Stagflation Fears, Rate Cuts, and Fed Independence Explained
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE Patrick Harker, former Philadelphia Federal Reserve President and Wharton School Dean, and current Wharton Professor of Operations, Information, and Decisions and Director of Academic Engagement at Penn Washington, covers key takeaways from the Jackson Hole symposium, rate cut forecasts, views on federal independence, and what economic issues Americans should be keeping their eyes on.
ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.
#jacksonhole #federalreserve #economicpolicy ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Well, the Federal Reserve is drawing quite a bit of attention these days with any potential decisions around interest
- rates, uh, the recent Jackson Hole Symposium, and the question of the Fed's independence. Pleasure to have joining
- us to talk about all of those topics, Patrick Harker, who's former Philadelphia Federal Reserve President,
- former Wharton School dean, and back at Wharton as a professor of operations, information, and decisions, as well as
- director of academic engagement at Penn, Washington. Pat, great to talk to you again. How are you?
- >> I'm great. Thanks for having me. >> So, you were out in Jackson Hole. So give us a sense of of everything that
- went on there and obviously the comments by uh chair pal after the symposium was
- completed. >> So I think there are some shortrun and long run um feelings that I take away
- from Jackson Hole. In the short run uh there are clearly the the chair did signal openness to a September cut. Um
- personally I'm a little skeptical about that. I think that the data is very mixed. kind of feels a little like
- stagflation light is upon us. Now, I hope that's not the case. It's not the 1970s. Let's be clear, right? We're not
- talking about that kind of stagflation, but you know, inflation's running above target. It just seems to be stuck there,
- maybe even drifting up. Uh unemployment is hanging in there. We're not seeing any real move there. Uh quits are easing
- some, so people clearly feel a little jittery. On the consumer side, uh the Philly Fed just put out its most recent
- life survey. Uh this is a survey we started when I was there, the labor, finances, and expectation survey of
- consumers across the country. And that's not it wasn't great. Net optimism is down. There's clearly people who are
- either cutting back on discretionary spending. Some are cutting back on >> spending they have to do um and they're
- skipping payments increasingly. Uh the sentiment is the lowest it's been for quite a while actually since the
- inception of the survey. So there's a there's an there's a funk I would say use a technical phrase right there's a
- funk that's settling in that's disturbing. >> Yeah. And so from that perspective, does
- it make you think that, you know, is there a rate cut probably more in line in the near future? And I
- I'll keep that wide near future doesn't necessarily have to be September, but at
- least sometime by the end of this year because of some of those dynamics you see.
- >> So my last SP, which was June, the the dot plot, the survey of economic uh projections, I had two forecast, two
- rate cuts in for this year. I still think that's probably right. So, uh, we pro we need to start easing down. The
- other part that isn't getting a lot of attention, the Fed did slow the reduction in the size of the balance
- sheet uh on purpose. Um, I would be in the camp of just stopping the reduction altogether right now. Just sit there for
- a while and go flat in terms of the size. Liabilities will eventually build up and drain reserves more. So, I think
- there's some things they could do, but dramatic cuts right now don't seem in the forecast. I just don't see it.
- >> Where do you think that target number is then for the Fed? And obviously, some of
- this is still a moving target because of the dynamics in the economy, but I think
- a lot of people have a belief of, you know, if we see the Fed eventually, and it may be over a two-year window in that
- three to three and a half% range that maybe that ends up being the target. >> Yeah. So it all depends on where you
- think the real the our star is, right? The real rate, the neutral real rate. And there's wide divergence of opinion
- in the economics profession and on the street about that. Some of it's betting on productivity gains from AI and that's
- possible. Um others are more pessimistic thinking it's still hovering around 0.5
- to 1%. So if you in that if you're in that camp then you're looking at a neutral rate a nominal rate of the Fed
- funds rate of three three and a half roughly. >> What do you what do you think are the
- areas that obviously the leaders of the Fed the governors will be focusing on but for us on the outside
- because it seems like business news and business data is more uh on our fingertips than ever before but what are
- some of the areas that we should be kind of keeping our own eyes on. So, this gets to my second point. It is a point
- that may sound heretical and so I be clear, but stop obsessing about 25 basis points up or down with the Fed fund
- rate. I understand bond traders, this is your business. This is how you make a living. But the problems we have in the
- economy are not the Fed. That the problem is not the Fed. The Fed knows what it's doing. It will make mistakes.
- Sure, we make mistakes from time to time, but that's not where the real action is. And by the way, moving the
- Fed funds rate is not going to move the rates that Americans care about, right? Credit card rates, mortgage rates, and
- so forth. In fact, if you look that since November, the 30-year rates gone up what, 32ish, you know, over 32 basis
- points. The 10 years been flat. And given how much supply we're going to be putting into the market with the deficit
- spending, why would you expect the long rates to come down anytime soon? Unless you see a big surge in demand, which I
- don't see. So, you know, the administration can ask all they want for the rates to come down, but the Fed
- doesn't control the long end of the yield curve, the the end that people care about. And why is that the case?
- Well, there are broader economic issues that I'm concerned about. One of the themes of the Jackson Hole meeting was
- our our fertility rate and the issue of will we have the labor force. We're not replacing ourselves. We are going down
- in terms of the size of the labor force because we with immigration net immigration turning negative. Now, I'm
- not commenting on whether that's a good idea or bad idea socially, but economically it's not a good idea. We
- are going to and our friend Ken Smeters in the penorton budget model has done an
- analysis of this. It's just not moving the needle in the right direction with where we are with economic policy.
- >> Before I let you go, I did want to approach the topic of Fed independence, which is obviously on a lot of people's
- minds right now. Uh with all that we have seen gone on, the back and forth between the White House and the Fed, how
- are you viewing what we are seeing play out right now? >> Oh, it's not it's dangerous. very very
- dangerous for the country. There's never been a case where breaching the independence of the the bank over the
- long run, the central bank, ours or anywhere in the world, has turned out well. It just doesn't happen. When
- political interference gets into the business of the central bank who has to do things that people don't like from
- time to time, uh like raise rates, that it puts us in a dangerous position. Now that said, the Fed, every central bank
- has to earn the right to be independent. It's not something that we just take for
- granted. And we earn that right by doing our job all the time. And also, I put this in a Wall Street Journal piece
- recently. The independence is also incumbent upon the American people realizing what the
- Fed can do and what it can't do. often because of some dysfunction we see in other parts of government, the Fed is
- asked to do things it simply is not legally allowed to do and frankly can't do. For example, we could move the long
- end of the yield curve if we went into a quantitative easing cycle, but we only do that in an emergency. And it's hard
- to argue we're in an emergency right now. >> So be clear on what the Fed can do, but
- also be clear on what the Fed can't do. So when you criticize the Fed, you may not be criticizing the Fed. You may be
- criticizing conditions that you think the Fed can solve, but it's not designed to solve those.
- >> Pat, always great insight and uh obviously great to have you back at Wharton. All the best and look forward
- to talking to you uh in the months ahead. >> You thank you Pat Harker, former Philadelphia Federal Reserve President,
- former Wharton School dean, and currently uh professor of operations, information, and decisions here at the
- Wharton School.
Brief Summary
Patrick Harker discusses Fed interest rates, Jackson Hole insights, and the importance of Fed independence.
Key points
- Fed's Potential Rate Cut. Chair Powell signaled openness to a September cut, but skepticism remains about the data.
- Consumer Sentiment Decline. Recent surveys show consumer optimism is at its lowest since inception.
- Fed Independence at Risk. Political interference with the Fed could lead to dangerous outcomes for the economy.
Episode highlights
- Fed's Potential Rate CutChair Powell signaled openness to a September cut, but skepticism remains about the data.“I think that the data is very mixed.”0:54Sep 5, 2025
- Consumer Sentiment DeclineRecent surveys show consumer optimism is at its lowest since inception.“Net optimism is down. There's clearly people who are cutting back.”1:49Sep 5, 2025
- Fed Independence at RiskPolitical interference with the Fed could lead to dangerous outcomes for the economy.“Breaching the independence of the bank is dangerous for the country.”6:44Sep 5, 2025





