Tata's Takeover of Jaguar and Land Rover: Bumpy Road Ahead?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Tata's Takeover of Jaguar and Land Rover: Bumpy Road or Smooth Ride?

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] this podcast is brought to you by Indian knowledge at Warton please visit
  2. knowledge. won. up.edu India for more [Music] information will the acquisition of Land
  3. Rover and jaguar be a smooth ride for Tata Motors that is the question many observers have been asking ever since
  4. the Tata group and Ford announced their $2.3 billion deal at the end of March the Takeover has been greeted with lots
  5. of Jubilation especially in India because of The Prestige of these Marquee brands on the other hand Skeptics have
  6. also been wondering how this acquisition fits in with the tataa group's overall strategy what can the Tartas do
  7. differently than Ford to ensure that the acquisition pays off what major challenges will TARTA Motors face in
  8. integration and marketing to help us make sense of these issues India knowledge at water interviewed John Paul
  9. McDuffy a professor of management at Wharton and co-director of the international Motor Vehicles program and
  10. harbir Singh acting chair of the management department at Wharton and co-director of the Mac Center for
  11. technological innovation harbir and John Paul thank you so much for joining us today glad to be here so let's start
  12. with the question that's on everyone's mind does this deal really make sense economic sense uh John Paul do you want
  13. to start sure uh it's a very fascinating deal I think for uh all the reasons that you
  14. that you highlighted um it's clearly not a deal that is trying to build economies
  15. of scale in just one business and uh just reach into new markets it's a quite a differently motivated deal and for
  16. Tata it's uh not the first time that they've reached for uh brand with some Prestige value as part of expanding
  17. their Global visibility um so I think viewed as an acquisition that they intend to learn a great deal from uh I
  18. think it could very well make sense uh the uh uh the exposure that they'll have to uh the high end of the auto business
  19. which they know very well uh at the at the at the domestic end uh and to the managing of this uh very prestigious
  20. brand I think could uh offer a lot of learning opportunities har just to follow up a little bit on the same issue
  21. the T do have the indicia and they also recently launched the the Tata Nano the the famous One lakh rupe car or the
  22. $2,500 car do Brands like the jaguar and Land Rover really fit in with that overall portfolio what's your sense of
  23. the fit uh my sense is that the tatas are trying to um expand the portfolio in general and uh these Brands kind of I
  24. don't think it's a question of um the the customer viewing Nano and jaguar and Land Rover as all offerings of the same
  25. company it's much more a question of uh you know like Louis vuon MO Hennessy having a a set of Brands and really
  26. doing the best you can for Land Rover and the best you can for Jaguar and in terms of you know the economic sense of
  27. the transaction I think another way of looking at it is what's the replacement value of those Brands right and clearly
  28. uh whatever price they pay is much lower than the replacement value so the real challenge here for them is to make sure
  29. that they can enhance jaguar in its own terms and en Land Rover in its own terms John Paul do you do you agree yes
  30. and uh you know Ford of course sold the companies because they're in deep financial distress and they really
  31. needed cash now uh toats others can be dispute I guess about the uh you know was the price too high or too low but
  32. they certainly paid substantially less than Ford paid for those Brands and uh by all accounts Land Rover is profitable
  33. and uh and jaguar has has has made a strong comeback based on building capabilities improving quality uh they
  34. have some interesting new products in the pipeline so I do agree so so it's your sense that the the tatas did get a
  35. bargain or did did they overpay because the this was a higher price than the market expected yeah it's it's always
  36. very tough to uh to know exactly uh and there's always this kind of of speculation at the time um I think that
  37. Ford was certainly counting on uh increasing the volumes of of these Brands probably particularly Jaguar uh
  38. to a much higher level and so uh at a certain point their efforts to greatly expand the volume uh I think probably
  39. hurt them somewhat they were introducing uh lower price Jaguars that uh a lot of
  40. people didn't feel represented the brand very well they were trying to leverage their own uh you know for design parts
  41. from other models uh so I actually think managing it uh as Prestige brand from the base that Ford established should
  42. should work well for the tatas and that appears to be their pattern with their Acquisitions that they uh by and large
  43. uh allow the the management to uh keep doing what it's doing and and as I said to to look for opportunities to learn
  44. from these foreign Acquisitions right you know some of the critics have been saying that uh for for the tatas this
  45. was a deal motivated more by the desire to acquire uh Marquee brand or iconic Brands uh almost like you know former
  46. Colonials acquiring the uh you know the trappings of the for the former Empire uh uh is is does that criticism make
  47. sense uh or or do you think this is a deal that is economically rational in business
  48. terms who knows about that motivation there certainly uh uh a kind of Interest I think in the whole deal comes partly
  49. from all those associations um one of the other tataa deals that's gotten some attention is uh the acquisition of tle
  50. te another British brand and also of of British steel the the remains of British
  51. steel and so uh clearly investing in Britain has uh worked well for Indian companies uh there were competing uh
  52. buyers uh mostly private Equity uh sometimes in partnership with with other auto companies and the both the unions
  53. and the suppliers of jaguar and Land Rover uh very much prefer Tata uh I suspect not because they're an Indian
  54. company but because of their track record in the way they've managed Acquisitions they by and large have not
  55. done widescale layoffs uh they have not done lots of consolidation they've focused on uh leveraging the strengths
  56. uh and the capabilities they've acquired so my my comment on that is that it's important for I agree with everything
  57. John Paul is saying my comment is that it's important for the tatas not to get distracted by this the the nationalism
  58. and you know those kinds of things which are all inevitable and natural and I think it's good it's the pride is well
  59. placed you know the pride in tatas by with by Indian investors and others is well placed um but fundamentally this
  60. transaction has to perform because it's a this is a large transaction I think it
  61. is a very good chance of Performing but I think it's important for them to not get wrapped in the in the overlay of um
  62. national pride and British clanism and all of those things well I think that's an excellent point harir because as we
  63. know uh Ford really had a tough time during the many years that it owned these these uh Brands uh what could the
  64. tatas do differently to make sure that the Acquisitions pay off well I think Ford uh I think it's correct that Ford
  65. struggled quite a bit with these transactions uh I think one of the issues that John Paul mentioned earlier
  66. was that Ford um is in financial trouble so if you were think about tata's approach to all of this uh they they
  67. could get a good price because it's a distress uh sale and I mentioned Market to replacement value and it's a good
  68. chance that uh the 2.3 billion is well below replacement value because Ford bought Jaguar for a similar reason they
  69. wanted that luxury name plate and Land Rover also is a very very um Marky name plate highend name plate um so from
  70. those points of view Market replacement value it makes a lot of sense uh but we can also ask that based on these
  71. multiple biders present that what we will get is kind of almost an auction like value right except that it will uh
  72. given that the biders are all well informed and they've had access to the books this is a private transaction it's
  73. not a public transaction I would think that 2.3 is probably a fair market value and I say that obviously without access
  74. to the to the books so um looking ahead then what can Tartas do differently I think what Tas can do differently is to
  75. manage the supply chain uh effectively and uh and and take advantage of the their experience in in managing
  76. manufacturing companies in uh England uh and in Europe um specifically with chorus that they've had some experience
  77. with um and to preserve uh the sources of value where they are and enhance them where they are so I think they they
  78. should try that and not integrate quite as much as Ford and jaguar did with the uh Jaguar X type and the Ford Lincoln uh
  79. counterpart right now you you've looked at other mergers that the Tata group has
  80. done uh is it your sense that the Tata that Tata Motors will try to integrate jaguar and Land Rover with their other
  81. Automotive operations and if so what do you think will be the major challenges involved uh well I think that they uh
  82. just speaking of tata's um experience with m&a in general um they've as a as a group have shown um you know a boldness
  83. in uh in going Beyond boundaries and uh making rather visible transactions um uh
  84. I think each of the operating companies is very professionally run and um I think there's some opportunity for
  85. learning across you know what what does a tly acquisition uh tell the the Tata group about crossb Acquisitions and what
  86. does the chorus experiened more recently tell them about manufacturing based Acquisitions and I think they're going
  87. to try to transfer some of those learnings to tataa Motors and I think that'll be very effective
  88. uh John Paul you have any comments on what challenges they might face and how they should tackle
  89. them when you think of other big uh mergers or m&a activity in the Auto industry uh this may bring to mind for
  90. some people something like dler Chrysler in the sense that you had a a high-end brand assoc combined with a set of more
  91. mass Market Brands and at first people thought uh this meant that there was not going to be a a great
  92. deal of conflict for the two companies because they would operate in you know in those different parts of the market
  93. uh that quickly turned to criticism that they weren't achieving synergies from from the deal and uh towards the end of
  94. that you know somewhat ill faded uh Union uh they were trying in fact to leverage more dler engineering and parts
  95. into Chrysler vehicles uh and in the end of course it it it fell apart and chryler was sold um you know to me
  96. there's such a a huge range between the Tata domestic products and um these luxury Brands uh and there's also the
  97. complete you know physical location of of the supply chains and and the manufacturing facilities uh I I think
  98. that I agree with our beer that uh this is probably a case where uh rather less uh actual integration activity but more
  99. focus on where you know experiences in in other Acquisitions uh can be uh can be transferred is the way to go and just
  100. to just to add to that comment I would say that uh value engineering may be very important they could bring some
  101. value engineering skills which I think uh tatas definitely have uh but beyond that I think it's much more a question
  102. of uh was the price uh right in relation to the value that uh tatas would get down the road I think that's going to be
  103. the uh the key determining Factor and of course there are many cultural issues that we can also talk about what
  104. cultural issues do you think will crop up between uh Tata Motors and uh the the the new acquisitions so you know just to
  105. start it off John Paul talked about Mercedes and Chrysler right and a lot of um it seemed like the the national
  106. cultural differences in addition to just differences in terms of how you produce
  107. a very high-end automobile and and a medium priced automobile um those cultural issues organizationally began
  108. to play a significant role um and and became significant challenges what uh tatas needs to do is to avoid some of
  109. those Dynamics so I think they have to avoid nationalism from rearing its head particularly in jaguar and land morover
  110. um from their end um because I don't think it is productive to have that um secondly um they have to ensure that uh
  111. for that Land Rover and jaguar achieve their potential and and manage them as if um they were a luxury
  112. manufacturer themselves to do value engineering on the back end but give the resources necessary for maintaining and
  113. enhancing the brands so that really calls for kind of the the the Tata Executives to to sort of uh transform
  114. their thinking and yet bring in to the to the luxury end or the the higher end price point but at the same time bring
  115. in value engineering and some of the fruit ality that that they would have a better handle on and that's that's a
  116. that's a challenge again thinking back to the D Chrysler situation uh clearly a big factor from the very beginning uh
  117. was a sense that the Chrysler uh management had that uh essentially it was a takeover and that
  118. control coming from schukart was really uh uh the dominant factor and a lot of executive Talent left in the very early
  119. days um it already appears to be clear that the a lot of the jaguar and Landover management will stay in place
  120. uh they seem to have already gotten those assurances the uh again the the care with which rajant Tata himself and
  121. and his staff spoke with the unions and suppliers to assure them continuity I I think they've already approached some of
  122. those uh challenges associated with the transition um very skillfully uh I also noted in in just one press account of uh
  123. of the approach that Tata has taken with some of their Acquisitions something that uh I've seen as as being very
  124. effective in for example the Rena Nissan Alliance um which is essentially uh allowing a lot of decentralization um
  125. but reaching into the organization for uh Talent sometimes lower down in the ranks assembling task forces to work on
  126. certain important strategic issues and then letting their recommendations come up to a senior level and trying to enact
  127. them quickly and and providing res ources for them so again based on not a lot of information my sense is that
  128. they're approaching this quite skillfully so far let me in fact add to that um that sometimes we think about
  129. these companies as homogeneous entities so tatas produces kind of uh lower priced or medium priced in developing
  130. country Automobiles and these are luxury automobile manufacturers but I think I agree with John Paul's point that when
  131. you break it down to the operational level and you know the the automobile design groups and so on and so forth the
  132. supply chain uh there are there are a lot of commonalities in how you think about the engineering of these
  133. Automobiles and to try to develop task forces that can find the best of both practices and in fact transfer learning
  134. across organizational boundaries is entirely possible and the Reno Nissan example is an excellent one uh where um
  135. you know they actually uh went in and turned around Nissan uh and everybody thought that it was very very difficult
  136. to do so that was a concrete example that actually can be emulated in this setting so I think that's great point
  137. right apart from the operational and cultural issues there's also a marketing challenge that the tatas will face uh
  138. how how do you think that should be tackled um I mean first of all I think we've you know our basic stance is that
  139. a lot of the management of those brands should should probably continue without a great deal of change uh this is a new
  140. area for Tata to to to learn from uh I I noticed one uh quote from uh Shakur kapor the director of the two movies
  141. about Queen Elizabeth who lives in London and he talked about uh a sense of Pride that he felt at hearing about this
  142. acquisition and so there probably is an opportunity I wouldn't say to play to nationalism per se or to or to this uh
  143. Colonial uh reversal uh kind of angle uh but in fact to to Market uh to um you know successful Indian expatriates
  144. Around the World perhaps in India as well but I think particularly in in countries around the world that's a a
  145. desirable market and there's some opportunities there I would agree with that as well I think uh if you think
  146. about um the Tata group as a whole on one hand the challenges are that you don't want to you know dilute the name
  147. plate of jaguar and Land Land Rover with um the lower cost kind of imagery uh but
  148. tataa as a group has um you know marketed luxury products as well I mean they have you know jewelry division
  149. that's very successful I'm not suggesting they use the jewelry kind of approach but they certainly have the
  150. diversity of perspective within the group uh to to more than tolerate uh luxury uh products and Brands so um and
  151. if you look at data if you look at tly te most people don't associate that uh with with the Tata ownership uh outside
  152. of uh out outside of India and um you know deadle has thrived as a brand so I can I can see them replicating that kind
  153. of approach where we we keep the brand intact and we keep the management largely intact but we try to infuse
  154. knowledge where we think there is something beneficial to infuse into this uh this domain right let me uh conclude
  155. by asking one final question to both of you uh if rat and Tata the head of uh Tata Suns and Tata Motors were in the
  156. room with us right now uh what ADV viice uh might you give it I think I would emphasize uh two
  157. things that have been themes here um one is is focus and and not being uh distracted there is a need to extract
  158. value from this and that will largely depend on being very focused at finding what it takes to make jaguar and Land
  159. Rover succeed on their own terms uh kind of grander schemes that involve trying to leverage these Brands across uh the
  160. rest of of their portfolio I think think uh probably don't make a lot of sense at
  161. this point but secondly the the theme of learning I mean I think the that already
  162. appears to be a Thrust of some of the emerging market multinationals that when they acquire uh access to uh learning
  163. and the chance to develop new capabilities is really the motivation and and not simply ways to get scale or
  164. take cost out so uh if they can stay focused on that the the companies uh that I've filed for many years in the
  165. Auto industry that have have consistently been successful Toyota most notably um have kept that focus on
  166. learning and Improvement at the Forefront consistently in good times and bad and I would urge that on Mr Tata so
  167. I would say three things the first of course I would uh be honored to be in his presence you know and uh compliment
  168. him on his uh statesmanship you know he's he's led a group uh that already had a tremendous reputation but he's
  169. taken it to new heights uh but the second thing is to say that uh um that that he should trust his uh divisional
  170. his CEOs of his companies and and he does and uh you know see how they can get the most value out of this uh these
  171. transactions uh not just uh Tata Motors but also the Tata steel and the other transactions that the companies are
  172. doing and the third thing is to actually um Talk a bit more about learning across
  173. the group uh I think each of the companies is doing has a lot of practices within it and how can we get
  174. the most out of transferring knowledge across the groups and related to that is the point of discovering uh a unique
  175. style that is uh appropriate for these kinds of business groups and how do business groups create value I think is
  176. an emerging style and to further develop that so those are the three things great
  177. well har and John Paul thank you so much for joining us today for more information please visit
  178. knowledge. won. up.edu India [Music]

Brief Summary

Tata Motors' acquisition of Jaguar and Land Rover presents opportunities and challenges, focusing on brand management and strategic integration.

Key points

  • Tata Motors' Acquisition of Jaguar and Land Rover. The acquisition raises questions about economic sense and brand integration.
  • Challenges Ahead for Tata Motors. Experts discuss the potential challenges Tata Motors may face in integrating luxury brands.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes