MOOCs and MBA Programs: Opportunities and Threats

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Innovation 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. our guests today are Christian tursh a professor of operations and information management at Wharton and Carl rrick the
  2. vice dean of innovation at Wharton and we're going to talk to them about massive open online courses or muks as
  3. they're better called and how they will impact Business Schools uh Christian and
  4. Carl thanks very much for joining us today thanks for having us thanks for having us uh Christian perhaps you could
  5. start us off by describing the main findings or takeaway from your research now let me let me preface what we're
  6. going to discuss about business school by saying that Carl and I have been in the business school world for many many
  7. years we love this institution uh and we really want to make sure that we find a
  8. sustainable path forward for the business schools but Business Schools in the world of these massive online
  9. courses are somewhat threatened and a lot of that has to do with our cost structure we are very expensive
  10. organizations and there there are really two main reasons for that is one we do two things we teach and we do research
  11. but only the teaching part comes with revenues and so all of the research work that we do all this great research that
  12. is funded for is funded for by our students and the second thing like honestly like most nonprofits we don't
  13. always have an eye on efficiency if you and I would run an airline together and we would fly our planes half empty very
  14. quickly bad things start to happen yet that culture of efficiency of productivity is something that we
  15. haven't had in the business schools and as these moves are coming along and things that we about to talk about these
  16. moves are coming along the cost pressure on our institutions are going to change
  17. because suddenly there's some very serious alternative for coming to a two-year degree to Warden right car
  18. anything to add to what Christian just said the the other thing I would say is a key finding of our analysis is really
  19. to look at what the benefits are that MBA students derive from their full-time MBA experience and we point out that
  20. teaching and learning the more traditional academic topics are probably only a quarter or a fifth of the reason
  21. that students come and get an MBA program and that's the piece that we think is most susceptible to change from
  22. this emerging new technology but that probably doesn't impact the other elements of the of the MBA program right
  23. so one of the things I found interesting in your research paper uh is that you you talk about the fact that in a Muk
  24. what is relevant to the business school is not the moo per se but the technology
  25. the video based technology that is embedded in the moo uh and and this kind of struck me because I remember 20 years
  26. ago uh uh there was a lot of hype around uh the fact that video lectures were available on on videotapes or later that
  27. they were available on uh CD ROMs and and each time there was a lot of uh you know expectation about what this would
  28. do to Business Schools but neither of these affected or or of disrupted the business
  29. school model in any fundamental way do you think a Muk is fundamentally more disruptive and I would like to know from
  30. each of you if that is the case why that may be so so let's start with the technology as you say we find it's very
  31. helpful to separate the moo from the technology that enables the moo that technology is a combination of short
  32. videos smart testing with potentially automated grading uh social networking on communities all these things wrapped
  33. together as we've seen with courses at edex in particular with corsera uh is creating a technology that is applied
  34. now to the moo given away for free as we've kind of seen it over the courses that we've taught here at warten but
  35. that moo and that technology are two separate pieces the moo is just one application and we can imagine many
  36. other ways in which these new technologies we we call this a superx that superx the videos the Adaptive
  37. testing so social networking there are many other ways which we can deploy that technology and in those other
  38. applications we believe is a much bigger threat to institutions like ours compared to taking these courses teach
  39. them to 100,000 students at once and giving that away for free we we don't feel threatened by the moo we do feel
  40. threatened by the super text I I'd make a few other observations about video video's been around it's been available
  41. to Consumers for 30 years but there's something fundamentally different about the availability today of video and I
  42. think that's evident if you look at the behavior of consumers online they're watching KH Academy they're watching TED
  43. Talks they're spending a lot of time on YouTube when I watch my teenagers do their math homework they do it with
  44. their laptop their smartphone so they can text their friends and then and then they watch a YouTube video to explain
  45. how to do the math problem so video is is fast and it's available everywhere with just a click and the big Insight I
  46. think in the first move was that by chunking the video by making it just a few minutes long and making it
  47. semisynchronous that is available on demand during a week of the course you get a much greater adoption and viewing
  48. of that video as opposed to for instance having to take a a video cassette out of
  49. a library check it out of a library take it home plug it in scan you know fast forward to the right section that that
  50. friction substantially diminished the usefulness of video when it was first introduced right now so so I I get the
  51. fact that uh because the video is so easily and readily available that that the adoption rates are much higher uh
  52. but one of the things you mentioned in your paper is that of the three Pathways that you describe in your research uh
  53. the first one is that uh B schools will be able to serve more students better and more efficiently uh as a result of
  54. this technology now since each of you teaches a course on corsera I wonder if you could draw on your own teaching
  55. experience and show how do you teach better and more efficiently via the Muk platform than you might do in a
  56. classroom I I teach product design at pen I've taught it for 20 years and I've recently taught a moo in which maybe
  57. 100,000 students over four offerings of the course have participated in that subject and I have I made 65 videos
  58. short videos that explain some of the key Concepts in product design I found myself when teaching product design two
  59. years ago I found myself in class opening up my web browser going to my cors era course and showing my students
  60. a video because says oh I have this great example let me show it to you and then I realized how silly that was and
  61. that what I really should be doing is having those students watch the videos without me before they got to class and
  62. so in the last year when I teach product design I've posed to myself the challenge what can we do in the class
  63. room that can only be done when 60 people are together sharing the same time and location and I have them watch
  64. the video offline and then when we get together we do a simulation or an exercise or presentations or group work
  65. things that can only be done in that location when we're all together so that's the flipped classroom mod that's
  66. the so-called flipped classroom are you using the same model through well I'm Carl his his videos are actually funny
  67. and so I I am in a somewhat more constrained environment but but I think the question that you're posing is an
  68. important one that we think about our brick and mortar classroom offerings here I teach the core course in
  69. operations management among other things it's 12 time 80 minutes that every student at the Wharton School has to
  70. take 12 time 80 minutes uh 960 minutes in total my online course on corsera is about 40 45 video segments of about 6 to
  71. 7 minutes right so you see that there's almost a compression of 50% as you go from the traditional
  72. classroom to the online medium so now the question is of course what happens to the other minutes right and I think
  73. it's helpful to break those up into a couple of buckets uh the first bucket is just there are certain things that we do
  74. in the classroom we unfortunately cannot replicate on the Mooks these are case discussions game exercises those are
  75. moments that Carl describes those are things that only can happen when we're together but I also have to point out
  76. that there is a fair bit of waste in what we do in the classroom and that has to do just do with the fact that
  77. different students learn at different rates when a student struggles on the move they can just rewind or they can
  78. just read something and then catch up again whereas in the classroom you're constrained by a common pace for
  79. everyone and so you really do gain efficiency you gain productivity as you take the same group of students and have
  80. them moved over to a hybrid model and I think Carl has been on the Forefront on this in the core again we uh I don't
  81. think we're quite as far but the direction is certainly clear we have to benefit from that new technology now
  82. despite the you know evident uh advantages of muks one of the challenges that all muks face is that the
  83. completion rate typically tend to be uh pretty low uh and I wonder both as teachers and as researchers what you
  84. have learned through your experience that might be relevant to the B schools well the the completion rate statistic
  85. really is a red herring I mean people like to to trot it out but it it it doesn't seem terribly relevant to me if
  86. you think about what the barrier is to registering for a moo it's literally one click in the Corsair environment so many
  87. people enroll to to check it out to watch a few videos to see what it's all about my moo requires hundreds of hours
  88. of effort uh to complete a substantial design project very very few people are willing to put in hundreds of hours but
  89. but many people are interested in learning a bit about customer needs or Aesthetics in design or prototyping so
  90. they watch a few videos so we really think pretty carefully and mukes about three categories of Learners those who
  91. are just browsing those who want to view the material but won't do the work and then those who will do all of the work
  92. and I I think the so as I say that that that narrow completion statistic I don't
  93. think is terribly meaningful in terms of evaluating the success of the muks yeah
  94. it's a classic example of what often times people do when an innovation comes out they take a performance metric that
  95. is designed to evaluate the old technology which is kind of brick and Mortal learning and they take that old
  96. metric you know completion rates is an important thing if you pay uh you know $120,000 for your mbba degree or or even
  97. more dollars when you send your kids to college their completion rate is a really really important number to track
  98. uh and we are anchoring this on the kind of the 95 plus% completion rate that we
  99. have in that world taking that number and comparing it to the 5% in the moo just absolutely makes no sense as K
  100. describes most of these people since they don't have to pay anything they just click and register in an effort
  101. that you would maybe browse through a store when you retail kind of in a retail experience you check out an item
  102. and you wonder like oh do I want that well this is not in some sense purchasing it's just looking at
  103. something and the it's just the nature of the web that every looking instance is actually recording as you enrolling
  104. so I think that that statistic is in that sense not telling anything and we should focus much more on the
  105. participation that once of the students is in and again we see the segmentation that some of the students really just
  106. want to do some videos they just want to watch this stuff and then there are those students who really do the work
  107. those that drop out at the beginning because they really find that this was maybe not what they were looking for I
  108. really couldn't care less so so let let's push a little further on that $120,000 number you mentioned that MBA
  109. students pay to attend uh an MBA program uh and as you correctly said joining a moo costs nothing at all mean given the
  110. fact that to produce content for a Muk uh is expensive in terms of time and money how do you think muks can be made
  111. financially sustainable it it's actually not very expensive so if you look at what it
  112. costs to develop a moo it's it's in in in a sustainable mode in the long run it' be about
  113. $70,000 but but we reach with a Muk several hundred thousand students so we really look at it if you look at it on a
  114. on a per viewer basis it runs to about 50 cents per person and at 50 cents per person that's cheaper than almost any
  115. other form of Outreach that we do at the Warton school and 50 cents for that kind
  116. of Engagement very very inexpensive so I'd like to object to the idea that they're expensive they're just not very
  117. expensive well a little bit further math might might might help here right so we
  118. as Elite universities Elite business schools are in the business of creating reputation reputation is important it
  119. will drive our demand it will drive how our graduates are viewed in the market so reputation is key how do you create
  120. reputation the traditional vehicle of reputation building was research so if you do some numbers on how much it costs
  121. us when Carl and I sit down and we write a scholarly article that makes a cut into the best academic journals we found
  122. in our report that it takes us somewhere around 3 $400,000 of research Investments to just
  123. get one scholarly article out for that money for one single paper we can basically create somewhere around three
  124. four five muks with the enrollment that we just talked about the other reference
  125. point that we might use is just the University of Pennsylvania's operating budget
  126. multibillion the Wharton schools operating budgets hundreds of millions and what we're spending on Ms we're
  127. spending about 0.1% and if not a little less of our budget on muks that apparently we all
  128. believe is z key technology for the future so this notion that we're overspending I don't buy other forms of
  129. disruptions other forms of concerns we need to discuss but the notion that this is expensive and we're stealing money
  130. from our kind of traditional customers and giving that content away for free that threat I think is not real yeah
  131. that that was not the point I was trying to drive at I mean clearly there is a huge value to to the knowledge that is
  132. disseminated through the muks uh the the question of course is that different schools are trying to monetize them in
  133. different ways uh at places like Harvard for example they have introduced a paid
  134. pre-mba program if you were to look at some of the different economic models that are being wrapped around muks uh
  135. could you of give me your thoughts on where do you think this is going and which model is are likely to be most
  136. sustainable well the the first thing I I think we should do is distinguish between muks and other forms of online
  137. education because I think muks are fundamentally about Outreach and social Mission and that's and they're not very
  138. expensive and so I think we can easily justify them based just on this this the social value that's created now that's
  139. not to say that there aren't some nice economic opportunities for online education and I would say at at Wharton
  140. there are two that that we think could be important one is Executive Education if you look at how expensive it is to
  141. send someone physically to Philadelphia to spend a week in Executive Education it's a it's a maybe A5 or $10,000 cost
  142. and we may be able to deliver some of the benefits of that experience much less expensively using technology so
  143. that's one the other is that we think that a place like pen and Wharton can be the originator of content that's used in
  144. instruction by other institutions and that like with textbooks there's a way to charge P per use or per per user for
  145. that material and so that could be a potential Revenue Source yeah there's a lot of value on the table uh especially
  146. I mean going back to C's Executive Education example uh there are lots of people in corporate settings that come
  147. to warten and that's great but uh you know we're talking about tuitions of $ 7 $8,000 for a week these people traveling
  148. and these people being away from work and so by Design This is only some privilege that you get if you're working
  149. in in in top management there is a large number of other people in executive positions at the Eon below that that we
  150. are right now not reaching but that we could be reaching through technology they would love the learning we can
  151. certainly deliver through the technology at Cost Points Way South of maybe $1,000
  152. if not $500 for that onee learning experience online so we bring those two things together and we're going to
  153. generate a lot of value and there's no reason to believe that especially with a strong brand like we have at warten we
  154. wouldn't be able to also then capture some of the value for ourselves sure so I mean in other words the uh you you can
  155. spread the Ripple effects of Executive Education much further you know to to the lower tiers of an organization if
  156. you like by combining uh Executive Education and muks that's a great Point absolutely right uh well the other very
  157. interesting point in your research paper is that uh you said that uh you can teach existing students with fewer
  158. faculty members now uh given the fact that most things tend to happen in Academia when they get enough faculty
  159. byy in uh do you think that um uh unless there is significant faculty by in two muks uh uh are faculty members likely to
  160. really support something that threatens to cut down the their numbers in the future well this one is a scary thought
  161. but let's put this in context uh what we do in the paper is we articulate three scenarios that we believe can play out
  162. in the world of the super TX as as I said earlier on I I'm not too wild about the term of moo because we're really
  163. talking about the technology here um there are three scenarios and the reason why we work with scenarios history
  164. Academia is full of bad forecast and predictions so we didn't want to join that club we know that social systems
  165. are so complex that if you and I with car sit here and make predictions about the future in 10 years we're going to be
  166. wrong and so what we did is we articulate three scenarios the first scenario is we're going to have this new
  167. technology that makes us more productive we have the same faculty the same business school stay in place and so now
  168. that they are more productive they can reach more students for example that goes back to the Executive Education
  169. online the second scenario is the one that you are pointing to is that scenario where we have a constant
  170. student population because really the demand for top MBA programs almost by definition is Not Without Limits and so
  171. if we have fixed demand but a much more productive production technology but by definition they're going to be fewer of
  172. us and then the third scenario that we can talk about in a moment the third scenario is so disruptive that the
  173. business school is fall into pieces so that second scenario that we're talking about we call that the clowns and the
  174. movie theaters the effect of the clowns and the movie theaters is that in the you know 18 18 19th 20th century if you
  175. wanted entertainment you would show up to the local Village Square you would watch a clown they would do some funny
  176. things in front of you and you would have a laugh while now you watch a movie and unfortunately most clowns have lost
  177. their jobs and so the question that we're debating is to what extent Carl and I here are going to be the clowns of
  178. the 21st century The Other M you asked about whether faculty would resist the change clearly they would under that
  179. scenario but I think we already have pretty good evidence that in the face of cost
  180. pressure there will be a reduction in faculty I mean just look if you look at higher education more generally over the
  181. last 10 to 20 years the number of student credit hours taught by tenur and tenure track faculty has been steadily
  182. declining and there's been an increase in the use of adjunct in part-time faculty that is a trend driven by cost
  183. pressure yes we all didn't like it but it didn't mean it didn't happen and so we cannot like it but in the face of a
  184. competing technology that may be better and that's definitely cheaper it's very hard to argue that that we can
  185. completely resist it let's talk a little bit about the third scenario before coming back to all three of them is if
  186. when you talk about the complete un unbundling of the business school or the emergence of other alternatives to
  187. Business Schools uh what do you think might play out in that sort of the third option well I think the first thing to
  188. recognize is that the primary reason that an MBA student matriculates at the Wharton School or at any other top
  189. business school is because they think it's going to advance their career and that to some extent they want to learn
  190. some specific skills and knowledge but there really is an other there are other benefits that they look to to achieve
  191. and to obtain and they are access to careers uh and the development of a social network that will benefit them
  192. throughout their their lives and and to some extent a credentialing or a stamping of appr approval that
  193. distinguishes them from other people in the in the in the labor force if those functions of credentialing of social
  194. network and of um and of access to employers are now provided by others outside of Business Schools then I think
  195. our role is quite threatened and right now they're they're bundled together and they include this academic learning
  196. piece but if they ever become unbundled and are started to be provided by other institutions then I think Business
  197. Schools are threatened yeah the metaphor that Carl and I use in our report is the the idea of a Swiss
  198. army knife right when you purchase a Swiss army knife you don't know yet when are you going to use it and you don't
  199. know which part of the knife you're going to use for going to use first that's very similar to our MBA students
  200. they come here they get all this knowledge that one day in their life and sometimes 10 15 20 years into their
  201. career they might have to access but they don't know when and they also don't know what part and so that back the
  202. question is there another way of delivering that knowledge very much on demand when you want it instead of
  203. buying this library of videos have much more of an iTunes or Netflix model where
  204. you say like well I want to watch that movie today well just click on it and get it when you need it so you face a
  205. situation at work you're doing some m&a work well why don't you take the m&a course right now when you need it of the
  206. three scenarios that you outline in your research uh which ones do you think are
  207. most like for business schools and why well the nature of scenarios is that they are all somewhat unlikely otherwise
  208. we wouldn't have created them uh let let's add to that that these scenarios to some extent are scenarios like we
  209. would roll the dice and it's going to be 1 2 3 4 5 six right it's it's exogenous
  210. it's a shock it's Randomness and it's just hard to predict but to some extent these scenarios are also active choices
  211. there are strategies especially at the top schools especially in the leadership of the school we can make some choices
  212. that will influence the future and that will basically you know fall into these three buckets uh personally I feel that
  213. we are well under the way of playing scenario one we have done the moo for outreach we're experimenting with
  214. Executive Education we need to do more but we're clearly on the way on scenario one I would love us to play a little bit
  215. with scenario 3 that's the furthest out scenario two I think right now we're in this privileged situation here at
  216. Wharton at least that the cost pressure has not been quite as big and the implementation feasibility the kind of
  217. the reluctance obviously from us as a faculty to embrace this that's not going to be the first point where we start so
  218. I would put my money as somebody making a strategy on a combination of one and yeah I I would I think there scenario
  219. two I think is pretty likely there's going to be some decline in faculty size that the cost pressure is unavoidable I
  220. don't think it'll be a catastrophic decline in faculty I think it'll be my prediction would be a modest decline in
  221. faculty um I think actually to build on Christian's point we need to aggressively pursue scenario one pathway
  222. one in order to mitigate pathway 3 and so in particular I think we have an opportunity at Wharton and at the other
  223. Elite Business Schools to create an unrivaled educational experience for students but one in which they learn a
  224. lot of the RO subjects the more mechanical subjects online and without the use of expensive faculty resource
  225. then when they're here together we challenge ourselves to give them an experience that they couldn't get
  226. anywhere else and by doing so we reinforce the value of them participating in the Wharton experience
  227. and that helps us mitigate against the unbundling that could happen in pathway 3 what surprised you most about this
  228. research that you've done what was your biggest surprise I have to say you know our our analysis is just arithmetic it's
  229. just adding and subtracting a little bit division but we were quite surprised at
  230. what scholarship costs just how expensive it is and how expensive it is relative to the the educational
  231. activities of the school that surprised me yeah for me the biggest surprise has been how seriously threatened our
  232. institution and the Business School Community is asess I said at the beginning this is the institution we've
  233. been employed for over 20 years with kind of with graduate school this has made our careers that has been at least
  234. for me I I think I can speak for Carl on this front this has been the perfect job
  235. that we love uh the institution that we love and nevertheless you when you run those numbers you feel how threatened
  236. that ecosystem is there is no guarantee that in 20 years from now we're going to
  237. have the same business model going as it is right now well do your research focuses primarily on Business Schools in
  238. the MBA program uh what do you think uh in your research could apply more broadly to U higher education as a
  239. whole higher education sees the same pressures and the same threats and opportunities in fact to some extent the
  240. other parts of the University have felt them before Business Schools my wife's a
  241. professor in in the English Department at Penn and they've already seen tremendous cost pressures and they've
  242. seen that that impact on that they've seen that impact the faculty ranks the way they do and the way they do
  243. instruction so I don't really think Business Schools are terribly unique they are somewhat
  244. unique I think in well I would say professional schools are somewhat unique in that the primary purpose of paying
  245. the tuition dollars is to advance yourself in your career and that's unique to professional schools as
  246. opposed to say an undergraduate experience which I think is much less threatened because an undergraduate
  247. experience is much more about going away finding your identity having enabling experiences building a commun social
  248. network those things I think are much harder to substitute at least for the elite universities the IVs and so forth
  249. yeah so I think certainly we as business schools are particularly threatened because
  250. again I think we're used to this very high tuition very high salary type of Lifestyle we could afford ourselves that
  251. luxury of not looking at efficiency something that in many of the second and third year schools in many of the other
  252. fields outside Business Schools those things these guys have been under that cost pressure so many years ahead of us
  253. that I think they are better prepared I think the small liberal arts colleges they don't have this Dual Purpose that
  254. we talked about earlier on the research and the teaching for them it's all about
  255. the education of the student and so as long as they do that that well as long as they serve their customers the
  256. student well people will be willing to pay for it I think we are threaten in particular about that scenario of
  257. unbundling the teaching and the research that is something that is pretty unique
  258. to law schools and Business Schools I have an appointment at the medical school where the tradition is much more
  259. like if you want to bring research if you want to spend time doing research have somebody pay for it bring in the
  260. research dollars this cross subsidy is actually something that is not that broadly applicable other than the the
  261. kind of the social sciences and I think that's the one where I would feel we're going to see some big pressure mounting
  262. and if we can can have just one last question what what future topics for research uh do you think are sort of
  263. thrown up as a result of what you've studied so far I would love to see more insights into the scenario 3 into this
  264. unbundling we make it sound so nasty in many ways it's unbundling the business school falls into pieces I think it's
  265. actually not that bad and in many ways quite exciting right because what you do is right now when we do research there's
  266. really other than the perer evaluation there's there's there's no measurement of quality there's no feedback whether
  267. what we research actually one day that new knowledge is is is used anywhere in practice if you think about scenario
  268. three where the students learn on demand what they need in practice that would actually create an enormous pull from
  269. the market that would direct us where we develop new content where we develop research and I think would be actually a
  270. very interesting development in terms of guiding our research where it is mattering the most in practice so I
  271. would love to see more of research understanding scenario 3 understanding exactly that business model and how that
  272. activity system is falling into different pieces but then these pieces are potentially managed by different
  273. organizations uh that is something where I would love to spend more time on and I
  274. certainly will i' I'd very much my Personal Agenda I'd very much like to see a quarter to a third of the content
  275. of our MBA program U move to more self-directed asynchronous learning online and I think one of the real
  276. challenges there is how you assess competence and how you assess and and I think it's actually an opportunity
  277. because right now we don't assess competence in business education we simply assess did you complete the
  278. degree per did you complete these courses get a passing grade in the courses so I think there's actually an
  279. opportunity to improve what we do by developing some methods of assessing how good you are when you graduate from the
  280. Wharton School and if we can do that we can both improve the quality of the education a student gets and we can
  281. possibly make it better by moving some of the the the instruction online great uh Christian Carl thank you so much for
  282. joining us today hey thanks for having us here thank you [Music]

Brief Summary

Christian Tursh and Carl Rrick discuss MOOCs' impact on business schools, emphasizing efficiency, technology, and financial sustainability challenges.

Key points

  • The Threat to Business Schools. Business schools face challenges from MOOCs due to high costs and efficiency issues.
  • The Value of Technology in Education. The technology behind MOOCs could disrupt traditional business school models.
  • Rethinking Completion Rates. Completion rates for MOOCs may not accurately reflect their value or success.
  • The Threat to Business Schools. The discussion reveals how business schools face significant threats from unbundling and cost pressures.
  • Scenario Three: Unbundling. Exploring the potential benefits of unbundling business schools and the shift to on-demand learning.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes