Crypto Regulation: Policy, Innovation, and Stablecoins Explained

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Crypto regulation presents complex challenges as digital assets blur traditional boundaries between securities, commodities, and other financial instruments. In this episode, host and Wharton professor Itay Goldstein speaks with Tim Massad, formerly at the CTFC, currently at Harvard Kennedy School and Wharton professor Jessica Wachter, formerly at the SEC, examines how SEC and CFTC roles intersect, why coordination—not just fragmentation—is a key issue, and how the regulatory status of tokens can evolve over time. It also explores the systemic risk potential of stablecoins and cases of fraud in lightly regulated crypto markets.

This discussion is part of a special series called “Future of Finance: The Rise of Crypto and Digital Money.”

SERIES OVERVIEW Hosted by Wharton finance professor Itay Goldstein, this limited series takes a deep dive into the cutting-edge insights and pioneering perspectives of innovation experts in the finance industry. Discover the dynamic landscape of financial thought leadership as we explore concepts, groundbreaking research, and predictions that are shaping the future of finance.

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

#CryptoRegulation #DigitalAssets #Stablecoins #DeFi #FinancialRegulation ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Welcome everyone to the future of finance podcast here at the Wharton School. My name is Itai Goldstein. I'm a
  2. professor in the finance department and currently the chair of the finance department and we are focusing the
  3. second season of the future of finance uh podcast on cryptocurrencies uh digital assets uh decentralized finance
  4. and everything related to that. These are new innovations that are promising to change the world of finance, the way
  5. that we trade, the way that we pay uh and the financial system uh more generally. And an important part of the
  6. story of uh cryptocurrencies and digital assets is certainly regulation. Some people will say that we have too much uh
  7. regulation or regulatory uncertainty and that this is stifling innovation in this
  8. space and others will say that we need regulation and maybe we need even more regulation because there are many
  9. threats potential fraud uh and potential risk for uh the system as a whole uh what we think of as systemic risk. So
  10. those are issues that we want to discuss here today in uh this uh episode of the
  11. second uh season. Uh and we have two perfect guests uh to talk about uh these uh these issues. Uh one is uh Jessica
  12. Waktail who is the Dr. Bruce I Jacobs Professor of Quantitative Finance here at the Wharton School. So I've been here
  13. with Jessica over the last 20 years or so. I think she arrived one year before me. uh and uh she uh thought a lot about
  14. the regulatory aspects of uh digital assets and cryptocurrency because she just came back from serving
  15. as the chief economist at the SEC, the Securities and Exchange uh Commission. Uh welcome uh Jessica.
  16. >> Thanks so much for having me. I'm happy to be here. And then the second guest
  17. that we have is uh Tim Msad who is currently senior fellow at the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard
  18. University. Uh he also has a vast experience in uh policy and thought a lot about uh crypto and digital assets
  19. among other things. He is the former chairman of the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the CFTC
  20. and he has been participating in many of our events here at the Whartalon Initiative on Financial Policy and
  21. Regulation uh Wiffer where we have been thinking quite a bit about the regulatory aspects of uh crypto and
  22. digital assets. Hello Tim. >> Hi, thank you for having me. >> So with this introduction, let's uh dive
  23. right in. There's a lot uh to discuss and I want to start from uh the basics. Uh we talk a lot about regulation in the
  24. space of digital assets. Uh but this is not disconnected from broader financial regulation and regulation that we have
  25. in other markets and other financial institutions. So I want to take a step back and understand a little better what
  26. is potentially special about uh digital assets and why is regulation of digital assets potentially different uh than
  27. regulation in other areas of the financial system. Uh so Jessica maybe you can start with that.
  28. >> Sure. Um happy to start. Uh so I think there's a couple things to be considered. One is that the original
  29. vision of uh cryptocurrency uh going back to you know the white paper um uh the Bitcoin white paper is one of
  30. decentralization and that's going to create a tension with our regulatory system and moving
  31. more towards the present um this is a situation where securities and non-securities are inseparable
  32. and just to put it in non um digital asset terms. We don't normally use gold to say buy Apple stock on the New York
  33. Stock Exchange. We don't really know how that might work and that's the situation
  34. that we have with crypto platforms. I think another challenge is that the crypto ecosystem developed outside of
  35. the regulatory system and that's created a bit of a chicken and egg problem. So in
  36. the traditional financial system we have securities that trade on registered exchanges. That's a very important part.
  37. It's not the whole financial system by any means, but it's a very important part of how um institutions and retail
  38. interact with the financial system, but what do you do when both the tokens, which are kind of like the equities
  39. here, and the platforms are unregistered? You don't you need one to go first, but neither can operate while
  40. the other is still unregistered. So I so I think that those um decentralization the intertwined notion of securities and
  41. non-securities and the chicken and egg problem are three challenges uh that would need to be overcome.
  42. >> Very good. Tim, do you want to weigh in? >> Sure. Well, I would first say the the
  43. problem is that we speak of digital assets as if it's an asset class and it isn't. It's a technology. We're talking
  44. about blockchain and tokenization technologies which can be used in all sorts of ways. You can have tokenization
  45. of securities of stocks and bonds and potentially other real world assets or other financial instruments. You can
  46. have network tokens of blockchains which is what Bitcoin and ETH are. You can have tokens that are really for
  47. consumption as in games. You can have meme coins. you're going to have collectibles. So, we can't really
  48. regulate digital assets per se. What we need to do in regulation is really three
  49. things. One is we have to address the gap we have in the United States with respect to regulation which is that in
  50. so far as some tokens aren't securities but are financial instruments whether you want to call them commodities or
  51. something like commodities we don't have a federal regulator for that spot market
  52. and that's been something that lots of people have recognized but we haven't done anything about it. Secondly, we do
  53. need greater clarity in when is a token a security, when is it not a security. And as Jessica said, that's, you know,
  54. there's um a lot of gray areas to that because tokens can change over time, if you will. Um and the third thing we need
  55. to do is make sure that the rules we have about how to use this technology are neutral or that is the rules we have
  56. for things like recordkeeping, custody, clearance and settlement should be technologically neutral. They
  57. shouldn't be inhibiting use of this technology but I don't think they should be promoting it per se either uh also
  58. let the market decide that. So I think what both of you are saying is pointing to one friction that has
  59. been on the minds of many people who are observing this. uh I would say maybe more generally with financial regulation
  60. but in particular when it comes to uh digital assets and this is the potential uh fragmentation the fact that uh it is
  61. not clear who should regulate uh what and then you have some tensions you have different rules coming from different uh
  62. uh agencies uh and that creates even uh greater uncertainty. So is that a a bug that we can uh overcome or is that just
  63. a feature of the system that we are dealing with? >> It certainly has been a cause of some of
  64. the difficulty in addressing this. You know, we have two market regulators, the Securities and Exchange Commission and
  65. the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. And when you have a technology that allows for the
  66. development of innovative products that kind of cut across those agencies jurisdictional lines that becomes very
  67. challenging. If for example we had a unitary regulator as some jurisdictions do it be it is easier to address
  68. financial innovations because you say all right my my jurisdiction covers all financial instruments. I see kind of
  69. this new technology I'm going to address that. So we have been saddled with that.
  70. I do think that that's one of the reasons when we think about the solution about how to regulate we actually need
  71. to bring the agencies closer together. A lot of people say well what we need is very clear lines of jurisdiction. What
  72. the CFTC regulates and what the SEC regulates and that all sounds good but in fact there are gray areas here. You
  73. can have tokens which kind of seem to be securities at first but then can become
  74. commodities effectively because they are decentralized. So and again you want rules on how to use this technology
  75. which are reasonably consistent between the two agencies. So I think the solution lies in
  76. bringing the agencies closer together in various ways. You don't have to merge them. uh that's been suggested many
  77. times before and we've never wanted to take that step, but we do have to create ways that they're going to work together
  78. on on these issues. >> So Jessica, what is your take on fragmentation? Uh obviously you just
  79. experienced some of it in DC. I don't know how much you want to >> Sure. Well, I I'm I I'll I'll say a
  80. couple things and I'll um I think uh um Tim uh said it well, which is um I I've I don't believe that bringing that
  81. creating one financial regulator actually is the answer here, but this is clearly something that the CFTC and the
  82. SEC uh would will have to and actually do currently work together on. Um and that's something that both agencies know
  83. how to do. And it does it does you know at the margin create some frictions and perhaps slows them things down a little
  84. bit. But I I believe in my experience the extent to which that happens is somewhat overstated.
  85. And I think that fragmentation itself is not really the problem that we have. Um
  86. I mean I think the the issue is that some of these problems are difficult problems and it's not obvious what the
  87. solutions are. uh but I think that the many issues actually are similar to the types of questions that the SEC has
  88. worked on for many decades. Um so I I generally think both here and in other settings that the you know fragmentation
  89. of the US financial market story is a little overstated. I think that there's strengths to our system visav other
  90. jurisdictions. You know, for one thing, we have a strong and experienced market regulator and not all jurisdictions have
  91. that. Um, and I think that's been very helpful for the development of financial markets. And I think having the CFTC and
  92. the SEC separate has allowed for experimentation also. So in some cases um you know for some sets of rules and
  93. this is outside of crypto uh the CFTC has gone first and the SEC has been able to see how things have worked out and
  94. learn from that and vice versa. So so I think that there's actually some real benefits to our system.
  95. >> Yeah, I you know I I would agree with a lot of that. I don't mean to suggest that fragmentation is the main problem
  96. here. Um and you know I do think there are benefits to the fact that we've had two regulators. Um,
  97. but I do think when Congress thinks about what to do here, um, it's not just going to be a simple process of writing
  98. legislation that says, "Okay, this is a digital commodity. Uh, CFTC go regulate that because um those are, you know,
  99. those are difficult questions and I just think we want the two agencies working together and I agree they're they're
  100. capable of that um particularly when they're led by chairs who have that mentality. So one of the biggest
  101. questions when it comes to regulation and it's not directly what we talked about but follows up on that is uh the
  102. idea that because of regulation and because of regulatory uncertainty we don't see uh as much innovation in the
  103. space of digital assets and decentralized finance as we would have hoped. And uh proponents of this theory
  104. would say that here we have a set of new technologies that uh promise to revolutionize the the way we do finance
  105. and monetary economics. Um but then because of all these uh uh regulations and regulatory uncertainty and all
  106. potential political issues um there is just not enough uh innovation and we are uh falling behind. Uh so what what is
  107. your take on that? I think it's overblown. Uh I, you know, the industry loves to say this. Uh and sure, you
  108. know, you could certainly make the argument that gee, if we had regulatory clarity, uh people could, you know, more
  109. easily launch products, raise money, they wouldn't even consider doing something abroad and so forth. But in
  110. the grand scheme of things, I think it's an overblown argument. Um I don't think
  111. uh you know that's what's preventing um this technology from displacing JP Morgan or something like that you know
  112. which sometimes uh crypto enthusiasts love to say oh this is really going to transform finance. I think it's an
  113. important technology. I think we will see it used in a lot of ways. I think we're getting there. I don't think we're
  114. as far behind other jurisdictions as uh some would have. >> Jessica, do you agree with that? Uh yes,
  115. I do. Um I I'll add a couple points. One is that um the sort of broad crypto space
  116. developed for years uh really without this it developed to be actually quite large and significant I would say um
  117. relative to where it started without the regulatory certainty. Um I I think it's
  118. possible that the regulatory uncertainty has impeded some of the traditional financial players from having as large a
  119. role in crypto as they might otherwise. But the fact is crypto has generally been a retail and sort of decentralized
  120. driven business anyways. So um I I do agree that this is a overblown argument. That said, I mean, I think regulatory
  121. clarity would be quite helpful. >> So, going a little deeper into why we need regulation to begin with, I would
  122. say one issue that is general in in finance uh but seems to be particularly prevalent when it comes to uh digital
  123. assets is fraud. And we have seen uh I would say a fair share of of fraud uh probably more than uh was anticipated uh
  124. initially and and this has uh caused a lot of concern and and led to a call for more uh regulation. Um what what do you
  125. think about that? So why do we see so much fraud in this uh space and is there a clear way forward when we can uh avoid
  126. it or is that just going to be part of the system? Well, I think we've seen a lot of fraud and manipulation for and
  127. other problems for two reasons. Um, one is it is an unregulated sector largely at least the um what we what we often
  128. call the spot market in tokens that are not securities and of course the crypto industry is has argued that basically
  129. most security most tokens are not securities. Um that's unregulated number one and it's also um easy to enter. uh
  130. you can be you know 18 or 20 year years old and in college and create a token or
  131. create an app and launch that and who knows you know you might make a lot of money at it. Um but you also therefore
  132. have a lot of people uh as you do in any kind of um area of financial activity who are looking to make a quick buck and
  133. often not through the most uh ethical means. And so you have pump and dump schemes. You have a lot of wash trading
  134. on platforms. Wash trading is where people essentially trade with themselves to push up the price uh of something or
  135. to make it appear there's more interest than there is. We saw with the whole ICO
  136. phenomenon of people selling tokens without good disclosure. Um so you know it's not surprising uh that we've had
  137. all this. Um and again it's the reason why we need a comprehensive sort of regulatory approach to it.
  138. >> Yeah, I would say that it's surprising from the point of view of you know our current markets some of the
  139. most visible parts do not appear to be rife with with fraud. Now, that's I think in part, you know, we've never
  140. done the experiment, but I think in large part because of our um securities regime going back to the 30s. Um but the
  141. point is people forget that we've got that. It becomes in the background. It's like, you know, part of the air we
  142. breathe. It's like, you know, the fish in the water. And so we forget that that's protecting us from what would
  143. otherwise be probably rampant fraud in traditional securities as well. So crypto developed and it didn't really
  144. have this this backing. Um so I'm actually not sure it's more prevalent. Um maybe it is. We don't have the data.
  145. Um part of the data is that we don't have the part of the issue is that we don't have the regulations. Um but you
  146. know there's plenty of fraud in the um sort of dark corners of the equity markets too with very small um equity
  147. securities that don't trade on exchanges. And the other side of uh regulation, the
  148. other reason why we have regulation in financial markets more generally is the concern about systemic risk. Uh and the
  149. idea that if there is a problem in one type of asset, one type of institution, this is going to spill over affecting
  150. the rest of the financial system and uh ultimately also the real economy. uh this has been mentioned uh in the
  151. context of uh cryptocurrencies and digital assets but it's not clear that this is at this point big enough uh to
  152. worry us. Uh what is your take on that? >> I'll just quickly jump in and say I I
  153. don't think crypto at the present time is large enough to to pose a systemic risk. I tend to think that the nature of
  154. some of these contracts is not such that it would normally tend itself to systemic risk because they're more
  155. equity type contracts. Um but of course stable coins which perhaps we'll talk about are big exception because those
  156. are demand deposit contracts like like a deposit in a bank account and so um in some sense you could say are asking for
  157. trouble. >> Yeah, I I I would agree with that. Um the only thing I would add though is
  158. that you know when we talk about systemic risk it's um it's hard to identify where that's going to come
  159. from. Uh you know and and you can imagine scenarios where because of the overall context something happens in
  160. crypto it's gotten a little bigger and maybe the overall environment uh has some other factors that are contributing
  161. to to anxiety or to to uh concern you know. So it's it's the proverbial uh you know thing of the butterfly flapping
  162. its wings in Brazil or whatever. Um but I would agree that today the sector is is not so large that it would be my top
  163. concern for systemic risk. That's for sure. >> Right. But you did mention uh stable
  164. coin uh Jessica and uh I would say this is potentially an area where we might see it because the whole point of stable
  165. coin is to offer stability and then you have the usual problem where uh you commit to certain payments but uh the
  166. underlying assets might not support it and this might generate a run. I should say we have another episode where we
  167. talk in detail about uh stable coin and go into some of these uh issues. Uh so that that might be one place where we
  168. might uh fear about uh systemic risk and and that is a good segment to thinking a
  169. bit more about uh stable coin because if we are focusing on regulation I would say stable coin is one area where uh
  170. there is a clearer path for uh regulation and as we speak the there is a bill that is making its way through uh
  171. congress. Um so what is your take on uh stable coin uh the the regulatory aspects of it where we are and are we
  172. headed in the right direction? >> Um happy to take that one first. I think we're headed in the right direction. Uh
  173. as you mentioned while the at the time we're recording this the Genius Act is uh coming up uh soon for a vote in the
  174. House. it may very well uh have gone to the president by the time this is aired.
  175. The Genius Act creates a basic framework for the regulation of stable coins and I
  176. think it gets um some things right. Uh it's good on uh some of the basic credential requirements that we would
  177. want to see. I mean a stable coin is a token whose value is pegged uh to the dollar to another fiat currency or or to
  178. another sort of asset. Of course, there can be stable coins that are tied to other crypto tokens. I'm just talking
  179. about the ones that are tied to uh fiat currencies. And so, the legislation that is
  180. currently being considered, a stable coin issuer, you know, would be required to have full reserves backing the stable
  181. coins that it's issued, meaning for every token, you have to hold that dollar. You have to conservatively
  182. invest it. There are limitations on the activities of stable coin issuers, and that's all good. Um, I do think there
  183. are some weaknesses in the legislation. We can get into those if you want. Um, but you know, the real question is will
  184. this market grow significantly and we'll have to see. Um, there are a lot of elements to payments and why people
  185. choose certain payment instruments and the big volume of payments of course is not retail, it's businessto business.
  186. And will we see uh large use of stable coins among businesses? Um that's not clear. We can get into that uh if you
  187. like. >> Yeah. So Jessica, I I'll give you an opportunity to uh weigh in. >> Sure. And I I would agree. I think this
  188. is directionally right. Um I think anything and uh it you described it well. anything with a structure like a
  189. stable coin is uh is going to have some kind of run risk and I I think that can be mitigated by the certain safeguards
  190. that um you know Congress is putting in about restrictions about what they can hold and the the requirements for
  191. audits. I'll add that there is this question here about how stable coins relate to the vast money market fund
  192. industry. Um, there's this question about whether stable coins pay interest. Um, I'm not an attorney. My
  193. understanding is that this this is still a little bit of a gray area. Um, people might want a stable coin that
  194. pays interest. Um, but currently it's, you know, money market funds. This is how they differentiate themselves. And
  195. the more stable coins come to look like money market funds, the more we might start to see the tendency for regulatory
  196. arbitrage versus the money market fund regime. And that's probably an area where we don't want a race to the
  197. bottom. >> Yeah. And we're already seeing tokenized money market funds. And I agree there
  198. are going to be a lot of um participants who want an interestbearing um tokenized
  199. instrument. I think, you know, for where we are, I think it made sense to stay in
  200. the legislation as it currently does that stable coins can't pay interest, but there's clearly going to be the
  201. development of tokenized products that pay interest. Now, whether those are more accountbased in some way, you know,
  202. tokenized deposits or deposit tokens um by banks, uh that's another uh innovation that we may very well see and
  203. not in in the not too distant future. So, how big do you think this sector is going to be going forward? You started
  204. talking about that. >> I'll let Jessica make the prediction. >> I I really think this is just this is
  205. just impossible to say. Um I I really think it just depends on on too many things. um and in part on whether some
  206. of the more optimistic claims for the crypto sector as a whole bear out because that's obviously one of the
  207. possible uses for stable coins. >> Yeah. And when you when you think about the use cases, I mean, clearly people
  208. who are in countries with weak currencies or high inflation, who want access to the dollar and who can't get a
  209. US dollar bank account might turn to stable coins, and they are um clearly to the extent we're talking about trading
  210. tokenized assets on chain, you need onchain cash. That's what a stable coin is. Though again you might see tokenized
  211. money market funds used for that as well. So if you see tokenization of other products and trading on chain that
  212. use case could grow. But again when you look at sort of businessto business payments that now use you know chips or
  213. the fed wire are they going to suddenly move to stable coins? There's a lot of issues there and uh that's why it's so
  214. hard to predict this market. >> Right. So going back to the uh topic of uh regulation uh I think we had a good
  215. discussion on what are the reasons for regulation what's good about the current framework what's not so good what could
  216. be improved uh one argument that often comes up is that the US is falling behind other jurisdictions and Europe is
  217. often mentioned as uh you know a system where uh they acted uh faster and they have a more uniform approach there is
  218. uh Mika uh framework uh that that is uh supposed to uh capture the the whole system of uh digital assets and stable
  219. coins and so on. Um so what what is your take on uh the issue of uh the US versus
  220. other places and what might explain why the US has not done so well on this? I don't think we're as far behind as uh
  221. some crypto enthusiasts might uh lead you to believe. Yes, Europe has imple has passed ma but they still have to
  222. implement ma and implementation of ma involves the 27 member countries in many cases writing rules. Uh that is a
  223. challenging process. I just held a 4-day training session at Harvard for regulators around the world on digital
  224. assets and a lot of them were saying no we still face a lot of the challenges that the US faces and even with Mika for
  225. example it regulates things that aren't financial instruments. Uh so they actually have
  226. even in their law the similar challenges that we have on when is something a security, when is it not a security, if
  227. it's not a security, what is it? Um so you know we're getting there. Um it may not be as fast as uh as we'd like. Uh
  228. clearly the Trump administration wants to move forward. Uh Congress uh wants to move forward. Um so I don't think this
  229. is uh you know as big a problem as the industry might like you to believe but I do want to see us you know develop a
  230. regulatory framework so that we can see how this tech how this technology can be
  231. used. >> Uh Jessica >> I mean I'll I'll say that the the commission has indicated um that people
  232. should come in and discuss their product. So I I I think that the case that we are currently impeding
  233. innovation is is pretty weak. Um and the US just has an enormous financial market
  234. just in absolute as well as in relative terms. So I don't I don't see evidence that we've fallen behind here. Um though
  235. I do think that it's going to be valuable to solve some of the problems that we've been discussing. uh that's
  236. that's going to be helpful but um I I think that there's there's a commitment to doing so and so that's that's really
  237. I think what people need in terms of you know putting these ideas forward again I
  238. don't think that the barrier at this point is not a regulatory one >> okay so as we are coming close to the
  239. end of this episode I would like to maybe offer you a chance to kind of summarize your uh view on future
  240. regulation and what you would like to to see going forward. So maybe in in you know 30 seconds or so uh if you were to
  241. envision a regulatory framework that uh will uh take care of this uh space of digital assets and have us go into a
  242. world of innovation and the future of finance if you want. Uh what do you think it should include and how do you
  243. think it should look like? Tim maybe you can start. >> Sure. Well, um, the first thing I would
  244. say is while this is a very important technology, might be used in lots of ways,
  245. we want to be sure that the regulation we develop does not undermine our existing markets. The securities and
  246. derivatives markets that we have and and the uh equity and debt markets that we have are so important to the to the
  247. world, not just to the US economy. They're very very large $120 trillion market cap uh securities alone. Um and
  248. when I say undermine, what I mean is we don't want to rewrite the securities laws in ways that
  249. undermine a framework that's been developed very thoughtfully and carefully over a hundred years. Uh we
  250. don't need to create, you know, a lot of exceptions uh to promote the technology.
  251. We want techn technologically neutral rules but you know again uh we need to be careful. So the three things we need
  252. to do are I think one create a framework for regulation for what we typically call the spot market in digital tokens
  253. that are not securities to the extent they're financial instruments. Number two, provide greater clarity as to how
  254. we regulate tokens, whether they should be regulated as securities or not. And you know, the SEC is working on that
  255. today. And that's not a something that can be easily defined in a statute in a couple of paragraphs because it depends
  256. on does the token represent an interest in the business, is there a capital raising going on, how might the token
  257. change over time, things like that. And the third thing we need to do is again make sure our rules on things like how
  258. you tokenize assets and how you keep records and how you custody uh tokens and how clearance and settlement works.
  259. We want to make sure our rules work for this technology. Again, they shouldn't be promoting it excessively, but they
  260. shouldn't be inhibiting it either. Jessica. >> Um yeah, I I agree that is a that is a
  261. great vision and that that is absolutely where where we want to get. Um uh I will
  262. just bring up the um the case of the exchange traded fund. So that was a case where there was an innovation and it it
  263. solved a very real problem and now these are very a very important part of our financial system and this is a
  264. completely different situation but I think it's it is similar in the sense that we've seen an innovation and it
  265. exists to solve problems that actually people have and they like it for that reason. So a path towards bringing this
  266. into the regulatory system I think is key and um I think that the the three elements which probably will involve
  267. some kind of temporary relief as is what's happened with ETFs um that that will probably be part of it. Um also you
  268. know the the sort of chicken and egg problem. Um and I think if if these three elements are solved I think we'll
  269. be on our way. One of them is decentralization. Um, one is uh the the the fact that non-securities and
  270. securities are going to be traded together. That ties very intimately into this question of the fact that um the
  271. CFTC currently does not have the authority to act as a regulator in the same sense as the SEC over um
  272. nonsecurity markets. Um and uh lastly, you know, what do you do about the fact that these are um you know, the
  273. unregistered trading on nonregistered ex platforms? Um so I think solving those three pieces which will involve
  274. some tricky line drawing at least in the short run. Um that's what I would like to see.
  275. >> Yeah. Yeah, and if I could just add maybe a word on the decentralization point um because I agree that is one of
  276. the aspects of the technology that is quite novel quite interesting and the question though is what do we really
  277. mean by decentralization and what is truly decentralized finance? Um clearly if you have software protocol that
  278. operates autonomously that people can use on their own without going through an intermediary you would call that
  279. decentralized. But what we actually see in the world is a lot of what even commissioner Hester
  280. Pur who's quite sympathetic to the crypto industry recently called Dino decentralized and name only. uh because
  281. you have that protocol but then you have a business that's facilitating how people use it or a business that's
  282. administering or maintaining that and and that's where it's important to I think take the position that look
  283. decentralization doesn't equate to a regulatory pass. We have to think about what is the activity that's taking place
  284. and how do we achieve the same regulatory objectives. Now, maybe some of those objectives we don't worry
  285. about. If I'm custodying my own assets, then maybe I don't worry about, you know, what someone might do with them
  286. because I'm holding on to them. But, you know, we still want market integrity. We
  287. still want to prevent fraud and manipulation. And it's not the case that just because it involves some kind of
  288. autonomous software that we should say, okay, no regulation. We just have to figure out who are the actors who are in
  289. a position to meet some of our regulatory objectives and how do we meet those. >> Yeah, those are great points and uh
  290. certainly the issue of decentralization is central uh to this uh fintech revolution and digital assets uh more
  291. generally. Uh and this is certainly something to to think about how the financial system is going to look like
  292. going forward and how decentralized it's going to be. But yeah, I think we have to to stop here. So, thank you very much
  293. Tim and Jessica for this very thoughtful conversation on regulation and decentralized finance, digital assets,
  294. how regulation is affecting the innovation and what we should expect from regulation uh going forward. As I
  295. mentioned, we have been discussing these issues in the Walton initiative on financial policy and regulation whiffer
  296. and we have a few white papers that have been commissioned to talk about regulation uh in this uh space and
  297. there's certainly a lot uh to think about here and we will continue the discussion of uh digital assets in uh
  298. other episodes uh of this uh future finance uh podcast. So uh thank you everyone for listening.
  299. >> Thank you. Thank you.

Brief Summary

Experts discuss cryptocurrency regulation, challenges, and the future of digital assets in finance.

Key points

  • The Future of Finance Podcast. Exploring the impact of cryptocurrencies and digital assets on finance.
  • Regulatory Challenges in Crypto. Experts discuss the complexities of regulating digital assets and the need for clarity.
  • The Genius Act and Stable Coins. The Genius Act aims to regulate stable coins, requiring full reserves and conservative investments.
  • Regulatory Challenges in the US. Discussion on the US regulatory landscape compared to Europe, highlighting challenges and progress.
  • Future of Digital Assets Regulation. Experts discuss the future of regulation in digital assets and the need for a balanced framework.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes