Antitrust Case Lets Google Keep Chrome but Requires Data Sharing With Competitors

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Wharton Professor Herb Hovenkamp unpacks the recent antitrust ruling against Google, which stopped short of a breakup but forces the company to share its massive search index with rivals. He explains why injunctions are more common than breakups in monopoly cases, how low switching costs could shift user behavior if competitors improve, and why AI could be the wild card that finally brings real differentiation to search.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#Google #SearchEngines #TechRegulation #TechPolicy #Antitrust #FutureOfSearch ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. A decision in early September allowed Google to avoid a breakup of some of its most important components, one being its
  2. Chrome browser. It will though have to start sharing search data with its rivals and do away with the exclusivity
  3. agreements it has netted billions of dollars through. to discuss the ruling. We are joined uh right now by Herbert
  4. Hovindamp who is professor of legal studies and business ethics here at the Wharton School. Herb, great to catch up
  5. with you again. How are you, sir? >> Thank you. And good to see you, too. >> Good to see you as well. Um, so the
  6. ruling itself, what was your reaction? >> It was very much in line with what I expected. Uh, contrary to public belief,
  7. breakups in antitrust cases are really not all that common. Only a minority of monopolization cases result in breakups
  8. even when the defendant is condemned. They're you the typical relief is some kind of injunction which either uh
  9. prohibits the defendant from doing certain things or else mandates that it does certain things. So, this was
  10. entirely in line with that. >> What should the consumer take from this ruling? >> Um, I think the most important part of
  11. the ruling is the one you suggested a minute ago. Judge Ma required uh Google to share its search index data. Now,
  12. that's an enormous enormous database, very likely the biggest database in the world of web pages. uh anything that's
  13. ever been crawled by the Google search bot goes into that uh index data. And uh basically Google's going to have to give
  14. a group of qualified rivals, we don't exactly know how many that is, but I'm guessing it could be as many as a half
  15. dozen, uh a copy of that data. And that would kind of in the judges eyes level the playing field give them a chance to
  16. improve their search quality. And uh one of the hopes would be that some of these other search engines would be able
  17. to increase their market shares. For example, Bing, which is owned by Microsoft, a firm of, you know, roughly
  18. equal size to Google, has only about a 4% market share as against Google's 90 plus percent. Duck.go is now less than
  19. 1%. Yahoo is down in the same area. So, so the so the belief is that by sharing the index data, the market shares of
  20. these rivals will come up and we'll get a more even competitive field. So it's an interesting question you you you
  21. bring up right now is the fact that for the most part the consumer is used to using Google and I guess the question
  22. becomes is how much might consumers switch away from Google and go to some of those other platforms that you
  23. mentioned or does the convenience of what people have used despite the you know the component of a potential
  24. monopoly you know does it not have as much impact? It's a good question. Um, two things about
  25. uh consumer behavior. Number one, yes, they get habituated to certain things. Number two, however, switching costs and
  26. search are incredibly low. I mean, you don't have to register. You don't have to give them your life history. You
  27. don't have to give them your credit card. You can go on any search engine you want. The sticky thing which has
  28. been the subject of this litigation has been default search engines where Google
  29. paid boatloads of money to firms to make Google search their default search engine. Even on those devices like
  30. iPhones for example, you can switch defaults but very few people do. So, uh, the judge in this case really did not
  31. give, uh, did not give the rivals any major, uh, thing to pressure consumers to switch other than improvements in the
  32. quality of competitors. They will be free to switch if they want to. Uh, but, you know, there's no real stick that
  33. fortes forces consumers to switch. So, we're in a time where artificial intelligence is starting to have a
  34. greater impact. Uh, and one of the suggestions brought up in some of the articles is just how technological
  35. advancements like AI and what we may see uh in the future could potentially impact this idea, this whole world of
  36. search. This whole case was tried with very little reference to AI and that trial
  37. was you know about a year and a half ago now. Uh so these AI developments have been very recent. The judge is clearly
  38. uh blown away by them. Half of this opinion is about the impact of AI. But the problem is there were no findings
  39. about AI in the trial record. And right now you know the market is up for grabs.
  40. I don't think anybody can say categorically uh who's going to win or whether there
  41. will be a winner in AI. One of the things AI permits is very much more product differentiation and search. That
  42. has always been a problem with search is it's not sufficiently differentiated. So
  43. you know in social network sites where you've got lots of different platforms, we've got fairly robust compet
  44. competition. Uh but search has not been able to achieve that. So the you know the real uh the real loose cannon in
  45. this uh in this situation is what's going to happen to AI and will AI permit firms to differentiate their offerings
  46. and establish themselves a little more strongly so that you know maybe four or five years from now we see a market that
  47. looks a little bit more like say the social networking market where you've got several substantial firms and viable
  48. choic faces among them. >> But realistically, we're still a ways down the road from a time, and you kind
  49. of just alluded to this, where Google loses its dominant position because the others positions were so small that they
  50. are going to need to have time to build up. >> We're certainly talking about years
  51. rather than months, but it could happen. Uh, one thing about digital content is consumers can switch quickly if they
  52. want to. Uh it's not like a house or something where you have to go through a major event in order to get rid of it.
  53. They can switch quickly and then the only question is whether they will. >> Herb, great to catch up with you and get
  54. your thoughts. Thank you very much. >> Thank you. Herbert Hovamp who is a professor of legal studies and business
  55. ethics here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Google must share search data with rivals, impacting competition and AI's role in search engines.

Key points

  • Google Avoids Breakup. A recent ruling allows Google to avoid breaking up its key components but requires data sharing.
  • Impact of AI on Search. The ruling raises questions about how AI will affect search engine competition in the future.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes