Investing for Social Impact

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Bridgeway Capital founder John Montgomery speaks with Wharton's Katherine Klein about his core values: Integrity, performance, efficiency and service. More: http://knlg.net/188B1mn 📂 ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hi I'm Katherine Klein I'm a professor in the management department at Wharton and the vice Dean for social impact and
  2. I'm going to be speaking today with John Montgomery founder and chief investment
  3. officer of Bridgeway Capital Management uh and I'm just really looking forward to this conversation to really explore
  4. with you John what it means to be a values-driven company so welcome thanks for meeting with me thank it's great to
  5. be here really is so John you uh 22 years ago you found Bridgeway Capital Management over $4 billion in assets um
  6. and obviously your financial success is very important another striking example of U aspect of your company is the
  7. extent to which your values driven and um so I know from our conversations and from your website that you say
  8. consistently the core values of Integrity performance efficiency and service guide your company yes and
  9. what's so striking to me about about that you know Integrity performance efficiency and service a lot of
  10. companies say this I mean to the point where I I actually put in Google company values put these four in and Bridgeway
  11. Capital Management is not the only company that espouses these four values my sense is you your company lives them
  12. in a and enacts them more fully than many companies um so so let's start by that by by talking about that what does
  13. it mean to live these values in your company how would we see that well um you know I think of a
  14. report card on those and sometimes that's actually an edgy conversation um but from 22 years ago uh I took uh time
  15. more time than most people take in starting Adventure um to actually write uh the mission statement of Bridgeway so
  16. really put a lot of thought into the values and trying to answer the question so how would was baked in from the
  17. beginning it was baked in from the beginning so our mission statement has has has been tweaked some so there are a
  18. few words that are different and we've uh crafted some of the wording um better but the four business values are exactly
  19. as um as we wrote them down uh 22 years ago and um Integrity is at the top of the list
  20. and that actually is in a specific order so we like to say Integrity trumps the other ones it's actually probably the
  21. hardest to measure and the hardest to um know are we are we actually doing what we mean to say here um so service you
  22. know in in a service industry there are some ways to measure service you can you
  23. know interview your clients and their metrics to do that so reasonably you have have some Clues on what you're
  24. doing service-wise investment performance- wise in our industry there's some very clear um metrics The
  25. Return part is much easier than the risk part disagreement about the risk but nevertheless as an industry for
  26. something that you're producing we actually have very strong metrics on that Integrity well okay so means we don't
  27. lie cheat and steal well you know that's that's a good beginning that's a that is
  28. a good beginning in the financial services business you can absolutely take that for a given but but but
  29. essentially almost everybody in any industry walks around thinking they're a good person right um it's it's a
  30. disconnect not to be able to um to say that actually doing it and having very high standards is much is much different
  31. and how do you know so um I think of um one of the questions is um how do you how is it just not a word on a piece of
  32. paper right so let me describe a couple of ways in which that's true great um uh
  33. one is uh in the hiring process so if you're if you're really want to seriously be about a company of
  34. Integrity you makes a big difference who you hire um and we look for people who can distinguish aspects of Integrity so
  35. you're not just saying to people well honesty is important are you honest that's right uh because you know you're
  36. going to get what you what you uh think out of that one of the um one of the partners at Bridgeway um in his early
  37. career worked for two weeks under the top leadership of Enron in the early stages of Enron yeah now I come from
  38. Houston everybody in Houston knows somebody that worked for Enron and typically it took out their career their
  39. savings and and their retirement all in one Fell Swoop right um the partner at Bridge way in two weeks came home to his
  40. wife and said the following I can't work for these people they're Crooks wow now
  41. this was more than a decade before things blew up over in my view issues of Integrity right and I believe even um so
  42. so one is we we look for that people that have that kind of int like wow I certainly didn't see that I had other
  43. friends at inran they didn't see that uh coming so what is it about this man who
  44. has that strong an antenna for um for well in his in his words you know a a crook so I don't you know I'm I'm I'm
  45. not I'm not here to dissect Enron but it was a but but was a specific instance the other one that comes to me is in the
  46. hiring process um we try and specifically go after the issue of integrity and and on my team we have
  47. done a role play um that basically is intended to paint you into a corner yeah um of either telling a white lie or
  48. being disloyal to the company and you can see people you know as you're you know you're doing role
  49. play and you're kind of you can see there like uhoh now what do I do um because like I'm if I'm disloyal to the
  50. company I'm probably not going to get this job but and this is just a little white lie it's not you know it's be like
  51. I'm out to lunch yeah like this you're so you're asked to do that represent it on behalf of somebody else at
  52. Bridgeway our standard is you don't lie and uh your word of Integrity being true
  53. to your word is very very important yeah now it gets harder than that I'm I consider myself a person of Integrity I
  54. have a very hard time getting places on time but if I tell somebody I'm going to
  55. be somewhere at a particular time and I'm not there where is my Integrity in that in that word and what and how do
  56. people see that that's that's complicated in a in in some cultures there would be no expectation to be
  57. there literally you know right on time in ours it tends to have some other um negative consequences so I myself
  58. struggle with um areas of Integrity but the role play brings that out and you can just see in the roleplay a morning
  59. in time where they're like oh if I go this way right um and I've had people you know say the white lie uh and then
  60. you decompress it afterwards and say things like well well you know when I was in college and I had a roommate I
  61. did this it's just what people do right it's just polite it's just you know it's
  62. people do it people expect it they don't literally mean you know think that you're out to lunch it's just an excuse
  63. um we're continually trying to move in the direction uh of the highest standards of Integrity uh that we can so
  64. that's the second one the third one that I would say that gets down to the actual
  65. operations of Bridgeway would be um we have an internal slow that goes like this what's in the best long-term
  66. interest of current investors at Bridgeway every every adjective and and word in that sentence is very very
  67. specific it's longterm it's not just what we can do to cut Corners now and sometimes you like you lose Revenue
  68. generating opportunities when you're really serious about that and it's current investors not the next one that
  69. we hope to get so you have opportunities to make a trade off off in terms of how
  70. you spend your time that's a very active um question we want our investors to know that when they're not in the room
  71. right that we're thinking literally about their best interest and this and this phrase what's in the best long-term
  72. interest of current investors is a way to help draw us back in so in just in operational decisions we'll sometimes go
  73. right the four business values on the on the board and say how does this inform our decision or say is there any way in
  74. which our SL is being compromised by entering into this operation so let me ask you about some other
  75. practices and and things uh you know very strong defining and distinctive practices that you that you have um that
  76. I assume a reflection of your values and I'll and I will so in order of importance perhaps or important striking
  77. to me anyway I would say number one Bridgeway uh donates 50% of its profits to support charitable and nonprofit
  78. causes organizations yes every year so 50% of your profits you donate number two you maintain a 7 to1 salary ratio
  79. for all full-time employees so you as the most you know the founder that the the chief investment officer of
  80. Bridgeway are making seven times what your lowest paid full-time employee could make I can only imagine you
  81. probably know what that differential is and if you were with another firm uh and
  82. um did I use the word employees I think I just used the word employees you Dida and you never use the word employees
  83. right so that would be a third one those count 50% of after tax profits to support uh nonprofits 7 to1 salary ratio
  84. don't call them employees so tell us about those decisions how they reflect your values and how they create a
  85. culture that's distinctive for Bridgeway okay um well some of these things there's just a an Natural Evolution or
  86. something in time and then you work out the details or the implications of um the giving back half is one way we say
  87. it uh Ed Bridgeway was um frankly a very naive idea from the very beginning it went like this um I'm thinking about
  88. leaving my secure job in another industry that has a paycheck associated with it to start a company and
  89. investment advisory firm in an industry where I've never worked before most people don't make that transition quite
  90. in that way but I thought I had some um skills and Gifts in in investing and had
  91. been doing it personally for six years and had a reason why I thought the structure and using quantitative methods
  92. and investing um worked and would be a good idea it's a lowcost way to do what we do and if you're successful in our
  93. industry um you have the revenues and if you're lower cost then you have very strong profits so I'm thinking about the
  94. structure of this and there's some other wonderful Financial characteristics but
  95. thinking about this and thinking like okay this should actually be a very profitable company um if we do this and
  96. what will we do with that money my wife and I were 37 at the time and I thought you know we've already kind of achieve
  97. the level of the American dream that well beyond what we' aspired to or thought when we were courting in college
  98. um I thought I'd be making the equivalent today of maybe $60,000 a year in the path that I um thought so we had
  99. a house um you know we had a car at that point I guess we had two cars um we had
  100. children we were on our way to saving enough for their college education like we were on track um on all the things
  101. and I I um I had some reservation about too much so too much isn't always a good
  102. thing in a lot of areas in life and I think that's true about money as well so I had this uh dilemma and conversation
  103. my wife I'm sure an investment manager can say that but you just did so I did that's true um
  104. which I think actually I think that's a powerful thing in inside our but you're right it's unusual so um uh we thought
  105. uh well if we gave half away then there would be less and it wouldn't be as big of a problem it was I mean that was
  106. literally the thought process wasn't any more complicated than that I didn't go out and do surveys like I do for some
  107. things it was just a thought um and then I started thinking well if you did that
  108. um maybe you could have that be part of the fabric of Bridgeway so as in the process of writing a mission statement
  109. and the idea of giving back and attracting people to our organization who similarly wanted to make a really
  110. strong difference in their life and the and the giving back half provides some resources to help uh reinforce that
  111. right of the 12 good ideas in starting Bridgeway that I thought I have PS nine of them probably weren't marketable um
  112. two of them were and so we're here today and that's great but the one the concept
  113. of giving back which is a pretty naive um idea then very few Role Models I didn't have there are some today more
  114. happily um was uh just a naive idea but the single most powerful 10 times more powerful than I had any idea of at the
  115. time so I do want to hear about these these other aspects of the company the 7 to1 ratio and so on but tell us about
  116. what this you know the the why this is so powerful in what way has this been powerful now Bridgeway Foundation has
  117. done some remarkable things um but in what ways has has this giving back been powerful um The Leverage of it is huge
  118. and Frank it's just fun um so sometimes I think you know if more business people
  119. could get inside my head and see how powerful it is for the business and how fun it is just by way of living life
  120. like their philanthropic corporate philanthropy would just Skyrocket so sadly I'm not I haven't gotten the key
  121. to communicating that well but on the business side just as an example we are able to attract more people and we know
  122. from research that the millennial generation is more attune uh to this conversation of wanting to make a
  123. difference so we say if you're all about making you know a seven figure salary you can do that in our industry other
  124. places you can't do that at Bridgeway that's the 7 to one cap but um you shareing the profits through our um
  125. stock ownership plan that everyone all the full-time Partners at Bridge White that's all the full-time people um uh
  126. committed with a long-term relationship uh at Bridgeway um have so um you're able to attract people that you wouldn't
  127. be able to otherwise and you get to keep them longer and that's a part that's also very powerful um uh um so it's not
  128. that people never leave Bridgeway and and we're not trying to create golden handcuffs to keep people there but we're
  129. trying to create an amazing place to work about people serious about the service that we provide investment
  130. advisory services and giving back at the same time on my team the investment advisory team we've lost one portfolio
  131. manager or researcher in 20 years amazing so it's I would say that's so despite this the seven
  132. to maybe not even despite the 7 to1 salary cap maybe in part because of that you're still able to attract great
  133. talent and talent who want who comes to bridgew want and those folks want to stay and in the early years and people
  134. like John that's crazy you know a you won't be able to attract them and B you'll train them up and lose them right
  135. in 20 years we haven't lost anybody a Bridgeway over that we've had people move away for family reasons or um you
  136. know other reasons though our turnovers uh quite low um but this hasn't hit the radar screen I can't say it never will
  137. right um but uh that hasn't been a problem yet and and and how do you think the 7 to1 salary ratio affects the
  138. Dynamics within your company the set of relationships among your partners it just it sends a signal that we're about
  139. something else so frankly you know my salaries of a public record it's easy to live off of and nobody's going to cry
  140. about the seven right um but it's damped down like the president of our company could easily make twice as much if he
  141. wanted to just earn more at another place could he have the quality of life that he has in his home life that we
  142. intentionally try and support for all the partners at Bridgeway um would he have the opportunities and giving that
  143. he had has um serving on boards and portable water is one of his um big things he's done some amazing things
  144. there you know you only get to live life one way you don't really know um but these are big things right right we hear
  145. we hear stories of spouses uh talk about Bridgeway and what it's meant in their lives and that's when you really think
  146. okay we really have something here yeah so we're going to need to wrap this up shortly I'm interested in how your part
  147. Partners influence your philanthropy so part of I know you have a passion uh and
  148. a deep commitment to ending genocide it's not the the only kind of work that you're funding through the Bridgeway
  149. foundation so how are you connecting Partners who are coming to you you know for this social mission in part for this
  150. very distinctive company how do they drive the philanthropy that that your company enables so we're still creating
  151. that so that's a that's a creative process at Bridgeway we've done some very creative things along the way um uh
  152. and we are very happy to borrow ideas from other people so um one is uh uh we have a um a design what we call a
  153. designation which means a certain amount of money um that every partner has to give away we send it to their Donor
  154. advised fund the early years of Bridgeway this is problematic because like there's certain things as Bridgeway
  155. we don't want to support right and we finally said look we trust these people enough to have them be partners at
  156. Bridgeway um uh and the donor advisor fund provided a way to give it to that entity and then they control where it
  157. literally goes from that so that was one step another step is the um Affinity groups or committees um that we've had
  158. at Bridgeway over the years so that's where groups of Partners get together to go after some topics so we've had one on
  159. micro Finance for example internationally had one on portable water two on education these are areas
  160. that partners are particularly interested in my personal area of passion is peacemaking and ending
  161. genocide so a life calling on my part and it's a big deal to me um and I'm very passionate about it and uh and the
  162. other partners support this as as part of what we call the core Mission at Bridgeway um but everybody's called to
  163. you know a different area and based on your own experiences in life you may be more powerful in one place than another
  164. we don't want to discourage that we want to light that up so it took us probably
  165. 10 years to figure this out and how to how to start these you know like giving groups and involving the Partners more
  166. in the process um and money is part of it but it's also volunteering it's also serving on boards it's just being
  167. creative about what we call transformational change in Bridgeway yeah so last question I can imagine
  168. people listening to this conversation and at once thinking this sounds great I believe these
  169. values you know I I want to do this I want to be part of this kind of company I want to create this kind of company
  170. and on the other hand thinking I'm too busy I don't have time I don't have time in my work role to to drive this forward
  171. in my company what's your response to those who who may be attracted to what you and inspired by what you're doing
  172. and simultaneously thinking too hard too much time I can't I can't do it um well
  173. I think about that like this I think about um uh I tell a story about life stages and I say if you think that at 20
  174. years old you're too young you're too inexperienced you have you know student loans to pay off um uh nobody's going to
  175. listen to you then and it and it 80 you think I'm too old um um you know I'm I'm
  176. spent people won't listen to me because I'm too old I might not be able to remember uh the conversation then I
  177. guarantee you at 40 what you'll be saying is I've got a big mortgage I've got kids whose college education I have
  178. to fund I've got all these demands on my life there's no way right there is no time of life or situation where you
  179. either can or can't do it it's a decision that you make and how you spend your life so at any of those stages you
  180. know live your life fully be about something important and if you're too busy make the decision to figure out how
  181. to how to reduce that there was when I was aged 37 uh there was a moment in time where I had a kind of a
  182. breakthrough on I was too busy and and well it was clear to me I was too busy so I took some dramatic steps to
  183. withdraw from some things um we say there's there's you don't have an authentic yes if there's not the
  184. possibility of a no so no is an important word uh in life too to focus on what you're really good at what
  185. you're passionate about why would you not do that yeah why would you not do that people think they're trapped in
  186. you're not trapped in yeah there are there are you know I could go on but getting the energy of people around you
  187. to help make those transitions I think is key and important and you don't have to be rich you don't have to have the
  188. resources that I or Bridgeway do to make those transitions great thank you so much for talking with us it's great to
  189. have you with us thanks John thank you Catherine thank you

Brief Summary

John Montgomery discusses values-driven business practices and philanthropy at Bridgeway Capital Management with Katherine Klein.

Key points

  • Values-Driven Company. Katherine and John discuss what it means to be a values-driven company.
  • Integrity as a Core Value. John explains how integrity is prioritized at Bridgeway Capital Management.
  • 7 to 1 Salary Ratio. John discusses the company's unique salary structure and its impact.
  • Philanthropy at Bridgeway. John reveals that Bridgeway donates 50% of its profits to charity.
  • Attracting Talent. John explains how their values attract and retain talent.
  • Life Stages and Decisions. At any age, it's a choice to live fully and pursue what matters.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes