Fed Independence, Inflation, and the Future of the Federal Reserve

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Can the Federal Reserve remain independent in an increasingly political environment?

Patrick Harker, Professor of Operations, Information and Decisions at the Wharton School and former President and CEO of the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, discusses Jerome Powell’s legacy, the growing political pressure facing the Federal Reserve, and what to expect from incoming Fed Chair Kevin Warsh.

The conversation explores how the Fed navigated the pandemic, why inflation expectations remain a major concern, how geopolitical conflict could impact monetary policy, and why Fed independence may be one of the institution’s most important strengths moving forward.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Well, Kevin Warsh has been approved by the U.S. Senate to be the next chair of the Federal Reserve,
  2. so it is a perfect time to take a look at the leadership from Jerome Powell, who is heading
  3. out of that position after being there the last eight years, and looking ahead to what we might
  4. expect from Kevin Warsh as he heads into that role. And great to have joining us to discuss
  5. this Pat Harker, who's a professor of operations information and decisions here at the Wharton
  6. School, but he was also in an earlier life, not too long ago, president of the Philadelphia
  7. Federal Reserve Bank from 2021 through 2025. Pat, always great to talk to you and get your insight.
  8. Thank you, sir. I'm great. It's glad to be here. Thank you. Let's start with Jay Powell and give
  9. us your thoughts on his time, his tenure in overseeing and leading the Federal Reserve the
  10. eight years. It's been tough. I mean, he's been dealt blow after blow, and I think he's
  11. stood the test of time. You think about what he's faced, yes, banking crises, but they are kind of
  12. normal, although there are shocks to the system. The Fed knows how to deal with those. Pandemic,
  13. no, not so much. So you have to go back to Marian Eccles to think about somebody who
  14. faced, yes, bank shocks, but then he had the Second World War. And what you think about with
  15. the Second World War and the pandemic is you don't know when it's going to end. You don't know how
  16. it's going to end. You sort of know how a bank shock's going to end because you know how the
  17. Fed's going to respond and other parts of the government will respond. So Jay's been dealing
  18. with all of that. And then he's been dealing with a direct frontal assault on the independence of
  19. the Federal Reserve. And I think he really has stood up, he's held the line, and I'm just proud
  20. to have worked with him. So let's touch on the element of the pandemic because I think that
  21. obviously, as you kind of alluded to a moment ago, it was such a unique time and period for everything
  22. in our lives. But for financial leaders, take us through what it was like to try and kind of get
  23. an understanding of what was going on with the economy at that time. We were scurrying around for every shred of information we could get. Because the data we
  24. have, the official data from the government, is backward looking, right, by definition. So we were
  25. looking at open table reservations, Google commuter patterns. We were trying to find every
  26. shred of information to get some sense of where the economy was going. And, unusual for a central bank, we had to become amateur epidemiologists to figure out and talk
  27. to doctors about what was going to happen. What do you think Powell's legacy ends up being?
  28. I think his legacy will be what he's doing right now, which is standing up for the independence
  29. of the Federal Reserve. Look, presidents before have gone after the Fed, right? But it's done
  30. privately. This is a very public attack on the Fed, including legal action, at least threatened
  31. legal action. This is unprecedented. And the fact that Jay's standing up for the institution
  32. is what I think will be remembered for. How much of a concern is there that the Fed
  33. obviously is being challenged on its independence, but could potentially lose some of that independence moving forward?
  34. Well, I think it's really important is Humphrey's executor case that's going through the U.S. Supreme Court. They should be deciding this any day now. That will say a lot,
  35. because the court has hinted at the Fed being different than other federal agencies,
  36. but we'll have to see what they ultimately decide. If they decide that the president
  37. can fire at will governors, for example, who could then fire at will presidents,
  38. there is no independence on the monetary policy side of the Fed. Right. And that obviously becomes interesting as well because of the fact that Chair Powell
  39. has decided that he is going to stay on as a Fed governor, which take us through that as well,
  40. because historians tell me that this is not always the norm, that a Fed chair just
  41. automatically moves over to that slot. No, no. So you look at Eccles. Eccles did it,
  42. but actually Truman, President Truman asked him to stay on. This is different. Jay is staying on
  43. until he's assured that the institution is safe. That is, he wants to see these legal cases
  44. dismissed. Then I think Jay will move on. That's my guess. What do you expect from Kevin Warsh as he takes over this role?
  45. So on the monetary policy side, not a lot. I mean, if he's the one person changing, the rest of the
  46. committee members, the other 18 aren't changing, except there'll be a new president of the Atlanta
  47. Fed coming soon. So there, and plus he's dealt this hand right now with the war, where he's
  48. not going to be able to deliver on any kind of cuts. It's just not possible. Now, on the
  49. regulatory side, I think there's going to be action, and that is really in the hands of the
  50. governors, solely in the hands of the governors. So I think you'll see some action there, but
  51. I wouldn't expect a sea change when it comes to monetary policy anytime soon. But I guess the difference is that Warsh does have more of an economic background than Powell did,
  52. but obviously Warsh, a lot of people believe, from an economic standpoint, has a pretty good
  53. hold and pretty good frame on what we might need to see done in the years ahead.
  54. Yeah, I think so. I think Kevin's a professional, but again, he is not going to get his way if the
  55. committee is against it. And so you saw that in the last meeting, where three dissented to the
  56. hawkish side on the statement language. So I think Kevin's got his hands full on that. He's
  57. going to have a committee that's nervous about where we are in terms of inflation.
  58. Where do you think, and I guess you may have to a degree answered this already, until we get a resolution on the conflict with Iran, there's really not a lot that the Fed
  59. would want to do maybe at this juncture. No, I mean, I put a piece out recently, we talked about supply shocks, and the Fed not having a lot
  60. of tools for supply shocks. What's different now is this is, I call it supply coercion. These are
  61. actions by nation states, because they know in an asymmetric war, they need to get an upper hand
  62. somehow, and they can influence us through these supply shocks. I saw comments earlier this week, we talk about rate cuts all the time. But the potential of a
  63. rate increase is something that I guess, at least has to be on the minds of Fed leadership
  64. moving forward. Yes. I mean, if inflation expectations start to get unanchored, there's signs that people are
  65. getting a little nervous. But if they start to move up in a significant way, the Fed will have
  66. to take action. It cannot allow inflation expectations to get unanchored. What do you take from your time running the Philadelphia Fed and obviously the relationship
  67. you had with so many governors and that experience over that window of time that you were there?
  68. I wish Americans could see an FOMC meeting. We disagreed, we would have reasoned disagreement, but it was never personal,
  69. there was never politics that entered the room. It was 19 people debating what was best for the
  70. country. And seriously, there was no ego, there was no politics, it was people trying to do what's
  71. best for the country. Now, we disagree, we all have the same data, we disagree in our judgments,
  72. but we never took it personally. Should there be a level of concern that what we're seeing play out in our politics right now
  73. could bleed into the Federal Reserve? I sure hope not. I think the beauty of the Fed that was, you know, set up here in 1913
  74. was that you have 12 reserve banks that are somewhat isolated from the political discourse.
  75. And I think that is one of the secret sauces, one of the superpowers of the Fed or the reserve banks.
  76. Pat, I appreciate your time today. All the best. Thanks very much. Take care. Thank you, Pat Harker, who is a Professor of Operations Information and Decisions
  77. here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Pat Harker discusses Jerome Powell's legacy and Kevin Warsh's upcoming role as Federal Reserve chair amid challenges to the Fed's independence.

Key points

  • Kevin Warsh Takes the Helm. Kevin Warsh has been approved as the new chair of the Federal Reserve, succeeding Jerome Powell.
  • Jerome Powell's Legacy. Pat Harker discusses Powell's tenure and the challenges he faced, including the pandemic.
  • Concerns Over Fed Independence. The Supreme Court's decision on the Humphrey's executor case could impact the Fed's independence.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes