A Battle of Ideas Against Terrorism

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. uh Our Guest today is Omar sa kobash the ambassador of the United Arab Emirates to Russia Omar thank you so much for
  2. joining us today at knowledge at Wharton thank you well considering that you uh you know have come from the UAE and
  3. everyone who's thinking about the Middle East these days is concerned about what's happening with terrorism we hear
  4. news reports all the time about one yet more one more beheading by ISIS I I wonder how you see the situation from
  5. your perspective uh from the region sure I think uh yeah we're all obviously very
  6. concerned about the um most recent developments with the development of Isis uh and I think um in in a sense
  7. Isis uh has has um presented a real uh development uh kind of a qualitative in a negative sense development of
  8. extremism in the region uh uh the fact that they seem to have what looks like an army uh um revenues from oil uh and
  9. what's probably the most dangerous thing about them is that they have a very very
  10. uh attractive uh reductive view of uh how Islam should progress uh and one of the worries is also um that in the realm
  11. of ideas um they provide all the correct references uh and so that in a sense they legitimize themselves by making
  12. references that are very very common in the Muslim World about the caliphate about um about fighting both the Persian
  13. Empire through Bagdad and Iran and then the West presumably representing historical Rome uh and so in in a sense
  14. they're playing uh to all of the kind of um themes uh that that we we we've been
  15. educated in so that that's what's extremely worrying um uh the other thing that I think is of of interest is that
  16. most of the public debate about Isis has been what I think is tactical um how to
  17. B them out of existence uh and this is going to take many many years uh when I think really the Strategic aim should be
  18. uh a global a global issue uh an issue for Muslims and an issue for for the Arabs to think about the set of ideas
  19. and the um the as I said the reductive uh interpretations of our own history uh and our belief system which have led to
  20. this so how do we do that if you want to take the Strategic view what is the correct response both for uh governments
  21. in the western world and for countries in the region well I think the first thing to do is to recognize uh that
  22. there is a strategic element that hasn't been addressed which is the realm of ideas um and we've heard about it ever
  23. since September 11th that the realm of ideas is where the battles really need to be fought uh and that's part of the
  24. reason why I've continually personally been very interested in where this is going and so we often hear about
  25. moderate Islam moderate Muslims and I regard myself as as a moderate Muslim um and there's frequently called on
  26. moderate Muslims to stand up and and and say something uh and that's pretty much
  27. where it ends so moderate Muslims will appear on television on news uh broadcasts and they will make an appeal
  28. to other moderate Muslims to say something but they themselves don't say anything so in a sense I think uh we
  29. moderate Muslims have done Islam a disservice by not providing a a a clear framework for uh young men and women
  30. whether they're in the west or in Indonesia or in the Arab world to really deal with um the problems of modernity
  31. uh uh the exist existential crisis that young men will will will face when they haven't got a job they haven't got a
  32. wife or they haven't got you know any opportunities so how how how do we take Islam as this moderate force and provide
  33. sustenance to them rather than uh providing uh an extremist version uh of Islam that that uh that um satisfies
  34. their anger and their and their uh need for um Vengeance of some sort so I think
  35. we need to really tackle that um and there have been a couple of attempts um for example recently there was uh a
  36. conference of Peace in Islam and that took place in Abu Dhabi and it was under the uh um uh organization of the
  37. Ministry of Foreign Affairs so we had um Islamic uh clergy theologians uh thinkers from across the Middle East uh
  38. and they got together and they they did have this two-day conference um but the the question is are they able to really
  39. tackle the issues of Arab and Muslim youth uh now I'm somewhat sort of hesitant about giving them uh uh 100% on
  40. that I think that perhaps it's time for uh uh people of Goodwill um young men and women who are concerned about uh
  41. where their religion is taking them uh to start thinking for themselves outside of you know theological circles and
  42. outside of religious authority to begin to really think of uh how we can um interpret uh our traditional Islam into
  43. modern terms yeah I mean obviously what you saying about the the war at the level of ideas if you can call it that
  44. or at least the debate at the level of ideas is extremely important uh but do you believe that the situation
  45. especially with Isis and I'm not singling them out with other aspects of uh you know extremist thinking have gone
  46. beyond the realm of just debate and and need some sort of political or even military solution and if so what should
  47. that be well I I I wasn't suggesting that uh there shouldn't be tactical Solutions uh for for the short term or
  48. whether they're military or or other uh but what what is worrying is that Isis um in a sense represents a breakthrough
  49. for extremism yes uh and they in their ideology do not actually differ that much from other other groups uh who are
  50. often called moderate uh by the Western press uh who have the same goals uh the same intentions uh but who are described
  51. as being more pragmatic uh ready to make compromises with the present um who we within the Arab and Muslim Community
  52. know that um they actually have precisely the same same goals uh which which is essentially uh intolerant and
  53. and it's a very narrow world view so I'm not saying that you know you you shouldn't tackle uh the phenomenon of
  54. violent extremism right now perhaps absolutely any thoughts on how it should be tackled at the Tactical level no to
  55. be honest and I I prefer not to think about that because I don't have a any kind of security or military background
  56. that would allow me to to understand really what's happening on the on the ground so I what's the one thing about
  57. this Isis phenomenon that uh hasn't been clearly understood by the Western World which it
  58. is very important for them to understand I think uh there probably two things the first thing is that Isis is a
  59. Sunni movement within Iraq essentially uh and in a in terms of the battle between
  60. Sunni and Shia Islam uh it's very difficult for the Sydney World to say no uh and condemn
  61. 100% uh I think it's that this is one of the key kind of problems that I I find we we we face it's um we are faced with
  62. an ethical problem and a political problem and in the case of Isis I think uh essentially the political overshadows
  63. the ethical um and so we have a problem in that there is this perception that um
  64. the Iranian influence over the region is growing uh and that uh the sunnis of Iraq have genuine Grievances and these
  65. are the kind of the Warriors of the the the Sunni group so that's that's one of the key uh problems that that needs to
  66. be resolved now do you resolve that um politically by having an inclusive government uh in Iraq well that's one
  67. possible approach um but I think the the deeper and The Wider issue there is that
  68. um perhaps we should begin to think at a global level of a grand reconciliation between the Sunnah and the Shia um
  69. because we at least uh at the level of of leadership uh whether religious political leadership in the region uh
  70. have not succeeded to to reconcile ourselves with each other um and so that's one thing that I think is really
  71. very important for the global uh Community to to to look at this issue and and wonder whether it is um it is
  72. appropriate for uh 1.1 billion Sunni Muslims and 300 million Shia Muslims to be uh so divided um so I think that's
  73. that's one key issue that needs to be resolved you know it it's sometimes said it's very dangerous to make predictions
  74. especially about the future yes agreed uh but how do you think the situation will play out over the next 12 to 24
  75. months uh I i' prefer to go a little further than that if that's okay uh I'm uh actually very optimistic um about the
  76. situation because I think one of the issues is that in in our part of the world we generally try to paper over
  77. differences and when the differences are uh now etched in blood um it becomes very very clear what the consequences of
  78. our differences are um and it also becomes very clear uh what the implications of our beliefs are uh and I
  79. think that there is um a great deal of interest uh at least amongst the Youth of the Arab world to see uh a better
  80. future um it's pretty clear um that mass executions of your enemies is not the way forward so I'm actually optimistic
  81. about the future in the in the Middle East great uh I'm really happy to hear that Omar uh given your role as the
  82. ambassador to Russia you also uh have you know very interesting insights I'm sure about the situation in that country
  83. uh and especially you know the way things are going with Ukraine uh a lot of people uh all around the world have
  84. been very concerned about that situation and what it might mean uh uh in geopolitical terms I'd be very
  85. interested to hear your analysis of the situation and again how do you think it will play out interesting uh my analysis
  86. is going to be peac meal um I in in a sense I'm caught between two worlds um having a sort of a British
  87. education and being exposed to um the West in in a direct manner uh and then also having Russian Roots my my mother
  88. is Russian so I I I I'm almost given an inside track on how people are are thinking there at least at the level of
  89. kind of political decision- making so it's it's very interesting to see how uh how misunderstood different people can
  90. be uh it's also interesting to see how little they listen to each other uh and how ego plays a role in many uh
  91. many conflicts uh and you know as as a result I become very interested in the role of uh the Shameless Ambassador uh
  92. who can you know take a beating from both sides but try to uh see how people can understand each other um the the the
  93. view from Russia uh on the Ukraine uh is obviously it's colored by the historical
  94. relationship to the Ukraine it's colored also by the the collapse of the Soviet Union um and the promise that NATO
  95. wouldn't expand uh and and the it's for my Russian colleagues and my Russian friends it's very difficult to see um
  96. Russians and ukrainians actually fighting it's actually um deeply upsetting yes uh even you know even at
  97. the level of decision makers it's actually they they talk about it as brothers fighting and they are very
  98. upset um that that they know that the relationship will never be the way it used to be with the Ukraine they also
  99. see it in purely geopolitical terms I they translate Western interest in the Ukraine uh from a geopolitical um
  100. standpoint um so that that's also very interesting so let's assume that we had in this room uh Mr Putin and Mr Obama
  101. and both of them are turning to you for advice on on what they should do next what would you tell
  102. them I would tell them to watch the uh um Kissinger Charlie Rose interview he got it pretty pretty pretty straight
  103. which is leave the Ukraine come to some kind of agreement don't ask the Ukraine to take sides uh and just essentially
  104. postpone uh the day of judgment great well uh from from from the Middle East and from Russia wonder if we could turn
  105. now uh to to the UAE uh uh and and and especially some of the educational initiatives over there uh I I know that
  106. you personally were involved in in helping uh you know some institutions you know move to the the the UAE could
  107. you tell me a little bit about how you see the educational needs of the region uh today and how they will evolve over
  108. the next few years well you know again after September 11th there was this great interest Global interest and the
  109. Educational Systems of the Middle East and the Muslim world uh there's some big sort of criticis Syms of rote learning
  110. and and uh you not having a policy or of of inquiry basically not encouraging inquiry uh and so governments in the
  111. region took up uh the opportunity to invest tremendous amount of money into education now um it I'm I I criticize
  112. only from the point of view that I think we could always do better uh and the situation I see today is that we have a
  113. a large number of sort of vocational technical colleges colleges that focus on business on on on creating these
  114. opportunities entrepreneurial opportunities which is all all very useful and very interesting but what
  115. I've always wanted to see is a much broader education so um you you you can have your engineering degree but you
  116. need to be also informed by the social sciences by Philosophy by history uh to be able to place your engineering uh
  117. tradition within a context so that you know why you are building it's not purely to create economic value or
  118. purely to reinvest the uh proceeds of oil and I think that's one of the problems that we've got at the moment is
  119. that uh either whether it's in the Arabic language or whether it's in sort of English language education in the
  120. region we don't look at history as a a a place of of debate uh of opinion of proof and evidence uh we we have these
  121. again reductive histories um and so you have a checklist of facts uh a selective
  122. facts that are supposedly um to help you Orient yourself in the world uh and I think that's that's one of the key
  123. problems now why is a western uh educational institution important uh it's I I remember being told that this
  124. was a case of Western intellectual imperialism and my response to that was at least they ask
  125. questions and that's the most important thing about it uh if if we if we look at
  126. education as opportunity to be fed opinions then yes it is imperialism but if we are taught uh the art of asking
  127. questions repeatedly uh then you've got an education and that's why I still support um Western education in the
  128. region yeah I think you're so right because very often uh people think about education as uh you know something that
  129. tells you what to think rather than it should really be teaching you how to think yeah absolutely uh so uh uh if you
  130. were to think about the the role uh of uh education in the region uh and collaboration with Western institutions
  131. how has the experience been and where do you think this could lead in the future uh I think um I think the
  132. experience has been broadly positive um it's going to be interesting to to begin
  133. to see these graduates then uh fill uh places whether in government or in business uh in the region uh one of the
  134. other things is that the Emirates uh has tried to be a magnet for students from uh in the surrounding region and I think
  135. that's extremely important uh in a sense what it'll do is it'll create that kind
  136. of personal connectivity um with let's be honest Elites from Iran or India Pakistan Iraq and Saudi Arabia um and to
  137. be able to have that kind of personal understanding uh is going to be very very important I remember having a a
  138. wonderful discussion some years ago with shik nahan when he was education Minister yeah and I was all very struck
  139. by one of the things he said which is uh when I asked him the Festival of thinkers which is one of the great
  140. initiatives you have in the UAE he said we know that the oil is not going to last forever sure and when that day
  141. comes the only thing that will keep us competitive is the quality of human capital that we have and that we are
  142. able to offer in the world do you think that process is is going smoothly from your point of view and if not what are
  143. the primary obstacles that need to be dealt with that's a very interesting question you know knowing that that is
  144. actually policy of the government uh and knowing that it actually it's a policy that uh that comes out of the nature of
  145. the the leadership of the Emirates where they actually value the individual is is
  146. is very important uh what I think um is happening is again we've got these very powerful forces within the Middle East
  147. and within Islamic thinking that are pulling kids to very simplistic interpretations of the world uh and
  148. rather than you know often I think why would a Jihad or a suicide balma go and do what he does or what she does um and
  149. and I times I think that they're just very very selfish uh and lacking in responsibility now they would think that
  150. actually they're they're they're they're selfless because they're giving their lives uh and and taking full
  151. responsibility we're actually um losing your life in Jihad you know in in three months from now is the easy way
  152. out the tough one is to learn face uh daily uh troubles uh uh get married and have children bringing
  153. up children is unbelievably difficult uh these are the true responsibilities and
  154. this is the true challenge I think that people need to refocus on uh and and that's what needs to be uh raised up as
  155. a holy way of living uh rather than this whole idea of going off and blowing yourself up in the desert somewhere for
  156. as Canon fer in somebody else's game I think that's great way to sort of come back to where we started in the
  157. beginning how how do you think that message can be communicated most effectively to the Youth of the region I
  158. have to be honest I think it's going to have to come from people speaking out and speaking I'm going to be honest in
  159. in the manner that I'm speaking to you today um very often uh we we have a um we have a a traditional respect for uh
  160. somebody on a higher position whether it's a job or or in the community or uh age uh and so we don't have that kind of
  161. inter Direction I think we need to get beyond that um uh you know we've got uh you know people of my generation and and
  162. the generation before me of educated and and and well traveled uh and there's absolutely no reason uh to maintain that
  163. kind of patriarchal uh uh approach uh to youth uh and the reason I think that's it's very important that we stop um
  164. treating youth with distance is because there are recruiters out there who are making sure uh that they grab those
  165. youth from us and I think that's that's the challenge great Omar thank you so much for speaking to Wharton thank you
  166. [Music]

Brief Summary

Omar Sa Kobash discusses ISIS, education reforms, and the Ukraine conflict from the UAE's perspective.

Key points

  • Omar's Perspective on ISIS. Omar discusses the worrying developments of ISIS and extremism in the Middle East.
  • The Role of Education in the UAE. Omar highlights the importance of a broader education system in the UAE.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes