Talent Hunt: Getting the People You Need, When You Need Them

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Ask any CEO or senior level executive what his or her biggest challenge is, and the answer is almost always finding and keeping good people. Yet most executives fail to manage their company's needs in a way that recognizes the unpredictability of the global marketplace. In a book titled, Talent on Demand: Managing Talent in an Age of Uncertainty, Peter Cappelli, director of Wharton's Center for Human Resources, proposes a new approach to this issue based on applying the principles of supply chain management to people. He and Joyce Bradley, senior vice president and general manager, Delaware Valley region, of Lee Hecht Harrison, spoke with Knowledge@Wharton about talent management, including the challenges of managing employees in a recessionary economy. πŸ“‚ Management;Human Resources

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. this podcast is brought to you by knowledge at Wharton please visit knowledge Wharton upendi D you for more
  2. information ask any CEO or senior level executive what his or her biggest challenges and the answer is almost
  3. always finding and keeping good people yet most executives fail to manage their company's needs in a way that recognizes
  4. the unpredictability of the global marketplace in a book titled talent on demand managing talent in an age of
  5. uncertainty Peter Cappelli director of Wharton's Center for Human Resources proposes a new approach to this issue
  6. and that is to apply the principles of supply chain management to people he is here today to talk about his ideas
  7. including the challenge of managing the workforce in a recessionary economy joining him is Joyce Bradley senior vice
  8. president general manager of the Delaware Valley region of lee hecht harrison a global human capital
  9. consulting firm headquartered in woodcliff lake new jersey peter enjoys thanks for joining us Peter could you
  10. define talent management and then summarize your approach to thinking about how it relates to supply chain
  11. management so talent management is a simple issue and that is we're trying to anticipate what the needs and the demand
  12. will be for people for human capital into the future and then setting up some sort of plan for meeting it so it's
  13. pretty simple it's the same problem that you see in lots of different parts of business what do we think we're going to
  14. need how we're going to go about meeting that the complication is in the old days
  15. this was really seen as a sort of engineering problem that is things were thought to be quite predictable if you
  16. went back to the days of regulation for example where companies were pretty sure
  17. they knew what they were going to be making ten years out or so they could just work backwards and say this is our
  18. product demand ten years out these are the products are going to be making these are the skills we're going to need
  19. in order to produce those products let's just work backwards and the other assumption was that all your talent was
  20. internal you'd hire people right out of college to school you put them in apprentice
  21. programs or development programs and then you'd work them through those processes to develop the skills that you
  22. had so we had these big bureaucratic systems that we're based on the assumption of certainty that you knew
  23. what you were going to need and you could just work backwards and build to that so the problem now is all that
  24. assumption of certainty is gone product markets change so quickly people hop from company to company and you can't be
  25. sure what the demands are going to be and you can't be sure what the supply is at least your internal supply so we have
  26. to go about thinking about this issue differently and there are a series of techniques that come from feels like
  27. supply chain management that are designed specifically to deal with us this uncertainty and so that's what
  28. we're thinking about doing how to manage the uncertainty of the process Joyce you're out there every day dealing with
  29. companies and employees what do you hear about the problems they have with talent
  30. management well I think talent management is a good descriptor of how many companies are approaching their
  31. talent pools and there are human resources today in this market what we're seeing is that many companies are
  32. looking at it from a holistic perspective from not only recognizing talent and selecting Talent but hiring
  33. talent retaining those same people developing those people keeping them engaged and at the appropriate time
  34. redeploying and transitioning so it's more of a holistic approach it ties into Peters descriptor of what's happening in
  35. the marketplace and I think the the whole area of leadership development is really intensified as a result of what's
  36. happening in the demographics and the mergers and acquisitions and the productivity demands maybe just one
  37. additional thought on that the reason why this matters so much to companies is that when you make mistakes it's really
  38. costly that is you don't have the need people to get the work done or we're seeing that more now you have too many
  39. people and you either are losing them and losing the investments in them where you have to lay them off which is
  40. expensive and traumatic but no one you're when you think about supply chain management you think about
  41. widgets you know people sort of moving in victorian moving it out is there a downside to thinking about people as
  42. widgets you know that are that you know they have to be cancelled have to be pre-ordered maybe they're overstocked I
  43. mean is there is there some kind of dehumanizing involved in this approach certainly could be and you know there's
  44. a long history of dehumanizing employees in in the workplace but I think these are decisions that get made anyway that
  45. his companies have to think about how many people are we going to hire they have to think about are we going to lay
  46. people off and how many we're going to lay off they have to think about are we going to develop people and how many are
  47. we going to develop and at the moment most companies a survey results show they're they're sort of just doing that
  48. by flipping coins so they're making those decisions anyway and the problem is they're just not making them with any
  49. kind of logic behind them the survey evidence shows and maybe you've seen some of this too that about two-thirds
  50. of companies do no planning for workforce issues at all so they're just making these decisions ad-hoc without
  51. any thought behind them so I'd like to think the way we're pursuing this is thoughtful versus not thoughtful as
  52. opposed to widgets versus humans yeah and I think to add to Peter's point I think the way you create your corporate
  53. culture as a leader is playing more and more into the retention of talent and the attraction of talent people are
  54. looking going online and looking at mission statements and vision statements and trying to understand what kind of
  55. organization this is and what their values and whether their ethics are and trying to determine whether that's a
  56. good fit for them and on the flip side the companies are looking for people that will fit into their culture so it's
  57. it's a really important issue i think the Labor Department recently reported that the US economy shed 80,000 jobs in
  58. March which is the biggest drop in five years what kind of challenge does that pose for a company that knows it has to
  59. lay some people off but doesn't want to gut its workforce well maybe a Joyce may say some in the
  60. middle minute about the layoffs side per se but I would say if you if you took a
  61. step back and thought how were you thinking about these issues before the economy turned down and I think the
  62. worst way to do it is to simply assume you know what the demand will be and that is not recognized that there's
  63. uncertainty so I think the model that I'm suggesting is one where we try to be adaptable and responsive to the
  64. inevitable changes in demand rather than just assume that we're going to plunge away I think the the little bit of
  65. history here what killed this old approach was the planning efforts that went on in the 1970s when companies were
  66. expecting growth rates of about five percent a year and they just planned for that and the economy unexpectedly turns
  67. south they had these long talent pipelines that were like ten years long to produce people internally and then it
  68. turned out that you know they were producing a lot more talent than they needed 1980s came along and they ended
  69. up having to lay everybody often they got rid of all the functions for managing this so I think the issue is
  70. that before the recession's come to be responsive to set up a system where you can be responsive to the changes that
  71. are happening and not just plunge blindly ahead with the assumptions about growth that you pretty much know aren't
  72. going to be very accurate to pee back on what Peter just mentioned what we talked
  73. about a lot is agility and what we hear our leader leadership folks in leadership talking about in companies is
  74. the agility of leaders to flex and to bend not only with the marketplace but with employees we're in a situation now
  75. where we have multi-generations in the same workforce multi cultures leaders have to be able to address the needs of
  76. individuals treat individuals as unique people in the workforce and flex to the demands of the market place and meet
  77. those at the same time so agility is really a key characteristic of leaders that were saying they maybe we could
  78. just be concrete about an exam about how you might do this and that is if you think about the kind of talent
  79. the amount of talent you're going to need in an organization some of that you want to be developing internally but the
  80. more you do that and develop internally you're making a big investment than you're making taking out a pretty big
  81. amount of risk and the risk is if we don't need these people we've blown the investment so you probably don't want to
  82. if you think you're going to need let's say a hundred people and that's your best guess but you're uncertain about it
  83. you may not want to develop 100 internally you might want to develop maybe 80 internally and then expect to
  84. hire on the outside if you fall short of that demand and then maybe you might want to say you know we'll use some
  85. contingent work and some temporary help to close the gap as well right so that we are building some adaptability into
  86. the system and not trying to meet our entire estimated demands simply with internal development which is a big risk
  87. a big upfront investment and really expensive if you get it wrong Peter in your book you point out that many of the
  88. talent management techniques that are quote in vogue now like 360 degree Oh if if if if
  89. I if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if yo yo yo yo
  90. yo yo yo yo yo if if if if if if yo yo yo yo yo yo yo yo if if if if if if yo yo yo yo yo
  91. if yo yo yo if if if if if if if if if if yo yo yo if if if if yo yo yo yo yo yo yo yo
  92. oye if if if if if if if if if if yo yo yo yo yo yo yo yo yo yo yo if if if if if
  93. if if if if if if if

Brief Summary

Peter Cappelli and Joyce Bradley discuss innovative talent management strategies using supply chain principles amid economic uncertainty.

Key points

  • Managing Talent in Uncertainty. Peter Cappelli proposes applying supply chain management principles to talent management in today's unpredictable market.
  • The Cost of Mistakes in Talent Management. Joyce Bradley highlights the costly consequences of mistakes in talent management, especially during layoffs.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes