Wal-Mart India's Raj Jain on Modernizing Supply Chains

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Wal-Mart, the world's largest retailer, finds itself in a curious situation in India. Barred by government restrictions, it cannot directly operate as a retailer. As a result, the company's strategy has been to develop what Raj Jain, Wal-Mart India's president, calls a business-to-business wholesale cash-and-carry operation. In addition, Wal-Mart India is playing a leading role in helping develop modern supply chains in India. In an interview with India Knowledge@Wharton at the recent U.S. India Business Council meeting in Washington, D.C., Jain spoke about Wal-Mart's operations and strategy in India.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. this podcast is brought to you by India knowledge at Wharton please visit knowledge Wharton UPenn dot edu slash
  2. India for more information inclusive growth infrastructure development and collaboration in science
  3. and technology where the major themes discussed at the recent Global Partnership summit organized in
  4. Washington DC by the us-india Business Council business and political leaders from both countries participated in the
  5. event which also marked the u.s. IBC's 33rd anniversary Indian knowledge at Wharton spoke with business leaders at
  6. the event about the challenges they faced doing business in a rapidly globalizing economy our guest today is
  7. rod Jiang president of Walmart India mr. Chen thank you so much for joining us today my pleasure
  8. before you joined Walmart could you tell us about your career at whirlpool and Unilever yes for sure I am an engineer
  9. actually by education and I soon after my engineering I joined Unilever where I worked in both in Europe as well as in
  10. India for 16 years and various assignments and manufacturing logistics supply chain and marketing and then I
  11. moved to whirlpool in the supply chain area and then finally I was the managing director of whirlpool India and then
  12. moved on to a regional role in Shanghai in China and then for last two years I've been working Walmart was based in
  13. Shanghai recently moved to India with a view to run a joint venture in India how
  14. did you move to Walmart come about well having worked for 10 years in whirlpool I was kind of getting a bit tired of
  15. selling appliances and and that industry so I was looking for a change and I got
  16. a call from somebody and they said Walmart was looking for a president of emerging markets to evaluate entry of
  17. Walmart and new countries outside of where Walmart was already present seemed like an interesting challenge I
  18. interviewed and led to this new job Walmart is the world's largest retailer and the number one company on the
  19. fortune 500 but Walmart in India is not really in retail business could you please explain
  20. this curious fact to people who may not know the whole story sure I think it terminates out of you
  21. know the fact that in India currently retailing is a protected sector and the government does not allow any
  22. multinational to operate and retailing so no foreign investment is allowed in retailing other than in wholesaling and
  23. also in 51% in a single brand retail which of course is not a business model so that's why we do not have any
  24. retailing in India what we propose to have in India is wholesale cash and carry business which is only permitted
  25. for business members and then we are also a franchisee soar to a retailing company which is party retail who are
  26. our joint venture partners who will run and own stores but we do provide them with merchandise and management
  27. expertise to do so how exactly would that business to business model work I think the way it works is essentially
  28. India is a nation of retailers if you look at it India has 12 million Khurana stores which you know per capita given
  29. even the population of India is I believe the highest in the world so we have a lot of small mom-and-pop stores
  30. in India catering to all kinds of consumers these Kirana stores traditionally buy from wholesale markets
  31. and some of them are also serviced by directly by manufacturers in fact India has one of the most evolved distribution
  32. systems by big companies so companies like Unilever for instance and ITC have probably one of the most evolved
  33. distribution systems in India and they service just close to a million of those 12 million Kirana stores directly which
  34. basically means that you know 90% of Khurana stores actually have to go to wholesale markets to buy products and
  35. there is a very evolved wholesale network in India for products which these Khurana stores get serviced from
  36. it is a low-cost operation but it is also very inefficient and especially when you move to
  37. to produce areas fresh merchandise fruits and vegetables meat and so on and so forth
  38. it is very uninvolved and it is very archaic in many ways so how this model works is essentially that you have a
  39. selling point where you directly source products from manufacturers and then sell it sell those products to karana
  40. stores at you know great prices all under one roof Walmart's success around the world has been driven by your
  41. effective use of information technology and supply chain management techniques that is basically what allows Walmart to
  42. pass along low costs to its customers in the context that you just described how
  43. would you apply those principles yeah I'm in Walmart's mission a worldwide and I think which is extremely relevant to
  44. all emerging markets let alone the United States itself it's saving people money so that they can live better and
  45. therefore the whole Walmart business revolves around you know running a very efficient supply chain saving every
  46. aspirin in every aspect of that supply chain so it's not just about negotiating better prices with consumer with the
  47. suppliers it is actually about working with suppliers to remove any inefficiencies in the supply chain and
  48. that is exactly what we will do and are doing in India we are working with suppliers on packaging they're working
  49. with suppliers on stock control we are working suppliers and better management and inventory and so on and all those
  50. savings which come out of that effective management of supply chain would be passed on to our katana stores who will
  51. be our customers in this case you have also worked with Walmart in China what are the main differences between working
  52. in India and China India is very unique in fact I've lived in China so maybe I can say it with a little bit more
  53. Liberty that I think the only thing common between India and China is the one billion population and if you really
  54. operate in the two countries I think they're very different consumers they're very different legislations they are a
  55. very different you know level of economic development social infrastructure and government
  56. you know management of the economy so I would say there are lessons yes they always are but the differences in in
  57. China and India are very very unique and India is a very unique market because India is a very evolved wholesale
  58. network over several centuries what are some of the main challenges you face in implementing supply chain strategies in
  59. India I think the biggest challenge to start with is there is no organized supply chain in India and actually we've
  60. been even surprised by some of the the leading manufacturers in India like Unilever Procter and Gamble and some
  61. other big names who are actually welcoming the the arrival of organized supply chains in India and Walmart
  62. pioneering that effort in India because you know because of the lack of that supply chain today there is no
  63. forecasting there is no understanding of how demand is it's largely push based system and so on and so forth so I think
  64. getting that transparency across the supply chain I will be very unique the other thing is there is no refrigerated
  65. Cochin for fresh produce in India so therefore a lot gets wasted by McKenzie's own work which Mackenzie has
  66. done almost 40 percent of fresh produce in India gets wasted from farmland to the time it reaches the consumer and
  67. thirdly because there is non transparency of of consumption the farmer and the small manufacturer is
  68. actually ending up selling to the middlemen who actually then you know may or may not be so transparent about
  69. pricing some of these challenges seem to be big issues that the government should
  70. be tackling rather than an individual company how are you navigating you be around those challenges I think they are
  71. as far as possible working with the government and trying to tackle some of those issues I think the good news is
  72. that government recognizes it is restricted in its ability to invest and do a lot in this area so there is a lot
  73. of public-private partnership possibilities in this area we are working with the government in areas
  74. like training and development government is very keen on promoting training for people who can work in the supply chain
  75. area we are working with the government in the area of setting up large warehousing and distribution
  76. facilities and making land available at reasonable cost to us to be able to do that so there are several initiatives
  77. which we are working with the government the government has also recognized this
  78. as an issue and I think from a taxation standpoint in the recent budget actually
  79. reduced the taxation on Courchesne equipment which will I think go a long way in making some of those investments
  80. possible what is Walmart sourcing strategy for India and how does it differ from that
  81. strategy in China sure I think Walmart's the relationship with India is actually
  82. much older than our recent joint venture and our recent steps in the area of wholesale supply chain we've been over
  83. 10 years in India sourcing products in India largely textiles apparels home products now recently gems in jewelry
  84. and so on we do approximately 400 million dollars worth of sourcing out of India currently and that can grow
  85. several fold as we go forward but once again you know the efforts become magnified several times if there is a
  86. deeper understanding of the supply base and I think with this new effort in this
  87. joint venture about wholesale cash-and-carry we will make deep inroads into small and medium industries and
  88. help develop those industries to a level where they can improve their quality and
  89. and compliance where these products can then be taken on to other parts of the world so I see a very bright future for
  90. sourcing out of India with Walmart over the next decade one of the big problems in sourcing from China was the recent
  91. controversy over lead contamination that affected products like toys do you see any hidden landmines in sourcing from
  92. India that consumers should be concerned about I think the issue of India is once
  93. again developing responsible sourcing points in India and manufacturers in India and as I said earlier you know
  94. developing that responsible base which is compliant to global standards in terms of the kind of labor which is used
  95. the manufacturing practices and finally the quality of the product is critical and as Walmart we spend an enormous
  96. amount of time and energy doing that and it is a slow process it doesn't happen overnight so I think we all we need to
  97. do is to just be patient and work through those processes to ensure that Indian small and medium manufacturers
  98. come to that level having said that there are some very high-quality manufacturers already in in India who
  99. are supplying to us already so we are very pleased with our sourcing operations out of India where will
  100. Walmart India be four to five years from now I think you know we are just setting
  101. up the initial foundation of our our very business in India from from a wholesale cash-and-carry standpoint I
  102. think it's learning about the market learning about the end consumer learning about the trade and you know developing
  103. a team of good leadership and a team of large associates who can make this business work if all goes as per plan I
  104. think in five years from now we should have several cash-and-carry operations in India may not be across India but
  105. certainly in the important geographies in India and we should have a very good understanding of the end consumer of the
  106. trade and we should have a scale from which we can grow very rapidly our submission to the Indian government is
  107. that in this time frame we hope the government would liberalize you know the the FDI regulations in retail and permit
  108. Walmart and companies like Walmart to be able to participate in the retail growth
  109. going forward in thinking back on your career what is the single biggest leadership challenge that you have faced
  110. how did you overcome it and what did you learn from it I think the single biggest
  111. leadership challenge in my experience has been to to craft a vision which is way beyond quarterly goals which is way
  112. beyond financial goals and sometimes leaders get to you know mired into achieving financial targets and so on I
  113. think a compelling vision which is not unique to the business but it's good for the larger society and the customer
  114. which you are serving is important and I think WA important is being staying true
  115. to it because for leaders it is very easy to get derailed into meeting financial
  116. quarterly goals and so on and so forth so if your if your vision is compelling and if you can stay true to it I think
  117. developing a sustainable business becomes that much easier in whatever you do mr. Jane thank you so much for joining
  118. us today thank you very much for the opportunity for more information please visit knowledge Wharton UPenn dot edu
  119. slash India

Brief Summary

Rod Jiang discusses Walmart's business model and challenges in India at the Global Partnership Summit.

Key points

  • Walmart's Unique Position in India. Walmart is the largest retailer globally, yet faces unique challenges in India's protected retail sector.
  • India's Retail Landscape. India boasts 12 million Kirana stores, showcasing a vast network of small retailers.
  • Supply Chain Challenges in India. Walmart faces significant hurdles due to the lack of an organized supply chain in India.
  • Wasted Fresh Produce. A staggering 40% of fresh produce in India is wasted before reaching consumers.
  • Vision Beyond Financial Goals. Crafting a vision that transcends quarterly goals is vital for sustainable leadership.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes