Understanding Stablecoins, Regulation, and the Future of Digital Asset Markets

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Kevin Werbach, Wharton Professor of Legal Studies & Business Ethics, discusses what a stablecoin is, its use cases have evolved over time, the implications of the GENIUS Act and emerging regulation, and the role of the Wharton's Stablecoin Toolkit in shaping policy and industry conversations.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#digitalcurrency #stablecoin #crypto #digitalassets #regulatoryframework ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Well, as we go deeper into the world of digital currency, it's becoming more important to make sure that there is a secure
  2. connection to the traditional financial system. A new stablecoin toolkit has been developed at the Wharton School as a way
  3. to potentially bridge the gap between the two worlds. Pleasure to be joined by Kevin Werbach, who is a Professor of Legal
  4. Studies and Business Ethics here at the Wharton School. Kevin, great to have you with us again. Thanks for your time.
  5. Thank you, Dan. You know, we have talked so much about this area over the years. I mean, the stablecoin, it's not a new concept, but
  6. it becomes more important to bring forth a toolkit like this now because why? Stablecoins have been around for roughly 10 years. A stablecoin
  7. is basically a digital asset, so it's a cryptocurrency like Bitcoin or ether, but it's designed to remain stable, to
  8. typically keep at the value of the US dollar. And stablecoins have been used primarily in the digital asset world as a form of
  9. liquidity on exchanges, but they've been kind of in a regulatory gray area. And what's happened in recent years is
  10. there's been a lot of activity around stablecoins. There's been interest in stablecoins for other uses, like payments.
  11. And regulators are now starting to create regimes to deal with stablecoins. There was one adopted in the European Union,
  12. and just last year, the US passed something called the Genius Act, which created a legal framework for stablecoins.
  13. And so the importance of this toolkit is to help provide a better understanding of kind of the stablecoin landscape at
  14. the moment? Stablecoins are bigger than most people realize. There are several 100 billion dollars of value in assets. But if you look
  15. at the transaction volume of stablecoins, Visa has found that the transaction volume of stablecoins last year was
  16. $35 trillion, which is double what Visa's traditional payment volume is. Now that's a little bit overstated. A lot of that
  17. actually turns out to be high- frequency trading and spoofing and so forth. But the adjusted number they come up with is
  18. still $7 trillion. Again, most of that is used in digital asset trading. But it's quite significant. 80% of all digital
  19. asset trades use stablecoins for at least one leg. And a survey last year by Fireblocks, a digital asset custody company,
  20. found that 90% of financial services firms— and this includes traditional firms and fintechs as well— were looking
  21. at using stablecoins or already were doing so. So it's a significant phenomenon. But it's a deeply misunderstood
  22. phenomenon, which is why we put this toolkit together. Okay. And so one of the sections of the toolkit is defining and
  23. categorizing the different types of stablecoin. It turns out that when you ask the question, what is a stablecoin,
  24. it's a much harder question than people realize. The specific laws like the Genius Act have a definition of
  25. what they call a payment stablecoin. But then you look at all the stablecoins that are actually out there in the market
  26. today, many of them don't conform to that definition. And there are all kinds of other things, like central bank
  27. digital currencies, tokenized deposits, tokenized money market funds, money market funds, that are similar to stablecoins. And
  28. so what we do in this, is this is really, I think, the first academically-rooted document that says, systematically, what
  29. is a stablecoin? We come up with a definition— precise definition about what is a stablecoin. And then we talk
  30. about how stablecoins are different from other forms of money, how they're used, how they're made stable and so forth.
  31. Right. And so you laid out a variety of uses for stablecoins. But from where we are now, how much farther
  32. do these uses go, potentially? Potentially, very far. We are trying to, in this report, put
  33. out a balanced perspective. This report involved an expert group of industry participants, academic participants, legal
  34. experts and others from around the world with different views. And there definitely are people who are convinced stablecoins
  35. are going to be massive. There are various reports talking about the value going from roughly $250 billion to two or
  36. $5 trillion in a few years. We're not taking a position on that. We're trying to map out what the use cases look like, and
  37. help policymakers as well as industry participants understand what to do. So clearly, the biggest use of stablecoins
  38. today is in digital asset trading. But there is interesting take-up of uses in payments, especially in
  39. developing countries, places with high inflation. But a lot of interesting experiments and activity going on in places like
  40. the US, with major financial services firms, because there's tremendous efficiency, especially for any kind of cross-
  41. border transaction, in using a stablecoin, as opposed to the traditional payment system. And then the other potential uses
  42. are tremendous as well, but they haven't really taken off yet. But do they go to the point of this kind of moving towards kind
  43. of a commonality use of us using traditional currency at some point? The point that we make in the paper is that stablecoins are
  44. potentially the bridge between the digital asset world and the traditional financial system. The traditional financial system
  45. has all kinds of limitations. It's massive, but especially when you talk about payments, which is this plumbing that most
  46. people don't see, it's trillions and trillions of dollars going back and forth around the world, but it's incredibly inefficient.
  47. There's all kinds of limitations and silos and inefficiencies and gatekeepers and so forth. And in order to overcome that, you need
  48. a common, global, secure, decentralized platform. That's what blockchain is. And so there is this potential to bring these
  49. worlds together in a very powerful way. So you talk about the global component of this. How much of a
  50. global framework is already there in the use of stablecoin, and what needs to potentially develop even farther as we move
  51. further down the line? There are a whole set of regulatory issues. Law is national, even though money is global, and blockchains are
  52. global. And so different countries come up with legal regimes. As I said, the European Union has one, although theirs
  53. is not very widely adopted, for various reasons. The US now has one. Hong Kong has one, Singapore has one. Many
  54. countries are looking at creating legal regimes, and there's some commonality between them, but they're not all going
  55. to be the same. And that's— that's okay. Every country doesn't have to be the same. It isn't right now for traditional
  56. finance. But there's also a huge amount of activity in stablecoins that's still in this regulatory gray area, uses that
  57. are not mapped into these existing regimes, but they're being very widely adopted. Ultimately, there needs to be an
  58. environment where there's clear regulation, because it's essential to have things like any money laundering and
  59. countering terrorist financing checks to have certainty for global transactions, to have mechanisms for oversight while
  60. still allowing for fluidity of currency flows and innovation. So that doesn't mean every country has the same regime, but
  61. there needs to be a lot of coordination. It's starting to happen, but it's still very early.
  62. Right. So that at least everybody is reasonably on the same page in terms of how this process is going to work and develop as we
  63. move forward. That's a big goal of this toolkit, to try to give everyone a common language and a common understanding of what the
  64. possibilities are and what the issues are, and then they can decide where they go from there.
  65. So what, then, do you hope this toolkit will bring to the table? Well, it stimulates discussion. It gives everyone a solid
  66. understanding. The core insight that we started with is that we can't talk about stablecoins without having a solid
  67. understanding of what a stablecoin is. And it's, fine, again, for the US to say there's all kinds of stablecoins that we
  68. are not going to allow within the US financial system. But at least you can't ignore that the other stablecoins are out
  69. there, and they may be legitimate in other countries, and maybe those need to be brought into the US regime,
  70. because they actually are other appropriate mechanism. Those are the kinds of conversations that need to happen. And frankly,
  71. industry participants need to be aware of what the possibilities are, and not just be going on hype or not just be fixating on
  72. the way this market used to be historically. Those are the kinds of conversations. And since the toolkit came out,
  73. we've already received a number of inquiries from regulators and other organizations that are interested in starting
  74. conversations and potential collaborations with us. Kevin, it sounds very exciting, and congratulations on the work
  75. that you've been doing. Absolutely. Thanks a lot. You got it. Kevin Werbach, Professor of Legal Studies and Business
  76. Ethics here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Kevin Werbach discusses stablecoins, their toolkit, and regulatory challenges in bridging digital assets with traditional finance.

Key points

  • The Importance of Stablecoins. Stablecoins have been around for roughly 10 years and are crucial in digital asset trading.
  • Regulatory Developments. New regulations like the Genius Act are shaping the landscape for stablecoins.
  • Global Framework Challenges. Different countries are developing their own legal regimes for stablecoins, creating regulatory challenges.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes