'Kill the Company': Identify Your Weaknesses Before Your Competitors Do

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

For many, implementing an innovation strategy, which requires changes within an organization, means adding layers of new processes. Lisa Bodell, author of Kill the Company: End the Status Quo, Start an Innovation Revolution, argues that there are straightforward ways to make change without bogging down the organization. Knowledge@Wharton spoke with Bodell recently about her approach to getting companies to face their vulnerabilities, why taking risks are essential and why small changes make all the difference. 📂 Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] Lisa thank you so much for joining us at knowledge of warden today thank you for
  2. having me you open your book kill the company with a group of people ferociously plotting to decimate their
  3. main competitor as they aim for Market domination but there's a Twist we discovered that this group is engaged in
  4. exercise to help them look at their own company's vulnerabilities it was their own company that they had torn apart in
  5. fact what is kill the company all about oh I'm glad you asked it's of course my favorite exercise because it's the name
  6. of the book um you know kill the company is about um having an outof company experience it's about um really
  7. examining your weaknesses so you can make them your strengths so the idea of kill the company is um rather than how
  8. it happens in most businesses that each year we we do a SWAT analysis you know our strengths weaknesses opportunities
  9. threats and most people use it as like a political construct to say where they're
  10. strong and they're not really weak it's where they're challenged and that doesn't really work and so kill the
  11. company is pretend that you are your number one competitor you have 30 minutes how will you put yourself out of
  12. business and what that does especially with Executives it kind of gets their War mentality on and they're given
  13. permission to really look at what's wrong and then ideally what you find out is where are
  14. you really weak what can you do about it who can you partner with and even best how can you then turn that back onto
  15. your competitors so it's just a neat way a neat twist in terms of looking at what
  16. how your weaknesses are but you give it kind of a gaming mentality right and part of what you're looking at is
  17. removing those obstacles to Innovation what what are some of those obstacles that you see well there's many there's
  18. many I mean I think inherently a lot of people are adverse to taking a risk and they don't realize it they'll say
  19. especially leaders that uh they want their teams to take a risk when they may be the biggest barrier to risk because
  20. they have so much on the line you know quarterly earnings they've got all kinds of things that they have to manage but I
  21. think U one of them is just aversion to risk another thing is is a lack of definition around how much risk you can
  22. take so those are some of the biggest barriers if you can have leaders all of a sudden be open to more risk and Define
  23. it I think they'll operate less with handcuffs and more with guard rails and be willing to do not just incremental
  24. change but really dramatic disruptive ones that's great and if a company is committed to making that kind of a
  25. change and looking at you know where they are uh where how would they go about looking at where they fall in The
  26. Innovation Spectrum well it depends on what you're talking about it could be around risk I
  27. think what they have to do is look at their culture and I talk a lot about this in the book and that I think you
  28. can really look at a company's culture and determine how much risk they're willing to take and I think they can
  29. look at a few things um how much do their Executives lead by example how much failure or experimentation are you
  30. allowed to take how much resources that can be time or money do they put towards
  31. new Ventures um what metrics are they measuring and do those metrics have to do with um uh new things new to Market
  32. New to the world types of Adventures and that will kind of give you a feeling for
  33. what is their culture like and are they really involved in leading Innovation or
  34. is it more of a lip service you'll get a real feel for that Spectrum quickly right right and just in terms of those
  35. those uh different types of cultures what what do you see are some of the uh main types of cultures within
  36. organizations well I uh I'll tell you it's interesting what I did over the last few years is I studied corporate
  37. cultures and change and what was fascinating to me is we seem to talk about change um or cultures in terms of
  38. good versus bad but I I don't think it's that simple actually I think there's another culture that permeates all the
  39. organizations that many of us have worked at and is probably like the silent killer um the worst kind of
  40. culture isn't a bad culture it's a complacent one and I think the world has gotten so complex that we keep putting
  41. more and more processes in place and the result of that is is that people become
  42. complacent they no longer think they can affect change even though they might want to they kind of give up it's the
  43. everything's just fine mentality and we see that at a lot of big corporations they've got the money and the brand and
  44. they can write it out for a long time until all of a sudden where did that small company come from who knew and
  45. they had a compl culture so I think that's that's something people really have to watch for in the
  46. future and if if an organization is ready to change if they have identified these things and um sort of reckon with
  47. their their own culture what are the what are the tenants to make change stick well there's a few in fact we did
  48. some um some case studies over the last couple years and because we didn't know what really made change stick and why
  49. corporate culture change was so hard and what we found through some of these case
  50. studies was it was interesting it wasn't what I thought when we first set out to
  51. do it the first was is that I think change has to happen not from the top down but from the middle out and what I
  52. mean by that is it has to really stick with people that are in the trenches and they're respected by leadership but
  53. they're admired from those that are rising stars these are the guys that are in the meetings and emails and slugging
  54. it out every day that I think can really affect change the most as long as of course leadership wants you to make that
  55. change in the first place the second thing is I think we think change is a um it's a process and I don't believe
  56. that's true I think that um if Innovation or change was a process we all could do it because I'm sure people
  57. are very smart and can follow the rules I think it's a toolkit I really think it's in this world that's so complex
  58. they need OnDemand tools that they can draw on with different things that come at them and then the final thing I think
  59. with change is um I can't I don't think it can be big mandates I think it has to
  60. be something called little bigs it's change with a little C we have to start affecting change on on an everyday level
  61. in those meetings with emails with reports with procedures we have to affect it by Leading by example in small
  62. ways to get people to them want to take big change and that's not something we expected we thought it would be big
  63. change initiatives and in fact it was the opposite that worked so that was a great cool learning for
  64. us in in fact uh just to pick up on the first part of what you talked about you cite Recent research from whon
  65. management Professor Ethan mik that shows that midle managers have more impact on a company's performance
  66. than nearly any other part of the organization you know according to this work you've done and the research you've
  67. done uh why is that important and can you tell us more about how um that that works well I think it's very um it's
  68. important for people that are in organizations and you know there's more managers than there are leaders right
  69. and those are the people that really are on the ground and that know how to run the business and can really affect
  70. change with so many different people so I I think it's important one to acknowledge it um I think two what you
  71. find is like people don't want to fire lit from underneath right they don't want to uh fire lit from underneath them
  72. by leaders they want to fire lit within them and people can't tell you to do that they have to really believe that
  73. they can affect change to do it so I think the managers are the ones that really we need to concentrate on with
  74. change versus always these top- down approaches we got to put more money here not just here you argue that employees
  75. need certain skills what are some of those uh I again you know when we did some research it wasn't what I thought
  76. it's um it's some basic things it's perseverance I think especially with Innovation and change um you can't
  77. expect it to happen the first try so you have to have some perseverance that's hard in this really on demand do it this
  78. quarter World um I think you need to have agility you got to be able to Pivot have a plan B that's really important we
  79. talk a lot about um provocative inquiry I think that there's a lost art of asking questions so we're so focused on
  80. getting the answer and being right that we've forgotten how to ask the right question some of it is because we don't
  81. want to make people comfortable um and I think some of it is we've just forgotten how so provocative
  82. inquiries another one another one I'll mention is strategic imagination and I only say that because I want to separate
  83. it from you know creativity because I think people can come up with ideas but you've got to be a dreamer with purpose
  84. in today's day and age because there's only so much money and time so people that can really have strategic
  85. imagination I think will be the ones that rise to the top and can you tell us um as a final question about one or two
  86. of the companies that you think are are really um headed in the right direction when um and have done this type of work
  87. oh sure um I'm a big fan of shell and not many people mention oil or energy companies I a fan of them because I
  88. think what they do that's really interesting is they have um game changers or futurists on staff that are
  89. constantly looking to disrupt their business model so they imagine and they have plenty of money and they can make
  90. money for a long time without changing but they imagine for example uh will we live in a world soon where we are no
  91. longer extracting energy but growing it and they start to build that kind of a business I think that companies like GM
  92. and BMW um they are looking at their business models and saying well gosh if everybody is really moving towards Urban
  93. models and living in cities maybe they won't be able to drive as many cars so maybe we won't be a car company it will
  94. be a Mobility systems company so they're really doing Forward Thinking in terms of how they destroy or kill their own
  95. companies to become ones that they need to be before someone else kills them very inspiring thank you very much for
  96. speaking with us today Lisa oh thank you I appreciate it [Music]

Brief Summary

Lisa discusses corporate culture, innovation, and risk management in her book "Kill the Company."

Key points

  • Kill the Company Concept. Lisa discusses her book 'Kill the Company', focusing on examining weaknesses for strength.
  • The Silent Killer Culture. Exploration of how complacent cultures hinder innovation and change.
  • Change from the Middle Out. Lisa emphasizes that effective change must come from middle management, not just leadership.
  • Everyday Change Matters. Highlighting the importance of small, everyday changes in corporate culture.
  • Future of Mobility. Discussion on how companies like GM and BMW are evolving into mobility systems.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes