The Economic Reality Behind Billionaires Taxes and State Budgets

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Kent Smetters, Faculty Director of the Penn Wharton Budget Model and Professor of Business Economics and Public Policy at the Wharton School, analyzes the origins of billionaire and wealth taxes, explains why they consistently underperform revenue expectations, and explores their economic distortions at both the state and national level.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#WealthTax #PublicFinance #BudgetDeficit #StateTaxes #FiscalPolicy #Economics ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. The concept of a billionaire's tax is one that has become somewhat fashionable for political leaders in the last
  2. several years. They see it as a necessary way to somewhat level the playing field between the haves and the have nots.
  3. California is the latest state to bring this idea forward. But do these ideas work? And we asked that question and more of
  4. Kent Smetters, who's Faculty Director of the Penn Wharton Budget Model. He's also Professor of Business, Economics
  5. and Public Policy at the Wharton School. Kent, great to catch up again. How are you, sir?
  6. It is good to be back. Doing well. Hope you guys are doing well as well. Thank you. We are. I guess, let's start with the— I think, to
  7. put some background on this, the idea of a tax like this, where did it actually come from in the first place?
  8. Yeah, yeah. So there's— at Penn Wharton Budget Model, we did some—a little bit of surveying, as well as talking to a lot of
  9. business leaders and policymakers and so forth. And there's a couple things that keep coming back that both come
  10. from the left and the right on the political spectrum. Kind of— kind of fallacies, if you will, in terms of how to get money and
  11. why the budget problem is not necessarily a big problem, which is actually not true. But one of these is that, man, there's just so
  12. much revenue out there that we're not getting, in the form of kind of really wealthy people, billionaires. And so the simple
  13. idea was, okay, suppose that we actually tried to grab all that money. And so I just did a hypothetical exercise with
  14. policymakers, and said the following. "Listen. I mean, suppose we do the following kind of upper bound calculation."
  15. We say, '"All right, let's just outlaw being a billionaire. Let's just actually grab all the wealth above $999 million, and
  16. more nines and change. And we'll grab everything above $1 billion. And then let's suppose hypothetically that we could
  17. actually get it, if the money can't be moved. Let's suppose hypothetically that we could then sell all those assets at
  18. current market prices. That we wouldn't— you know, market prices wouldn't plummet. We won't be selling it at a fire sale and so
  19. forth. With— even with all that, you know, pretty— call it egregious, you know, extreme assumptions in terms of
  20. modeling, how much money could we actually get? How much— for how long could we actually fund the federal government?" And
  21. people— just the way I ask that question, people often think, "Okay, it must not be a big number." So they'll guess, like,
  22. you know, maybe 10 years, 15 years. And it actually turns out it's around 8.8 months right now. And so it's way less than
  23. what people think. And so people are just completely uncalibrated in terms of the size of the federal problems that we have,
  24. in terms of the size of the spending that we have, the size of the federal budget deficits that we have, the exploding debt
  25. path that we're on. And that lack of calibration is really on both sides. So I'm picking a little bit more on the left
  26. right now, but the right has its own problems in terms of how they're conceptualizing AI and things like that.
  27. But the assumption, I guess, is that if you were to bring a tax like this into play, that it would have a significant impact
  28. on reducing debt. In this case, in a state. Because it seems like states are the ones that are trying to move this forward
  29. here. But other countries have tried this as well. Yeah. And almost every country, except for three, who've tried
  30. it have gotten rid of the wealth tax. And the reason why is that consistently, they've found that it's raised a lot
  31. less revenue than they originally projected. And so over a dozen countries— including France, by the way,
  32. that's, you know, currently hot debate about this idea right now— had wealth taxes. They all got rid of it, because they
  33. realized that the distortions caused to the economy just way outweighed any revenue that they were getting. In fact, the
  34. revenue that they're actually— you know, it's way less than they're expecting. And that's at a country level. I mean, it's
  35. much harder to move your assets out of a country. Much easier to move your assets out of a state like California, especially when
  36. you think about, so much of the wealth in California is tech based. And so as a result of that, I mean, lots of that can be done—
  37. you know, if I'm an owner or founder of one of the big tech companies, I can easily move my domicile to another state.
  38. Right. You can go from California to Nevada or Utah, or wherever else you wanted to go. - Or Texas. There's Texas.
  39. Yeah. Exactly. One of the things, though, I guess you also have to consider, is the cost of
  40. running a program like this. Correct? It is, it's— here's the— what makes it a little bit
  41. different than other programs, and that is, usually, when it comes to things like income, even a sales tax, things like
  42. that, it's pretty clear what you're measuring. The problem with wealth is that a lot of wealth is not publicly traded.
  43. It's not marked kind of daily. Yes, your 401(k) accounts and your other, you know, taxable accounts are marked pretty
  44. frequently in terms of their value. But that's not true for— with a lot of wealth owned by billionaires. A lot of it's very
  45. private. And the last marking of that wealth, even if it's venture backed— I mean, that last series that might have
  46. been— you know, that evaluation was established— was maybe a couple years ago. And so it actually is not marked very
  47. frequently. So here's the problem, is that I could actually be a billionaire and not actually know it. And so
  48. what happens if my company does take off in value? My next funding round, I go from $100 million valuation to a $2 billion
  49. valuation. And then when it was only worth $100 million based on a pretty dated funding round, you know, the government
  50. says, "No, no, no. That was really worth— you know, in the intermediate time, it was really worth a billion dollars. You
  51. should have— you should have been paying taxes on that." And so as result, you're going to have a lot of people having to
  52. do these valuations just in case, so they don't commit tax fraud or get accused later. So anybody who is hopeful that
  53. their company's gonna pop in value, unless you just had a really recent funding round, you better be doing these valuations
  54. a lot, and including everything, including your jewelry, your property, private property, everything— a house should be
  55. marked and valued. And that's a really tough exercise to do. So I think we've laid out the case where a billionaire's tax
  56. is very tough to kind of pull off. So then, what are some of the other options potentially out there that need to be
  57. considered in order to deal with the level of debt that we are seeing, not only at the federal level, but at the state level as
  58. well? - Yeah. So, California has had this problem for several decades, where their revenue bounces around a lot through the
  59. realization of capital gains. And the problem is— in fact, this happened just a couple years ago. Big revenue increases
  60. because of realization of capital gains, especially during COVID and so forth. And so what happens is that they will
  61. project this out and say, "Hey, you know what? We're gonna get all this fancy revenue going forward, and we're gonna spend
  62. that money." So they put themselves on a spending path going forward that is assuming this revenue comes in, even
  63. though their own equivalent of the CBO, called the LAO, warns them that that's not true. They still do it anyway. So they get
  64. this big mismatch between spending and actual revenue coming in. And this has happened multiple times before in
  65. California. So ultimately, unless they get that spending down, they're gonna have to get revenue up. A wealth tax is gonna be very
  66. hard to do it. And so it's— you're back to your classic means of more income taxes, which already is pretty high in
  67. California, especially at the high end. You know, put the highest marginal tax rate in California added to the federal
  68. rate. Those people are actually paying the majority of their income in taxes. And so over 50 cents on the dollar in taxes. So it's
  69. already fairly distorting. So there's pretty much no option in California outside of really broad-based taxes like a more
  70. aggressive sales tax, a value- added tax, something of that nature, where they're going to get more— a lot more revenue.
  71. They're going to have to do some combination of bringing the spending down. And if they, in fact, want more revenue, it's
  72. going to have to be very broad- based. Kent, always great to talk with you and get your insight. Thanks
  73. very much. Pleasure. Thank you. Kent Smetters, who is Faculty Director of the Penn Wharton Budget Model, and also
  74. Professor of Business, Economics and Public Policy here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Kent Smetters discusses the challenges and misconceptions surrounding a billionaire's tax and its potential impact on state and federal budgets.

Key points

  • The Billionaire's Tax Debate. Exploring the viability of a billionaire's tax and its implications for revenue generation.
  • Challenges of Wealth Valuation. Kent Smetters explains the difficulties in accurately assessing billionaire wealth for taxation.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes