Smart Cities
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
π Public Policy
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- our guest today is Sita Hari heron she is the general manager and group head at the digital software and solutions group
- at Tata Consultancy Services and we are speaking with her today about smart cities a toolkit for leaders a special
- report that we produced collaboratively recently Siva thank you so much for joining us today acknowledged at Wharton
- Mikael it's so great to be here particularly talking about smart cities a topic that you and I are quite
- passionate about exactly right so again thanks so much for being here I know we can start with a very basic question
- what is a smart city what was what are the concept meat mean originally and how has it evolved over time and thank you
- for having me Moo Cole I mean it's such a pleasure to be here with you and let's
- look at some data if you look at smart cities and the number of smart cities between 2002 and 2015 it had quadrupled
- across the globe from approximately 21 to 88 at the end of 2017 about hundred and seventy eight cities embarked on 250
- smart city projects from Melbourne to Copenhagen to San Francisco this data suggests that there is this rapid
- urbanization across the globe and there are leaders in the municipalities and cities that are trying to figure out how
- to cope with this rapid urbanization and as you rightly said the definition of smart cities has evolved over the last
- couple of decades in the first phase when smart cities started to be discussed in the public forum technology
- players looked at some of the challenges that were created by the urbanization so
- they said let me create point product solutions addressing the various challenges which is what technology
- players do related to parking mobility water management lighting and so on so that was the phase one how
- as many city leaders lamented technology players didn't quite understand how the
- city would consume those solutions so came the second phase when the city leader said let me take control of the
- technology agenda for my city and however there were two things that were lacking number one collaboration across
- the various departments of the city and number two keeping citizens at the center of
- everything that they do so collaboration with the citizens so now we are in the third phase of smart city definition I'm
- quite excited about that Mukul because city's leaders are saying that I want to create cities that are livable that
- focus on the well-being and happiness of my citizens so it is a citizen centric agenda and that is evolving and one of
- the examples that come to mind is a place that you visited last year for your vacation Iceland and the capital
- city of Iceland Reykjavik developed a program right after the 2008 financial crisis called the better Reykjavik
- program that is a platform by the way which gives voice to the citizens in policymaking and there are other
- examples in san san antonio as an example with your highway sign boards and beijing with a I love Beijing app
- that can be used by the citizens to report either power outages broken street lamps or potholes to the
- government I'm really glad you mentioned the idea of a platform because I was very curious to see how you think of
- smart cities functioning as platforms that enable collaboration between different groups groups of stakeholders
- I was wondering if you could speak about that a little bit more yeah so if you start with being citizen-centric that
- provides the right motivation to drive the right behaviors take the right action
- and collaboration yes is absolutely needed across the various departments of the city but it is also needed with the
- citizens and private enterprises as well so if you look at the linkage as an example between water management and
- traffic management or between event management in a city and city commerce it becomes quite apparent as to why such
- a collaboration is really essential as an example if there is water pipe breakage in one part of the city you
- really want to divert traffic in that part so as to avoid traffic jams or congestion in that part and similarly
- when the city is hosting let's say a football match or a popular music concert one thing that isn't obvious is
- while the city will improve its enhance its safety and security measures what is
- not clear is how does it relate to city commerce as an example the retailers will do well if they can increase the
- foot traffic in the areas where such special events happen what that does for the retailers is it increases the
- revenues for the retailers not just that it increases the revenue for the city because of the taxes so the
- collaboration across the various departments of the city is absolutely essential and having a unified platform
- as you said will drive that collaboration but as you and I know we also have to collaborate the city has to
- collaborate with the citizens as well as with private enterprises and academic institutions and one example that comes
- to mind is how arizona's Institute for digital Progress has set up the structure they have a unified leadership
- structure that drives collaboration across the various municipalities authorities Academy institutions like
- the Arizona State University as well as private sectors like Google uber Cisco Intel in order to tackle some of their
- traffic congestion problems I'm really glad you brought up leadership because it seems to me that the role of the
- leadership is very crucial in making a city smart or at least smarter how do mayors and other civic leaders go
- about setting priorities that define how a city becomes smarter across different
- dimensions of its operations you're right mogul mayor's play such a critical role I was watching a documentary
- several years ago from HP bow which is called the weight of the nation this documentary takes you through the
- neighborhoods of Columbus Ohio particularly Lyndhurst and huff they're about eight and a half miles apart and
- as you drive through these neighborhoods the life expectancy drops by approximately twenty four years and it's
- not so unique to Ohio you see when you take a tube ride in London from Oxford Circus to silver Lane which is about 15
- minutes train ride the life expectancy drops by approximately 15 to 20 years to neighborhoods that are so close to each
- other but so far apart the question is why an obvious answer is yes that is a healthcare disparity between these two
- communities but as you and I know the healthcare disparity doesn't come by itself it's also because of the
- disparities in education housing food access and possibly workforce development so mayor's as you rightly
- asked they have a crucial role role to play in terms of addressing some of these real-life challenges and balancing
- that with driving economic growth for the cities so they need to do that in my view in three steps
- number one they need to first define a clear vision for their city in a very simple manner I'll use an overused
- example here but a powerful one one of the former mayors of Barcelona mr. arrow said that his vision was to
- create a dancing Barcelona a city where the visitors felt welcome the streets were well lit the city smelled fresh and
- the citizens and the visitors were safe and happy you know this powerful simple vision
- drove the choice of choice of technologies for Barcelona whether it be in mobility parking lighting energy
- management or security and even mace waste management for the city right so to start with the mayors need to define
- in simpler terms what their vision is for the city the second of course as we discussed earlier is collaboration with
- the citizens and driving initiatives that are citizen-centric that becomes very important as a second next step and
- the third is and the mayor's need to understand the local and political context which I think they are quite
- adapted so if if let's take an example in San Francisco a few years ago they implemented a dynamic pricing for their
- parking system la is implementing a similar system called la Park but this expansive and expensive in Street
- sensors Garage sensors smart meters and all of the technologies that are required to dynamically calculate the
- pricing for the parking isn't suitable for smaller cities smaller cities can do by using data transaction data that they
- collect as well as some manual surveys that they could do quite occasionally and so it is really important for mayors
- to understand the local and political context instead of getting excited and trying to figure out these solutions
- work somewhere else can i replicate it in my city so those are the three steps I would say that the mayor's need to
- consider but also balance the resources that are available to them between serving the citizens and
- addressing some critical challenges and driving economic growth I'm glad you brought up the challenges that mayor's
- face because one of the biggest challenges that many of them seem to be facing these days is how to handle the
- influx of new people that could either be immigrants coming from other countries or it could be just an influx
- of people from the hinterlands the rural areas into the cities do you have any thoughts on how mayors and other civic
- leaders can deal with these challenges in a smart and also an inclusive and compassionate manner absolutely let's
- look at some data if we look at places like Asia Africa and Latin America every hour of every single day nearly 1,000
- people are moving from the rural areas to urban areas if this were to continue we would have to build a city as large
- as London one every month for the next 33 years so this is what is causing the rapid urbanization phenomena that many
- of them are talking about and it puts a lot of pressure as you and I know on the
- city's limited and scarce resources but there is one other critical issue at play that many of us are overlooking
- which is the growing disparity gap across the various regions of a nation so if you look at the u.s. here the
- bigger communities today are growing at a much faster pace and they're also contributing overall to the nation's
- growth more than ever before and these bigger communities are being powered by well-educated Millennials and the
- agglomeration of trends caused by digital technologies right and these are happening as some of the smaller metros
- wayne and the rural areas are sliding into deep decline and if you just look at the
- u.s. in the last couple of years more than half of the jobs that have been created because of the digital
- technologies have gone to the bigger metros the top 20 metros here in u.s. which is only home to one-third of the
- American population with the usual suspects of New York Boston the bay area Seattle Washington DC followed by the
- Sun Belt hubs of Atlanta Dallas Miami and Orlando so in this context the mayors have two key imperatives number
- one make regionally balanced growth a priority it's not a very difficult task to do it is just that the leaders have
- to consciously say that I'm going to drive economic cohesion and it's not a novel idea either because if you look
- across the pond the european union said that i'm going to allocate one-third of my budget between 2014 and 2020 to the
- cohesion policy a program that will allow some of the lagging regions to catch up so that should be a key
- imperative for the mayors the second is make rescaling a priority there has been
- a lot of talk about machine learning artificial intelligence robotics and automation getting to the factory floors
- the jobs of tomorrow will not be the same as jobs of today or yesterday even the white-collar jobs will get disrupted
- if you go and look at the historical data one thing is certain whenever the public sector investment is
- directed towards the human capital that has always led to prosperity right in three decades following 1910 you has
- spent a lot of its funds public sector funds in educating the citizens so the high school graduation rate in that
- period went from 17% or 18% to 73% and the graduation rate went from 9% to 51% it's an amazing growth in just a
- very short period of time so what does what did that mean it meant that for us the citizens were
- highly educated and their income was substantially higher in comparison to the counterparts some of the other
- industrialized countries at that period of time in my view if we can do it then we should be able to do it now
- particularly given access to many of the digital tools that we have at our disposal
- you mentioned digital tools and one of the of course digital technologies spreading everywhere
- and one of the effects of digitalization is that it throws up vast amounts of data and I was wondering if you could
- speak a little bit about how data analytics and collaborative data sharing can enables smarter decision-making
- about you know cities so data is by far the most valuable asset nowadays that private enterprises have as well as
- public sector has so whether you are driving through a traffic light or paying a utility bill or browsing a
- city's website or calling a city department or even dumping garbage into your neighborhood dumpster the city
- collects so much of data about you if the data is mined properly then the city can use that of course to serve the
- needs of the citizens better at they can even anticipate the needs of the citizen
- so if the city were to mined this data and develop a platform there or face sees that the report talks about let me
- see if I can outline those five for our listeners number one the first see is all about collaboration that we talked
- about across the various departments of a city I think we spoke about an example
- of water management and traffic management and how they are interrelated so that is the first C collaboration
- across the department's of city the second is how do you use the platform to effectively serve the needs
- of the citizens so the second C stands for the citizens so using that unified platform
- how can a citizen such as you and me either pay a bill or get a license for starting a business and this would
- require collaboration as we can imagine across several departments of the city itself the third C is about the colleges
- and the university systems so how do you collaborate with them effectively in order for you to tap into the local
- talent and the fourth C is communities a neighborhood how do I use the platform to effectively serve the needs of a
- community neighborhood provide them information related to their neighborhood maybe it is related to
- safety it is related to health about that particular community and the fifth season' tech space how do you open up
- your platform publish api's that the companies can use the private sector can use in order to develop new applications
- tools in support of your smart city agenda so those are the five C's but when it comes to data Michael I'm
- certain you and I will say that before city starts to collect your data and use it they have to get explicit permission
- from the citizens write an explicit opt-in is absolutely needed not just that the city needs to explain to the
- citizens how they plan to use that data in simple terms instead of throwing a 25
- page document at us and in the end cities need to be responsible guardians of citizens data I I agree we couldn't
- agree with you more about the need for privacy and actually I wanted the next question I have I use about a sixth C
- and that is cost obviously you have a lot of expenses involved with cities trying to become smarter which brings up
- the need for how do these initiatives get funded and how do you get the costs covered and I was wondering if you could
- talk a little bit about the different financing models that cities have used to to fund some of these smart city
- initiatives and what are some of the pros and cons you're absolutely right moving the cost and funding is by far
- the biggest challenge when it comes to funding any smart city initiatives so of course you know federal grant is an
- option philanthropic grant which is the knight foundation as an example funded some of the smart city roadmap study
- that the city of Philadelphia didn't publish last month as we all know but these grants are not sufficient if you
- are looking at a citywide smart city program there are other couple of other options that have been toyed around one
- is possibility for possibly increase taxes and thereby increase the revenues of the city to fund some of these
- programs but most of us may not be in favor of getting our taxes increased the second option is how do you as we just
- discuss the city has accessed so much of our data can they sell it can they monetize the data I'm not actually in
- favor of that option until we understand that there are adequate privacy and security measures that are in place by
- the city so that gets us back to an option that is an age old technique but it has been improvised recently it is
- public-private partnerships the way it has evolved lately is there is also the repayment model that has been built into
- this partnership now let's look at a couple of examples one that comes to mind is Kansas City with its citywide
- IOT effort and the municipality in this particular case funded approximately 3.7
- million the private partners they for about twelve point three million so brought the total to about sixteen
- million the city used sixteen million dollars to install twenty five kiosks around the city and the kiosks provided
- free internet access to the citizens as they are getting out and about in the city through which they can also access
- city related information the city also uses these kiosks as emergency alert system now the revenue model for this
- comes through advertising on these kiosks and the initial calculation has shown that both the city as well as the
- private partners that funded this initiative will be able to recoup most of their costs in less than five years
- which is pretty impressive right the second example is Portland Portland Oregon and the initiative
- however is a pilot instead of a full-fledged smart city program like in the case of cancers so the city could
- pretty much live with the federal grant for this pilot where they are using IOT related sensors that go on top of the
- traffic signals as well as many of the light poles in the city the objective of this project is for them to figure out
- how they can improve some of the stalled traffic they can reduce stall traffic in
- these major intersections of the city thereby improving the air quality so that's the pilot scope and if it goes
- well they want to figure out how to get the funding for the entire city itself so the initial funding came from NIS T
- National Institute of Standards and Technology and all of the sensors that are needed for the major intersection
- were provided by the private partners so those are the funding approaches that the cities have looked at but
- predominantly it has been the public-private partnerships with clear repayment models so once the funding has
- been raised what are some of the best practices and the way the funds can be allocated
- across different priorities that the city says McCool you're absolutely right funding is by far the most challenging
- thing for the mayor's to continue it when it comes to smart city programs but there are three ways at least that they
- should consider before they go about spending the money number one which is pretty much a no-brainer which is to say
- pick programs that give the maximum bang for the buck or the greatest return on investment let's take a example and if
- you take a city approximately depending on the size of the city you will find nearly ten thousand to three hundred
- thousand lights and this is in my opinion a very valuable part of the infrastructure because it already has
- power supply built into them it said at an elevation of nearly 30 feet so imagine if we put some sensors on top of
- these light poles they can be used to monitor foot traffic based on that determine when to turn on the lights and
- turn off the lights it can also be used to monitor the traffic detect crimes so with just a few sensors on each of the
- light poles the city can achieve at least three things increase the safety and security of the citizens east
- congestion traffic condition and the third thing that they can do is save energy costs for the city so that is a
- project that would provide a maximum bang for the buck a good ROI so choose projects that give a good bang for the
- buck the second one I would say is before spending the money think through any of the regulatory changes that are
- needed as an example Columbus Ohio plans to roll out electric vehicles and autonomous vehicles the question
- that the city has to ask is how do they work in the context of the existing infrastructure what regular regulatory
- changes have to be made so that is the second aspect to consider the third one that the cities should consider in my
- view is the procurement process itself how do I streamline procurement if funding is the most difficult thing to
- do the second most is the procurement processes in the city they are pretty long they're also quite laborious so
- there are a couple of approaches that have been proposed in order to ease the procurement process number one consider
- cooperative procurement as an example if there is another city that is already working with that vendor see if you can
- piggyback on that contract the second is consider driving the initiative at a state level as an
- example in January 2017 the state of Illinois the department of transportation in the state of illinois
- launched an RFP for smart street lighting across the state now once that RFP is awarded the cities can use that
- existing contract instead of having to negotiate the terms and conditions on an individual basis so those are the three
- things to consider before the cities start to spend the money no cities at the u.s. do you think have done a good
- job of implementing smart city initiatives I know you referred to a few names early on a conversation but if
- specially if you think like challenge and like climate change which cities do you think are doing a good job and what
- kind of the cities learn from the example yeah so there are quite a few cities in u.s. that have been that have
- driven several initiatives that are smart that are sustainable and there are some that are tackling climate changes
- well let's take a few examples in each of these areas two cities that I to talk about one is Atlanta Atlanta and
- another is Orlando in the case of Atlanta the reason I'm biased towards Atlanta is
- because I met the chief operating officer of Atlanta the previous one then Gordon a few years ago and he had this
- clear vision on what he wanted to do for the city and thanks to him and thanks to
- the former mayor Kasim Reed they put together several smart city initiatives in the areas of transportation safety I
- would say also communication with not just citizens but also the businesses so there were several such initiatives and
- Atlanta plans to use what they call as the short spotter IOT acoustic technology in order to
- reduce the while violence in the cities due to guns and this particular technology will help them to dispatch
- the officers to the crime scene in real-time without anyone having to call 9-1-1 so that's that's a cool example
- isn't it atlanta also plans to install solar panels and many of the large buildings in the downtown area and that
- would be towards their sustainability initiative to be used to increase their renewable energy capacity as as well as
- reduce energy waste staged as well as greenhouse greenhouse gas emissions as well
- orlando is quite quite an interesting city Mukul as we all know right i mean with the disney world and it has about
- 75 million visitors every year and the mayor says that it has the highest hotel and car rental rates in the entire world
- and the director of the smart city program says that his city gets people with all sorts of driving habits and and
- what are the things he says is you know you don't need x-- of Technology even some simple fixes
- could go a very long way when it comes to making the city smart and he gives an example of this mobile parking alert
- systems that the city has developed and there was a lot of resistance I believe initially because the city officials
- would worried that revenue coming out of the fines parking fines would go down it
- did however what the city saw was increase in revenues because it allowed people to pay for the parking through
- their mobile devices and of course both the citizens and visitors were happy and
- because they could avoid fines as an example Orlando is also a city quite unique because it's the only city in
- Florida that has passed an ordinance saying that all of its public buildings will publish both their energy and water
- consumption and the City of Orlando also has committed to ensuring that all the buildings will use renewable energy 100
- percent renewable energy by 2050 and what is even interesting is that the municipal operation will transition to
- renewable in another decade which is by before end of 2030 so those are some of the examples of cities that are not just
- focused on infrastructure but they are also focused on citizens and sustainability and to your question on
- climate change and are there any cities that are tackling climate change I think
- Atlanta with the solar panels is of course an example San Francisco recently received an award for its zero waste
- program that it launched in 2002 since the program was launched it has an incredibly incredible reduction in the
- error in the landfill rates diversion rates of about 80 percent San Francisco also every uses 100 million
- fewer plastic bags so with many of these initiatives I think San Fran San Francisco is well on
- its way to achieve the zero waste goal by 2012 actually 2019 end of this year I see just a couple of last things to wrap
- up you referred earlier to public-private partnerships being so critical I was wondering if you have any examples
- of cities that are doing a good job working with the talent in the companies in the in in in in their geographic
- boundaries so as to enhance the impact of their smart city initiatives are there any examples of that kind that you
- you can think of and what can companies learn truck cities and companies learn from those in
- yes absolutely local I think collaboration with the private enterprises and the University's
- academic institution is a way by which the cities can tap into local talent one of the new concepts
- thanks to Brookings Institution is this concept of innovation districts think of
- them as geography clusters that brings together academic and scientific research institutions private sector and
- small and big right small entrepreneurial organizations enterprises that are large and then
- public incubators that are focused on doing research and all of these Geographic clusters that are placed in
- amenity rich urban cores mixed use urban cores and simply put these or geographic
- areas that drive the economic development for a particular city there are several example the one that I
- will mention is by Mayor Andy Berke and his initiative in Chattanooga he set up the Chattanooga innovation district that
- has helped the city drive the growth - absolutely the next level it's one of the best places to live in the country
- top hundred places to live nowadays and some of the example of companies that have been successful
- that were built in that innovation district that come to mind is access America transport which was eventually
- bought over by UPS and the same founders also created another startup called the
- lamppost group so these innovation districts are a way for companies to create the clusters to drive economic
- growth but also dry partnership across the various entities in the city one last question Sita and that is will
- focus quite a lot in this conversation on the American experience of making cities smarter I wonder if we could
- compare take a look now cross the pond at Europe and see how does the American approach Rebecca lapping smart cities
- differ from the approach you see in Europe and are there lessons that each continent can learn from the other in
- terms of how to make the world more sustainable and more inclusive and you and I know Mukul that Europe has been at
- this Smart City program and initiatives I would say for some time a little bit longer than us has been in u.s. the
- Smart City programs typically have been tied to infrastructure and economic development and Europe being at it for a
- little bit longer they are now focused on creating citizen-centric initiatives how do I make my cities more livable how
- do I make my cities where the citizens are happy and sustainability is one of the key initiatives that Europe has been
- focused on but I think Europe is also unique in the sense that it has smaller countries then you have the European
- Union so there is a concerted effort between across communities cities and the European Union itself to drive some
- of these smart city programs and and that I think is going to help them achieve their goal of 300 smart cities
- by end of 2020 and so which is an ambush just goal and I think they are on the way to do that but you and I know
- sometimes it is never late or it is sometimes good to be late to a party because then that allows you to learn
- from the lessons that someone else has had so in my opinion I think us can take a lot of lessons from how Europe has
- approached some of the smart city programs but with several of the initiatives across us and the investment
- that the cities are making I sincerely believe that us is well on its way to drive growth across major metros as well
- as the smaller metros as well I want to conclude with this Mukul if I may as we look at some of these programs that are
- happening I believe that it is the responsibility of the leaders in the private and public sector and academic
- institution to collaborate effectively with the city leaders as well as with the communities to figure out how to
- make Digital Inclusion part of the agenda when it comes to smart city programs see that thank you so much for
- speaking with knowledge at word and so here the pleasure speaking with you thank you very much Michael it always is
- a pleasure for more insight from knowledge at Wharton please visit knowledge Wharton
- pen edu [Music]
Brief Summary
Sita Hari Heron discusses the evolution of smart cities, emphasizing citizen-centric approaches, collaboration, and funding models for urban initiatives.
Key points
- The Evolution of Smart Cities. Sita discusses how the definition of smart cities has evolved over decades, focusing on citizen well-being.
- The Role of Data in Smart Cities. Sita explains how data analytics can enable smarter decision-making in urban environments.
- Funding Smart City Initiatives. Sita outlines various funding models for smart city projects, emphasizing public-private partnerships.
- Smart City Funding Challenges. Funding is a major hurdle for mayors trying to implement smart city programs.
- Atlanta's Innovative Safety Measures. Atlanta is using IOT technology to enhance public safety and reduce violence.
- Orlando's Mobile Parking Solutions. Orlando's mobile parking alert system increased revenue and improved user experience.
Episode highlights
- The Evolution of Smart CitiesSita discusses how the definition of smart cities has evolved over decades, focusing on citizen well-being.βI want to create cities that are livable, focusing on the well-being of my citizens.β3:01Apr 22, 2019
- The Role of Data in Smart CitiesSita explains how data analytics can enable smarter decision-making in urban environments.βData is by far the most valuable asset nowadays.β16:40Apr 22, 2019
- Funding Smart City InitiativesSita outlines various funding models for smart city projects, emphasizing public-private partnerships.βPublic-private partnerships with clear repayment models are essential.β24:25Apr 22, 2019
- Smart City Funding ChallengesFunding is a major hurdle for mayors trying to implement smart city programs.βFunding is by far the most challenging thing for the mayors.β24:35Apr 22, 2019
- Atlanta's Innovative Safety MeasuresAtlanta is using IOT technology to enhance public safety and reduce violence.βAtlanta plans to use IOT acoustic technology to reduce violence.β29:43Apr 22, 2019
- Orlando's Mobile Parking SolutionsOrlando's mobile parking alert system increased revenue and improved user experience.βOrlando is unique because itβs the only city in Florida that has passed an ordinance.β31:51Apr 22, 2019
- San Francisco's Zero Waste InitiativeSan Francisco's zero waste program has significantly reduced landfill rates since 2002.βSan Francisco received an award for its zero waste program.β32:49Apr 22, 2019
Tension
40/ 100Low tension





