Vaish Associates' Ajay Vohra: "Vodafone Is a Test Case."

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

The conventional practice in many parts of the world is to own foreign assets, particularly those that are not core, through a chain of subsidiaries, many of them registered in tax havens. One of the advantages is that the deal does not attract capital gains tax. The Indian Revenue department has, however, challenged this. The tax authorities have claimed US$2 billion in the US$11.1 billion Vodafone acquisition of Hutchison Essar. The world is watching, says Ajay Vohra of Vaish Associates in this interview with India Knowledge@Wharton. Vaish spoke on several other issues.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. ajay thanks so much for joining us today so you're the managing partner at veish
  2. associates which is a law firm tell us a little bit about what you do there i am
  3. heading this firm which is a firm engaged in tax corporate and i p law of practice
  4. we have offices in delhi bombay bangalore and gurgaon and we are a firm with 80 attorneys
  5. some of them with dual qualifications of chartered accountancy and a lawyer or company secretary and a lawyer i am
  6. myself an accountant and a lawyer but you specializing in practicing as a lawyer
  7. now okay and what are the some of the areas that you practice um you know in terms of what kinds of
  8. law that you have personally i am a direct tax specialist so i practice on the tax side i'm responsible for
  9. tax advisory and also tax litigation i handle complex corporate tax matters up to the
  10. supreme court i litigate personally before the supreme court and the higher court okay
  11. um so tell us a little bit about the um the the environment for businesses in india
  12. um the legal environment for businesses what are some of the obstacles or hurdles that they have to
  13. face and and how do you help them through that businesses that are being set up in
  14. india required uh to obtain couple of permissions couple of registrations and we handhold
  15. foreign corporations in order to help them set up incorporate a company get them
  16. registrations which are necessary under the income tax act if a fipv permission is necessary for
  17. foreign investment seek the necessary permission or if an rbi approval is required
  18. help them obtain that so essentially handheld the company write till it is uh you know set up up and running
  19. and you have both foreign and domestic clients yeah we have a large clientele of
  20. large multinational corporations indian domestic business houses a good mix of both of them
  21. okay and right now as i understand it foreign law firms are not allowed to set up in
  22. india tell us about that and what are the pros and cons of of that see india made a commitment to
  23. the wto that they would open up the legal services market but within india opinions are divided
  24. one set of law lawyers feel that if the foreign law firms are allowed to set up shop in india
  25. with their deep pockets they would be able to poach talent and poach business from the
  26. existing law firm so that's clearly a threat that many people feel and the other
  27. thing is they feel that with the foreign law firms coming in people will tend to go
  28. in for retaining their services and they would take away the cream of the work so again uh and the experience with
  29. the accounting firms on the accounting side the big four are present in india and fact of the matter is the big four
  30. handle you know the top end of the work so lawyers don't want that to be repeated and
  31. lawyers want that if india should open up they should equally have reciprocity in the other countries as well you spoke
  32. about the big four um accounting firm setting up what do you offer as a law firm that's a
  33. little bit different than say the tax practice of a big four accounting firm see basically as i told you i am both an
  34. accountant and a lawyer i started practice as an accountant and was a partner with
  35. deloitte but didn't find that challenging enough you know litigation was my forte
  36. and what the cutting edge that we have compared to the accounting firms who are engaged in
  37. tax practice is that we provide the end-to-end solution we are in tax advisory we conceptualize the approach that the
  38. client must follow and if it gets into litigation you know we can navigate uh the litigation and see that
  39. ultimately our stand is vindicated whereas the week four will eventually have to hire lawyers
  40. at some stage of the litigation so and and i i think if you are in the court and you have a feel of uh what the court
  41. really thinks your advice is more practical in terms of talent you talked about you know
  42. if foreign law firms come in they might poach talent what do you look for in talent at your
  43. law firm i mean is it similar to a u.s law firm where there is an incoming class from the top
  44. law school say every year almost a stepwise kind of a hiring tell us a bit about how that works in
  45. india with law firms and your law firm yeah india also has now currently very good
  46. law schools we have a five-year integrated law course extremely professionalized with a very
  47. good curriculum and students from such law schools are extremely extremely knowledgeable polished competent so law
  48. firms look to hire these kind of students from these national law universities and that is one level of hiring the
  49. other is you do get people who are willing to move from one law firm to another or
  50. moving from industry to professional practice so that's the hiring at a relatively
  51. higher level so talk about one of the cases that has made some headlines vodafone has made some headlines uh
  52. regarding um the issue with hutcheson so tell us a little bit about that case and
  53. i think vodafone is a case that is currently being watched across the world and in this is a test case for india as
  54. well you see if shares of a company which is resident outside of india changes hands
  55. between two non-residents india does not have the jurisdiction to tax and that's been the accepted
  56. position in india in vodafone's case what has happened is the agreement provided that the change
  57. of shares at the bvi level a one dollar share of a bvi company has changed hands for
  58. i think billions of dollars and ultimately as a result of that the entire chain of subsidies including
  59. the last 10 was the india piece that has also chained hands so vodafone became the owner of the india subsidy
  60. which is running the vodafone network in india and the indian revenue said that this
  61. agreement which seems to be a simple agreement for transfer of shareholding of one dollar
  62. at the bvi level is eventually a transfer of business in india and transfer of assets in india
  63. which gives india the nexus to tax this transaction vodafone did not withhold any tax out of the payment made to
  64. achieve the sale consideration on the belief that no part of it was taxable in india
  65. so the indian revenue has taken the easy way to slap vodafone with a tax demand saying
  66. that you defaulted in your withholding obligation and therefore we need to recover this
  67. tax from you this case is being highlighted in the foreign media as well because if this
  68. goes in favor of the indian revenue it will become a test case for several such transactions which have taken place
  69. outside of india resulting in transfer of ownership of the india peace as well right and currently this is uh reached
  70. the supreme court the supreme court is going to hear it in july right so it's something to watch out
  71. yeah i think the international media and the international tax community is very alarmed about the prospects of
  72. this case right and last question um obviously the law um in india it's very complex
  73. there's been a lot of you know media attention about how difficult it is to get anything
  74. through courts etc what got you interested in the law to begin with why why did you choose it as
  75. a profession i always dreamt and visualized myself as a lawyer standing in court and arguing
  76. it took me some years to actually realize that you know that was my calling and i then
  77. gave up my chartered accountancy degree to specialize into law i think every case that i fight is a
  78. challenge and it gives you a great high when you know you are able to put forth innovative interesting arguments
  79. irrespective of the consequences whether you win or you lose but a good nod from the judges or a good
  80. word of appreciation from the client that you've done your best i think gives you a great sense of achievement
  81. thank you so much for joining us thank you you

Brief Summary

Ajay from Veish Associates discusses tax law, business challenges, and the Vodafone case in India.

Key points

  • The Complex Legal Environment in India. Ajay discusses the hurdles businesses face in India and how his firm assists them.
  • Vodafone Case: A Legal Landmark. The Vodafone case is a pivotal test for India's tax jurisdiction over foreign transactions.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes