Rightsizing Support Functions Part 2

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. can you give an example of a company that managed to figure that out and then how they went in and change things I can
  2. give describe one that I feel there it did it extremely well and the so the year the onset was that that there was a
  3. logistics company and a liner what we call it so transporting large pieces of on huge vessels across the oceans and
  4. this is a difficult industry and a lot of cost pressure and they basically took out whatever they had in their
  5. operations or at least they felt they had taken it out and here but it still wasn't good enough and discussions
  6. around further cost reduction were difficult because people who are arguing I've already taken out ten twenty thirty
  7. percent of my cost of my people and what then happened was that the CEO said well
  8. then if that's at the end of where we can get to then we'll change this so i will change the whole environment in
  9. which we run our companies so they moved from a very localized country by country
  10. set up and said we will now as of now run it on a global scale certain things will be global enter and there for
  11. example sales or services or there they also took out all the support functions and drove them on a global scale so let
  12. now allowed people first of all to have a completely different view and things and end question do we really need this
  13. on a local level do we really need to have an HR department doing recruiting in germany or is it good enough to do
  14. that for western europe and thereby have a completely different discussion that previously in the old environment in the
  15. old governance structures didn't just didn't happen and thereby i think what the what the real success was that there
  16. wasn't just maybe getting another five percent through a different global structure but it enabled another
  17. critical questioning of what do we really need where do we move to and how can we how can we change our whole
  18. delivery model and thereby they actually created another twenty-five percent savings on top of
  19. what they had done before companies that have been successful overall with this what what what are some of the
  20. approaches that they took to figure out the right thing to do right in general when you embark on such a journey I
  21. think the first and foremost critical thing is that you'll understand and agree in your senior leadership what
  22. your aim for is this another let's say five percent cost take out with keeping everything where it is or are we talking
  23. about a radical transformation and durand and thereby changing not only what's happening in the support
  24. functions but also indirectly what's happening in the whole business and and that needs to be discussed first so
  25. that's all about scope that's about speed how quick do we need to see results how much do we want to see and
  26. how much do we want to involve the organization so these are critical questions that leadership should ask
  27. themselves and align on so that later when things start to roll they can actually compare and adjust according to
  28. the principles they've lied laid out at the beginning so once that's are such a discussions taking place and agree then
  29. it's important to take stock and really understand where is our starting position where do we actually jump from
  30. and and then decide how far are we going to move as i said before like a cost target or speed that needs to relate to
  31. a baseline so you say well I want to take out twenty-five percent of costs over three years and the cost to achieve
  32. is allowed to be whatever the annual savings then you get a very clear breakdown of what needs to happen over
  33. what sort of time and thereby also a good understanding of which methodologies which approach can you
  34. actually use in order to achieve that which is the next step so we often find her in these discussions that people
  35. have things in their mind that they want to do like I want to engage the whole organization
  36. at the same time they want to change the the setup enter and move things to India
  37. so it will be difficult to involve everyone and ask them whether they want to move their job to India so there are
  38. certain things which are contradictory and we once you've you've set your mind on certain goals you need to make sure
  39. that your your approach to achieve them actually fits it that sounds are a bit trivial but you often find that there's
  40. there's these processes which are in terms of engagement in terms of duration in terms of swiftness of execution they
  41. don't match what the original goal of other companies so once you have that plan established what are the next steps
  42. supposing you are you have set your targets then the next step is to really work on detailed plans to deliver
  43. against these targets and once these have been are developed it's a rigorous management process of making sure it
  44. happens enter and there we always sir try to remember our our clients that the key after some stage is not to do your
  45. change but to arrive at your goal because after some time you can often find in a header I worked with a bank in
  46. Germany enter they were so stuck on on basically doing a certain change that they forgot to monitor what they
  47. actually try to achieve enter and before they actually implemented that sort of change they had already arrived
  48. coastwise at the point where they want it to be and then you can have a discussion whether it's really useful to
  49. let go of another 300 people or whether you want to do that at another time or not at all so it's always key to keep
  50. focusing on where you want to get to so at the other end if there's a cost lift up due to other effects inflation
  51. whatever you adjust your plans so you arrive at at your target and last but not least enter and that's sir I think
  52. core is to use such a such a drive to foster different kind of thinking a different
  53. philosophy so the sale of how did you look at cost and thereby make sure you don't have these big programs all the
  54. time or every two years but you have a continuous discussion around best use of resource as discussed before between
  55. units so the ones who produce and the ones who take it both on a budgeting level on a quarterly level so you really
  56. make best use of your enterprise resources especially at the support function level so let me ask you when
  57. you go into a company as a consultant how do you actually observe that there's an efficiency there what is it you look
  58. for how do you see it you mentioned that sometimes the waste is invisible it's not like laying around on the shop floor
  59. we look at it through four lenses well number one is we measure how many resources are attached to certain
  60. activities so how many HR people do recruiting number two is we look at organizational structures how deep is it
  61. how spread is it typically you find her that if there are two spread or two deep
  62. in the organization then they are inefficient number three we look at what do they deliver so what sort of key
  63. process indicators or key performance indicators do we find how long does something take how long does it take you
  64. to get your monthly closing how long does it take you to do your budget how long does it take you to actually get
  65. someone hired if you have an open position and lastly number four we look at the internal way of looking at the
  66. quality of service what's the feedback that HR gives finance what's the feedback that procurement gives
  67. controlling about the quality of service the timing the level of service and so on so if you look at those four lenses
  68. and you evaluate them it gives you a really good picture where the real problems lie enter and how to overcome
  69. them so could you give an example of a company that that actually did that so we worked with a chemicals company in
  70. Europe and what we found just taking their finance in their HR function that they had very different
  71. so the finance function was actually very lean very narrow structured in their in their organization but they
  72. didn't get involved in any kind of business related needs so they didn't provide the numbers that people needed
  73. to do sales forecasting due to proper client based budgeting to do proper pricing and so on so they they were not
  74. lacking on the cost side but they were lacking on the content side what do they deliver on the other end there was the
  75. HR department who was seen as very receptive they were always there if you require them there they were very
  76. friendly and but they were inefficient so it took them very long to do anything like a recruiting process took for three
  77. months shouldn't take longer than six weeks to find the right person they were way too many they were actually twice as
  78. many than you would assume from an industry benchmark and their structure was complex and complicated so within
  79. the same company but under different and a different leadership and and with different history you can find very
  80. different issues that require then different approaches to actually get them into a state of excellence what are
  81. the most typical inefficiencies in companies on a support function level I think the most most important lever is
  82. to get the service level discussion between those who provide a service and those who actually take it up going and
  83. thereby reduce service levels to the right degree so when you look at let's say a total saving range of your savings
  84. being a hundred percent work and safe you'll probably get about thirty to forty percent of those savings out of
  85. that specific lever and other levers being getting a structure right getting your processes right getting automation
  86. going maybe doing some offshoring or getting the services to the right price that all all is usually only about half
  87. the size of what you get from getting the service levels adjusted to what's really needed by the business for all of
  88. these things it may vary by industry you could let us know about that but what kind of savings do
  89. you see with these companies when they take on a program to really go into this deeply and and make changes so what we
  90. typically I think that our average program which would yield a saving of about twenty-five to thirty percent
  91. let's on the one hand not being too radical but on the other hand also being a worthwhile to actually engage on the
  92. discussion whether things need to change or should we just take out for example five percent then you often see people
  93. just changing mine herb it's not really questioning themselves just doing a little bit on the fringes and trying to
  94. get everything through the door as previously so twenty five to thirty percent on the cost side and in addition
  95. I think that the biggest side effect is that you get a different culture of discussing things and thereby quicker
  96. decisions much quicker decisions to cut decision time by half for example and a lot of better understanding of what the
  97. other person is actually doing so how do we provide real support as a support function to the business instead of
  98. being a bureaucratic burden on someone and and so there's a lot of indirect benefits from a process where you engage
  99. the organization not just the support function but also the the the units that work with those support functions so
  100. that the intact and develop a new way of working so you have a one-time reduction
  101. in cost which may continue throughout the years but you've also set up a situation where maybe some of those
  102. inefficiencies that crept in those layers of complexity are less likely to creep back in executive exactly so what
  103. you try to do and we will all be in human beings will never fully succeed is to reduce the level of the era of the
  104. old problems coming back enter that so so structures becoming more complex governance becoming more complex people
  105. just being added on and thereby creating complex processes and information flows so all of this being trimmed down
  106. to an acceptable level keeping in mind that for many companies cost is important but cost is only a means to
  107. actually achieve revenues so they're in the business that might be growing that might be expanding you might acquire
  108. things so it's important to look at cost enter and these support functions but it's important to look at them in the
  109. way not only as a cost Center but in way of enabling the other functions to deliver their best what do you find top
  110. leaders the top team struggles with the most as they approach a program like of cost-cutting like this in my observation
  111. the biggest issue that we find is it there is little alignment on the actual goals that such a program is is having
  112. and so the real underlying issues that you try to address they often paste it over by we need to save twenty percent
  113. and then people trying to push their own agenda indirectly by saying this is in scope this is out of scope we have to do
  114. this we have to do that but it only comes out over time so misalignment or not existing alignment at the beginning
  115. think it's the biggest issue that we observe to hinder these on on a senior management level and the second one that
  116. sir that's key for such a program to to succeed is then to engage over time and not to declare victory when you've
  117. basically only started to see how it could work so I think the really sticking with it supporting your people
  118. pushing them but also then a pet on the back where it's required and helpful is extremely it is extremely helpful and
  119. powerful in order to make such a program a success the companies that get it right what is it that they do
  120. differently what's their approach there when you get into a company who are who is performing well I think we see two
  121. elements one is two really open an open arena to discuss core issues on a senior level so they
  122. discuss that doesn't mean that it's this is basic democracy and everyone can then
  123. raise their hand and then they take a vote they can still have a very hierarchical decision process but
  124. there's an open discussion to get the real issues out and then a line on it and then everyone pulls on the same side
  125. of the rope into the same direction so that's number one and there's a number two is to actually bring that down one
  126. level deeper into the organization there were three levels where people between various functions intact so to get them
  127. to a line on what they want to achieve rather than on what they are doing so a goal-oriented thinking process
  128. goal-oriented and solution-oriented rather than I need to deliver step one two three four and then I hand it over
  129. that makes difference between a well-functioning company and one that's struggling in your work you've found a
  130. way to link this cost efficiency drive to shareholder value I'm curious about back and you tell us about that indeed
  131. what we saw when we looked at it by industry and in various countries it's there's there's a clear correlation
  132. between a three year total shareholder return enter the change of the air SG&A costs for sales general and Edmund house
  133. which comes close to our support function definition and there there's a bit of the question of the chicken and
  134. the egg is it good companies also have good support functions or is it good support functions creating good
  135. companies but what we believe in is there certainly a correlation between being good and having good support
  136. functions so whatever position you in aim for good support functions and it will help you drive the rest of the
  137. company and their bar also the total shareholder return okay thank you thank you for joining us it's been a pleasure
  138. to be here thanks you

Brief Summary

Corporate efficiency strategies lead to significant cost reductions and improved performance through leadership alignment and global restructuring.

Key points

  • Transforming a Logistics Company. A logistics company shifted to a global scale, achieving significant cost savings.
  • Efficiency Observations. Consultants look at four lenses to identify inefficiencies in companies.
  • The Importance of Leadership Alignment. Senior leadership must agree on goals for successful transformation.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes