Why U.S. Healthcare Stays Expensive

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Mark Pauly explains that healthcare stays costly because incentives reward richer insurance plans and create little pressure for lower prices or higher-value care. Prepaid HSAs add cost awareness but rarely replace the need for full insurance, so overall spending patterns stay similar.

He points out that premiums are rising as delayed post-COVID costs surface. Employer tax breaks push higher earners toward generous plans while offering limited benefit to lower-income workers, widening affordability gaps. Attempts at value-based payment have not produced reliable savings, leaving core cost drivers unchanged.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#healthcarecosts #healthcarepolicy #healthinsurance #UShealthcare #healthcaredebate ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Seemingly the main topic of discussion right now is how to fix health care and make it more affordable and accessible
  2. to the general public. Part of that discussion is about the ACA tax credits. And now a new proposal is coming forward
  3. from Senator Bill Cassidy for a different option using prepaid health savings accounts instead of the credits.
  4. Mark Paulie is professor ameritus of healthcare management here at the Wharton School and he joins me to
  5. discuss this topic. Mark, great to catch up with you again. How are you, sir? I'm fine, Dan. Thanks.
  6. >> Thank you. Obviously, this is a huge topic and realistically healthc care has
  7. been a topic for quite a while. Uh, but with what we see going on right now, and
  8. I'll get into Senator Cass Cassy's proposal in a second. Are are you confident that maybe we're starting to
  9. think like we need to tackle the issue of of what's going on with healthcare? Well, tackle, I guess, fix is a bit is a
  10. bit more of a reach. It's easy to try um because health care is intrinsically expensive. It's hard to produce a
  11. solution that um satisfies all the stakeholders. >> What were your thoughts on Senator
  12. Cassid's idea? >> Well, he's trying to repurpose an old Republican idea of health savings
  13. account. And the intuition in favor of it is uh well, we're going to create this account with dollars in it, but
  14. it's funny money. So the dollars can only be spent on health care. So that they like, but the idea is that provides
  15. you with an incentive then to economize on your use of health care yourself or economize on the health insurance
  16. premium plan you choose because if you use money from your account for one thing, you don't have it left for
  17. another thing. So it provides not a high power incentive but at least an incentive to be for individuals to be
  18. more economical in their use of health care services. So that's the logic of it. Of course the the details matter and
  19. particularly what matters is how much money and to whom uh which is really what is much more important to a person
  20. than uh than this uh uh rather um limited incentive. Well, and and I think one of the questions in, you know, in
  21. regards to counteracting that idea, uh, is if you're providing these HSA accounts, these people still need to be
  22. able to get insurance. And the question is, would they be able to get insurance in the first place?
  23. >> Yeah. The political backstory here is insurers are ripping off the public. And
  24. of course, you never can go broke by attacking insurers. Uh so uh and uh the instead of uh doing what what the
  25. Obamacare does which is when you choose your plan your your subsidy if you're eligible for subsidy and most people are
  26. goes straight to the insurer. Instead the subsidy comes to you. But your comment is quite right. If you then turn
  27. around and say well I'm going to need insurance. Uh, and most people would say that because they don't want to be
  28. exposed to the risk of financial disaster if they got really sick. You're going to pay money to the insurance
  29. companies anyway. So, they'll get you coming and they'll get you going. Uh, one way or another, uh, the only um
  30. advice you would offer to a person is, well, be careful what insurance you buy and try to find one that doesn't um,
  31. charge you excessive amounts for what you're expected to get. So, is there a direct link to what's being discussed
  32. right now of what we've seen play out with the Affordable Care Act and the higher costs and the higher prices of
  33. healthcare in general over the last few years? Well, there's a political link which is that uh we we are seeing in 24
  34. and 25 an upward blip in health insurance premiums. My diagnosis is it's a delayed response to the end of COVID,
  35. but nobody knows for sure the reason. And that's made people uh look for a solution. Uh uh obviously the solution
  36. in the Biden plan, which just um was what the Democrats were holding out for but they didn't get, was to provide more
  37. money to pay for the extra cost. Republicans don't want to do that. They want to economize. And so the idea is to
  38. convert uh at least some fraction of what would have been the Biden subsidies to health insurance plans to payments
  39. directly to individuals for these accounts. But as I said, uh we would expect that the great majority of people
  40. would then turn around and uh use most of that money for health insurance anyway. So the insurers aren't going to
  41. be crying crocodile tears over this development. I know you and I have talked for many years about health care
  42. in general. Let me put you in the big chair for a couple of moments and think about what moves can be made as we move
  43. forward here to improve healthcare in general because seemingly that's that's going to be the biggest talking point
  44. for it feels like quite a while into the future. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. Well, from an economic point of
  45. view, I'm a card carrying member of Health Economists Associated and we always pick on the subsidy to employer
  46. provided health insurance. So, when I was still working at Forton, I figured about $15,000 a year was what
  47. um Pennaid toward my health insurance and I didn't have to pay taxes on that. So, and that pro probably did and did
  48. make me choose the most generous plan. Uh, because after all, uh, Penn was paying for it. Um, although we
  49. economists think sooner or later you're paying for it yourself out of your wages. But at least you get this tax
  50. break. The Treasury was helping me as a upper middle income Wharton tenure professor to afford health insurance.
  51. And of course, it's a crazy subsidy because for my assistant or for a lower income person, uh the subsidy isn't
  52. nearly as great because they don't have as high a marginal tax rate. So that's what we would think of as but that
  53. doesn't have political uh uh political uh appeal. Uh the other of re rearranging the health care system.
  54. Well, a lot of people have tried and so far uh you know, they come up with with nothing, but they keep trying to change
  55. the way they pay providers of health care to try to get them to either offer lower prices andor recommend the most, I
  56. would say, cost-effective services as opposed to services that are of relatively low value. But so far, uh
  57. nobody's come up with a with a magic formula for that. And it and and it feels like that that we're going to
  58. continue to kind of ride down that road for for the foreseeable future. >> Yeah. Um I mean it's not it's the sky is
  59. not falling. The fraction of GDP going into health care in 2023 was essentially the same as what it was in 2009.
  60. Healthc care spending wasn't running ahead of people's ability to pay for it. Although because income is unevenly
  61. distributed, the people who didn't get that bump in GDP translated into their income were the ones who are complaining
  62. about it's getting less and less affordable. >> Right, Mark? Great to talk to you on
  63. this. Thank you and uh have a great day. Thank you, sir. >> All right, you too. Thanks. Bye.
  64. >> Thank you. Mark Paulie, professor ameritus in healthcare management here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Mark Paulie discusses healthcare affordability and Senator Cassidy's prepaid health savings account proposal.

Key points

  • Senator Cassidy's Proposal. A new option using prepaid health savings accounts instead of ACA tax credits is proposed.
  • The Challenge of Health Care Costs. Mark Paulie explains the difficulty in creating a solution that satisfies all stakeholders.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes