How Analytics Shape NFL Team Building
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE Brandt Tilis, Executive Vice President for Football Operations for the Carolina Panthers, joins the show to break down NFL roster construction, draft strategy, and the economics of quarterback contracts. He explains how teams balance analytics, film evaluation, and salary cap constraints. In the second half, the hosts discuss the intensity of the World Baseball Classic, automated strike zones, and surprising NHL playoff races.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
#SportsAnalytics #CarolinaPanthers #NFL #NFLDraft #FootballStrategy #NFLInsights ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Welcome, welcome to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics here on the Wharton podcast
- network. This is Kade Massie hosting this week with two of my usual three co-host. Audi Winer is here. I think
- he's coming in from New York. Shane Jensen is here. Looks like he is on campus. I'm guessing Eric Bradlo's out
- and about. Eric is doing Eric things. He'll be back. We are delighted to have a first-time guest, a a longtime friend,
- first-time guest. Brandt Tillis is with us. Brandt is a sitting executive in the
- NFL, executive vice president for football operations with the Carolina Panthers. He is, I think, rolling into
- his third year in that position. Having come over from the Kansas City Chiefs, he was with the Chiefs for multiple
- championships. He came into the world, I think it's fair to say, as kind of a cap
- guy and helped do a lot of the negotiating there with Kansas City. Before KC, he was at the league office.
- Um, and before that, interned with the Raiders. Brandt, glad to have you on the show. Thanks for
- making time for us. >> Hey, Kaden, the crew. Thanks, thanks for having me. You You took my my joke I was
- going to make. think I was going to make the first time longtime joke because >> I've been
- >> you're actually a listener. >> Yes. >> That's awesome. Well, >> you guys you guys helped get me through
- through COVID and understanding what the heck was happening there, too. So, the show's always been been great. But then
- I got to do one quick shout out here, which is um Shane is friends with a good buddy of mine from high school who I was
- shocked to find out he is not really a sports fan and he's a lawyer from Denver. His name is Ross Ziv. And Ross
- texted me one day and said and said, ' Do you know Eric Eager? And I was like, "Yeah, of course I know Eric. He's
- amazing." And he said, "Uh, my friend Shane knows him." Like, how do you how do you know the Wharton Moneyball
- Analytics guy? You're a lawyer in Denver who doesn't even like sports, >> right?
- >> That's great. See, I'm glad to know our footprint expands. That's awesome. As
- well, >> I remember I was I was hanging with him last summer and uh talking about just uh
- I mean, actually talking about the work you guys are doing down there in Carolina. uh mostly um you know I think
- it's it's been a early success for sure. >> Well yeah hopefully it was a good conversation man.
- >> We have to say that I mean Eric is a multiple time guest of the show and and and a good friend over the years. He's
- an example of we've built relationships in 12 years of the show. It's more than just the show now. We have this these
- relationships we didn't have before and Eager is one of those guys. You kind of stole him from us in some ways Brandt. I
- mean, he used to be able to talk publicly and say things and write provocatively and make people mad.
- >> He is a unicorn for us. He's he's obviously very smart, very analytic savvy, but he can talk to anyone in the
- building about any kind of problem that he can help solve or or that that that they may have that he can bridge a gap
- to. I mean, he spends time with our coaches, with with our scouting staff, with obviously with Dan and myself and
- coach Canales and um and as well as some folks in our business operations. So, he's he's all over the place and he's he
- does excellent work for us. He's completely exceeded expectations. >> Well, that's that's great to hear. And
- it it strikes me that your job, you know, you moved over two plus years ago. We talk about how important staff hires
- are for coaches, but I can imagine that it was very important decision for you. Like, who do you bring in to work with
- you as you move over to Carolina, and he was one of the guys that you recruited to bring in? Shane alluded to it. Um,
- you took over a club that had just won two games the year before, five games in the first year, 24 season, and then
- eight games last year. So, that the trajectory is definitely in the right direction. Can you give us some sense of
- what the building feels like this spring? What what are the what are the questions? What are the enthusiasms?
- What are you most working on? Any anything you can tell us about where you guys are at the moment?
- >> First of all, we're just we're very proud of the season we just had. This was the first division championship that
- the club has had in and I believe 10 seasons. And we had a home playoff game and the the crowd and the atmosphere was
- was unbelievable. Um it was right up there with with some of the crowds we had there in Kansas City during our runs
- there. Uh it was it was truly special. You know, we couldn't we couldn't finish the game out unfortunately, but we're
- very proud of the season that we had and we're very fortunate to be able to continue to build on it. So, we're very
- excited about all that we've done in free agency. We signed uh a few a few really good players so far and and then
- we have a whole draft in front of us. And so things are things are certainly trending up here in Carolina and and so
- I you know I think I think just the the continuity that we have, the support that we have from ownership, uh those
- are all the things that we're really leaning into at this point. >> Ownership is a drum we beat occasionally
- around here. It took me a long time as a sports fan to realize how important ownership was. As soon as I started
- working in sports, I'm like, "Oh god, the whole thing's driven by owners essentially." Turns out shouldn't have
- been surprising. Can you give us some an example of when you said supportive ownership like what's one way concrete
- manifestation of that when you feel happy with the ownership you have as sitting in your position what does that
- look like certainly um in free agency just last week um we were we laid out our plan to to Dave Ter about look we're
- gonna we're going to go after Jaylen Phillips and it's going to cost a lot of money and it and we're going to have to
- pay him potentially $30 million a year. And then we're also going to follow that
- up and go after go after a really good defensive playmaker. And it that's also going to cost a lot of money. And these
- two and these these two deals don't come without risk. And he he hears us out. He
- he he pushes back on a lot of what what we say, not to not to say no, but just to just to test. All right. How how
- resolved are you? Have you thought about this? Have you thought about that? And we get to a really good place together.
- And then he says, "Great. You have like you you have my permission. And you need
- and you need to go and execute this plan." And so we're able to to do that. We're able to act fast. We don't have to
- go check with him after every little thing, every little move during a negotiation.
- Um he knows he knows what the parameters are that we're we're we're working within. and then we can just we can just
- go and execute. >> Well, I guess just kind of following up on sort of the success that you guys saw
- last season, I I feel like there was several teams this past season that essentially went from worst to first. I
- mean, I'll count Carolina in there as well, even though I it's kind of a you weren't actually I don't think worst in
- the previous year, just tied for it, but like New England also Chicago. Do you think there I I mean that happens? It's
- not like it's completely unusual that that would a worst to first worst would happen, but I I feel like three in one
- season or or or like that many. Do you think there's something is there some aspect of today's like league or or or
- you know the way things are done that that le can teams can kind of turn change their fortunes around quickly
- more quickly than they used to? >> Yes. I I think I think you're going to see it a lot more. Um and and I think a
- lot of it has to do with just a rising salary cap and the fact that that they're that uh teams you'll see every
- year you'll see a team with $100 million in a room, $80 million, whatever whatever it is. And so teams are able to
- to to kind of propel themselves quickly. Um, I think I think for us in particular
- when when I came in here and and Dan took over as GM and and we had Coach Canales here, you saw that a little bit.
- We we signed a couple of good free agents and then then the next year we signed a couple of more. So, ours was
- more of of a slow burn, but you'll also see you also see some teams like really jump in and then, you know, what they do
- from there is up to them. >> The the rising cap, do you kind of feel like that means that do you kind of see
- a kind of an increasing role for free agency actually in the future versus kind of d you know the comparing
- drafting free agency is kind of the two main team building kind of actions. Does
- the rising cap kind of continue to give more preference towards free agency in your mind?
- >> No, I don't. I I think that I think teams I think that teams now um it's just like
- it was 20 years ago when I first came in the league, which is the best way to build a long sustaining
- team that that contends every year is to draft, develop, and retain. So you can you can get a a jump start on free
- agency of course, but you still need to draft and you still need to keep those players to keep your your culture and
- your continuity going. >> Free agents are expensive and so when they if they if they explode on you, you
- have to take the hit if I mean if you particular if you backended money and then all of a sudden it comes up yet and
- that destroys your cal salary cap. But a lot of first round picks, they don't all
- have to be great or a lot of picks in general just have to have a few that turn into something. But I I guess my
- question is the NIL has made a is making a huge change in co college football. What is it doing to the the drafting
- kind of climate um at the professional level? One would argue that maybe the players are staying a little longer
- because they get good money and maybe you know more about them. I'm just completely um at a loss to understand
- what that's going to do um at the draft level. Have you what what are you seeing
- there? Certainly players are older coming into the league. We're seeing that this year. A lot of the a lot of
- the top players in the draft are are older players. So that's just something new that that we're going to have to
- deal with uh leaguewide. Um and then the other piece too, which which is more of a positive I think is
- is these players have money in college, so we can see how money is going to affect them in the pros. that that used
- to be a big a big jump for us to make is all right how's money how's money going
- to change this this person and and now now we kind of know what it is so there and and we we haven't found equilibrium
- yet with this NIL and and transfer portal that that the college system has like I I I think it's going to take a
- few years for us to to fully understand how things are going to function um but just based on how things are now.
- There's there's some positive and there's some negative and and we're just we're just trying to navigate that
- ourselves. >> Brent, I just want to hear a little bit more about the comment you just made and
- it's fascinating to me and I had not thought about it at all, but I've heard highlevel professional basketball
- coaches say this is one of the if they could know one thing, it would be how's this person going to respond to great
- wealth? And he may be talking about a 19-y old kid, so they're a little bit older in the NFL, but that was literally
- the thing he most wanted to know. And you're saying, well, that's benefit of NIL is that we get to see that. So my
- question back to you is, do you get to see it? And now I'm not asking for your trade secrets because I know this kind
- of information is what you what your personnel department traffic's in, but do you think you're able to get some
- signal on how a player responds to having anywhere from a few hundred thousand to a few million dollars in his
- checking account? >> A little bit. Yeah. I I wouldn't say it's it's earthshattering by any
- stretch, but but you you do see players in in the co in the college game who are
- coasting a little bit or you you more positively and and more often you see players who are leaning into it more,
- you know, and so now look, there is a downside to all of this too, which is there's a transactional element to to
- the college game now, which is which is hard for us to handle in the pros because there so much of of football is
- kind of buying into your locker room, your teammates, playing for each other, playing for your city, for your
- organization. And and it's easier to to continue that uh that narrative in college when you're playing for a a
- great school like Texas or Alabama or or one of those programs. But now, um, you
- know, it it we just got to kind of break them in a little bit different now. >> Yeah. Well, I'm really interested in the
- question of this is a long-standing question about quarterbacks. Does a team in order to be successful have to have a
- quarterback that you're not paying huge amounts of money for? Is that something that's that's a really a useful thing to
- to do or is it or or not? I mean, is the way to to succeed to have a a long-term contract
- with a really great quarterback that's not overwhelming or have a a a quarterback that's not amazing, um,
- maybe only average that you're not paying a lot of money for? It's a hard question to answer and I I always go
- towards regardless of position, but specifically with quarterbacks, you got to have a
- good one. He's got to be good. So, if you know that you've got one, keep them. And obviously, you have to make a
- a business decision at some point of can we continue to build around this player
- knowing what what we know about him. But it's it's hard to move off of a quarterback and no one's done it yet.
- >> Uh I do think someone will do it eventually. >> What do you mean by do it? Do what?
- meaning no one's no one's done what I think Audi is getting at, which is have a have a quarterback under under a
- rookie contract >> and then move off of him and get on to another rookie. Like have have success
- with that player and then move off of him >> and get onto another lower pay. >> The way I think about there's a
- contingency table of like good not good cheap not cheap. And the trouble is if it's good it doesn't good and cheap are
- a cell that's only temporary. You can never lock in good and cheap for a whole career because it good means not good
- means not cheap in the end, right? So, it's kind of like Yeah. I I I feel like I again it would be interesting to hear
- what the te what teams are thinking, but like it it seems so chancy still to kind
- of or getting a a a new good young quarterback via the draft is still a stochastic enough or high high
- uncertainty enough prospect that I feel like that's probably one of the reasons that teams never kind of make that
- progression from like, oh, this person's good, but they're no longer going to be
- cheap where we'll go in a different direction. I think it's always if they're good, they become expensive. And
- I think the teams that get kind of, I guess, locked in to the saddle point or whatever are the teams that have the
- kind of just average quarterback, but they have to >> pay full market, >> pay them like they're good.
- >> Yeah. >> Well, is isn't there some variation? I mean, right, you still don't have to pay
- even a a rookie a quarterback on his second contract that's only average. They don't you don't have to pay them
- massive amounts of money. I'm not sure I know the the numbers exactly, but they're not the most expensive. Is that
- or am I wrong on that? Just to keep someone who you want is just going to cost you the maximum. That's that.
- >> Yeah. I guess I don't know if Brand whether we can brainstorm what you mean by like an average quarterback. Like
- Daniel Jones is certainly probably, you know, somebody like Daniel Jones is an example of somebody who like maybe
- average is generous, maybe it's not, but he just you had to pay him basically. He's no he is, you know, no longer cheap
- by any stretch of the imagination. He's he he's getting paid like an expense a good quarterback regardless of whether
- he's actually good or not. >> Yeah. And it'll be super interesting to see to see what happens with the Colts
- in the next few years. They've got they've got a great coach and and a great GM and and and I think they have a
- good plan. So, it'll it'll be fun to watch. And and that and that's what's kind of cool about my job and and what
- I've been able to do for the last 20 years in the NFL is just watch how other teams handle uh handle these issues and
- and what's working and and what's not and then try to use those to the best I can with the team I'm working for. And
- um you know we've had some success here. We had a lot of success in Kansas City.
- We had some you know some less success at points in Kansas City too. So um that's it's the fun part about about
- football is just seeing seeing how all this plays out. >> Brent, you had a chance when you moved
- from KC to Carolina two plus years ago. So you were doing your first draft that you're coming up on your third. You were
- doing your first draft two years ago. You come in, you and Morgan and the rest of the team build out your draft
- process. Now, you were subject to the scouting that had been done over the previous nine months. I mean, the
- scouting begins almost a year ahead of time, basically a year ahead of time. But that was a chance for you to take
- these learnings from what you'd seen at KC, from what you'd seen other clubs do and kind of build relatively from
- scratch. Relatively. What were some ideas that you were trying to put in place when you got
- there around the draft and the scouts? And I know you're just one member of the team, but you were part of the team
- designing that process based on your experience. >> Yeah. So, the the the biggest thing was
- just having an an inclusive process and not siloing uh people, not siloing our scouts, our coaches, uh any of our staff
- members who would who could have a say in the in the draft. And look, let let's get all the ideas out there. Let's get
- them all on the table and let's talk about them in an open forum. Uh so creating creating that security uh
- within the draft room was was critical. Uh being being film based, watching the watching the film, watching the tape um
- was was also important. That's something I learned in Kansas City. I >> as opposed to what, Brett?
- >> As opposed to just relying on data. um which which was which was kind of a cool
- um turning point for me at the Chiefs was um when when John Dorsey first took over
- as GM there. John had me sit in the draft room with him and he had me go through all of the combine measurables
- and all the stuff and see if we could figure anything out from all the data that that we had and I would come up
- with all these players who I thought could be could be really good and and John was amazing because John would sit
- there with me and he would point out like okay you like this guy but he has no instinct. See, look, he's run the
- wrong way here, or you like this guy, but look, he's getting torqued here, you know. And so, it was just all of those
- all of those lessons. And then and then when Brett took over as GM there, too, it was it became very it became very
- film based, but also use the data to to push back on on what we believe and make
- sure that we are right or to point out something that maybe we're missing. >> Yeah. Right. So, it it goes both ways.
- you're leading with the what you had to learn coming in as more the quant guy, the cap guy, the numbers guy, you had to
- learn appreciation for the film, but it it certainly goes both ways. It's amazing for me to hear you say you lead
- the first thing you said was an inclusive draft room. Um, after spending whatever I've spent working around this
- stuff, maybe 20 years, I have kind of concluded that it's mostly a culture issue and and so you're talking about
- culture. You're talking about a culture where kind of you'll take an edge from anywhere, right? It's a hard thing to do
- what you're trying to do. It's borderline impossible. You'll take an edge from anywhere, but that might be an
- unexpected place. >> Yeah, absolutely. And and the thing too about evaluating is
- a lot of it has to do with, let's call it, job descriptions. And sometimes a misaluation of a player has
- more to do with with with not having the proper job description for what we're asking that guy to do. And so just
- making sure that we're all on the same page about that is is important as well. >> So we talk a lot about drafts and I
- think it's one of the reasons we do that because it's one of the most statistically interesting and intricate
- thing for we analysts to think about. But every year after the draft, after the draft happens, every team gets its
- draft rated. Now, you know, the pundits do that, right? Some get an A, some get a B, some get a C, whatever it is.
- Do you think those ratings are have any merit? You don't know for a few years how how good a draft is. Also, the the
- our the draft analysts, they they do a great job of of understanding what's happening in the league, how the teams
- are seeing these players, and they and they're able to to me to mesh that with their own evals, but they're just one
- person, whereas we have an army of dozens of people in this building that are watching all these players and and
- understanding who they are. So we have much more complete information than a single analyst does. And so then we are
- rated by the analyst based on the analyst's perception of our draft which is um which I think is is incomplete.
- And then also it takes it sometimes it takes these guys two or three years to be to grow into their own as players. So
- we don't we we just don't know enough. And so I I we don't take a whole lot of stock into into that. Um, obviously we
- see them and and our fans get excited about them either way and we just deal with it. But but the players go in and
- they they still put in the work and they and they do, you know, as as good of a job as they can.
- >> I just my only followup is that that I know that for example in baseball the the evaluations of the draft class just
- don't don't have any signal. They don't predict anything more than just the position um the in the draft itself
- predicts. And that's essentially what what I was wondering about in football is after the draft has happened and you
- see what someone's done. You're essentially you're essentially saying that the teams know so much more than
- the pundits outside can possibly evaluate that you won't really know until it's until that the seasons have
- un unwound themselves and you've observed and then you can go back and see how you did.
- >> Do you do that? Do is there kind of like I mean obviously you wouldn't want to
- base this on some pundit's opinion but kind of inhouse uh do you kind of like do you guys have
- sort of some sort of systematic like oh here's here's the how do we do in the 20
- now now that we we're far enough out from the 2023 draft or the 2024 draft how how did we do I don't know how much
- kind of very I I mean I'm sure there's very indirect process kind of like optimization you guys are doing I don't
- know how much you're actually evaluating your own past decisions. I >> have no doubt that Eric Eager and his
- team will come up with some way to grade past drafts. We haven't done it yet. I do just sometimes anecdotally go through
- past drafts that I've been a part of to say like what what could we have done here or what should we have done here?
- Um but look like it is a decision-making enterprise. So we it is like usually we're making the best decision at the
- time with the information that that we have. And so I can justify every pick that's ever been made by going through
- by going through that way. Now, at the same time, saying maybe we should have done this instead,
- or wow, we got lucky that we weren't thinking about this. >> I I had the chance to sit with an NBA
- team one time that did that two years later. They had the entire anybody that was involved with this with the draft
- process in the room talking about they just went through the, you know, the all all whatever it is, 60 picks in the
- first two rounds and they just talked about what they each thought and how it's played out in the first years. And
- the stunning thing to me about that was that it wasn't just the scouts talking. It wasn't even just the head of
- personnel. It was the GM. There were owner representatives in the room and everybody was saying, "Yeah, I got this
- wrong." It was remarkable um embrace of humility in a certain way. And that's way I mean it's so it's so
- hard what y'all are trying to do. It's so uncertain. Anything I think you can do to underscore, yeah, we know this is
- hard. We're going to get it wrong sometimes helps with that culture. I've got a question for you, specific
- question for you. the the the the very numbersy the analyticsy guys who will evaluate a draft after the fact will own
- up to the fact that they have no idea which defensive tackle is going to be best or which edge is going to be best
- and they'll evaluate a draft on two things and only two things. One is draft capital. Did they trade up and burn some
- capital? Do they borrow some picks from the future or do they trade down? And the other thing that analytic analysts
- will do is uh consider position value. And I wonder, Brandt, if you think the analytics community takes position value
- too far. I wonder this myself because I see some very sharp teams. Take a center
- in the first round or take a safety in the first round. And I'm curious your philosophy on position value because the
- Edalus crowd would say you should do nothing in the first round except take quarterbacks, edges, and wide outs or
- maybe left tackles. That's it. Just based on the position value. position is something that that we've talked about
- in every draft I've been a part of since I've worked for a team. So, my first year with the Chiefs was 2010. We
- drafted Eric Barry with the fifth pick and and I remember >> safety and I remember there was a lot of
- discussion about does it make sense to draft a safety but you just need to get an impact players if you're picking in
- the first round especially if you're picking high get an impact player. So, if you can draft, think about this. If
- you could draft a Hall of Fame center at whatever pick you're at, would you rather do that or would you
- rather draft uh a guy that's a starting edge for eight years but never really, you know, does never really stands out,
- never really makes a great impact. Which which would you rather have? I personally would rather have the Hall of
- Fame player. So, >> say more about that. say more about that because I think it's hard for those of
- us outside the building to appreciate what when you get to that level the contribution a kind of under the radar
- position like center makes or guard or nose tackle. Sure. You you can't have enough good players on your team now.
- Yes. Would you would you want to have Miles Garrett? Yes. Like when you're talking about a Hall of Fame player at a
- premium position, yes, you want that you want that player on your team. But when but if you're convicted that
- somebody is going to make an impact on your roster and be a force multiplier, go and get them. Don't worry about the
- position. Just get the player. >> I think you just used a term that's the key and kind of deludes analysts in the
- NFL. Force multiplier. We're still valuing these guys based on what we can say about their contribution directly
- and we don't capture their contribution to other players contributions. It's a force multiplier when he makes other
- players better. We're That is kind of the um holy grail still in analytics. Grant, we're going
- to run out of time with you and I want I just got to ask you at this time of year
- I have to ask you. We talked about quarterbacks. We're talking about the draft. You were there and one of the
- great quarterback picks of all time. Can you give us now, you know, mostly I don't trust people's memories, but
- you've been telling the story for a long time. So, can you tell us when what you guys thought you had when
- you drafted Mahomes and then when you learned what you really had at what point and how did you learn what you
- really had? >> I think there was there was a lot of excitement about what what Pat could be
- when we drafted him and and Brett Vch uh was not the GM at the time, but but was
- was pushing for Pat for a whole year. And so I think we were excited that we could get somebody that we had been
- talking about for a year. I think I think that was for me like that was a relief. I saw all the arm talent, right?
- Like you you you see that on on on the tape and and the numbers that that we were running uh from an analytic
- standpoint were also also very good with Pat. I think there was just excitement about the potential and then his first
- training camp. It was like appointment viewing to go watch and Brett's talked about this
- before but to go watch our second team offense and he made he made this one play and if I had if I had my old phone
- I I saved it on my phone. Um he made this one play where he he rolled out and you thought he was just going to run out
- of bounds and the next thing you know he fires the ball up the sideline and and our receiver was
- running he was running back across the field. He saw the ball but this a quarterback didn't and this receiver
- just ran over this quarterback who thought there was no way this ball's coming out and and and caught a
- touchdown. And we're like, "Okay, this is this is real. This is very real." And then we you we used we used a lot of
- those clips the next year to during free agency. We were showing them to we were
- sending them to to agents during free agency to say, "Hey, like we have a receiver or I'm sorry, we we we have a
- quarterback >> that that your receiver is going to love playing with." >> Yeah. Yeah. That's great. That's really
- cool. Okay, we should let you go. It's high season in your world. Thank you very much for cutting us some time. The
- Carolina Panthers are sitting on the 19th pick in the first round. We'll be sitting on the edge of our seats to see
- what you do with it, Grant. And we wish you well with the way that pick goes and
- the rest of the draft. But thanks much for the time. Really appreciate. >> Thanks, guys. Hope we get an impact
- player there. >> Absolutely. Exactly. Grant Tillis, executive vice president, football
- operations, Carolina Panthers, preparing for his third draft um there in Charlotte. Welcome back. Welcome back to
- Wart Moneyball. Welcome to the second half of this week's show. Kade Massie hosting with two of my three longtime
- compatriots, Shane Jensen, Audi Winer, Eric Bradlo will be back just off the line with Brent Tillis. Grant was piping
- in from his office with the Carolina Panthers in Charlotte, North Carolina. He's in his third year down there. Fun
- conversation talking a lot of draft stuff. We're still we're about a month out, five weeks out from the draft.
- Getting a little warm on that front, guys. Uh we're not playing Major League Baseball real regular season yet. We're
- getting close, but we are playing this World Baseball Classic, which had some controversy. So, the US was in the semis
- against the Dominican Republic. If for those of you who don't know, the Dominican Republic is surely the single
- hottest non US base for talent. I'm guessing it's like international international baseball scouting has to
- be bigger in the DR than in Japan. No. Am I wrong? >> Japan actually has great players, but
- they play in Japan and and very rarely leave. So, DR are desperate to get out. There's no way to make money in the DR.
- So every one of their players who's there wants to go play in the major leagues and in huge numbers too. Japan
- only bleeds out a few every now and then. Not because they couldn't. It's because they stay in Japan.
- >> I see. I see. It has to rise to a certain level. That's that's a great um that's a great distinction for us. So
- late I mean I don't know what else there is to say about this but the the last out of the game. So the DR were batting
- their last time at the plate. They had two outs, went to a full count, men been on base even down a run. I mean, it was
- like the game. It could have been go ahead run kind of thing and there was just a brutal call. The the last strike
- was a call strike way low like three inch three and a half inches off three and a half out of the zone
- >> which is a lot. Um, I don't know what else is to be said about that other than
- that Shane's always ready for the I >> Yeah, I'm looking forward to the ABS system rolling out for Major League
- Baseball this year. So, we can, you know, that'll probably still happen a lot because teams will have limited
- challenges and they'll blow through them. So, maybe we'll still have a lot of ninth inning controversies like this
- even with the ABS system because teams will have already blown through all their challenges. But, it it can only
- help. Shane, is it just a baby step toward eventually this thing will be fully automated? I mean, is that
- eventually it'll be manual exceptions in the other direction, right? When it's obvious the system got it wrong, then
- we'll have a manual override. But this is just a matter of >> it's a baby step towards replacing the
- humans with machines. It's a microcosm for every baby step we're seeing in society today. This one I'm cheering for
- a little bit more than most of the most the other humanity reducing initiatives we got going on right now. But uh but
- yeah, no, I this th this is one where the machines really do do better do it better. So I I I support them on this
- one. >> Okay, Audi, before we leave the bad call and and and the automatic umpire system,
- anything for you on that front? >> Uh well, certainly I really enjoy watching the World Baseball Classic
- because I love the enthusiasm with which the Latin teams in particular play baseball.
- the bat flip when when I guess it was when Venezuela won their game with a with a walk-off that was and the
- cheering and the craziness of the fans. It's almost feels like almost like a college football game, you might even
- say. Um it just a has a a a uh a an environment that and I was I was watching the game last night with
- Venezuela playing Italy. Italian is basically Italian-Americans playing with the usual sort of stayed way that
- Americans play baseball and the Venezuelan fans and the Venezuelan players are just over the moon with
- energy and excitement and happiness over everything and it's just infectious and
- I sort of wish some of that uh would carry over to the the regular season. You know, you compared it to college
- football, which I'm sympathetic to and I and I do think is probably the best sporting environment in the US, but it
- really feels like the comparison is soccer when you're talking about those Latin teams and the crazy fans. It feels
- like a a soccer thing. Who won that Venezuela Italy game? This is who's going to face
- >> Venezuela. So, the U it's US Venezuela in the finals, which is a rematch of probably one of the best games of the
- last World Baseball Classic in 2023. the US and Venezuela played each other I think in the quarterfinals and that was
- the one where the US won on like a Trey Turner grand slam. It was amazing game. So, you know, hopefully we'll get
- something similar to that this time around. It's it's Yeah, the >> I I I just to kind of piggyback on what
- Audi was saying. Um the energy with which the players are playing in general, it feels like a playoff like
- almost like a super playoff atmosphere. And it it makes me wonder kind of, you know, it's weird. This is all happening
- during spring training when usually it's like this really kind of slow, very kind
- of patient, don't don't pull a hammy kind of ramp up to the regular season. I kind of wonder, you know, I mean,
- obviously we touch wood, we mostly avoided uh injuries in the actual classic, but I kind of wonder like does
- this like for the players that are in this like are they going to hit the season like in a different way than they
- usually would because they have had this quicker ramp up, you know, is I don't know. It it makes it I'm going to be
- really interested uh obviously not just for the game tonight and the end of the World Baseball Classic, but like to sort
- of see how these World Baseball Classic players kind of do in the first month of
- the season, whether it really looks like this was kind of a a a different kind of, you know, because I'm I'm kind of
- hopeful they do this every three years to be honest. So, can you tell me a little bit about
- it? Now, it's reminding me of the the Olympic hockey that we just came through where everyone talked about it seemed to
- mean more at least as much as the Stanley Cup, which is remarkable. >> Um, when the US tipped Canada in the
- finals, um, how were they? So, it reminds me like team selection on all of that. How who selected the players? How
- many players were selected? Could you tell that the players wanted to be on these teams? Like, what's the story on
- all that? Yeah, I mean certainly the team America, the American team I feel like I mean
- Mark D. Rose has had a large role in kind of both building this team and managing it. And uh I mean anyway uh so
- I I I but the the team building part of it I think is kind of just I I I mean in
- the past it's been kind of an open negotiation between I think how who what great players can we get and what great
- players actually will be able to play. And certainly on the pitching side that's been tough and it still is a
- challenge. I I I do think we are transitioning more towards kind of a a nice setting where even even the top
- pitchers are willing to at least participate. It's during their spring training too.
- So you have to be careful and we and people have been careful. But at least have this time around having all the top
- pitchers and you know having skins and scoo go for the US has been an extra delight beyond kind of you know and I
- think this is the only time where at least America's brought really great pictures.
- >> Okay. A lot of that, ju just to follow up with that, a lot of that has to do with schemes himself. He uh made it a
- priority and uh he tried to get other good pitchers to come with it. Um that comes from his Air Force background.
- He's uh he wanted to play for the US. So he was uh anxious to do this. Many players just view this as something
- that's in gets in the way of their training, their spring training. And pitchers in particular, it's a touch and
- go. You don't want to throw your arm out right when you may not be ready. And even Skins isn't pitching more than 60,
- 70, 80 pitches. They're not going to get more than that. >> Okay. Okay. >> There's rules even that limit them
- actually um within the within the >> Audi. Remind us what Skins's Air Force background is. He's too young to have
- actually been in the Air Force. He's an Air Force brat. I'm guessing >> he was a cadet. No, he was he went to
- Air Force Academy. >> Yeah. It's You don't understand his background. He was a catcher.
- >> Um and not particularly good one. Um, and he was went to Air Force, which does
- not have a terrific baseball program. He was not drafted and he I don't know, one
- of the coaches discovered he had an impossibly strong arm, put him on the mound, and within a year or so, they're
- like they're like, "You you can't stay here at Air Force. You got to go to a real baseball program." And he developed
- very quickly into probably the best pitcher in baseball right now. Um, and yet he he went to the Air Force because
- of his, you know, military commitment, not because of baseball. >> Have y'all seen that that Twitter video
- or whoever put the video on Twitter where it skins like four or five different pitches from the same from the
- same release and people say, and then there was one where it's even the same speed. saw 97 mph and they have four
- different paths and you're like what chance does a pitch a batter have if if his four pitches are completely
- identically delivered at the same speed and yet they're going to do different things in the one second that they
- travel. >> I'm I'm not going to I'm not I'm no statistician, but I think his ch the
- pedra's chance is probably capped out at one and four. One and four. One and four.
- >> But that that's just guessing the right pitch. You still got to actually hit it.
- So it goes down from there. >> That's right. That's right. That's right. >> Yeah. Yeah.
- >> Yeah. >> Yeah. Audi's pointing out that you are in fact a statistician, Shane. So, um,
- good on good on you. >> Um, all right. Let's jump over to do a little bit of hockey. This is the time
- of year where it kind of has it almost has things to itself. Basketball, of course, is there, but um, hockey is the
- other sport that's in full swing at this point. the ABS. Shane's been pointing us
- to them from the very beginning and they're still the points leader. Um, I want to point out
- >> that I want to talk to you about this. I Yeah, the Sabres. I This is why I want
- to talk hockey, Kade. I was wondering if you'd realize what the Sabres have been
- doing this year. >> I have it, which is wonderful. I'm very happy for them. It's bizarre to me
- because they've been so bad for so long. And it's also bizarre to me because they
- have the same owner as the Bills. And it's not that he's a great owner and so where have the Sabres been? It's more
- like the other way around. I think the Sabres are more representative of his ownership style
- than the Bills are. So I want to know what's going on this year, Shane. How is it that that all of a sudden they're at
- top of their division and one of the top points leaders in the in the whole NHL?
- >> Yeah. No, I I I mean I I I I've been kind of amazed by it myself and I don't have any good answers other than they're
- playing a lot better than expected essentially across the board. Um I I feel like pundits even like as as as
- late as like Christmas were just kind of talking about like oh you know typical Buffalo terrible se you know it's it's
- been you know I mean they're break uh they're breaking one of the longest playoff streaks I think of all time
- actually >> they should be. Yeah that's right. I think it was the longest of all time
- almost 20 years. Is it more than 20 years now? Um and they're sitting on top of a tough
- >> 14 years 14 years. 14 >> 14. >> Yeah. >> Sometimes these things happen when you
- play in a weak division and that's not the case. They're on top of the Atlantic division. And the sixth place team in
- the Atlantic, the Ottawa Senators have the same number of points as the first place team in the Pacific, for example.
- So, they're sitting above the Lightning, above the Canadians, above the Red Wings, above the Bruins, and above the
- Senators. And even the Leafs are down there. Well, the Leafs are suffering now with Austin Matthews out. But,
- >> um, strong division and they're at the top of it. >> Yeah, that's right. And uh I I should
- point out since we're talking about kind of playoff streaks, I think the Detroit
- Red Wings have the second longest playoff drought at like 9 or 10 years. And they're looking likely to I I mean
- they're not guaranteed to make the playoffs like the Sabres are essentially. But Detroit is like likely
- to break their streak as well this year. >> It's so strange to me that they've been
- off because they were so good for so long. It's weird that they were so bad. Whereas like the Sabres have never
- really done much in the NHL. The other team that we've got some affinity for Shane's given me love for the Sabres
- because I spent two years I cut my hockey teeth basically on the Sabres in the in the mid90s.
- >> You saw them at their peak. >> Yeah. Peak. Exactly. I They saw them at They got a playoff series win. I saw the
- playoff series win. That's how that's how peak it was. Um the Penguins with with uh relatively new management still
- relatively new ownership, relatively new management were not supposed to be any good this year. They're in rebuilding
- mode. Have been in rebuilding mode and they're sitting there at number two in the Metropolitan Division. It'll be
- interesting to see whether they can hang on. They they they kind of seem to be outperforming early on, but then that
- outperformance has persisted. So maybe depends. You know, one of the things that they did, Shane, they got a new
- coach this year and they went they went to a guy they knew was great build a great team builder, good in the locker
- room, good with relationships and it could be that some of that outperformance is a new coach and and
- and unex maybe, you know, it's a serious I think it's a great management team. So
- maybe they made an especially good coaching hire that pulls that the talent of the the guys up a little bit.
- >> Yeah. I think also corre like Sydney Crosby's clearly an amazing leader uh on
- on the ice and kind of has had I think part of I think there them continuing maybe longer than we expected is Sydney
- Crosby continuing longer than he expected or anybody expected of him at the top of his game both in the
- leadership because you know the leadership that he contributes but also still being an elite level player. I I
- think the Penguins were probably kind of >> know knowing they'd still get the leadership part, but still getting the
- elite player part, I think, is an unexpected bonus for them the last couple years.
- >> That's interesting, Shane. And it is an interesting question. Like we we we we
- know some of these psychological effects matter. It's just hard to pin them down.
- it. How how much do you think it matters when a team you this maybe young guys, some unproven guys, maybe on the roster
- they don't look that talented, but they're in the middle of them is one of the all-time greats in the history of
- the NHL who still plays at a high level. What do you think that does to the motivation, the practice practices, you
- know, the discipline of the rest of the guys around him? You know, it has to elevate it. It has to make it and also
- like how many more seasons does he have? you know, we have to give what we can now to make sure that his season there
- has to be some of that in there. No. >> Yeah. Yeah. No, I I I think so. I but I think that also is probably a a subtle
- function of how that player respon you know responds to their late career and the leadership they show whether they
- end up still just being kind of more of a self you know I I think you know I think players age gracefully or not
- gracefully psychologically as well as athletically in a way that it's it's hard to kind of quantify but is I think
- super important to kind of team culture as you were sort of suggesting >> what you're saying is he he's no Aaron
- Rogers is that what I'm hearing from Great example. I was trying to I was, you know, I'm like, do I want to just
- throw somebody I I I was trying in my mind to come up with somebody who did not age well in this particular way or
- somebody. Yeah. Who held on to their position way too long. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. And maybe not the best leader at
- this late stage of career. Um I'm happy to throw Rogers on the best. He's been too much of a queen uh the last couple
- of years. Um anyway, all right. Why don't we wrap it there? Fun discussion. Glad to be back with you guys. It's time
- to really pay more attention to hockey as the season ramps up. Um, for the whole team, Eric Bradley went absencia.
- Audi Winer who just ducked out has business in New York. Shane Jensen from the campus of the University of
- Pennsylvania. This has been Kade Massie. Thanks to Dion Simpkins making everything happen behind the scenes.
- Aaron Tran stepping in and Deionstead today. To Marissa Raina, our producer for Deep Patel, the boss lady. And to
- you guys for listening. Thanks for being here. Come back and join us next time between now and then.
- Enjoy your sports.
Brief Summary
Brandt Tillis discusses NFL team building, free agency, and the draft process with the Wharton Moneyball hosts.
Key points
- Brandt Tillis Joins the Show. Brandt Tillis, NFL executive, shares insights on team dynamics and recent successes.
- Reflecting on Team Success. Brandt discusses the pride in the team's recent achievements and playoff atmosphere.
- Navigating NIL Changes. Brandt addresses the impact of NIL on player behavior and team dynamics.
- Draft Room Insights. A look into the culture of an inclusive draft room and the importance of collaboration.
- Evaluating Draft Success. The challenges of accurately rating draft classes and the uncertainty involved.
- Position Value Debate. A discussion on the importance of drafting impact players regardless of position.
Episode highlights
- Brandt Tillis Joins the ShowBrandt Tillis, NFL executive, shares insights on team dynamics and recent successes.“Thanks for having me!”1:13Mar 18, 2026
- Reflecting on Team SuccessBrandt discusses the pride in the team's recent achievements and playoff atmosphere.“We’re very proud of the season we just had.”4:05Mar 18, 2026
- Navigating NIL ChangesBrandt addresses the impact of NIL on player behavior and team dynamics.“We’re just trying to navigate that ourselves.”11:07Mar 18, 2026
- Draft Room InsightsA look into the culture of an inclusive draft room and the importance of collaboration.“It's amazing to hear you say you lead with an inclusive draft room.”19:46Mar 18, 2026
- Evaluating Draft SuccessThe challenges of accurately rating draft classes and the uncertainty involved.“We just don't know enough about draft ratings.”22:04Mar 18, 2026
- Position Value DebateA discussion on the importance of drafting impact players regardless of position.“Just get the player, don't worry about the position.”27:23Mar 18, 2026
- The Mahomes MomentA pivotal moment during training camp that showcased Patrick Mahomes' potential.“This is real. This is very real.”29:48Mar 18, 2026
- Skins' Incredible Pitching SkillsSkins showcases his unique pitching ability, baffling batters with identical deliveries.“What chance does a batter have if his four pitches are completely identically delivered?”39:46Mar 18, 2026





