MOOCs Don't Cannabalize Traditional Education

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

he question keeps educators up at night: Do free, massive open online courses cannibalize enrollment at traditional schools? The results are finally in, part of a new study co-authored by Wharton professor Ezekiel J. Emanuel. Rather than poaching traditional students, MOOCs reach new audiences that business schools, at least, want to target.

In this Knowledge@Wharton interview, Emanuel notes that "it doesn't seem that MOOCs are undermining traditional business schools, but may be complementing them, enriching them and providing a great opportunity to [engage] other diverse student bodies." ๐Ÿ“‚ Innovation ๐Ÿท๏ธ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. so we were interested in how mukes might affect business education everyone is sort of worried and I think spending a
  2. lot of sleepless nights that this that mukes might be uh might kill Business Schools uh free cheap or cheap or free
  3. online education uh take apart the bricks and mortar of traditional high-end Business Schools like Wharton
  4. and uh we were wondering is that like to be the case uh the surprising findings to us is that uh with nearly a million
  5. people registering for the Wharton core courses uh things like accounting and operations as well as uh some added
  6. courses like gamification and the uh business of sports it turns out that in fact uh muks seem to be attracting
  7. people who are uh not in the usual MBA or Executive MBA kind of programs uh people from uh developing countries High
  8. proportion of them in these mukes they don't go to mbas or executive mbas uh firstborn Americans who tend to be
  9. highly educated but not terribly well employed again a big proportion of the mukes surprising to us and uh yet not a
  10. big representative group in the MBA and Executive MBA program and probably uh against very surprising to us a lot of
  11. underrepresented minorities African-Americans Hispanics and others taking these uh massive online open
  12. business courses uh but obviously uh a group that we're trying to get uh increased representation in the uh uh
  13. regular MBA and Executive MBA programs so getting these people uh who are otherwise not in the mainstream of MBA
  14. in to the uh uh business education through moo seems to be very surprising and it suggests that uh actually mukes
  15. are serving a different kind of clientele than regular mbas and executive MB a those people who maybe
  16. are traditionally excluded or underrepresented in our uh regular bricks and mortar classes and it might
  17. serve a very enriched population to Target for recruitment to mbas and Executive MBA programs smart
  18. well-educated very interested people who otherwise we might not have contacted and in that regard it doesn't seem like
  19. muks are undermining uh traditional Business Schools but maybe actually complimenting them enriching them and
  20. providing a great opportunity uh to get uh other uh diverse student bodies so I think the uh massive online
  21. education uh these courses that reach thousands tens of thousands hundreds of thousands of people on various platforms
  22. like corsera edx have been a real worry to people that they're going to upset the higher education Marketplace uh
  23. maybe undermine traditional education and we were very interested in that uh I'd say that the three or four big
  24. takeaways from our study are first uh we these massive online open education courses or mukes seem to Target uh very
  25. important groups that uh otherwise aren't involved in the traditional MBA or Executive MBA programs groups like uh
  26. students in developing countries uh especially non brick countries uh student first generation American
  27. recent immigrants who are well educated from their home country but may be underemployed in the United States
  28. probably using these mukes to gain additional skills and training and to demonstrate that they are competitive
  29. for jobs here and then a another very surprising group underrepresented minorities were uh also very uh over
  30. represented in the moo uh program as it compared to the MBA or the Executive MBA
  31. program nearly 20% of the enrollees in the American uh side were under rep represented minorities and that's a
  32. group that uh many business schools have been trying to Target uh to enroll in uh
  33. traditional MBA and Executive MBA programs a second surprising finding was that women did not Faire that well
  34. especially women in developing countries in these muks they tend to be still dominated by well-educated men uh there
  35. may be bigger barriers for women maybe they're not they don't have the educational preparation to take
  36. advantage of the business style muks uh it may also be that they don't have access to uh internet uh and other uh
  37. Necessities computers uh for doing them third big takeaway uh is that many people uh lament the fact that there's
  38. High enrollment numbers but when you look at the number of people who complete the course and get certificates
  39. it's way down at three or in the the B the case of Business Schools 5% um even though that's a small
  40. percentage uh it's an important to remember that when you start out with very large numbers hundreds of thousands
  41. that's small percentage is many many thousands of people many more people than you have in a regular MBA program
  42. but more importantly many of the students say look getting a certificate is not that important for me I got a lot
  43. of information or a lot of knowledge or what I wanted without getting the certificate and so we need to think
  44. through how mukes are actually satisfying the educational needs of uh students rather then figuring out you
  45. know the the end result is to get everyone a certificate and that may also have some important implic for the
  46. pricing model uh charging at the end for a certificate may not be the wisest uh move uh maybe a uh uh other platforms
  47. for charging uh like a a monthly subscription fee or some other program would be a much wiser way of uh Revenue
  48. generation so I think one of the important elements from our study of uh students who take the business massive
  49. online courses uh is that they are probably a very good uh uh Target population for recruiting for
  50. traditional mbas uh these are groups that business schools have wanted to enroll uh students from developing
  51. countries um underrepresented minorities who traditionally are underrepresented in business school and so H these
  52. massive online courses may allow targeting for recruitment that could be uh greatly enhanced I'd say that the
  53. second uh uh important conclusion certainly for uh Business Schools is that uh they should look at muks and
  54. these online course opportunities uh as opportunities not as competitive and shy
  55. away from them fearing that they're somehow going to undermine what they do in a traditional classroom or an
  56. Executive MBA programs at least initially now they don't look competitive they look like they might be
  57. synergistic and I think exploring more deeply uh with the students who have taken the course es and what they think
  58. they've gotten out of them how these courses can enhance or maybe bring them into the Executive MBA bring them into
  59. the traditional MBA programs I think is where we should be looking uh and so I think the The Fear and Loathing that
  60. often accompanies muks among academic administrators is probably overplayed and we need to think of it much more as
  61. a positive opportunity to expand uh all the great resources we have uh educating
  62. uh students well this research focuses focused on uh Business Schools and business education
  63. because we had this unique opportunity uh given the fact that Wharton was running these sort of core Preparatory
  64. courses uh in things like accounting and uh marketing uh uh and operations as well as some of the additional uh more
  65. expansive courses like gamification uh but I think the conclusions probably extend to high education much more
  66. broadly uh you know again many higher education administrators have sort of on the one hand think uh uh thought they
  67. needed to experiment with massive online education but on the other hand are kind
  68. of dreading it and fearing that it's going to somehow undercut their uh tra their finances and the enrollments uh
  69. what we suspect is that there's actually opportunity to use the online courses to
  70. augment what is happening in the traditional educational program that in fact there are different audiences to
  71. use I think the Big Challenge which our study doesn't solve is the question of how do you uh how do you make a business
  72. model that makes sense for it uh because it does look like completing the program
  73. completing a set of courses uh and paying for that is probably not the optimal uh
  74. approach there was a an article in the Wall Street Journal just the other week talking about how Business Schools might
  75. adapt uh or might fear uh massive online education uh but it had no data and so one of the things we have tried to do is
  76. instead of having a lot of speculation about massive online courses and what they're going to do to higher education
  77. and who's taking them is to actually collect data and I think the University of Pennsylvania has been uh probably the
  78. leader uh both in offering massive online education courses both for business as well as in the non-b
  79. business areas uh mythology or poetry or my own uh Health policy um course uh We've also been Pioneers in actually
  80. looking at who's taking the courses why they're taking them uh we've been among the best to document the uh High number
  81. of people who sign up about a third of them actually take the course uh uh begin the course or sort of initiators
  82. uh but only about five or 10% of those who have started the course actually complete it uh I I like to say it's
  83. rules of thirds uh about a third of the people who sign up actually look at the first lecture and about a third of those
  84. uh who actually look at the first lecture actually complete the course that's a little bit of an exaggeration
  85. but that's a pretty good rule of thumb uh and we need to study each one of those it's easy to sign up when it's
  86. free right once you've started the course uh we need to understand what you're expecting from the course and why
  87. why uh many of those people get what they seem to want out of the course without completing it what is the it
  88. that people are looking for in courses that doesn't require completing every lecture or completing every assignment
  89. uh is it brushing up in their knowledge is it prepping them for uh their next uh
  90. program or their next job uh so I think a lot of uh uh additional research is going to be needed and as I said I think
  91. uh at the University of Pennsylvania rather than speculate we have been delving into the data and trying to
  92. publish as much as we can to educate the conversation about massive online education
  93. programs well I think uh the University of Pennsylvania has been a leader in looking at people who take massive
  94. online courses and trying to understand who they are why they're taking the courses which ones complete which ones
  95. don't complete what sociodemographic groups they come from what countries they come from and getting hard data and
  96. looking at the hundreds of thousands and now millions of people who've taken these massive online courses is one of
  97. the things uh the University of Pennsylvania is leading in uh another thing we're trying to evaluate is uh
  98. what exactly people get out of the courses and how do they use that information a third thing we're looking
  99. at is whether in what ways these uh massive online courses actually enhance education or maybe undermine education
  100. and trying to actually empirically evaluate their benefits and in terms of actual education knowledge retained
  101. knowledge utilized I think is going to be a very important finding as well that obviously takes more time uh uh but you
  102. know we are committed at the University of Pennsylvania our group and many others here to actually uh good
  103. quantitative research that'll inform the discussion going forward about massive online
  104. courses we're actually trying to understand uh more concretely uh what people are getting out of the course uh
  105. what expectations they come into a course with and what uh when they stop what have they gotten that allows them
  106. to stop or are they stopping because it's too much time or they don't have the resources or there's some other uh
  107. barrier that and they would like to go to completion so this idea of how exactly to tailor a massive online
  108. course to make it maximally beneficial for the groups that are taking them I think is a major issue and really
  109. something we know almost nothing about so that'll be a major Focus uh we in my office and my research group are
  110. especially interested in the global perspective uh I run uh pen Global and uh part of what motivates us is who are
  111. the people in foreign countries especially developing countries who are using massive online courses and how can
  112. we enhance our offerings to really uh enhance their education uh that's our mandate in our office and and we are
  113. going to uh continue to research that particular issue [Music]

Brief Summary

MOOCs may enhance business education by attracting diverse, underrepresented students rather than undermining traditional MBA programs.

Key points

  • Surprising Findings on Mukes. Mukes attract a diverse group of students, including underrepresented minorities and those from developing countries.
  • Women Underrepresented in Mukes. Women, especially in developing countries, face barriers in accessing mukes.
  • Opportunities for Business Schools. Mukes should be seen as opportunities to enhance traditional education, not threats.
  • Enrollment vs. Completion Rates. High enrollment numbers in mukes contrast sharply with low completion rates.
  • Research Focus on Global Education. The University of Pennsylvania aims to enhance education for students in developing countries through mukes.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes