How the NFL Uses Data to Shape Rules and Create New Metrics

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Michael Lopez, Senior Director of Football Data and Analytics at the NFL, joins the Moneyball team to explain the use of causal inference and drive simulations in shaping the modern game of football. Plus, Eric and Adi explore the mathematical phenomenon of regression to the mean and how it applies to the unprecedented career trajectories of athletes like Carlos Alcaraz and Shohei Ohtani.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#FootballStats #NFLAnalytics #FootballAnalytics #SportsData #SportsAnalytics ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Welcome, welcome everybody to the podcast edition of Wharton Moneyball. This is Eric Bradlo, professor of
  2. marketing, statistics, and data science here at the Wharton School. Some combination of myself, my co-host who is
  3. here today, professor of statistics and data science Audi Winer, Kade Massie and
  4. Shane Jensen are here every week on Wharton Moneyball. Audi, first, it's great to see you. It's always great to
  5. be back with the show. 11. Oh, actually we're approaching 12 years of the show now. But one of my favorite parts of the
  6. show, I know it is yours, is when we get to interview people that actually apply
  7. statistics and data science in the real world. And today, not only is today no exception, but probably someone that has
  8. impacted you'll talk about this audi I'm sure, which you can talk about the big beta data bowl and how it's impacted you
  9. and your ability to train our students. But we're honored to be joined by Michael goes by Mike Lopez. Mike's the
  10. senior director of football data and analytics at the National Football League. Longtime friend of ours here at
  11. Wharton Moneyball. I actually think Audi, it's important. A lot of times I don't need to read someone's bio, but I
  12. think his bio is so impressive because of his ability to straddle academia and practice. I think it's important for our
  13. listeners to know you can have your cake and eat it too. So I'll say at the National Football League, his work
  14. centers on how to use data to enhance and better understand the game of football. Academically, his research is
  15. split between causal inference with a specific focus on causal inference methods for multiple exposures and not
  16. surprisingly application of statistics to sports. He's an associate editor of one of our lead journals, Journal of
  17. Quantitative Analysis and Sports. And then in the more practical side, he's written for 538, Sports Illustrated,
  18. Hockey News. Uh from 2014 to 2021, he worked Skidmore College first as an assistant professor, then as a lecturer
  19. and a research associate. And in 2020, he was named the American Statistical Associ statistics and sports significant
  20. contributor award. I think we could name Mike Lopez that each and every year. So
  21. Mike, first of all, welcome back to Wharton Moneyball. >> Thanks so much for having me. Really
  22. appreciate it. And that was totally unnecessary. Um, and couple of those publications are out of
  23. business now. So maybe I didn't do such a good job, but >> I don't know about that. 538 still in
  24. business. Well, sort of. Not really. No, I think >> not really. Not really. Yeah. Audi, why
  25. don't we start with this? Um, it's not on the in the list of topics that Mike helped to provide us, it's listed as the
  26. last one, but since, as you know, the big data bowl meant so much to my son and my family. Um, could you start Audi
  27. and just talk about what the big data bowl has meant for you and then it would be appropriate for you to ask the
  28. question for Mike about the 2026 one and what's going and the impact it's had and
  29. maybe tell people what it is. >> Okay. So I mean uh I can from our perspective the big data bowl you
  30. started it as when when Eric when your son Zach was a senior it was the first year and we weren't even a a wasabi
  31. hadn't even existed yet um and its kernel existed as a seminar that I was running every Tuesday evening Tuesday
  32. afternoon with just my great students who are interested in statistics and sports and that included Zach uh Andrew
  33. Castle um and some other students and when you had the dig data bowl they just jumped on it without even I didn't even
  34. know about it. I don't think it it it hit my radar. The students found out about it much faster than I did. And I
  35. remember but you the timeline was terrible. It was like right around finals week. I mean, I don't know what
  36. you did, but you you set it up so that it was right during their finals, yet they managed to to put together a
  37. winning entry. Um and uh that and it was a a terrific opportunity and we we've jumped on it and and not every year. It
  38. depends on what the question is. Um and uh and actually for us it really depends
  39. on how statistical it is as opposed to how almost uh maybe AI the question is or how the goal is to learn something
  40. about football from a statistics lens or maybe you're trying to do forecasting. So we don't always participate but we've
  41. had many many teams uh be finalists and honorable mentions and of course even many students who did Moneyball Academy
  42. with me. They went on to do Moneyball I mean the big data ball with their different schools uh that they went to
  43. and we've had many winners who who are not at Penn but also but did Moneyball Academy. So it's a hugely important um
  44. uh um enterprise and we we're delighted Mike to have you here and and for the invention of the contest.
  45. >> Can Yeah. Can you tell us about it and just tell us what made you guys started
  46. at the NFL? Could you tell us about the 2026 version and we'd love to just hear,
  47. you know, the impact it's had on you personally and the NFL? >> Yeah, I mean in in the Field of Dreams,
  48. it's if you build it, they will come, right? In in football, it's if you have the data and share it, they will analyze
  49. it. And that's been the motto. Like we when I started in 2018, it was the first year that the teams had the player
  50. tracking data. And when you're going from traditional game stats in play-by-play, which has maybe 160 rows
  51. per game to this massive data set that has 300, 400,000 rows per game, um, you just don't quite know what to do with
  52. it. Uh, and traditional sports hackathons up till that point had been sort of one night, two night sprints.
  53. And I mean, I had the player tracking data for four months on my computer and I couldn't get anything out of it,
  54. right? So, you know, what are we going to learn in a sprint and a sort of a one night or twoight thing? Probably not
  55. much that's usable by teams. Um, so we really needed four, five, six weeks at least. Um, apologies for putting it in
  56. finals week. It was a it was one of those things that came together. I I I'm still in retrospect um wouldn't say
  57. lucky, but it's it's pretty amazing that we sort of were able to build that um without too much uh sort of um push back
  58. from the league. Um the league wanted innovation. They wanted new ideas. the clubs wanted it. They they sort of
  59. valued this experience. Um Jay Reed and I Jay's currently at MLS. You know, when
  60. we started asking the right questions at the league office, we we didn't get a lot of push back. Um the the team was
  61. teams were interested in it and we could certainly sell this as something that was going to help teams help the league
  62. office in terms of thinking about the rules and sort of modern metrics. Um and then also helping NextGen Stats. Almost
  63. every collaboration we have um for a topic comes with NextGen Stats. And and that sort of leads me to this year's
  64. topic. Uh where we're really thinking about predicting player movement. You think about when a quarterback drops
  65. back to pass. A lot of what we want to be able to do in terms of thinking about who that quarterback should throw to is
  66. thinking about if they throw to a certain receiver, what will happen? You really need to know how the defenders
  67. are going to move if the ball is thrown to a certain location in order to make those assessments. So it started with
  68. that reality and then sort of worked backwards. Okay, maybe we don't focus on the quarterback. We can do that a lot.
  69. Let's just focus on what the defenders do. What's their movement like when the ball's in the air? Who covers more
  70. space? Um, should you even be going for where the ball's landing or should you be going to try to figure out where
  71. you're going to tackle the player once the ball's caught? Um, so a lot of fun questions out of issues of competition,
  72. which is is not really surprising given the the effort and and the sort of quality of folks that are participating
  73. at this point. Can I ask you um so all these submissions come in I understand students there are you know winners
  74. finalist honorable mention kind of things like who gets to see the output of this like besides you and maybe some
  75. people that you're like there's some ones that are maybe so extraordinary you want to make sure it's shared throughout
  76. like the National Football League offices but like do the teams get to see the results of these and like if you
  77. could since you know we're also besides you know we are a business school um has
  78. stuff come out of the NFL big data bowl that you think has either changed your thinking, the NFL's thinking, or like,
  79. wow, teams are now doing something different. And who would have thought? It just, you know, these students or I
  80. know there's a student division, an open division, but like these people don't even work full-time and they did
  81. something that kind of moved the needle a little little bit in the sport we all loved.
  82. >> Yeah. Yeah, I mean the NFC championship game back in 2020, I was sitting, you
  83. know, having chili or whatever, just like everybody else, and suddenly on the Leonard Fornette ran for a touchdown,
  84. and they put up a a thing like yards over expectation, Leonard Fornette plus 17 or plus 19, whatever the number was.
  85. And I'm like that that's the big data bowl, right? Like that we turn from the competition into a new metric for our um
  86. you know, our NGS team. And then not only that, they turned into sort of a real time way to look at running back
  87. effectiveness on a given play, which is then shared with our network partners. Um, we are over 20 metrics from the big
  88. data bowl that have been uh sort of used or sort of put into the NextGen stats ecosystem. Um, that is then shared by
  89. clubs. Um, as always in professional sports, clubs aren't exactly reaching out to say, "Hey, I'm using this and
  90. it's really helped." Um, because they don't want to give any type of edge that they found. Um but undoubtedly that it's
  91. being used on the club side. Um on the league side, I think with each passing year, we're looking at the tracking data
  92. as being able to replicate a lot of what exists in the football beta lexicon. Um
  93. it's we're able to take the things that scouts have been doing for years um turned into metrics and do it, you know,
  94. sort of at scale uh in ways that can speed up time, too. So we've used a lot of it for our analysis of rules changes,
  95. looking at the space and the speed of the players in the kickoff, for example, last year. Um and and obviously our job
  96. is to make the game better. We're pre-player agnostic, but you know, we also understand that our teams are using
  97. it, too. >> Um I skipped by the entire 2025 season and one of that's one of the things we
  98. wanted to talk to you about. Um we'll talk about the Super Bowl in just a second, but you you mentioned for
  99. example the kickoff changes. You mentioned player speed is now an issue. um what kind of things from uh whether
  100. it's metrics or now using player tracking data are like what are the big forget what the solutions are yet what
  101. are the questions you guys are now answering at the NFL I know for a large number of years and this will never go
  102. away player safety I know is at the top of everybody's concern and that's I don't imagine that's ever going to
  103. change but could you give us a broad sense of the topics to which you know when they come to your group the data
  104. and analytics group what are the kind of questions they're asking you guys to think about.
  105. >> So I I would say broadly and it's not always just us answering questions too.
  106. A lot of it's sort of understanding what data is out there and what questions that we know that they're sort of
  107. thinking in the back of their heads that we can use data to answer for too. Um, and that's kind of the fun part about
  108. our group is there's a lot of room for creativity uh to sort of think think a little bit.
  109. >> You let people know, by the way, how big a group are we talking about and what
  110. are the backgrounds of people because a lot of people that are listening to our show might say, "Huh, you know, I wonder
  111. when the next time Mike Lopez is going to post a job at the NFL, like how group are we, how big a group are we talking
  112. about? What kind of degrees do people tend to have, etc." It' be good to hear that, too, and your thoughts about what
  113. kind of creativity and things you're able to do. >> Yeah. So I mean I I work on our football
  114. data and analytics group and at when I started I think I was the first person at the league office to code in R in any
  115. group anywhere. Um when I had to download R like it gave me a hard time because I don't think they knew what it
  116. was. Um we we are now a lot more modern. Um our group right now is somewhere between 8 and 10 depending on the time
  117. of year. Um that's on the football data and analytics side. Uh we're close with our health and safety group on the
  118. analytic side. Uh we're close with our broadcast um and sort of network groups. Um we are in the same larger data and
  119. analytics group as sort of a fan international um sponsorship. There's sort of other data and analytics groups
  120. that we're we're sort of also um uh sort of collaborating with at different points. Um our job is to make the game
  121. better. Um you know some some of our folks on our team have PhDs. Some have um you know are really good football
  122. wizards and can code a little bit in R Python. Um but largely we're looking at the competitiveness of the games. Uh the
  123. officiating of the games, health and safety, pace of play and replay is a big one. Uh using modern using technology uh
  124. to improve the game. Um so those are the the the areas that we're focused on. Uh
  125. obviously a lot of the increases in accessibility of data, whether it's the player tracking data that we've had now
  126. the last eight years, um inevitably we're going to be getting player skeletal pose data, trying to think
  127. about that, how to use that for either improving the game, um improving the officiating, um thinking about how to
  128. use to recognize certain objective aspects of penalties, for example. Um that's the the areas that falls under
  129. our bucket and with each passing year, our group's doing more and more and having more of an impact. So it's a lot
  130. of fun. Um, >> go ahead, please. >> The, uh, the new kickoff rules, how much of a role did your team play with that?
  131. Did you try to forecast, for example, what the impact would have been on total scoring, on on strategy? Um, it just
  132. seems like a totally different game in some in many aspects. I mean, the the kickoff and what was your role in that?
  133. How do you think it went? Yeah, I mean in fact like a couple weeks ago I looked at our um projection from last year
  134. where we projected a lot of our key metrics and I sort of put a check or a check minus as to whether or not we got
  135. it right or wrong. Um yeah, I mean our group was in charge of projecting the return rate um and then conditional off
  136. that what are all the things that are going to happen based off that return rate. Um we built a drive simulation
  137. model which sort of simulated drives. We wo that up into a game simulation model
  138. which then simulated games. Um trying to estimate the sort of overall change you
  139. know holding all else equal and assuming that the typical trends from 24 we're going to hold again in 25. You know what
  140. would we expect for scoring what we'd expect for um you know we anticipated that we were going to drop about 100
  141. punts and sure enough we dropped about 100 punts. Um we anticipated we'd have a little bit more scoring than we had. Um
  142. but some other other things I think sort of are responsible for that. um impact on the total uh sort of we'll call them
  143. action plays where it's not just total play count which is typically what the league looks at but how much action are
  144. we returning to the game return yards um obviously you can take a lot of those things and then turn them into projected
  145. injuries and things like that. So um you know working with the the folks in in in
  146. the the various leagues or league office to to sort of come up with a encompassing reflection of what that
  147. impact would be. So, I have two follow-up questions to Audi's questions, but it's on the same basic topic, but
  148. it's something Mike you just mentioned. Um, you know, since Audi and I are exactly the same age, graduated the same
  149. time, we're, you know, in our days, you had to know what I'll call mass stat, you had to build, you know, let's say
  150. probabilistic models, etc. Now, a lot can be done by simulation. So how much of the I'm just interested how much of
  151. what you do is simulationbased and in some sense you know let's let the power of computing you know handle the
  152. complex in some sense I'm not saying math's not important math's always important but if we can just simulate
  153. because of massive computing power you know bazillions of outcomes let's let that decide things
  154. >> yeah I mean in fact the two most recent rules changes that our group has had an
  155. impact on uh the kickoff being one of them. And then the other one was overtime. I mean, our overtime model,
  156. there's there's no empirical data to measure against. Um so what we did is we took play data, we simulated drives, we
  157. simulated what what the overtime would look like. Um and then we got our estimated impact of the the the sort of
  158. new overtime rule. So, um I wouldn't say we're always simulating, but it it it's
  159. certainly a tool that we'll want and depending on the question that we're after. Um you know, it's it's it's
  160. certainly important to to be able to use. >> The next question is kind of a selfish
  161. question for my own knowledge and how you think about this only because I was just teaching it today to my MBA
  162. students. I'll call it a and for our listeners it'll become clear what I mean, which is a multi-attribute
  163. objective function. And what I mean by that is you change the kickoff rule. Okay, so certain things get better,
  164. maybe certain things get worse. So there's multiple metrics or attributes you care about. And of course, any real
  165. decision maker has to decide how to trade off these different things. So I'm not asking you for the secret decision-m
  166. of how the NFL does that, but I'm just asking you more broadly. I would imagine any rule changes you think of, they're
  167. not paro dominant in the sense that they improve every single metric the NFL would ever want or the teams would want.
  168. I'm just interested how you approach those kind of problems from a leadership perspective and thinking about it.
  169. >> Yeah, I mean that is exactly how we approach it, right? Like so when we did overtime, we had a scale and depending
  170. on where you put your thumb on the scale was going to pick your favorite overtime
  171. format, right? Do you want equity of the coin toss? Do you want the overtime to end fast? Do you want it to be
  172. explainable to fans quickly? Um do you want it to have um uh sort of a traditional kickoff and punt play?
  173. Right. So depending on where you were going to put your thumb on the scale there, that was going to pick your
  174. favorite overtime format. Um we changed overtime because we wanted to sort of increase the importance the decrease the
  175. importance of the coin toss. We changed the kickoff because we wanted um you know, we found a play that had an injury
  176. rate that was more in line with runs and passes and as a result we wanted more competitiveness. Um, so yeah, I mean I
  177. think our job is to be objective and to show the sort of full impact of of a potential change um or modification and
  178. ultimately we're after rules that will benefit, you know, all five or six of the elements that we're after and and
  179. those are a little bit unique and and there's not always easy solutions to those, but that's uh ultimately what
  180. we're trying to do for the game. >> Well, let's talk now about the upcoming game in I guess uh whatever five days,
  181. the Super Bowl coming up. I'll just repeat and then I'd love your thoughts on this. So, we had Aaron Shatz, someone
  182. I'm sure you know of and know well, uh, we had him on during the season and his comment was that Seattle and the Rams,
  183. by every, you know, metric that he's ever created, which is a lot, that these were historically great teams. Like,
  184. measuring in the last 50 years, like Seattle and the Rams the were in the top 10. And then he also commented that of
  185. course New England had like the third easiest schedule since 1978. So, in your mind, like how do you guys think about
  186. the Super Bowl upcoming? Um, how do you think about the teams? And, um, yeah, how does the NFL think about the game in
  187. general and how do you think about these two teams? >> Well, it's it's funny like all the
  188. things that Aaron said, we don't do like we don't exactly care who our best teams
  189. are. Um, we don't exactly care. we do care a lot about strength of schedule and sort of balancing and sort of
  190. understanding the impact of our schedule but within a season um you know there's
  191. not much we're going to be able to do and so as a result there's not a ton of value in it. Um I I do think it's
  192. interesting this year set an NFL record with I have 1,089 quarterback scrambles.
  193. So that means of every NFL season in our history more quarterbacks scrambled this
  194. year than ever before. Um and I have New England number two in scramble rate. Um,
  195. so I think the the interesting part from our angle in terms of the some of the long-term trends of the game is that um,
  196. New England has has typically made its uh, impact. Um, Drake May in the AFC title game was no different. Throwing
  197. the ball, his numbers weren't great, but his impact was running the ball. Um, curious where that nets out. I know
  198. Seattle plays maybe the second highest zone rate in the league. Um, so we're we're sort of a little bit more agnostic
  199. in terms of, you know, caring which team exactly is going to win. Um, obviously we have to deal at the league office.
  200. Sure. >> Um, but I do think that, uh, the New England quarterback is somewhat reflective of the trends and sort of
  201. where the game is going. An athletic quarterback that can do a lot and when he doesn't see anything downfield, isn't
  202. afraid to run. >> Certainly, before I get to, it's certainly an interesting matchup because
  203. I, you correct me if I'm wrong. I would assume, but maybe I'm I have pretty good
  204. knowledge of football. Um, a zonebased team could be more susceptible to a running quarterback. Is that in general
  205. the thought? Just to make sure I'm clear, I >> I think the idea is that they'll prevent
  206. big scrambles because they're in the zone. If you go man coverage and your players are staying on their players,
  207. conceivably you open up big gaps, >> but you could also assign somebody to the quarterback, in which case maybe
  208. you'll stop them right at the line of scrimmage. Um, so my my sense is that there'll be three, eight, eight, 10 yard
  209. chunks there for Drake, but maybe not the big ones. Um, but but not I'm not obviously a prognosticator there.
  210. >> Please, Audi. Okay. So, um this year's Super Bowl, um does not feature really
  211. any of the top teams that were thought to be the top teams in the preseason. None of them. I mean, of course, we
  212. regret the the Eagles are not there, but none of the top teams. Uh in fact, each
  213. of them had less less than 4% probability of being in the Super Bowl, let alone winning it. Yet, here they
  214. are. So, I just ran a quick simulation. Turns out that um one out of every 20 years you'll get two
  215. long shots in the Super Bowl. at least if you trust the preseason's odds and let them run.
  216. >> Um that there's any of the these two specific teams is actually much smaller,
  217. but that's not the right the right question. So I'm going to ask somewhat of a causal inference kind of question
  218. to you without data. Um is there anything about the way the season played out or anything about the way the
  219. forecasts were made preseason that suggests that we were just not getting it? Um and that these teams, which in
  220. particular Seattle, but certainly New England as well, turned out to be terrific and we missed that. Is there
  221. anything about the way the game has changed, the u you described scrambling, potentially other outcomes that have
  222. made the made the the models kind of off their their calibration early on and that in fact it took a long time before
  223. people decided that New England was any good maybe because they just couldn't get over Tom Brady was not leading them
  224. or some sort sort of narrative. But I'm very curious to know that people think deeply about the game in terms of
  225. structurally what you think of the fact that we have two preseason long shots playing each other.
  226. It's certainly a trend that we at the league office would be wanting to watch. Um, you know, we've done a lot of stuff
  227. with the equity of our schedule, right? We have three standings based games after the year. Um, where one seeds play
  228. uh, sorry, one division number one division winners play other number one division winners. Um, and so
  229. understanding the impact of that, I believe both teams this year played the NFC South, which wasn't exactly our
  230. strongest division. Um, so that might have played into their records, which then obviously played into Seattle
  231. getting the number one seed, New England getting the number two seed, um, and the
  232. strength of schedule thing that I know Aaron's talked about. Um, we've, and part of this is stuff I had done before
  233. the NFL, too. But we've compared our our sort of playoff format and structure to
  234. other leagues and have a good sense that it's a single elimination tournament. A
  235. lot can happen. Um, these two teams put themselves in pretty good position based
  236. on the regular season. So, I don't think anything necessarily that happened in the postseason is that surprising. Um,
  237. but to get to this point in the regular season, um, you know, we've we've tracked quarterback injuries and I do
  238. think based on the reality that quarterbacks are scrambling more often and asked to I mean, we had um, our
  239. quarterbacks held on to the ball an average of 2.7 seconds per drop back. Um, that's it doesn't sound like a lot,
  240. but that's 04 more than a year before that. And it's 20 more than it was a decade ago. So
  241. 0.20 times 20,000 dropbacks in a season. You can do the math on how much longer quarterbacks are holding on to the ball.
  242. Um I don't think it's as much just the quarterback wanting to hold the ball and wait, wait, wait. Obviously defenses are
  243. in zone. They're further back, different personnel. There's just not as many people open. Um so conceivably um you
  244. know if you put the extra emphasis on the quarterback position you know with certainly the the trends of their
  245. availability is something that we at the league office would be wanting to follow
  246. and adding noise to that right is only going to um sort of increase the variance in terms of who moves on. I
  247. think Audi brings up Audi's point also brings up an interesting question from a league office point of view which is
  248. let's imagine it happens for a significant number of years that one or both teams in the Super Bowl were you
  249. know not preseason favorites. Now one is the NFL could say this is a good thing you know in some sense this is parody
  250. this is lots of you know it's there's no longer going to be the years of dynasties that could be good. Um,
  251. another thing you could say is, and maybe this is implication, I'd love to hear your thoughts too, Audi, on this.
  252. Maybe our preseason models need updating, and that's not the NFL's business. Like, you know, it could be
  253. just the models aren't great. The other could be the NFL says, you know what, maybe we red need to redesign the
  254. postseason in some way to make it so that, you know, I'll make it up, the it's not as easy for someone to sneak in
  255. as the seven seed, although that's not what happened this year. and it's not as easy for that team to make its way
  256. through and make it all the way to the Super Bowl. So, let me start with you, Mike, and then Audi. How do you think
  257. about, you know, could this be is this an indictment on preseason models or does it have implications for how the
  258. NFL thinks about designing a postseason tournament? >> I do believe we are the only league that
  259. after a season takes the teams that finish towards the top and gives them a harder schedule than the teams that
  260. finish towards the bottom. I mean, most of the professional leagues at this point reward the teams that finish
  261. poorly with the higher draft picks. Um, we also reward them with easier schedules. Um, and I think the longer
  262. that this would play out, I do know this is something the league cares a lot about and the clubs particularly care a
  263. lot about. Last year, we we tried to push a um we found like there were a lot of positives about a proposal from
  264. Detroit that would have seated the postseason teams based on winning percentage. um the clubs pointed out
  265. that it's not necessarily fair to compare winning percentage alone when the quality of teams that each division
  266. finishes uh faces are much different. And so I know the clubs are keenly aware of the differences in their schedules.
  267. Um and my hunch is that if if we have we all we always celebrate the sort of last
  268. to to first teams but the reality is for every last to first team there's probably a first to last team. Um and
  269. being cognizant of sort of what what is best for the league is something that we
  270. would be tracking. AI, do you want to weigh in on this top? >> Yeah, sure. Well, first of all, we love
  271. I mean the the imbalanced schedule, even though you try to sort of caused by this
  272. offers great Simpsons Paradox examples. We've every year you find a team that's uh that's better against good teams and
  273. better against worse teams, but ends up having a worse record overall. That's the classic um confounding. And so, by
  274. the way, might be the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. My team this year, they beat Seattle in Seattle this year. Yeah,
  275. >> they also beat I think they I forget who else they they beat the Brams I think
  276. they lost to New England by three points and then they couldn't beat the Saints,
  277. Atlanta, the Panthers. They couldn't Miami and that inconsistency is is is a football issue when I'm talking about
  278. teams that that beat the better teams at at a they have a lower winning percentage against better team because
  279. they're good teams and they beat the the poor team better than another team who's
  280. got a yet because the team has a just imbalanced schedule, their overall record looks a lot better. And that was
  281. why people didn't trust New England because their their record was so built upon beating beating up on weak teams
  282. that we felt we had no no substantive ef estimate of how they would do against strong teams. Um, I will say that u I
  283. don't think it's in in MLS, which is soccer, they don't have a mis in so much of an imbalanced schedule as they have
  284. these other tournaments that the top teams have to play, which brutalizes their bodies and the travel and the
  285. exhaustion of playing soccer and becomes very hard to repeat because you get to you get to do all these extra things
  286. like um the cups they play in in in South America and the and they travel and that the teams that don't do well
  287. don't get to perform in. that there there's uh other other leagues have to to deal with that. Um but I but I have
  288. to say I mean I'm not sure the models were wrong. Um I think that maybe people just didn't believe that someone like a
  289. rookie essentially a rookie quarterback like Derek May not rookie but is his Drake May. Drake May
  290. >> Drake May is his second year or is is that what he's second year and someone who had who played for the Jets for so
  291. long could actually be good. I mean, may maybe it's our it's our na our story narrative that's kind of gotten in the
  292. way as a uh as a Jets fan who's who's sort of given up hope um and adopted my Philadelphia Eagles. Um how does Sam
  293. Darnold go for so many years at the Jets doing nothing and now now being two years in a row um a 13 game winner? We
  294. got >> 14 14. So, so I I have one of the things we do a lot of which I think is is
  295. underutilized in football is we try to understand the conditions in which teams play
  296. >> and in baseball every time somebody talks about a game in course field everybody just naturally adjusts for the
  297. altitude of course field >> for whatever reason we just don't do it in football. Um you know and I think I
  298. look at Darnold and we look at we treat all quarterbacks the same etc. Um, I don't if we look at all the reclamation
  299. projects, the quarterbacks that have gone from bad sort of situations team-wise to good situations teamwise. I
  300. mean, Baker Mayfield went from Cleveland to Tampa. Daniel Jones from the Giants to Indianapolis. Gino Smith went from
  301. the Jets to Seattle. Darnold went from the Jets Minnesota. All those teams went from outdoor stadiums, cold conditions,
  302. tough conditions to domes or indoor stadiums and easier conditions. Um, when we look at Drake May's two worst games
  303. of the year, the last two games, one was in basically a blizzard in Denver. The other one was in terrible conditions in
  304. New England. Not an accident that those were poorly poor conditions. Um, I relatedly, I mean, Drew Brees,
  305. unbelievable quarterback. Are we that surprised that the quarterback who set the single season completion record
  306. played in a dome? No, we shouldn't be, right? That's where we would expect it. So, um, the differences in in sort of
  307. quarterback setup, um, Darnold's had, you know, a tremendous, uh, turnaround of his career, but I think those things
  308. play play a small part of it. And, you know, we're constantly trying to think about the weather and the conditions of
  309. the game. More and more teams are having turf, so what is the impact on those? We
  310. average a couple more points per game in turf games than we do in outdoor games.
  311. Um, and so those are the the the natural sort of league office type things that we get uh pretty nerdy with. Well, how
  312. many turf teams are there at this point? >> Uh, we're pretty I don't know the number
  313. off the top of my head. I want to say we're getting like 18ish. Um, and then obviously like Seattle's a sort of
  314. inbetweener, right? It's an outdoor one, but it's it's partially closed, but sometimes it's pretty bad weather there,
  315. too. So, um, yeah, they're they're almost like halfway in between. >> So, Mike, for the last question I wanted
  316. to ask you today, um, let's imagine obviously we hope we have you back long before a year from now, but let's
  317. imagine the three of us are sitting here a year from now. um what rule changes are kind of on at least the that you can
  318. talk about that are are on the consideration set that you guys are analyzing? >> Yeah, I mean I my hunch is we are you
  319. know our our priorities for the offseason, you know, continuing to figure out it refining the kickoff play.
  320. Um you know ultimately league office doesn't decide the rules, right? We put them in you know we have conversations
  321. with the clubs and the clubs if they vote on a change you need 24 votes. So, um I think the kickoff one and maybe
  322. some tweaks around the edges, keep it competitive, um but but making sure you know the injury rates are low enough and
  323. things like that. Um my hunch is in where we are going in football is we will be getting skeletal data. Um we had
  324. Hawkeye in all 30 stadiums this year. Their system is called Skeletrack. Um the completeness of this data is is
  325. fairly promising in terms of um being able to show the the the joints of the the players. Um and trying to think
  326. about where we can use that data to improve the game um is a big part of our offseason. Um so for example, you know,
  327. for years you've had to pay a company to figure out if a player was in a two-point stance or three-point stance
  328. at the time of the snap. We don't need to do that anymore, right? We'll just pretty quickly calculate that when we
  329. see the skeletal data. Um you know relatedly we can calculate a lot of additional football metrics with this.
  330. Um we can uh recreate the officials view of a play um based on the the sort of where their vantage point of uh vantage
  331. point of vantage point was when a a sort of a defensive pass interference occurred things like that. Um so I don't
  332. quite know what we're going to do with it. Um but I know that it's going to be a bigger part of the gun in year. Hm.
  333. Well, we've been fortunate uh for the last half hour here on Wharton Moneyball on the Wharton podcast network uh to
  334. have Mike Lopez. Mike is senior director of football data and analytics at the NFL. Uh we've talked a lot about and
  335. please please I know you will please continue with the big data bowl. I don't mean just for our students. I just mean
  336. it's you know people love the NFL and as Audi says uh they think they're learning
  337. about sports and all this stuff. We're teaching them statistics and data science through the Trojan horse of the
  338. NFL. And there is no better Trojan horse. So Mike, Audi and I would like to thank you for joining us today on board
  339. Moneyball. >> Always a pleasure. And um tell Shane and Kate I miss him. >> We'll we'll do. Uh thanks Mike and we'll
  340. join you again right after the break. >> Sounds great. >> Welcome back to the Wharton podcast
  341. edition of Wharton Moneyball. This is Eric Bradlo. I'm here today with my friend colleague uh Professor Audi
  342. Winer. some combination of the two of us. Kade Massie and Shane Jensen are here every week on Morton Moneyball. So
  343. Audi, obviously we just finished with uh Mike Lopez talking about the NFL. I want
  344. to talk to you about a few other things. Whenever it's just you and me, I like to
  345. kind of interview you about how you think about various things going on in the sporting world.
  346. >> So I want to provide you some data on tennis given the Australian Open just happened. I know you know this. Carlos
  347. Alcarez won the Australian. Yes, >> he's not got the career grand slam at the youngest age ever, age 22, two years
  348. younger than Nadal was when he won it at age 24. >> He's also got seven Grand Slam titles,
  349. which is also I'll just give you an example. Feder and Djokovic had one at age 22. He's got seven. Well, you know,
  350. just to interrupt here, uh we knew maybe earlier with Alcarez that he was going to be great earlier in his life than any
  351. other player. I remember. Well, how old was he when we were talking about this phenom coming up? 16 was he? 17.
  352. >> 17. He started he didn't win a major until I think he I know he's won his first one in 2022. So, he's probably
  353. 18/19 when he won his first. >> But the the reviews of the of Algaras as a kid were just off the charts. The only
  354. thing that I remember that's comparable in terms of previews of stunning greatness. So we as statistitians always
  355. regress forecasts to the mean. You have to that produces the best forecast. Now for our listeners what that means is
  356. when someone makes a forecast that's really extreme there's going to be some regression meaning moving it down
  357. towards the average. Um and we see this in lots of places. So as a as someone who interacts with the media whenever I
  358. hear a you know a crazy expectation you always have to bring it a little bit down to earth. But Alcarez has certainly
  359. b born borne its way out to the fullest. And the other one that I maybe I'll just
  360. which I if you look back which superstar forecast they're probably others um have
  361. turned into absolute dead-on predictions. >> Well, I mean the f the two that come to
  362. mind obviously is Tiger Woods and golf and >> certainly Tiger Woods and golf. >> No no Tiger Woods in golf. LeBron James
  363. in basketball. LeBron was, you know, at age 15, people knew about LeBron James. And he entered the NBA at age 18.
  364. >> Bryce Harper, you think in in baseball? >> I don't think Bryce Harper is at the
  365. level obviously of a Tiger even comparable. >> No, he's not. But he Yeah. So, in some
  366. sense, he's regressed. He's going to be Hall of Fame, right? To show you, but he's not going to be tier one Hall of
  367. Famer. >> No, he's not going to be a tier one Hall of Famer. I I'd have to think about the
  368. other sports in >> there's one in baseball that I that I think is his career is only halfway
  369. over. Um it's not Aaron Judge because he was never forecasted to be terrific. Um
  370. >> I'm just trying to think who you're thinking about. Was it Juan Sodto? >> Uh no Juan Sto didn't have that.
  371. >> It's it's certainly nobody predicted Mike Trout until he did what he did at age 19. Um Um the answer is Show Otani.
  372. >> Yeah, but he didn't join the N MLB until what age? What age was he when he >> No, it's not. No, it was one. So,
  373. usually we discount Japanese performance in the Japanese leagues. And so, I remember listening to Neil Payne on on
  374. his show Hot Takedown talking about this insane forecasting and he was of course
  375. gave it a statistical spin saying you no one ever lives up to the hype of being top in two positions. It just doesn't
  376. happen. Um, but he was forecasted to be a star pitcher and a star hitter. And I remember listening to this and thinking,
  377. "No way. he'll end up being one and not the other. Yet here he is being both. And so here's my example. Uh let me so
  378. let me ask you to do a little forecasting here. So we just said Alcarz has seven majors.
  379. >> Okay? >> Let's say he's basically been playing since the beginning of 2022. He might
  380. have started a little earlier. Let's just assume as a real professional since the age of 18, he's played 17 majors.
  381. He's won seven. So let's assume he's winning at a 40% rate right now. Right now. Right now he's winning at a 40%
  382. rate. Although he's won five of the last nine, it's fine. If you had to project out, I'm not going to ask you for his
  383. career. We go out another five years. Okay? So, 20 majors. Is there any reason why I shouldn't
  384. predict he'll have eight more, which is 15. >> Well, you know, okay. So, uh, he's been
  385. healthy, correct? >> He has been healthy for I'm trying to decide if he's missed any because you're
  386. right. What you're pointing out also is there's no doubt if Rafa Nadal hadn't been injured in his career, he might
  387. well have the most majors. He has 22. Obviously, Jookovic has 24, but Nadal missed years worth of majors. Djokovic,
  388. I don't know he's ever missed one. Federer wasn't that injured in his career. Nadal was. Let's Yeah, you're
  389. right. So, we have to take into the probability, right? So, miss some, >> right? So, he's uh so that your eight
  390. forecast is just is just sliding over the previous fraction, rolling it forward. No, he's going to he's heading
  391. into his prime, right? So, >> he's not even No, no. Prime typically in men's tennis is like 27. This is not
  392. even his prime years, >> right? So, by that measure, it'll go up. But nevertheless, we're you got to
  393. regress down slide word because he's been so dominant going. It's a tr such a tricky thing. Also, I what really really
  394. changes the forecast is what who emerges to oppose him. Right. So, right now he's
  395. got sinner as his his principal um opponent and and regular challenger. Jookovic is probably done, right? He's
  396. 38 years old. I don't think we're doing much of that. >> Um, are there any uh any coming up and
  397. coming players who can consistently challenge him? How many are there? >> Great question. So, I'm glad you use the
  398. word consistently because let's even talk about the big three era, right? >> Um, Stan Marinka won three majors in
  399. that period, but he couldn't consistently do it. Andy Murray, some people even call it the big four. Andy
  400. Murray won three majors, but he couldn't consistently do it. Delpatro won one major.
  401. >> Yeah, I remember that. >> So, no, no, I'm just saying. So, are you asking me right now? I don't see anybody
  402. out there on the men's side. >> The better opportunity. People are talking about Ben Shelton or Taylor
  403. Fritz or even Zarev who as you remember was one game away from beating Alcarass and the Australian, but consistently
  404. absolutely not. And so now the challenge is like it's not unreasonable to and I'm
  405. even being I think conservative here. Let's since they've won combined the last nine majors. It's the longest
  406. streak by the way in tennis history. The two men have won nine the last nine majors. All of 24 all of 25 and now the
  407. Australian and 26. Five have been won by Alcarz. Four have been won by center. Okay. I think it's fair. It's not
  408. unreasonable predict and center's 24. It's not unreasonable predict over the next four or five years combined the two
  409. of them will win 75% of the majors. It does not mean that there isn't one a year on average that somebody else could
  410. win, but right now I don't know how you could predict less than that. And if that's true, then 12 of the next uh 16
  411. majors are going to be won by one of the two of them. And even if it's a 66 split, that puts Alcarz at age 26 with
  412. 13 majors. Yeah, I'd say that's a reasonable expectation quite honestly. >> Yeah. So,
  413. >> that's definitely I mean what I'm what's amazing about tennis is that it really
  414. does have this uh longtailed distribution. You don't that you you don't have this pileup at
  415. the at the you almost like you think about it is at what is the end of what a human can accomplish and then you have
  416. this pileup at that near that maximum. Where do you see that? You see that in in sprinting, right? Um you see that in
  417. home run rates even. Um, but it seems like in tennis the one or two or even three bests just leap out way ahead of
  418. everyone else. And is that due to the fact that tennis is such a >> a tennis match has so many
  419. >> um repetitions? I think it is. I think it is. You know, this is what I always
  420. say. You know, it's the same thing. Obviously, you know, I have a son that plays squash. All three play squash, but
  421. one was pretty competitive. you hit like I forget the number of balls, but if there's like 150 points in
  422. a squash match, you might hit a thousand balls in a match. You know, in tennis, you know, think about just how many
  423. shots are hit. And if I hit even 2% 3% better than you, you add that over a match and now I've hit 30, 40 balls
  424. better than you, and that's going to make the difference in a tennis match. And even more so in the majors where
  425. it's best to five. If if anything, the longer the match obviously is favoring the better player and so it's just
  426. bigger N. There we go. >> And that's that's but you'd still would expect to have a little bit more
  427. clumping than we do considering that there should be some intra interournament variation. Like what I
  428. mean by that is that the center that shows up to the Wimbledon might not be the center who shows up to the
  429. Australian Open, shows up to US Open, etc. you'd expect to see enough variation, which is human to do that,
  430. right? Um to see that the the the compression among the top, but you do you don't in in in tennis, the dominant
  431. players are able to just not only win, but crush um say five or 10. >> I only have 20. I have one other pet
  432. topics related to test and I want I have want to go over to MLB in a second but um you know obviously
  433. Jookovic is the most accomplished player of all time you know he's won the most majors the one the most the Masters 1000
  434. ranked number one in the world the most number of weeks I still have a problem calling him the
  435. best and let me say why or the GOAT so let me just say why >> so between Federer Nadal and Djokovic
  436. this is a metric Maybe I've cherrypicked it. He has the worst winning percentage
  437. in Grand Slam finals by far. Now, he's got the most, but that's cuz he was never injured and he made the most
  438. finals, but his winning percentage is the worst in Grand Slam finals. >> Yep. Yep. Back in the Okay.
  439. >> He has a losing record to Nadal in majors and in major finals. >> Well, that's because of the Nidal's
  440. dominance in the French, right? >> That's I'm going to get to that. >> Now, he has a better record. He has a
  441. winning record against Nadal 31 and 29 in his career overall. Winning record against Federer 27 and 23. Although you
  442. might expect it to be better given he's 6 years younger and when they played in their career. And actually if you end
  443. Federer's career ended at age 37 he would have had a winning record by the way against Jookovic. Just so you know.
  444. Um if you had to rank order the four majors in tennis from most prestigious to least please rank them for me.
  445. uh Wimbledon US Open French Australia. >> I would completely agree and so would everyone else. Do you know who has the
  446. most Wimbledons of all time? >> Roger Federer. >> You know who has the most US Opens of
  447. all time? >> Roger Feder. >> Roger Federer. >> Do you know who has the most Frenches of
  448. all time? >> The I have to go down to the Australian >> to get to Djokovic. And he's got so many
  449. more. He's got 10. Matter of fact, >> that's another thing about Algres. No, Jookovic was 10 and0 in the
  450. Australian finals. Now he's 10-1. But my point is he didn't even win the M. I mean,
  451. >> he wasn't at work. >> So, let's let's be clear here between you and me and anyone else listening,
  452. which hopefully you're thousands. Is Feder the goat? That's a tough one. It's a tough one.
  453. Here's what I'll say. Um, this was always my claim about Djokovic. Djokovic always plays great.
  454. >> Yep. >> That was his great strength. When he was at his best, Nadal was at his best and Federer was at his best.
  455. Who do I think is winning the match? I'll debate Feder Nadal. It's hard for me to say Djokovic because I've seen
  456. Djokovic get blown out by each by those players and others. Andy Murray, Winka, Delpatro, blew out Djokovic when they
  457. had their A+ game. I say to me, he's the most accomplished tennis player of all time. Is he the greatest? Was his peak
  458. greatness greater than the others? No, I don't think so. >> That's just my opinion. That's my
  459. opinion. By the way, I'm sure we could look at a flawed EO rate. By if we looked at flawed ELO ratings, I think he
  460. does have a higher ELO rating. >> Yeah, but that ELO doesn't know how to rate um ma matches by with a different
  461. rating system. Right. It doesn't though. >> Yeah. All right. Well, that's that's
  462. some tennis. So, I'm going to I know you haven't looked at this. I didn't put it
  463. in the spreadsheet. There's no way you could see this. I'm going to give you the 2025 win total for an MLB team and I
  464. want you to give me your guess of what the fan graph's 2026 win number is. Okay. You ready?
  465. >> Okay. Sure. >> I just picked out seven or eight. Okay. Let's start with the Dodgers. The
  466. Dodgers won 93 games in 2025. And I'm right. They're the two-time repeating champion Dodgers, right? Y.
  467. >> Okay. What do you think Fan Grass has them for uh 2026? >> Okay, first of all, Fan isn't stupid, so
  468. they regress to the mean, but I think the Dodgers significantly underperformed their their their payroll, their roster
  469. given injuries. So, I'll bet they're at 96. >> Well, you're off by one. 97. >> Okay. That was my I was about to say
  470. either one of those. Yeah. >> All right. The next one. >> By the way, to our listeners and
  471. viewers, I am not cheating. >> HE'S NOT. I have it in front of me. He cannot say this.
  472. >> Bring it up on my own. I'm just >> Yeah, there's no but he's not. He can't see. Well, we'll see if you're not
  473. cheating in a second for the next one. >> Yeah, >> the Braves won 76 games last year.
  474. >> What does Fan Graphs has them for 2026? >> Uh somewhere in the low 80s, low to mid
  475. 80s. I'd probably say 84. >> 91. >> 91. What do they pick up that they think that they that they're thinking?
  476. >> I don't know. That's Well, that's the question. I had I didn't get that far to
  477. look. Um here's another couple interesting ones. The Phillies won 96 games last year.
  478. >> I would guess they're probably going to regress them down to about 91 92. >> 85 8 That's an enormous regression. The
  479. Yankees won 94. What do you got? >> Yankees haven't changed their team. Uh they're going to get Garrett Kobach. Uh
  480. we have some pitchers I would say around 93. >> 87 >> 87. So, >> the Brewers 97. Best record in baseball.
  481. What do you think? >> Under 90 for sure. >> 82. >> Yeah, of course. Yeah. >> Here's the most fascinating one for me.
  482. The Rockies won 43 last year. >> Yeah. >> What do you think they have? >> 65. >> 66.
  483. >> Yeah. >> So, the two that surprised me, I have to admit, look, obviously, >> I mean, I have to say Atlanta's
  484. surprising me. I mean, to predict them that high, that's why I gave them slightly above average, right? Why would
  485. you pick them to be as higher as high as the Phillies? >> Higher than the Phillies unless unless
  486. they gained some players or unless they you just felt like their true strength last year based on metrics was 85 90
  487. wins and they just way underperformed. There'd be no other explanation. Yeah, it's interesting because one of the one
  488. of the one of the examples I'm doing with my class is to measure organizational advantage in terms of
  489. wins above payroll expectation. >> Oh, that's a great metric. >> And uh and it's actually many people
  490. have done this and they've actually done it incorrectly. Um a standard way to do
  491. that is to build a model that predicts wins as a function of payroll and then residualize each team and then average.
  492. But if you do that, you don't control >> say average over years. >> Uh yes. So in other words, every season.
  493. Yeah. So you take you take 20 years worth of data, you predict the wins as a function of payroll
  494. >> and then you uh and standardize it because money changes its value. >> Um so you do whatever standard.
  495. >> You're telling me that's not right. >> What's that? >> That's not right. >> Oh no. So yeah. So if you do that,
  496. >> that's what I would have done. >> Yeah. The problem with that is that what happens as we imagine that better
  497. management gets more money. Then you have a confounding. The worst teams, the people, the organizations
  498. that are the worst could end up with very low payrolls >> causally >> and then and if you think causally,
  499. which is essentially what we're trying to get at, you're going to have a confounding component. And you see this
  500. in sports all the time, see this in field goal kicking, right? If you look if you try to modeling the conditional
  501. distribution of the number of expected wins given the payroll. So, so what you so so the standard way of people have
  502. always done this is they predict wins given payroll then then you build that model then you residualize for every
  503. team and you take your average residual. The problem with that is that if there's
  504. confounding and the teams that have a lot of money also have good management you'll absorb the managerial effect with
  505. your estimate of the payroll. I see. So classic example is and by the way this this undermines the Yankees for example
  506. Yankees don't particularly overperform their payroll but if on the other hand you say to them that that high payroll
  507. is given to them because they're run well you can think about it like that. So an alternative way to do it is you
  508. residualize each team's winning percentage and their payroll and then you get the and then you predict
  509. their residual winning percentage versus their residual payroll. So the Yankees are judged by how much more money
  510. they're paying than what they average in a given season. And you compare the Yankees to how much they and that's that
  511. mathematically corresponds to a fixed effects model. And that's the one that I come up with. And what's interesting is
  512. Oakland A's are still at the top no matter how you calculate it, but the Yankees move into like fourth position
  513. and the Atlanta Braves and the St. Louis Cardinals are the two teams that are in
  514. between them. So the the the actual value of the and I I don't have the the lecture notes. If you give me a second,
  515. I'll probably be able to pull it up. But at the actual value of the of the uh in
  516. terms of wins above expectation after adjusting properly for the team quality for the Oakland A's it's around six for
  517. the Yankees it's around three and a half and for the Cardinals it's around somewhere and and and Braves it's around
  518. 3 to four. >> So this is some real that's some real action. I mean those are that's a real
  519. number of wins. >> Yes. Now of course this was the A's in the in the Billy Bean era when they had
  520. that advantage. I I wouldn't argue that they have that going forward, but that might produce one of the reasons why you
  521. suspect Atlanta to be good because they're generally good every year. And therefore, when we look back at a a a
  522. poorer season that they had, that is their their forecast is to regress them much much much higher than 82. Um, and
  523. that's maybe and maybe they've seen some some action off the field that we haven't that our memories don't don't
  524. have and that's why they're coming up with such a high number. But I am a little bit surprised and that's
  525. something I want to dig into. >> So the last topic related to baseball since you and I always like to talk Hall
  526. of Fame. But just for our listeners out there, by the way, one of my greatest honors in a couple of weeks we're going
  527. to have Josh Trowick, the president of the National Baseball Hall of Fame uh on our show, which will be fantastic to
  528. talk to him. Uh one of the questions I'm going to ask him is, and I told him I was going to ask him this, like when do
  529. you see a day where advanced metrics dominate the plaques in the Hall of Fame? like this p this person had a you
  530. know I well on base percentage has been on for a long time. What would be an advanced metric that you would like love
  531. to see on someone's plaque out of in the Hall of Fame? >> That's a great question which because I
  532. um >> uh B uh I mean yes I mean for a pitcher batting average on balls of play I'm not
  533. really sure that um that would be it. Um, I certainly wouldn't be war because that is still in in the uh although I
  534. will say I do like the pitcher wars much better than the hitter wars. Um, I think
  535. they're much much more >> percentage has been on for a long time. >> Percentage. OPS is a great number. OPS
  536. >> ops is a single counting stat. Um, that makes a lot of sense to me as as something that should be. In fact, if
  537. you go to a stadium now, OPS is on the is on the >> Oh, it's on the screen. It's absolutely
  538. on the screen. >> And uh that that's a great number. Um so if it you have to make it simple but um
  539. I probably pitching war starting pitcher war uh is a great number >> interesting to see
  540. >> and uh it's interesting I went and spoke at uh a Daniel X class in he was on our
  541. show he teaches a class in um in uh in baseball statistics and I I gave a to talk about my grid war that I wrote with
  542. Ryan Bril and right and how that really teases out in players that for the Hall of Fame that that that aren't um that
  543. aren't uh um noticed by the the conventional metrics. Actually, interestingly enough, it came up two
  544. pitchers rise substantially in in in well, not >> well, you've been talking about Kevin
  545. Brown and Dave Steve forever. It's not the two of them, >> right? It's not the two of them, but
  546. here's two here's two others that are interesting. They're Yankees. Ron Gidry is underrated as with Hall of Fame
  547. credentials. really on and and if people are talking about Pettit, Gidri is way ahead of Pettit in terms of of dominance
  548. during his during his peak and even longevity. Um yet nobody talks about Gry for the Hall of Fame. I don't think we
  549. really should be talking about Pettit. I mean that's he's a re but he might make
  550. it because >> for lots of reasons. Here's another un unsung hero that was historically
  551. beloved but the Saber Matricians don't like him. Whitey Ford. Whitey Ford is not I mean every he was I
  552. mean he has the best winning percentage of any pitcher with more than you know >> history right in history
  553. >> in history it's not even close and of course everyone discounts that because he played for the great Yankee teams
  554. right but if you actually look at what he performed as a pitcher ignoring what the Yankees were able to do do for him
  555. on the batting side and look at his opponents and look at the the way he was able to get out of difficult jams and
  556. really produce his difficult opponents leave them with not very many um opportunities. He is an unsung player. I
  557. mean, he's a genuinely a top 20 pitcher of all time. Wow. >> And uh most people don't think of him as
  558. that. >> So, just in the last one or two minutes, uh any quick reactions? I don't know if
  559. you and I talked about it to, you know, Jeff Kent, Carlos Beltron, or Andrew Jones. I mean, any excitement for you?
  560. As you know, I'll be there in Coopertown seeing them. any excitement that you have about either of the three of them
  561. being in the Hall of Fame or you like but no real excitement. >> No, Belchan was never much on my radar.
  562. He had his great He's really one of the classic um um you know postseason player, never playing for my team, so I
  563. don't never played that much. And Jones, of course, he finished his career with the Yankees and he was thoroughly
  564. mediocre in those seasons. Um, and I and I always thought of him as, you know, he
  565. so much of his great years were in his early part of his career. >> And it is a saber metric. I mean,
  566. frankly, he did over hit over 400 home runs. Yes. >> Um, and he was a center fielder and he
  567. was a damn good one. Um, >> damn good one. >> Only like there's like three players in
  568. history like him, Maize, and Griffy have I know they they artificially make these
  569. cut offs, but like 400 home runs and 10 golden gloves in center field. >> Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. Um, and I remember
  570. when I first, this is a point of history in our work, when we first got the grant
  571. from ESPN, it must be 20 years ago now to do uh maybe not quite that far. It was maybe 20, 2007. Um, we got this not
  572. tracking data because it wasn't tracking data, but it was video recorded. Human beings watched plays and wrote down
  573. information. We and we ESPN bought that data for us and that launched my sports analytics uh research line and Shane's
  574. as well. And in a paper that Shane and I wrote uh called SAFES uh um basically spatially adjusted fielding um metric,
  575. we we discovered two particular center fielders who just stood out from the rest and that was Andrew Jones. The
  576. other was Jim Edmonds. Um >> well that's that's he was certainly known for that.
  577. >> Yeah. Yeah. And uh andrew Jones was particularly good at at at playing the low ball, the ones that were they were
  578. they were short. And he was just an incredible center fielder. and we actually valued that that um that
  579. contribution. >> I don't have a let me just say I don't have a problem except for the sign
  580. stealing stuff or the banging on the trash can stuff with Beltran, but whatever. Um I don't have a problem with
  581. Kent, Beltron, or Jones, you know. Am I excited that they're in the Hall of Fame?
  582. >> Hall of Famers. All three >> third tier Hall of Fame. >> Yeah, but they're fine. They're in
  583. they're not undeserving. Are they exciting? Uh, who's coming on down the pike next year? We looking that far
  584. ahead yet? >> Any new book at one point? I don't think there's anybody that exciting, which is why a
  585. lot of people are thinking it could be Chase Utley's year next year given where he's grown. Um, Andy Pettit could make
  586. it. Um, you know, there's even discussions, there's been a lot of discussions where how can you put Utley
  587. in without Jimmy Rollins in who's better than him on every statistical category.
  588. But either way, I think Utley and Pettit may get in next year. >> I think >> interesting thing that it's funny
  589. because uh second baseman traditionally under hits the shortstop and it's not because it's a more difficult position
  590. and therefore you require it has to do with the fact that the best athlete tends to get put at shortstop. So it's
  591. an interesting confounding, right? If you think about confounding, right? If you look at the production at which
  592. position produces the worst batting production historically at second base. >> Yeah. Because usually, as you said, they
  593. that's where they tend to move people that can't field that well and you know, they just want their bat in the lineup,
  594. but they're not the best athlete. >> Well, no, it's important. It's a middle infield position, so at the major league
  595. level, you need a very good second baseman and that person has to be quick. But they tend to as a group to under hit
  596. or offensively produce far less >> than the the shortstop which has to be even better fielder.
  597. >> So it's an interesting um correlation that creates a causal misunderstanding.
  598. It's a classic you know if you think about it. So Utley I think is far better is far more deviant as a second baseman
  599. than Rollins is as a shortstop. That's a And and by the way, a lot of people like
  600. myself, and we'll wrap up with that, a lot of people like myself believe that is an important criterion for the Hall
  601. of Fame. Like Jeff Kent, put him in center field. Jeff Kent's not a Hall of Famer. But does he have the most home
  602. runs ever as a second baseman? Yep, he does. That's worth something, Audi. It's got to be worth something.
  603. >> That's the argument right there. >> That's the argument. >> All right. Well, this has been one hour
  604. of Wharton Moneyball. like to thank again Mike Lopez, head of data science for the NFL for myself, my colleague and
  605. friend Winer. Uh in absentia, Kade Massie and Shane Jensen. Uh it's been a great hour with you here on the Wharton
  606. podcast network and Wharton Moneyball between now and next week. Enjoy the Super Bowl. Enjoy your sports. Enjoy
  607. your statistics. We'll see you next week here on Wharton Moneyball.

Brief Summary

Mike Lopez discusses NFL analytics, the Big Data Bowl, and player tracking data's impact on football strategy and safety.

Key points

  • The Big Data Bowl's Impact. The Big Data Bowl has transformed how data is used in football, leading to new metrics and insights.
  • Innovations in NFL Analytics. Mike Lopez discusses how the NFL uses data to enhance player performance and game strategies.
  • Quarterback Scrambles Record. The NFL set a record for quarterback scrambles this season, highlighting a shift in play.
  • Super Bowl Surprises. This year's Super Bowl features teams that were long shots in the preseason.
  • Preseason Predictions Questioned. The unexpected Super Bowl matchup raises questions about the accuracy of preseason models.
  • Alcaraz's Historic Win. Carlos Alcaraz won the Australian Open at just 22, two years younger than Nadal.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes