The Evolving Crisis in Ukraine

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Events in Ukraine are moving swiftly these days, with Crimea's vote to secede followed by evolving reactions from Russia, the U.S. and Europe. Sophia Opatska, CEO of Lviv Business School in Ukraine, discusses what led to the current crisis and what lies ahead for a country now divided.

Read the full story: http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/evolving-crisis-ukraine/ 📂 Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're here today with sfia oasa CEO of Lviv business school in Ukraine Sophia yesterday 97% of the voters in Crimea
  2. decided they wanted to secede from Ukraine and be annexed by Russia what do you make of
  3. this well um I don't think that people in the world believe that that was 97% because if you have uh elections and
  4. the conditions which and pressure uh which was happening yesterday in Crimea and which is happening already for two
  5. weeks in Crimea I don't think that this is like real world um of people and that
  6. um that uh people in Crimea uh even many of those who would think that um it's going to be better with Russia that they
  7. are aware of all the facts that they aware of all the situation and um that they that they take conscious decision
  8. right now what do you think Russian President Vladimir Putin Putin has on his agenda
  9. he's going to talk to I think both houses of Parliament tomorrow what is he going to tell
  10. them well what you know there might be difference between what he's going to tell and what's on his agenda so um I
  11. don't know what he's going to tell but um speaking about agenda I think that um he did not really like what was
  12. happening in Ukraine over last months um I think the uh plan was to have um some kind of um um some kind of
  13. unity between couple of countries like Russia Kazakhstan Belarus and Ukraine economically but also I think that was
  14. very much about political influence uh because um that was something uh related to
  15. dictatorship and not real democra y that was something um uh related with um absence of free media and um um of
  16. violating human rights um so so the whole the whole protest which took place in Ukraine that was really against those
  17. things but also against corruption which I think all of us are aware um take place not only in Ukraine but Tes takes
  18. place in Russia um maybe in a little bit different woran but but it still happens
  19. there um so I think he does not really like what happened in Ukraine and this is um his opportunity to take care that
  20. those processes do not happen in Russia so what do you think the decision uh after the referendum will mean for
  21. Ukraine going forward well I think Ukraine in no matter what happens with Crimea needs to
  22. do very important important economic reforms and reforms overall reforms in in um um uh rule of law uh reforms
  23. economic reform administrative reforms if we I mean we were not really doing them for 23 years and um one of the
  24. reasons why people in Crimea would like to go with Russia because they they did not find economic um wealth in Ukraine
  25. and they they look for uh different opportunity so if if economically Ukraine would be doing differently I
  26. don't think that would be an issue at all um so no matter what happens with Crimea I think um it's very difficult
  27. it's very difficult for many people emotionally you know keep doing work and focusing on reforms but this is
  28. definitely what we need to do in short term because when of of opportunity for Ukraine is very short right now and we
  29. have to take this uh moment but what do you think that the the new government in
  30. Kiev ought to do in response to Putin's actions um well it's very important that
  31. we do not allow the same things in in other Eastern oblas regions in Ukraine um there are some tries
  32. to um with with people brought from Russia you know waving Russian flag and uh to destabilize situation and I think
  33. that's very important right now to have the situation stable in the country um we are still I think we as a
  34. count still look for some diplomatic Solutions and in that sense I think um I think our new government did a great job
  35. you know uh working with other International peers um and yes Beyond the politics what are the
  36. economic advantages of Ukraine aligning with Europe as opposed to Russia uh well there were a lot of
  37. discussions you know what Ukraine will gain with Europe what Ukraine will lose with Europe well maybe for some um uh
  38. for some Industries it's not very very well to go with Europe and um I think the major issue for ukrainians is that
  39. going with Europe should create a different system of management in the country it was for us I think uh it was
  40. uh one of the main reasons how we can get how we can become more transparent country how the rule of law can start
  41. working um so that people don't have to go to the court and bribe for the for the decision of the Court um which means
  42. that other counterpart knows from the very beginning that if you don't bribe you don't get the decision we need to
  43. get rid rid of those issues and for us um we have a lot of questions towards Europe as well I mean it's not that we
  44. support the way of life 100% you know we have some differences in values and in some sense we um we are um we would like
  45. to go with some things like we do in Ukraine but still uh the most important is how the
  46. system is is running the country and and that was the most important thing and again you know know I I I understand
  47. that some industri might lose but I'm sure that those are not knowledge-based Industries those are most probably last
  48. century or last two centuries Industries which we need to to reform in any way and this can be also a good uh reason I
  49. know it's going to be tough I know it's not going to be easy and in short term we might lose but the question is would
  50. you like to win in short term or in long term so in Moscow today according to press reports these sanctions that the
  51. US government did impose today were met basically with derision and mockery in fact the Russian stock market I think
  52. went up assuming that everyone both sides want a diplomatic resolution no one's interested in a military one what
  53. types of sanctions could the US and EU impose that would be effective but not drive drive both sides into into a
  54. deeper disagreement uh well I think you have posted the question very in in very
  55. right way that assuming two sides would like a diplomatic resolution well unfortunately we don't really see that
  56. the other side would like to have this diplomatic resolution even moreover I think that um there is even more and
  57. more pressure um how not to resolve it diplomatically but if I were to answer the question how this can how the
  58. situation can be influenced you know from outside of the world um outside of Ukraine world
  59. um um I think that has to do something with energy issues um well Russia is uh selling oil selling
  60. gas and definitely it's one of the major uh sources of income in the country to the to the country so I think if um
  61. there was a way somehow to influence that would be the way to do it for the energy sector most probably what's what
  62. do you think is going to happen to the minorities in Crimea the the people who did not want to join rejoin Russia well
  63. thank you very much for this question because unfortunately uh very often this question is not asked about other
  64. minorities which are not Russian minority in Crimea um in reality well Russian Russians have the majority uh
  65. about 50% of of the population in Crimea are Russians but they were not ethnically settled there ethnically were
  66. Crimean tatars uh who make about 20% and uh they were deported by Stalin and then 23 years ago when Ukraine
  67. gained independence um they had they got the chance to come back to Crimea there are
  68. also ukrainians there who make also about 20% and then there are about 10% of other ethnical groups Greeks
  69. Armenians uh Georgians so very very huge mixture um what will happen to them neither tatars nor ukrainians uh nor
  70. many other minorities who live in Crimea accept the results of the referendum and
  71. the whole situation itself uh so unfortunately we will have very many refugees uh in my opinion Crimea will become
  72. nothing will be happening there so it will be it might be kind of Silent War which can last for very long time like
  73. it happens in Pria or it happens in uh abazia or North Atia um which means there is kind of no
  74. war there but nothing H happens no tourists no in no development of infrastructure just you know
  75. Frozen um the way it is um so so most probably a lot of refugees will move to to Ukraine to to
  76. Mainland Ukraine if we can say that way uh I know that Western Ukraine already gets a lot of refugees uh especially
  77. from Crimean tataris um there were a lot of pictures already uh quite uh from Crimea which
  78. are quite offensive to creman tatars and um I think that in reality one of the major reasons why Ukraine is so uh
  79. focusing on the situation in Crimea and tries to keep Crimea um with with the whole Ukraine sovereignity is also
  80. because not only ukrainians but uh Crimean tatars who don't have other land to live could you explain a little bit
  81. what the impact of the agitation in Ukraine has been on the Lviv Business School uh
  82. and and how how how has it affected you and what do you think is going to happen
  83. going forward of the situation how it influenced the school uh well it well our University it
  84. it was always I I should talk not only for the school but for the University overall Ukrainian Catholic University we
  85. always have been in very proest Western position in the education as well so for
  86. this reason we had quite a lot of um uh difficulties with former minister of Education who was very Pro Russian and
  87. uh who was putting a lot of pressure on our institution and he was trying to control as much as possible
  88. universities um in what sort of ways was that control exercised well well for example we are we're
  89. completely private institution and we don't get the penny from the state but in a way still we get a lot of um uh
  90. rules a lot of uh um from Ministry of Education uh they provide accreditation for example it's not um it's not the um
  91. independent body or Association providing accreditation to the universities but it is Ministry of
  92. Education so you have to go for license there you have to go for accreditation you have to um the books have to be
  93. under um the signature of Ministry of Education so there are a lot a lot there was a lot of controlled things uh plus
  94. there was a huge corruption in the Ministry of Education for example all institutions had to put down some um uh
  95. some database system and they had to buy it from some relative of minister of Education company so so the whole system
  96. is is very is very corrupt and very uh interdependent and our institution was always honestly saying that we believe
  97. that this should be according this International standards this should be according to these best practices in
  98. Western countries um and of course this was not liked very much um so uh from the very very first day for students and
  99. for the faculty body it was not the choice what we should do um I think a lot of things were run by students a lot
  100. of initiatives were run by students and um Administration and um faculty members
  101. were always supportive uh a lot of people as individuals participated in the protest um well um yes we had
  102. somehow to to to change the way we are working you know sometimes uh we are doing right now some social things which
  103. are not directly related to our work uh but at the same time I think one of still important rool which we have right
  104. now is to build the community I think the university and the Business School itself has very high level of trust from
  105. business community and from Community overall and it's not only about leiv it's about cave as well um it was always
  106. very transparent institution and um this level of trust which we have um it it um
  107. you know we we could see it in in very different initiativ which we started and how they were supported and people very
  108. often right now they they like to come for our events though that the time is not uh easy but they like to come and to
  109. see how other people think what they think to discuss to you know just to be together what is the outlook for uh us
  110. and European companies who do business in Ukraine or or want to do business in Ukraine what what can they look forward
  111. to in the next year year uh well last years were quite difficult we did not really were getting
  112. investments in Ukraine um for the same reasons you cannot plan longterm you cannot um uh you have to deal with uh a
  113. lot of bureaucratic issues so one of the um very important reforms which we need
  114. to do is deregulate we need to create environment for Innovations entrepreneurship
  115. and uh this is one of the first initiatives which our Min uh Ministry of Economics is right now focusing on um
  116. also from our business school a lot of alumni are involved in the regional projects of D regulation so that
  117. business people are telling from business side how this reform should be done in a way that they can run business
  118. in a transparent way but at the same time that it's not controlled completely um by um government um in a way
  119. International companies were in better situation because many Ukrainian companies that they had additional
  120. challenge um they did not have very good environment for doing business but at the same time if you were doing business
  121. it could have been taken away um just you you know companies were offered amount of money and either you sell for
  122. this amount of money which is half of the price of the company or you lose it so there was a lot of pressure on
  123. Ukrainian companies as well so 3 months ago could you ever have anticipated where you would be and and
  124. how far you would have come and is the euphoria that you all must have felt several weeks ago month ago is that
  125. sustainable is that still there is there still a sense that things will move forward and get
  126. better if you would ask me in October is it possible that people in this country after not
  127. fulfilled expectations of orange Revolution would be able to get out of the streets I would not believe you I
  128. mean I I would say no definitely no everybody were you know I would say had enough of the what is going on in the
  129. country but I don't think people really believed but what happened is that in 23
  130. years there was um no situation that then people were injured or or killed you know so be there was everything in a
  131. peaceful manner done in Ukraine um and and that was a huge shift for many people that that such things
  132. could happen in the country and um I I would never say that it would you know it comes sometimes we think okay we
  133. cannot it cannot be more than that but then there is another month and and it's more more than
  134. that um about aphia I don't think we had aphia this time I mean we were happy that um we were happy that it's almost
  135. ended though now we see that it did not end but um because so many people were lost because so many people died and
  136. those people were just amongst us you know it's it's it was it was very difficult emotionally
  137. and we still live through this and day after day and because of that I think right now we cannot give up we just
  138. cannot give up we every time we remember how many people lost their lives and we
  139. think was it worth doing that so what we have to be different you know um I think
  140. one thing which every Ukrainian should promise to to himself to his it cannot be the way how it was for months ago and
  141. I I have to do whatever I can do at my place it's my obligation it's not obligation or responsibility of the
  142. president of the country it's not responsibility of prime minister or the cabinet of ministers it's responsibility
  143. of every single Ukrainian or citizen of Ukraine to do something to change this country otherwise it was not worth that
  144. maybe one last thing uh what based on the experience of the past few months what lessons in leadership do you think
  145. you have have learned that you have may not have learned before it's very interesting uh because
  146. um during last three four months you know people people were always looking for some
  147. leader but maybe because our opposition leaders were a little bit undecisive we saw other way of
  148. leadership um this we saw this um opportunity and this possibility when every person can take a leading role so
  149. due to that due to self organization so many new interesting initiatives evolved
  150. and people were supporting them and uh people were engaging in different initiatives and right now it's still
  151. continues because we uh again we realize that it's not anymore a job only of the
  152. government you know people people take the initiative um just to give you an example you know right now we need to
  153. have a lot of new faces in in the in the public service in public administration
  154. we realized that we need a lot of new young people going there and changing the system so we as a school got a
  155. request you have to start some programs in public administration something we have not been thinking about a month ago
  156. and right now you know when we say that we would like to start a free month modular program in one month you know it
  157. looks a little bit unrealistic but at the same time if not us then who that it we just we have to to we have to respond
  158. to the need and I think that's what people learn learn to do and that's Al that's one of the way of
  159. leadership I think another another understanding of leadership is that um it's it's about leadership but it's it's
  160. about all as human beings I think that's something what we really as ukrainians started to realize I mean we started to
  161. communicate before all these events people were living in their small silos you know business people communicating
  162. with business people church with church NOS with NOS um you know according to Social
  163. statuses all those um Silas were maybe meeting but not talking too much and and still people were perceived very much by
  164. social position or or their professional position I think what happened at maidan
  165. people you did not really know who was there and there were very rich people there people who are on on on retire
  166. retired already uh people who have their companies or who don't have their companies who do different professions
  167. and you did not really care who they are you were just grateful that they are support all of that that you have same
  168. values and people were talking to each other about important things um no matter which social or professional
  169. status you have so we we we started to notice each other as human beings first of all not not according to um regali
  170. which we have and I think that's I think that's the major shift in in our society
  171. as Society great well thank you so much for joining us we'll look forward to to following what happens thank you very
  172. much and thanks a lot I hope it will go positive way thank you thank you [Music]

Brief Summary

Sophia Oasa discusses Crimea's referendum, Ukraine's reforms, and leadership lessons from recent protests.

Key points

  • Crimea's Referendum Results. 97% of voters in Crimea chose to secede from Ukraine, raising global skepticism.
  • Ukraine's Economic Reforms. Ukraine must implement crucial economic reforms regardless of Crimea's fate.
  • Leadership Lessons from Ukraine. The recent turmoil has shifted perceptions of leadership, emphasizing individual initiative.

Tension

65/ 100Some tension

Related episodes