Susan T. Spencer's Briefcase Essentials for Women in Business

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

As the first and only woman general manager of an NFL team, Susan Tose Spencer has long been accustomed to playing in the big leagues with men. In the 1980s, she was vice president, legal counsel and acting general manager of the Philadelphia Eagles football team, which was owned by her father, Leonard Tose. But her role with the Eagles wasn't her first -- or her last -- foray into male-dominated business territory. From starting a clothing manufacturing business to running food distribution and processing businesses, Tose has managed companies with combined annual revenues that ranged from $20 million to $50 million. In her new book, Briefcase Essentials: Discover Your 12 Natural Talents for Achieving Success in a Male-Dominated Workplace, she offers advice for women trying to succeed in male-dominated industries. 📂 Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] Susan thank you very much for joining us today congratulations on your new book
  2. briefcase Essentials thank you very much um as a young woman you played tennis but you didn't like the unflattering
  3. short straight cut tennis dresses that frustration motivated you to create a dress that better suited your figure
  4. soon your friends asked you to make them dresses in the same style how did that set you on the road to start your first
  5. company well when I made the dresses for my friends I found out at the end of the
  6. day when I counted my money that I had less than I started with so I didn't think that was a good proposition to to
  7. be able to be making any more for my friends so I said well maybe I could sell these I could actually sell this
  8. and actually be in a business which was a shocking thought at the in in my 20s and so I said well let me just try it
  9. you know I just go see if I can find somebody it'll make these dresses on a mass production basis in small
  10. quantities for me and I called around and used the fancy Yellow Pages in those days that's what we had and it worked
  11. great and I found a a Russian immigrant who was welcoming told me to come to the
  12. his plan I told him I didn't have a business but that I was thinking about it and he was very hospitable and
  13. charming and spent a lot of time time with me and within two months I was in business what an extraordinary
  14. experience um what what did you learn along the way as you um were an entrepreneur for the first time well
  15. what I realized is that if a thing that natur women naturally do is they don't have a problem asking for help if in
  16. fact it's asking for something that has a purpose behind it and for example in business if you want to get started and
  17. you're looking for a manufacturer by asking somebody who is a manufacturer you know will you help me
  18. will you help me will you make my dresses and what else do I need to know well if you're going to offer him an
  19. opportunity perhaps to get some business from you then there's that's a good reason to ask them for help and he then
  20. sent me to a pattern maker and said you must have a pattern maker a fancy pattern maker somebody that's been in
  21. the business a long time that does it for mass production so and he he gave me the names of some material suppliers and
  22. he said these are the kind of materials I would suggest go on your way come back
  23. when you have it and without that I would not have gotten started in the right direction that's great thank you
  24. um although you had many successes in the in the first Venture ultimately you were forced to close the business what
  25. happened and how did that experience influence you in later uh business ventures permanently indelibly said
  26. never take a partner because you really don't know what a partner is until you live with
  27. them whether you live with them as a husband and wife or whether you live with them as a partner in business you
  28. they might look great on paper they might have great skill sets that doesn't show you how well they use their skill
  29. sets so you really don't know until you're into business with them so I have two rules now my rule in business was
  30. never take a partner and I never did never again but if you're going to take a partner you better have a honeymoon
  31. trial period with lots of good contracts written written lots of information that
  32. allows you an out that doesn't destroy your business in 1976 she moved to Philadelphia with your husband and young
  33. daughter and began law school two years into your education you convinced your father Leonard to to hire you as legal
  34. counsel for his business he was then owner of the Philadelphia Eagles football team as many know soon you were
  35. legal counsel vice president and general manager you write that although you were
  36. general manager and ran the day-to-day business it would not be made public what why was that and how did it
  37. eventually become public well it was kind of ridiculous to say I was the acting general manager but I was
  38. calling all the shots so I think the media came to that conclusion much quicker than my dad did my dad felt that
  39. being a woman in that business would be very negative for him as a macho guy and
  40. also for me because I would be subject to a lot of criticism and a lot of abuse but the truth was I got it anyway so it
  41. didn't matter and Philly fans are tough they're very tough and when you put into
  42. place you take a macho all male stereotypical business like football and you say okay now I have a woman who's
  43. managing the operation it doesn't go over well it just doesn't and the fans were very angry they really were they
  44. were they were frustrated they were angry and every loss was my loss and everything I did was my fault and
  45. eventually you figure out either I take it and I handle it and I handle it within myself or I get out and um my
  46. option was to stay and hang hang in there which I did until my dad sold the club that's right and to this day um
  47. you're the only General Manager who is a woman for an NFL team do you see that changing not unless there's a lot of
  48. dads who bring up business daughters who really are convinced they want to take the flak because it's a lot of flak and
  49. if you don't know yourself well if you're not comfortable with who you are you better not be in a place where
  50. everybody doesn't like you because then it's really going to make it you're going to have a lot of bad days
  51. thank you what was it like to work with your father and what did you learn from him um also how would you say he
  52. influenced you on your professional path well he probably got me into a professional path in spite of him
  53. because he was a typical father of that generation that said women should be at home and he always wanted boys he had
  54. two girls so we got exposed to business but not because he intended the exposure
  55. it just was there because business was all around us he was a businessman so he was always doing business deals so we
  56. would be like flies on the wall so we absorbed a lot of the information that he was sharing but not trying to share
  57. with us and I think that because he was not pro women in business that I was driven to be in business in order to
  58. kind of prove to myself that I could do that and so I think he was a very important force in my life and my early
  59. force of going into business just because I thought it was something I should do that felt right for me and the
  60. Eagles really came kind of in the back end I wasn't looking for a job at the Eagles I went to law school because I
  61. had a fight with my partner in my first business and said I'm never going to let
  62. that happen again I need to understand what I'm doing I need to understand the consequences of contracts if they're
  63. poorly written it can get you in a heap of trouble and I didn't want that to happen again so I went to law school to
  64. get the education so I could have that discipline but I really wanted to be back in business but at the time when we
  65. moved back back to Philadelphia because I went to Villanova Law School my dad was in the same neighborhood that I was
  66. we hadn't been together in maybe 15 years and uh as a result of that I got to see him more often than I did over
  67. the 15 years not a lot but once in a while and I happen to ask him one day at dinner who was what law firm was he
  68. using and how much was he spending because the team was always losing money so he said I'm using a very the largest
  69. firm in town and I'm using the senior partner so I said that has to be a lot of bucks he said it is so I I said to
  70. him I'll do it for $50,000 a year he said fine when can you start how about tomorrow because I told him that the
  71. kind of law that was necessary at a professional football team was really very basic law it was something that a
  72. first or second year lawyer could do it wasn't complicated law because the big complicated lawsuits were handled by the
  73. National Football League so I was able to kind of bluff my way through that for a year or two and while I was there the
  74. business side of me really really kicked in because I was very interested in how
  75. he was running the business and what he was doing and how he was doing it so I did a lot of research and I paid a lot
  76. of attention to what was going on and I would go in and talk to my dad when he was in the office he usually came in
  77. late in the afternoon and say dad do you know that such and such is you're spending money for such and such and he
  78. never answered me and he never indicated that there was any issues with it I just
  79. felt he should know if he didn't know I wanted him to know even though maybe he didn't want to know and that one for two
  80. years I kept saying do you know about this expense and do you know about this one and he just kind of looked at me
  81. didn't say a word and I so I left but it didn't deter me I continued to do it and
  82. I was kind of like the pest on the wall that just wouldn't go away because after
  83. all it's my dad it's my it's the family business if you look at it that way and I wanted to protect it for the family if
  84. I could and one day he called me in and he said I just fired the general manager
  85. you fire everybody else so I figured once I fired everybody else I just stepped right up became something else I
  86. became a vice president and a GM so that was kind of an interesting day it was a
  87. kind of a a total surprise for me I didn't think about it I didn't yearn for it I wasn't looking for that job but it
  88. turned out I got it um after the team was sold you saw an opportunity to start a business complimenting the burining
  89. casino business ultimately you started a food distribution business which was outside of your experience at that time
  90. how did you ramp up your knowledge at that pace at the pace that was required how did you build trust among your
  91. clients and employees and what did you learn along the way I think the best lessons I learned were learned in my
  92. first business after my dress business and that was in the food distribution business you can take a business you
  93. know nothing about and if you're a good study and if you're smart and if you're driven and determined you can learn an
  94. awful lot about that business and that's what I did I studied every product that
  95. I thought would be possible to sell to the casinos and one of the buyers of one of the casinos gave me his purchase book
  96. so it was a couple thousand pages of what he bought and how much he spent and what the wholesale price was so it was
  97. like going getting a college degree in food Pro in food distribution so I studied it it took me about three four
  98. months to really study it and understand the items and then I kind of cherry-picked the items that I thought
  99. would be good for my business as a small supplier to be able to compete with the
  100. big guys and a lot of it was fresh product because the fresh product was harder to handle
  101. it was much you got much better margins because it's very hard it's very perishable if you don't keep the
  102. temperature in your truck right the stuff goes rotten on you so then it's no good nobody will take it so I ended up
  103. finding the vendors in Philadelphia for every product that I sold to the Atlantic City casinos and I would just
  104. walk in and introduce myself and say I have this little business it's I'm Distributing the the casinos do you want
  105. to sell them and they would say yeah we sure do and most of the people I dealt with were not not the owners they were
  106. either the supervisors the plant managers in most cases they weren't sales managers these were small
  107. processing plants so there was most of the business was done by the manager of the plant and they just gave me carp
  108. lunch to go take the product in and try to sell it and I did and then I got contracts with them to continue although
  109. they were kind of very loose 30-day cancel cancellations not nobody ever turned and went to after I built the
  110. business nobody ever turned and went somewhere else and left me behind so there was a lot of loyalty but when you
  111. make acquaintances with people in your business whether they're suppliers or customers and you make serious
  112. Relationships by really caring about them taking care of them they they maintain that loyalty I learned that in
  113. that business it's interesting one of the ways that you built loyalty I think in in reading your story was that you um
  114. sometimes challenge the way that um uh things have been done so so I think of when um a product had come in and there
  115. was a question about the weight you rolled up your sleeves and dived right in and um got the answers that you
  116. wanted and one of your colleagues said at the time you know but that's not how things are done or you don't want to
  117. offend this client but in fact um you weren't put off can you tell us more about that um well I think when you're
  118. an outsider in a business and you're determined to make it successful you don't take what the traditional thought
  119. is about what is possible what isn't possible you kind of check it out yourself because you it doesn't make
  120. sense to you if somebody says to me you can't weigh that because we don't have a
  121. big enough scale I then use a lot of little scales I mean it it seems so logical to me and because I was an
  122. outsider I was able to question it easier than somebody that had been in the business and said this is the way we
  123. always do it so I guess that's the way we'll do it I didn't know I didn't know the meat business so I came in as a
  124. complete novice and therefore I questioned everything everything and by asking asking the right questions I got
  125. the right answers and when I got no for an answer I did it myself um do you think that that workplace is still
  126. discriminate against women in terms of promotions penalties for taking time off for CH child rearing and so on
  127. absolutely unfortunately absolutely not every business and not every not every category of business but generally there
  128. continues to be The Stereotype of what a woman is in terms of a businesswoman what her skill sets are what her talents
  129. are her short points are and the word leadership never comes into play when we talk about women and that's one of the
  130. biggest problems that I see is why is it that men don't think that women can be leaders they can be but when men talk to
  131. me about what women's skill sets is they always tell me oh it's the softer you have the softer skill sets so I said
  132. softer what does that mean and what they mean by that is this is what they usually tell me Well women are multi
  133. taskers they can feed a baby they can make dinner and they can talk on the phone all at the same time that gets my
  134. blood pressure boiling because that's a terrible example that's a typical stereotypical comment from a businessman
  135. who wants to try to put women down and I don't take it I give it right back to them and tell them that's unacceptable
  136. that's not an accurate stereotype women can do more than one thing at once but it doesn't have to be feeding a baby and
  137. making dinner and cleaning the house there are other things we can do what do you think are the toughest male
  138. dominated Industries for women to enter um right now and why well it's interesting last night at a seminar that
  139. I did uh Arthur Miller who's a noted uh legal historian and lawyer uh said that he thought that now
  140. there's a Level Playing Field for women in the legal profession and uh me being the person
  141. who can't keep their mouth shut said I don't agree with you he said what do you mean mean you don't agree the a woman
  142. that was in my class in law school 40 years ago is sitting on the Supreme Court I said great and how many female
  143. partners are there in the large law firms in the United States he said I don't know I said how about
  144. 16% that's not a real good number if we've leveled the playing field 16% is a heck of a long way from 50% so I think
  145. it's almost in every profession where there's a Bastion of male dominance it is very slow for them to make a change
  146. and I think that's because they take advantage of women because women tend to be more passive much less aggressive
  147. much less outfront in terms of what they feel their skill sets are what they feel
  148. they've accomplished and if you took a male law student or and it could be anybody and you took a female law
  149. student and they both day one go to a large firm on day two the male former law student is on the door of the senior
  150. partner saying look what I did today I did six of these I build this I buil that every day they're promoting
  151. themselves what are women doing they're doing their work diligently and doing it
  152. beautifully and they're getting a gold star but that gold star doesn't mean anything unless they're in there at the
  153. same level pushing the same information and making sure that the senior partner knows the kind of work they're
  154. contributing they will not get partnership or anything else so that's really the message that I have for women
  155. is stand up let people know you're around don't be AF afid it's not bragging to say I've done this this this
  156. and this it's selling you're selling yourself and you're selling yourself in a positive light because if you don't
  157. sell yourself nobody else will

Brief Summary

Susan discusses her entrepreneurial journey, challenges in the NFL, and the importance of self-promotion for women in business.

Key points

  • Susan's Journey to Entrepreneurship. Susan shares how frustration with tennis dresses led her to start her first business.
  • Lessons from Business Partnerships. Susan reflects on the importance of understanding partners in business.
  • Challenging Gender Stereotypes. Susan discusses the ongoing stereotypes women face in business.
  • Empowering Women in the Workplace. Susan encourages women to advocate for themselves and their accomplishments.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes