A View From Above: Gerard DeMuro, General Dynamics

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

An interview from the recent Wharton Aerospace Conference

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] well I'm currently Executive Vice President of the Information Systems and
  2. Technology Group in General Dynamics uh it's one of four groups it's about $12 billion in Revenue primarily uh selling
  3. defense uh and military equipment around the world world to uh not only us but International customers and about 10% of
  4. the business is commercial well the topic of the conference is strategic agility and what
  5. I intend to speak about is take uh the basic components of strategic agility which I think boil down to really three
  6. three concepts having a keen sense of one's Market competition the environment the trends Technologies uh and portfolio
  7. position couple that with having the fluidity of resources both financial and human capital to take action and then
  8. thirdly with organizational alignment so that whatever action you want to take uh
  9. or whatever uh management philosophies you have or are implemented fully at all echelons put them together and see how
  10. those have been applied uh over the last 50 to 60 years in the defense industry and no surprise uh being a member of the
  11. industry for 30 plus plus years now that's what I've chosen secondly uh I will use some examples primarily from
  12. General Dynamics and try and illustrate in up cycles and down Cycles how those uh concepts of
  13. strategic agility have been used to success and some have not been so successful and maybe examine why uh
  14. we'll use some other examples of other corporations as well but in particular um we chose the last 60 years of the
  15. defense industry because it has some very defined Cycles uh at least three or four major upturns and downturns so I
  16. think it provides a good laboratory to examine corporate behavior and and what works and what
  17. doesn't first you see different players take a different position uh depending on whether or not they determine it's a
  18. structural change or it's simply a cyclical change and let me illustrate uh an example of both in the late 40s after
  19. World War II uh up until the time of uh World War II this nation pulled together
  20. an army and a force to protect its natural interest or project its uh forces around the world when it felt
  21. threatened or when it had in action uh in the Philippines wherever after that war basically that Arsenal was and the
  22. forces were uh drawn down and defense budget and defense spending went down tremendously this even occurred all the
  23. way way through World War II uh World War I rather where after World War I we geared up then there was a huge draw
  24. down in forces a reduction in spending and we went into kind of an isolationist policy post World War II with the Cold
  25. War Mutual deterrence uh Russia as the uh the other pending superpower uh there was a
  26. structural change and we now kept a standing defense industry later became uh referred to as the defense industrial
  27. complex some see that as a positive some see that as a negative it's not for us to examine that but it existed so
  28. there's a structural change now there's a new threshold in that Market at that point um electric boat which had been
  29. supplying submarines Patrol boats Marine Engines uh since maybe 1899 to the defense uh firm saw an opportunity to
  30. create additional value by expanding in that market because there was going to be a new threshold and so they grew the
  31. business and they expanded into other lines that was have application to that mission so there was an opportunity to
  32. create value and grow uh in the defense Market because there was a structural change there have been other Cycles post
  33. World War II there was less spending but it wasn't going to go down as far then there's an upcycle when we had the
  34. threat in Korea similarly Vietnam Bay of Pigs uh the Reagan buildup um and then more recently with Iraq and Afghanistan
  35. so some of these uh Cycles teach us uh definitive lessons some of them are as what happens in a down cycle well
  36. applying the Strategic agility if you don't have all three components it's difficult to be a success what do I mean
  37. by that um for instance in the uh in the late 50s with the down cycle of the 50s
  38. General Dynamics said well the Cycle's going down how do I continue to grow and build shareholder value they took their
  39. ability to build uh fighter aircraft and bombers and said we're going to go into
  40. the commercial business and build two commercial Jets originally it was the 880 and then there was a version called
  41. the 990 well they had the money they certainly had the technological capability and they had alignment in the
  42. organization up and down about what they wanted to do about the strategy what they lacked was the first component a
  43. true sense of what the market conditions were over there and they're markedly different in the defense industry the
  44. way customers come to Market to buy products and service and the way you go to market to sell products and services
  45. are vastly different they misjudge that now was it a good idea poorly executed or was it doomed from the start because
  46. it didn't have the right marketing foundations I think probably more the latter than the former but there's two
  47. examples one where it was seen as a structural change an opportunity to make money one where there was a clearly
  48. defined cycle maybe not unlike where we're headed today and what seemed like a very reasonable approach we have the
  49. technology we have the the resources we got the corporate alignment seemed like a very reasonable approach it didn't
  50. work well and I think it was Norm Augustine that uh had the famous line about the uh the record of success of
  51. defense companies getting into the commercial space is almost unblemished or the record is almost unblemished by
  52. success something like that so there are lessons in both directions and that's really the essence of of the U the
  53. discussion we're going to have this afternoon that you need all three components to be successful
  54. well let's go back to your original question what kind of situation do we see ourselves in now
  55. inherently this industry uh provides one critical problem any business plan has to have a demand model and then
  56. everything is built off of that demand model history has shown that we're very good at seeing these Cycles after the
  57. fact very difficult to predict that that people like Saddam Hussein was going to
  58. invade Kuwait uh you may it's kind of like an earthquake what's happening in Egypt now you saw the tension building
  59. you know something's got to happen eventually but when how where and at what magnitude almost impossible to
  60. predict so that level of uncertainty in our industry um I think will continue for a while I think it's fair to say
  61. with the economic environment the political rhetoric we're clearly at an apex of spending in the longest runup
  62. that we've seen uh in my mind that does not mean that we are without opportunity
  63. as an industry uh to continue to have U create shareholder value uh you ask how I think we'll follow the traditional uh
  64. rules of making sure uh what a good cyclical does and it makes sure that it can execute on its backlog we'll do the
  65. right things to size the business appropriately shed excess capacity and assets but we will also look both
  66. organically and through deployment of capital Acquisitions as you say to grow the
  67. business we'll grow it in our core and we'll grow it into uh some some near adjacencies we leverage their talents
  68. skills Technologies and Innovation and in some cases we've even acquired some of those unique talents skills uh and
  69. and brought them inhouse uh because we wanted to apply them more broadly and the key is if you have that kind of
  70. innovative model in a large Enterprise how do you preserve what's created value for them and that that
  71. engine of innovation and it just doesn't get sucked into the you know the broader
  72. operating uh practices of a big platform company few years back we acquired a company uh that was actually started by
  73. two cognitive psychologists at CMU one may not see the direct correlation of of these gentlemen to uh the defense
  74. industry but they were dealing eventually in their business with what they called uh making the complex simple
  75. and a particular problem that they had lit upon was this information flow as we move an internet likee capacity to the
  76. battle space you have a commander like any other business manager who is getting information about competitors
  77. and in the case of the military about the enemy where your assets are what strategies you want to deploy or develop
  78. and how you want to deploy your ass Assets Now to counter competition or the threat so they took a commercial model
  79. and they said we're getting this information how do I how does a human being want to process it and they were
  80. looking at particular problems in the military battle space and they were also applying it to other problems like
  81. energy management and buildings to Transportation Solutions uh for big transport companies around the world
  82. think of big Logistics firms I won't mention the names but that were clients and it was how to simplify and man AG
  83. the complex and they were looking at this information problem we thought it had great applications to some things
  84. that we knew were a problem in the domain we had some expertise with our customers the military customer we put
  85. the two together and we did it in such a fashion that we left a kernel development kernel here we put the
  86. business around it a business wrapper preserve them from the usual vagaries of reporting out on a monthly basis we left
  87. that to our traditional business guys and then we used that kernel to uh Foster innovation and development in in
  88. some other areas uh it's been very very productive for us it's a company called Maya Vis um out of Pittsburgh
  89. Pennsylvania I think we talked a little bit about the business environment uh we've had the opportunity over the last
  90. 20 years to um go through some pretty large Cycles we had the procurement holidays of of the 9s where this company
  91. shed a lot of excess asset asss and an opportunity we thought to create some value for our
  92. shareholders um and then from the late 90s through the present day we've uh built the organization organically and
  93. through about o over 50 Acquisitions so we see opportunity on both the down cycle and the Up Cycle to create value
  94. for um not only our shareholders but the other two stakeholders that we have employees and our customers and continue
  95. to do that so we think that fence will be uh a good Market uh to stay in for a while we've Diversified the portfolio uh
  96. tremendously in the last 15 years I think that puts us in as good a position as everyone all portfolios have
  97. strengths and weaknesses uh no doubt ours does as well but we've also got significant exposure to commercial
  98. Aerospace which I think puts us in in good stead to balance that portfolio a little
  99. bit well uh we are always opportunistic as I said uh uh last 15 years or so we've done 50 plus acquisition so we're
  100. going to continue to be opportunistic where we think we can create value uh for our Enterprise um it it's
  101. interesting there's a little bit of a discontinuity right now between private valuations and public valuations uh we
  102. see private Equity entering the market again uh to a large extent so that'll sort itself out over time and uh you
  103. know you look back to the the '90s there were consolidators and and and there were Liquidators and I I think
  104. eventually uh as the market trims down it's a law of supply and demand if there's excess capacity the market will
  105. eventually sort itself out

Brief Summary

The episode covers strategic agility in defense, focusing on market understanding and resource management with insights from General Dynamics' experience.

Key points

  • Strategic Agility in Defense. Exploring the components of strategic agility and its application in the defense industry.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes