MOOCs Making Progress after the Hype Has Died

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Coursera co-founder Daphne Koller talks with Knowledge@Wharton about how MOOCs can maintain momentum even though the flurry of attention surrounding them has died down. More: http://knlg.net/1tDtIrd 📂 Technology

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hello I'm Don houman I'm the managing director of the Wharton schools Innovation group uh today I'll be
  2. speaking with Daphne ker Daphne is the co-founder of corsera the world's largest provider of mukes uh she's also
  3. a computer scientist at Stanford University Deanie uh discussed the corsera initiative with us two years ago
  4. and today we're looking for an update to find what's new what's changed and what's coming in the future thanks
  5. Stephanie for coming and talking to us this uh this morning um pleasure to be here it's been a couple years since we
  6. saw you last and uh 2012 when we saw you was according to the New York Times the
  7. year of the moo that's right and then a a number of people in the higher education press decided that by 2013 the
  8. Revolution was over so my question is is the revolution over no I think um the both the we're in the Gartner hype cycle
  9. and were just I think emerging from the trough of disillusionment partly what happened was that the hype was
  10. completely unmar it was based on a presumption that we're going to put universities out of business a position
  11. that we neither endorsed nor thought was the right thing to do um and then in 2013 we had the disillusionment because
  12. whoa It's been 12 months and we still haven't put universities out of business oh my gosh so I think neither of those
  13. two views are the right one uh what we're we're seeing as our target audience is people who are primarily
  14. working adults and are not currently candidates for um for traditional forms of Education that's the vast majority of
  15. our audience and they keep coming we have over 10 million users on the site right now and they're very happy with
  16. what they're getting and the rate of increases remain constant yes we're seeing a significant increase over time
  17. in both the number of users overall but also the number of active users on the site and also very significant increase
  18. in number of people who consider this sufficiently valuable that that pay for one of the verified credentials the
  19. verified certificates that we offer in terms of uh looking at the the metrics that some of those that you just
  20. mentioned wondering what the key metrics are for you in terms of uh uh addressing
  21. some of the critics of the moo landscape people have suggested for instance that
  22. the early demographic studies that showed uh that most participants are not who we imagine but are rather well
  23. educated uh from uh developed Nations uh disproportionately male um uh have those demographics changed or
  24. or uh is that uh a metric that you follow in terms of evaluating the initiative right so we definitely follow
  25. those metrics those initial studies were done on a subset of early courses that were primary primarily graduate level
  26. courses when offered at the universities that offered them and as such appealed primarily to people with University
  27. degrees um if you look at our current demographics um 75% of our users do have college degrees that in turn means that
  28. 25% don't which is still 2 and a half million people so that's just an awful lot of people that are getting access to
  29. education that don't currently have that um however I think it's important to remember that even the 75% who do have
  30. college degrees that doesn't mean that there your wealthy yuppies working on Wall Street um there are many parts of
  31. the world where having a college degree is far from being guarantee of employability in some cases like um in
  32. the developed in the developing countries um many of the colleges offer a very um mediocre educational
  33. experience that in many cases is by is far from being guarantee of a of a good job in many other parts of the world um
  34. people are finding that the education that they got when they went to college 15 20 years ago is no longer adequate
  35. for the kind of jobs that the current economy needs and they absolutely need to have that kind of refresher in order
  36. for them to have access to the jobs that they like we're getting so many stories
  37. from people who say that by taking these courses even when they had college degrees it was a complete transformation
  38. for them in terms of their career prospects is there evidence from the employer side of the that that the or
  39. what evidence is there that the employers are valuing either the signature track certificates or or if
  40. you could speak to as well this new concept of a specialization so first of all um there is evidence from both the
  41. employer side and the employee side uh we're at something like 70% of people who earn verified certificates from a
  42. either a a course or a specialization are posting those credentials on LinkedIn we're currently the second
  43. biggest credential supplier if you will corsera on LinkedIn right after my Microsoft which is incredible for two
  44. and a half years that suggests that the that the prospective employees are seeing value in these credentials in
  45. terms of the employer side um we had one of our other university Partners Duke uh
  46. together with RTI did an interesting study of employers in North Carolina so this is not you know just high-tech
  47. Employers in Silicon Valley this was across multiple sectors and I think 73% of them said that they would value a
  48. credential from AO as a component in a hiring process so I think we're starting to see significant uptake on the
  49. employer side um with regards to corsera as an organization uh I have a couple of
  50. questions one is the uh last time we met we talked about various potential avenues for Revenue generation uh any
  51. updates on the business model behind corsera so partly as a matter of focus we have decided that we're going to
  52. initially really pay attention to the verified certificate for both courses and specializations as the primary
  53. revenue source for us that's worked out really well in the sense that if you look at the number of people of course
  54. completers the fraction of course completers who are opting to earn a verified certificate that number has
  55. climbed steadily from less than 10% when we started to to somewhere between 20 to
  56. 25% um right now with some of the courses especially ones that are part of those specializations that that we
  57. talked about which are these larger units of learning where there's also a project at the end that demonstrates the
  58. ability to apply those learnings in the context of real world problem the conversion rate into the verified
  59. certificate in those courses is often north of 40% uh among course completers and
  60. that's a very significant fraction so we're very confident that this can be a significant Revenue source that will
  61. make us sustainable while still allowing us to continue to offer free education is there an appetite on the
  62. part of uh of companies who have HR departments and their own internal you know professional development processes
  63. uh to reach out to you to use your materials or the or let's say the the learning assets that are available
  64. through the corsera platform for their own internal purposes absolutely we've had contact with a relatively large
  65. number of companies including some of the largest and highest branded employers out there uh we have put this
  66. on hold temporarily until we build the current platform that is moving to an on demand model which would make the
  67. courses available to anyone at any time rather than at particular dates which is
  68. the model that we've had so far um this will help our Learners in the general public who are often working adults and
  69. would cannot structure their lives around their learning they need to structure their learning around their
  70. lives um but also it would be uh incredibly important as we've heard from these potential corporate partners
  71. because need their employers employees to have access to the content whenever they need it to be there as opposed to
  72. um you know at some particular start date that's arbitrarily determined by some a faculty member's calendar so
  73. that's going to be a key part of getting this into these corporate training programs I wonder how that uh uh syncs
  74. with uh some of the feeling around the cohort model that was so distinctive regarding what you had managed to
  75. accomplish at scale and the role of uh social learning in the process of uh of professional development and um
  76. remaining motivated and staying with a project through to the end aren't those two at odds that's a really great
  77. question and one that we spent a lot of time thinking about uh we are very committed to the social component of
  78. learning uh but I think what we realized is that when you have a very large course uh what matters is that there are
  79. people around you doing the same thing at the same time as opposed to it's the same people from the beginning to the
  80. end of the course so um if you're in module three what matters is that there are a few hundred or thousand people all
  81. working with you in module three that you can engage in conversation with doesn't some of them might have started
  82. earlier and are going slowly some of them might have started very recently and are blazing through the course but
  83. that doesn't really matter to you in terms of the social engagement that you have that being said we're also building
  84. out the capability to create preconstructed cohorts so for example a group of employees at a company or a
  85. group of uh uh Learners in one of the learning hubs that we have in US embassies around the world could come in
  86. and say we're going to take the course together as a group all of us on the same schedule and the ability of the on
  87. demand platform to accommodate the fact that they want to start today as opposed
  88. to in 3 months is going to be really important for enabling that while still allowing them to create that little
  89. social community of people who really do get to know each other and it really is
  90. a cohort in a way that 50,000 people isn't um I have a question about corsa's uh choices regarding uh its uh
  91. for-profit structure by comparison to most notably I guess Ed X which chose to go the 501c3 nonprofit approach does
  92. that difference in corporate structure uh change the way decisions are made at corsera uh we believe that by going this
  93. route it has made us more on Nimble and uh faster to move because we don't need to get approval from a governing board
  94. for every decision uh we believe that it's also given us um a sense of urgency which is not as easily obtained when you
  95. have you know $60 million and and the backing of two of the world's richest universities so I think we have been
  96. able to be very fast to execute while still I think remaining very true to the social mission that inspired us to start
  97. this in the first place so to be very concrete as an example when we launched the verified
  98. certificates um we realized that $50 might not be a significant amount to someone here in the US or in Europe but
  99. it is for someone in Africa or in India and so we launched it together with a financial aid option which uh allows
  100. someone who is who really can benefit from the credential but can't afford it to request basically a fee waver and we
  101. just grant it um I don't think edex has had that maybe they had it recently but they didn't in the beginning and I think
  102. it really speaks to the fact that we're sort of balancing the you know the commercial component of who we are but
  103. also staying very true to our social goals so the Venture capitalists aren't a problem for you no uh they have not
  104. been pushing us to monetize in fact I have to say that the biggest pressure for us to bring in Revenue has largely
  105. been that we wanted to bring Revenue back to our University Partners so that they can sustain course development
  106. because otherwise it's a drain on resources that might be hard to justify because it's coming at the expense of
  107. something else so we've started to bring in revenues early as we did primarily so
  108. as to allow our University Partners to increase their content Pipeline and just one last question is just looking into
  109. the future a bit mhm uh can you project where corsera might be in two or 3 years
  110. yeah well I think it's a really exciting question and I think there's different parts to it first of all today we're
  111. getting close to 900 courses I think that early in 2015 will be at a thousand I think in three years we'll have 5,000
  112. courses um which is about the curriculum of your average medium to large University in terms of the breadth of
  113. courses that we're able to offer when you layer on top of that the very significant trend ation localization
  114. effort that we're currently undertaking that will be uh a time at which we can teach anybody anywhere anything they
  115. want to learn which I think is a really compelling Vision in terms of democratizing education and we all know
  116. that democratizing education can have profound impact on pretty much any problem that plagues the world and and
  117. making it a better place [Music] [Music]

Brief Summary

Daphne Koller updates on Coursera's growth, user demographics, and employer perceptions of online education credentials.

Key points

  • The State of Online Education. Daphne discusses the current state of online education and its evolution since 2012.
  • Coursera's User Growth. Daphne reveals Coursera's impressive user growth, surpassing 10 million users.
  • Changing Demographics. Daphne explains the changing demographics of Coursera users, highlighting access for all.
  • Employer Recognition of Credentials. Daphne shares that 73% of employers value Coursera credentials in hiring processes.
  • Vision for the Future. Daphne outlines her vision for democratizing education and its global impact.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes