Estée Lauder's William Lauder: 'The Consumer Still Wants to Be Touched'

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] first of all I mean Estee Lauder has always placed a great emphasis on sticking to its core values and keeping
  2. the heritage of the brand intact could you talk to me a little bit about what are those core values and kind of how
  3. they figure into both day-to-day operations and also decisions to expand and add new brands to your line well you
  4. know the core value of our companies really play into decisions virtually every single day at almost at almost
  5. every single level and I guess you have to go back and say well what are those core values and how do they inform the
  6. decisions that everybody makes now mind you we've got a company of over 30,000 employees where we're selling something
  7. every 4 seconds of every single day 365 days out of the year if not more um if we could sell more we would and the fact
  8. of the matter is is there are thousands of decisions being made every single day
  9. and they're not controlled by some Central allowing allseeing organization but it's about those core values it's
  10. those principles about what makes our company great what makes Our Brands great and it's all about great Brands
  11. great people and what is the right thing to do for the consumer to make her happy
  12. and we try to focus that in and everybody has their mission and their moment for what they're doing and how
  13. does that what they do contribute to the overall mission of the company we look at ourselves in many
  14. different ways and say okay well we're s the hierarchy is an inverted uh pyramid where the top of our
  15. organization are the people who represent Our Brands to the consumer in stores around the world they are the
  16. most important because they touch the consumer every day and it's the consumer's connection with them and with
  17. the brands that continues to make us successful MH and now tell me a little bit about how women have changed over
  18. the years like I was reading a recent story in the New York Times about the company that had mentioned that one of
  19. your grandmothers kind of the things that she always did when people came in try to touch every customer that came in
  20. either by dabbing lotion on her hand or giving her a makeover and then there was
  21. also a point where discussing like the new Clinique counters where people can actually go and do more self-service
  22. without having to talk to um a customer service associat so talk to me a little bit about that dichotomy and how the
  23. customer has changed and what they want has changed many of the Dynamics of how consumers shop today for their beauty
  24. products have remained the same for 20 30 40 years and some of the aspects in the behaviors have changed
  25. dramatically and they have continually involved over time I think what's happened is first of all they have an
  26. extraordinary multiplicity of choice they have many different retail environments to choose from many
  27. different brands to choose from in these many different retail environments and the notion of convenience in shopping
  28. and how they stratify themselves according to shopping patterns has changed over time so for example in the
  29. 1970s the consumer who shopped in A very upscale prestigious store like a Neman Marcus would never consider shopping in
  30. a Walmart or with a Walmart of the day today she thinks nothing of driving her Suburban to nean Marcus in the morning
  31. to buy that very fancy Prada outfit having lunch with her friends and then getting in her suburban and going to
  32. Walmart and picking up the toilet paper that she needs because she knows it's the best value she doesn't have a
  33. problem with that today and she doesn't think that says anything in a negative way about herself in fact maybe she can
  34. even say I didn't shop Walmart I Sho Costco that's just an example for our products itself you know really is the
  35. consumer has comes in very informed she knows she know she thinks she knows what she wants but the
  36. expertise that somebody gets in the store that hasn't changed the authority of that expert in
  37. the store the SD loer makeup artist the Clinique consultant the MAC makeup the SD lorder Beauty adviser the MAC makeup
  38. artist the Clinique consultant that really hasn't changed and that human touch that is so important that was so
  39. important one of the key core principles around which our company was founded that still hasn't changed because the
  40. fact of the matter is is the consumer still wants and needs to be touched and the EXP expertise that she gets in
  41. helping to find the right product for her she appreciates and she puts that into the value calculation that she
  42. makes when making a purchase that's a very important element of the behavior that she has convenience is another
  43. issue the notion of convenience has changed not just because of perhaps what the internet offers which really doesn't
  44. represent a meaningful size of her consumption in our category and and most retail overall doesn't really represent
  45. a big meaningful side except for Books and Music and a few other categories where you can actually buy the
  46. equivalent online without having to go to a store but the fact of the matter is consumers still want to see it touch it
  47. feel it smell it technology does not allow that to be replaced so she Still's willing to go the other thing is is that
  48. shopping the notion of what shopping is about that's a behavioral pattern that hasn't really changed it's still as much
  49. about entertainment as it is about an AC of consumption and many people can entertain themselves happily at home
  50. with all the different electronic gadgets they have to keep themselves entertaining home but many still want to
  51. get out and about and be in a social environment so the result is is they still like to
  52. shop in an environment like that and that's this is a part of the whole activity and then you add that the
  53. interaction with an expert who they with whom they can talk and that that behavior has only evolved a little bit
  54. not a lot so there are certain things that CH and we in the Cosmetics business for example we thrive on the fact that
  55. so many of our consumers once they find the product that they love and they like
  56. they want to come back and buy it again and again and they want something new but they want the thing that they like
  57. not to change so they can use it again and again the number one consumer feedback we get from the consumers is
  58. bring back when we've discontinued a product their favorite shade their favorite this the number one if you just
  59. if I just say categorize their what do they complaining about it they complaining about service they
  60. complaining about environment number one is bring back that I was going to say you take away someone's favorite Shad of
  61. lipstick and they're going to tell you about it absolutely true now tell me I guess one of the other things in the
  62. time story was that you you were quoted us saying that working for a family business means every member of the board
  63. has your home phone number they know where you live talk to me I mean what are some of the challenges and also the
  64. benefits of working for a company that really I would say at this point is probably like another member of your
  65. family almost well you know a family company is both you know there's two definitions of family there's family
  66. that's blood and then there's family which is everybody who belongs to the organization regardless of blood who are
  67. also family in a way and you want to treat everybody the same at in that respect but you also want to treat them
  68. with respect and professionalism which is such an important part of what we do I think what's our competitive advantage
  69. of as a family company really is and has been since our founding is our Innovation and our patience that has
  70. allowed us to maintain our leadership in our industry because of our patience in
  71. nurturing and developing new brands nurturing and developing people and creating an environment where we are the
  72. place to come for Innovation we are the one we're the most Innovative marketers we're the most Innovative brand builders
  73. we're the most Innovative on a retail on a retail basis and we do that because not only do we have a for Innovation and
  74. we may have baked that into our behaviors and mentalities of how we look at Executives and their skill sets and
  75. development but also how we succeed with the consumer that keeps us coming back from more and doing more but we also
  76. have the patience to nurture new brands and new ideas perhaps longer than companies that don't have the same
  77. ownership structure now tell me I guess conversely I mean what are some of the challenges of it being kind of a
  78. family-owned business and well many of the challenges of a family-owned business are the same no matter what
  79. kind of business you're in which is you have family members who may have certain
  80. uh emotional opinions and biases which may or may not be B based on rational thought and they may be based on emotion
  81. and sometimes those emotions are legitimate and sometimes perhaps they're based on ideas that did work at one
  82. point but perhaps are not as relevant today in other words when I was your age well I did this or that and it often
  83. times to be able the ability to say gee you know I'm not so certain that might work right now isn't so good now that is
  84. the other side of what I talked about before which was we are very Innovative and we have Innovation as a part of what
  85. we do but occasionally there are stakeholders who perhaps have the same last name as me who have a stake in the
  86. way it was not necessarily the way it will be and it takes extra convincing to get there that's one of the issues and
  87. you know what at the end of the day I'd say we have more advantages than we have
  88. disadvantages and you just and even for our professional managers there are those who from a personality basis fit
  89. within our organization and the psychological profile that it takes to be successful within an organization and
  90. they're really good and there are others who come along and who aren't as successful perhaps because they aren't
  91. as comfortable in the family style environment perhaps they don't have the same collaborative approach to what they
  92. do and but that's almost any organization anywhere regardless of the ownership structure you have great
  93. personality fits when people succeed because they fit within the organization well and they contribute so well with
  94. their peers and you have others that aren't as successful because they don't fit within the psychological profile of
  95. the organization I guess no matter where you are institutional knowledge is sort
  96. of both a great advantage and also can be a double-edged sword though correct now a few years ago you step you decided
  97. to step down as CEO of Este Lauder and and now you serve as executive chairman could you talk to me me a little bit
  98. about some of the professional reasons why you made that decision and then also how how has that changed your role what
  99. is your role today and how does that differ from when you were serving as both chairman and executive well you
  100. know quite honestly um being a CEO of a public company today in today's environment not only the post sarban oxy
  101. and other things is is not quite what it's all cracked up to be if you read it in the press and it can be a sentence
  102. now if you're the CEO of a family company if you're not careful it can be a life sentence
  103. and the fact of the matter is is that it's uh very hard work it's a great deal of time it takes a great deal of energy
  104. and often times I found and I did not have a COO with whom I was working so I was if you will doing a great deal
  105. myself doing three jobs essentially well essentially yes I was doing a lot and had a lot going on and when I looked at
  106. the roster of the most senior Executives that I had within my organization and I
  107. said okay fine whom do I have who can be a long-term partner business operating partner with me to run this company and
  108. as I asked that question I also said let me take a survey of the outside to see if there are any Executives out there
  109. who are perhaps not a part of our industry not not a part of our company not a part of our industry who might be
  110. able to add something to the collective thought and wisdom of way our company runs that would be
  111. different and when I started to look outside I found Fabrizio Freda who is now our CEO who was someone who was
  112. thinking along the lines the way I was thinking but yet at the same time brought a very different perspective a
  113. very different background and I thought you know what he's going to add a spice and a different way of looking to what
  114. we do in a way way that's going to add more to what our company can do and at the end of the day I said I've always
  115. said from the day I walked in as I've been with my family company for 51 years practically but the day I became CEO I
  116. said I will only be here as long as I can be as effective or more effective than anyone else who can do this
  117. job and when I found Fabrizio and we found each other in the sense hey you know we got along great we said this is
  118. really great I think this is a partnership that can work and he can add a lot to our company and our company can
  119. be a better company for what he can add and he can help take preserve what's the
  120. best about what we do and then add some thoughts and disciplines the way we do things to make it better and after a
  121. year and a half I said you know what this is perfect tag you're it you're now CEO so how does that change my life um
  122. I'm spending more time on those things which I really like to do spending much more time on the strategy broad
  123. strategies of the company much more time in our development of our Emerging Markets spending more time traveling
  124. working on brand development working on Market development working on strategic Acquisitions and I'm also working a
  125. great deal unfortunately on government relations why is that an increasing increasing regulatory environment around
  126. the world predominantly but not exclusively Asia and Europe as well as in North America and I find I'm actually
  127. pretty good at that piece and so it allows for brizio to keep doing what he's really good at and I can focus on
  128. what I think I'm pretty good at and seems to work very well for both of us and our company is performing better as
  129. a result I still spent a great deal of time working not just with with a lot of members of his team and I've still got
  130. some Executives who report directly to me in certain key roles because it's both an expertise I have as well as it's
  131. the right allocation of responsibilities between the two of us so what it effectively does is from a leadership
  132. perspective it gives us a strength in the leadership in both a strong partnership as well as a very balanced
  133. approach as to who leads which efforts effectively and and there are certain things that Fabo is expert at and which
  134. I say go wonderful do this really well there's certain things that I'm more expert at that he may be focusing in on
  135. but we talk together about it and then he goes and does it or he may say look this is something I'm working on I'd
  136. really love your assistance in this and whether I say go do it and he go does it
  137. or he says please and he sort of toss it in my lap and I go do it that's we really are very comfortable there's no
  138. ego we both have enough of an ego for certain but there's no ego in the sense of saying we want to get it accomplished
  139. we're both very results oriented that's very important great and you actually me
  140. you mentioned Asia so I guess that brings my next question um talk to me a little bit about like what what
  141. countries or what regions is Este laud looking to expand or create maybe a new presence and how I mean how do you adapt
  142. to sort of going into Global markets to different markets other than maybe the US and Europe well the fact of the
  143. matter is is that we've been a global company for 30 40 plus years or if we first expanded outside of the United
  144. States in the UK I think in 1960 and today we're doing 63 to 65% of our Global businesses outside of uh North
  145. America um and that's growing much more rapidly than inside of North America for
  146. a number of reasons number one it's a less developed market so those markets are growing faster number two our share
  147. isn't as strong as it is in North America so therefore we've got more share to gain and number three for the
  148. vast majority but not exclusively for the vast majority of the last 10 plus years the dollar has been very weak so
  149. the result is is as the dollar the Dollar's weakness actually helps us as we translate
  150. back into Dollars our results so the combination of the fact says we need to be continually investing more
  151. we we're in Europe very early on in the process but most of our key competitors are European or asian-based we don't
  152. have as many American competitors in the prestige cosmetic space they're predominantly European some Asian um but
  153. we've been early investors in a number of different markets in the world and this goes back to the question you asked
  154. about advantages as a family controlled company the fact of the matter is is we've got a great deal
  155. of patience when it comes to investment in markets so we are continually investing we started investing in
  156. China 12 14 years ago and we made some very conscious decisions about 67 years ago that not we were going to ramp up
  157. our investments in China and we were going to change from management perspective how we made those
  158. investments in China or how we treated those investments in China to make sure that no short-term decisionmaking got in
  159. the way of the long-term goal of having a leadership position in share and Prestige cosmetics in China as an
  160. example we're continuing to invest in India it's small now but it's growing we're investing in Russia and it's
  161. growing very rapidly now and it's getting to significant size we're looking very seriously at Latin America
  162. we have a presence in Latin America but it's small and it's growing and we look at where might be and perhaps the next
  163. Frontier is Africa obviously growing very rapidly in population there seems to be a growing
  164. middle class we' like to see how the retail networks develop in the in those markets where there is some growing
  165. middle class the key characteristics are stronger emerging middle class with disposable income which they have to
  166. spend on themselves we've been investing in the Middle East for a number of years
  167. quite successfully and we'll continue to do so too so there's lots of regions in
  168. the world that still offer us great opportunity as well as our established markets where we look and say well how
  169. can we how we model those markets against our more wellestablished markets and say where can each of Our Brands go
  170. and develop their share to a level that we think matches the opportunity in the marketplace and we continually find ways
  171. to invest in those opportunities where they are where there are competitive advantages and sometimes we pull back
  172. and say you know what we're not going to invest as much here because we're the investment's not giving us the turn we
  173. need that's a very important element of what we do and now how do you adapt kind
  174. of your marketing to more of a global audience I mean is is it one siiz fits-all or do you have to really
  175. specialize to fit the customer in different areas you know the concept of global imagery for Brands is very
  176. important there a consistency of imagery but not a slavish consistency to image where all of a sudden perhaps it looks
  177. the same around the world but isn't as relevant in many places so how we customize the relevance is extremely
  178. important for the success of any of our marketing programs and that may mean things like I'll give you a great
  179. example this was a number of years ago but to me it's a great example we had a product where one the key prop for one
  180. of a better word in the advertising shot was a birthday candle and so that was the key profit
  181. and was leading up against the product and the notion was that you're going to stop seeing the signs of agent so you're
  182. going to stop seeing the signs of what more and more birthday candles May mean right and we like the photograph it was
  183. a beautiful Photograph by wellknown photographer and it really looked great and we were showing our Asian brand
  184. managers for this one brand the picture and the shot and I noticed when we showed it to them that they were very
  185. silent their silence was very loud Asian many Asian cultures there's a belief that one shouldn't be
  186. confrontational so instead of like the European counterpart saying I hate it I don't like it and this is what you're
  187. wrong about they were just quiet they weren't noding saying yes I love it they weren't clapping they were just quiet
  188. and to me it was a very loud silence so I said guys what's up and finally one of
  189. the Bolder ones said well it was a white birthday candle and they said well you know in
  190. Asia we only burn candles like this when somebody dies there was a reev revelation to us
  191. oh okay fine what kind of candles do you have in a birthday cake or whatever when
  192. you to celebrate somebody's birthday and they said oh it's a red and white or a pink and white candle same style but all
  193. white is when somebody dies with a stripe in it it's for a birthday oh okay easy to
  194. fix but that's a cultural relevance piece in other words so there's a consistency of the image you just change
  195. the one thing that all of a sudden says the wrong thing to the consumer you know
  196. the classic case of course you know the most classic is the Chevy Nova marketed in Latin America in Spanish NOA means no
  197. go know that actually I mean you use you you you there's there's actually a website I forget the name of the website
  198. with all these really classic marketing mistakes that were really born out of cultural ignorance mhm great well thank
  199. you so much for being with us today I guess one quick thing to wrap up I guess can you share with us quickly was there
  200. sort of a favorite Beauty tip that your grandmother would always talk about you know uh my grandmother was famous of so
  201. for so many expressions and so many things she said well I mean a beauty tip she said everybody's beautiful and I uh
  202. and she said every every woman is beautiful just some are more lazy than others and how they work on their beauty
  203. one of the things and one of my favorite expressions of hers is she said our job
  204. is we have to get women to put their hands together in this hand she has her pocketbook and this is her free hand we
  205. need her to stick her free hand into her pocketbook P pull out her credit card and say I'll take it because at the end
  206. of the day the efforts we make to create the product we want is all about the customer saying I want it I need it I'll
  207. use it and I'll come back again great thank you so much for being with us today thank you

Brief Summary

Estee Lauder discusses core values, consumer behavior changes, and global expansion strategies in the beauty industry.

Key points

  • Core Values at Estee Lauder. Estee Lauder emphasizes core values in daily operations and brand decisions.
  • Evolution of Consumer Behavior. Consumer shopping habits have evolved, blending luxury and value shopping.
  • The Importance of Human Touch. Despite technological advances, consumers still crave personal interaction in shopping.
  • Family Business Dynamics. Working in a family business brings unique challenges and advantages.
  • Global Expansion Strategies. Estee Lauder is focusing on expanding in emerging markets like China and India.
  • Cultural Relevance in Marketing. Understanding cultural differences can make or break a marketing campaign. A simple candle color change can have significant implications.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes