Japan's Corporate Comeback: New Leadership Models for Global Impact

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Japan’s corporate sector is undergoing a profound transformation driven by a shift from traditional hierarchical systems to adaptive, hybrid leadership models. This podcast episode with Wharton professors Michael Useem and Harbir Singh examines how leading Japanese firms are embracing stakeholder capitalism, long-term strategic vision, cultural reinvention, and organizational agility to regain global competitiveness. Based on insights from their new book, Resolute Japan, their discussion details examples of top executives navigating structural change, talent redeployment, and innovation across industries from manufacturing to technology.

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

#japaneconomy #CorporateLeadership #BusinessInnovation #BusinessTransformation ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Many of these Japanese companies, to us anyway, are kind of creating the future. Not only for them, but a future that
  2. we can see through them, that may be our own future. So that's why we wrote the book. Wanted to tell the Japanese— the story in
  3. Japan. People in Japan know the story. So this is really not for people who are living it. It really is for people who want to
  4. think about their own leadership, their own firm, and how they too, just like these Japanese, these turnaround
  5. resolute new leaders in Japan have turned around many companies there. Dan Loney: Welcome to <i>The Ripple Effect,</i> the podcast that takes you on a
  6. journey through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host, Dan Loney, and in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the
  7. inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have conducted and exploring how
  8. their findings resonate with the world today. Well, we know that Japan is an extremely
  9. important economy on a global scale, and it has also had a very unique corporate leadership style with
  10. its largest companies and within its government. But a new book looks at the shift going on within the country in regards to
  11. that leadership model and why there are changes afoot right now, and they are leading to an amazing comeback. Pleasure to be
  12. joined here in studio by Wharton's Harbir Singh and Mike Useem. They are part of the author trio of the new book <i>Resolute Japan:</i>
  13. <i>The Leaders Forging a Corporate Resurgence</i>. Great to see you both. Great to have you in studio.
  14. Dan, thanks for having us. So let's start with what happened and why did it happen? Harbir?
  15. So, this is just to acknowledge our third author, Professor Ikegami, from Waseda University.
  16. Japan kind of was at his peak in the stock market in the late '80s. And after that, it began to
  17. decline. And many people thought that the argument was that the companies had kind of— were wedded to the manufacturing model,
  18. which was a total quality movement and so on, but not as much in services and information technology-based businesses and
  19. so on. And what we've seen in the resurgence now is really a discovery on the part of these— several corporation's leaders,
  20. that they need to pivot to technology-based industries. Gaming, media. And they have to be— adapt the model. And so what
  21. they did was they actually brought in processes that they saw in various parts of the world and incorporated them into
  22. the Japanese model, retaining the process discipline. So you have this idea of, you know, pivoting into new industries,
  23. you know, creating a sense of tolerance for failure, but also entrepreneurial activity— which is a huge shift for them— and
  24. also then understanding that you cannot have the same hierarchies as you had before. You had to have a flatter organization. And
  25. that leaders needed to be more approachable and be more informal and seek ideas from the middle of the organization and
  26. the lower levels in the organization, and bring a sense of ferment and exploration in these companies. And the best
  27. performance— it so happened, we were studying models of management and trying to understand what's unique about
  28. Japanese-headquartered firms? Many of them are global. And we found that there were four elements. The first one was
  29. really a question of a stakeholder view of the firm. That the firm is more than just responsible to shareholders.
  30. It's responsible to customers, employees, shareholders and communities. But importantly, it's a flywheel. It kind of— they
  31. reinforce each other. And that sense of momentum is what they were trying to bring in the current reality. And the second
  32. part was the idea of learning from the— for the long run. Leading for the long run, more like 10 to 15 years. So they
  33. retained that principle. And the third one was exploration versus exploitation. Really enhancing the exploration piece and
  34. allowing for some internal venture capital. And the fourth one was really addressing inspiration of employees and
  35. bringing a sense of empowerment into the organization, and really following what we've seen in the tech world here. So that
  36. blend— really a hybrid of modern management techniques in many parts of the world and the traditional Japanese model, is
  37. what we call the hybrid leadership model that they came up with. And I know Mike will have a lot more to say.
  38. I think I would just add, Dan, that we went into this study of Japanese top management on the premise that Japan was
  39. languishing, and it was for a couple decades. Just to go back a little bit on the history of Japanese business in the '60s and
  40. '70s. Japan, around the world, became known as number one. Hugely successful companies, not just in auto making, but just
  41. about everything, including banking. And a professional colleague wrote a book called <i>Japan Was Number One</i>, which
  42. aptly described many of the methods that had carried them well through the '70s and then through the '80s. But around 1990,
  43. Japan kind of went off a cliff. And for the last three decades, it's been kind of in retreat. And as summary, to pick it up from what
  44. Harbir said, there are— the four specific points, I think, is captured by a phrase that comes from a very well-known executive
  45. coach, Marshall Goldsmith. It's a great phrase. I'm going to take it out of context. He uses it in a slightly— slightly
  46. different way than I'm going to reference it here. But he basically has said that as you look at careers develop, what
  47. got you to where you are won't get you— what got you here won't get you there, the next five or 10 years. And I think that's
  48. what happened in Japan. What got them to this "Japan is number one" status— worldwide best practice, everybody wanted to be like
  49. Japanese companies, Mitsubishi, Nissan, Toyota and so on. And I think picking up on the particulars that Harbir just
  50. offered up, over the last 20 years— or the last 30 years, really— sometimes now I'm refer to it as the lost 30s.
  51. Over 30 years, Japanese companies languishing because it's taken that long, believe it or not, to shake off what was
  52. serving them well back in the '70s and '80s, in favor of a new set of principles for leading big companies.
  53. Well, and I guess— you know, from the outside looking in, Harbir, you hear the stories about— and you kind of alluded to not accepting
  54. failure. You know, that's one of the components that you— you hear was legendary within kind of the Japanese structure for such
  55. a long period of time. I'm sure they don't accept failure, but they kind of moderate with it, now that failure is kind of
  56. a component in business. But you can become better off of it, correct? Yes, so, exactly right. And it is very much ingrained in the
  57. societal culture and history, you know that you— failure is not an option. And that goes very far in process discipline. And
  58. many companies explicitly created a sort of a context in which you could experiment, and if it didn't work, you pivot. So
  59. they kind of got into this idea of pivoting and the idea of agility. So a company called Asahi glass, which was number
  60. one in glass in the world, found that the glass industry was commoditizing, and so they needed to get into some other
  61. things. So the head of that company actually created a business development function to allow them to explore various
  62. ideas. And he had a three- element process. Materials— try new materials. Try to incubate. And try to transfer. And they
  63. went through a 10- or 15-year period of driving that. And they ended up going from glass to applications of
  64. different materials, including even life sciences. And they were able to make that transition. And that is sort of
  65. an example of retaining process discipline, but allowing for exploration, which is very interesting.
  66. In there a component of this, Mike, that, while we're speaking about this in the business perspective, that this is also,
  67. to a degree, a cultural change in terms of how Japan views itself and what it should be in the decades ahead?
  68. It's a great point in the sense that as we went into the study, just by way of a context here, we didn't have any priors as to
  69. what was happening or why it should be happening, or what kind of changes were underway. But we discovered in talking
  70. with people, say at the head of this glass company, or at Mitsubishi or Nissan, and well beyond, that a number of the top
  71. managers in these firms were kind of coming to terms with the fact that their stock price has been down, their earnings have
  72. been off, and they're really going to have to reinvent themselves. And that, in our view, is the driver. Is, a
  73. number of people— some already in office, some brought into office, with the support of their board—and by the way, Japanese
  74. governance changing along with top management in its attitude about this— saying, "Look. The old way, the old ways of running
  75. firms worked very well back in the '70s and '80s. But it's— they're doing very poorly in a much more competitive global
  76. market." And therefore they said, "We've really got to help people working for us rethink what they're doing and how they're
  77. doing it." Moving away from lifetime employment, for example, or the assumption that once you're there at a given
  78. company, you're going to be there for life, and it's just a matter of kind of regular upward procession. Many of the people
  79. we talked with said that they began that way in their own career, but they came to appreciate that if they didn't
  80. get the people working for them to really focus on what the market was doing, and getting rid of some old business that
  81. was no longer all that competitive, and appreciating that new methods of manufacturing, new materials,
  82. new products, were going to be important. They set about a long remake. And this— the remake we describe in the book actually
  83. probably goes back at least five or 10 years. And, in part, because— back to your initial point, Dan— because the culture ultimately
  84. has had to be changed as part of everything else. So a new focus on talent and its development, as opposed to taking for granted
  85. the people who are hired in by you are going to do well. They don't need a lot of coaching. A different attitude about the
  86. role of top management. In a nutshell, the old method of speaking from on high, if you were a CEO. And everybody's going
  87. to hear and apply what you want them to do in their own work life, no longer was working. And so the culture change now that
  88. is underlying all that we've said—the four particular points that Harbir referenced up earlier— we think is the— is the
  89. fundamental platform by which Japan resolutely is coming back from the disaster it faced.
  90. So how are we starting to see, then, those four points play out, Harbir, in terms of the corporations that are trying to
  91. lead this comeback right now? So one of the most fundamental things that we see among the
  92. leaders is that they're actually instilling a sense of vision that is kind of a wider aperture. It's not just that
  93. particular business, not just the product. It is kind of a set of services, a set of, you know, new knowledge that they're
  94. trying to develop. Then also, there's a sense of going beyond the traditional hierarchy, creating a greater element of
  95. informality. Interestingly, they have a lot of town meetings, the most successful. Because you need to— you need to mobilize people,
  96. you know? So almost walking— you know, and kind of walking around in shirt sleeves with a microphone in hand, not sitting
  97. at a table, and then broadcasting the message. So there's a sense of activism, a sense of momentum, inspiration.
  98. And then also accompanying that, a sense of processes and incentives and so on. And the other point that's very
  99. interesting is, as Mike mentioned, the talent part. They tend to retain talent. They of course, shut down factories.
  100. They lose talent in those situations, but they've learned how to redeploy talent. And there's a lot we can learn in
  101. our context. And it's because they have a longer time horizon to build businesses. They're a little more patient with capital
  102. in their business. So they're retaining some of the traditional Japanese skills, but modifying them.
  103. So off of something that Mike said, I think it's interesting. That component of hearing the message from on high and it being passed
  104. down to the employees, and the employees just implemented, that's unique to see that change because of how historical that
  105. is within the culture of business within Japan. - Exactly. In fact, they even said that in some cases they used to have
  106. meetings with seating charts. And they got rid of the seating charts. So it's a kind of a level of formality that is
  107. beyond anything you might imagine. And one of the leaders actually said that he used to, sort of— to make— to convey the
  108. sense of approachability, he said, you know, "I'm the one who takes out the garbage." You know, sort of— you have to say, "I'm
  109. every man, every person." You know. And metaphorically, he was saying, "All of us need to do that." You know. All of us need
  110. to be in charge of our own situation. And that, I think, was fascinating. That was, in fact, Mr. Kaz Hirai from Sony.
  111. And this— he led a 10- or 12- year horizon of changing Sony's portfolio. Sony was struggling a lot. You know, when Apple began
  112. to dominate consumer electronics. And they were not doing well so much in the— in the production, theater, movie
  113. production business. They had to change the whole portfolio of businesses. So I think that's an example. Now it's only about a
  114. third of the companies that have been able to do that. That's also interesting, because— and then I think they're the leaders. And
  115. we're presuming the others might follow. Well, I was gonna say, are— I mean, is the—
  116. is the landscape open to making change right now, more— more reticently than maybe it was,
  117. say, 20, 30, 40 years ago? I think it definitely is. Mike and I remember, you know, the early
  118. start of this work, stages. And seeing a sense of, you know, sort of some despondency that, you know, for so many years the
  119. economy has remained stagnant. And I think a sense of urgency. So I think there's a context in society where you start seeing
  120. working examples and people start emulating those. How do you think, then, when you think about leadership, of what
  121. these companies were, and now what it is and what it could potentially be, it almost feels to a little bit— a little bit
  122. like you're seeing a shift, a movement. To a degree, this will play out probably generationally, with the leaders
  123. that will be there 20 years down the road, of what these companies and what the expectations of the leaders will be in the next
  124. couple of decades? - Well, to speak to that, I think Harbir and our colleague in Japan
  125. concluded after talking with 102 of these people at the top of the chart— chief executives, board chairs and so on— that this
  126. has an amazing amount of momentum. It's happening. It's going to, I think, play out over the next five or 10 years. And
  127. even more importantly, from our standpoint, what's developing now in Japan, we think is worth thinking about, even if you're
  128. not running a company in Japan, in that they've invented— we tend to call it a bit of a hybrid. They've kept some of the
  129. old methods that worked very well. The people at the top of this particular— of these organizational charts. But
  130. they've also— I'll take one particular point here to make the point. They've also added in sort of new pieces to how they do it.
  131. For example, not sitting in the high castle and casting or pushing directives down, but actually getting out of your
  132. castle and walking around and talking with people. So we think longer term, that what's happening in Japan, it is a kind
  133. of a quiet, largely unseen revolution in how business is getting business done that is responding to changes in the
  134. workplace and the competition these companies are—and we think we can, in a sense, see some of our own future in
  135. looking at Japan. What do you think is, then, the potential economic benefit of— of
  136. having this style of leadership, this change? I mean, obviously, a lot of these companies had been successful for such a long
  137. period of time, going through the down cycles that they did, but still they're, you know, well-known, well-understood
  138. companies and brands. What does it mean for their fiscal outlook moving forward?
  139. I think that's a very, very interesting question. I think what it really says is that those who have been able to
  140. adapt see a very positive horizon. And others have a sense of urgency to sort of retire some of the— you know,
  141. the legacy assets, and move forward. And they've also seen a kind of a more— less stressful way of doing that, but a longer
  142. time. So they're understanding the hybrid model. So we think this hybrid model will actually diffuse through the economy.
  143. There are some structural elements that are still a problem, that are— it's hard to reduce employment in Japan.
  144. There are demographic challenges in Japan as well, and not much immigrant labor coming in. So they are really looking at the
  145. high tech, high value added services. And in that, I think they are doing very, very well. - Mike?
  146. Yeah, I just— I'll offer up an illustration of the same from the low tech world. In Japan, there is a chain that's very
  147. much like 7/11 over here, called Lawson. By the way, 7/11 is also Japanese-owned. Not appreciated by most Americans. And at Lawson,
  148. the new chief executive came in some years ago— not so new at this moment— took the view that the way that Lawson had
  149. traditionally run its 15,000 stores all across Japan, these convenience stores, is to say, "Look, you’ve got to stock the
  150. following items, and you've got to follow the rules coming out of headquarters down here in Tokyo. The new guy that came in—
  151. for us, kind of a paradigm of what this shift means— has said that it's a little bit nuts in that local needs are different.
  152. There are a bunch of Lawson stores, for example, up near the Fukushima area, where we had this nuclear disaster now going
  153. back to the tsunami, going back about 14 or 15 years. And he said to the stores, "Think through what people need in your
  154. area." What people needed was water, for example. They needed— they needed food, which these local stores didn't have so much
  155. of. And he just simply said, "Figure it out. Look at your customers. What do they need? You're hereby delegated to be
  156. your own leader, so to speak." So we believe that this form of delegation, intent clear, but delegation of authority to make
  157. on— on-the-battlefield decisions is a good idea. It's here to stay. It's helped turn around the stock market in Japan, which
  158. is now way, way up. That's why some large investors, including Warren Buffett, are increasingly looking to invest in Japan.
  159. Quick summary point is, this kind of quiet revolution behind the scenes, along the lines that Harbir outlined there at the
  160. very start, is happening. We think it's here to stay. We think other companies are going to pick it up. And we think it's
  161. worthwhile, if you're running a company in Japan— Japan, India, North America, Brazil, Europe, it's a good idea to take a look
  162. at what's happening in Japan. Because in some respects, I think it's our own future as well.
  163. Do the challenges, then— are they there as well? If you're taking these ideas and
  164. going to other cultures, because they will have— similarly to what Japan has had for a long time— they will have their own
  165. philosophies on how to lead, how to run companies, and— and what they believe is successful. And how receptive do you think they
  166. will be to— to bringing these ideas in? It's a great question. And I think just to pick up on that, and
  167. then, Harbir, over to you— and that is, I think we've— Harbir and I, and our third colleague in Japan, have independently come to the
  168. conclusion that one of the best ways to evolve your own leadership is look around. Other companies in the US, other
  169. companies in Brazil or China or Japan. And many of these Japanese companies, to us anyway, are kind of creating the
  170. future, not only for them, but a future that we can see through them, that may be our own future. So that's why we wrote
  171. the book. Wanted to tell the Japanese— the story in Japan. People in Japan know the story. So this is really not for people
  172. who are living it. It really is for people who want to think about their own leadership, and their own firm, and how they
  173. too, just like these Japanese— these turnaround resolute new leaders in Japan have turned around many companies there. We
  174. think that some of the— our future is seen now in Japan. Thus, good to take a look at what Japanese companies are doing. We
  175. think it's the future. - Harbir. So in fact, one of the big debates in the US today is the issue of
  176. shareholder value and purpose. Right? That you— shareholder value has a primacy. And very often, people allude to that and
  177. say, "Therefore, we are shutting down these divisions," and so on. And at the same time, in many of our corporations here, there's a
  178. sense of the pursuit of purpose as a way of, you know, attracting people and giving them something that they can be
  179. motivated by. I think the Japanese model we have here, the hybrid model, actually has a very good sort of example on the
  180. firm's role in society and kind of seamlessly working with, you know, consumers, employees and communities. And that's a well-
  181. established tradition. And I think with about half or more of the Fortune 500 trying to follow purpose with mixed results,
  182. there's actually a transferable model from these companies that we have studied to our corporations over here.
  183. Great to have you both here with us today. Thanks very much. Harbir, Mike, great to see you again.
  184. Thank you, Dan. - Thank you. The book is titled <i>Resolute Japan, The Leaders Forging a Corporate</i>
  185. <i>Resurgence</i>. And a pleasure to have two of the authors with us here in the studio today. Harbir Singh and Mike Useem, along
  186. with their cohort, JJ Ikegami. Thank you for listening to <i>The Ripple Effect.</i>
  187. We hope you found this episode informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review
  188. so that we can continue to bring you the best insight from the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Japanese companies are shifting leadership styles to embrace technology and innovation, as discussed by authors Harbir Singh and Mike Useem.

Key points

  • The Lost 30s. Japanese companies have struggled for three decades but are now on the path to resurgence.
  • A Cultural Change in Leadership. Japanese firms are embracing a new leadership model that encourages exploration and agility.
  • Resolute Japan: The Leaders Forging a Corporate Resurgence. A new book explores the shift in Japanese corporate leadership and its implications for the future.
  • Resolute Japan: A New Perspective. The authors discuss how Japanese leadership models can influence future business practices.
  • The Ripple Effect Podcast. A closing note encouraging listeners to subscribe for more insights from the Wharton School.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes