McCullough David SF

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I've always had the interest and when I first I started a bunch of things I was one of
  2. these constantly changing your majors people and I changed between applied physics is where I started and then I
  3. went to international studies but then somehow transitioned to anthropology and archeology but I always kept the
  4. interest up in international studies so kind of went from wanting to study current cultures Mo's going on to
  5. studying past cultures and what was going on there and that the constant you know urge to learn more about all
  6. societies kept me interested in forecasting in what was going on in different countries and as I said by
  7. switching all the time i went to quite a few different universities in quite a few different countries i was at school
  8. in the stars beginning utah followed by vermont and then norway then back to utah and i finished my doctorate in
  9. Scotland where I was there for seven years and then I went to Ireland for 10 years so you know constantly moving in
  10. different cultures dimmer societies different political systems it was always something of great interest to me
  11. in what I do for my day job in maritime archaeology it's a very similar thing we
  12. take the outside view we have very disparate information we have maybe a few artifacts maybe not even maybe some
  13. historical sources maybe someone stumbled upon something and just have rumors historical studies ethnographic
  14. studies and we have to take all this information and try to piece it together to come up with a solution to or
  15. explanation of what we're finding and it's very similar in forecasting I kind of approach it the same way where I'll
  16. take very disparate information um I won't take the big huge pictures that are thrust in your face I'll take
  17. outside of use and use some of the same tools that I use at work I'm a huge proponent of using GIS mapping of
  18. different issues to try to get like say it's a question that has a geographical perspective I'll make my own GIS program
  19. and basically you know put the model together that has all the contributory information from different press sources
  20. different mapping where different roads are communication routes transportation routes and it's the same kind of thing I
  21. would do in archaeology I just apply it to the future and forecasting as opposed
  22. to applying it to the past the first one was there there's almost no but I'm I'd say there's no nothing is
  23. certain that's not entirely sure there's I'm sure there's certain things that are
  24. sir but for the most part nothing is certain the other thing was don't trust one source of information but then don't
  25. discard all sources just because you think it's not valid when you're whenever you're reading a source of
  26. information if you have just one single source and is the only one saying it I didn't sometimes I wouldn't dismiss it
  27. but I would not trust it I'd look for something that would you know contribute to it or just help verify it and that
  28. can even be one of these sources where you know you see it on the intern you think wow that's really dubious these
  29. guys are you know pretty crazy but somewhere in there if you read through the whole thing there might be one
  30. sentence which collaborates what's going on in that other source that was a single source and I was like okay now
  31. I've got two independent sources so and you can start to build on that um so one
  32. of the things that would have says don't rely on the one don't discard sources just because you may think they're a bit
  33. out there and there are quite a few sources that are out there trust yours self but doubt yourself as well and
  34. always be prepared to be devil's advocate to yourself if you're working within a team that's even better because
  35. most forecasters do not have a problem being devil's advocate or we call red teaming and keep an open mind don't go
  36. into something thinking you know exactly what's going on it never seems to work out that way just when you think you
  37. know exactly what's going on it changes it'll be the main thing is just you know
  38. be open to change in dr. tetlock spoke he mentions that were in perpetual beta that is a great way of thinking of it is
  39. always be willing to change and learn and just you know go with it a lot of people get really kind of stuck in the
  40. mud on certain ideas and that's that's the quickest way to get it wrong like I said I go back and forth between
  41. the different you know venues of inquiry in archaeology and in forecasting so there has been times were one of the
  42. things that forecasting told me is it's great if you have a model but all there can always be a better model always be a
  43. better model you might have one that's showing you exactly what you want but you know if you tweak it a little bit or
  44. you say you find a new data set can always be that little bit better and I've started to apply that to some
  45. shipwreck hunts that I've been doing where we have a model on how to locate shipwrecks in areas of high probability
  46. but it can always be better so I've actually started tweaking some of the models that I use at work to add
  47. additional data sets maybe pulling things from multidisciplinary studies from geomorphology marine geomorphology
  48. riverbed hydrological processes going into shipwreck site formation and just basically in a constantly tweaking the
  49. models um there's something the other thing that I've tried to do as much as I can as I have two young sons who I'm
  50. trying to teach them how to approach different issues you know not not so much to get him in trouble at school for
  51. questioning the teacher all the time which is very possible but when they answer a question say well is that it I
  52. spoke to my son about a tree growing in a field and so how much do you think that tree is going to grow next year and
  53. you just said oh well this I said why'd you say that he's like well because just
  54. looks like well did you think about how much is it gonna rain next year how much
  55. fertilizer is the farm are going to put in that field without trees in the middle how often is he going to plow it
  56. but you know there's so many issues that surround one issue that when you hear one question there's usually you know 20
  57. 30 however many more questions that can help you answer that question so I've been trying to push it on them to kind
  58. of think that way you

Brief Summary

Dr. Tetlock discusses forecasting, archaeology, and critical thinking in information analysis.

Key points

  • The Journey of Learning. A constant urge to learn about cultures led to a diverse academic path.
  • The Art of Forecasting. Forecasting requires piecing together disparate information, much like archaeology.
  • Teaching Critical Thinking. Teaching my sons to question and think critically about issues.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes