Building a Contender: Analytics and Leadership in the NHL
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE Eric Tulski, Head of Hockey Operations for the Carolina Hurricanes, joins the Moneyball team to explains how analytics, roster construction, and organizational philosophy influence performance, player evaluation, and playoff outcomes in the NHL. Cade, Shane, and Adi also discuss the dominance of teams like the Los Angeles Dodgers, the debate over salary caps and spending floors, and how analytics and labor negotiations may shape the future of Major League Baseball.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
#nhlpredictions #hockeyanalytics #sportsanalytics #sportshighlights #nhlplayoffs #hockeystrategy ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Welcome, welcome to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics here on the Wharton podcast
- network. This is Kade Massie hosting today with two of my three regular colleagues and co-host. Shane Jensen is
- in here. Audi Winer is in here. And quite unusually, we are all three on campus. Sadly, we're in different parts
- of campus, but we are all three on campus. Eric Bradlos isn't. Eric is away doing Eric Bradlo things. Steve will be
- back. As you guys know, we some combination of us anyway are here almost every week of the year. We're talking 48
- 49 weeks a year and have been for more than 12 years now going back to when we started March 2014. We're recording on
- Tuesday afternoon as we typically do. Show will go up Wednesday morning and we're going to follow our usual format
- guests in the first half hour, open topics, open lines in the second half hour. We are delighted to welcome onto
- the show, first time in a long time. It's hard to have a bigger gap than Eric has had appearing on the show, but Eric
- Tolski is joining us, head of hockey operations with the Carolina Hurricanes, the wildly successful Carolina
- Hurricanes, highly thought of executive, rags to riches story, if you will. We'll
- cover that in a moment. Eric was on the show in May 2014, just before he went to
- work for the Hurricanes. one of our first, I don't know, 20 or 25 guests ever. It's quite a delight to have you
- back, Eric. Thanks for making time for us. >> Yeah, of course. We should do this once
- every 12 years as a matter of routine. >> And hopefully we'll get three or four more in.
- >> Yeah, we promise. We promise if it goes 12 years, we'll make sure to get back to
- you, Eric. But but we may may come to you before then. Eric, um give us we have lots of questions for you, but just
- let's make it concrete. You're running a hockey club right now and the season's heating up and you guys are as
- competitive as you usually are. Give us some sense of what today has been for you. Something a couple of things that
- you've done or worried about or thinking about right now. >> Yeah, so this part of the year we're
- through the trade deadline. We're getting ready for the playoffs. So there isn't a lot of player movement going on
- right now. A lot of it is sort of day-to-day stuff. you know, we had a player who was sick during the night and
- so can we get someone here in time in case he can't go. Um, what does the flight schedules look like? There's a
- lot of logistics like that that people don't think about that end up, you know, just being stuff you have to organize.
- Um, and then we're also, as we, you know, with a couple months left in the season, it's time to sort of think about
- what we want to do from a staffing perspective in the coming year. And so thinking about, you know, getting
- contracts extended, thinking about who's ready for a promotion, thinking about where we want to reshape things a little
- bit. So I've had some of those conversations today, too. >> Okay. But it feels like from from this
- team's construction perspective, it's baked. You've done the baking. It's it is what it's going to be. And does does
- that does that what does that say about where team dynamics and play and and game
- strategy and that kind of lower level more detailed than roster construction where that sits in the organization and
- where it sits right now this time of year? >> I'm sorry I didn't follow. What was the
- question? >> The things like in-game strategy, closer decisions week to week, anything about
- team dynamics and any interpersonal stuff going on. Does that all just sit with the coaching staff? And so it's
- kind of outside your purview. What's your role in that stuff? >> Yep. So the coaches have primary
- responsibility for all of that. Um I, you know, everybody in the world has opinions about it. Um I have
- conversations with them from time to time about how I see things. Um it's ultimately like they are the experts,
- right? And so in management, we will have things that we do to sort of highlight, hey, here's an area where we
- might be able to get better. here's something that looks like a problem. Um, the coaches are the ones who are going
- to be better than anyone at going through the video and saying, "How do we fix that problem? What can we do about
- it?" Or, "Hey, you know what? If we tried to fix that, it would create these two other problems. We don't want to go
- down that road. This is just a weakness we have to learn to live with." >> Um, that sort of consideration mostly
- falls within them. But yeah, you know, I have conversations with the coaching staff every day about what we're seeing,
- how we're seeing it, you know, what we think. >> And when you say what you're seeing, do
- you mean what you're seeing with your eyes or what you're seeing maybe with the data or both?
- >> Both for sure. So you know it's the daily conversations are mostly about what I saw with my eyes watching the
- game and um you know we will get regular reports from the data team analyses where they will say hey you know it
- looks like in this area we're giving up a lot of chances like this that we didn't used to give up and that's
- something that can be hard to pick up by eye because a lot might mean you know one or two a game and It's hard to tell
- the difference between two per game and one and a quarter per game, but it can be a big difference. And so data
- sometimes flags stuff like that for us, but what did I see last night is mostly eye stuff.
- >> Shane, >> yeah, I guess I mean this is my way of getting I wanted to ask you about
- Brandon Busy. You're the go and obviously his his story this season, something that's been on our radar for a
- few weeks now. Um, how much of that like I I I kind of would like to hear a little bit about how you found
- slashdeveloped that talent because he seemingly came out of nowhere and what and also I I would like to hear kind of
- what we were just talking about like how much of it was kind of a I test versus a
- a data thing uh for and and how much that how easy it is to evaluate goalenders using data.
- >> Yeah. So, I mean, you know, just for the viewers who aren't aware or listeners,
- um, the Sig goalie who we claimed off of waiverss at the start of the year, he had never played an NHL game before. He
- got into our lineup and just started winning. Um, and you know, I wish I could claim that we had a super clever
- formula that told us, you know, our coaching staff. If we knew he was going to do this, we would have just signed
- him in the summer and planned on having him in the NHL all along. We wouldn't have let someone else sign him and hoped
- we could get him off waiverss. Um, so, you know, like obviously we've had some good fortune here. This is something
- that I'm not going to oversell and say we knew was coming. We did see him as somebody who deserved a chance, right?
- So, he he went to college. She was undrafted, played a few years in college, did really well, came out of
- college as a free agent. Um, we were interested in him at the time, but had kind of a full goalie depth chart. Um,
- and he went somewhere where he probably saw more opportunity for himself. Um, and then that team had a couple goalies
- emerge and didn't end up with opportunity for him. So, he was in the minor leagues for them for a couple
- years and did really well in the minor leagues. and um finally got to where he was an unrestricted free agent and could
- sign anywhere. He changed to a new team that still saw him as the number three goalie. So you carry two in the NHL.
- Your number three is normally a minor leaguer who you will call up when you need him.
- >> And because of his age and experience, he had to clear waiverss before he could
- be sent down. And we had somebody else as our number three goalie who we knew we might be at risk of losing on
- waiverss. he needed to clear waiverss, too. And so we picked up Brandon basically as an insurance policy to make
- sure we had someone. And then the confluence of events, first we were the only claim on him, so we got him even
- though a good record meant we didn't have high waiver priority. Second, we did in fact lose the other goalie on
- waivers. So we needed a third goalie. And third, a goalie who one of our top two found himself struggling to come
- back from an injury that we thought he would be back from and missed a bunch of time. And so all of a sudden, the guy
- who was sort of brought in as a backup plan to be an emergency goalie was now one of our top two goalies. And you
- know, the the goalie who was out ended up missing a lot of time. And it created opportunity for Brandon to get a bunch
- of games. And he fit in the locker room. He fit on the ice. He's a great kid and
- it's, you know, it's been good. And we signed him to a three-year extension a couple months ago. Can
- >> Let me ask a real follow because this is almost like um a a meta question about
- analytics in general. Like why was it that his minorly career, his college career, which all you're saying is all
- really good, um didn't lead to um a a playing job either first or second in a in a NHL team. Is it because, and this
- is my speculation, that goalie is just really hard to predict. Um, or is it that you just missed it? I mean, that
- those are the two possibilities, I guess. >> Yeah. I mean, there I mean, so we looked
- at his data and said he was someone who deserved a chance. Um, that's different from saying he's someone who I know is
- going to be good. And when you're filling out your top two goalies, you're looking for people who you have
- information on and confidence on. And there are a lot of people who have done well at college level and minor league
- level and look like they deserve a chance. And you don't really know how it's going to go until they get into
- games. The misfortune for him was that he spent three years as a backup as a sort of minor league emergency goalie
- and never happened to get into games. And most of the time there's an injury here or there, a trade, whatever, and
- you get 10, 20 games, and if they go well, now there's a market for you. You just
- never got that. >> So, just to summarize, it sounds very interesting. The It's very hard to know
- coming out of minor leagues and college who's going to be good. So, what people do smartly is see the ones who get a
- chance, use that information, and that dominates over a question mark person um who could be good or maybe not. And so
- you you you go with the people who have experience. And so you basically took a a chance on someone who could be good.
- You didn't know he wasn't good. Um and you just had a a high question mark. It's almost like drafting a college
- pitcher for baseball. You just don't really know until they face major league hitting or a high level minor league
- hitting. Um but you know more than say a high school pitcher. So that's a And and
- do you think that's more at the goalie position than at others or is that uh pretty typical across hockey? uh it's
- probably more a goalie than others because there's there are you know there are not as many spots for a goalie on
- your roster, right? So if you've got you know a forward who is in this situation,
- you've got 12 forwards in the NHL, one of them's getting hurt here and there, there's a lot of opportunities to get
- him a call up. It's more possible that a team could go through a year without any
- goalie injuries and never need that call up, >> right? If that happens two or three
- years in a row now this guy who really deserved a chance just hasn't gotten it yet where a forward you would have found
- chances somewhere in there. >> Can we take a moment to update us on the current wisdom around hockey I mean
- goalie performance in the playoffs. My sense as an outsider is that it matters a great deal. Um hot goalies tend to
- carry teams or at least they give a great advantage but I've never remembered the wisdom on is that
- predictive or not? or is it only descriptive after the fact? What's our best understanding of this right now
- just to make me, if nothing else, a more sophisticated consumer of playoff hockey
- this year? >> Yeah, so I think what you sort of hinted at is exactly right that a goalie can
- very easily single-handedly win a series or lose a series. And you know, obviously the better ones are a little
- more likely to be the winner than the loser, but the good ones lose series for you sometimes and the bad ones win
- series for you sometimes. It's just hard to predict. And what it comes down to is, you know, if a good goalie is going
- to stop 91% of the shots he sees and an average goalie is going to stop 90%, we're talking about a difference of one
- shot per 100. And you might only face 150 shots in a series. And so just by random dumb luck, you know, a bad goalie
- might be at 93 or 94%, a good goalie might be at 87%. It just happens, you know, it's a small sample.
- >> Shame. >> Kind of following up on that, not just specific to goalies, how random do you
- feel like the playoffs in hockey are? In baseball, I think it's a fairly well-held belief that the playoffs are
- quite random and at least in certain circles that it's almost not worth building a a team for the playoffs
- because of the randomness. Do you kind of feel like in hockey there's enough? Is is is it so random or or can you is
- there actually like strategy you can kind of do to build a team specifically for the playoffs?
- >> Yeah, I mean both things are true. the the game does change a little bit in the
- playoffs when everybody's a little bit more willing to be physical, playing a little bit harder. You know, over the
- course of 82 games, there are more lulls in energy than there are in a playoff series. And so that does change the game
- a little bit. You know, there's also probably a tendency of referees to try to stay out of the picture a little bit
- more and so they let a little bit more go and that so there is some stuff that changes. Um, a lot of that is kind of at
- the margins. Um, but you know, it's not zero. You know, to your question about how much randomness there is. I, you
- know, I the thing that is tricky for me is when people hear someone say there's a lot of randomness. They think you're
- saying, "Well, it's just dumb luck." And it's not. You know, the guy makes a great save. That's an actually great
- play. He didn't get lucky. He made a great save. luck is that he happened to make the save today when he might not
- have tomorrow, you know, and it's like sometimes you do it and sometimes you don't. That's not luck, but it's random.
- Um, and you know, it like that is a real thing, right? Teams, one of the things to your point about
- how random it is, in almost any given year, it is more likely that the best team in hockey will lose in round one
- than that they'll win the cup, >> right? So it's that gives you a sense of the sort of amount of randomness. That's
- definitely not true in basketball, right? So >> I I love I really love what you just
- said because we talk about that a lot. What we call as statistitians randomness isn't randomness.
- >> It operates mathematically as as if it is randomness. And it often gets in the way of us dealing with with
- team because if I were to talk to an NFL coach about a model that I have for deciding whether they should be going
- going for it on fourth down, they're going to say, "I don't care about your model. I'm going to ask the question,
- can I run the play that will work right now?" >> And for them, that's not a question of
- randomness, but for me, it absolutely is. >> And it's just almost like a philosophy
- among the statistitians versus the players. And you're you understand the distinction very clearly um which is
- really and that number about the about the um not making the going past it. But let me ask you a question specifically.
- How much does sort of line diversity matter at the playoff level uh as opposed to the season? So these are I'm
- I'm starting to learn a lot about hockey. Shane's are Canadian so he knows the most. Um I don't even know where
- Kate is relative to me but I've always been pretty low down on the the hockey knowledge um uh tree. Um, but I started
- to learn that about lines and and we actually went to if you see it. So, how much does it matter between the between
- your top line versus your second and even how many you have three? Um, and and does that make a distinction in the
- playoffs? >> Yeah. So, different people will view this differently and I don't think there
- is a clear right answer. Um, some people will say they want their team to have an
- identity where all four lines play the same way and they're going to wear you out doing it that way. Um, other people
- will say then you run into a team that can handle that style of play and you have nothing to fall back on. You know,
- I truthfully I think probably how good your team is matters more than any of that. You know, again, we're we're sort
- of fighting at the margins and um it does sometimes come down to whether a team is a good matchup for you or a
- tough matchup. That's that can depend on a lot of things, right? It can be, you know, your best defensive player happens
- to naturally play well against their best offensive player >> and then, you know, nothing else really
- matters because you already have that starting advantage for you. >> So, it it's hard to say really when it
- comes to that kind of stylistic thing, what is right or best. Um, you know, my personal view is accumulate as much
- talent as you can and we'll figure it out from there. Eric, let's talk about that a little bit more. I'm curious what
- you think your edge is against the NHL. You guys have been very strong performers for a number of years now. To
- the extent that you can articulate where that edge comes from, what do you think
- it is? What is it that Carolina's doing differently or better than other clubs are with that that helps explain your
- success? >> Yeah, so there's a couple things. One is the way we play. Um so our head coach
- has a philosophy of being sort of very aggressive pressuring all the time. Um it's hard to do and he is a very detail
- oriented coach. Um that he makes sure that everything behind that pressure is designed to cover it up. Right? So, if
- you took five guys on a pond and said, "We're going to pressure all over the ice," they would screw it up from time
- to time, cuz that happens. And you wouldn't have the discipline to cover, and it would be breakdown after
- breakdown, and it would be a mess. Um, we have a coach who is detail oriented enough to think through how you minimize
- the downside of that pressure. And, you know, of course, there's always going to
- be some downside. You can't avoid that. That's a trade-off. but his ability to get everybody playing the right way and
- make sure we're covering for each other makes it so that we can be really effective playing that way. And it's
- exhausting to play against us when you've got four lines that are playing really aggressively pressuring you just
- kind of never get a break on the other team. >> And so that's one part of it. Then what
- goes handinhand with that is we have a very deep roster. So there, I would say most of the best teams in the league
- have a couple of superstars who they got, you know, at the very top of the draft when the team stunk and you wait a
- few years until those guys hit their prime and now they just give you a starting point that makes everything
- easier. You've got, you know, those two guys to build around or three guys or however many it is
- >> and you can sort of be middling through the rest of the roster and still have a
- really good team. We don't really have that. Most of our best players are guys who came sort of later in the first
- round, second round, free agency, however it was. And so the way we make up for not having those guys at the top
- end is being really solid all the way down to the bottom of our lineup. >> And a that means the bottom of our
- lineup, you know, is often better than the other teams bottom of the lineup and they can gain ground there for us. But
- B, when you couple that with a system that is high pressure all the time and you're rolling four lines and three D
- pairs that can all do it and are all putting you under stress all game long, it's a hard team to play against. And so
- that >> that combination of a roster that is built so that everyone can do it and a
- team that, you know, a coaching system that has guys playing in a very high pressure way. It just it makes us tough
- to play against. >> Related somewhat related question and going back to the playoff hockey
- plausibly being different. I'm curious how you've maintained your philosophy in the face of a narrative that says you
- got to build a roster differently in the playoffs. And especially given that you
- were knocked out two years in a row by the Panthers who follow that philosophy. And it's this it's this very general
- tension in sports between the narrative and the process. You guys have a process. Analytics oriented
- organizations like to focus on a process. Sometimes the narrative really stresses that process. If everyone's
- saying you guys got knocked out by the Panthers, they've got a team built for the playoffs. You've had to stand in the
- face of that and maintain your process. And you seem it seems that you have what
- has that been like? How is it that you've been able to maintain your philosophy and your process in the face
- of such a strong narrative? >> Yeah. I mean, so partly part of the answer is I think a lot of the narrative
- stuff is just, you know, not terribly grounded in reality, right? So, forget about our team or Florida's team and
- just ask someone what playoff hockey looks like. And they're going to say, you know, you can't rely on your power
- play being great because there aren't as many power there aren't as many penalties in the playoffs. They're going
- to say you can't rely on, you know, fancy rush offense because a lot of that tightens up when everybody's defending
- hard. You have to be willing to just put in deep and go forch check and create turnovers and get some chaos and you
- know things will work for you. That's exactly how we play. >> It's also exactly how Florida plays.
- Like >> they copied the way we were playing before they got good. And so it's, you
- know, like >> the difference is they have um they have some players who probably play a little
- bit more on the physical edge than our team does. And you know that creates a sense about
- the way they play that people don't have about us. But in terms of the style of play, we're doing exactly the same thing
- in terms of keeping the puck in their end, putting the pressure on, not relying on, you know, high octane
- superstars making plays through the neutral zone, not relying on getting power plays as our only way to score.
- Yeah, it is a very similar thing. And the other thing is the first time we played them, we out chanced them by a
- million >> and we got really good goalending at our end and they got goalending stopping 97%
- of the shots at their end and we lost four games by one goal. You know >> with I think two were in overtime and a
- third one the goal was with 30 seconds left in regulate. >> You know it was a very very close series
- where again you know that guy makes two fewer saves and we win the series. Okay. Excellent. But it just reminds me
- that Shane and I have a perennial like fantasy an analytics question from hockey that you might be able to answer
- off the top of your head. Shane, you might help me here. We have a sense that players step it up espec hockey. We It's
- like it's like we start texting each other when that happens because it's like mustwatch TV because everything
- just goes up. We have so much motion tracking data now that should be an observable difference. Is that true? If
- we had the motion tracking from a regular season hockey game and a overtime playoff hockey game, would we
- see differences in how much exertion there is on the ice? >> Yeah. And if you want to make even more
- tangible, you could talk about like say the for check or something like that or or or or back check, what whatever.
- >> Yeah. So, I would say um the challenging thing about that is when you get to overtime, players start to get tired,
- right? So, third period of a tie game, the energy is way up there. By midway through the first overtime, it's falling
- off. And so when I tell you we out chanced Florida by a million in that series, it actually at the end of the
- series, it was only a thousand because we had one game that went into three or four overtimes and our guys just got
- worn out >> and we out chanced them through regulation of that game >> and first overtime, second overtime,
- third overtime. It was like, you know, we're playing this dump and chase game where they're dumping it in and then
- going for a line change because they don't have the energy to forch check. And if every time you dump, you get the
- puck, you dump it in and go for a line change, it's hard to ever create offense. And so that one game wiped out
- a lot of our advantage for the series in terms of the scoring chances just because our guys, you know, couldn't
- keep the pressure up for seven periods in a row and, you know, hopefully they never have to,
- >> right? Okay. Okay. Very interesting. That's good. That's a good rejoiner to the fantasy that we have. All right. I'
- I've got one I I consider it maybe the most important question for some of our audience. Um and it goes to your
- background, Eric. FA famously, you have a PhD in chemistry. Famously, you have 27 patents. Famously, you worked in
- industry for 10 years before jumping over. And you started as a blogger and then as a part-time as a consultant. And
- you've really worked your way up step by step through the organization to your current position.
- We work with a lot of analysts. We have students that come through here as analysts. And a lot of analysts have
- trouble building credibility in a sports organization because they didn't grow up
- playing the game and they're they're they're they have a different background. They talk differently. They
- look different. >> I know this is hard to reflect on given that it's you you're talking about you.
- But what do you think you've done over your 10 years, over your 12 years, over your 12 years with the Hurricanes to
- build the credibility where you could come in as such an outsider and and and then get responsibility after
- responsibility until now you run the organization and the head coach is a Hall of Fame player and plausibly a Hall
- of Fame coach eventually. It's like you've you've got very strong folks in that building. What advice would you
- give to others as they try to follow that kind of path? Yeah. So, I mean, in some real sense, I
- was lucky. So, in 2014, there were five or six hockey teams that hired people out of the blogosphere to be sort of the
- first analyst in the league. Um, and some of those teams, it was kind of owner driven. Um, somebody reading stuff
- and saying, "Why aren't we doing this? Go hire someone." And the GM said, "Fine, I'll hire someone." and gave the
- person a cubicle and ignored their reports and went on their merry day. >> Um, I was lucky that the team that
- reached out to me was a team where it was GM driven. It was, you know, a management group saying, I don't really
- know if there's anything to this, but I don't want to miss the chance to get better. So, let's bring someone in and
- see what we think. And so, you know, I still, like you say, you have to build up credibility, but I had every
- opportunity to do that, right? So from the outset, they were asking what I thought. They might not weigh it very
- heavily initially because I'm an outsider. What do I know? But they at least asked, they paid attention. They
- remembered. And you know, each time what you say sort of pans out, you build up a
- little bit more credibility if somebody's paying attention to it. >> And they were. And gradually, you know,
- they brought me in because they wanted to see if there were ways I could help. And over time, they came to believe
- there were. You're speaking about an organizational culture that was open, not maybe more
- than open, interested in an outside perspective. Are there other examples of what the organization was doing at that
- time that showed that kind of openness? Were they were they looking for edges in
- other ways as well? Were they unorthodox in other ways as well? >> Yeah. So, I mean, the that time was a
- little complicated for the team. Our spending was near the bottom of the league and the team was in a deep
- rebuild. Um, and so a lot of, you know, looking for an edge meant trying to accumulate future assets, not trying to
- find ways to be better today. >> Okay. >> Um, and, you know, so it was a lot of it
- was sort of making sure we were thinking about the draft the right way, making sure we were not missing chances to
- collect uh, future assets that could help the team when we were ready to compete. um the management group at that
- time. I would say this may be different from at least some teams is there was a strong ethos that you know again hall of
- fame GM um believed he didn't get into this to try to squeak into the playoffs as an eight seed. He got into this to
- win championships and so he was not interested in taking shortcuts at a veteran free agent who might put us in
- contention for that bottom playoff spot. He wanted to build it the right way and
- put together a core that could really contend. >> Um so there was an ownership group that
- was prepared for that as long as spending was kept low during that time and a management group that really
- thought about it that way. Um, and that was probably freeing compared to some markets where you would feel like we
- can't do that. We have to compete. You know, whatever you do, you need to get three wins better than you were last
- year. >> Right. Right. Right. Okay. We're we're going to have to let you go, but Audi
- wants to jump in. Audi usually has great last questions. >> Think of it as a last question. It
- partly is from my lack of knowledge. Um so in every sport we always ask the question what is the biggest way that's
- analytics data analysis uh statistics has impacted the way the game is either played strategically or player
- acquisition. And so the of course with B with Moneyball with baseball the player
- acquisition is a big deal where you look for under undervalued uh asset particularly on base and the way the
- game is played you don't worry so much about strikeouts you bunt less you steal you know home runs that kind of thing
- and every sport kind of has that um and in fact you can early on you could identify that the teams that were doing
- well were doing those things as opposed to the other things. So my question is hockey um what are those if I were to
- say what are the you know the the analytic contribution either strategically or or in asset evaluation
- that has changed the way we think of hockey what would be like I would say on the strategy side a lot of it is either
- behind the scenes where people aren't really seeing it or sort of minor stuff at the margins like how early do you
- pull the goalie you know stuff like that there's a little bit of that um on the roster side, I think the biggest
- shift, and it's one that's still in progress, comes back to that point about there not being very many goals per year
- and there being room for fluctuation. Um 10 years ago, 15 years ago, there were a
- lot of contracts handed out because somebody's shooting percentage was higher than it had been in the previous
- five years. >> And hey, it looks like he's figured it out. He's a 25 goalc scorer now. And if
- he took kind of the same number of shots and kind of the same caliber shots, the
- odds that he had figured out something new and was going to make them keep going in were not as high as people
- thought. >> Um there's still always going to be a little bit of that pull, right? Because
- >> when when they are successful, you know, it impacts the way you perceive each
- shot. It impacts the way you perceive the way he's playing. like there's always going to be some influence and
- maybe rightly so, but I think the sort of catastrophic mistake from 10 or 15 years ago has mostly been eliminated
- from the game today where, you know, people recognize, yeah, he had a great year. I'm not ready to assume that's
- what he is forever now. >> Progression to the mean. They discovered it. >> All right, we should let you go, Eric.
- Uh, thank you much for taking time. Uh, great to talk with you and good luck with the rest of the regular season and
- the playoffs. We'll be pulling for you and pulling for the Hurricanes. >> Yeah, thanks. It was fun. I'll talk to
- you in 2038. >> That was We knew that was coming. Thank you, Eric. It was great.
- >> Thank you. >> All right, that's been the first half of Wharton Moneyball. Come back and join us
- after the break. Welcome back. Welcome back to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to the second half of
- this week's show. the second half of a full hour on sports analytics here on the Wharton podcast network. Hey Massie
- hosting this week with my buddies Shane Jensen and Audi Winer. Brad Low is away.
- Bradlo will be back just off the horn with Eric Tolski uh general manager of the Carolina
- Hurricanes, the high-flying top performing Carolina Hurricanes. Made the conference finals the last two years and
- they're playing well again this year. Shane's been enamored of their um free agent offseason signing in the in goal
- who is setting all kinds of records. So good fun. Good fun. Any reactions to the
- Tulski conversation? >> Well, I loved it. Um I don't know that much of hockey, but he gave me an answer
- to a question that I really appreciate which is something that I think is true is that I think the observation of
- analytics to the naked eye when you watch the the sport is less than in the other sports. Like basketball looks very
- different and you can point to analytics as causing the the the the collapsing of
- the sport down to post ups and three-pointers. Football looks different, way more aggressive. U
- baseball of course is different. People would say it's worse, but we can argue that. Um
- >> yeah, I was going to say like it's it hasn't gotten around to ruining hockey yet is what you're getting at.
- >> But you don't really notice it like I mean if you watch hockey I don't people
- haven't said it it's a different game now because analytics have changed it. And that's kind of what he said. We we
- do muck around a little bit on the edges, but nothing in a not nothing in a really game-changing way. Although I
- thought he might get there because one of the things that that in golf um that Mark Brody has taught us about analytics
- is you just you just put you it's risk you just hit it as hard as you can. Um instead of trying to be precise, it
- turns out that value is that aggression is worth it. And in soccer, the aggression pressuring is worth it. And
- then he said that his team they they're aggressive. They pressure. But he didn't
- say that's the way to do it. He said that's the way that they do it. And that's a little bit different. Um
- to be clear, he credited Brenda uh at least. But I think he did a lot of crediting other people in this whole
- interview. He credited the organization. He credited management. He credited his
- coach. He was very humble in that way. >> Yeah. Yeah, I mean I feel like it always
- like I mean let's say like basketball and hockey are you know the analog is they're both kind of continuous movement
- uh kind of you you'd think that they Alex would hit them equally hard but you know hockey has a way smaller sample
- size on kind of the outcome like in basketball you've got a process you want to refine a move you've got like 50
- times a game to try it out or something like that and and you get to see the results because you actually have a high
- success rate on each one, right? Whereas hockey, I think a lot of the analytics is towards kind of creating
- opportunities or kind of like essentially latent aspects of the game that you know again justify the kind of
- process or whatever. I'm sure I'm sure there's kind of internal data that companies are that sorry that uh teams
- are using to justify their process kind of decisions but I mean if you just look
- at you know from the public's point of view where it's just like goals and wins and stuff like that I think it's just
- there's less kind of uh outcome to um to see that. So I I do think it's like less
- apparent kind of I guess like you know it's harder to kind of see it's more subtle to see the the changes in process
- perhaps that come from analyt any analytics applied to hockey. >> Yeah. >> Shane you uh we're you've given us a few
- hockey notes. What what do you think's most notable here as we hit kind of the stretch run of the regular season? What
- should we be thinking about? What are you paying attention to? Well, I I just I I guess it's uh um I
- mean, we already talked a little bit in the first half about the the Brandon Busy uh situation with that. So, I I
- think honestly it is mostly about I I mean, we talked about this a little last week, what the Savers have been doing
- this season going out of nowhere >> is is pretty uh pretty interesting. I feel like the East has really kind of
- other than I guess Carolina is a main state, but I feel like the East at least in hockey has kind of been all over the
- place. Like Florida's not even Florida's tank. They're this defending Stanley Cup
- tank champions and they're basically tanking now for a top 10 pick. Um, yeah. I just so essent
- you you know I guess the playoff we talked a little bit with Eric about how random the playoffs are and I've kind of
- I baked that into my expectations. The regular season has looked a little bit more random to me this year at least in
- the East. >> Yeah, the East looks a little weaker, right? And so a team like Carolina that
- is strong and has been strong has a little easier path to the finals coming out.
- >> True. Yes, that's right. I think Carolina is the only team in the east I would put with any of the say top two or
- three teams in the west. I mean the stars and the avalanche are really kind of head and shoulders above above uh
- everybody except for I think Carolina. >> So you know let me ask a question because I didn't really understand the
- role of stars in hockey. Um and he described specifically that the the Hurricanes do not have it's not a star
- driven team. >> Yeah. >> Right. And they're just de and balance. Um how common is that? I mean is that
- >> well I mean >> highly unusual or I mean how much of like in basketball you think if you
- don't have a star or two or at least one where you going and >> well you're not Yeah that's why there's
- five teams in basketball actually going for it at any given year you know right uh in hockey the stars I think are
- spread around a little bit more but I mean some of the big like like I mean Edmonton is obviously the case of of
- what I think Eric was describing of you know they've got a couple good player like superstars But it's not a depth
- team and it's, you know, it's not it's kind of it's it's a very uneven team in terms of like, you know, line diversity,
- I guess, as we talked about. And so that's anam, you know, that's kind of an example in the other direction. I and I
- I think again Eric talked about as a team building thing. The way the the way that has to happen, the way an Edmonton
- can happen is you need to be terrible for several seasons to get like a few number one picks. and and that's that's
- essentially what Edmonton was terrible for like a decade and accumulated the kind of like superstar talent, but in
- hockey most teams don't want to be terrible for that long and it's even chancey then to get that superstar
- talent. So I think most teams try and do more what Carolina does. I mean to again
- as Eric described I think what Carolina can make their specific combination work
- because of kind of the gravitas and process of their coach and and and various other elements that I think are
- unique to them. >> Right. I think it is a it's a it's a it I don't think there are many teams that
- are as philosophically depth oriented as Carolina is and partly because it does match so well with the preferred
- strategy of the coach. Um, but I mean, you know, you usually hear teams, at least fan bases. I know less about the
- front offices, but the fan bases lament not having the stars and when are they going to get the stars and what's the
- strategy for getting the stars? >> If I was a Hurricanes fan, a really deep hurricanes star, I'd be like, "Fine,
- build the deep tea. Just add a star on top of it if you got a chance. Why not?" >> And that's one of the critiques of these
- guys and they and it was one of the critiques of the of the of the deadline this year. They were quiet at the
- deadline. They didn't make a push for that extra that extra star. Um, so we'll see. We'll see how it plays out. All
- right. Um before OD's going to leave here just momentarily. Odd. Anything on baseball? You guys are kicking off the
- season. Your season starts tomorrow. >> The day this show goes up. >> It does. Not every team is playing
- tomorrow. Um >> No, it's Yeah, I mean it's the Yankees and Giants are playing tomorrow and then
- the mo most teams start it off on Thursday, I guess. >> Well, there's my night. There you go. Or
- is it the They're playing in the afternoon. So, um >> Oh, they're playing each other. They're
- doing inner division on on day one. >> Yeah. really inner league play on day one. That's
- >> Yeah, it's all over the schedule now. I I think that I think the Red Sox are starting out against the Reds. So, I
- think uh yeah, >> I guess that's a way of that's fun. If you're going to give one game, you'd
- give a game to both leagues, I suppose. Huh. >> I don't have don't have much to say
- about it. Could wait till the game get season gets started. Looks like the Yankees don't have a major catastrophe
- in spring training, so that's good. Um we'll we'll we'll wait till the season rolls out. But next week, just a plug,
- we have a baseball historian coming to talk on our show, a professor of history who specializes in modern urban history,
- has written a new book on baseball, so we can and he's got a chapter on analytics, but we can ask it in general
- any of our any questions. Um, so that's next week. Professor D, >> bring your bring your uh tweed jackets
- and your pipes, fellow. >> Yes, absolutely. And although I have to say uh I didn't realize it but but he's
- maybe we'll talk about it next week. He's a crazy fan. Usually professors to have a a standoffish attitude towards
- this the subject that they're actually researching but he's a nut crazy fan. >> Wow. I try and maintain my impartiality.
- Yeah. But I mean everybody's got their own thing. >> Yeah. And Eric and I really do that with
- the Yankees every time. >> Oh yeah. No, I mean unbiased. Unbiased. Cover all cover all parts of the country
- equally. How how do the forecast for let's just pick the most obvious team Dodgers compare to historical top teams?
- How how high is this projection these for this team? Dodgers so high up there. >> I haven't done it analytically, but the
- projections seem whack like like really out of out of out of handle. I mean I guess it's been a while since we've had
- like a repeat champion. Maybe people's I I don't know. It's people are going crazy over but like you know I think I
- had them Pakakota had them at like you know something like 105 like we again projections above 100 wins.
- >> Well that's crazy fan graphs which is generally as smart as you get when it comes to simulating and regressing to
- the mean. >> They have them at at it's got to be historically high 96. >> That's rid Yeah.
- >> 96 is historically high. What do you think the >> I've seen probabil like basically
- probabilities of like almost guaranteeing playoffs for them? >> Yeah, so playoff percentage is
- undoubtedly extremely high. I mean, look at the playoff odds graph. Um I'm sure it's, you know, ridiculous, but um um
- >> I mean I again I think we I'm though I actually kind of do like the you know obviously some of the team players
- specific players on the Dodgers are some of my play favorite players in baseball.
- I kind of feel like I I I I feel like we I'm I'm I'm cheering against him this year because I I do think like if the
- Dodgers win it all again this year, it's almost guaranteed like the drum beats for kind of a lockout and like all
- this kind of stuff. I I I think, you know, we've got a collective bargaining uh negotiation coming up next off
- season. I feel like just for for my own kind of optimism for how that ne salary negotiation goes,
- the best case scenario is not the Dodgers winning it all again. Right. >> Okay. So, hold on. Let me make sure
- >> because this is the big issue is going to be a salary cap and the the owners and the teams are going to resist it and
- you're saying >> players are going to resist it. Major >> That's right. Owners are pushing,
- players are going to resist. If the Dodgers win, it's going to be more fuel for the salary cap side because they've
- been so outspending everybody. And and Shane, you're revealing a bias against a salary cap because you don't want that.
- You're saying you don't want the Dodgers to win because it would increase the chance. It would increase the ammunition
- for the salary cap people. Now, normally I'm for the players, but in this case, I
- don't know, man. I mean, >> well, I I'll give you a little little fact. So, Bruce
- Oh, yeah. Okay. He sat next to me. Well, I'll just to finish this simple point and before I actually head out to
- my class, um he before he was the head of the union, he said, "If I'm representing the union, they'll be a
- salary crap over my dead body." So, you know that they're going to fight this tooth and nail. It's what And it's it's
- in some sense an odd um thing for the players to support because it's great for the top, but pretty bad for the
- median. >> Yeah. Why don't why don't why don't they say why would they would trade the cap
- for a higher share would they not like you >> maybe they would and we'll see how that
- plays out because you got to get teams that have who are not spending spending and that's
- >> yeah that's that was what I was going to say is the problem is not the cat like
- the problem with baseball is not the five or so teams that are really trying to win it all it's the 10 or so teams
- that aren't trying at all to win >> ever >> and just kind of taking in revenue sharing so it's like, you know, it's
- more about the floor than it is about the ceiling. I mean, the Dodgers are maybe testing that by I mean, they're
- being kind of uh ostentatious, I guess, for lack of a better term right now. But, you know, no more I don't think any
- more relatively ostentatious than what the Yankees were doing in the early 2000s when baseball was at its peak, by
- the way. Um, at least in my my mind. >> Shane, Shane, why are you against the salary cap? because you're Red Sox fan
- and they spend pretty freely or or what is there? >> No, no, no, no. It's I think it's more
- off I think it's a distraction. I I mean I think it's very obvious. Um, you know,
- there it's it's again it's penalizing the teams that are trying to win to the to to to the benefit of teams
- under the opaces of fairness, but really to benefit to to essentially continue to
- carry all these teams that are not doing anything, >> right? >> Because they pay this enormous luxury
- tax. Dodgers are at, you know, whatever hundreds of millions of dollars they're paying. huge num amount of money goes to
- the other team because of the ledger tax. So the pirates can just sort of rake in money with revenue sharing and
- whatever deals they have, not spend it on anyone and and just never compete and never lose.
- >> It feels but it feels like you you can't you can't say you can say you're anti-
- salary cap, but really that doesn't mean you're pro the current structure. You want some structural changes. We
- probably going to have to >> take this head on and move multiple levers in order to get a deal done. It
- feels like restructuring is better than what we have right now. >> Yes, I would argue. And but I it come
- hell or high water, I want to make sure there's no strike. That is just the worst.
- >> Oh, that's going to happen. What I'm hearing is that's going to happen because both sides feel so strong.
- >> Lockout. It'll lead to a more creative >> for the sport. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. No, I mean I I and again I I
- >> I think a returning to our original thing, I think a lockout um I think a a lockout is more likely
- um if uh if the Dodgers win it all again. >> Yeah, I I agree. But I I I don't play
- stoppages are terrible, but I don't see a way out of this. I think we need to restructure and you're not going to
- restructure without a stoppage. And so if we need a little more ammunition to get the stop edge, so be it. I hate to
- pull for the favorites this year. Um, I can't quite get there. What if another high salary cap team, a high spending
- team did it? Would that be helpful? Maybe it wouldn't be as helpful as the Dodgers, but the
- >> Again, I think like it's a weird Yeah, I mean, no, it wouldn't be because at least there'd be variety or something. I
- I don't I don't know. But again, it's like the teams that spend more should win. I I mean I I don't think it's like,
- you know, it's >> But again, I I don't I don't question that. I >> is a sympathetic party in this the the
- the poor owners of like, you know, the the the impoverished owners of the Cincinnati Reds that just can't compete
- aren't aren't aren't enough of the billionaire level that they can't compete with the billionaires in New
- York. >> I don't know. I it's it's >> I don't I I don't care because of poor owners, but I do care about poor fan
- bases and the lack of competition, the lack of interest, and how much of the league is kind of irrelevant from day
- one. Look at the number of teams whose playoff probabilities are like 2% or less. It's it's like half. It's
- literally half of the league. That doesn't feel healthy. And I'm not saying >> is it really? I mean, again, back that's
- not that can't be right. It's it is very close to right. We looked at this a couple of weeks ago.
- It's very close to right that there are >> half the teams have no chance or like
- less than 5% >> more than what are we 30. >> Well, but that was using those probabilities that gave like like 40%
- odds the Dodgers. I mean those are whack probabilities. But I I I I'll concede your more general point that that that
- there is structural issue to the the league. um a a disparity um of a disparity of talent between
- teams that is partly driven by a disparity um in spending and and that that you know some aspect needs to be
- corrected. I just think the salary cap unless it you know if they instituted I would be not in favor of a salary cap
- instituted without a commiserate salary floor. >> Yeah. No, this is I I I'm not saying
- let's just cap it and be done. I'm saying reorganize or restructure it al together.
- >> Shane, real quickly before we go away, can we just have any words on March Madness? We're we're through the opening
- weekend. Um, so 16 teams get to play, get to It's always fun when you're pulling for a team when you get that
- second weekend. It's It's great to make the tournament, but it makes a big difference just to get another week,
- another four or five days of enjoying it, kind of reing in the experience. Um, and so 16 teams are getting that. It is
- jockey jockey chalk jock. We were worried about this last year. Now we have two seasons in a year.
- >> So it's NIL and transfers. NIL and transfers have really changed the game. This is I forget by what measure, but in
- 97 years of the tournament, there had been two in which it's something like in the NF in the in football it would be
- the group of five in which no group of five teams had made the Sweet 16. Two years out of 97 and those are the last
- two years. like no no no Cinderellas progress essentially the Longhorns are ran as a 11 seed but they're hardly
- qualifying as a Cinderella SEC middle of the pack SEC team. Um, so something >> and I mean I guess it's sort of like I
- mean I I think obviously what you're talking about is some of the structural changes in the sport that has maybe led
- to are we seeing I I guess more of a disparity between teams now or more of a predictive thing because it could also
- be that we're getting better at seating team like just the acts of seating teams. the concentration of talent. All
- all >> it's really all it's all about the concentration. >> All the mid- major talent that used to
- be there and now moves, they migrate up. They get identified and migrated up. And
- so the top hundred, you know, mid- major players, they would have almost all still been
- with their mid- major teams in the past and that and you know, a guy one guy on a basketball team can make a big
- difference. Maybe 80 of those guys have been migrated up um above that level. Now, would that then make the later
- rounds more R because I mean obviously that means like if you're if if the talent's kind of moving up the
- hierarchy. >> Yeah. >> You'd see then it would be certainly the the the result would be chalk in these
- early rounds like a you know a one a one versus a 16 is like even more uh of a mismatch than it used to be. But then
- that does probably mean the ones that certain unless unless it really is like an exponential like increase in up the
- hierarchy like you'd presumably they would we we'd now be now that we're kind of down to like whatever the level is
- >> whether it's a sweet 16 or elite eight then it's there's no chalk to it after
- that point. I don't I don't know. I don't >> It's a It's a It's an empirical question, but you're right. It's not
- obvious. If it's just that >> all the talent from the mid- majors popped up above that level and got
- randomly distributed, then we'd expect more competition, more uncertainty in the second half of the tournament. But
- if it's just the case that everybody kind of moved up the escalator so that even the very top teams, the elite teams
- got gained additional separation as well, then we might not see that increased uncertainty and leveling out
- you're talking about. Um, what would be your hypothesis? Do you think it's got a
- compressed, right? That that what's left in the tournament has to be more compressed than what was left in the
- average historical term. No, I mean honestly it's it's making me think like what it's I mean if if you kind of cast
- the entire 64 team tournament is like okay there's not 64 teams of real like like like that's that's our sample size
- for determining this this like this kind of concentration and now you know the point the round at which it becomes
- basically random is the number of teams worth of worth of talent you have in the
- system >> essentially right >> that's right that's Um, that's right. That's right. And that would suggest and
- we we we know we know it's more it's it's more than 64 teams or less than 64 teams. We know it's probably less than
- 16, but now who knows how many it kind of concentrates around. And you know, you probably have the same technical
- dynamic in football, but of course they don't do nearly the broad enough playoff
- structure where you'd be able to explore. >> Also the talent individual players can't
- change. >> Yeah, I guess. Right. That's right. It's also the team how much any one player
- influences a team outcome is different too. But the we here's a simple version of the question like at the top here's a
- simple version of the question at the very top among the top two three teams are they any more separated from the
- next six or eight than they were historically is that is that separation you just take the take the elite eight
- >> is that separation more or less than it has been historically and I think that's
- an open question it's not obvious this next round the round of 16 has to be more competitive than it was
- historically and that's the way if you remember the the typical tournament dynamics with, you know, crazy first
- weekend and then boring second weekend. >> Yeah, that's right. That's right. All
- all our Cinderella's like uh the shoe falls off the Cinderellas usually when once again.
- >> That's right. Too much disparity. Too much disparity. >> Um All right. Well, good fun. We've got
- uh we've got games again Thursday and Friday. Good fun. Um why don't we let it go there, Shane? for the whole crew, for
- St. Jensen here through the full show, for Audi Winer who just had to slip away and run to the classroom, for Eric
- Bradlo in absentia, for Dion Simpkins who makes this whole thing go, for Mir Serena, our producer, for Deep Patel,
- the boss lady. Appreciate you guys listening. Come back and join us next time. Between now and then, enjoy your
- sports.
Brief Summary
Eric Tolski discusses the Hurricanes' strategies, analytics, and unpredictability of playoff hockey.
Key points
- Welcome Back Eric Tolski. Eric Tolski returns to the show after a long absence, discussing his journey with the Hurricanes.
- Evaluating Goalie Talent. The hosts discuss the challenges of predicting goalie performance based on minor league and college success.
- The Randomness of Playoffs. The unpredictability of playoff hockey and the impact of goalies is explored.
- High Pressure System. The team's high-pressure system makes them tough to play against, exhausting opponents.
- Building Credibility. Eric Tolski discusses how he built credibility as an outsider in the organization.
- Analytics in Hockey. The impact of analytics on hockey strategy and player evaluation is discussed.
Episode highlights
- Welcome Back Eric TolskiEric Tolski returns to the show after a long absence, discussing his journey with the Hurricanes.“It’s quite a delight to have you back, Eric.”1:29Mar 25, 2026
- Evaluating Goalie TalentThe hosts discuss the challenges of predicting goalie performance based on minor league and college success.“It’s very hard to know who’s going to be good.”10:10Mar 25, 2026
- The Randomness of PlayoffsThe unpredictability of playoff hockey and the impact of goalies is explored.“A goalie can very easily single-handedly win a series or lose a series.”12:06Mar 25, 2026
- High Pressure SystemThe team's high-pressure system makes them tough to play against, exhausting opponents.“It's a hard team to play against.”20:23Mar 25, 2026
- Building CredibilityEric Tolski discusses how he built credibility as an outsider in the organization.“I was lucky that the team that reached out to me was GM driven.”27:24Mar 25, 2026
- Analytics in HockeyThe impact of analytics on hockey strategy and player evaluation is discussed.“People recognize, yeah, he had a great year. I'm not ready to assume that's what he is forever now.”32:43Mar 25, 2026
- Hurricanes' Unique StrategyThe Hurricanes thrive without star players, focusing on depth instead.“It's a very uneven team in terms of line diversity.”39:08Mar 25, 2026
- Baseball Season KickoffThe baseball season is starting soon, with teams gearing up for competition.“The day this show goes up, the Yankees and Giants are playing tomorrow.”40:57Mar 25, 2026





