Aegis' Sudhir Agarwal: In M&As, Integration Is About Dealing with Emotions

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Sudhir Agarwal, president, global M&A and business transformation, at outsourcing services firm Aegis, believes that acquisitions typically fail because not enough attention is paid to the softer aspects of integration. Aegis, which has done over 19 mergers & acquisitions, has a detailed framework to address this issue. 📂 Management;Human Resources

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] So uh Mr. Ara very uh very warm welcome to you uh to Wharton and knowledge at
  2. Warden. Thank you for taking the time uh to be with us here today. Thanks An. Um so would love to start off
  3. with uh getting a sense of about your company, your background uh and obviously given that you're in the BO
  4. industry just a high level overview of current trends in the industry, where you see it going, what challenges you
  5. faced recently given the economic downturn in some of your key markets. Yeah, I' I've been fortunate enough to
  6. be a part of the uh outsourcing industry rather than just keeping it restricted to the BPO industry in India since early
  7. 99 pretty much since it was set up in India. Uh I worked with GE for for a significant period of time and then I
  8. really uh came on board onto Aegis where we started the whole journey of setting
  9. up a company which is to make it a little different. uh in the last six and a half years in AIS we've now achieved
  10. uh you know to hit about 52,000 people globally uh we are uh we we've done about 19 mergers and acquisitions
  11. now were you an entrepreneur before at any point in your lifetime you know actually I wasn't an
  12. entrepreneur but but most of my colleagues in Ages are entrepreneurs are they obviously are are very lucky to
  13. have the parentage of the SR group which is full of entrepreneurs so you know from a family point of view I come from
  14. a family of entrepreneurs. So maybe that became natural for me. But I think one unique uh you know
  15. composition that we have in the management team of a of ages is pretty much every single person is an
  16. entrepreneur. Okay. Okay. U so I think it's been a it's been a good story so far. If you look at the
  17. industry overall if you you know map it over the last 10 years uh we saw a large
  18. number of companies specific to India starting in the BPO space right? uh and over the last five to six years you see
  19. a lot of consolidation that's happened uh uh the the recession that hit I think overall the industry did see
  20. challenges in terms of the recession u you you know they did see with currencies getting stronger uh with
  21. companies specifically US companies starting to look at the whole uh offshoring uh you know with with a more
  22. closed uh eye I think I think some companies did face a challenge I think if Look at Aegis though our business
  23. model is extremely different. So we are not a pure play offshoring BO or company. Uh you know we've got for
  24. example over 5,000 people employed in the US which not too many people know about. U so we actually have operations
  25. in the US in South America in South Africa in Saudi in India Sri Lanka Philippines and Australia and leaving
  26. maybe a Philippines and a part of India which does both domestic work and as well as offshore work all the other
  27. countries actually support domestic work. Sure. So pretty much from a recession point of view that that that helped us
  28. uh not to let it impact us in a major way. Now a couple of very interesting things
  29. you mentioned. So first of all you know given that you have operations in so many different countries uh and
  30. increasingly a lot of Indian companies in different sectors are expanding abroad expanding their operations
  31. abroad. Can you share some lessons from what you have learned some management lessons that you have learned from
  32. having been running these operations abroad? What has worked well for you? What has not?
  33. I think I think the first key and narrower thing is that you know when we started there were uh there was a core
  34. team of about six of us that came on board within the first 12 months of starting ages. I think even today all
  35. six of us are intact and I think that as a fundamental is is the basic you got to
  36. have the foundation very strong. Other than that we obviously have a co-management team and we have a we you
  37. know you you you touch the word entrepreneurs. The way we run every country is we like to have a leader in
  38. that country who's like an entrepreneur and who runs it in their own uh uh model. We obviously have defined
  39. processes, defined systems to make sure that you know a customer they could be serviced from any part of ages. They get
  40. the same feel. But as far as the management teams go in each of these countries, they are local.
  41. Sure. You know it's it's it's pretty much like be a Roman in Rome. So if you go to
  42. Australia uh you will see the management team which is Australians and when you go to South Africa you will see a local
  43. team of South Africans but the foundation the processes the systems the IT and everything behind it is common in
  44. every single location of ages. Sure. Um and so what has not worked for you when you've or what are some of the
  45. you know hurdles you faced and what are some of the lessons you've learned as you try to expand abroad?
  46. You know I think we've done we've done 19 mergers and acquisitions. Okay. U and and frankly speaking I think cross
  47. border cross border mostly u I think before getting into that there are basically majorly two reasons of why
  48. we've done so many acquisitions. Uh one to acquire or enter a vertical where we did not have expertise in
  49. uh so maybe for example could be the collection space could be uh you know you know tech help could be uh the IT
  50. space in terms of system integration second to have geographical presence. Sure. Once we do the two, we then you
  51. know let the organic engine kind of you know boost and and grow those businesses.
  52. Uh very early on when we started on our M&A journey uh you know we we we realized
  53. that the integration framework has to be really very strong. So the framework that we built uh uh
  54. after the first two or three acquisitions is a very detailed one. And we in fact won a award from NASCOM last
  55. year on it's called the five you know uh 59 uh DNA really framework that we have.
  56. Can you share a bit more detail about that? So basically you know really if you look
  57. at if you look at any acquisition uh and and if you study the last 100 acquisitions that have happened
  58. irrespective whichever geography there it is in um uh I would say more than 80% fail only because they did not do a good
  59. job in terms of integration. Mhm. Uh integration is not in our minds about acquiring a company on a piece of paper.
  60. It's not about you know combining the balance sheets or the P&L but it's really dealing with uh you know the
  61. emotions uh the emotional part which is a softer part of the aspect uh and you you got to really empower you know make
  62. people feel comfortable. U I'll take I'll take one or two examples. We've got colleagues of of ours who was who were
  63. probably running a small let's say a $20 million company once they become a power
  64. of ages they now handle much larger roles and larger responsibilities uh uh you know you know you know pretty
  65. much at sometimes panning continents right um so I think I think you know that whole emotional part which which is
  66. there I think the connect which is we've been able to do that pretty well the 59
  67. framework which I'm specifically talking about is actually a very simple framework but um which is again it's
  68. pretty much focused a lot around people. It really says that in the first 9 hours
  69. when you acquire a company you need to roll out uh you know you make the announcement roll out the o charts make
  70. sure that there is there is no room for questions in terms of people that goes and the last nine would really be uh 99
  71. days which would really mean the entire integration and acquisition needs to be completed by them uh both in terms of uh
  72. legal financial as well as the people aspect. So for us irrespective whether it's a $10 million acquisition or it's a
  73. $150 million acquisition the framework would be the same and consistently across the board.
  74. So that's very interesting. So you know you mentioned that this was also recognized by NAS um so if I can just
  75. ask you to take your own individual experience you know with your company and how you've managed integrations and
  76. other management lessons you've learned. Can you start to generalize or at the more macro level if someone who is
  77. viewing Indian management practices or Indian management philosophy could you share some insights into what
  78. you think is unique about Indian management philosophy? Now I know I'm asking to generalize but if you could
  79. just offer some insights on how Indian management philosophy would let's say differ compare contrast against the
  80. management philosophies or practices of other western countries. Yeah. So I you know and I've
  81. had the the the fortune of working for a very large MNC in the past and and today I work for an extremely
  82. large Indian-based uh MNC uh and and I honestly feel that uh I would never trade again for for the two and and I
  83. say this uh uh for obvious reasons. one I guess the biggest management comfort that as as a part of a
  84. management team that you have working for a Indian Indian company is is is is one uh that you're not really just a SAP
  85. ID or or a or a kill ID you're not just ID number you know they really empower you and they enabled you to run your own
  86. business like an entrepreneur uh when we acquire companies we we understand that
  87. it's it's not just about letting people go uh it's about you know really doing the right stuff with the management
  88. teams, sitting with them, discussing with them and a lot of time is spent actually on soft aspects which which I
  89. feel is a big thing in terms of Indian best practice that I would take. Sure. U in any acquisition uh even before
  90. doing the M&A we would meet a management team for example uh and we would we we would take that commitment that they
  91. would stick with us for at least 18 to 24 months. In some cases we walked out of a deal because those core people said
  92. they won't stick with it. Um so I I I think that's uniquely very different you know when when there are trouble times
  93. be the other good Indian management practice is they believe long-term they can look at returns more in terms of 5
  94. years and 10 years and not kind of panic and say what's going to happen next quarter
  95. right uh and that's another big uh comfort factor that you get uh you know you know
  96. working for an Indian company and now if I can flip that question around and ask you what's the one thing
  97. you would change about Indian management Indian practices you know I think uh for the for the firm
  98. that I work with the SR group I'll honestly say I think and and that would probably be a best practice for other
  99. Indian companies I think they've managed to strike a perfect balance between who
  100. runs the organizations and and what the role of a promoter versus the role of a management team that runs the company I
  101. think that whole structure is very well defined uh they they spent a large time over the last uh six to seven years in
  102. terms of defining that and I think as long as that is defined where you know what is the promoter's role okay and
  103. what is the management team's role and and and the management team has that uh you you know that comfort factor and the
  104. freedom to go and run the organization by itself I think companies will do well uh and that's something which MNC's in
  105. the western part of the world do really well sure well Mr. It's been a pleasure having you uh at for knowledge at
  106. warden. Uh thank you again for sharing uh your insights and also giving us your time. It's a pleasure.
  107. Thanks. Thank you. Thank you.

Brief Summary

Mr. Ara discusses BPO industry trends, management lessons, and the impact of economic challenges on business operations.

Key points

  • The Importance of Integration in M&A. Discussing the critical role of emotional integration in successful mergers and acquisitions.
  • Insights on Indian Management Philosophy. Exploring the unique aspects of Indian management practices compared to Western philosophies.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes