An Outsider's Inside View of Apple
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
In the days and weeks before the new iPad was announced, the media was rife with rumors about what Apple fans could expect next. But few might know that Apple employees were among those who waited anxiously to find out what their own company had planned. Knowledge@Wharton recently had an opportunity to talk with Adam Lashinsky, a senior editor at Fortune magazine and author of Inside Apple: How America's Most Admired -- and Secretive -- Company Really Works, for a rare glimpse into one of the world's most innovative companies. 📂 Technology
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] [Music] Adam thanks so much for joining us today thank you for having me great well uh so
- we're talking about your book and uh I I read in in what you said that Apple didn't make available Steve Jobs Tim
- Cook or any Apple executive or employees for interviews in your book uh so you've
- written inside apple as it were from outside Apple yes how did you manage to do that well I um I interviewed many
- many many people who worked at Apple at some point and also their partners and suppliers and other people who've dealt
- with them in one way or another my bias for the research on the book was over the last 15 years I I wanted since I was
- since I wrote a book about how Apple operates I wanted to talk to people who uh who were there while they were in
- their their radical wonderful transformation since 1997 so I spoke with very senior people and very Junior
- people and everybody in between and my perspective on that is that their perspectives were as valuable to my task
- as what I would have gotten had I had senior level interviews with apple Executives so uh of course apple is so
- close closely ident identified with Steve Jobs he was such a larger than life person and so closely identified
- with the company's identity uh how has Apple changed and not changed after he passed away last year so far Apple has
- not changed much at all so because there's such intense interest in the company I I feel like the people who
- watch Apple are grasping at straws to try to discern a change so there have been Little Things Tim Cook the new CEO
- instituted uh us philanthropic uh matching Grant shortly after he became CEO and before before Steve Jobs died uh
- more recently Apple has begun has announced that it is going to begin paying a dividend for the first time in
- many years and people want to latch on to these things and say ah this is the new Apple and I don't believe it for a
- second these are changes sure but Apple was changing all the time I think the culture their ways of doing business
- their tone their behavior uh everything is exactly in place for the time being from the way it was when Steve Jobs died
- do you think it should change I I think Apple will change it will have to change
- if for no other reason because it's so much bigger and so much more complex than it than it was 15 years ago when
- Steve Jobs came back to the company that he had co-founded so um should it change
- sure they will have to adapt to a new reality of being big of having more scrutiny for example their secrecy will
- become more more difficult over time and I suspect they will try an intelligent approach to adapting to that difficulty
- rather than just trying to hold things off as long as possible we'll come back in a bit to the question on secrecy
- about which I have a few questions but for now why don't we talk about Tim Cook and his leadership style u do you have a
- sense of how is uh how cook is putting his stamp on Apple and how he should in some ways think different by not
- emulating jobs and everything he does one thing that cook has going for him is that he is not Steve Jobs and my
- impression of the man is that he's not confused at all about this he is extremely different from jobs in almost
- every way he's not an emotional person he doesn't have a creative or artistic background the the way jobs did he's
- passionate about Apple he's passionate about business he's passionate about operational excellence some of the
- things that that have made Apple great so um I I think eventually he will put his stamp on Apple in that it will
- [Music] um it will it will be more professional and that it will do more things and it
- may be more evenhanded and less quirky but I think he'll do these things over time and how and what ways is he
- different than jobs cook is different from jobs in in almost every way so uh educational background
- demeanor um the things that they're personally interested in so cook has cook is a is a workaholic as was jobs
- but he's somebody who doesn't have a lot of outside interests he's interested in
- uh Fitness and and in sports and then not much else he doesn't seem to be interested in the Finer Things in life
- jobs let a relatively simple life for a multi-billionaire but did have some some
- expensive habits and tastes jobs was a product person and there's no indication that cook is uh now let's come back to
- the question of uh secrecy uh as as we all know Apple's corporate culture is notoriously and even obsessively
- secretive uh what do you think are the pros and cons uh for Apple well let's start with the pros of of secrecy um
- secrecy taken to its EXT dream as Apple does makes Apple an incredibly focused and disciplined company it's people do
- not typically multitask they focus on one thing they don't get distracted because they're trying to pay
- attention to somebody else's business they pay attention to their business and and only that Apple does a very good job
- of not letting its competitors know what it's working on and apple does a very good job of not confusing customers by
- causing them to anticipate what the next new thing is going to be and then causing those customers not to buy the
- products that are on the shelves now um there's obviously a negative of this secrecy apple is so secretive internally
- they keep secrets from each other at some point you would assume that that would hurt morale that that would make
- people not feel good about working at a place where they're where they're treated like uh horses fitted with
- blinders on they're not supposed to look right or left they supposed to just charge forward uh playing for a winning
- team or or having a winning team has covered up what we might otherwise expect to Bubble Up in terms of poor
- morale up until now i' heard from some people that Apple has been known to hire people into fake jobs did you to find
- out any of that in your reporting yes I I refer to these as dummy positions in other words you're told that you're
- coming to work at Apple you may even be told broadly what kind of project you might be working on but you're not told
- specifically what you're being hired for the fact that you've been vetted and that you've been hired to work at Apple
- should be good enough for you for the time being and furthermore even though we've hired you frankly we haven't
- decided if we can trust you yet and once you're learned once we figured out that
- you can be trusted then you'll get the uh you you'll find out the specifics of your position is cook as obsessive about
- secrecy as Jobs used to be uh there may be reason to believe that cook is more obsessed with secrecy we'll find out but
- as secretive as Jobs was he would go ahead and Spill the Beans when he felt like it so he would give press
- interviews and he would explain what was going on at Apple and he did this in an
- orchestrated calculated way and with great great effect in terms of publicity and promotion so far there's there's
- less evidence of cook behaving that way but we don't have as much a time to look
- at and by the way it's been an extraordinarily difficult time because this his short tenure as CEO he's had to
- deal with first the resignation of of a founding genius his boss and then that person's death now continuing along the
- same uh secrecy uh uh theme the details of the iPad three sort of were known before the launch do you think this was
- an intentional change in strategy well it's interesting you refer to it as the iPad 3 because that was one of the
- rumors is that that was what that was what was known before the launch and of course Apple chose not to call it the
- iPad 3 they chose to call it the new iPad uh It's Not Unusual in past years for aspects of the of new products to leak
- out ahead of time I I think this is the dribble has become a little bit more of a flow so no it it it wasn't a huge
- shocker there were still Surprises with this announcement if we looked at the transition from from iPad 1 to iPad 2 we
- might have assumed that the iPad 2 would be phased out it's not going to be phased out of course the name the name
- also was a surprise but no I don't think it's terribly shocking that that we knew
- that they were going to go to better screen resolution these things will come out because suppliers can't be can't be
- kept completely quiet now your book has an unconventional organization chart right in the beginning called Apple
- score uh help us understand how do you think Apple's hierarchy Works do the people operate in work ways that are
- independent of the OG chart and if so how apple is a military like command and control uh organization where people
- lower down in the organization manage up they are constantly preparing their boss
- who may be preparing their boss and their boss for a presentation to the CEO or to the executive team so people below
- manage up and people at the top manage down where information is held very tightly at the top and only the only
- information that seeps down is the information that Senior Management wants to seep down which includes by the way
- rapid and thorough feedback on product development that is that is underway um so the the org chart is such that the
- CEO can reach does not have to reach far down into the organization to get very good information and I presented the or
- chart of my own design of our design actually at Fortune Magazine as a circle this isn't necessarily this this this
- does not mean that this is how Apple draws the or chart they don't draw an org chart by the way because they don't
- like org charts they don't want to disclose what it looks like but the circle enables me to show how close the
- CEO is to everybody who's doing the work in the organization uh you ask do people
- operate independently of the orc chart there is an individual contributor culture in apple and there is a history
- of people being pulled off of one group and moving on moving to another group this would not necessarily be the vice
- presidents in the in the inner or outer ring of Senior Management this would rather be typically talented uh
- Engineers whose skills would be required elsewhere now despite having almost hundred billion dollars in cash U Apple
- doesn't have a history of acquiring other technology firms unlike say companies like Cisco or Oracle is this a
- prudent strategy in the IT world Apple's uh lack of of major Acquisitions to date is beyond prudent I
- I think it's almost a a a truism uh that if this is the way the world's most valuable company does it
- then it must be it must have been prudent for them and what about the future but well let's let's let's dive
- into the past for a moment then we then we can look at the future so you're right Apple has done relatively few
- Acquisitions they have never been the kind of Blockbuster multi-billion dollar Mega Acquisitions that Google and Cisco
- and HP and Oracle and Microsoft and others have have all done they typically acquire small companies for the people
- or for the intellectual property not for the revenues and uh I I think the academic research would would bear out
- that most of these Mega Acquisitions are disas most of them hurt the culture of the
- company few of them create the vaunted synergies that they're supposed to create and so yes I I will go so far as
- to say that I do not see apple doing uh a mega acquisition for the foreseeable future and if they do it will be a sure
- sign that their culture has changed radically will Apple find it easier or harder to hire disciples without the
- lure of jobs uh Apple will find anything that requires a uh a personal touch to be
- harder without Steve Jobs Steve Jobs for all of his many qualities was an incredibly charming and charismatic
- Suitor he could woo Talent like nobody else and he would paint a very compelling Vision about why you want to
- come at work come to work at Apple now part of the script will remain and it will be accurate and it won't
- necessarily require Steve Jobs's reality Distortion field Tim Cook and others will still be able to look a recruit in
- the eye and say if you want to come do the best work of your career if you want to come to the only company that created
- the iPad the iPhone and the iPod and so on then come to Apple but I would if if by the by I think I infer from your
- question that it won't be the same if the message is not delivered by the master I would agree what do you think
- is the biggest threat facing Apple today um I think Apple's biggest threat today
- is its size and complexity this company has thrived on Simplicity it has mastered the art of Simplicity for such
- a big company but that will not be an easy trick to maintain so there are other risks they
- have good competitors who are watching them carefully competitors like Google and Samsung to name two they have to get
- the next major shift in the industry correct as they've done the last few shifts and I'm not smart enough to know
- what that what that shift is but they will need to but they also just have more balls in the air than they've had
- at any point in the last 15 years and they're either going to have to figure out how to continue to keep those balls
- in the air or they're going to need some radical new thinking about how to comp how to compartmentalize the things that
- they do you know every tech company today wants to be be like apple uh is Apple so much of an outlier
- that it's almost dangerous for them to try to emulate it and should they even try I think if companies want to emulate
- Apple they they need to take it as they they need to take a peac meal approach to it they need to write down what they
- perceive to be Apple's attributes as I write them down in the book and then and then ask themselves can we do this or
- can't we do do this um not every company is going to have the courage to bet the
- company every 3 or four years on one major product uh as Apple has done successfully I think every company can
- say to itself are we doing a good enough job of saying no when we evaluate a new
- project or have we said yes too easily because that's a Hallmark of Apple I think every company can say are we being
- clear enough in our message and are we being tight enough about uh about how we deliver it I think every company can say
- have we adequately or sufficiently focused our people on their task do we care that our people are off doing this
- and off doing that maybe that's a part of our company's culture we're and we're going to continue but maybe that is
- something where we want to be more like apple and the list goes on like that one
- last question uh what was your biggest surprise in writing this book my biggest surp surprise was my realization about
- Apple's internal secrecy I understood external secrecy I understood already that they want to keep secrets from
- people like me what I didn't understand until I researched it was how much they try to keep secrets from each other it's
- astounding how little information an Apple employee has that's why by the way Apple employees go to a a c company
- cafeteria to watch Major product Launches on closed circuit television because they don't know
- what the what's being announced in public that day even if they worked on the product they typically only will be
- familiar with some feature or subfeature on the product I think um there's an you
- know people people thinking about this will see an obvious downside that can't be good for someone's esteem to be so in
- the dark all the time on the other hand um I I came to have an understanding of how focused Apple employees are because
- of this internal secrecy because because of this lack of information I'm not sure
- that it's a model for other companies to follow but I think it ill illustrates Apple's Excellence really well Adam
- thanks so much for speaking with us today it's been my pleasure thank you [Music]
Brief Summary
Adam Lashinsky discusses Apple's culture, Tim Cook's leadership, and the impact of internal secrecy on employees.
Key points
- Apple's Transformation Post-Jobs. Apple has not changed much since Steve Jobs' passing, despite public speculation.
- The Secrecy Culture at Apple. Apple's internal secrecy is so intense that employees often don't know what others are working on.
Episode highlights
- Apple's Transformation Post-JobsApple has not changed much since Steve Jobs' passing, despite public speculation.“I don't believe it for a second these are changes sure but Apple was changing all the time.”2:21Apr 4, 2012
- The Secrecy Culture at AppleApple's internal secrecy is so intense that employees often don't know what others are working on.“It's astounding how little information an Apple employee has.”16:45Apr 4, 2012
Tension
40/ 100Low tension





