AI Could Make Supply Chains Smarter But Not Disaster-Proof

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Wharton’s Gad Allon explains how the aluminum plant fire in New York exposed the danger of concentrating too much supply in one location and why many companies still haven’t built real resilience into their supply chains. He shares how the drive to cut costs led firms to favor efficiency over stability, why true resilience means paying for redundancy and flexibility, and how AI can help by predicting disruptions, improving coordination, and supporting preventive maintenance. Allon also shows how Amazon’s logistics model proves that speed, resilience, and efficiency can work together when strategy and operations are fully aligned.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#OperationsStrategy #AIinManufacturing #SupplyChainRisk #OperationalExcellence #SupplyChain #AI #OperationsManagement ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Recently, an aluminum plant in New York State caught fire, destroying a large section of the facility. That plant was
  2. a supplier to several automakers in the development of their vehicles. Events like that and others have an impact on
  3. the supply chain and force companies to have to make adjustments. Of course, the
  4. pandemic really challenged the supply chain and forced many entities around the supply chain to rethink how they
  5. would operate on a daily basis. As for where we are at the moment when we think about supply chain, pleasure to welcome
  6. in Gad Alon who is a professor of operations, information and decisions here at the Wharton School. Gad, great
  7. to catch up with you again. >> Yeah, great to be here. Then >> what do you think is the general state
  8. uh of supply chain right now and and what did the pandemic teach companies about their supply chains?
  9. >> It's a it's a great question and two different question and one question. I will say most supply chains are are I
  10. won't say deep trouble that that's that will be probably an exaggeration but there are still there are suffering from
  11. some implication of what started even before the pandemic which is you know more and more issues that are more and
  12. more frequent from climate to geopolitical risk to demand fluctuations to suppliers having issues to now you
  13. you add tariffs to that and then so most firms are are struggling to just get their supply chain to stabilize
  14. but then you have continuously the other issues that just happened and that's of
  15. like the the fire that you're describing is just an illustration of one more issue that one needs to prepare for.
  16. >> Okay. So for the automakers that uh did get aluminum supply from that plant, how
  17. are they adjusting to not having that access that they've had or and are used to having for such a long period of
  18. time? >> Yeah, I think so for many of them I think that's going to take a very very
  19. very long recovery and and I think that's to some extent really the the first question. So just to get the
  20. numbers right so 40% of the aluminum to US manufacturers come from that plant. So we might ask why do we have such a
  21. concentration in one place but then my understanding is only Q1 in 2026 they will be able to recover back to
  22. the full capacity and even then it's questionable. So here multiple things need to happen. So the first thing is
  23. many places many of these manufacturers will have to think about we like what we
  24. like to call time to recovery. How long will it take until they can recover? And
  25. then you start rationing. You start saying, "Okay, which models are going to get the aluminum they need and which
  26. models not so much." But you remember in during the COVID days, one of the things
  27. that we had shortage of were semiconductors chips. And there what you saw is that
  28. most manufacturers prioritized more expensive models. So Audi prioritized Q7 and and Toyota prioritized the Lexus and
  29. the like. And and so that's potentially what we're going to see. We might see cascading effects of suppliers that are
  30. now going to get, you know, fewer orders and now they're going to reduce their manufacturing only to get caught back
  31. again where the aluminum is going to be back at capacity. Firms are currently probably scrambling to find spot markets
  32. that as we know has implication on price as well. So what you'd expect is expensive models will become potentially
  33. more expensive, cheap models to either not exist or becoming expensive. It will take a while for for this market
  34. to recover or what we're going to see is is those who actually were impacted will
  35. have to shrink their margins while those who are not impacted will be able to actually gain market share. Let me go
  36. back to something you said at the beginning of that answer and about the fact that such a a large percentage of
  37. the supply is in one location. So obviously that's something that needs to be looked at as well when you think
  38. about we're talking about a period of time of growth in this economy right now that there needs to be a consideration
  39. of not only repairing the facility that was damaged by fire but looking at another facility the potential of a
  40. larger buildout uh in this sector. >> Right. So I think that goes back to what something you asked me in the beginning
  41. which is what did we learn from the the pandemic and and I'm sad to say nothing but it's not that
  42. we didn't try to learn there's just a inherent trade-off between resilience and cost cost efficiency and one of the
  43. things that many CEOs came out of COVID is with the idea that we need to build a
  44. more resilient supply chain but most of them do not understand or don't appreciate the fact that to build a more
  45. resilient supply chain you need to to increase costs. You need to have excess capacity. You need to have redundancy.
  46. You need to have many a small overlapping plans rather than one big ones. The main reason that we have such a
  47. concentrated risk in one place is that firms optimize for economies of scale as a way to reduce cost. They try to
  48. optimize for quality and compliance and it's very hard to qualify multiple suppliers. You try to be just in time.
  49. So you try to concentrate everything in one location. All of these are best practices if what you try to do is
  50. reduce cost. This is not what you try to do when you try to be more resilient. But as long as the customer still wants
  51. cost and unwilling to pay for resilience, that's what we're going to get. >> How will artificial intelligence play a
  52. role in supply chains as we move forward? >> Yeah. So it's a great question. As we know, AI is the solution for
  53. everything. Well, not so much. So, AI cannot prevent the the fire. I don't think so at least.
  54. But it can prevent concentration. It can help. You know, one of the things that has been always the big promise is this
  55. notion of digital twin. And digital twin is the idea that you can actually run continuously simulation real time and
  56. understand the implication of everything you do. These are what very very hard to
  57. build and underutilized because most humans just do not understand the implication of what they see. And but
  58. now we're going to see more and more AI agents run supply chains and we're still
  59. a few years away from that. But there are already firms that are developing AI agents. Then these AI agents are are
  60. actually capable of saying that. So we might see inventory that's more strategic and more in better places.
  61. It's trying to understand the implication of this longtail implications. So you know we're not
  62. preparing for a fire, but we should prepare for the fact that 40% of our supply is going to come from one
  63. location and and maybe we we may want to hedge that. maybe. So I think AI is going to make us more predictive so
  64. easier to predict things. It's going to be easier to try to orchestrate things and potentially also do more preventive
  65. maintenance and predictive maintenance and and and so that's and and that potentially may prevent some of these
  66. longtail events. We cannot prevent tariffs but we can prevent some of these things. And I think the other side to
  67. this is that you know so many of the stories around supply chain obviously because of the pandemic and and
  68. recovering from the pandemic have been negative and the excess cost and and the negative impact that you know we've seen
  69. because of supply chains. If you flip it the other way, thinking about how positive a strongly run, efficiently run
  70. supply chain, what that can mean to not only economies but to cultures around the globe.
  71. >> Yeah. So that's a it's a great question to some extent. I mean I think it's a
  72. there there are two sides again to that story. One is that of course we read only negative things because it's a
  73. little like okay you don't read about a great defense. you read about great difference only when about difference
  74. only when they many there are many goals scored on them that's a story of of supply chain but you're right I mean I
  75. think firms cultures that managed to actually build robust supply chain meant that they actually you know I mean let
  76. me just tell a very very simple I mean you know very simple story which is you know you have to go you can go back to
  77. World War II and and you realize that the countries that had better industrial base with better supply chain those are
  78. the ones that managed to ultimately win the war. It was not just about having being able to have the best army, but
  79. the best army that can actually replenish very very quickly its supply and and so I think we we are many years
  80. away from that and so we forgot many of these lessons and and and I think we we are start trying to relearn some of that
  81. now. COVID was a route awakening for many but but not apparently not for everybody and and definitely at that's
  82. at least where we see at the federal level some awareness now for that topic but again it's it's exactly as you say
  83. it's usually through negative stories not through positive stories. So then how should companies think about supply
  84. chains right now having gone through everything that they've gone through in the last few years but thinking about
  85. the next 15 to 20 years about being as effective as they possibly can because it obviously is something that's going
  86. to impact their bottom line. >> Yeah. So I think I'm I'm it's interesting you know the the best
  87. example for that and and I think the firm that you'd expect everybody to try to copy is Amazon right and Amazon
  88. understands supply chain almost like better than anyone else Amazon and Walmart and but Amazon specifically
  89. Amazon has a good website but it's not such a great website but the main thing is that when you order from Amazon
  90. something today you will get it today and if you order it and you're willing to pay you might get even within a few
  91. hours and within a few minutes and Amazon is definitely a firm that I mean the amount of cash in their supply chain
  92. is then used to fund the rest of the business and every customer Amazon Amazon customer is is an Amazon customer
  93. not because how well the website is run that's great that they have everything but you have they have everything and
  94. you'll get everything and so you'd expect more firms to understand that you can actually be both resilient and agile
  95. and cheap at the same time if you just continuously think about how do you improve everything, how do you integrate
  96. everything, how do you make sure that there constant loop and you continuously try
  97. to optimize for both proximity and cost and and and it's possible but it requires a constant effort to do that
  98. and we just don't see firms most firms have the share of mind of leadership into doing that Gad great to talk to you
  99. again thanks very much for your time and your insight today all the best always great to be here thank you Gatalon
  100. professor of operations information and decisions here at the Wharton

Brief Summary

Gad Alon discusses supply chain challenges post-pandemic and the impact of an aluminum plant fire on automakers.

Key points

  • Aluminum Plant Fire Impact. A fire at a New York aluminum plant disrupts supply chains for automakers.
  • Lessons from the Pandemic. Gad Alon discusses what the pandemic taught companies about supply chains.
  • AI's Role in Supply Chains. Gad Alon explores how AI can help manage supply chain risks.
  • Historical Supply Chain Lessons. Gad Alon reflects on how supply chains influenced World War II outcomes.
  • Amazon's Supply Chain Strategy. Gad Alon highlights Amazon's effective supply chain management as a model.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes