Wharton's David Reibstein interviews William Lauder

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hello and welcome to measured thoughts today I'm delighted to be joined by William Lauder from the Estee luders
  2. companies welcome thank you I'm glad GL to have you with me William why don't you tell us how big is Estee Lauder
  3. today in terms of number of employees sales number of Brands Etc put it in perspective EST laer company Estee
  4. Lauder the brand was founded by my grandparents Ese and Joseph laer in 1946 in 1958 my father Leonard Lauder also a
  5. graduate of Wharton joined the company after a three-year stint in the Navy and the company was doing $800,000 in sales
  6. on a global basis today we're a family of 27 different different brands doing business in 130 companies in the world
  7. we have approximately 27,000 employees and we'll do somewhere around 7.8 to 28 billion dollar in sales on a net basis
  8. for our next fiscal year in North America we've got three brands with each with a network of between 120 and 160 of
  9. their own stores Origins Mac and Aveda we also have a group of stores which we call the Cosmetics company store which
  10. are sold primarily in off-price malls taking excess merchandise that is created by the brands and or returned by
  11. the retailers which we sell they are both past operations which operate in certain places for example in our office
  12. building in New York as well as some other large buildings we used to have a very successful operation in the World
  13. Trade Center before that tragedy and there's perhaps about a dozen of them that operate in other parts of the world
  14. outside of North America the key principle behind all of our retail operations for any of our
  15. Brands is that the brands control of their image is so important and each brand retail has a different level of
  16. significance and importance so for example I've named the brands like Origins Mac and Ava which have a
  17. meaningful presence in North America Clinique has a couple of retail stores in North America SD Lauder brand has a
  18. couple of retail stores in North America um Joe Malone has a handful of stores in
  19. North America but Joe Malone is a British band brand which we acquired a few years ago and they have quite a
  20. number of stores in the UK and their core Authority emanates from their own retail presence in the UK where it had a
  21. really strong cult following and we're trying to graph that into a success in North America as well as other parts of
  22. the world let's talk about looking across the brands are there some objectives that you set across all the
  23. brands that are common or does each brand have its own unique objectives there are common standards that we
  24. expect every brand is going to perform to and those are pretty much Rock Solid we have an expression for our company
  25. which is bringing the best to everyone we touch that means that we are expected to deliver deliver the best service the
  26. best experience the best quality product to the consumer within the mission of your brand I have another expression
  27. which is great Brands great people across the board we are looking to have the very best brands in every single
  28. category in which we compete and the only way we're going to do it is if we have the very best most talented people
  29. leading those Brands and at every level of the company we're spending a great deal of time and effort and resources in
  30. making sure that we're developing the best talent inside of our company identifying them and developing their
  31. skills and abilities so they can be fabulous so help me to try and understand the role of marketing at Este
  32. lader it's got a to it's got to play a dominant role so what do you see the role of marketing within the company
  33. well the marketing def marketing responsibilities and roles as we Define it in our company is the central Nexus
  34. of the decision-making of any brand at any given time the Marketing Executives are responsible for developing the
  35. concepts for new product and branding and positioning work working closely with their product development partners
  36. and their creative Partners in creating new great brand ideas working very closely with the sales organizations in
  37. making this message relevant to the consumer to the trade understanding what makes it successful and maintaining the
  38. mission essentially when I look back at the history and the success of our comp adding one brand and the collective of
  39. our company it's having that intuition and Imagination to know what consumers want and give it to them almost before
  40. she knew she wanted it and that's a messaging and a marketing position is that creating that demand or is it
  41. recognizing what that demand is I had to stop you in that almost before she knew
  42. that she wanted it it's that you understand what it is that she wants or are you creating what it is that she
  43. wants I think it's both she may want it but she may not may not have been able to articulate it in
  44. such a way that someone says okay yes I know what you want I'll give it to you as much as to say can I imagine what she
  45. want wants where she wants to go or create something new where she says aha that's what I want I love it let me go
  46. there you it's sort of a chicken and egg thing you can't say she didn't know she
  47. wanted it well she knew she wanted it she just couldn't articulate it in away but when she saw it she knew she'd like
  48. it you said something about the role of marketing within the company if I brought the CFO in here and asked him or
  49. her I don't even know if it's a him or her would I get the same answer from the CFO I would imagine you would get the
  50. same answer from the CFO that marketing and the decision- making around the marketing organization is Central to the
  51. success of our company I believe that's a core principle that everybody has the vast majority of our leadership in our
  52. company has grown up in the sales and marketing organization and if you've grown up in the sales side of the
  53. organization you've got a very intimate working knowledge of the marketing organization if you've grown up on the
  54. marketing side of the organization you have a very intimate knowledge of the sales side and a good business leader
  55. has a CO understanding of the total business but with a strength and expertise in one area which they can
  56. bring and complement their skill sets with experts in other areas then with this understanding of marketing at the
  57. SD luders company um let me understand the budgeting side so I went from the CFO
  58. talking about the CFO to thinking about putting together the budget each brand has a budget how does the each brand
  59. come up with their budget well you know it's interesting you say that because we're in the very last throws of putting
  60. together our budgets for the next fiscal year and the process often times is sausage making at its ugliest but it
  61. starts with we give the brands Targets in certain key metrics and we give them targets based on how we would roll up
  62. the performance of the total company look at our commitment over a three to five year cycle and say we need to be
  63. here as a company here are the performance metrics of each of the brands that we've seen historically and
  64. we go back to the brand and say this is the Target we have for you for sales growth this is the target we have for
  65. you for cost of goods Improvement this is the target we have for you in operating expenses I'm going to write
  66. these down sales growth uh now sales growth is a function if you will we have a key core metric
  67. we've committed to delivering to our shareholders improve performance and return on invested capital and EPS
  68. growth those are the two key core Financial metrics which we promise to deliver to our shareholders from that we
  69. build operating budgets that look to sales growth on the top line operating expense
  70. improvements and cost of goods improvements those are the three key metrics that will
  71. drive operating income the brand managers have certain leeway in certain areas they do not have
  72. leeway in quality control they must deliver the highest quality product period end of story and none of us
  73. unfortunately have much say in taxes we try to manage our tax tax exposures as best we can but the fact of the matter
  74. is is that's not a brand management decision that's a corporate decision and how we work out our corporate exposures
  75. to taxes around the world we also do not demand from our brand managers to be victims of or beneficiaries of uh swings
  76. in currency they manage their businesses on a current constant currency basis and
  77. we as a company will manage currency globally to the best interest of the company how do you set those sales goals
  78. history and ambition and reality and the negotiation Is that real is history ambition and reality is somewhere in
  79. between and is that fairly uniform across brands or does each brand have its own particular each brand has its
  80. own particular sales goals based on its historical Trend if you have a grow brand growing at 20% and they come in
  81. and say I'm going to grow five next year we tell them to go away and come back with a realistic Trend if you have a br
  82. growing at 5% and they come in and say I'm going to deliver 20 we want to know why and we want to
  83. know what the investment is behind it and what is the certainty of delivering the top line for the certainty of the
  84. spend let's say you have a brand and their goal for next year is to grow by 10% take me through the steps of how
  85. does that translate into a budget brand has a 10% sales growth goal we would look to them to have at a 20
  86. basis point Improvement in cost of goods we would look to them to grow their operating expense at 6% no more than 6%
  87. so that there would be an increase in their margin so both driven by cost of goods and operating expense and if the
  88. net math of that is is if they're growing their sales at 10% and their operating expense at 6% we've got a
  89. 4% Improvement in operating income that budgeting process is a negotiation in both the Top Line how much you're going
  90. to grow it and the bottom line how much you have to spend to fuel the growth when you realize I I look at it across
  91. all of our Brands there's only four lines in our pnl where the brand spends towards the
  92. consumer cost of goods and the quality of the product and the packaging advertising promotion and
  93. selling expense selling expense being how we represent our brand to the consumer at
  94. retail so you as a brand manager have a given cost of General administrative expenses all the salaries and occupancy
  95. expenses associated with it but where you have real input and you can have real levers to manage your business and
  96. those those four lines you only have certain leeway within cost of goods because you've got a historical business
  97. built up with certain product with certain cost of goods how can you improve that how can you add new product
  98. programming with beneficial cost of goods that moves the number meaningfully advertising how much and
  99. where are you advertising what's that Medium what's the voice that's built Market by market by market one of my
  100. favorite examples is commuting media commuting media is those media where you communicate to those consumers who are
  101. commuting to work well in the United States commuting media is predominantly radio and in certain markets it might be
  102. billboard and in a handful of markets where mass transit is a factor it might be some form of mass transit Community
  103. uh me messaging when we go to Japan where 95% of the population that commutes takes public transportation
  104. commuting media is 100% mass transit radio is not relevant and I use those just as examples to say the definition
  105. of commuting media changes Market by market in the world if you go to Korea where you have something like an 80%
  106. online penetration Factor commun communicating with the consumer through online messages which is highly targeted
  107. can be far more effective than in markets where you have a 20% penetration online right so how the brand builds
  108. their spend and an average advertising and Communications message is is Market by market and also brand specific brand
  109. specific Market specific how do you evaluate whether or not this spending ended up being
  110. productive the ultimate Crucible is the success of the brand in the marketplace and I'll give you an example when I
  111. travel to certain markets in the world one of their pitches to us is is they show us their market
  112. share total market and then they look at their share of voice and they we they we
  113. try to look at the Benchmark of share of voice versus market share one of the consistent messages I get back from our
  114. our Our Brands around the world is is that our share of voice is lower than our market share meaning you're more
  115. productive meaning thank you very much they're looking to argue that they want more money and share of voice I'm
  116. looking to say congratulations look at how much more efficient you are than your competition because you're spending
  117. less to get more in this one area and they look at it saying okay fine but why is that
  118. that's because we as a company tend to spend much more money at the consumer at retail the consumer who's already in the
  119. store we'll spend more than our competition they may spend more at the voice in getting her there but we spend
  120. more when she's there and we think we convert that better because of the value of the exposure to the consumer who's
  121. come in is that because of your selling expense it's predominantly selling expense and if you will the the
  122. promotional expense is somewhere in between it's not all branding and imaging what
  123. advertising is it's not all selling expense which goes on in the store it's somewhere in between and it's more of a
  124. call to action to get that consumer into the store and convert the sale when she's there okay so we've covered sort
  125. of your your budgeting process and how you evaluate that what measures do you typically look at uh Beyond of course
  126. you just went through sales cost of goods sold you're looking at the margins I'm trying to think about sort of
  127. interim measures that you might have for example do you measure brand and Brand's
  128. Equity there's no real way to measure brand equity in the way that Robert Parker says this is a 95 point wine the
  129. brand Equity is this it's like trying to grab Mercury but the core of it is is this brand desirable is this brand
  130. strong and are consumers coming back for the brand so we would look at a program
  131. and say what kind of imagery are we building from this is this stimulating attention and interest to the brand and
  132. there are me so many different ways of doing it and one of the things I think I mentioned before
  133. is the conventions the conventional conventions of looking at traditional media and their their ability to drive
  134. consumers have so dramatically changed that the old metrics need to need to change along with them and I don't think
  135. our metrics of measurement have changed as fact quickly as the consumer Has Changed For example when what we found
  136. for our own Brands is that the brands that have not used conventional advertising print radio
  137. television have been growing faster than the brands that were dependent on the more traditional
  138. forms that doesn't mean that the page rate from the magazines hasn't gone up that doesn't mean that the ad rate for
  139. the network television hasn't gone up or maybe it has that maybe not a good example but the fact of the matter is is
  140. that the brands that had grown up on more traditional forms have not had the same growth as the brands that used
  141. Alternative forms but you've got 27 Brands really great strong Brands uh do you know whether or not the brands are
  142. getting stronger or weaker as a brand or are you looking just at the sales of the
  143. brand well the sales of the brand in one way shape or form are one of the key blood pressures of the brand you could
  144. to really take the key vital signs you have to look at sales why do you have to look look at sales the consumer is
  145. voting every single day with her wallet right and if she's voting for The Brand more this year than last year then we
  146. would presume that she we are successful if she's voting less then we presume that we're missing on some Metric so
  147. what about spending that has an impact on a short-term basis versus spending that doesn't immediately result in sales
  148. but has a longer term uh value that's so fabulous question and um let me refer you to some work that we did with the
  149. Clinique brand um in one of the most competitive markets in the world which is Japan for in our industry in Japan
  150. it's probably the single most competitive market for any number of reasons because it's an extraordinarily
  151. sophisticated consumer it's a relatively compact homogeneous Market from both a distribution standpoint and a cultural
  152. and psychographic standpoint so the result is is that the program in and measuring measurements you can put into
  153. this brand with a limited number of doors and the very high productivity you see the results fairly quickly positive
  154. or negative with an extraordinarily sophisticated and demanding consumer the Clinique brand was the first and most
  155. successful imported non-japanese brand for many many years and the brand went into a period of years of flatness if
  156. not decline in share that came from a number of different factors number one of which was there was a lot more
  157. competition of imported Brands coming in and it had the most share to lose because it had a dominant share but just
  158. as importantly there was some key work that we needed to do in understanding the messaging of the brand that was no
  159. longer as relevant so we took a very deep dive for this brand in Japan and we found was we found was in understanding
  160. the equity of the brand was that over time the principles that had built the brand had come to be perceived as cold
  161. and not connecting with the consumer in the same way so we started doing work to
  162. understand how we can change that and what we did was we started investing four years ago in a more humanizing
  163. messaging element for the brand at all different factors the national advertising image to your point that's a
  164. long-term brand Equity investment the inore investment in the experience the consumer got at store so you're real to
  165. tolerant of you know we're investing right now we're probably not going to meet some of those financial objectives
  166. shortterm but we're building something that longterm is going to help us brands are not made overnight and brands are
  167. not killed overnight except for Extraordinary problems so therefore we have to have a level of patience of
  168. investment and to your one of your questions you asked is about resource allocation there's that traditional BCG
  169. model if you have the dogs the star the cow and whatnot we invest according not according to some strict model but we
  170. will tend to invest both in brands that are grow growing and you have to invest in the growth of the brand and perhaps
  171. not demand the same profit level and the brands that are very highly profitable not growing as much we will demand a
  172. certain level of performance so we can Harvest some of their success and excess return to invest in new brands the fact
  173. of the matter is is that I would attribute over 80% of the sales of our company today to Brands we've created
  174. ourselves almost all of those we were making bets and making Investments long before they pay paid off some of them
  175. unfortunately I'm still waiting for the payoff but we've gotten tremendous return on our investment because of the
  176. Investments we've made in our brand and The Branding we've created and the positioning we've created and one of the
  177. key strategic objectives for our company is to continue to have brands that the consumers want and that the retailers
  178. want and we almost in the balance of power we always have to have more of what the consumer wants so that the
  179. retailer always wants to be our partner and doesn't feel like we're Tapped Out intellectually one last measure I'm
  180. going to ask you about do you measure the value of a customer what I'm referring to is the lifetime value of a
  181. customer if you get a person to become a c customer of Clinique you know what kind of Revenue are you going to be
  182. generating from that customer over their entire lifetime you're talking about one
  183. of the single biggest opportunities we have in the future which is intimate more intimate knowledge of the consumer
  184. now this issue crashes against the principle of the ownership of that consumer and we have been in a
  185. historical arm wrestling match with our key retailers is to who owns that consumer does the retailer own that
  186. consumer do we own that consumer do we share her share that knowledge and how do we do it how much does the retailer
  187. know about her and her buying patterns in our category how much are they willing to share with us so we can come
  188. to understand it more I'd say where we were 10 years ago the retailer said that's my customer all you can you can't
  189. know anything about her today we are a much much closer partnership with our retailers we're both learning more about
  190. our consumer how she shops where she shops why she shops and how we can get learn more about her as they're coming
  191. to realize that assets delivered to the best customers return multiples more than
  192. assets aimed at the consumer who's a lapsed consumer the research we've done shows that there's a six to1 difference
  193. in investment assets invested at a consumer will return you six times that that same
  194. money devoted to a laps not a laps user someone who's never been your customer often times we've been guilty brand by
  195. brand in focusing our efforts at recruitment new consumer and haven't devoted enough to retainment and of that
  196. consumer who's already there and as we shift our resources and knowledge to that more existing consumer I think
  197. we'll get a better more effective use of our but the form in which we communicate
  198. with that loyal consumer is a very different form than we might find in Broad General
  199. advertising this goes back to that media change the the way the consumer shops the brand and understands Brands today
  200. is so different that the traditional forms what's one of the real areas where I'm so concerned about the relevance of
  201. traditional media versus New Media the last area that I'm going to ask you about is about your relationship as C
  202. CEO with the different brand managers how do you interface with them is it at arms length or do you partner with them
  203. since you have the CEO and CMO under one office I try to focus most of my effort
  204. on with the brand managers somewhat on a personal level somewhat on a brand level when I say a
  205. personal level at the end of the day I would say I how do I allocate my time I spend a third of my time on strategic
  206. implications for the company a third of my time on people and a third of my time
  207. on everything else everything else being What's happen happening today what came
  208. across the transom last week what do I see as a big issue that's coming forward and with a brand manager for example I
  209. spent a lot of my time with the brand leadership on key appointments whether it's the key appointment of a new brand
  210. leader when an opportunity comes up key appointments in their marketing area the
  211. product development area or the sales area I let them make decision making on everything else and working with them on
  212. the key challenges they have in front of them where can I add value and my value
  213. add is different brand by brand both based on the relationship I have with the brand manager as well as my own
  214. personal passion and expertise for certain brand for example no surprise I take a great deal of passion about the
  215. leadership and the origins brand since this is a brand that I was intimately involved in its formation and that's
  216. very different say than the passion my father Leonard laer has for the SD Lauder brand which he's been intimately
  217. involved with since the start and that's just an example the other examples would
  218. be what are the challenges we have going forward for a brand and the brand leadership I don't get involved in the
  219. choice of shades of lipstick I leave that up to those who are far more expert than me I talk to the brands about the
  220. key metrics that drive their business what's the brand Equity how are you enhancing the brand Equity one of the
  221. analogies I use is that brand Equity brand imagery is like a road certain roads are country lanes two lanes and
  222. it's very clear to know when you're on the road in your brand or whether something you're doing is off mess
  223. but certain other brilliant are eight Lane highways it's very hard to know when you're on or off the road because
  224. there's such latitude and leeway so a lot of the time I spend with the brand managers is clearly identifying what the
  225. key metrics are in the brand equity and how they continue to need to push it the
  226. open and honest Communications you have with your brand managers the the latitude you give them and the guidance
  227. you provide are all essential traits that you have and are necessary for a great leader to build a wildly
  228. successful company thank you that's all the time that we have here today at measured thoughts but I would like to
  229. thank William for joining us and sharing his insights about the Esters company it's been a great job today so thank you
  230. very much appreciate it I appreciate taking the time

Brief Summary

William Lauder discusses Estee Lauder's growth, marketing strategies, budgeting, and the importance of brand management.

Key points

  • Estee Lauder's Growth Journey. From $800,000 in sales to $7.8 billion, Estee Lauder has grown immensely.
  • The Role of Marketing. Marketing is central to decision-making and brand success at Estee Lauder.
  • The Value of Customer Knowledge. Understanding the lifetime value of a customer is a major opportunity for growth.
  • Retailer Relationships. The historical battle over consumer ownership is evolving into closer partnerships.
  • Investment Focus Shift. Shifting focus from acquiring new customers to retaining existing ones can yield better returns.
  • Brand Equity Metrics. Identifying key metrics in brand equity is crucial for brand managers' success.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes