The Business Case for Diverse Leadership

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

After more than 20 years on Wall Street, Sallie Krawcheck was widely considered one of the most powerful women in banking. Recently, Krawcheck purchased the global women's network 85 Broads and has taken her experience in a new direction.

Read the full story: http://knlg.net/1roecR4 πŸ“‚ Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'm Adam Grant I'm here with Sally cotek you may know her as the most powerful woman on Wall Street she ran Merill and
  2. she also ran Smith Barney and now she's the owner of 85 broads the business Network for women Sally welcome thank
  3. you Adam talk to me for starters about your views on leadership and how they've evolved over the course of your career
  4. oh well leadership is a lot of hard work uh you know I sort of hoped when I was earlier I'd just be a natural leader um
  5. or that it was something that was innate but it's really learn skill and it's the
  6. result of I don't have to tell you thousands and thousands and thousands of micro lessons over long periods of time
  7. in which you try a little bit of leadership it worked you try this method of leadership you fall in your face
  8. somebody gives you feedback you adjust and it can be some big lessons the end of your review uh but more importantly
  9. it's those micro lessons that occur and one of the things that I'm very aware of
  10. is that that for women one of my P my passions is is women in business and helping women to get ahead in business
  11. that that feedback loop can be broken uh that women won't get as much feedback from male bosses as men will get um and
  12. so therefore they have to make an extra effort whether that's unfortunate good bad indifferent uh have to make that
  13. extra effort as I did during my the entire course of my career to say how did I do how did I did I do an okay job
  14. on answering that question how did I do in terms of that business presentation how did I do uh you know with that deck
  15. how did I do in that meeting and to constantly be looking for feedback that might otherwise not be offered in order
  16. to learn leadership and to get ahead so I I think that's a fascinating Dilemma to to navigate because one of my mentors
  17. Sue Ashford spent the about the last 30 years studying feedback seeking and she finds that people who actually seek out
  18. criticism get better ratings and tend to rise faster of course fishing for compliments is bad but there's also this
  19. risk of being perceived as insecure if you're constantly asking how did I do what could I be doing better how did you
  20. manage that but I think it's tone you know there's how did I do did I do okay and there's hey how could I make that
  21. better what what did you think of that was that you know was that okay um and so I think there's a certain matter of
  22. factless to it um and look you don't have to do it 12 times a day but if you present to the board of directors it's
  23. worth when it's over what can I do next time to do a better job and what that does is it gives other individuals those
  24. who give you feedback a stake in you you know because they gave that feedback they're there for you then in a way that
  25. they wouldn't be if you finish the presentation leave the room and that's that assuming of course that you
  26. actually listen to their feedback and take it into account the next time around well and this is where people can
  27. run into trouble because if you ask for feedback you're not going to get positive feedback 100% of the time and
  28. indeed some you'll get feedback that just doesn't feel right and there's always that desire particularly amongst
  29. younger professionals I've seen to fight the feedback or get defensive about the
  30. feedback and the truth is if that's the feedback it's the reality it might not be what you were intending it might not
  31. be what you think but that's that's even more valuable if it doesn't feel quite right because you're learning new
  32. information that you can incorporate so you mentioned that that seeking feedback is actually one way to
  33. increase the investment that other people have in you and I think that relates to one of your favorite
  34. observations which is that networking Isa the most undervalued skill that people deal with in their careers what
  35. are your your favorite tips on how to build a great Network well the problem is many individuals think of networking
  36. as shmoozing and what can pop into our head is a couple of folks on a golf course and then there's a beer
  37. afterwards and and I have nothing against that whatsoever um I prefer wine but beer is perfectly good too but what
  38. a network actually can be is a a network of of nerving sort of a a feedback mechanism and that you get a certain
  39. amount of feedback if you and I are the only people we know in the world you will'll have a pretty limited um set of
  40. information but as you know more and more people you're able to hear much more quickly about the new piece of
  41. research that impacts your company the startup that can impact your company the RFP that's being done the board position
  42. that's opened up you know you name it the the really talented individual who's now available for higher
  43. and loose connections are more likely to lead to your next business opportunity than your close connection so it's
  44. really having a network out there and my advice for folks on networking is and you will appreciate this more than
  45. anybody give give give you'll later receive but you're really planting these seeds that are out there and many of
  46. them some of them will die and they won't become anything and many of them will take many many years before they
  47. pay off for you if at all are there favorite acts of giving that You' focused on is you've thought about
  48. building your own network you know it doesn't it doesn't have to be big stuff it doesn't have to be Adam I am
  49. presenting you with a business gift uh but instead it can be oh gosh I met with Adam a couple weeks ago and I know he
  50. was interested in X and here's an article on X so let me send it over to him um you know or I met someone that
  51. Adam would you know I think they'd really hit it off let me make that introduction to them or offer to make it
  52. to them it's the little things that are out there um that one can do just keeping other people in mind
  53. that you know that I find come back double and triple time and in fact you know I don't think I've gotten a new
  54. business opportunity or a new job from an executive Search person terrific though many of them are um since I
  55. graduated from Business School uh but the opportunities that I've uh come across have come from my
  56. network so what do most people do wrong then when they build their networks one problem obviously you mentioned is
  57. dealing with people who are too similar to you or having a closed loop another is focusing on SM smoing or what I can
  58. get as opposed to what I can contribute any other errors that you see well as we
  59. think about women um women as they move through their 20s into their 30s they're
  60. not doing enough networking and and I can feel what so many of them are thinking like I like I don't have enough
  61. time to do everything I'm doing much less that but uh some of the research I've seen shows that as we get into our
  62. mid-30s as some of the gentlemen move ahead in their careers and the women don't one part of it is who you know
  63. what you know it's not are you good at your job by that time if you're not good at that job you're in a different job
  64. but is as the individuals get the promotion it can be those people who've got those those strong networks and so
  65. for many women it's not a network this way or network that way it's it's think about networking and again it doesn't
  66. have to be the day at the golf course it can be the email connection that occurs
  67. he used a word that's a little bit music to my ears a moment ago which is research it's something we don't hear
  68. leaders do very often but it's something that I've noticed it's very distinctive
  69. about your writing that there's often a research shows or here's what the evidence suggests how do you stay up to
  70. date on evidence and what advice would you offer to leaders on that it's so funny I was earlier today I was I was
  71. saying I I consider myself to be a recovering research analyst and my first job wasn't as a research analyst on on
  72. Wall Street but it was very early on and it was sort of my my foundational job and what I love about research you know
  73. is you know you can you can just vacuum it all up and you can piece a very interesting portrait together from the
  74. little bits of research you put together um so I always said as a manager and a leader I embrace your opinion I'd love
  75. to hear your opinion but we're making decisions off of facts and off of research um and so I read research like
  76. other people read sports magazines or fashion magazines I'm glad I'm not alone oh no
  77. it's it's a really uh party time around my house on the weekend as I read research
  78. well so the other thing that I've I've admired most when reading your work over the past few years is how candid you are
  79. about failures especially um again extremely unusual to hear a leader with so much experience and so many
  80. accomplishments admit I got fired not once but twice and here's what I took away from it how did you get to that
  81. level of cander first of all I don't know you know I look I think there's a I think I have an underlying gratitude for
  82. the opportunities I've had if you had told me when I was a a girl growing up in Charleston South Carolina the 60s and
  83. the 70s that I would be on the front page of the Wall Street Journal I I wouldn't I would have said what's the
  84. Wall Street Journal but it would have flabbergasted me and if you'd said then and by the way you're going to be fired
  85. on the front page of the Wall Street Journal would said score wow I get to do something that is g to is going to have
  86. an impact and and I still have that sense of I can't believe I get to do what I get to do it's by accident of
  87. birth it's by accident of who my parents were that I've had these set of opportunities which I've to take nothing
  88. away from the hard work which you know I've worked hard to to achieve but if it's there's a sense of gratitude and
  89. then if you think about all the folks who've helped me along the way if I can share some of my experiences and keep
  90. one young person from making one of the mistakes I've made and and by the way this is particularly true for those of
  91. us who were in the banking industry during the downtown I think every one of us should be talking about what happened
  92. and really exploring and thinking about the causes of those downturns I think we
  93. owe it to the next Generation I think we owe it to our country quite frankly so I
  94. don't know you know by the way it was all in the paper anyway so what what the heck am I going to hide pretend like it
  95. didn't happen does that mean it was maybe more difficult to be that open earlier in your career when you had a
  96. stumbling block or an obstacle nobody cared so I mean you do reach a you do reach a point where if you're you're
  97. talking about the stumbling block and you're 30 years old people are saying you're you're boring um but that you
  98. know once you've had a certain level of achievement um you know again I think you you you have an obligation to to
  99. share if you if you feel comfortable doing so you've mentioned that women in business is a big passion of yours and a
  100. relatively newly discovered one yeah what what are your favorite recommendations for first of all
  101. increasing the representation of women in leadership positions and secondly not just representation but making sure that
  102. that women end up having a real impact well I I think this is incredibly important and I think there is an
  103. enormous amount of good advice much of it directed to women about what they can do to achieve um and they're terrific
  104. bestselling books on it I think there's another Avenue for us to explore because
  105. if we take that to an extreme you know we have to remember that the positive part the benefit of diversity is
  106. diversity and so if we try to put everyone into the same box how much of that benefit of diversity are you giving
  107. up and so I as I think about it I think a lot about getting the gentleman into the conversation on gender diversity uh
  108. we're having conversations earlier today about some of the biases the subtle well-meaning biases men and women have
  109. about women and how to see those as being uh a sort of friction in the system um that if we can overcome can
  110. enable business to be more successful because while you know our all the analysts out there will say we haven't
  111. necessarily proven causation I'm not sure if we've gone to correlation but it is an awfully big coincidence that more
  112. diverse companies have higher returns lower volatility lower risk more client focus more Innovation you know that
  113. diverse leadership teams outperform more smarter more capable leadership teams I
  114. mean all these things are good and so I think we have to ask ourselves what are the if it were easy we would have
  115. already fixed it so what are the many different means to helping get um more diversity the top put another way less
  116. group think let's bring this then to Wall Street specifically so I spent some time working with Goldman sacks over the
  117. summer on the culture change initiatives that they were beginning including not working on Saturdays and uh actually
  118. redesigning jobs to make them more enriched more learning opportunities more client contact I was quite
  119. impressed by their commitment to actually Reinventing what work was like for analysts and Associates where do you
  120. see Wall Street moving well thank goodness we're companies are starting to address that because there's just no way
  121. that's good for anybody and and even if we think it's a good idea to drive these
  122. young people into the ground um you've seen the research that I've seen on business creativity and business
  123. productivity and there's no doubt someone who's pulled all nighter after all nighter there's no way there's doing
  124. they're doing as good a job for the clients and eventually for the shareholders as someone who is able to
  125. string two thoughts together um so I think you know that that is a a worthy undertaking and that's at the bottom of
  126. these organizations we've talked about diversity getting to the top of these organizations you know one of the I
  127. think truly unexamined causes of the financial crisis and we've spent so much time as a country on the topic of greed
  128. as a cause I'd say a cause we should also be thinking about as group think and while there is in the sort of
  129. popular press this view that these were Wall Street Evil Geniuses who who foresaw the
  130. downturn you've probably seen the research that I have that shows that subprime Bankers had worse personal real
  131. estate performance than the average American so these were not Evil Geniuses these were individuals who bought you
  132. know who made the soup and ate the soup and so how do we inject um skepticism questioning different thinking into
  133. these these companies and one is let people get some sleep so they can think another is diversity and I think we need
  134. to keep chipping away at this I love the the idea of focusing on group think when
  135. Janice first did the research on this topic he thought it was all about becoming too cohesive and that if if a
  136. group got too tight-knit then they would actually stop questioning and challenging each other and now the
  137. evidence suggests something quite different which is it's actually about overconfidence that a group can be tight
  138. but as long as we know we don't have all the answers and we are willing to question each other we can actually get
  139. diverse perspectives how do you then keep confidence in check especially as you gain success in your career well I
  140. think that's one question I think the other question is the tone from the top what you know what I've seen in the I've
  141. worked for seven Financial Services CEOs directly so I think that's more than anybody um and the the real question is
  142. how does that CEO incourage an active debate and drive an active debate and at the best I've seen oh come on Adam give
  143. us your point of view take the other side okay you don't believe in the other side take it anyway let's you know let's
  144. argue and let's scream each other let's really get into this and on another side
  145. I've seen CEOs who've shut people off and shut people down we don't have time for this we we don't have the luxury for
  146. this this is the path we've chosen let's go where they have put quickness of decision- making over quality of
  147. decision- making so I think it's you know I think there's an individual question of how does one do that but I
  148. think there's a tone from the top question too which has to come from the CEO or the business leader as well as
  149. the board what do you do with a leader who doesn't quite appreciate the importance of that find another job
  150. ideally well you know the look there are um sometimes when one has to sort of fold one's tent and go to someplace else
  151. um whether it's a a because there are plenty of companies in this world you know you you do not have to stay at one
  152. company for forever if um there isn't the environment one wants if the company doesn't have the values that one wants
  153. you know you can try to work from within but if you're a mid-level employee and the company's doing things you don't
  154. agree with you're allowed to get another job yeah so you obviously have a chance
  155. to make a huge impact on many of these issues through the work that you're doing with 85 broads what's your vision
  156. well 85 broads is I say the Chek named 85 broads um I think it's such an interesting business because it it's
  157. modern in many ways it's a network and I'm so fascinated by the idea that if we wanted to accomplish things in business
  158. until 5 years ago 10 years ago it was a company and now people can come together
  159. with a common goal in a network so that's fascinating for me to sort of watch how a network can move and evolve
  160. and this is a network around helping women Advance their careers and helping companies Advance their women which as
  161. we've discussed as something that can have a real economic impact if women were as engaged in the economy as men
  162. are our GDP would be 9% bigger and in many countries around the world they grow even more and and we've talked of
  163. course about the positive to individual companies um networking as we mentioned is the number one Unwritten rule of
  164. success in business so those things coming together for me is a topic that matters something that I feel passionate
  165. about my team feels passionate about it's Heaven it's absolute heaven so we've got lots of cool and interesting
  166. things to try many of which will fail many of which will fail um but the opportunity to try it and be nimble and
  167. entrepreneurial at this stage of my career is about the most fun thing I've done in a long time that's encouraging
  168. to hear actually and it makes me wonder what can men do to get into this conversation I've I've talked frequently
  169. with Executives and with students about the fact that oftentimes conversations about women in business shut the door to
  170. men um it's a topic that I care a lot about and it's not always easy to get into that dialogue so what can we do
  171. well I'll take the other point of view um which is I'd say get into that conversation I have sort of a joke
  172. except it's not a joke that I often tell when I go to these these conferences um in which I say I mean we've convinced
  173. each other we women all agree that gender diversity matters but I will tell you I worked in businesses that were
  174. mostly men and by mostly men I mean by far mostly men uh for more than 20 plus years um and I have to tell you I've
  175. I've interrupted a lot of gentlemen having discussions a lot of times over that time and never once did it go like
  176. this hey guys hey what are y'all talking about oh Sally interesting to see you we're talking about the importance of
  177. gender diversity for business that never happened and so I'd say get in the conversation you know begin to talk
  178. about it begin to live it you know take actions to overcome those subtle biases and it matters tone from the top tone
  179. from the top of a business uh matters recognize that we all have these biases learn about them and learn to overcome
  180. them well I certainly hope that more of us can and we're really thrilled that you're able to join us today you Adam
  181. thank you for having me [Music]

Brief Summary

Sally Cotek discusses leadership, networking, and advancing women in business with Adam Grant.

Key points

  • Sally Cotek on Leadership. Sally Cotek shares insights on leadership as a learned skill through micro lessons.
  • The Power of Networking. Sally Cotek discusses networking as an undervalued skill in career advancement.
  • Sharing Experiences. Sally Cotek emphasizes the importance of sharing experiences to guide others.
  • Diversity in Business. Sally Cotek explains how diversity leads to better business outcomes.
  • Unwritten Rules of Success. Sally Cotek identifies networking as the key to success in business.
  • The Importance of Gender Diversity. A discussion on the necessity of gender diversity in business and overcoming biases.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes