Mergers in the Air? Microsoft/Yahoo and Delta/Northwest

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

The ongoing takeover battle between Microsoft and Yahoo has taken several surprising turns over the past few weeks. After rejecting Microsoft's unsolicited $44.6 billion offer in late February, Yahoo has announced a two-week ad testing program with its main search rival, Google, and has reportedly entertained a possible merger with Time Warner's AOL. Meanwhile, Microsoft was rumored to be considering News Corp. as a possible ally in acquiring Yahoo. While spectators wait for the next twist in this saga, another headline-making deal has been announced: a merger between Delta and Northwest Airlines to become the world's largest airline. Knowledge@Wharton spoke with Wharton management professor Saikat Chaudhuri and Wharton legal studies professor Kevin Werbach to find out whether these deals make sense and for whom. πŸ“‚ Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. this podcast is brought to you by knowledge at wharton please visit knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu
  2. for more information the ongoing takeover battle between microsoft and yahoo has taken several
  3. surprising turns over the past few weeks after rejecting microsoft's unsolicited
  4. 44.6 billion offer in late february yahoo has announced a two-week ad testing program with its main search
  5. rival google and has reportedly entertained a possible merger with time warner's aol
  6. meanwhile microsoft was rumored to be considering news corp as a possible ally in acquiring yahoo
  7. while spectators wait for the next twist in this saga another headline making deal has been announced a merger between
  8. delta and northwest airlines to become the world's largest airline knowledge at wharton spoke with wharton
  9. management professor psychot chodri and wharton legal studies professor kevin warbach to find out whether these deals
  10. make sense and for whom microsoft is basically giving yahoo three weeks to accept its current offer or face a proxy
  11. battle it's a very aggressive stance what do you think of this strategy psycho let's start with you
  12. well you know i think they've waited patiently for quite some time to see whether yahoo would come to the
  13. negotiating table and now they want to move things forward because this can't continue endlessly
  14. yahoo hasn't indicated any positive inclinations so far to come and negotiate so they're just putting
  15. forward this step in order to make sure there's some resolution either way i would tend to agree with that i don't
  16. i don't think microsoft can sit around forever and wait for yahoo's feelings to change or wait for something in the
  17. marketplace to change this is a pretty major strategic deal for microsoft and i think at some point they need to signal
  18. both to yahoo and its shareholders in the market that that's the way they feel about it
  19. and they're going to go forward if they can and try and close the deal by taking this tax does microsoft risk
  20. losing one of yahoo's key assets that is its talented employee base well i think
  21. that's why they were patient for so long and they were perhaps overly cautious in order to allow for yahoo employees to
  22. see that they're not taking a very aggressive approach i think after you know a few months pass
  23. everyone expects some movement to be there i'm also not sure um whether it's going
  24. to have a negative impact i mean you're absolutely right in that the sources of value are a lot in the people here as
  25. well as the customers that yahoo has but see yahoo hasn't performed up to expectations for some time now
  26. and i would imagine that there certainly is a very loyal group of supporters who sticks to terry yang no matter what
  27. but then there is also a group which is perhaps a little demoralized given that they don't see much movement and
  28. they may be willing to move forward in a deal as well and perhaps uh go forward with microsoft so i think
  29. it's it's the right move from that point of view yeah i was going to lose some important
  30. employees no matter what i mean these are people who don't want to work for microsoft it's they're people who think
  31. of microsoft as the evil empire and that that has nothing to do with the nature of the acquisition whether it's hostile
  32. or friendly um so i think frankly those those people will leave anyway um at this point you know if they want
  33. to close the deal they need to go on with it kevin how much at this point does it
  34. seem that pushing this deal through as a matter of um of ego for steve baumer um i wouldn't say ego i would say it's a
  35. very important deal personally for steve ballmer he's not going to be running this company forever bill gates has
  36. already stepped away recently from basically active involvement in microsoft you know ballmer is you know
  37. this is his last chance for a real signature move he understands that the industry is changing um and so i i don't
  38. think he had to make this deal but i think once he decided that this was a direction they were going to go it's his
  39. stamp on it so i think it's it's not just a matter of ego it's it's a matter of this is his last signature move in
  40. terms of how he's going to leave microsoft whether it's to ray ozzie or to whoever else comes after that
  41. i agree with that and i think that you know if anything microsoft's been criticized for not um taking more
  42. aggressive steps in the past to compete with google and and improve their presence on the internet and the web
  43. space and so forth and so now they decided that they're going to do a very credible serious move in that direction
  44. so there's a strong moving it towards this logical conclusion so i think it's about
  45. that it's very rational move in my opinion for them to do something because if you
  46. look at it both yahoo and microsoft combined could actually be some force against google and the internet
  47. especially the advertising space and alone they've been struggling for quite a few years now
  48. yeah i mean that's that's an important question in terms of just how successful the deal will be but in terms of the
  49. microsoft's approach they're a very aggressive very paranoid but very calculating company they don't
  50. do things just on emotions they do things because they really feel like it's in their interest
  51. well what do you think of uh of yahoo's highly publicized test of using google's adsense service on its
  52. site well first of all can you explain what they're hoping what the actual test is what they're doing with it and sort
  53. of what they might hope to get from it i'll let that first part go to kevin sure so so both yahoo and google uh have
  54. services that that monetize searching they they match advertisers who pay to be matched with people searching for
  55. different things on the internet google's search ad matching technology just works
  56. better than yahoos or anyone else's it converts more advertisers like it better yahoo did a sort of crash course project
  57. called panama to improve their service didn't really move the needle very much so this is partly just trying out a
  58. different uh technology that that everyone agrees is the the gold standard in the industry but obviously there's
  59. more to it than that in this current environment google is the competitor that that clearly microsoft is trying to
  60. buy yahoo in part to compete against um so it's definitely also a shot across the bow yeah and you know i mean yahoo's
  61. been trying to search for other alternative options in the last couple of months ever since
  62. this offer came up so they're still searching for that option i think this is a tactic in that direction
  63. nothing has emerged very concretely no white knight has emerged or the alliances seem unlikely but nonetheless
  64. i think they are this is a credible signal that they are looking for exploring other opportunities
  65. and perhaps even hoping that this might increase the offer a little bit from microsoft to
  66. make a convincing case let's look at some of the other deals that are reportedly under consideration
  67. yahoo and time warner were reportedly talking about folding aol's internet operations into yahoo
  68. would that make sense i don't think it would be a more attractive option i think it's a way for aol
  69. to survive in that space but also for yahoo to stay independent so if you if you think about options where yahoo
  70. would be able to remain independent that's something which is can be taken fairly seriously and looks quite good
  71. but if you don't agree with the basic premise that yahoo can survive on their own
  72. then i think the microsoft offer looks much more attractive yeah and yahoo's view all along has been
  73. uh microsoft undervalues the company and it still has a lot of legs as a going concern as an independent business so i
  74. think shotgun is right aol and some of the other rumored deals getting news corp involved uh even the
  75. partnership with google are all ways that don't involve submerging yahoo into a larger entity as the microsoft
  76. deal would can we talk a little bit about microsoft this rumor about microsoft's teaming up with news corp
  77. what's that all about some sort of joint offer joint bid in the works perhaps to sweeten it for
  78. yahoo or you know maybe to help with the financing of the deal um i think honestly it would be very
  79. complicated um not perhaps to pull off from the point of view of striking a deal though that
  80. is one consideration but especially how would the you know post acquisition arrangement look like you
  81. know i i just am not comfortable with the idea from that point of view you know how would
  82. uh news corp then think about this who would own which piece and manage and influence what piece i
  83. i think it's a constellation which was thought about to perhaps make it more attractive or help perhaps increase the
  84. bid but it would be very complicated to implement yeah rupert burdock has a tremendous
  85. track record of basically injecting his company in a very effective strategic way into basically every
  86. aspect of the media landscape and every key transition and so they're they're very savvy and very smart
  87. they have some real important assets um yeah i'm also not clear that it's that that would make sense for either
  88. microsoft or yahoo but we have to remember we're at the sort of mating dance of the dinosaurs
  89. here these are all the big players see assets in play now that are valuable to them
  90. in the future of the digital economy so pretty much everyone is is mobilizing uh
  91. to get into this fight would the complexity of these deals be a severe handicap to the merger should it
  92. go through i mean surely it's a large deal with established players there's some hostility between them their
  93. competitors right now but if they can unite and rally around the common objective of successfully
  94. competing against google that might be a strong unifying force so i think if that
  95. need becomes clear to both sides which is very i think it's very clear to microsoft but if that need becomes clear
  96. to the yahoo employees as well they decide to stick in our conv and can be convinced
  97. that uh joining forces with microsoft would indeed be the right answer i think some
  98. of those challenges can be overcome and then of course you have to figure out common processes
  99. post-merger organizational structures in that i actually see an opportunity because microsoft could actually open up
  100. a strong presence in silicon valley should they choose so for instance instead of running the internet
  101. advertising operations out of redmond they could conceive of some sort of reverse integration where msn
  102. essentially would be folded into yahoo with a strong and a large office and presence in the silicon valley area
  103. that would also go some ways to alleviating the concerns that people have about oh here's that big giant big
  104. bad kind of player that comes in and brings everybody to redmond and stifles ideas if that's the perception that some
  105. have they could counter that as well both internally and externally so i do see some opportunities there as well
  106. yeah i don't really think any of that ultimately matters i think that both of these companies face a fundamental
  107. challenge that the industry is going through a transition and they're they're stuck
  108. uh you know on the outside chair in musical chairs microsoft is a software company yahoo is basically a an online
  109. new media company and the world is moving to web-based services basically the place where google right now is is
  110. at the center and dominating and they're both smart companies they have smart executives they understand
  111. that that's i think part of the reason that this deal is being bandied about i don't
  112. think the deal solves that problem i think it puts two companies together that have some complimentary assets and
  113. absolutely there there would be smarter ways to do the integration to to take advantage of it but fundamentally
  114. i don't see you know no matter how simple or complex it is how this deal gets the merge company to a point where
  115. they can really compete effectively in this new world so if you were steve ballmer what would
  116. you do kevin well i would certainly call the wharton school first and ask for our advice but
  117. um no i you know to the extent that he has made this call and who am i to second
  118. guess steve ballmer he's he's a brilliant extraordinary business executive um if they've gotten to this point of
  119. feeling that they need a yahoo that they've taken a look internally and said we are not going to make this transition
  120. from being a software company that builds you know package software and operating systems into a web-based
  121. services company because they've really been trying if the conclusion internally
  122. is we couldn't get there alone then by all means go for it i mean the yahoo is probably their best chance
  123. to actually change things even if outsiders like me are pessimistic they'll get there
  124. go for it give it a shot i agree i mean i think that uh microsoft needs to do something in order to
  125. strengthen its presence in that area this represents a fantastic opportunity they've started it so i think they
  126. should also for reputation's sake um given given that this is quite a rational move for them i think they
  127. should move towards its logical conclusion so let's flip the question so if you're jerry yang what would you
  128. do in this case try and squeeze out the best offer possible i think that you know he's doing some good tactical moves
  129. but i would start sending a few feelers out because at some point your own stakeholders and i'm saying not just
  130. shareholders but also other stakeholders such as some employees might begin to question
  131. why you're not you know trying to at least extract a good offer in the absence of alternative offers and also
  132. the fact that this does represent a good premium and a very good opportunity i would start doing it but of course you
  133. play the tactical game in order to squeeze out the best value that you can and move towards whatever evaluation
  134. they think is fair um for their side i think that's right he's in a very tough position look he co-founded this
  135. company it's an extraordinary entrepreneurial success story and yet he's got to see the writing on
  136. the wall and i don't think anyone i mean yahoo is still a growing profitable company has a lot of incredibly
  137. successful businesses tremendous number of users and so forth i think it's been enough time over the
  138. past few years to suggest that it's going to be hard for them to just pull out of the slide that they're in on
  139. their own and and so it's a difficult thing i think both personally and as a leader but i think he needs to
  140. make that transition whatever the outcome is whether it's microsoft or something else that helps the
  141. organization understand that so how do you think this is going to play out in the end
  142. i think microsoft wins in the end is there they're relentless and and again i can't think that they've come this far
  143. without having made the decision that this is a bet the company deal and if that's the case they're not going to
  144. give up until they win i agree i think that's going to be the outcome that microsoft buys yahoo great well let's
  145. turn to another merger that's making headlines the one between uh delta and northwest
  146. airlines does this merger make sense i'm happy to see it finally materialize and the reason is
  147. these airlines have been struggling for some time and you know with the oil prices being as
  148. high as they are they have to try and extract synergies um on the cost side in order to go
  149. anywhere um and i don't see oil prices coming down substantially so i think this is a new reality they
  150. have to deal with the reason i like this particular solution with northwestern delta is also
  151. because it's clean from the point of view that it's within an alliance and the complementarities are fantastic
  152. delta has a strong franchise in latin america and more recently they've built it up in the atlantic roots northwest is
  153. strong in the pacific routes so from that point of view i think they fit well together
  154. and there i think this will also lead to further consolidation but we can talk about that a little bit later sure
  155. yeah i don't have much to add to that i'm not an expert on the airline industry per se but but i will say it is
  156. another industry where scale matters uh probably even more so than in technology
  157. scale is very important in the microsoft yahoo deal but but with airlines there's
  158. just such extraordinarily high fixed costs i mean as i was saying the fuel in the planes and so forth um that that
  159. typically a you know an effective merger can actually create some economies of scale
  160. so that said are can we expect other mergers from the big carriers i think so i think what will happen now
  161. is that others are not going to sit back and and watch them be the largest carrier or potentially reap rewards now
  162. of course these integrations are going to be complex because unions are involved and uh and so forth
  163. but uh i think the next one that probably might uh occur is something like united
  164. with continental for similar reasons continentals built a bit of a an atlantic franchise they have an east
  165. coast presence they have a bit of latin america united is stronger on the west coast and has done some more on the
  166. pacific routes and in that case what you might it might work nicely because continental would then come or could
  167. then come into star alliance um because unlike delta they're not a founding member of sky team so they
  168. could come into star alliance which would work very well they'd be welcomed because star lines especially lufthansa
  169. and the others have really been looking for a new york area hub so that would work and then the question
  170. though becomes if that were to happen this is all hypothetical then will american airlines sit back having been
  171. the largest carrier or will it try and do some kind of smaller deal like u.s airways perhaps
  172. but you know a lot of this is also subject to regulatory approval so it's not as though these are going to sail
  173. through automatically it'll take six eight months to get them approved and there will be some redistribution of
  174. hubs and assets and routes and so forth so we kind of have to see it collectively i think what
  175. they'll do is basically a few of these will be announced and then it'll all be evaluated together to try and optimize
  176. on a macro level yeah the anti-trust review is going to be very significant because this is
  177. already an industry that's consolidated a lot and and i agree it's potentially going to consolidate a lot more
  178. and that involves law but also politics so it will depend uh almost certainly who's in the white house next year and
  179. what the posture is of their justice department um and which deal goes first um so a lot of that is hard to read
  180. right now obviously we have a presidential election coming up where you know the outcome will have a
  181. significant effect here it's hard to see all the deals going through on the other hand to the extent
  182. a major deal like like the northwest delta one goes through and and again i'm not a an expert per say in
  183. this area but it sounds like the expectation is that it would um then it's harder every every step down the
  184. road for the justice department to say this next deal is that much worse than the previous one even if you look back
  185. and it wasn't that long ago that we've had airline mergers scuttled because of regulatory review
  186. now this merger announcement came after four of the smaller airlines shut down so are we going to see a lot more
  187. fallout you know among the smaller discount carriers do you think cycad yeah it's hard to say um what their
  188. posturing will be i do think though that everybody's struggling a little bit so they'll have to consider these things
  189. but it's i primarily see the cost basis of the full service carriers being the ones which are most challenging and
  190. they're the ones who are facing competition from the low-cost airlines so most of the activity will be there
  191. but yeah i mean they can start considering options for themselves amongst the low-cost carriers but there
  192. aren't too many opportunities left there as you're alluding to some of them have folded so
  193. i'm not it's hard for me to predict what will happen on that front yeah i'm thankful i'm not in the airline
  194. industry you can make a lot of money in good times but it is it is really challenging
  195. um and and it's hard to see it getting less challenging going forward and is fuel the major impediment right now
  196. would you say are there other issues that are that would drive consolidation or some of these closings labor costs
  197. were the other issue but i think after all everyone went through bankruptcy protection
  198. they worked on that angle right now fuel is the uh has become the largest uh cost for these
  199. airlines yeah how will this uh this merger affect consumers do you think kevin that's it's hard to say i don't think
  200. most consumers at least in america are terribly happy with the airline industry um and so it's hard to see
  201. the consolidation per se making them happier except to the extent that the merge company
  202. decides to you know try to invest more in improving service quality they use some of those efficiencies that they
  203. would get from the merger to improve customer service or to the extent either they or one of the other major carriers
  204. decides to make that a point of emphasis um i mean again not not speaking as a as
  205. a business school professor just as a person who flies airlines it certainly seems like a lot of people
  206. would pay another 10 or 20 or even 50 dollars on a transcontinental round-trip ticket for just the level of food and
  207. service and leg room that they they got 10 or 15 years ago um and it seems like there should be an
  208. opportunity there but there's a lot of complexity of course within the industry that makes it hard to get there yeah i
  209. do think so as well hopefully they will do some of that otherwise the immediate fear is of course higher prices if
  210. there's uh further consolidation in the industry i mean if we look at it from the point
  211. of view that we want airlines to survive then for the consumer it's good for them
  212. to merge so that they can at least try and get some of these efficiencies but secondarily i think so i think in recent
  213. times and by that i mean the last few months there has been an effort again to trying
  214. increase or at least give some thought to a better service on board and bring some pillows back and the like you
  215. know so but we all fly uh often from east coast to west coast uh overnight and ordering the day and and would like at
  216. least a hot meal on that plane i wouldn't mind shelling out another 10 20 or perhaps 30 or 40 bucks for it as
  217. irrational as that may sound but i think the trouble is what kevin is really alluding to is that
  218. the airlines have dissected the market into two groups and i think there's a third group they're forgetting they've
  219. thought about either the first class traveler or they've thought about um the extremely price price conscious traveler
  220. on the other end they haven't thought about the medium or high-end economy traveler i'll call them who's willing to
  221. pay a little more they won't just go with the cheapest option because it's five dollars or ten dollars cheaper and
  222. i think that's a certainly an area whether to a premium economy or through um you know introducing some service
  223. levels again that you would have previously i think that's an area that i can only hope like kevin says that some
  224. of these efficiencies will then uh turn into um positive service improvements so
  225. so given this the the current economy how would you if you're an airline go about making a profit
  226. well i i i think well no i think i think there's an opportunity what we're saying
  227. and of course it depends on what what size airline you are and what what cost structure you have i mean the others
  228. southwest for a number of years profited when all of its competitors didn't just because they executed better
  229. in lots of ways some of it was structural some of it was just decisions they made about hedging fuel prices and
  230. so forth but i i would agree i think this i think the opportunity is um if you can't be
  231. the the absolute low-cost company and that's just really hard to to do and to pull off consistently
  232. um find a way to get people to have brand loyalty which which hardly anyone has in the airline industry and and
  233. again to go back to the the technology field amazon.com is not the cheapest place to buy books hasn't been for a
  234. very long time it's cheaper than a bookstore but there are plenty of online book sellers that undercut amazon's
  235. price people still go there because they have a good experience they have loyalty
  236. and amazon has done a lot to cultivate that i think an airline that executed that strategy would have a much more
  237. enduring competitive advantage than one that just focused on just a little bit better
  238. yield management a little bit better cost cutting yeah and i think the tremendous opportunity now is if you
  239. have these consolidated networks by combining airlines you truly have global coverage and with that you know we all
  240. know that the margins are higher in the international sectors both transatlantic
  241. and trans-pacific so if one can position oneself as a good global carrier with many options to
  242. connect to smaller places and then harmonize the service a little bit so somebody who comes on a transatlantic
  243. flight and enjoys somewhat of a decent quality of service doesn't get shocked when they land at a hub and fly another
  244. four hours to go to san francisco for instance from the east coast with a completely different level of
  245. service they could reposition themselves and they could tap not into you know the
  246. complete leisure traveler who uh travels once or twice a year but really okay global business travel and we know that
  247. a lot of it's not just in business class but it's also an economy class given the
  248. state of the economy nowadays and and certainly technology companies and startups make use of that i think that's
  249. the positioning that can now be done especially as part of these larger networks and global alliances which the
  250. low-cost carriers don't have so i agree with that i think fundamentally they need to
  251. orient their strategy again or reorient their strategy not just to try and emulate and copy what the
  252. low-cost carriers are doing but really to try and find a niche for themselves and to position themselves accordingly
  253. yeah and one other piece of this again to get back to government part of the reason flying is so much worse of an
  254. experience now is this post-9 11 security climate and certainly people coming in from overseas the you know the
  255. difficulty of getting in uh arriving in the united states certainly security is is critically
  256. important and and it's it's obviously important for the government and for the the private companies to ensure that
  257. terrorism is prevented and so forth there's a great deal that that we do that makes fliers lives worse that
  258. doesn't make security any better and in some ways makes it worse and again with an election coming up whichever parties
  259. is not a partisan thing but if if someone comes into the white house who makes this you know an issue
  260. to ensure that we appropriately find ways to be secure while not stepping on the toes of people flying i think that
  261. will help the carriers as well very good well thank you very much for joining us thank you thank you thank you
  262. for more information please visit knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu

Brief Summary

Microsoft's aggressive bid for Yahoo and Delta's merger with Northwest Airlines are analyzed by Wharton professors.

Key points

  • Microsoft's Aggressive Strategy. Microsoft gives Yahoo three weeks to accept its offer or face a proxy battle.
  • Yahoo's Search Test with Google. Yahoo tests Google's AdSense service, signaling a search for alternatives amid Microsoft's bid.
  • Delta and Northwest Merger. Delta and Northwest Airlines merge to become the world's largest airline, aiming for cost synergies.
  • Impact of Election on Airline Deals. The upcoming presidential election could significantly affect airline mergers and regulations.
  • Challenges in the Airline Industry. Airlines face increasing competition and operational challenges, especially from low-cost carriers.
  • Consumer Sentiment on Airline Mergers. Consumers are generally unhappy with the airline industry, raising concerns about future mergers.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes