Building Companies that Make a Difference

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Joey Hundert — social entrepreneur, start-up consultant and founder of the “Sustainival” — has been working for a decade and a half to promote ventures that both make money and make the world a better place. More: http://knlg.net/1Fo6ld5 📂 ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Hi, I'm Tyler Ry, professor of entrepreneurship in the management department here at Wharton. Sitting here
  2. today with Joey Hund, who is a social entrepreneur in residence here at the Wharton School for the Week. We're going
  3. to talk a little bit about Joey's experience as an entrepreneur, as well as the energy he's seen around social
  4. enterprise here in the Wharton student population. So, Joey, welcome. Thank you so much. It's nice to have you here.
  5. It's awesome to be here. So, you've been doing this for a few years now. Tell me
  6. a little bit about the background, how you got into social enterprise and how you ended up coming to Wharton to talk
  7. about it in terms of what I do here at Wharton or how I got here. Well, I got here from your invite about four years
  8. ago to come and guest lecture in one of your classes and then I discovered the Wharton Social Impact Initiative and
  9. just what's going on there um and Cheryl Coleman and and her the people she's working with to create a really unique
  10. platform for social enterprise here at Wharton in a very in a very powerful way. Um, so I've become sort of this
  11. social entrepreneur in residence and while here get to learn what they're doing at the impact initiative and I'm
  12. always amazed at how they're developing each year. These are super ambitious people developing something really
  13. unique to help nurture social enterprise and I guess within that um the intent is
  14. for me to come and lecture initially on not just social enterprise and social entrepreneurship but entrepreneurship in
  15. general from a deeply experential point of view. Um given that what's understood
  16. by faculty here and people who care about the student body is there's tons of drive for people to get a lot of
  17. students want to get into startup and into venture only they're coming at it from a very theoretical academic basis
  18. um lacking experience and so some awesome professors such as yourself will have students try to create startup
  19. ideas and work on startups in class which is getting them this much needed experential component and I suppose I
  20. drop into the system to try to work with them and and and get them heads up about
  21. um the experience of entrepreneurship and what they're missing and help work on their ideas with them and help them
  22. refine their ideas. Right on. So maybe let's dig in a little bit on this social enterprise piece. So this is one of
  23. these terms that's still thrown around a little bit. You know, we talk about social enterprise, we talk about social
  24. entrepreneurship, but in my experience when you start to really dig in around this, you know, people can be having
  25. really different conversations about what these two components mean together. Yeah. You know, there's a social,
  26. there's the entrepreneurship, which are both vague. you start mashing them up and you know sometimes you lose a little
  27. bit in the combination. So how do you define this stuff and what are you seeing in terms of the students who are
  28. working on it? Interesting. I define social enterprise or social venture as a company or venture nonprofit or
  29. otherwise some sort of organization that has a social impact baked right into the
  30. product or or right into the value they seek to offer society. Not like, hey, on
  31. occasion with 1% of our profits, we do this thing for helping people out. To me, that's too minor. Uh, more so it's,
  32. well, every time you buy this, we give the exact same value to another community or by virtue of you buying
  33. this product, people are getting educated just by being around. To me, social enterprise is when the social
  34. impact of either uh education, helping lift people out of poverty, helping provide access to food or drinking
  35. water, helping to level quality of life around the world. These sorts of things,
  36. lifting people out of poverty, um creating education, inspiration, that has to be worked right into the product,
  37. not like, hey, uh once a year we go volunteer. That's not it. to me uh an actual uh larger percentage of cost of
  38. goods sold or a larger percentage of gross revenues is is put at this purpose and it's continually reinvested in. Not
  39. only that, but the the values of the founders are commensurate with this creating impact. It's uh it can be that
  40. the founders have figured out that this is a market advantage. It gives them a leg up on their competitors. I don't
  41. really care if that's the driver. More so that the impact is consistent. it's measurable and it's doing something
  42. great in society. So there's a lot baked into that definition. Maybe we could just pull on the mix between the social
  43. and the financial aid. So what you're talking about is a real hybrid organization, right? I mean, you're
  44. pursuing some sort of revenue stream at the same time you're addressing a big social problem. Totally. So what sort of
  45. problems do these organizations run into? I mean, so there's got to be challenges that are baked in. Oh, yeah.
  46. But then what are the benefits as well? Got it. So in my own case, so I started the world's first green carnival in
  47. 2011. All of our rides run on waste, vegetable, oil, wind, and solar power. And we we created the carnival
  48. specifically to educate people on sustainable technologies, and even more to inspire people about why to be
  49. hopeful about the future, why tomorrow could be better than today. Um now if you look at our cost structure uh us
  50. versus a typical carnival um we have to generate our own energy collect the feed
  51. stocks to make our own energy create a totally compelling and engaging educational layer on top of everything.
  52. Engage students, nonprofits, foundations, government. You like we have a thousand times more relationships
  53. baked into our show to make it happen than the carnival that rolls into the shopping a shopping store parking lot
  54. sets up for 3 days. And then let's look at revenues. Their revenues are ticket revenues. 100% of their revenues are
  55. coming through tickets or people playing games or buying food. And it's that's 100% of the revenue base for us. Our
  56. revenues are ticket revenues, people playing games and buying food. But much more so corporate sponsorship,
  57. government grants, u contributions, donations, the whole mix. And then if you look again at the cost structure,
  58. our show costs about 90% more than their show costs. So, we have this huge risk of having a wildly more expensive show
  59. than they do because we're serving so so many more mandates and we need so much more resource to make it happen. At the
  60. same time, it opens us up to all those other revenue streams. There's no company out there that really wants to
  61. sponsor a dingy carnival with questionable operators and safety and ethics. Whereas over here, you have the
  62. world's first green carnival which is engaging people in blowing minds and doing something beautiful in society.
  63. We're a sponsorable asset. And so with that, we have a diversified revenue base that a traditional carnival does not
  64. have. And at the same time, it's way more complex to run. It's way we need a total different acumen of operator and
  65. executives to make that all work. Whereas this is way more simple. There are definitely pluses and minuses to
  66. social enterprise. And I think that any social enterprise with a blended mandate, blended return to society is
  67. inevitably going to be more complex to operate and at the same time is going to get benefits for that like diversifying
  68. revenue streams lasting through economic recessions because they're seen as as a
  69. greater value than just a cash value. So is there any risk with that of abandoning social mission when the going
  70. gets tough on the financial side? And I mean, you know, what you're you're talking about is, you know, a cost
  71. structure complexity that's an order of magnitude higher than your competitors. Sure, it opens you up to additional
  72. revenue streams and additional opportunities, but I mean, there still has to be this tension. You know, what
  73. happens when you have these moments where it's just not clear, okay, we need to run this thing. We need to keep the
  74. lights on. We have the social mission. What happens when these things butt into each other? What do you do? I get it. I
  75. think that the question you just asked is going to change per entrepreneur that you ask because each of us exists on a
  76. continuum on the spectrum from I'm driven by social mandate to I'm driven by profit motive. I'm driven I'm I am
  77. towards the social mandate side and I've used I've learned to make uh better and
  78. better decisions as it relates to making money so that the organization can survive. But here comes my answer which
  79. is going to be a direct relation to who I am and the way I feel. when the going gets tough or sustainable, I there's
  80. nothing in my mind that says if we hollow out the education side that things will be better for us. It just
  81. that never occurs. Instead, um I use that stressful moment to find new ways to make the whole thing work. Here's an
  82. example. Um we're really good with big machines. We've got giant giant generators on site and we run them on
  83. waste vegetable oil. I got approached by a company and they have giant machines,
  84. wood grinders. They grind up waste wood like pallets and construction waste. And
  85. they turned to me and they said, "Can you run our grinders on your waist vegetable oil?" I said, "We sure can."
  86. And then I said, "Not only that, we can run it on waste vegetable oil and because we're you'll be the only green
  87. wood grinding company in Canada. Let's form a partnership and I can go get bigger contracts because we're doing
  88. something special and unique. Our name will rise to the top of the pile." So the going got tough. We sourced a whole
  89. another new partnership of wood recycling and it became a revenue center that has grown independent of how well
  90. the show is doing. And so it's just an example. I structurally cannot abandon um the impact side because I my brain
  91. doesn't even go there. So would it be fair to say then I I certainly don't want to put words in your mouth but the
  92. commitment to impact and to building a sustainable venture when these things start to create tension this seems to be
  93. very generative for you. Yeah. It seems like a source of creativity. Is that a fair comment? Totally. I thrive in that
  94. tension and I encourage entrepreneurs to get there. Um, and that's the part that
  95. you can't simulate for new young people that have not yet created a venture. You
  96. can't simulate the pressure cooker of that terrible moment of creative destruction where the thing the product
  97. as it is is not going to live past that moment as it was. And how are you going to change it in order to bring in more
  98. revenue, make it safer, diminish cost, whatever you have to do to make it survive. But but if the values are
  99. really baked into the entrepreneur that the inclusion of the social impact is going to be organic and h and happening
  100. naturally so that the solutions that are uncovered contain the room for that impact to continue. Okay. So I think
  101. this is probably a good point to pivot and start talking a little bit about the students here at Wharton. Yeah. What are
  102. you seeing in terms of the energy around social enterprise with what they're doing? Do you see the potential of the
  103. people who can mix the two? I mean Wharton has a reputation as being perhaps a little more financial than
  104. social lean at all. I think we're starting to even out the scales a little bit, but how's this resonated in the
  105. student base? Given that I've been coming here for four years, I can I can take metrics on what I'm hearing and
  106. what I'm seeing advancing. What I can say what I'm hearing from the student body is that there's this deep desire to
  107. do good in the world. And I think if you look at the millennial set and the younger set, there's something about
  108. these these young people that their need to see the world improve is really powerful. And if you think about what's
  109. happened on in their youth, they've seen a terrible recession, a lingering recession. They've seen a lot of new
  110. data on climate and ecosystems and terrible weather. And so this is constantly on their consciousness and
  111. it's affecting their decisions. Even at a school that's as competitive and elite
  112. um and high acumen as Wharton, this is seeping into people. So the cool thing is you've got these students that are
  113. just brilliant at finance and they're wanting to create a huge impact in the world. And you put that together, it's a
  114. very productive intersection. Now, they're also super high achievers, which is actually a down a bit of a downside
  115. because they can't stand failure. And and entrepreneurship is just an one failure after another. And what you do
  116. with those failures, the difference between a failure and a pivot is the entrepreneur that at the moment of
  117. failure um either they they put their tail between their legs, pack up, and go home. That's a failure. Or the
  118. entrepreneur that smacks into reality and their product breaks. they remake the product to I to to to more naturally
  119. suit that reality so they can now progress and that's a pivot. So while I'm seeing lots of desire to create
  120. something awesome in the world and use these unique skills and financial acumen, there's also a bit of a a
  121. mismatch between people's appetite for failure here and what's coming for them in venture uh should they get into it.
  122. That's part of our work is is is getting the student body ready to get hit on the
  123. head in re repeat. You know, I agree. It doesn't seem to matter how many times I
  124. hit them on the head in class, they don't like it anymore. Right. So, we're running a little short on
  125. time, but if you were going to leave students with one piece of advice from all of your experience, one
  126. crystallizing moment that they could take forward with them as entrepreneurs, spec specifically in social venture,
  127. what would that be? Start now. Start small. um start now because no amount of thinking about it and and
  128. and philosophizing about venture is going to help you understand whether or not you're you're fit for it or if you
  129. like it. You know, there's so much obsession about startup and it it'd be as ridiculous as there being a huge
  130. obsession about ballet and everybody wanting to be a ballerina. It doesn't work that way. you know, the same
  131. percentage of society likely somewhere around that is going to be fit for entrepreneurship and actually like it
  132. and thrive within the constant unknown and the huge pressures. The only way to find that out is to get into it, but you
  133. don't want to get into it at massive stakes for your first kick at the can because what if you don't like it? So, I
  134. tell students a lot to start a sub $1,000 startup of some kind to address some sort of social need if they want.
  135. It could be social impact, it could be real estate, it doesn't really matter. It's start that sub thousand dollar
  136. venture so that the stakes are super low, but you put yourself in the pressure cooker to understand if you
  137. like it. Lastly, because there is no great success, there's no billion-dollar company. Uh there's no selling to
  138. Facebook for 20 billion without small successes that lead to medium successes. Like the the lineage of success that
  139. leads to the mega success that everybody reads about in Fortune, it's a long tale. And so get started and build that
  140. momentum and and should should students discover that in that first thousand venture that they hate this then stop.
  141. Go take that awesome job at Goldman or for the UN or FAO or in Washington. I mean, you know, people can access
  142. amazing things from this place. So don't cut off all the other opportunity because there's an obsession with
  143. startup. All right. Well, that's awesome, Joy. So start small, small wins. See if you like it. Yeah.
  144. Terrific. That's all the time we have. Thanks so much for joining us and I hope you will come back in the future. more
  145. years at Wharton. Hopefully, this is just the start. Amazing. Thank you, Tyler. Thanks, Joey.
  146. [Music]

Brief Summary

Joey Hund discusses social entrepreneurship, its challenges, and advice for Wharton students to start small and gain experience.

Key points

  • The Power of Social Enterprise. Joey Hund defines social enterprise as organizations with social impact baked into their core.
  • Navigating Challenges in Social Ventures. Joey discusses the complexities and benefits of running a social enterprise.
  • Advice for Aspiring Entrepreneurs. Joey encourages students to start small and test their entrepreneurial fit.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes