Is Climate Change Speeding Up?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. We've invited Eran Michelle Kjan who is the executive director of the Wharton Risk Center to speak with us today about
  2. a new study by one of the world's foremost climate scientists Jim Hansen and his 16 co-authors uh most of whom or
  3. all of whom are also leading lights in in the world of climate science. and we're we're asking him to chat today
  4. about uh what this uh striking new study means for planet earth and also for business. Sure. Um well, first of all,
  5. as as we discussed before that hasn't been peer reviewed, which means that we still have to uh see what the community
  6. will will will think about their assumptions. These are models. So there are the assumptions behind the models
  7. but clearly they want to uh uh trigger a big signal uh toward the international communities. I think what what's
  8. interesting to me is that we typically refer to the IPCC as uh almost the benchmarks today. What in reality the
  9. IPCC is a consensus document. So a very large number of scientists agreeing on what number. So we basically will select
  10. the lowest denominator and um and great experience with the IPCC except that yes
  11. we have to make assumptions on thing we don't consider a very different sitting here used to be the chief climate
  12. scientist at NASA most of the co-authors are top people in the field um you know
  13. there are many top people but they are among these groups from the US from Europe from China so that's an
  14. interesting coalition of author right here. I think for many years we thought we had the luxury to believe that well
  15. we're facing a linear threat. So basically next year would be a little bit worse than last year but only on the
  16. margin. And let's be honest about the discussion about climate often pushing the discussion in 2100 not really
  17. telling the people what it means for me tomorrow or for my kids tomorrow. Uh what Enson is do now is well first of
  18. all we don't have much time. They're talking about 2050. So it's literally almost tomorrow. And two, we're not
  19. talking about increase of sea level by a few feet. We're talking about large large number uh 5 10 20
  20. meters. Basically two, three, four, five floor. So it's it's a very I mean if that's true, that's a radical change in
  21. the way we think about the impact of climate change. Now the uh I just want to mention the IPCC is the
  22. intergovernmental panel on climate change. I think they have a big meeting in September and I believe that uh
  23. Hansen has been quoted as saying they wanted to get this study out. The reason they didn't wait for a peer review which
  24. would take months and months is that they wanted to get this out in time for this IPCC meeting uh I believe this is
  25. correct in in September. So just just point that out. Yeah. Yeah. And to their I mean just for people to understand
  26. it's typically peer reviewed before and then published but the way that journal works is the way it works. publish
  27. first, then you invite the entire scientific committee to comment and that becomes peer-reviewed by a large number
  28. of people. So, it's not negative that hasn't been peer-reviewed, right? Uh and there's not an excuse to tell that
  29. they're right or wrong. Um so, that's just to keep and that journal is the atmosphere, chemistry, and physics
  30. discussion journal. So, it is literally a journal for discussion. So, it's different than a peerreview. Okay. Very
  31. good. So uh so potentially a big change, a geometric change rather than a linear
  32. change is what's being talked about here. What does obviously that means that coastal cities like New York City
  33. could be in big trouble. We've heard talk about other so many coastal cities uh if people have to migrate inland and
  34. if it happened very quickly there could create great conflict. So we like to hear a little bit about that. But then
  35. also from the business side, this could change how companies pay for insurance who maybe you can't get insurance.
  36. Nothing immediate of course, but it sounds like if the evidence for this starts to to turn up o over the next
  37. couple years that it's it will be getting taken even more seriously. So yeah. Well, if you take the United State
  38. of our example here, about 40% of our population live in coastal areas. So it's not just New York or Miami. It's
  39. lot number of people affected here. So you can think about a real estate implication. You know your apartment or
  40. your house used to worth $500,000 now no one wants to buy it. So I mean the implication could be massive. uh
  41. insurance companies are obviously looking at these type of analysis very carefully because what is insurable
  42. today may not be insurable tomorrow or if it's still insurable will be insurable at double the price or triple
  43. the price depending on what the risk is. Uh I think the big discovery again is it's that tipping point almost the fact
  44. that uh we may wake up one day it's not one day but we can wake up in 20 2025 2030 and in a matter of two or three
  45. years see rapid sea level and that's what people have been um have been fearing for years because you don't have
  46. the time to adapt. If you have 50 years, 100 years, if you're the the chairman of
  47. the board, you can talk to your board of directors saying, "Well, this is a new environment that our firm will have to
  48. live in in 20 years from now. What do we do about it?" That's fine. If you move for 20 years to next five years, that's
  49. a radically different discussion. And just to be clear um roughly about the science, you can help me with this
  50. please, but my understanding is that there are these huge ice shells on land that move towards the sea and
  51. particularly green land in Antarctica or Antarctica. And that they're melting uh
  52. first of all, maybe they shouldn't be melting at all, but they're not only are they melting, but they're melting at a
  53. rapid pace. That's fresh water going into the ocean. That changes the salinity. It changes the hot and cold
  54. levels of the ocean. Oddly, it can cause the ocean temperature to rise, but then somehow
  55. warmer water can get stuck under the ice in Antarctica, which actually causes it
  56. to melt fast. It's very complicated, but things are really melting even though they make it it may seem like they're
  57. getting colder at first. Yeah. Uh no, I mean it's complicated and that's part of
  58. the difficulty to communicate about it. uh because very clear quickly people get
  59. overwhelmed with the information and the reason it's complicated is that you talking about planet earth um multiple
  60. interrelated systems uh air water soil uh sun feedback loops feedback loops uh but no you describe that pretty well
  61. basically it's like you take a piece of ice and you put it in your glass of water you let it melt nothing happened
  62. your glass stay at the same level now if you take that piece of ice and let it melt on the plate, you see water. And
  63. that's exactly what we're talking about that that ice is actually above sea level, which means that it's additional
  64. water coming in. That's one aspect that the sea level and Antarctica and Greenland has by far the largest uh
  65. resource for ice around the world. So when the ice start melting, you have sea level rise. That's one. Two, you have
  66. less reverberation from the solar system. So basically the planet Earth is going to absorb much more heat than
  67. before. Not as much ice reflecting the exact the light and heat back out into the atmosphere. So that's for the two
  68. part. And then you starting to challenge the oceanan systems in a way that we don't know how they're going to react.
  69. And I think that's the issue here. Uh, and I think that's what they discussed in the paper too, saying, "Well, we know
  70. we don't know for sure, but it's totally plausible that we'll have that um rapid
  71. ice melting." That's what they're referring to. So, we do want to see what happens when when it becomes more
  72. peer-reviewed or when more scientists have a chance to look at the data. But this does seem like a step change uh in
  73. in prediction uh compared with what we've seen in the past from top people. And um is is there a way to sum up what
  74. this study means or how important it is? Sure. Well, I think it's fair to say that other people have predicted that
  75. before. They're not the first one or the only one except that as time passes, we
  76. have more information that's being collected. The technology is more advanced as well. So, we're in a better
  77. position to actually validate certain theories than we were maybe 10 or 15 years ago. And uh and planetars is
  78. already changing. I mean, that's a big thing. We don't have another 200 years to see change. It's already happening as
  79. we speak. So more drought. I mean look at the situation in California. I mean you can take anecdotes here and there.
  80. When you take them all together and start looking at the system, the planet system, planet earth is already starting
  81. to fight back. So um I the question for businesses to me is twofold. One is what
  82. does that mean for my current business model like kind of risk management asset protection. Two is uh on the value
  83. creation side. If that is the world we're going to live in in the next 20 or 30 years, what type of new products, new
  84. services, uh new intellectual property should we develop between now and then to be leading in a world with much more
  85. uh which higher sea level. Um so that's that's an interesting in the history of forecasting or
  86. predictions of climate change. you point out there's there's been many um the IPCC has made many of their so-called
  87. consensus predictions. How have they fared in um over the last 10, 15, 20 years when they predict something? How
  88. accurate has it turned out to be? Because as you say, we have more evidence, better technology for
  89. collecting evidence today. No, that's a great question and the answer is um not the one that as scientists would like to
  90. see but the reality is if you go back at the very beginning of the IPCC and you look at the prediction back then u what
  91. year might that be uh 15 years ago say and you look at what they predicted for 2020. Mhm. Uh in terms of greenhouse gas
  92. emission, in terms of impact on the planet, uh the worst case scenarios are already happening. And I think that's
  93. important for people to realize that we have more data. But we thought I think it's fair to say we the international
  94. community thought we had more time. It will take much longer for planet earth to react.
  95. And what we're discovering year after year is that we don't have much time. Actually, uh, planeters are starting to
  96. react much quicker than we had thought it would. And that new paper should potentially, uh, not only much quicker,
  97. but much more intensely as well. [Music]

Brief Summary

Eran Michelle Kjan discusses Jim Hansen's climate study, highlighting urgent sea level rise and its implications for coastal cities and businesses.

Key points

  • Urgency of Climate Change. Experts discuss the alarming pace of climate change and its immediate implications.
  • Potential for Rapid Sea Level Rise. New study suggests drastic changes in sea levels could occur much sooner than expected.
  • Planet Earth is Reacting. The impacts of climate change are already being felt, with significant consequences for the future.

Tension

65/ 100Some tension

Related episodes