Why Incomplete Products Increase Consumption

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

If a product is seen as 'incomplete' -- half a sandwich, say -- people consume more of it. Wharton's Barbara Kahn explains the lessons that can be drawn from this for branded consumer goods.

Read the full story: http://knlg.net/PUJEZ2 📂 Marketing 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. our guest today is barbara khan professor of marketing at wharton and director of the jh baker retailing
  2. center she is also chair of the high velocity growth summit a conference on the retail and consumer
  3. package goods industries that knowledge at wharton is organizing in collaboration
  4. with the bakery tailing center on april 28th and 29th barbara welcome thank you for
  5. joining us happy to be here so we are here to talk about your research and and one of the papers that
  6. you have written recently uh in collaboration with your colleague julio cervia is about the notions of a
  7. product's completeness and how they affect perceptions preferences and even purchase decisions
  8. of buyers uh what was the question you were trying to investigate in this research
  9. well one of the things that we know is that way people decide what to buy and what to eat and how much to eat is not
  10. necessarily based on objective measures but it's based more on their perceptions of how
  11. things work look etc and one of the big findings in the literature before we did our study
  12. was that product shape and size package shape and size affects how much people consume
  13. so there's been previous work that shows that holding the size of the of a product the same but changing its
  14. shape can influence how much people eat and we were interested in how whether or not you think the unit is
  15. complete versus an incomplete shape whether or not that affects how much you eat
  16. um so so just to make sure i got it right if i were to take a bag of cashews and i would eat a
  17. lot of the broken cashews at the bottom of the bag would i be right to be not feel guilty regardless of how much i
  18. consume because i think i haven't eaten the whole unit right yeah so that's the idea so
  19. whenever you eat a whole thing you think like you're the the process underlying is when it's
  20. a whole thing you feel like you're eating more um even if the amount is the same as a broken
  21. piece so if you ate a whole pretzel you'd be aware that you ate a whole pretzel whereas you ate a whole bunch of
  22. pieces you're not aware of how much quantity you're eating one of the things i found fascinating in
  23. your research is how do you exactly decide whether a product is complete or not well that is the interesting thing and
  24. we do show that you can manipulate what the expectation is and change people's behavior so for
  25. example we did a study in in this research where we had rolls or we had cheese and and the roll was incomplete because
  26. there was a hole in it and the cheese was incomplete because there were holes in the cheese
  27. and so it wasn't a solid piece of bread or a solid piece of cheese when we just called it a roll or
  28. cheese then people thought the ones with the hole in it were less complete and they did what i said they tended to
  29. consume more of the holy bread on the other hand if we set the expectation that it was a bagel or that
  30. it was swiss cheese and then their thought a whole bagel has a hole in it that reversed the findings how did you
  31. go about conducting your research well we did a lot of the research online with you know assume
  32. if this was what it looked like you know how much do you think you'd eat how much do you think you pay for it but
  33. we did run what i thought was really interesting and help validate the research we ran a field study
  34. and in that field study we did it we did it down in miami and it was for a class
  35. of people who were going for a health mba course and interestingly they were physicians and health
  36. professionals so they were senior sophisticated people who understand health and we had a condition where we had two
  37. classes and they either ate lunch in class room a or classroom b and what they had for lunch were
  38. sandwiches that were either cut in half or they were whole now we held constant in each one of these the amount of bread
  39. the amount of meat the amount of everything and and we also just counted how many sandwiches they ended up eating
  40. we were careful so that a normal portion size would be more than one because there's also some kind of bias
  41. called the unitary bias where you might just take one of something so these were small sandwiches
  42. and so people would naturally take more than one and what we found is when we held
  43. everything constant but we cut the sandwich in half versus the sandwich was a whole people
  44. ate more sandwiches when they were cut in half and mind you these were doctors and health professionals that were
  45. liable to fall for this bias as well interesting and what would you say were some of the
  46. main takeaways of your research the main takeaway i mean there's public policy takeaways and then there's
  47. marketing takeaways basically we add to this growing literature and there are others who
  48. found these kinds of things another big finding that people found is primary dimension and and that's um
  49. what people do is they focus on the primary dimension of the product and they do insufficient adjustment for
  50. the secondary dimension so if something has a long primary dimension and a small secondary
  51. dimension but it's the same size as something that had a little bit smaller primary
  52. dimension and a bigger secondary dimension so they were holding these things constant
  53. they overweight the primary dimension so that's similar to ours where they overweight the completeness
  54. and basically what it shows is that people are not normative decision makers they don't eat what they think they eat
  55. need to eat to feel full they eat what they perceive is the right amount and they use these implicit
  56. rules for deciding how much to eat so it suggests that people these things can um backfire
  57. boomerang we call it so for example there's other research not mine but it's related where they
  58. show sometimes if people eat in a hundred calorie pack or something like that they can end up eating more because
  59. their perceptions of how much they ate or something is based on the package or the shape of the product not how full
  60. they feel got it now based on what you said so far i guess the food industry in the beverage
  61. industry is is probably uh uh the most interested or or most uh would be most affected by the findings of your
  62. research are there any other industries that that also would uh where consumer preference would
  63. be affected by portions of completeness it's hard for me to think offhand but theoretically certainly it should be
  64. what's what we find is it affects choice and more importantly probably is that it affects consumption and what
  65. the difference is is choice tends to be a more mindful we call system two thinking kind
  66. of decision whereas consumption is more of a mindless kind of decision and so these things that are subtle and
  67. perception changes tend to affect the consumption decision and that tends to be more true in food
  68. you know a lot like when you buy clothing you know it's more of a conscious decision what
  69. you're buying um but it's anything that has some kind of mindless consumption pattern
  70. you'd find that these things would hold let's now to some of turn to some of your other research in
  71. other areas uh you you were just telling me about uh a new research uh paper you have done on uh on on
  72. online and offline uh uh perceptions uh could you explain a little bit about what was the
  73. issue you were trying to uh investigate there yeah so what we're we're what i'm generally interested in
  74. is this there's kind of a cottage industry of research that looks at this is well now we have online assortments
  75. and it's true also in category killers and offline we can have a lot of variety and there's
  76. a lot of research that's shown that there's such a thing as too much variety if you go into an assortment and there's
  77. so much going on there that you can't take it all in some research will show that people will
  78. choose not to choose because they're just overwhelmed by all the choices and so what i'm interested in is how i
  79. think choice is good though i think that what differentiates some retailers online and offline is to offer a wide
  80. variety of choices so what i'm interested in is how can we get consumers to pay attention
  81. to the variety so that it's not overwhelming and they can take it in and i've done several studies along that
  82. and the metric that i'm really interested or the measure that i'm really interested in is attention
  83. and we can now measure that because of eye tracking we have eye tracking we have an eye
  84. tracking lab here at wharton where we can put people in front of computers and see exactly what they're looking at
  85. we can also give people goggles and have them walk up and down a a real store and see what they're
  86. looking at so we can see how we can make changes on the shelf and how that affects their attention
  87. patterns similarly if you're buying online i can you know put the storefront or whatever on a computer
  88. and i can see how you're scanning that computer screen so some of the things that i've done one
  89. of the things i did and when we do experiments what i want to do is hold everything constant
  90. so i can say i know for sure this is what happened and so one of the things that we looked
  91. at is how do people pay attention differentially to an assortment if it's depicted
  92. visually or if it's depicted by words holding everything constant so that makes it a
  93. little less realistic but i can then make these generalizations and what were some of your main findings here
  94. so with the visual what we found is if i gave people a choice would you like to see the assortment
  95. shown visually or described by words overwhelming majority would prefer it visually and we tried all sorts of ways
  96. to try to get them not to prefer visual because i wanted to find a boundary condition
  97. so like you'd assume for something that's a very aesthetic category visual of course you'd rather see
  98. but what about a category like mutual funds if i could show it visually people would prefer to see
  99. mutual funds visually so it's kind of surprising how strong the preference was for visual depiction what we found was
  100. when the assortment was depicted visually versus verbally people perceived there was more variety
  101. in general that was the main effect and you can kind of understand why that was because
  102. you can take in more of the attributes at once you can see the interactions better
  103. whereas when it's verbal it's kind of piecemeal the way you process it so you tend to see more variety when
  104. it's visual versus verbal and people prefer it's emotionally nicer they like variety
  105. they prefer to see it in visual versus verbal and when the assortment is manageable
  106. visual is preferable because it's you know they like it better you can take all the variety in
  107. it's nice when the assortment gets really large what we found with the eye tracking
  108. is that people can't take in all that variety visually and what they tend to do when we know
  109. this from eye tracking is they tend to like kind of glaze over and look haphazardly randomly over the
  110. visual assortment and as a result of that they miss certain items and it becomes more complex and they're
  111. more willing to not make a choice on the other hand if the assortment's really large
  112. and i depict it verbally they may not like it as much but the only way they can take in that information
  113. is to spend a little bit more time and they tend to look a little more systematically
  114. so the net result of that is they take in more variety and they're more willing to make a choice
  115. that's fascinating so two follow-up questions on that first what do you think would be the
  116. implications for say a company like amazon which is though now calls itself the world's biggest
  117. retailer right and has an immense variety of products all depicted online what what would how
  118. would your research be relevant to a region of that so amazon sells anything so anything
  119. that's depicted online would be relevant i i haven't done research specifically with amazon but i have looked at some
  120. results like with campbell soup and with other packaged goods and it would be the same
  121. thing with anything is what we found is when people like what happens was say campbell soup
  122. you go to your favorite soup chicken noodle and you buy chicken noodle now campbell's has lots of variety what
  123. they want you to do is appreciate all that variety if what we found with goggles is if they
  124. look at just the pictures people glance over and they don't take in all the variety when we can get them to
  125. look at the labels the names they read it and then they see there's chicken noodles chicken stars
  126. chicken whatever but you have to you can can you picture what i'm saying like you'll just glaze it with you're looking
  127. at the picture but if you're reading you'll so like that's what we know with packaged goods i talk to a sports
  128. retailer i forget which one but they told me like with athletic clothes people buy black they buy black
  129. all the time but if you just had black on the shelf people wouldn't see all the different
  130. shapes and sizes you have so what some of the retailers do and you can imagine this online also
  131. is they insert like pink and orange not because they think people are going to buy that but because it gives them
  132. something to pay attention to and then you appreciate the different variety that's there so what you've got
  133. to do is get people to stop and pay attention to certain things or else they kind of glaze over
  134. i was also wondering how your research would relate to a company like walmart uh which again a
  135. huge retailer but it's not unlike sports goods it's it's a wide variety of products
  136. how how would they be how could they use your findings well i mean so i'm just looking at visual versus verbal and i'm
  137. looking at an attention getter when there's a wide variety of stopping to read and
  138. things but you can imagine doing more and more research on this and with these goggles
  139. you can watch people walk so what we know is if you're in a big store like a walmart with all this
  140. variety everywhere it kind of looks like this mountain of product and what you see is maybe what's
  141. on the end dial or under the for sale sign or something and so what you want to understand is
  142. how can we set up a store so that people take in all the variety that's there especially when you have your inventory
  143. out there on a shelf i was thinking about just recently i went downtown there's a store downtown
  144. that used to have ann klein which was clothing it now is stewart whitespin which is shoes
  145. the same exact physical space but the space is used differently in ann klein they keep all the inventory out
  146. right so all the dress sizes all the blouses all the different things they're out
  147. there's no back room really but if you think about a store a shoe store they have just a few shoes
  148. out and all the inventory is hidden in the back and so you think about just that
  149. different configuration of a store how much variety you're going to take in is really different and i never really
  150. thought about it until i saw the exact same physical space used a really different way that's
  151. fascinating and and one one more of your uh papers is about the horizontal versus
  152. vertical dimensions of uh product uh placement can you speak a little bit to that
  153. research yeah that's also we used eye tracking and we had some theory on the theory of attention
  154. and perception so to get at that research we first stipulate which i think is true that
  155. there's two stages let's say there's more than two but let's start with two stages
  156. to your choice process one stage is when you see the whole category you kind of scan it quickly
  157. maybe you're not going to make a purchase it's three seconds or so and you walk by
  158. the second is when you plant your feet and you're ready to make a choice okay now you're spending unlimited time
  159. and so we looked at those two stages and under those two stages should you do it
  160. horizontally or vertically horizontally or vertically in the two stages so stage one
  161. three seconds you're just scanning there what we found is because your eyes are horizontal
  162. um you you can see things that are horizontally more easily we call that higher perceptual fluency so when things are
  163. horizontal and you're looking very quickly you take in more variety when they're horizontal than vertical
  164. because it's harder to see vertical because of the physical way your your eyes are and so the result
  165. of that is if things are across a horizontal row and you're going past it quickly
  166. whether online or in the store you think there's more variety you remember more variety when it's horizontal than
  167. when it's vertical now when you get to the choice that's no longer the case because i'm spending
  168. enough time to look at it the quickness or the ease of looking at is not a relevant thing
  169. but now what happens is there's another perceptual uh i don't know if you've ever seen this
  170. but if you take the same line that's vertical and you take that same line horizontal
  171. people always think that the vertical is longer than the same length line that's
  172. horizontal so what that perceptual says is that perceptual bias says is when things are
  173. horizontal you think they're closer together we also know when you think things are
  174. closer together you think they're more similar so when you're evaluating things if you
  175. don't have clear preferences the things that are horizontal are seen as closer together and more equal in
  176. preference and so you're more likely to say pick one up or more of them horizontally when you
  177. see them vertically they see more further apart there seems to be an order to it more when it's
  178. horizontal when it's vertical and so you tend to pick one whereas this way you tend to pick
  179. more than one and so what we find in general is things horizontally you tend to pick more
  180. variety you see more variety quickly and when you evaluate you think they're more acceptable
  181. options and when it's vertical you tend to pick one and anecdotally i think retailers know
  182. this i've looked at the stores and i've looked at a lot of convenience stores what they tend to stack horizontally are
  183. things where you're going to take more flavors what they tend to stack vertically is
  184. good better best or best better good you know kind of like that and then the notion is you're going to
  185. take one when it's vertical and when it's horizontal you take more than one and so what my research has
  186. done is the retailers have kind of figured it out by trial and error they don't care why they
  187. just know it works but what i do back in the lab is to figure out how you pay attention and
  188. your resulting perceptions is part of why you see that effect because there's no reason that you know
  189. thinking about in advance why something would be horizontal or vertically what's really interesting about what you
  190. said is that in addition to retailers there are also companies that like netflix you know
  191. that show thousands of film titles horizontally and and different categories of film
  192. types vertically that that also can have a tremendous bearing on on what you just said yeah you see and like
  193. it could be the other way around but over time they figured out it worked this way and i'm just saying yes that's
  194. right because you tend to pick more than one in a particular category and you choose one or another category
  195. see that's that's exactly the same thing and what i think is so interesting is retailers frequently they're too busy
  196. they just want to know what's worked they do a b testing or this ad works better than
  197. that ad and they don't know why and so a lot of times it's very reassuring to see the results that i
  198. find in the lab validated by real world stuff and what i can add to them is i know why that's
  199. working that way and it's important because when you're going into new types of retail
  200. so you're going into shopping online or these omni channel things you want to know is what worked offline
  201. going to work online if you understand why it worked offline then you can make the adjustment more
  202. appropriately to these new formats so we've talked about three of your really interesting research papers any uh
  203. future research projects that you're working on that that based on some of the findings of
  204. these research papers yeah i'm really am interested in how the process goes you know now in this new omni
  205. channel world so what's happening now is we know there's stages to the purchase process
  206. you know you have an idea you want to fill something you about you know you search for information you
  207. evaluate the options you make a choice you use the product so there's all these different stages in
  208. traditional research you did a i mean retailing and traditional retailing you made the decisions in store and then
  209. you took them home so there was in-store and there was at home that was it but now it's a 24-7 world you might look
  210. on your phone for one you might look on the computer for something else you might go into the
  211. physical store for something else so you have all these different stages that can be in all different channels
  212. and i'm curious to know how separating the stages by channel by time affects decision making so i'm working on a
  213. project and we started with warby parker as an example warby parker the eyeglass
  214. retailer started by four wharton students um what you do in warby park they've changed it now because they've opened
  215. real stores but originally you made the decision online you looked at this big assortment
  216. you waited a couple days and you got five pairs to try on at home so what i was interested in was that
  217. separation between making your decision online having to wait a couple days to get the
  218. physical glasses how did that time between the two stages affect your decision making
  219. so we're in the process of doing that research now and we're finding counter to what people might
  220. think the delay between the two stages may not be bad it may be a good thing well perhaps the high growth velocity
  221. conference where warby parker is going to be one of the participants might be a good way to continue this
  222. conversation further barbara thank you so much for joining us today thank you you

Brief Summary

Barbara Khan discusses how product completeness affects consumer behavior and decision-making in retail contexts.

Key points

  • Research on Product Completeness. Barbara Khan discusses how perceptions of product completeness affect consumer behavior.
  • Visual vs. Verbal Assortments. Khan reveals surprising findings about consumer preferences for visual representations of products.
  • Understanding Retailer Decisions. Retailers often rely on trial and error without knowing why certain strategies work. 'They don’t know why, they just know it works.'
  • The Evolution of Shopping. The shopping process has evolved into a 24-7 world with multiple channels affecting decision making. 'You might look on your phone for one, you might look on the computer for something else.'
  • Warby Parker's Unique Model. Warby Parker's model of online decision-making followed by home trials is under research. 'How did that time between the two stages affect your decision making?'

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes