How Manu Chandaria Mastered the African Market
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Africa is the next frontier for global business, presenting a rare growth opportunity in a stagnant world. But navigating this complex continent with more than 1 billion people can be exceedingly difficult, and many businesses have failed to make a lasting impression in the region. Kenyan business tycoon Manu Chandaria, chairman and CEO of the multi-billion dollar privately held Comcraft Group, explains in an interview with Knowledge@Wharton how he mastered the African market and how others can follow his lead. 📂 Management
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] [Music] Dr Manu shandera so nice to have you here at the wton school thank you it's a
- pleasure so there is a lot of talk right now about Africa and uh all the ripe opportunities on the continent and I
- wanted to ask you uh as one of Africa's foremost Business Leaders how does the rest of the world participate in
- Africa's growth today well right now I think that the people who really want to make a difference and want to really
- make imprints they are going to Africa without asking specifically the China and after looking at China the
- India the Asia the Indonesians even the Koreans they're all coming very fast and
- they want to make an impression there uh the question is that Africa is growing at least this out of the
- 10 topmost investment destination today six of them are in Africa this e Eastern Africa it's
- Kenya it's Angola it's South Africa it's Nigeria and in Tunisia uh and there are
- many more so I think that there is a huge potential right now that everybody's rushing because I think
- Africa is now providing a stable political climate ever before and number two that almost all the developing
- developed countries are now finding it extremely difficult in growth now Africa is going to grow probably at
- 6% for coming years now yeah I think you mentioned a number of very interesting in points in your answer I want to
- really uh take one of them I mean if you were going to start on the continent today which sectors or which country
- would you look at first if I got an appetite which is big enough I'll go to Nigeria is 140 thou
- 140 million people number one number two it also supports suring surrounding countries which are another 50 million
- so that is almost a quarter of Africa that area so I I'd go if I got that capacity to really handle that if my
- capacity is small then I'll going to East Africa because again East Africa is 180 million people from Kenya Uganda uh
- Tanzania Burundi Rwanda and now we're expecting southern Sudan to join that's very good but Are there specific sectors
- that you would look at as you went to those countries well uh our sectors which we are now doing is the house
- housing and shelter and I think that that is ever growing I don't think that we will change that for anything else
- right now uh we are not very very sure that whether we will go into Electronics or software or telephony because that's
- not our speciality our speciality over the last uh 70 years or 80 years has been built on aluminium and steel and I
- think that there is a great need for both of them yeah but let me ask you another question so you I think you have
- had the benefit of building a major uh conglomerate Out of Africa and having invested in other parts of the world in
- India in China in the US in Europe how would you compare managing your Investments outside of africas to the
- one in Africa because sometime people say yes but Africa is tough to do business I think you have the
- perspective of being able to compare the two what can you tell us no I I think the managing businesses in Africa for us
- because we've been there for so many years we understand how it how it manages and how to manage it uh we find
- that uh specifically in in the last 10 years because of the downturn in economy both United States Canada and Europe uh
- we are finding it that managing businesses there are more difficult than ever before I think the managing
- businesses in India is very competitive to us we are Indians but we still cannot
- manage a very strong and a Sound business in India because it's very competitive uh to me also managing
- businesses in Australia New Zealand China it's easy because they are very focused on certain areas as it's
- easier but to me because most of us came from Africa and we can understand the pulse of Africa to us it's quite easy
- to very good very good but you mentioned understanding the pulse of Africa can you tell us more about the type of
- mindsets it takes to succeed in business in Africa uh first you got to accept that it's a third world country it's not
- a first world country if you are thinking about the Comforts of the first world country it's not there but if you
- want to make sure that two multiplies by two becomes four and four multiplied by
- four becomes 16 then that's the area so pulse in Africa means uh there are speciality in every country there are 60
- countries in Africa a little more than that but each one has got a speciality and those speciality if you can really
- capitalize on those specialities I think that you're making a great can you give
- us an example well as for example let's say telephony yes uh recently the um the
- company in Airtel from India decided that they want to enter in Africa they've been thinking about Last 5 Years
- all of a sudden they came back and say all right will buy the whole company 16 African countries they're now in one go
- that's one uh in telepon and also in telecommunication China is getting very very fast very fast inside um if you
- take the um computers and uh all those products or ICT uh I think that uh all the Western
- World Korea and the Japan and at the same time the United States Europe they're all forerunners there so depends
- upon where you're going and which particular part you're going if it's textile obviously it's not the cup of te
- for for UK for for Europe or for USA it's Chinese and China sometimes is wondering
- you know today they Supply about 22% of the world government world and their Ambitions are to go up
- to 33% the think one country 1.2 million people providing 1/3 of the governments
- every third government of the world of 7 billion people that's that's a huge potential and I would like to actually
- come back to that point of China I think there has been quite a bit of debate around China's involvement in Africa and
- and most of the the undertone that you hear is rather negative where people say oh yes but you know China is trying to
- replace the West in Africa and we don't think it's for the benefit of the Africans what do you say to that well
- there are two ways of looking at it I think that this that the West had for last 10
- years has not really push what is known as social amenities they push more political
- they supported parties and supported government and this while these people came along and said first thing they
- will do build a stadium second thing they'll do build a road third thing they will do build a airport fourth thing
- they will do uh build a uh a a a hospital you know these are very much near to the hearts of the people it's
- not something which funding the government and saying this is your budget deficit so I think that it his
- own style of doing things and they know that they want so much more from Africa specifically all the
- oil that they can have it all the um other um copper aluminum boide anything that you can
- talk of that that can be done it's available in Africa and they got just they open up and that's that it's take
- it iron or and to me that's one part the second part is what they are not doing and
- which is very much necessary for them to understand that you cannot take the jobs
- of Africans into China you know when something is there in the ground we're not touched it it's
- not touching us at all if they come and take it out it's well and good but when there are thousand Africans employed in
- a plant and then they start competing with those products over there and closes the plant or
- almost on a on a on a on a on last minute closer that is stealing the jobs of Africans and that's where what you
- are seeing is negative attitude why would China want to do that is it that China China's own requirement and
- China's own middle class and ultimately they will have a uh lower middle class they itself own big market so I think
- that they should always trade and see that they do not put the feet on on little fits there and then get a bad
- name but otherwise I think that as far as nobody was digging iron or in Kenya if they dig well and good nobody's
- taking Zin from us if they do it well and good because it was not done anyway yeah yeah no that's a very interesting
- point let me then ask you about some of the funds there are major funds like Carly like KKR that that are now coming
- into Africa I was seeing somewhere that uh the level of fundraising to invest in
- Africa is at a record high how do search investors with a lot of capital coming from the west and the rest of the world
- partner with African entrepreneurs what would you tell them well I think that what they should be doing is that the
- they they should first have a a model which will work if it's a workable model says for example uh there's an
- agriculture project then it'll work in some part of Africa they can put all the money that they want that there not a
- problem but at the same time they must make very sure that African management is not replaced they must cultivate a
- better management capabilities if you bring everybody from outside and manage your project a time will come that
- you're not trans in the know how yeah so ultimately I think that all these big projects that are coming through will
- probably be you'll find that there will be a level at which the local persons and
- local intelligenti here will take over yeah I think we've talked about all the good things that are happening in Africa
- the opportunities but I think you have the benefit of perspective I mean you have also lived through some of Africa's
- quote unquote darket moment for example ID me in Uganda and some of the political crisis what would you tell
- people about managing uncertainty and risk in Africa well I would if I would be my way of doing is to educate more
- people give them a choice make them to understand what is good for them right now it is not being done quite a bit of
- people are just being all these examples of has left a very bitter test and many
- people in says for example Kenya 50 years Kenyan still feels the whole generation which was
- born which was 20 years old and now 70 year old at the time when the independence came they felt my God is
- going to be different after 70 after another 50 years of their life that 70 nothing has changed to them they're very
- bitter and the younger people because they have no jobs they're also very bitter so I think that to me the best
- thing is just to this kind of if the West is not very careful and if West does not put the standards of
- governance together with the standard of democracy but standard of governance in
- all field whether it's education whether it's government government whether it's
- banking whether it's industry that governance must be something which must be they must start taking the the
- ownership and I think that's the only way we can change we have seen a mean Uganda used to be number one in
- East African territories Kenya was a colony Uganda was protectorate and Tanzania was territory and Uganda
- supported all the deficits of both tya and Tanzania where they were there today after I me
- gone 50,000 60,000 as nations were thrown out he went I don't know how many meetings pan had it in in in London in
- other places but only few people came back now to start something which was already there to destroy them and
- restart again it's a long process and that's why still they're fumbling and and yet not there but this
- should be I think there is a question there which is interesting because you mentioned something about the need to
- give jobs and the needs to educate I think that the business sector has a role to play in it as well uh and so and
- and I mean you started the foundation of your family Shand Foundation back in 1953 long time ago I wanted to ask you
- from your experience what can business do to be more reconciled with Society well I think that if uh if any business
- who is to remain there they must remember that there is a a social responsibility uh for last few years we
- are pushing very hard the corporate social respons responsibility uh in that we feel that every person if you get
- something out of this country in terms of profits in terms of development in terms of growth must also invest
- something in this and specifically Education Health I don't think they can they can invest in in building roads but
- education they can touch one one life they can touch 10 lives they can touch 100 lives it's necessary for them each
- one of them to take conscious decision that yes they are going to be there they will be making profits they will be
- building their uh the the setup at the same time they will make very sure that people who are working and who are not
- working with them they're benefited and I think this is most important part but how do we make that happen because I
- think you you have that belief and you are known to really walk the talk on philanthropy
- but you are only one African business leader out of many so how do we make it happen well let's see let's take for
- example in Kenya uh it was in 56 when my 53 when I told my father that please let's have Chanda Foundation he looked
- at me I said you're are stupid I said what have I done wrong why I'm stupid he said you lived too long in United States
- I said I've lived three years in United States He said listen we're not for we are not
- Rockefellers we big hole over here fill it up first but I kept on arguing that we need a a focal point where the family
- if you're going to create wealth then we must have an understanding that this wealth is not going to be wasted away
- it's going to be also be responsible and the that wealth will support a projects
- and understanding so n56 says okay fine set it up now in Last 5 Years we had we created
- safaricom with the largest corporation safaricom Foundation the other Foundation East
- African breweries second largest corporation e African breweries Foundation kcb Kenya Commercial Bank
- again that a foundation we are now pushing as hard as possible that if you have a possibility create a foundation
- so that you have a compulsion that x amount of money is going to come out of your businesses and
- for profit and that you're going to look for Avenues where you can make a difference and and this is working now
- but it's very difficult now when you to ask me how many local Africans local Africans not conglomerate
- of a company like e brewi is is majority owned by probably still half 50% by overseas and 50% by local Kenyans but
- there are many billion years in Africa today how many of them are doing it that's where we go to crack how can we
- give them some kind of an exposure and bring them around and make them feel hey man you want something now let's become
- somebody in the society they will recognize and this a government play play a very important role and other
- foundations like our foundations is supporting many many people and come come along let's Hold Your Hand we'll
- hold your hand but let's go and do something good I think it's that doing good it's not that easy because it has
- to come both from your heart compassion has to come from here it's not just writing
- checks and getting involved the minute you start getting involved I'm sure that you then start finding how life is
- difficult for the others as long as you are not under standing that and you just write the
- check and said take it away that's not what we like to do we want to see that each one of
- them when I called the E breweries managing director at a opening up a clinic he's
- there he understands and sees and he finds that this Clinic has no water how can you run a health clinic
- without water okay we'll put money we'll create create buildup tanks now we'll create a b hole and the water will be
- available unless you see for yourself the difficulties in which the people live you cannot you cannot understand
- and that's why many of times you find that come and do the grassroot work the minute you do the grassroot work you
- don't have to be convinced you'll be convinced automatically but one of the things that have been uh really really
- pushing for and really advoca in for is entrepreneurship you are one of uh Africa most prized
- entrepreneur you've started businesses you've closed some of them uh what can you tell people that want to be
- entrepreneurs in Africa how do we create wealth you mentioned that in your answer
- earlier how can they create wealth well the first thing is that you know first you got to have a fire in the
- belly you want to do do something you want to become somebody without that looking around yes I will I will not no
- it's a risk the first thing is to take a risk and say yes I am going to go into that
- water if I don't take that risk then I cannot go I cannot be standing on the bystander and just look at and say how
- do is the water is it cold is it warm is it hot no you cannot you got to B it and
- many times as I I tell many times youve heard me that if you want to go to heaven you got to die
- first and so entrepreneurship is nothing but taking risks collecting the risks and failing
- if necessary failures always opens up another opportunity that is what you should be
- able to do it and take it if you don't have the stomach for it then you can just be not being able to do it but
- there is a possibility there is a necessity that people must wake up that there is a necessity for
- entrepreneurship to be in anything it's not only in business you're running a County Council
- how can you run the best you're running a health clinic how can you learn the best you know that's entrepreneurship is
- in every Endeavor or human endeavor that you can put an entrepreneurship but the
- question is that first is to convince yourself yourself are you want to do it or not are you prepared to take the risk
- are you prepared to go deep in it yes answers are yes and you'll fail so what it's not it's not that important
- but the minute you fail you then gain another experience that opens another door opportunity so I think that there
- is a tremendous necessity for people to become little bit more daring and say yes but if you just say
- oh but you know it's not safe but you know you cannot go out but you know but you know
- is not the answer uh I was I was an engineer and we started producing so much of goods we could not sell and so
- they asked me that why don't you go and and start selling to another country so I went to
- Uganda I didn't know how to sell anything and no Goods over there but what I did was I carried my
- brief I went to every shop who could be my potential customers who were not buying very much because there was a
- competitor who' given small quantities my quantities to come in large in a in a big
- truck so I'd go and talk to them and what I read in the newspaper today is a problem with this children if there's an
- income tax problem what's happening in the world you know in a year I made each one of them feel that if I I'm there
- I'll be the first one to get the order the minute it happened I opened up my God down and my competitor for 32
- years came on running please because oldest fellows were all fed up anyway and the contact the human contact
- of winning was the most important part but it took me six eight or N9 months to establish myself to say hey man how are
- you what's the problem with you our life is it and all kinds of things but it created one to one
- contact and that in by the time when I was ready they're already so I think that there a
- question is that how deep individual want to build relationships and World depends on
- relationships it's one to one relationship it's one to one country relationship one to one continent
- relationships if I go to Tanzania I'm like there if I go to Nigeria I'm like there because they all Now take me as an
- investor investor not only interested in profits alone but a track record of that
- yes I'm also seeing that the population gets something out of me because I've taken something from you I'm sewing it
- back and that's something which is very interesting there is actually something that you said which was very interesting
- about the ability to really uh deal with challenges so I wanted to ask you what is the biggest leadership challenge you
- have faced and then how did you deal with it what did you learn from it you know I when I was U when my my elder
- brother was was managing the businesses and he said that no now you see you start spending some time with
- me and every time his idea and my idea were just conflict will not will not meet uh so every time there was an
- argument so I asked myself what am I going to do now am I going to win this man or am I going to fight this man
- and I made up my mind I'm going to win this man winning means what he said I did it
- the way he said I did it but I did better than what he would do then start he all of a sudden started realizing my
- God he's doing exactly what I wanted him to do but even better that day onwards so you go to
- First you will meet this kind of crisis in life that either you decide that yes you want to sit in the mold which is
- already there be inside then break the mold but if you don't get inside you don't break I could have just walked
- away and said sorry I don't want to be with you but no I thought that I want to win unless and until you got that
- capacity of challenges you know you challenge yourself and say Yes I want to win let me give a simple example in 2003
- when the Kenya became uh the new government after Mo came in one day they they called a whole meeting of uh
- academias and Nos and private sector and government and they said one day asked us why don't we make one umbrella body
- of all the association commercial Association so I laughed at him and he said why are you laughing I said I'm
- laughing simply because each Association there are 200 each Association of chairman and board of directors whose
- ego is bigger than their shoulder now how do you expect me to put everybody in one
- go he said no Mr Chand you don't understand our problem we are new in the government we don't know which is the
- right which is wrong the the the the the Traders wants a the manufacturers wants
- B the transporter wants C the governments want for how can we manage this unless we know somewhere where we
- can get one advice that this is good for the country and this is what you will support so next morning again they
- called us and we said look then he said I challenge you Mr chandaria so I asked my people are we
- prepared to take a challenge and everybody said if you lead yes so we created then I made the set the
- government to if we make create capsa Kenya private sector Alliance then on the other side all the
- all the doors of the ministers and pses must be open for us we must come to your
- office and we can discuss it was done but the point is that unless the challenges are thrown
- unless the challenges are taken you don't make anything you can talk that doesn't mean you'll make it talk does
- not make everything talk is an isue necessary but after talk action is necessary and once we delivered that
- then it was okay so so any message you want to basically leave uh potential investors Africans and Leaders with as
- we close this interview look uh my my only message to them is very simple Destiny is in your
- hand don't expect somebody else to do it for you you say Mr X dies and I go to heaven no
- it doesn't work Destiny is in your hand unless you squarely make very sure you are going to make it and you are going
- to be in it and for it it not going to happen so to my simple to every African that comes up
- yes it's not color It's ability to say I won't do it I must do it first there is a message to myself
- and said I must do it I want to do it you can do it there's nothing that's not from 40
- people we started in when I came back from school to 40,000 people you cannot even think of it how
- can it be done in in 25 years we were in 25 countries how come it all doable so there's nothing seent about it
- that cannot be done but you must believe in yourself number one number two you must take risk number
- three you must be in it involved you don't involve nothing happens and your own destiny is in your hand please remember
- if anybody else pains for your destiny that will be totally nor work so we kept on asking
- that somebody else does the Destiny for Africa no it cannot work the Africans Must Die for themselves to make sure
- what they want to create and the capacity is there we are sitting on huge huge huge um um
- land water uh minerals you name it what's not there but you must have that determination they want to make it and
- that determination is the most difficult one to make once you make it you cross the
- border Dr Manu shandara thank you very very much thank you thank you for this opportunity and I I'll appreciate that
- because this is a message which I certainly would like to see that it's been distributed spread
- out Destiny is with us and we can make it thank you Asanti thank you [Music]
Brief Summary
Dr. Manu Chandaria discusses Africa's investment potential, local entrepreneurship, and the importance of corporate social responsibility.
Key points
- Africa's Investment Boom. Six of the top ten investment destinations are in Africa, showcasing its growth potential.
- The Importance of Risk in Entrepreneurship. Dr. Manu Shandera emphasizes the need for risk-taking in entrepreneurship.
- Destiny is in Your Hands. A strong message about personal responsibility and taking action for your future.
- The Power of Determination. Determination is key to overcoming challenges and achieving success.
Episode highlights
- Africa's Investment BoomSix of the top ten investment destinations are in Africa, showcasing its growth potential.“Africa is now providing a stable political climate ever before.”1:37Jan 30, 2013
- The Importance of Risk in EntrepreneurshipDr. Manu Shandera emphasizes the need for risk-taking in entrepreneurship.“If you want to go to heaven, you got to die first.”21:01Jan 30, 2013
- Destiny is in Your HandsA strong message about personal responsibility and taking action for your future.“Destiny is in your hand.”29:21Jan 30, 2013
- The Power of DeterminationDetermination is key to overcoming challenges and achieving success.“That determination is the most difficult one to make.”31:34Jan 30, 2013
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





