Why Credit Card Borrowing Remains Costly for Consumers

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE In this interview, Itamar Drechsler explains that credit card APRs stay high because defaults and interest rates account for only part of the cost, while surprisingly large operating expenses, especially marketing, make up a lot of the rest. He adds that rewards are funded mainly through interchange fees paid by retailers, not through high APRs, and that marketing-driven consumer behavior gives big issuers market power over lower-rate options like credit unions. Drechsler also notes that many banks offer lower-rate personal loans than their own credit cards, likely because these products require far less marketing.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#CreditCards #ConsumerFinance #APR #FinTech #Banking #CreditCardRewards ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Consumers rely on credit cards that cover their spending on a variety of fronts, but they also know that there
  2. are fees associated with those cards and for the most part they are going to be fairly high. Still, many wonder why the
  3. rates we pay on credit cards are so high. To better understand that, you have to know the basics of so-called
  4. credit card banking. And that was the subject of a paper earlier this year led by our guest today, Inamar Dressler, who
  5. is a professor of finance at the Wharton School and co-director of the Rodney El
  6. White Center for Financial Research. Inar, great to talk to you again. How are you, sir?
  7. >> Good. Thank you very much for having me on. >> Thank you. Uh, obviously this is a topic
  8. that a lot of people know about. It's in our day daily lives, but what was it that drew you to want to look at why
  9. these fees are so high? Uh actually my um co-authors who are uh also my students well two two of them are one of
  10. them is a former student who's a professor at Colombia now uh they came a couple years ago they wanted to talk
  11. about fintech because everybody talks about fintech and then we as we were thinking about why fintech may or may
  12. not be able to succeed in the marketplace. The question was what about the incumbents? And for a lot of these
  13. fintech kind of things, the incumbents, you know, in terms of getting people to borrow or spend with some kind of
  14. payment or borrowing technology, then the incumbent are credit cards. And we were like, okay, so what potential
  15. advantage or disadvantage do fintech have relative to the incumbents? And so we were trying to understand what's the
  16. economics of credit card banking. And one of the first things you see is okay, what kind of rates do credit cards
  17. charge? Uh, and they're extremely high. Uh, I don't borrow off my credit card, so I was less familiar with that. You
  18. look at them and they're just so much higher than any kind of um return that banks make on any other kind of loan or
  19. indeed any kind of other asset in the market. And so we're just interested in understanding like how do you get, you
  20. know, there is competition among credit card companies. How do you get to this kind of rate,
  21. >> right? And there obviously are are a variety of reasons for this and you go through a lot of in the paper. One of
  22. which uh I is how these companies market themselves and those marketing costs which have to be factored back into the
  23. overall uh fees that people pay. >> Yeah, that's something people have been uh particularly interested about in the
  24. paper, I guess, because it's the thing that you don't expect or don't think of. I maybe people do expect it, but I I
  25. didn't expect it. So when you think about it, you know, the kind of more obvious things are that significant, not
  26. huge, but a sign, you know, substantial default on credit cards, especially for lower credit scores. So you expect that,
  27. but that is nowhere near the rate that credit card companies charge. So the average credit card APR is right now is
  28. 23 24%. 5%, let's say, is just the short-term interest rate that the Fed sets. about
  29. uh 6% is is or 5% is uh sort of the average level of defaults. But that still leaves
  30. you know if that adds up to let's say 10 11% that still leaves another 13% that is not explained by either of those kind
  31. of obvious things. And what we saw is that uh not the rest not the whole rest of it but about a little under half uh
  32. in a substantial amount is explained by these guys operating costs. Now, maybe I'm not very imaginative, but I never
  33. thought that credit card was particularly high operating cost kind of a business. But it turns out relative to
  34. all kinds of other banking, it is apparently extremely high. But one big piece of that is marketing. And it turns
  35. out that perhaps because a bunch of the credit card banks are not heavy on branches or physical locations or things
  36. like that, um they spend a lot on customer acquisition costs as pure marketing. And I was surprised to see
  37. literally how much they they spent. Um operating costs are, you know, about 5% of assets, meaning that for every dollar
  38. people borrow off a credit card, five% of that, 5 cents of that uh that they're paying in terms of their rate a year is
  39. just going to cover uh uh operating costs. And and like I said, a big part of that is is these customer acquisition
  40. costs. And it turns out that credit card banks are among the largest marketers that we see in the economy for
  41. consumers. >> I also found it interesting, you know, in the paper that the rewards programs
  42. that most of these credit card companies have, those are elements that are factored in as well.
  43. >> Yes. So the people are very into rewards. So rewards are very large. If you look at the amount of dollars that
  44. uh is paid out as rewards, it's it's really big. Uh I mean it's it's around depends how you you judge you know how
  45. you look at it exactly but just the the few largest credit card banks which are the most you know paid over $70 billion
  46. of credit card rewards. However, I should say I think there's a misconception that this somehow explains
  47. the high rates on credit cards and that's not true. The way that they pay that off is through the interchange. So
  48. that there's there's been some news reporting this week about a 20-year-old court case that was set on this.
  49. Interchange is is the fees that retailers pay whenever you swipe your credit card there. And maybe I don't
  50. know how much people know about this, but they charge on average over 2% of what you're paying. They have to to pay
  51. to the combination of the the card network like Visa and most of it goes to the issuing bank and most of that goes
  52. to people's rewards. So it's it's essentially a pass through and a lot of dollars that get charged as interchange.
  53. I think retailers as this court case showed really hate that but they have not been able to get around it.
  54. >> You mentioned as well that just the kind of the market power that these firms
  55. have as well. >> Yes. So I think a lot of this market by market power you know to be technical
  56. about it mean their ability to charge a rate that is higher than sort of the marginal cost of providing the dollar of
  57. loans. So it's not just the average defaults, the interest rate, the it it is above that. There is a markup above
  58. the cost of providing a dollar, but that markup >> in large part goes to paying things like
  59. the customer acquisition cost. So it it's still the case that it's a markup. It's still the case that if they did not
  60. spend so much on customer acquisition marketing, credit card rates would be several percentage points, maybe more
  61. than several lower. But the reason that that happens is because people respond to marketing. Uh it works. So, you know,
  62. I've talked to people about this. I think the best way to explain it is you could there could be an alternative
  63. credit card bank that would say, you know what, we're not going to do any of this marketing. We're going to save the
  64. money. We're going to charge people, let's say, 3 4% less on their credit card a year. And people are going to
  65. like that. They care about lower rates and they're going to come and they're going to uh take this credit card. That
  66. doesn't really work. People would not know about it and they would not respond to it. So such cards exist. If you
  67. really want to, you can go to credit unions that have much lower rates, but you know, we can see their market share
  68. is is is minuscule. >> Yeah. So what is then kind of the the best future outcome for the consumer in
  69. still being able to have the ability to use credit to to their advantage when they need to, but maybe a path where
  70. you're not paying the higher rates, you know, as we look down the road. Is fintech going to be something that is
  71. going to really delve into this in the years ahead? >> So, I think for people right now there
  72. that the the better options if they care about this kind of thing, they're willing to uh go to the not big trouble
  73. but small trouble of doing that is to to actually search. And so, for example, go
  74. to one of the credit unions uh that have this lower rate. There are also some banks. And another thing, which I
  75. actually really don't understand it completely, but I think it has to do with the fact that they spend way less
  76. uh marketing dollars on it, is that the same banks offer um uh uh personal loans
  77. that are bigger than the amount of credit you could get off a credit card and have a lower rate. So, and actually
  78. the people who use that, so it's not like nobody uses that, often use it to pay off their credit card debt. as far
  79. as I can tell. I mean, I I shouldn't I don't want to be seen as giving financial advice to people, but that is
  80. a superior, you know, exchange. You can get a bigger loan. You just have to control yourself from spending it. Pay
  81. off all your credit card debt and replace it. It's, you know, credit card consolidation as they call it and and
  82. and pay what is often a substantially lower rate. And this as available from, you know, MX, Discover,
  83. uh uh you know, Chase, they have that. Um it's it's strange, but it's true. And it's part of it is they don't they don't
  84. market it. So they're not trying to pay to get back the the the marketing dollars from the higher rate there. So I
  85. think that's clearly a superior trade for people as far as I could tell. >> Edomar, great to talk to you today.
  86. Thanks very much for your time. >> Thank you very much. >> Thank you, Edmar Drestler who is a
  87. professor of finance here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Inamar Dressler explains high credit card fees, marketing costs, and consumer options for lower rates in this episode.

Key points

  • Understanding Credit Card Fees. A deep dive into why credit card rates are so high, including marketing costs.
  • The Role of Marketing in Credit Costs. Marketing costs significantly contribute to high credit card fees, surprising many consumers.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes