How Strong Stakeholder Relationships Can Help Your Firm Avoid a Crisis

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

The best way to handle a crisis is to avoid it. To do that, companies must invest the time in building relationships with stakeholders. More: http://knlg.net/2e9jMrL 📂 Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. today I'd like to welcome be told tenish and he's a management professor here at
  2. Wharton and also Cynthiana Darabont Oh who is from New York University and she's also a management professor and
  3. they're here to talk about their new research thank you for dropping in to chat with us much appreciated and the
  4. research is about corporations who are interested in limiting reputational damage when they come under attack by a
  5. protest group or shareholder group I'll let you explain exactly which groups companies need to be worried about but
  6. what they can do to limit the reputational damage and one of the things is to work on your reputation
  7. before you come under attack because that that encourages friends and family shall we say friendly shareholder groups
  8. and community groups to to come in and support you and come to a company's defense so let's start I think since
  9. Janna with an example of a company that may have done it right or done it wrong so viewers can get an idea of exactly
  10. what we're talking about so Steve thank you very much for for having us here we're always had very happy to talk
  11. about about research and this particular piece of research this actress so you I
  12. think if summarizes really nicely but i do want to point out that we're we're asking a fairly straightforward question
  13. what happens to companies when when they're faced with with a situation where a critical event and it can be a
  14. court decision it can be a negative news report sort of from an environmental organization what happens to to the
  15. company in such moments how do their shareholders response and how their circle the response after after after
  16. these events you see the single news all the time you see it with uber and i would probably use uber as a sort of an
  17. example of a company that's trying to expand internationally very very quickly and because of the pace of its
  18. international expansion it doesn't have the time and the resources to engage with every community that it affects and
  19. with every government and every regulator in every country so every single time there is
  20. new story about uber it's usually sort of surrounded by a lot of negative reactions from other stakeholders who
  21. have something negative to say about uber as well as stakeholder reactions who from cyclers who have something
  22. positive to say from consumers who are very happy with a new product and so on companies that you know companies that
  23. do this well you don't see in the news as much but there are companies of course I do this well erbium being the
  24. indo shared economy space is a good example ikea when in the 90s it faced a number of allegations of child labor
  25. being used in itself by one of its suppliers in india it responded it took its time to work with NGOs and with
  26. UNICEF to understand the problem and then put in place sort of long-term solutions to to make sure that the
  27. children who are you know the stakeholders that they cared about whatever they do that is in the best
  28. interest of the children so just wanted to ask so I believe we're talking about a situation where a company actually is
  29. doing things to make it right as opposed to just taking a public relations approach where they're just saying the
  30. right things yeah it's very much about that's what it takes to build up the relationship with stakeholders it's not
  31. enough just to put out a glossy press release to have a pretty sustainability report you have to really engage the
  32. stakeholders in fact some other research show we were talking about today really
  33. gets into the nuts and bolts of how you build up that relationship but it's it's
  34. a lot more than a press release it's a lot more than a check at some deep long-held interactions so maybe a short
  35. summary of what the research looked for and what it found would be interesting to hear now well I'll give you the
  36. nutshell version which is it's worth investing in relationships because once you have a strong positive relationship
  37. once you have a friend from a stakeholder that friend is going to stick up for you so when you're attacked
  38. when you're facing a down day when someone's coming after you you're not going to be first in front of the
  39. microphone ideally your stakeholders that I kias say twas Save the Children in ideas case that since he talked about
  40. they're the ones defending you against the allegations of a human rights abuse the community members are talking about
  41. how its are mine it's our factory we don't want to shut down so we're getting someone else in front of microphone to
  42. be what one could call an upstander or an advocate for the company so is the lesson that that you want to do this
  43. spade work ahead of time I mean I get that that's the lesson but do you talk about how to do that spade work or
  44. you're just saying you need to do the spadework figure out how to do it in this particular paper we we take these
  45. relationships as given all right so we're saying we're comparing firms that have good relationships with their
  46. stakeholders and with firms that don't and we're doing this on the individual stakeholder level so we're looking at
  47. every single stay cold and the stakeholder can be a local community the stakeholder can be an NGO or an activist
  48. group it can be a mayor governor a regulatory agency so we're looking where we found a way to to measure their
  49. perceptions of the company using newspaper report so we essentially coded 22,000 articles about 26 minds around
  50. the world in 20 countries around the world and for each of these minds we have a very very detailed timeline of
  51. which stakeholders spoke about the firm or took action against the mining firm and what exactly they did is it an act
  52. of cooperation or is it an act of conflict and using this that timeline we show that stakeholders that with with
  53. whom the firm has built good relationships in the past or though these are the stakeholders that when
  54. something bad happens when a negative court decision comes about they're gonna you know stand up and speak to defend
  55. the firm because they they see this as a good firm whereas the stakeholders with
  56. whom the firm has a really bad relationship are going to use this as an opportunity to reiterate their
  57. opposition and before you know it you have sort of a series or a chorus of voices for firms have who have really
  58. bad relationships with their stakeholders you have a chorus of voices uncoordinated voices but what the public
  59. hears in the media is this sort of chorus of voices all speaking negatively about the firm and that's how you know
  60. that's the making of a crisis in in in today's world so are there a follow-on it now just in the second part of the
  61. paper we show that it's those courses of negative opinion that contribute to a collapse and shareholder value so we can
  62. look at a similar set of critical events 160 in total and the ones in which you see this negative course of opinion are
  63. the cases and which shareholder value collapses the cases where you have the upstanders
  64. where you have the stakeholders speaking on your behalf the same degree of negative opinion at the onset doesn't
  65. translate into a collapse and shareholder value so it's not just this is a good thing to have it's a nice to
  66. have it actually contributes to the protection of shareholder value so that's obviously a key takeaway and as
  67. you were just giving us another one are there others that that would be sort of bullet point key takeaways from the
  68. paper that that we could talk about so to me it's really sort of the benefits of of stakeholder engagement and doing
  69. this in a strategic and systematic way of sort of the same process that the firm would apply to managing its
  70. relationships with suppliers and employees and customers need to be applied to managing much broader set of
  71. stakeholders including the local communities the activists and NGOs and the government sort of governments a
  72. different level so that's one one big big takeaway because you know if you if you manage to put in place these Goods
  73. take all the relationships you prevent the crisis and the best part of managing the crisis is to not have one at all but
  74. I think another one that was to me to me very interesting is how in today's sort
  75. of era of increased transparency or information availability you don't need to have explicit coordination among
  76. stakeholders to end up with a social movement against the firm and here's what I mean by this if you start with a
  77. court again- court report these things happen you know things i think the things get litigated and there's a
  78. decision if there's a negative decision against the firm then you might actually
  79. have a local protest in the local community you might have the mayor or government speak out against the firm
  80. you may have broader mobilization by by activists and these different stakeholders you know they never
  81. coordinate it they never you know they never got on a conference call or using an email distribution list what happened
  82. actually they were using information available in the public space in the media to social media in the soul and
  83. the social media force to synchronizer their reactions and these independent reactions all started to sort of sound
  84. like a concerted voice against against a company and at the same time I imagine social media can also be that early
  85. warning system the canary in the coal mine right if companies are monitoring it and they can see what some problems
  86. are that might be brewing the kids I'm a chance to go in and fix them not just sort of PR them but to actually say
  87. maybe we need to be doing some work in this area exactly i think one of the manager will take aways is the need to
  88. invest not just in the relationships but understanding your stakeholders upfront
  89. and so you need to gather that data whether it's i mean in other work we argue about the importance of actually
  90. meeting and talking and building these relationships within person contact but monitoring them on social media and in
  91. the print media being aware of what they're saying and what drives their behavior is obviously very important so
  92. save yourself a headache but more than a headache or in addition to a headache save yourself a savior stock from taking
  93. a big hit right you know again invest in these relationships the same way you invest in physical capital the same way
  94. invest in human capital invest in relationship capital and you talk in the paper about the value of information
  95. signals which i think you've been you're sort of talking about here but is there
  96. something specific to say about these information signals that that you haven't already covered here so they you
  97. know they have been in other research by other scholars has shown that is our information you know information signals
  98. coming from the medium from cycle of reactions are important to managers because they can foresee a crises are
  99. important to investors because again they can foresee some problems to the future cash flow of the firm we show
  100. with this paper that they're important to two stakeholders to you know to come to synchronize the reaction in the way
  101. that doesn't require coordination explicit coordination among them but i think you know if we want if if i were
  102. to push that to a managerial implication i would say to managers and their and their teams it's really important not to
  103. wait until they see something already kind of coming together and forming like a social movement they should they
  104. should really understand that again to in today's world almost any and even tiny statement any action can easily
  105. escalate into something much bigger into a broader crisis because of this time the dynamics that we observe in our
  106. research i think just to add there are two different ways these negative these critical events can ask
  107. and and both of them I think catch managers by surprise one is that when you have the allies it's not just that
  108. your allies discount the negative information they can actually rally to your defense so it's really worthwhile
  109. having them it's not just that they say oh this doesn't matter I don't believe this who are these people making these
  110. accusations they'll actually stand up and defend you so it's it's more than discounting the information signal it's
  111. reacting to it positive reinforcement and on the other side negative information is since since it was
  112. pointing I can really set off this cascade so it can be a lot worse than the initial news story it can blow up
  113. and spiral out of control when you don't have the relationships what company failed in all of this and can you think
  114. of a good example where was it went really south and and could have been avoided in other words there's one thing
  115. if they were doing some things that are going to be perceived by the public as negative and there's no way to spin that
  116. really but but maybe it was really a little bit miss perceived by the public in some way and and they missed the
  117. opportunity to I think I heard you say as we're chatting ahead of time to the time for crisis management is a year
  118. before the crisis right can you name names um I would use to example so I brought up uber a little bit at the
  119. beginning is something that I'm doing in in current research ongoing research and
  120. I think uber will defame defend the speed of its international expansion based on the business model you know
  121. they need a lot of drivers on the road in order to make the riders happy they need a lot of writers to keep the
  122. drivers happy and it's it's that need for support of critical mass on both sides that that explains the speed of
  123. their expansion and because they're doing things so quickly they don't have the time to build this relationship
  124. relationships take time right between people as well as between companies and their stakeholders and so this is you
  125. know this is this Boober is an example of a company that's been banned in a number of if in hundreds of cities
  126. around the world because they they didn't put themselves in a situation to to be defended by by those who have a
  127. lot to gain including the drivers who joined uber by those who have a lot to and the
  128. writers who are happy three years over it as a result their market their potential market capitalization i think
  129. is really plummeted I mean this is not a real impact if you look at what the the
  130. estimates were uber was going to be worth more than all the automobile companies it was gonna be worth it more
  131. than all the airlines that was based on uber being successful in China and India
  132. and Germany and France and England and it's not happening and so they can no longer justify that market cap this is
  133. it's really material to future to current owners potential future shareholders to the future of this
  134. company that it's had these missteps up front would they have been able to so developing relationships takes time and
  135. if they had invested that and taken the time with what competitors have gotten a
  136. jump on them I mean it's sort of a you know how do you what can you do your cut your kind of going to like take a hit in
  137. some way either way if you talk to someone from uber they will always say that this was the only way yes right
  138. because they needed to be the biggest player on the more in the market and they didn't have the time to you know
  139. now first mover and all that first mover everywhere and the biggest first mover and a result of that hopefully the
  140. biggest player in the market I you know and because of that I didn't have the time to to build these relationships is
  141. it going to backfire I think very much so is it likely that that some of the competitors who maybe took things a
  142. little slower and build these relationships are you know they were second in the market but they are
  143. understood they observed the problem the problems that uber was having and try to
  144. address them by lobbying the regulator's a little bit more and talking to the taxi drivers who are affecting and
  145. seeing how they can actually throw find a solution that works for everybody I don't know it's too soon to tell right
  146. it's it's with uber it's really true to some really interesting I think moving out of the new economy let's look talk
  147. about energy companies right this boom in the fracking industry that since he's also studying in some ongoing research
  148. these are companies that made the play to go quickly to expand gas supplies here in Pennsylvania and elsewhere
  149. around the world and they're all these estimates this is we're going to revolutionize the industry but there you
  150. know you drive through these towns and you see these protests you see you know no fracking here stop fracking don't
  151. build this pipeline you see concerns and you see reservations well who went slow with some of the
  152. alternative energy suppliers whether its wind solar and others who are moving more incrementally building
  153. relationships with government officials building up support for wind farms for solar arrays and I think you're starting
  154. to see the future of the energy industry change a little bit in terms of what role is fracking in a play versus
  155. alternative energy one of them was definitely move fast let's own this but now it's worked in a few states in the
  156. United States hasn't worked elsewhere it's not working in too many other countries of the world and alternative
  157. energy continues to kind of be the tortoise that's moving steadily ahead and we'll see which way it plays out
  158. over the next five or ten years oh that's really interesting um I just wonder if there were some you know there
  159. were some legitimate concerns about that industry that that I think maybe when ignored would would you agree with that
  160. and where you know I mean environmental considerations that that that they either didn't address or or or didn't
  161. know how to address well I think they could have addressed them through let's let's talk to the government's about
  162. what a reasonable the standard is for water disposal and what has to happen to the water that gets pumped out of the
  163. ground what are the standards for it to be disposed in the cities what are the standards of treatment that are going to
  164. be required and they chose to take a little bit more of a cowboy mentality and you know that's the city's problem
  165. it's not our problem we're following the law we're not giving up any information
  166. on what's in the water and that raised people's concerns and skepticism it would have taken more time to decide
  167. what a reasonable water treatment standard would be to build up state level and national level regulation it
  168. would have created more transparency more oversight I think the industry would be a lot healthier today
  169. interesting that's that's a very interesting example what misperceptions did the study dispel the I think one of
  170. the biggest ones this something that I see a lot in the industry is people think that building these relationships
  171. with the local community or with NGOs there's a symbolic actions right we're very limited
  172. effects on the compares operations or on the stock price and I think we're really
  173. providing evidence for the fact that it's really the other way around that these things are incredibly valuable
  174. both in terms of allowing the operations to go ahead on schedule and on budget and as a result of that also very
  175. incredibly valuable in serving the industry by looking for the stock price for the company itself for shareholders
  176. it reminds me of something you said where I mean in the environmental area again maybe an example is what the term
  177. greenwashing right so you have a company that they're really not taking care of the environment the way maybe they
  178. should or the way that that the community and a lot of other folks think they should but they'll do the other
  179. have a sustainability officer and they'll plan a few trees and they'll do a couple of symbolic things but you're
  180. saying that's that's not gonna cut it yeah it was really important we're not measuring something that's in you dating
  181. report whether they have a sustainability report whether they meet some reporting standard we think what's
  182. important is what stakeholders think about the firm and we're measuring that and so the key is not do you have a
  183. report do you meet a standard do you get five stars it's are there people will understand for the microphone for you
  184. when you criticize do you have that network of relationships with community leaders NGOs government officials that's
  185. what matters that's what we're turning draw attention to its not greenwash its substantive real relationships do the
  186. right thing in a way do the right thing for the right people yeah and to build off that so this is in a mining industry
  187. around the world and there's a lot of examples particularly in parts of Africa where mining firms which are in the
  188. business of building things have build a lot of schools and a lot of health clinics they tend to be empty because
  189. they don't think you know sufficiently forward to stuff them as well and these become targets of community protests
  190. they you know on a few occasions have actually been bombed the schools that you see you know you know CSR report has
  191. been bombed a few years later because the community really rejected that particular initiative because it was put
  192. in place without their input nobody asked them whether they wanted a school whether that this was their sort of
  193. their a priority for the community nobody asked whether the health clinic would make the biggest difference they
  194. were never consulted and this is you know one way of having a relationship is to actually start meaningful have a
  195. meaningful conversation sent to each other try to address each other's concerns and very few companies
  196. do that you know in a very serious way and what makes your research different from other research in this area there
  197. been a lot of assertions that building relationships with stakeholders being a responsible company can pay in a time of
  198. crisis people have talked about the insurance value of reputation this is the first research that we've seen that
  199. really gets down and shows that that's true that the reason there's a payoff when you're under attack the reason your
  200. share price doesn't collapse is because individual stakeholders rally to your defense we actually show that in our
  201. media reports that someone who is sort of neutral or slightly positive towards the mine the day after its attacked by
  202. the minister or the day after its attacked by Greenpeace those neutral or slightly positive stakeholders actually
  203. like the mind more in terms of what they say to the press and the reason is they
  204. themselves feel threatened and when you feel threatened you respond you defend it's not just that the people discount
  205. the bad news they're actually rallying and in favor of the mine and I think showing that effect at the level of the
  206. individual stakeholder is really novel and it really buttresses this idea that there is an insurance value we're
  207. getting under the hood and seeing why it happens and how important those individual relationships are so I
  208. noticed in your paper that you talked about the many other things that you could be looking at next so tell us a
  209. little bit about what you might look at next or what what's what are some of the
  210. more interesting things that this opens up for new research so we're continuing this line of research by by having with
  211. new research that looks at the important sort of the timing of cycle engagements
  212. so now we've sort of i think we've we've had a couple of pieces where we've looked at the impact in terms of
  213. financial paying impact and impact on on stakeholders reactions now we're actually trying to see how how can you
  214. build better relationships with with your stakeholders and we're doing this and in a couple of ways i'll mention one
  215. so in one we're looking at the benefits of doing this proactively i think one of
  216. the biggest differences in terms of leaders and loggers in this in in in today's world in many many industries is
  217. is this timing issue some firms have had the better in terms of thinking about their
  218. stakeholders as they strategize about their operations and trying to understand who they are where they are
  219. how they are affected what they care about what they might say and and essentially go to the stakeholders we
  220. know if it's a local community go to the local community and initiate a dialogue
  221. hopefully an ongoing dialogue to try to address these issues from day one right and if you do that and if you do that
  222. well then you're you're likely to be in a much better situation down the road right this is this is where you address
  223. the crisis here before it happens and you're not going to be in the news and if something happens you're going to be
  224. given a chance either the benefit of the doubt or you'll actually be funded by your cycles it'll be given a chance to
  225. address every single issue in a way that allows you to have a meaningful sort of
  226. solution which is probably also color collaborative solution so all right what haven't I asked you that would be
  227. important for everyone to know I think one of the things people often surprised that we study the mining industry and
  228. then we're drawing insights on what constitutes good stakeholder engagement good corporate social responsibility
  229. practices from the mining industry there's a reason for that mining industry made some massive mistakes
  230. these firms that were studying or firms in the industry wrote off a billion dollars a capital and I guess we'd
  231. encourage people to try to learn from their mistakes instead of repeating them most of the firm's we're studying didn't
  232. adopt better practices better processes until a disaster occurred and they learn
  233. from their mistakes I think the reason we're studying this industry is they have learned and other managers should
  234. try to learn from their mistakes instead of repeating thank you very much for coming in thank you
  235. you

Brief Summary

Management professors discuss corporate reputation management and stakeholder engagement during crises, using Uber and IKEA as key examples.

Key points

  • The Importance of Reputation Management. Companies must proactively manage their reputations to mitigate damage during crises.
  • Uber's Rapid Expansion Consequences. Uber's quick international expansion has led to reputational challenges due to lack of stakeholder engagement.
  • The Value of Relationships. Building real relationships with stakeholders can protect companies during crises.
  • Learning from Mistakes. The mining industry offers crucial lessons in corporate responsibility and stakeholder engagement.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes