The Uncertainty Facing Insurance Companies

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] One of the interesting things about the crisis and the putitive recovery from
  2. the crisis is we're left with a lot of uncertainty about the future. And maybe the only thing we can predict with
  3. certainty is that there's a lot of uncertainty. But your team at KPMG have been looking at potential trends which
  4. might shine through this. Some important trends which might help shape the future
  5. of the insurance industry. Would you like to talk a little bit about some of these trends and how you see them
  6. affecting the challenges and opportunities for insurance companies? Thank you very much. So
  7. that uncertainty is exactly why it was that we wanted to focus on some of the big issues that are out there facing
  8. insurers because um as you can tell from my accent I come from the UK and it feels at the moment as though we
  9. don't know what direction our economy is going. Um most recently um our economic
  10. forecaster was talking about is the economy zigging or is it zagging? And the one certainty it felt that
  11. insurers were having to face um was an increased burden of regulation. And with that uncertain outlook, we felt
  12. that it was timely to focus on what we've described as some of the mega trends potentially driving demand for
  13. insurance. So things like the changes in population demographics, people are living longer. Um I was
  14. talking to an actor earlier on this week about what he describes as the rectangularization of mortality. So at
  15. one stage we used to have sort of peak mortality and relatively few people used to live through into their 90s
  16. um particularly with some of the um medical advances particularly um detecting more cancers particularly with
  17. heart disease we're now seeing much broader cohorts living through into their 70s 80s and 90s um I have to say
  18. some people say well does that mean we're all going to live forever people just seem to decline by the time
  19. they get to about 1995. So that's why those statistics now look much more rectangular. So we're living
  20. longer. Um the other big trend is that particularly if I think about Southeast Asia and that's where I've been based
  21. the last three years. big changes in the incidence of childbirth and the role of
  22. women in the economy and that's also having a really significant impact on the demand for insurance. So for
  23. example, if you look at Korea, um the rate of child birth in the population has dropped almost half in 10
  24. years as the population has become more educated, more women are entering the workforce.
  25. And really as you're getting smaller populations, people can see that they need to save
  26. for retirement. That really creates the environment um that's got a lot of potential for
  27. insurers. So that's one piece of the equation. Um thinking about some of the other
  28. things that have a less positive um potential, just thinking about some of the changes in the environment.
  29. Um, relatively few people now question climate change. But the other big impact is not only
  30. what's actually going on in the environment, but really as populations are getting wealthier, as we're getting
  31. more urbanized, that's actually creating greater exposure to risk. We sometimes talk about the shape of risk changing.
  32. So clearly that's something that insurers need to be very alive to and that poses really significant issues. I
  33. mean around the world lots of different models adopted um in terms of dealing with some of the risks like flooding. Um
  34. I've just come from the UK where yet again um we have lots of pictures of the country underwater
  35. and the agreement between the government and the insurers that has let everybody
  36. actually buy flood insurance in the open market looks as though um there are real
  37. difficulties in actually reaching agreement on that going forward. And some of that is because where we find
  38. ourselves in 2012 is that governments really just have very little room for maneuver
  39. um as we come out of the global financial crisis. What else is going on? Um well, lots of
  40. technological change. Um that can feel like both a blessing and a burden. So everybody these days um
  41. wants everything to be on 24/7. Um, we've gone from wanting to deal with things online to wanting to deal with
  42. things through smartphones and tablets. Um, what are insurers doing to actually make sure their products are front of
  43. mind for their consumers? But also importantly as um customers are interacting with them in the digital
  44. world rather than face toface that leaves a vast array of data and a lot of the more forward-looking
  45. insurers are starting to mine that data, starting to use it to predict not only how to price their products but also how
  46. to design them. and actually really starting to tailor products to meet customer needs.
  47. And there's also a huge change in individuals preferences. Um a really significant loss of trust
  48. post global financial crisis. Um I was reading the papers as I came over and there was a short piece in the comment
  49. column um which was the co-chief exec of Deutsche Bank saying how unfortunate it
  50. was that at social events nobody wanted to talk to him because he was a banker. Well, some of the bad news for insurers
  51. is that if you look for example at the Adelman trust barometer which measures you know the public's trust in
  52. institutions I'm afraid to say that insurers are grouped with sort of broader financial services institutions
  53. they are even less trusted than banks. So that's a very rapid tour around some of these issues. And it seemed to us
  54. that these had both the potential for growth, but also some very real issues and threats.
  55. And so what we were trying to do was to find a way really to present some of those issues in a way that was lively
  56. and compelling and that was also functional and practical so that insurers could look at what it was that
  57. they were doing to address some of these issues. Some of the major trends you did
  58. identify such as um trends in population um which is obviously not only um going
  59. to generate uh potentially demand in the near future, it's going to affect the age distribution in the long f long term
  60. and maybe exacerbate some of the aging population issues which we've got in the US.
  61. um that one the the global climate change is another one which has some interesting implications um about how
  62. risk is transferred between people and what's the government's role in bearing part of this risk. You know for example
  63. if we can imagine climate change will change the values of properties in different locations. It might make some
  64. locations uninhabitable and they are risks which are of a mega duration. I was going to say and they are really
  65. difficult risks I think to see quite how they are addressed. So it involves dealing both with governments, dealing
  66. with corporates, dealing with individuals and quite what the forum is to resolve
  67. some of those issues I think is actually very hard to see. Mhm. Um so thinking about some of the flooding that took
  68. place well clearly lots of issues close to home here on the northeastern seabboard. Um but also in Australia last
  69. year there are a number of government commissions looking at those. Um I mean the thing that was quite extraordinary
  70. is that some insurers were providing flood cover for their customers and others weren't. Mhm. And not really any
  71. very clear answers as to how some of those really difficult issues are going to be addressed.
  72. And I think the one thing that we can see is that there is the potential that they are only going to become more
  73. significant and that's not only um because of some of these trends in the in the environment but
  74. also just because of the pace at which populations are urbanizing. So that means that the concentrations of
  75. risk are really building up very very significantly. And one of the very interesting examples of
  76. that I think is um I've got to get my years right. So the floods in Thailand last year
  77. um where I think a lot of people thought of Thailand as a holiday destination. They think of it having very beautiful
  78. beaches and I think they probably think of it as still being a largely agricultural country in the middle.
  79. Well, actually there's a huge amount of consumer electronics um assembly and manufacturing that takes place there.
  80. And the thing that was particularly critical was that in the early part of the year there had been the terrible
  81. tsunami in Japan. And so a lot of those Japanese light electronics um even sort of hard disk manufacturers were able to
  82. shift their supply chain out of Japan because they had the issues with power outages into Thailand
  83. and Thailand had significantly greater exposure to flooding than I think perhaps any insurer had expected. I mean
  84. it's actually a great success story for the insurance industry. So that's a good
  85. example of how when you think about these potential trends, we can make strategic decisions now to anticipate
  86. what might happen and protect ourselves to manage that risk. Can you give some other examples of opportunities which
  87. might be available to insurance companies? A you know given the distrust in the insurance industry these days or
  88. maybe things they can take proactively to address population change either to defend against it or find opportunities
  89. in it. Um well one of the things that I think is very interesting are some of the trends around micro insurance.
  90. So I think some insurers have historically really had some very significant questions around what does this mean for
  91. us? Um is this real insurance? Is it something that actually fits our business model? Um I mean insurance has
  92. got huge social value and if you think about it that part of the role of insurance is to buffer risk and to
  93. transfer risk. Well, it's got very significant practical implications for populations with
  94. really on that first few rungs of the ladder. And there are some very very interesting practical examples. Um for
  95. example in Kenya where we've seen um crop insurance developing but it's a very very smart product. So it's a smart
  96. product that actually is paying out on an index. So if your crop is subject to frost and so it's going to be damaged,
  97. you don't actually have to prove loss because there are statistics out there and a lot of this is actually transacted
  98. through mobile phones. It's a great example of insurers being forced to be very lean
  99. and nimble. And one of the things I think is very interesting is whether there are applications for that actually
  100. in the more developed part of the world. Yeah, this is really interesting. I mean
  101. I was recently looking at the um World Bank's vulnerability index across various countries and people in maybe
  102. some of the African states, some of the poor Asian states um are very very high on this vulnerability index. Now, it
  103. seems to me that the cap capacity of the insurance industry is going to be stretched when it comes to talking about
  104. some of these mega climate risks, but that same capacity could add immense social value um for a lot of the micro
  105. insurance programs you're talking about. But this is is this a viable economic model? Are the numbers there? Does it
  106. have to be driven by profit? or there are some other models by which the insurance industry can participate. I
  107. mean I think a lot of um a lot of these programs are initially being catalyzed through NOS's.
  108. Um I personally think there is a role for insurers and for insurers to make profit from this.
  109. But I think what it does do, it does force them to live within very slender means. And that's something that I think
  110. is going to become increasingly important. Um really there's a you know a huge focus
  111. on more customer focused products, products that are f focused around customer needs. And I think insurers
  112. that can take cost out of their business model I think are some of the ones who are going to be best positioned for the
  113. future. Yes. Because some of these products the denomination of tiny isn't it? It's absolutely tiny. You know maybe
  114. a $10 premium or maybe less than that and with that you've got to provide cover and the distribution as well and
  115. the claim settlement everything involved in that. But there are really smart things that you can do through some of
  116. the um mobile payments through a mobile phone. Um there's a great example where you can use the camera on the back of a
  117. smartphone to swipe the barcode on things like your bags of fertilizer or your bags of seeds. What a great
  118. application of technology. And if you think how lean that is, it's taking a lot of the intermediaries out of the
  119. process and so is taking cost out of the process. And are there messages there which we can bring back to Europe, bring
  120. back to United States? Is one of the most interesting um examples that I've come across. Um I really think there is
  121. more that can be done. I mean as I think I mentioned I've spent the last three years living in China and there's much
  122. much greater willingness and propensity um to want to transact um things mobile you know using mobile payments for
  123. example um I think here in well certainly in con in Europe where I come from there's a little bit more
  124. reluctance to do that but I think we might find that in future there isn't there isn't that much choice voice when
  125. particularly given some of the economic uncertainties that are out there and thinking about well one of the
  126. questions we posed is is insurance investable and you know I think a lot of investors
  127. have some really hard questions for the industry um and in order to achieve attractive
  128. returns I think insurers going to have to become much more nimble, much more agile.
  129. Well, I think the exciting thing for me about reading through your your um report and your deliberations is the old
  130. saw that there's always opportunity in challenge and you're really mining those opportunities. I was going to say we
  131. were trying to be very sort of evenhanded. Yeah. So, I mean the history of this is um
  132. this is going to work or not. So, At KPMG, we spend a lot of our time focusing on regulation and capital
  133. management. And I found that I was in China trying to talk to executives from stateowned insurers. And
  134. okay, they have a regulator that has very significant powers, but that's not how you're going to capture their
  135. attention. And so I needed to talk to them about what were they doing, what could they do
  136. to achieve further growth in this country that is changing very in some ways is changing very slowly but in some
  137. ways is changing very very rapidly. And that was the genesis of the intelligent insurer. It was something to really act
  138. as a catalyst for those discussions and sort of break us out of the regulation and capital management which were
  139. important but they're not the only thing that's important. Mary, thank you so much for doing this and good luck with
  140. the development of these ideas and I look hearing some more of them. Thank you. [Music]

Brief Summary

KPMG discusses insurance industry trends, including regulation, demographics, technology, and climate change impacts.

Key points

  • The Uncertainty of the Future. In the wake of a crisis, uncertainty looms large, especially for insurers.
  • Trends Shaping Insurance Demand. Population demographics and environmental changes are driving new insurance needs.
  • Micro Insurance Innovations. Micro insurance is emerging as a viable model to address risks in vulnerable populations.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes