something. So, >> I'm just saying Jaylen's 19th in in in QBR. >> We have Let's Let's ask about a few
  267. other important teams in other divisions. So, you just w you just went to one of them. Herds, the Eagles. So
  268. much drama. And where's Kevin Cole on on this team? >> I mean, I'm I I I'm relatively low, I
  269. guess. I mean, I have them ranked ninth. I've had them I I've had them low all season because they were such a dominant
  270. defense last year without really having a great offensive resume. Um, and then they obviously ended up exploding in the
  271. Super Bowl. And I don't know, there's just nothing they've done this year. They they had some close wins. One of
  272. the wins against the Rams, you know, where they I think they won off of special teams blocks like backtoback
  273. weeks and things and so I've been I've been in disbelief. I've been lower than the markets on them considerably. I
  274. think the markets have been, at least in my opinion, have been giving them a bit
  275. of a boost, an unnatural maybe boost versus what their numbers say. Just just so I don't know. I'm still low on
  276. >> unnatural boost. That's a new that's a new quant phrase I hadn't heard before.
  277. Kevin, uh, if you like offense so much, maybe you like the Cowboys. >> I do like the Cowboys. I mean, I have
  278. for for most of the season. And I don't know, it's it's funny to even see in the
  279. media now. I've seen some things about, oh, the Cowboys defense is is coming together. Um, because I always say, you
  280. know, the variance on that side is going to be is going to be a little bit higher. So, the Cowboys right now, I
  281. mean, I still don't have them ranked in the top 10 overall. They're they're right outside of they're 13th and but
  282. they're pretty close. Like, if they moved up half a point, they would be up into up into the top 10 because of that
  283. offensive play that that they've had so far this year. Um, and in relative to the Eagles, yeah, they're not that far
  284. away from the Eagles for me in team strength versus, you know, where some people would probably have them.
  285. >> Okay. Looking for the best of the NFC. You've already told us the Rams are your
  286. top your top team. Where where are you after that? So, it's not from the NFC East apparently. Where are the Seahawks?
  287. Where are the Packers for you? Are you still on the Lions at all? >> Yeah. Yeah. So, I mean, I have the the
  288. Packers as being the next best team. That's a team that it's interesting because they I mean, they just have good
  289. they have good numbers. They have good numbers by my by my adjusted scores. You know, everyone likes to to mock them
  290. when when they don't agree to say, but I actually have them being better in 11 out of the 12 games so far so far this
  291. year. >> Let me just say I love the adjusted score cut. It's absolutely fantastic the
  292. adjusted score concept. >> No, no, no, no. I I I'm I'm not I I take it I take it as friendly ribbing because
  293. you know um for because when I'll say it you know that the team the fan of the team that won where you say they just
  294. score said they lost they'll say like oh is this an adjusted this or an adjusted
  295. that they'll they'll like to make jokes about about about about the different teams. Um, but I think I think the thing
  296. with the Packers, the disconnect here seems to be related to to Jordan Love also, who is first in
  297. for his play involvements this year in EPA per play. And I know that's a that's a team stat, but then again, you know,
  298. passing touchdowns is a team stat, passing yards is a team stat, everything's a team stat. But even if
  299. you look at PFF grading, I think he's third in the in the NFL so far this year. But there are a few people who
  300. would probably point to him being at that at that level so far. So I I think he's maybe being discounted because
  301. people have a lot of belief in in Matt Laflur and everything else that's going on there because he revived Aaron
  302. Rodgers. And there's always these silly things that I think that have a a huge outweighed influence of something like
  303. Malik Willis coming in and playing well when he's played after looking horrible as a rookie. But, you know, it's just
  304. one backup quarterback for a handful of starts can really affect people's views of of how good someone is as a play
  305. caller. And we just saw with Kevin O'Connell, who people love and say, "Oh, he can make anyone good." You know, he
  306. he had a guy who was an undrafted rookie and didn't look so good this last week.
  307. I think most people I I'm just giving an opinion here. I mean, they're right what
  308. a half game back, I guess you would call it, of the best record in the NFC. I think if the Packers end up behind,
  309. let's say it, let's say they win their division, but aren't the number one seed, so they're going to have to win at
  310. home and then they're going to have to go on the road, let's say, to the Rams, maybe it's the Eagles, whoever it is, or
  311. Seahawks. I I don't see how they can be favored. I just don't see how the Packers the Packers of all the teams
  312. that are there, I almost feel like they need the number one seed the most. Besides, you you you lo you skip a game,
  313. like I just don't I don't have any faith in the Packers on the road in a big playoff game.
  314. Well, I mean, I would probably I mean, if I was going to say who needs the number one seed the most, I guess I
  315. would say the Lions. So, they could be at the dome and and playing in the dome the entire time might be might be the
  316. most important. But, I mean, they've beaten the Lions a couple of times now already. um you know they had they've
  317. had some struggles in other games but it was it's really strange because after that first week of the season I think
  318. with Micah Parsons coming there probably being a little bit overvalued in his impact people were you know seeing them
  319. as a Super Bowl contender initially and then I guess I guess they've had some un
  320. they've had some bad performances on some some high-profile games but I don't know but at least by by my numbers
  321. they're still they're still right up there whereas Detroit is maybe faded a little bit from from what I was
  322. expecting due to some injuries and some other things so far this year. I just want to note that they play Sunday
  323. afternoon with the ba the Bears are coming to town that the the current number one seed Chicago Bears going into
  324. Green Bay as six and a half point underdogs and we know home fields. >> Yeah, the Bears win that game. I'm going
  325. to I'm going to hear about it. I'm definitely going to hear about it. >> Okay, but as I think Mike Sando over the
  326. Athletic, he wrote a column about the Bears not being probably as good as they are. It's it's it's kind of too easy at
  327. this point to talk about these different things, but um the Bears being another game, right? So they they won a really
  328. high-profile game this last week >> and their offense stunk and their passing offense really I mean their
  329. offense but their passing offense really bad. >> It wasn't good. Yeah, it was really bad.
  330. >> But there's one play there was one highlight play that got shown a lot from from Caleb. And I think Caleb is one of
  331. those guys where the the the the film hipsters, they love to see that one play and they say, you know what, if we can
  332. get him to do that 10 times a game, but the problem is he he he just can't do it
  333. 10 times a game. Look, we got a playoff essentially, in my view, a playoff game on Thursday night. I was talking about
  334. it just before we came on the air here. Uh Cowboys Lions Thursday night. That's I mean, whoever loses that game is
  335. essentially eliminated. I mean, if the Cowboys are 66 and one, they're not making the playoffs. If the Lions go to
  336. seven and six, they're probably not making the playoffs. I'm just saying that's a highprofile Thursday night
  337. game. >> Was that Was that just last year that Dallas went to Detroit and got knocked
  338. out of the playoffs? Is that what am I thinking about that right? >> No. >> Um, >> one of the last
  339. >> I remember it. I was going to say two years ago. I didn't think Dallas made >> Maybe I got it wrong. All right, but we
  340. we're we're taking too much of your time, but I got to ask you two more teams. My two favorite teams, Ravens and
  341. Bills. >> No, >> I thought you were going to say the Buccaneers. Sorry. >> Sorry. Sorry. No, another B two other B
  342. teams. And Eric's got some Bills love ending. though it's just not as much as his Bucks or Eagles float.
  343. Kevin, give us some hope. >> Bills and Ravens. >> Well, I mean, the Ravens are probably
  344. the other team along with the Chiefs who has a combination of of as far as their
  345. struggles versus their record versus where you were expecting them going to the season being the furthest off. But
  346. it's I think it's been a combination of Jackson's injury and at least since returning from injury, he has not been
  347. very good and their defense was struggling a lot a lot earlier this year. So, I mean, I still have them as
  348. on the on the outside of the of the top 10, but I'm not sure it's good enough, honestly, to really get them going to to
  349. to to make a run in the playoffs. >> Um, yeah, it's just it's odd that that team
  350. is odd this year. Obviously, the the the Jackson injury is a huge thing, but just
  351. independently of that, it's just it seems like so far off expectations. I don't I
  352. >> Yeah, I mean, if you look at like just for offensive EPA per play they've had
  353. the last I guess is they've been back for four weeks, it's just barely positive, negative, barely positive,
  354. negative. And those and I mean, that's bad for a team that you're expecting to have to have a good offense. So, I think
  355. that's one of the problems is you hate to you hate to point to a few games and say is something wrong with um but there
  356. there were at least numerous plays whether it was against a very easy Jets team or or other offenses that they've
  357. played defense that they played recently where I don't know it just the things are not clicking at least for them right
  358. now and we have a smaller sample to judge Lamar Jackson by this season. >> So, the Bills did them a favor and
  359. knocked the Steelers off in a pretty impressive win I would say last weekend. Um talk about the Bills. Talk about the
  360. Bills. They obviously got a, you know, they're looking a wild card this year for the first time in a while. They're
  361. looking at a legitimate conference uh division um peer that's outpacing them. What do you think about the Bills?
  362. >> Well, they're an interesting situation because last year they were they had to
  363. sneak in uh with a with a late run where fundamentally they were a lot better than their record at about the same
  364. point. Um I think they're still they're still a bit better than their record. And I mean, I've viewed the Bills as,
  365. and maybe I'm I'm off from some people's perception on this, but you know, again,
  366. since 2020 when Allen had his thirdyear breakout till till now, as being the second best team in the NFL overall,
  367. despite the fact that they never made the Super Bowl because the Chiefs make it every single year, no matter how well
  368. Josh Allen seems to play in some of those games. And Josh Allen as, you know, I'm not sure if people saw Patrick
  369. Mahomes as as in his own tier, but I I I think I still do at this point as being
  370. the best quarterback in the NFL, but if anyone's approaching him, it's to me it's Josh Allen. when you have kind of
  371. that history of success as a team and you have that level of quarterback and I think I think he can probably turn it on
  372. or off a little bit more than what some what some others can do because of his ability to do every I mean he can he can
  373. he can be in a shootout or he can you know grind out um quarterback design runs all all day long if if he wants to
  374. do it. He's now been performing well in a short passing yak offense and he used to chuck the ball, you know, 30 yards
  375. down the field sometimes ill advisedly uh in the past. So, I don't know. I I think he's just on that level where I'm
  376. always going to be backing them as as a top top-notch team if they make the playoffs.
  377. >> Look, the tough thing for Bills or anybody that's in that seventh spot in the AFC is to make the Super Bowl,
  378. you're probably going to have to win at Denver and at Patriots. And that's not going to be trivial to do. It's not
  379. trivial for any seven seed to make the Super Bowl, but I'm just saying um those are two strongish teams and it w it will
  380. not be easy. >> I'm with Kevin. You you you if you have to back some team in those situations,
  381. you want to back a team with a proven quarterback and Josh Allen's about as proven as we have at this stage. Okay.
  382. Uh in in just 30 seconds, if you had to put chips on three teams, your life depends on getting the Super Bowl
  383. winner. Which three teams you got? >> Super Bowl winner. Um, okay. Well, that's gonna we're gonna have to factor
  384. in, you know, record and >> for sure. Yes. How good I I think these teams actually are at this point. I
  385. mean, it's a weird situation where the the the NFC has been performing a little bit better. Um, but I still think the
  386. AFC could be a harder path if these teams end up end up making the playoffs. So, it would probably be like multiple
  387. teams out of the the NFC. So, uh the Rams and probably the Packers next. Um and then
  388. I probably take the the I guess I guess I would go with the Bills before flipping back and just off of record.
  389. And you know, you never know what could happen in another difficult place to play is Seattle. You never know. Let's
  390. go with Sam Darnold after that and say he's he's already got he's got the record and maybe he's just crazy enough
  391. to to get his team to the Super Bowl. >> Okay. Well, one of the things you're telling us is you like you like three
  392. teams out of the NFC and you just damn near put all your chips on getting one of those and it'd be Rams, Seahawks, and
  393. Packers not in that order. Rams, Packers, Seahawks. Interesting, fun. Well, I I I just think if you know if
  394. the if the Ravens or the Chiefs make it and the Bills are in there, um you're going to have some stiff competition to
  395. get out. Even if you have a strong record, like let's say you're the Patriots or the Broncos or someone like
  396. that, you're going to have a pretty tough time. I I think and if they all make it in there, then then it's just
  397. stacked um as far as the difficulty of of getting out of that situation. Whereas if you can if you're the Rams or
  398. you're the Seahawks or you're the Packers and you get one of those top seeds, I think you could have a more
  399. comfortable uh trip through the playoffs. >> Yep. Like it. Kevin, thanks for the
  400. time, man. Really appreciate it. Y'all go track him down. Kevin Cole, Unexpected Points, Substack. Fantastic
  401. read on sports analytics, especially on the NFL. Kevin Cole, thanks for the time, man. Good to see you.
  402. >> Good to see you guys, too. Thanks so much. >> Come back and join us after the break.
  403. >> All right. >> Welcome back. Welcome back to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome back to the second
  404. half of this week's show. A full hour on Sports Analytics coming to you on the Wharton podcast network. This is Kade
  405. Massie back in the host chair after yet another technology issue at the top of the show. Eric sliding in gracefully
  406. kicking us off last quarter announcement. PSA PSA for especially my team members. I'm on a brand new laptop
  407. as of two hours ago. I have technology that wasn't produced pre- pandemic and maybe that will help with the
  408. cooperation with our platform. We are just off the line with Kevin Cole. Kevin, bring us up to speed. Very
  409. helpful to me on the NFL side. We've got about 15 minutes to run through the rest
  410. of the sporting world. Top up. First thing, let's acknowledge regular season over in college football except for Army
  411. Navy. We've got some conference championship games dead ahead this weekend. We have a little bit of drama
  412. around the playoff seeds, the bracket, who's going to be in. There's not a lot of drama, but there's some there's a few
  413. slots to be. >> I have a question. I do have a question for you about that. Let's imagine that
  414. in the um SEC championship game. Okay. Not hard to believe Georgia beats Alabama. Let's say that happens.
  415. Alabama's now a three- loss team. So, do they count that? Like we've talked about
  416. like there are a bunch of two loss teams that might say, "Wait a second, Bama's lost three." What happens if Georgia
  417. beats Alabama? >> We don't we don't have enough track record to really know, much less um
  418. track record with this committee because committees change year to year. >> Um there's plenty of argument that you
  419. shouldn't be penalized for making a conference championship and losing. And I think that's probably the the standard
  420. expectation. But if a team is panced and embarrassed and shown to be not what we
  421. thought they were, the committee has the right to revise. So I don't think that's
  422. going to happen. But I sus I mean I think if they got panced, there's some chance, but mostly no. And I don't think
  423. they should. I don't think they should be punished for making the SEC championship game.
  424. >> I mean, I'm f I'm fine with a three loss team making the playoffs if that you
  425. know. >> How about I got a three I got a three loss team for you. >> Well, I got Yeah. Well, [laughter]
  426. I just forget. You'll you'll correct me. Did Texas play Alabama this year? >> No. Uh they they they played and lost to
  427. Ohio State and they played and lost to Georgia and critically vitally for them. >> No, I know they beat Texas Tech or
  428. whoever the last week or whatever. >> Texas&M and you know Texas Tech haven't played Texas Tech. They beat&m uh&m.
  429. >> We don't need to talk about Texas right now. What is notable Eric? You like chaos. I'll give you this isn't chaos,
  430. but you'll like the story. >> All right. Give it to me. Yeah. Duke Duke has five losses, but by various
  431. tiebreaker shenanigans have made it into the ACC championship game against UVA. And the rule isn't that the four power
  432. conferences champions make it and then the the rest the group of five the best of the group of five. It's the top
  433. whatever top what I've lost my numbers. It's the top >> five top five rated conference champions
  434. make it. And um there's some chance that if Duke So Duke's a three and a half point underdog. UVA already beat him
  435. once this year. Duke's a three and a half point underdog. That's not that much. Duke could win. Duke could be a
  436. five loss champion of the ACC and be lower rated than two group of five or group of six champ conference group of
  437. five conference champions. So, it's possible that that ACC wouldn't have a a representative. Now, I've got your eyes
  438. open. Now, now I've got your >> I knew about that. I did know about that. I knew that it was no longer It
  439. wasn't that every uh group of five school like the ACC may have no representative and I would be fine by
  440. that. I It means that I assume you mean like Tain could be ranked higher. >> Well, Tain Tain would I believe be
  441. ranked higher um if they win their game against North Texas. So, the in North Texas. Whoever wins that game,
  442. >> North Texas two-lane winner is going to be higher. The question is whether James
  443. Madison, so we need James Madison to win, seriously, James Madison to win and Duke to be like unimpressive in their
  444. win over UVA and then we're going to get a no ACC playoff. That would be glorious. The other thing that possibly
  445. could screw things up, if you you who like chaos, is if BYU, who's a 12 and a half point underdog to Texas Tech, if
  446. BYU wins, that'll be a classic bid stealer like the like the NCAA that's like the March Madness bid
  447. Steelers where a team that otherwise wouldn't get in gets the conference champion ticket and Tech is Texas Tech
  448. in no matter what. And so that would knock out an atlarge power five team if they did that.
  449. >> Wow. So, just to be clear, that could knock out a Notre Dame as an example. >> Yeah. And the the ones on the edge are
  450. kind of Notre Dame, Alabama, Oklahoma. I don't know who's the least ranked of those.
  451. >> And just to be clear, if BYU, just to my Am I correct that Texas Tech, did they
  452. lose recently? >> No. Tech lost first half of the season to Arizona State. >> Okay. First half of the season. Okay.
  453. So, if if from some shocking way they get beaten by two scores, they're going anyway. Tech's in. Tech Tech can't knock
  454. themselves out of this. I don't think they can't knock themselves out. Well, >> it would be amazing if I don't even What
  455. are they in the big Is they still called a Big What are they in now? The Big 12?
  456. [laughter] >> Yes, the Big 12. >> Oh, is BYU BYU's in the Big 12? >> Yeah, they're both
  457. >> whatever. Whatever conference they're in. That would be shocking if two We There had been times, Kate, earlier in
  458. the season, we're talking about are any Big 12 teams getting in. We could get two Big 12 teams. No ACC, no ACC team.
  459. That's right. That's right. You can get two what you want. You want two Big 12. You want BYU, you want Duke to win in a,
  460. you know, fumble recovery at the end of the game and then you want James Madison
  461. to blow out whoever they play. They're big favorites, by the way. Um, and then so you'd have BYU, Texas Tech, two lane,
  462. and uh James Madison, but nobody from the AC. >> Beautiful. And by the way, are IU and
  463. Ohio State playing for the one seat? >> Uh, yeah, absolutely. Yeah, that's that's that's true.
  464. >> Okay. >> Um, >> nothing really to root for there. I mean, it doesn't really it's not a buy.
  465. I mean, the first four teams got a buy and both these teams >> Well, it's another question. No, no,
  466. >> they're probably both going to get a buy. >> It's no longer remember last year, I
  467. forget who it was, like the 18th ranked team got a buy. That's gone now. It's the top four ranked team. So, I both
  468. these teams are getting buys. Okay. So, so they're not I mean, they're playing for a lot. They're still playing for a
  469. Big 10 championship, but they're not playing for that much as far as >> it's interesting, Eric. That's That's
  470. exactly right. And that's a fair take. And it's similar. It's similar with the SEC. It's not It's not as It's not as
  471. cut and dry, but these they you kind of have to care about the champ the conference championships for themselves
  472. to care much about these games other than those Big 10 teams haven't played a lot. I mean, they haven't played a lot
  473. of competition. And so it's kind of a is, you know, are they both real? Are they both as good as we think?
  474. >> Let me ask you let me ask you another question. Is the following possible? I haven't even thought about this. Georgia
  475. has already lost one game, right? They have one loss. Okay, let's suppose Alabama sticks it to
  476. Georgia. Is there any argument that Alabama should be a top four seed, get a week
  477. off as opposed to Oh, so Alabama and Georgia are playing for something. I mean, if Alabama wins that game
  478. convincingly, Alabama could move into the four slot, which is where they have Georgia now, get a week off and and
  479. >> or the two slot. They could be two. I mean, the SEC champion. Are you kidding?
  480. That's a thing for sure. >> Okay. So, all right. So, that game I really So, I wasn't that excited about
  481. that game, but now I mean, it's George Alabama still, but I now I'm really excited about it because Bama's got
  482. something to play for. seeds are going to be moved around but uh but in but the the so what's what's the yeah the the
  483. margin the outside margin the extrinsic margin is not is there's a little bit of
  484. action but there's not that much action >> okay >> okay Eric um I know you want to talk
  485. about NBA talk to us about though I have before we do that you you brought my attention to the fact that the Colorado
  486. Avalanche have only lost one regulation game all season that's absolutely spectacular now they have
  487. >> looking Yeah I was looking They have six overtime losses. They have six overtime.
  488. >> No, but I mean I understand those are losses. I get how it's scored, but they're 181 and six.
  489. >> Are they just playing Are they just playing for overtime? Do they just do they do they just crowd the net and save
  490. the defensive zone once they get to the third? >> No. No. We don't know how many over I
  491. don't know how many overtime wins they have. I know they have six overtime losses. I They could be 0 and six in
  492. overtime as far as I know. I I just don't know. Um, but you know, I do this every year at this time of year. They're
  493. on pace for the best record ever in the history of the NHL. 138 points. The record, by the way, is 135 just a couple
  494. years ago. Obviously, you'd have to mean revert. They're not really on they have
  495. they do not have an exceedence where you'd give them anywhere near even a 50% probability. It would you you couldn't
  496. be more than I'm making up a number 20% at this point. It's not maybe even lower. It's not that low.
  497. >> Probably lower. Yeah. Yeah. Plus, we'd like to know we'd like to know some peripherals, as y'all call them in
  498. baseball, peripherals, like what what are the what are the fundamentals driving that 181 and six record. Do we
  499. believe are they are they above expectation, below expectation? >> What's the what's Pythagorean theorem
  500. for hockey? I don't I I don't I don't know what the parameter >> That's a great that's a great question.
  501. But either way, I just noticed they've only lost at the end of regulation right now, they've played 25 games and they
  502. have lost one. >> Um All right. Well, you got another example in the NBA, so let's jump over
  503. there. >> The Oklahoma City >> last week. Yeah, last week in the NBA, uh, you know, Audi and I were on the
  504. show. I said, Audi, how great do you think OKC is? Remember, they're the defending champs. I forget if they won
  505. 67 or 68 games last year, but they weren't a poter last year. They won the title and they were the one seed going
  506. into the They were the one seed going into the NBA tournament. No one believed in them. They they won the title last
  507. year, right? people who believed in them last year, they they >> not not but not as strongly like well
  508. you know they've not proven themsel now they're the NBA champs they've got the MVP in Shay Gildish Alexander they're 20
  509. and one 20 and one on a 12game winning streak >> last year they set the record you may
  510. remember Kade for the best point differential in the history of the NBA at 11.5 well they've played 21 games
  511. this year and they're 15.5. So, at some point soon, if this team wins another title, and it's not
  512. shocking me, let me ask a question. When do we start talking about the best record all time? They're 20 and one.
  513. >> Okay, the record 73-9. 73-9. So, they still have to go 53 and 8, which is no joke, but they're at a
  514. pace, I mean, you can do math right now. on the pace of I know there's not 84 games, but 80 and four.
  515. >> Yeah. Yeah. It's it's uh it's that's pretty fantastic. >> And their second best player,
  516. >> Jaylen Jackson, just came back from injury. I think he's played one or two games.
  517. >> Okay. What's the best, Eric? What's the best two season cumulative record we've
  518. ever seen? >> That's a great question. I'm only guessing and I'm gonna say it's a I'm
  519. guessing and one of our listeners at WMoneyball can exit us or tweet at us, however you want to call it. I'm going
  520. to guess it's uh 138 or 139 somewhere around there. Could be it could be as much as 140 like maybe
  521. that the um the Warriors when they won 73 167 or something around there the game before. It's certainly not more
  522. than 140. And I think I have to look exactly at how much OKC won last year, but uh here I can look at it up quickly.
  523. OKC 2024 2025 record. Last year they won 68. Yeah. So if they get to 72, that could well be a record
  524. for the best two year. And certainly I'm not saying it's guaranteed. I'd be shocked if they don't break the record.
  525. You'd agree with this. You'd be shocked if they don't break the record for the greatest point differential at this
  526. point. >> This point. I mean, I' I'd like to know how there's what schedule they've played
  527. so far. I don't know if it's if it's how balanced it is, how unbalanced it is. It's also there's a lot of there's a you
  528. know, we talked about this on the show two weeks ago. There's some real trash in the NBA this year. The trash is trash
  529. usual. And so adjusting for that in some way would seem to be appropriate. But >> I think also you have to ask the
  530. question if they're, you know, 70 and five, >> do they play for the record or do they
  531. say, "Look, forget the record. We want to win a second title back to back." They rest Sheay, they rest Chad
  532. Holgrren, they rest Jaylen Jackson. All of a sudden, you and I are playing the last 10 games of the season.
  533. >> I've got to I've got to believe they they would care a whole lot more about the hardware than the than the one last
  534. record. Eric, I've got another Oklahoma City before we go here in Oklahoma City that kind of connects to you in a way.
  535. Eric, you're a good New Yorker. Do you know who Robert Caro is? >> Who? >> Robert Caro, the biographer.
  536. >> I don't. >> You don't. You should. You You've got some Caroesque characteristics. And you
  537. should definitely know Robert Moses. Here's a New Yorker. Robert Moses. You know who Robert?
  538. >> Robert Moses. >> Okay. So, Carol is Moses's biographer. And then he went on to be a biographer
  539. of Linda Johnson. And he's generally considered the best living biographer, one of the best historian biographers in
  540. US history. And he's got these every 10 years he produces a thousandpage volume.
  541. He's got one on run on Moses. He's got four on OBJ with a fifth to come. And we're just hoping that he makes the
  542. fifth because in he's in his 90s now. Um is he in his 90s or upper 80s? He's he's
  543. getting up there. Anyway, ESPN just wrote an article about how Sam Prey, general manager of the Oklahoma City
  544. Thunder, is a big Robert Carroll fan. Like he like he's got a real thing about Carol and his biographies. He's
  545. apparently an interesting reader anyway, but he's so much of a fan. And Carol is
  546. like a basketball fan. And so Carol knows that Prey likes his stuff. And so it's just it's my world's coming
  547. together because I teach Carol's books and I read Carol's books and I love Sam Prey. And ESPN wrote this big honken
  548. article this week on Prey and Carol. >> It just makes me love him more. As if I didn't love Sam Prey enough.
  549. >> I'll have to take a look at that. But my summary of the NBA is not last year. If
  550. I told you three years ago, three years ago, the number one teams in the NBA right now would be OKC and Detroit.
  551. [laughter] >> No, I can see I could, you know, you can almost believe Oklahoma City because
  552. they've had so many they've been rebuilding towards this. >> You know, the Sixers had a ton of draft
  553. picks, too, and they haven't made it. So, but but I think the thing I wanted to just bring up quickly is, you know,
  554. we'll talk about this on an entirely another show is kind of the speed of turnover in certain sports versus
  555. others. Like, if I told you next year, I'll make it up. I don't know who the worst MLB team was. I forget if it was
  556. the White Socks or the Rockies, let's say it's the Rockies, I forget who it was, who won like barely 40 something
  557. games. If I told you they win the title next year, you say absolutely not. There's no chance. If I told you next
  558. year the Giants win the title, you'd probably still say no chance, right? No chance.
  559. >> Well, the San Francisco Giants, they bounce around pretty reliably. >> I meant the New York Giants. I meant the
  560. football, but probably in the NBA, you know, in a two or threeear stretch, certainly in the NFL, like the if I had
  561. told you two years ago the Patriots may be looking at having the best record in the NFL, I I no
  562. >> Yeah. Still no. >> Yeah. Still no. It's amazing how quickly they and that's why I think in my view
  563. Mike Greybel's the coach of the year. He has to be the coach of the year. >> Yeah, that's reasonable. Utterly
  564. reasonable. And what I mean what a hire he's proven to be so far. And Drake when
  565. Drake May and Drabel, you get a solid coach and a good QB and that's pretty much
  566. >> you're set. You're not quite set, but you're close. Okay, why don't we wrap it
  567. there? That's been a full hour of sports analytics here on Wharton Moneyball. Thanks to Kevin Cole, our guest in the
  568. first half of the show. Thanks to Marissa Raina, our producer, to Dion Samkins, our associate producer who
  569. makes this thing go round. Deep Patel, the big boss lady. And to you guys, the listeners, thanks for being with us.
  570. Come back and join us next time. Between now and then, enjoy your sports.

Brief Summary

Kevin Cole discusses NFL analytics, team performance, and power rankings, highlighting the disconnect between win-loss records and actual team strength.

Key points

  • Power Rankings Humor. Kevin shares a humorous take on his power rankings' accuracy.
  • Disconnect in Rankings. Kevin explains the disconnect between public perception and his power rankings.
  • Chiefs' Playoff Chances Dwindle. Despite being one of the best teams, the Chiefs face tough odds for the playoffs.
  • The Texans' Defense Dominates. The Texans have emerged as the number one defense in the NFL, surprising many.
  • Packers' Playoff Seed Importance. The Packers may need the number one seed to succeed in the playoffs.
  • High-Stakes Cowboys vs. Lions. The upcoming game between the Cowboys and Lions could determine playoff fates.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes