Why High Performers Sometimes Leave Organizations

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Wharton Professor Maurice Schweitzer discusses how organizations manage high-performing employees who come into conflict with senior leadership. Using examples from both the corporate world and professional sports, he highlights how personality differences and power dynamics can lead to the departure of valuable individuals. He also examines what often happens after such departures and why internal processes may not be sufficient to resolve conflicts at the highest levels.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#Leadership #Management #WorkplaceConflict #WorkplaceCulture #OrganizationalBehavior #TalentManagement #CorporateLeadership #WorkplaceDynamics ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Dan Loney: Have you ever seen a situation where, in the office, there's a superstar employee, but maybe he just doesn't fit
  2. into the mindset of the office? If you're a manager in such a situation, how do you handle that? Well, recently, the Boston
  3. Red Sox traded their best player and highest paid player after there were disagreements with leadership. And while this was
  4. occurring in baseball, there are potentially some correlations to what we see play out in the business world. Pleasure to be
  5. joined by Maurice Schweitzer, who's a Professor of Operations, Information and Decisions here at the Wharton School. Hi,
  6. Maurice, how are you, sir? Oh, great to be back with you. Thank you. You know, in many cases, the world of sports may not be
  7. applicable to the business world, but it seems like in this case, it very well could be. And I'm guessing there probably
  8. have been instances where a superstar employee may be great for business, but maybe not great for the overall setting of the office.
  9. I think that's exactly right. And I think— I mean, I think of sports, the world of sports, as a place where it's— those are
  10. important organizations. And they're— those are real businesses. I mean, the people running them, the people
  11. supporting them, they're— that's a business. I think we can learn a lot from sports, but there are many business cases where there
  12. are star employees that have clashed with senior leadership. In many cases, these stars end up either coming back to the
  13. organization or becoming stars in other organizations. I mean, one of the most famous is Lee Iacocca, who was at Ford, and—
  14. this is back in the '70s. And Lee Iacocca was really a great rising star. He was in charge of the Mustang. But Henry Ford the
  15. Second, related to the founder of Ford, really clashed with him, and Lee Iacocca was fired in 1978. And Iacocca went on to
  16. become the CEO of Chrysler, and revived Chrysler and really became this icon of a leader. But he did not get along
  17. with Henry Ford, the Second. So when you have a situation like this, I guess, let me ask
  18. you how you look at it from two perspectives— one being maybe the manager who's overseeing that employee, but also, number
  19. two, the other employees in the office who are obviously dealing with this as well.
  20. Yeah. I mean, let me share another example. So, I mean, we all know Jamie Dimon as the CEO of JP Morgan Chase, and he's one of
  21. the leading financial experts of our time. But he struggled with Sandy Weill when he was at Citigroup. He was the COO there.
  22. There was a succession, so there were other people in the mix. And at Citigroup, he got pushed out in 1998. And what's, I
  23. think, so interesting is, you know, he really was this protege of Sandy Weill, but they didn't get along. There were
  24. other people involved. And the dynamics there, you know, pushed Jamie Dimon out. But he was a star. And he ended up becoming
  25. this superstar at a different bank. Does the position of where that employee is within the company
  26. hierarchy make a difference as to how you deal with the issues that are at hand?
  27. Yeah, I think that's absolutely right. I mean, another example— like Sheryl Sandberg at Facebook had
  28. difference of opinions with Mark Zuckerberg, particularly around the regulation and responsibility sort of
  29. initiatives. And she was the CEO there, COO, and she ended up leaving in 2022, where she felt like her vision for the company
  30. just wasn't the same as Mark Zuckerberg's. And Mark Zuckerberg took a big bet on virtual reality, and now he's taking a
  31. big bet on AI. He's been leading Facebook. And, you know, Sheryl Sandberg ended up going in a very different direction, sort
  32. of doing more, you know, writing and other philanthropy work. How does a situation like this, then, potentially impact
  33. the company moving forward? And do they have to kind of look at their structure and look at their rules and regulations in
  34. place, and whether or not there need to be tweaks made to some of those along the way?
  35. Yeah, I like that idea about thinking about the sort of process and regulation. So often it comes down to personality
  36. clashes. Like Elon Musk and Tesla had these personality clashes. And actually, Musk was forced to step down as chairman
  37. of the board in 2018 but then clearly Musk took over later. I was thinking, we started off talking about sports. I
  38. mean, Tom Brady and Bill Belichick had this conflict and clashed, and Brady ended up leaving for Tampa Bay and then
  39. won a Super Bowl. I think you want to think carefully about sort of process. But so many of these iconic examples are with
  40. personalities at the top. And I mean, I keep coming up with examples that— where the person that was pushed out ends up
  41. becoming someone that was incredibly valuable. So, like Steve Jobs versus John Sculley. Back when Apple was founded,
  42. Steve Jobs was forced out in 1985. He didn't come back until 1997. And when he came back in 1997, Apple was not in good
  43. shape. I mean, like it's— it's hard to imagine, but John Sculley had a vision. It was very different from Steve Jobs.
  44. Steve Jobs is famously difficult to work with, but this brilliant leader who completely turned around Apple when he came back.
  45. Personality versus the bottom line is probably the ultimate kind of story to this. And as you kind of alluded to, in many
  46. cases, it's— it's a hard challenge for those two to meet when you have the personality being so strong.
  47. I think that that's right. I mean, in so many of these cases— so Steve Jobs, Elon Musk, Tom Brady, Lee Iacocca, Jamie
  48. Dimon— like, these are strong personalities. Brilliant minds, but very strong personalities. And I think at the top there's
  49. this clash. I mean, who's going to be the next leader of Citigroup, who's going to lead Apple? And, you know, I mean, I
  50. really liked your question about process, but I think it's difficult at the top when we're thinking about this, the most
  51. senior leaders. I mean, even like Bill Belichick and Tom Brady. Like, strong personalities. And they're
  52. really at the very top of the game. Maurice, great to talk with you. Thanks very much for your time
  53. today. All the best. Thank you. You got it. Maurice Schweitzer, who is Professor of Operations, Information and Decisions here
  54. at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Superstar employees can clash with leadership, impacting business dynamics and organizational success.

Key points

  • Superstar Employees and Office Fit. Exploring how superstar employees may excel individually but clash with office dynamics.
  • Lee Iacocca's Rise and Fall. Lee Iacocca was fired from Ford but became an icon at Chrysler.
  • Jamie Dimon's Struggles at Citigroup. Jamie Dimon faced conflict with Sandy Weill, leading to his exit from Citigroup.
  • Sheryl Sandberg's Departure from Facebook. Sheryl Sandberg left Facebook due to differing visions with Mark Zuckerberg.
  • Steve Jobs' Return to Apple. Steve Jobs was ousted from Apple but returned to turn the company around.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes