How Analytics Changed Baseball’s Strategy, Storytelling, and Fan Experience
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE In this Wharton Moneyball episode, the hosts talk with acclaimed baseball author Jane Leavy about how analytics have reshaped the game, from strategy to storytelling. They discuss her new book Make Me Commissioner, exploring whether data-driven decisions have made baseball less exciting and what changes could restore its charm. Leavy shares her thoughts on pitching, fan engagement, and how the sport might find balance between tradition and technology.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? The Moneyball podcast explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
#BaseballAnalytics #Sabermetrics #BaseballHistory #SportsAnalytics #SportsData ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Welcome to Wharton Moneyball. This week's show we'll be discussing all things analytics and sports. Um I'm
- Professor Audi Winer from the Wharton Schools Department of Statistics, Data Science, and I'm joined as usually with
- by Eric Bradlo, professor of marketing and statistics, Shane Jensen, professor of statistics, and hopefully we'll be
- joined by Cade Massie, um who is our regular host, and he's trying to come in right now. Um, and our show usually is
- in two parts. And we're going to begin with our interview. And we are delighted to welcome to our show, uh, Jane Levy.
- >> Levy. >> Jane Levy. Am I pronouncing it? >> It's Levy. There we go. I made an error
- at the right off the bat. Um, that's because I I I read your book, so I don't get to hear it pronounced properly. Um,
- so I'll give her a short bio about Jane. Jane is definitely um a baseball writer
- that I am well aware of, having read some of her previous books. I think I read three of the four previous ones,
- including The Big Fellow about Babe Ruth, um The Last Boy about Mickey Mantel and The End of America's
- Childhood, a story um that that's about Mickey Mantel and then Sandy Kofax, A Lefty's Legacy. Those are, you know,
- three amazing baseball players that were heroes to me my whole life and I read those three biographies. But most
- recently, um she has written the book, um Make Me Commissioner, I Know What's Wrong with Baseball and How to Fix It.
- um which is just relatively recent recently released and I I went and got it almost right away and just devoured
- it um because these are topics that we have thought about greatly on our show Moneyball. We've talked about what's
- ailing baseball and analytics is something that runs um substantially in your as a theme throughout your book
- although not positively. Um, so we're in some sense bringing you into our our our
- layer here to see what you have to say about >> Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait,
- wait. I >> I do say somewhere in there, you know, they're here to stay. They're not going
- away. The information is too good, too valuable, too irrefutable to get rid of, you know.
- >> Absolutely. Yes, you do. >> I do say all of that. What I also argue is that in ways that I don't think
- anybody has stopped to consider hereto for um they've what's the polite word destroyed the
- narratives that baseball used to be able to tell because they've so reoriented the priorities of the game and how it's
- played. So, you know, and I think that is part of the reason that fans have gone elsewhere for excitement. The fact
- of the matter is baseball's really exciting if you know what to look for. And if it isn't all three true outcomes,
- I couldn't believe I actually agreed with something Alex Rodriguez said when he's he said, "Home runs are boring."
- Yes, they're boring unless somebody brings them. the irony of that guy saying that by the way.
- >> Yeah. A guy who who has more than >> the guy who used it to hit a lot of home
- runs. >> So uh let's talk about this for a moment. Um so one of the things that this I think that's a good place to get
- started. I will say that you know all of us are deeply invested in analytics but
- we don't work for baseball teams and I don't think we individually are responsible for that. And in fact I have
- a lot of criticisms of the way analytics is used in baseball um because I think they miss the point in a lot of areas.
- But I just want to separate two aspects of analytics after reading your book. Um
- there's that I think our readers also deserve to understand the distinction. There's the techn technology side of
- analytics which has really changed the game. This is the the technologies all the bat path research the high-speed
- cameras the training programs that have made the pitchers so commonly hitting 100 miles per hour. Um and that's
- impacting baseball I think more prominently than maybe any other sport. And then there's the analytic side,
- which is the strategy, the the player placement, the approaches, um, and of course the def the LA the big changes in
- the game, getting rid of bunting, the lowering of stealing, the defensive shifts, all these things. And of course,
- and it's affected, of course, evaluation. That's really what Moneyball was all about. How analytics has
- affected evaluation. So, let's take you through this um and and talk about how these things have affected baseball in
- your in your view. Well, I mean, I think it's killing it. I mean, and I don't mean that because I
- hate all Look, first of all, I can't add, multiply, subtract, or divide. Got a 320 on my math GRE when they still
- used to take it out of, you know, 800 points. So, for me to have spent this much time trying to understand the math
- and following people around going, I have no idea what they're talking about. If I can't make it clear to readers, you
- know, it's the same issue as the analytics dudes in the baseball ops office trying to talk to players who
- have no idea what they're talking about and can't follow it. So, um I I I this is very idiosyncratic of me and and you
- know, maybe I'm wrong, but um there's a chapter a very long chapter in the middle of it um that's uh located at a
- beautiful maybe the most beautiful baseball field in America called Eldridge Park in Cape Cod where there
- are no seats. You just sit on the on a hillside and um volunteers come and bring their grills and make hot dogs,
- right? Um, it's it's everything that one would suppose baseball should be or was
- once. My kids used to be able to go out on that field between innings and catch fireflies and nobody was upset like, "Oh
- my god, what are they going to do to that gazillion dollar turf?" Um, so there is this idyllic portion of what
- baseball is thought to be, which I certainly have witnessed. But even that idol is has been significantly changed
- not just by analytics but p you know largely by analytics. I mean I said to the manager one day I you know MLB had
- gotten rid of the shift and he's still playing the shift. I said Kelly why what you you called what did the shift on? He
- goes yeah I want to win. Okay I get it. Um but what it's done in my view um and I think the most
- destructive part is the pitching. Um you know the the 100 mph um max heave style
- of pitching is not only dangerous for the guys who are doing it a percentage of whom have had double surgeries like
- Otani. I was about to write a piece that said Otani shouldn't pitch for the Los Angeles Dodgers. You know how many
- pictures they used this year? One of you probably knows. >> No. >> How many? Oh my god. They probably used
- over 20, I would guess. >> 47. >> 47. Oh my god. >> How many How many pitchers did they use
- in 19 in 1963 World Series? >> Seven. Probably >> four. >> Four. >> Areronowski had to come in relief of um
- Audrey. So um that in a nutshell is the difference between now and then. And I would argue that as an entertainment,
- it was a better game then. And virtually every old player thinks so. Um it it has been so con compacted,
- contracted, whatever, because of the three true outcomes, the same things happen over and over and over again. And
- when you get a guy like Jacob Young, the outfielder, um the gymnast for the Nationals, the only good thing any of
- them did all year, uh where he went to City Field and he brought a home run back over from center field and the ball
- drops out of his glove as he's coming back down to earth, right? And so what does he do? He kicks it and he kicks it
- into his glove and he makes the out and then he throws in. Great throat and and it's it's that's what's missing in
- baseball. It's you know Mookie bets with the wheel calling the wheel play because he didn't
- have a card index card in his hat. He was allowed to think use his instincts and his body the way he has been trained
- to use them. >> So Shane you have a you have a question? Well, so I mean I I guess my main kind
- of thought as I'm listening to this is um kind of like what would you kind of tang because I mean as you sort of said
- analytics are here to stay and it's not you I agree pitching has the the pitching as a narrative story story
- pitching has become more dehumanized I guess by our kind of conquest or or our our desire for efficiency.
- We've discovered that it's best to just have a whole slob of pitchers pitch two inn two times through the order and
- throw 100 miles an hour. But aside from I mean I I also lament kind of that going downhill but operation like act in
- terms of actionable recommendations are you kind of would you argue for like a rule change by baseball or I mean
- because teams you know teams aren't going to a subset of teams are always going to seek out that efficient uh that
- kind of efficiency. Um, yeah, I think they have to make and it's in pitching changes that that that I
- would make are are in the book, which apparently you haven't read. So, uh, >> I have I think the pitching staff,
- >> this is an opportunity to tell our listeners about it. >> Is I think the pitching staff needs to
- be completely reconfigured. They don't have enough arms. one um you know sitting in in a dugout with u Buck
- Shoalter or even Kevin Cash or you know um or Dusty and then they're trying to piece together okay where can I get
- another you know seven outs from now I can't ask him you know his arm's falling off no I can't ask him you know there
- forget strategy forget matchups it's just who can still lift their arm so they need more they need more arms and I
- could propose an NHL style healthy scratch list. Why should your number of pitchers, your 13 as it now is, include
- yesterday's starting or today's starting pitcher? You're not going to use them, right? I mean,
- >> wouldn't this Sorry, sorry to interrupt, but wouldn't this lead to more more like
- I thought we want, you know, I mean, in yesterday, you didn't have very many pitchers and you had to stretch them out
- and have these kind of like, you know, wouldn't that even more pitchers lead more starters or less starting
- >> impatient boys? one, you have three guys or maybe even four on this healthy scratch list who
- are, you know, the guys who are who are literally falling apart plus the plus the uh yesterday's starter. At the same
- time, you're you're a manager is allowed to pick only 11 of the his 15 or 16 pitchers, whichever we end up with, um
- to use on a given day. And he would base that on the opposition. He would base it
- on the health of his own pitchers, you know, and he would base it on analytics. Pick pick what which ones, you know, are
- in shape and which ones get which guys out best and that and nudge the game back towards having people go longer.
- There's a whole bunch of other rules in there um including um can't >> So Jay, I'm gonna I'm gonna just uh
- quickly comment. You did report that Theo Epstein in the book had recommended lowering the number of pitchers.
- >> He's for 11 >> to 11. The thinking that I my understanding of that the thinking of
- that is that if you only have 11 pitchers on your roster, >> your pitchers can't overburden their arm
- because they know they have to pitch many more innings. And the problem we have now is pitchers starting pitchers
- are going five innings and they know they're going five. And we know that and then or maybe six and that they they
- they overthrow and as a result you need 13 pitches to to to dominate. So you're actually proposing something that's like
- almost a hybrid where you you only have 11. >> What I'm saying is look, you know, the
- relievers drop like flies, right? >> Yes. They're just they're not that good actually.
- >> They're not that good and they can only do one thing and and they're they're they're fungeible. One guy is the same
- as the next. And I have to say as a person of literature narrative, you know, the fact that you don't know, you
- know, who the guy is who's being called in, you might as well not have any numbers on their backs because they're
- all the same, right? You know, did was the game better when we had people like Mariano Rivera? I think so. I think it
- was more interesting. So yes, we have to nudge in whatever is the most healthy way starting pitching back to being like
- starting pitching. You may have noticed that Dave Roberts, famous for having hauled Clayton Kershaw, Rich Hill, and
- Tony Gonelin out of perfect games or no hitters. Um and there's there's another guy he pulled out strippling, right? um
- you know, let two pitchers go a complete game and Blake Snell eight innings. Why?
- Cuz all of his relief pitchers are dead. So, you know, the they have to start training them the way that old pitchers
- were trained. There's a reason that, you know, the Atlanta Braves back in the 90s, aside from that they weren't
- throwing Maxa 100 miles an hour, had the same pitchers on opening day roster and
- the end of the season roster. They didn't they were trained to throw more often,
- less hard. >> In fact, we we've had uh uh John Smoltz on the show telling us exactly that.
- Eric? >> Yeah. So Jane, um, just so you know, I'm a consider myself a baseball historian.
- Just so you know, I go to the Hall of Fame every year for my, uh, for the induction ceremony. So I love the
- history of baseball. >> Masel. >> Yeah. No, I I I it's the greatest gift ever given to me as a lifetime
- membership to the National Baseball Hall of Fame. Um, my question to you was, um,
- I'll throw on a slight business school hat here. Um, if what you're saying is true, then owners like making money,
- why doesn't an owner, just takes one to say, "Look, we're not going to run the game in its boring way." Now, we're
- going to go back to the days where pitchers pitch longer. We're going to go back to the days where, as I always said
- to my kids, I've never, this is true. I' I've been to a thousand baseball games and I've never left one early, Jane,
- because you never know what you're going to see in baseball. Never. ever. But >> but now today you might know more often.
- >> Yeah. So why don't this is my point. Why doesn't somebody break the mold go back
- to the old days if you think by the way by the way that would include by the way
- three-hour games which appears most fans don't want now. Why doesn't do that? >> Not necessarily. And I think you're
- starting to see that happening you know out of desperation not out of brilliance. I mean, this postseason,
- you're seeing pitchers, starting pitchers go much longer. And you know, the ESPN guys, the day that I'm going to
- mess this up, Schlitler um went was sent back out to the to the mount at Yankee Stadium and for the eighth inning, there
- was a roar and it wasn't for what he had already done. It was for that he was being allowed to do what he could do.
- And that's the thing. I mean, the the the best story I can tell you, the funniest, you all must know Bill the
- Spaceman, Lee, who's my um new boyfriend. Um and um that's hyperbolic. Uh >> I was like, okay,
- >> I mean, might as well talk, I guess, is what we'd say at that point, right? >> But the day that uh that Dave Roberts
- pulled Kershaw out of his perfect game, and it was April 2022, he hadn't pitched
- much. his arm had been injured the, you know, the end of 2021, but he's mowing them down. His pitch count is 85, right?
- And he yanks him out. Spaceman calls me in tears. I I mean, I'm not being Now, I'm not being
- hyperbolic. And I said, "Spaceman, why are you crying?" And he said, "Because the guy didn't get a chance to find out
- how good he could be." And that's what's missing now. Too often it's shortcircuited.
- >> Let me say, Jane, just one thing. The way we talk as statisticants on the show, every pitcher has good days and
- bad days. You'd agree with that? There's a and there's also heterogeneity. Some pitchers are just better than others.
- But when you get a guy like Kershaw, who's one of the greatest of all times, and he's having a good day, there's no
- rational reason to take him out. you have evidence that you got the good Kershaw on that day and he's pitching
- well on that day. We talk about that all the time that why would you bring in a reliever who is some random person who
- may be having a bad day when you know the pitcher you have out there is happens to be on one of his good days.
- We talk about this all the time. >> I'm I'm just going to follow that up before I turn it to you, Jane, because I
- actually think that the analy analytics are getting it wrong. There are two questions that are analytical in nature
- that they pretend to have an answer to. One is somehow that pulling a pitcher after the sixth inning or the seventh
- inning with a low pitch count is saving them for future injur in injury. There is any data that suggests that works.
- This magic 100 I mean what they did to uh um >> James Andrews and I don't it's not datab based. I mean
- what they did to um the Nationals star pitcher um Straber, right? and they pulled him at after
- in the middle of early September um for some reason >> late late August. But Mike Rizzo did
- that with a a thing this big that I that he lent to me and I ran through it of every pitcher had had Tommy John surgery
- up to that time which was two August 2012 and where they hit the wall in their first season after Tommy John and
- it was at 160 innings almost unanimously 160 innings. >> I'd love to see that study and I don't
- think it is a study. It's a private analysis that Mike Rizzo did. But we one of the things that we also point out is
- that um and this is what Eric was getting at is when you bring in five relievers in a game, you're bound to run
- into one who's having a really bad day. And so it's really upsetting to see a starter who's doing having a great day
- be pulled in favor of a likelihood of of one of the five relievers that are coming in just blowing it. And as a
- Yankee fan throughout the season, as Eric will know, how many games did did Boone blow by bringing in five
- relievers? And I'm only gonna I'm only going to counterargue here because, you know, again, the the kind of
- counterfactual that we don't get to observe is what the starter would have done if they hadn't been pulled. And a
- lot of these decisions, and I'm not arguing that they I think again I I I I I I I dream of the days when starters go
- longer, but I think a lot of these decisions are based on like a particular like their third time through the order
- and we all know there's analytics on that like you know it's their third time through the order or there's a specific
- matchup coming up and manag I do think in our analytic heavy days managers are very quick to pull that starter but
- usually it's not necessarily just a straightup pitch count kind of argument or or or like rationale that's going
- into these decisions. >> How do you know that? >> Well, just based on what they say after
- the game when asked why they pulled the >> say after the game, >> including that it was the manager.
- >> Sure. >> Whose decision is it? >> All those decisions are made pregame by baseball ops guys.
- >> I mean, at certain teams that's certainly the case, but I mean that's not I think
- >> the Yankees. >> Well, yeah, we know. Yeah, the Yankees are a case but but but very analyt
- this style of pitching has so corrupted the arms so destroyed the arms of the relievers that they're being forced
- without realizing that they're doing the right thing back towards using you know
- starters more and you somebody asked the question why don't they change um there's a professor of economics who
- specializes in entertainment and uh sports economics particularly baseball really guys at Wisconsin lacrosse and I
- said I said the same thing to him why why don't they do something different and he said well there's something
- called path dependence which is an actual thing in economics which means that if you've gone along and invested
- an incredible amount of money in developing a gasg guzzling uh you know catal AC and Escalot or whatever the
- hell it is. Um, and you know, you're paying people and the the the line the, you know, the factory is all set up and
- it's all, you know, and the Japanese come along and produce small cars with lots of um better gas mileage for one
- year. Like what is it 79? Is that when that happened? And you know, you sit and you look at yourself and you go, "Oh, do
- I throw it all out? It's been working for how many decades, right? Do I throw it all out based on one year or even two
- years of evidence? How do I know it's not going to come back to where I am? And baseball was acted like the car
- manufacturers in the United States. And and that's and the same thing is true of
- um the copycat owners and general managers. Somebody is going to do exactly what you're saying. Somebody is
- going to say last year Jim Cot, Paul Molader, Rod Karu went to the twins um spring
- training. You always have, you know, these special adviserss show up and hang out at spring training and they were
- literally put in quarantine. they were not allowed to talk to um any of the current players and uh Korea who you
- know blessedly went back to Houston said within earshot of Jim Cot you know what
- do those have to tell me well let me just say they might have a thing or two to say and this is bigger than baseball
- this is what we're facing in the United States of America today. You know, the the lack of respect for experience that
- is or intelligence that is a kind of intelligence not verified by big data, right? The idea that that seeing games
- over 50 years might have taught you something that you know you can't find in a computer.
- I mean, it's really amazing to me that the only science in this country that is not under duress and having everybody
- fired is data science. I mean, how can you how can you base how can you say, you know, oh, you know,
- Dusty Baker's in uniform for nearly a thousand games, but that doesn't matter. >> So, I mean, so we definitely have heard
- a lot about the analytic side, but one of the things that the title of your book is Make Me Commissioner.
- I would like to hear some of the other suggestions you have to potentially change baseball and make it more return
- to more of its past. Not not going to see that because I think one of the things that that that I didn't really
- get from your book which which is the the rise of the other sports particularly football and their
- eventdriven interest where there's one game a week for just 16 weeks maybe some playoffs.
- It's a completely different phenomenon based on a different time and a different way of engaging. We're never
- going to get football to go away and let baseball go back. So, how do we get baseball to be to capitalize on its
- strengths and fill the void that's created because you have these event games and I think there's a lot to do.
- What would you suggest? >> Um, I'm going to say something I'm not supposed to say, but I'm going to say it
- because I'm really pissed off today at my publisher. The only industry I know that is as badly run, managed,
- publicized, and marketed as baseball is publishing. They don't know who their audience is.
- >> They have no idea how to start to build back a base of of fans. Um, they're just
- stuck where they were. They don't know what to do. So they just keep doing the same thing over.
- >> Yes. >> Shame. >> Just I I mean I >> that baseball has been pretty proactive at least in the last five or six years
- about actually trying to change the game, speeding up speed of play. >> H 23 24 25. Okay. Three years. Thank you.
- >> Okay. Yeah. Yeah. uh over the last few years, baseball has been kind of proactive. I I mean, just in terms of
- like it, you know, it's been inducing more rule changes, >> maybe out of desperation or need uh than
- most other sports I see around. Do you kind of feel like those aren't particularly impactful or, you know,
- just a drop in the bucket? They're not anywhere near the what's needed? >> Well, I don't think it's going to be
- football. I don't think being a 12 billion dollar industry is a terrible thing. But having the difference between
- now and then is all that inventory as you know economists like to talk about both in the number of games and in the
- number of seats is a really bad look. If you went to a game in 19 33 and half the seats were empty at
- Yankee Stadium. You knew that, but you didn't see it. Right? Every game when you when they pan the stands and there's
- nobody there is a really big problem because it says nobody else is going. Why should you? Right. Um they have made
- some serious gains based on improving the pace of the game and the length of the game. Um, but you know, here's that
- that question about the other day where they had the the why why is it okay to let a postseason game go as long as it's
- supposed to without a stupid ghostrunner, but it's not okay in the regular season.
- >> Yeah, I hate the ghost runner. So, like, >> you know, >> yeah, >> and it's analytics has worked to the
- benefit of football and basketball. >> It had. Yes, it had. Your >> sport was a better game because of
- analytics. Yeah, they're they're younger sports, right? And they are able to be uh responsive, you know, dextrous um in
- a way that baseball historically has not. Baseball has its feet stuck in wherever, you know, sand, quicksand,
- whatever it is. They don't respond quickly. They didn't respond in the 70s and 80s to the arrival of of the NFL.
- And I didn't look and go, maybe we need a Pete Rosel. Oh, no. Let's stick with Buoie Cune, rightwing Bible belt.
- >> Let me So, um, one thing, you know, it's clear that that analytics has changed
- baseball for the worse and the other sports are the better, but I will >> more exciting.
- >> The other sports have not because they don't have history, but you I'll just take a quick story and get your reaction
- to it. Um about three years ago, I reconnected with an old friend, one of my very best friends from forever. And
- we used to go to baseball games together as as middle school and early high school. And um we decided to meet at
- Yankee Stadium and like old times, we were going to go get there early and watch batting practice. So we show up
- and guess what? They're not letting anybody in. >> There's gates gates closed and they
- didn't let us in until after all of that was over. And I mean, it seems like the
- most foolish thing on earth that the student that to not and here we're we're old folks trying to relive our
- childhood, but we got drawn into baseball because of interactions with players on the field pregame. And
- they've taken that from us. And that has nothing to do with analytics. >> I agree. And you notice that's one of my
- fixes, right? >> Um is to bring batting practice back. >> Yes. I guess you didn't read it that
- carefully. No, I I wasn't sure you you So, one of the things is that they'll say, and I went and talked to some of my
- to my, you know, former students who work for teams is that the players like to go and work out in the cages
- underneath. They don't like to come up >> who's paying the salary. I mean, there's
- got to be rules that say you cannot go downstairs and be on the traject machine every day
- >> because among other things, you know what? Trac machines don't make mistakes,
- right? How are you going to adjust to that in the real time, right? What what got Otani to remember how to hit? He
- went outside and took batting practice on the field from live batting practice. That was the what changed his trajectory
- this last um you know uh series. Um Dave Roberts is the one who said to me, you know, they flipped the order of batting
- practice. So now if you're if you're if you're once the gates are open, the per the people taking batting practice to
- the extent they do it on the field at all are the visiting team. >> Mhm. >> You can't you can't see your guys,
- right? Um and and there's no requirement, no recognition by the union or any of the players that there is an
- obligation that it's an entertainment business. You know that this is part of your job, guys. and that's out the
- window. And you know, somebody's got to, you know, smack them upside the head. Um, you know,
- >> is that a union issue or is that just an owner can demand it at some point? >> Well, they they'd have to put it in the
- CBA. You know, um, you know, a lot of the things that I've suggested are so simple. Flip the batting practice, let
- people in earlier, open the gates earlier. That's how I became a Mickey Manel fan because my grandmother lived
- two blocks away and I would go down and you know walk around in the ballpark and wait to
- see him hit. And that's you have to let people gain purchase on the game in a way that is different from the handsoff.
- You know, everything's separate. There's gates. There's there's fences. There's locks. There's, you know, all the places
- you can't go as a place as opposed to where you can go. You know what? There are people who can't go to baseball
- games because they can't afford baseball food. You used to be able to bring a sandwich.
- Okay, they're not going to do that because they're rich, greedy bastards. But, okay, why don't you
- >> And in Yankee Stadium, I will say you can bring your own You can bring your sandwich to Yankee Stadium.
- >> Same in Phillies. Um, you can still bring sound [ __ ] ballpark, >> but why not have, you know, they all
- created picnic areas. Why can't that be designated as a place that if you want to bring food from home, bring it. Go
- ahead, advertise it. It's ridiculous. An $18 beer. I mean, unbelievable. Um, I think, okay, I think
- they should let all kids under the age of 10 in free with accompanied by a soap or adult. Um, imagine the public
- relations heist, right? Um, when Rob Manford or myself, my predecessor or me gets up and says, "You know what? We've
- thought about this a lot. We've done a lot of research. We've talked to a lot of people and we really do want more
- people in ballparks and we recognize that it's very expensive to come, you know, and to come more than once with a
- family of four is prohibitive. We get it." Okay. So, here's a list of the things we're going to do to make
- baseball more available to you. And starting with grandma, grandpa, whoever takes a 10-year-old kid to the ballpark,
- the kid gets in free >> for free because baseball has inventory. That is the thing that it has above any
- other. We have lots and lots and lots of games. >> That's the problem. Inventory was okay
- when >> back in the day though, you know, Yankee Stadium wasn't full for Joe. What's
- attendance records are are modern though. The the biggest I mean Dodgers and the Yankees and Red Sox, they're
- they're hitting attendance records. That's way beyond what they used to in back in the day when the games were in
- the daytime and and uh people couldn't get out as easily. Um so it's not I mean I don't think the problem is is big.
- >> Can I can I whoever asked what you know what's going to change it between baseball and football.
- Um, I've done a lot of work in a previous iteration on CTE. Um, when they can diagnose CTE in a 14-year-old, and
- God knows they have it already because they've been banging their heads against each other since they were seven without
- the musculature to support, you know, the head and the neck. Um, people are going to start rethinking putting their
- kids in um in tackle football. And the NFL knows it. And you know how you how they know, you know, they know it
- because they're the ones supporting and building up flag football. They know it's coming. Ball doesn't seem to know
- it's coming. And you know, the the tagline, you know, come back to baseball, the game your kid might
- remember. I mean, get get a little tough. Stop being such [ __ ] I mean, they're just
- unbelievable. They're >> MLB just definitely has his issues as we we've talked about on our show. So, I
- think it's time for us to end our our conversation as we have our first show. Oh, no. We go I we'd love to talk for
- hours. I personally I know Eric and and Shane and Kade we haven't heard from, but um it we we these are these are
- issues that are very dear to our heart. We are guys who've been watching baseball for a very very long time. And
- frankly, I do I'll finish with a comment. Um for someone who has attended basketball and football and hockey um uh
- and baseball games are the only ones regularly attended by families. Um and you don't see that in football and the
- other sports um because there are fewer games and and they're expensive, but baseball is something that families go
- to and and they it's and they enjoy as as a family. They need to capitalize on that to uh to bring back the interest.
- You know what I'd like to know from you guys? It'd be very helpful to me. >> Where do you think analytics has served
- baseball badly? >> Do we have time for one round quick round? You want to go around Kade? We
- haven't heard from you. Kade, you want to tell us? >> Audi's just getting me back for all the
- years when I miss his hand. >> Yeah. Um my position is that analytics analytics is nothing more than
- optimization. >> It's like advancing. It's facilitating optimization. >> Yeah. Efficiency.
- >> So if you don't if you don't I didn't say efficiency. Optimization. So whatever you're trying to optimize,
- maximize this, minimize that, you're going to get more of it if you understand the inputs and outputs
- better. So if you don't like what's happening, don't blame analytics. Change the rules. Which I was what I admire
- about your book. You're like, make me commissioner. I'll change the rules. But I think this whole grrowsing about
- analytics is wildly off base because mostly that's just optimizing subject to the rules. And it turns out that some
- games have rules that are more robust to quick intense optimization. And other games need to adjust the rules. So that
- is slightly defensive, but >> I agree with you and like I said, I I understand that the analytics that that
- third time through the order is harder for a pitcher. I get it. You see a guy more when the leagues were smaller and
- you pitched a guy a guy you faced a guy more often. All that stuff is it's obviously irrefutable.
- But I said to my friend Pekco Pasoy, who is the head of the MIT um analytics lab,
- you know, okay, you guys wrecked baseball, you know, shouldn't you fix it? And so we came up with a handheld
- game that can be played on mom's phone if the kid doesn't have one at a ballpark where you can interact with
- with the players on the field. There was some talk by the bananas that they were
- going to put um QR codes on jerseys um so that you could scan in the previous atbat, you could scan in highlights, you
- could send the guy a question, whatever. They have to speak to kids and a younger
- generation in the language that those kids speak and it ain't ours. That's for sure. what you're talking about, Jane,
- you're talking about changing the fan experience, which I think is really important and the batting practice
- flipping and the opening the gates early. That's that's one way to do that. What Kate is referring to is changing
- the way the game is actually played. >> I understand that. >> And so, but I do think for example,
- making the roster 11 starting pitch starting pitches will will change the parameters and therefore you'll have to
- change the way pitching occurs. Another potential change would be you can't pull
- a starter unless you have a real reason to do so after a certain number of >> That's in the book. I saw that those are
- things in your book, right? And yeah, and these are ways to change the parameters of the game, but you can't
- change the way the batter is swinging, but I do think the an analytics have made some errors. Um, and those errors
- will eventually straighten out. Um, and one of the things is they haven't really
- understood the interaction of players. They tend to add up everybody's contribution in what we call linear
- functional, an additive linear functional. But baseball actually has a lot of interaction. And I think they
- sort of missed that. And so what happens now is you'll have a player who hits 35
- 40 home runs with 70 RBI's. Why? Because there's nobody on base when they hit them. And that requires a mixture which
- they don't think they have quite gotten right. I think it it's telling that you tell us you we learned from you how the
- decisions that that the Yankees make come from the front office. They can't win a playoff series and something's
- going wrong there with their analytic staff and and they haven't diagnosed it. Um so there's an enormous amount we can
- talk about. I think Kad's uh reaction is actually good and and you actually catch
- that in your book because you did speak to Sam Andre Cohen who is one of my close friends and former students who
- told me and many times I've spoken to him is is just that you know you can't make us we're we're going to optimize
- and you can't stop us and don't expect that to happen. If you want things to be different you got to change the
- parameters. >> Sam said that to me exactly. I mean I think the rule that you can't take a a
- pitcher out until or unless he's given up a run in an inning. >> Mhm. Yeah, how about that? You know, you
- can put in extreme measures, you know, now and um that people are going to go, >> you know, and and moderate later. That's
- the problem with baseball is they haven't been willing to get off what they've done forever and and change it.
- So, they just, you know, the said to me, uh probably not supposed to repeat it, you know, the qu there was no
- leadership. It was less a fair. It wasn't that the game wasn't changing. was changing all the time to the to the
- game, you know, we saw up till 2021 when there was 3 minutes and 52 seconds between balls put in play, right? Um it
- was just not change that was guided. There were no tugboats helping steer that boat. And
- that's a big boat to steer, you know. It was it was going to go somewhere. It was
- going to do something. It had to. You know, these guys are bigger and stronger. Are they better baseball
- players? A lot of them are. Not all of them. A lot of them are just bigger and stronger.
- >> Um but it's that they got caught in path dependence. I think Michael's exactly
- right about that. And um I have a whole ton of suggestions in there. I I suggested and somebody was Petco was
- going to do this for me. What if you put up a plexiglass wall um like what surrounds a hockey rink in the outfield
- so that you didn't so sheep home runs didn't go for cheap >> so like a green monster a little higher
- everywhere so you didn't get >> but it but it would be uh but it would be see-through so imagine sitting behind
- that when you know Aaron Judge goes plowing into it right so it would force there to be a outfielders who can
- actually field and throw. And it would would create more doubles and triples, which is what fans say they want and
- which are more exciting than just watching some another behemoth hit the ball over the, you know, two rows into
- the, you know, >> even non-behemoths hit the ball. Anyway, I'd love to I thank you so much for
- joining us. >> I'm Moneyball. We have a second half of our show to do. So, um, it's been a
- pleasure to bring you on to our show, Jane, and for our readers, >> the guys make them buy the book.
- >> Absolutely, Kade. >> That you win the Blue Award of our 11 years on the show. And that's an
- accomplishment. That's fun. Actually, if you don't, you might get beeped out. Actually, back in the day, you wouldn't
- have gotten beeped out, but Dion may have beeped. You're gonna have more beeps than anybody's ever had on this
- show, which we enjoyed. >> We do. I don't like the thing but uh as academics we like to use
- >> writer >> know how I got answers in locker rooms by speaking the way they speak
- >> of course uh anyway we enjoyed having you and we look forward to uh discussing
- I I'd be delighted to talk the all the other books as well which I've read with great uh with great joy. So thank you
- once again Jane. >> So that concludes our >> All right welcome back to the second
- half of Wharton Moneyball which won't be a half. We had an amazing interview with
- Jane Levy uh Levy. I mispronounced her name once. I don't want to do it again. Um author of the new book Make Me
- Commissioner, I Know What's Wrong with Baseball and How to Fix It. She certainly has lots of ideas. Um so uh we
- enjoyed uh listening to them and I'm sure we'll be taking some of them apart uh going forward. Um in fact, maybe we
- can start by asking any of you guys to have any obvious reactions to some of those suggestions um that she brought
- about. I'm not a huge fan of one of the things we didn't talk about was the conservative nature of baseball which
- makes its history really so interesting to us goes back to the 1880s and it's still more or less the same game. You
- really change it you don't have that. I know that's something that I can think about. What do you guys think? I think I
- think baseball just quickly I think baseball should um experiment with stuff and just like we know they're you know
- Shane has been a big fan I think Shane right of the uh electronic umpires you know but that they tested in the minor
- leagues and they're then they're going to bring it up and um I think that's what we should do but I completely agree
- with everything that Cade said is that data science allows for optimization and teams you know people have it's also a
- principle agent problem. You could say, "Boy, it'd be great if the fans enjoyed themselves." Great. And I'll be out of a
- job because my I'm not my team's not winning games and I'm not utilizing my pitchers in a way that's optimizing what
- the rules say I should optimize. And so I liked your thoughts. Look, the question I would have asked her about
- was, you know, you know, Audi, the thing I care about the most is the comparability
- of baseball. And that to me is what's been damaged the most. You can't tell me that a statline from 2025 can be
- directly compared to someone from 1955. And we all want to do that and it's hard
- to do. >> But but hold on. But but that's that's a challenge we have in all sports. And in
- fact, part of our trade is knowing how to do that. Well, right. It's surprising to me that you want one sport to be
- different or that you would >> Well, I think baseball more than most holds on to its history and it has like
- twice the history probably. We don't do that with basketball and football and hockey because we don't we recognize
- it's not doable. >> We era we era adjust and all those >> we do it but we don't do it. We don't
- have the we don't have the the traditional I the straightforward counting stats that are comparable in
- >> like nobody would nobody would try and compare Patrick Mahomes's career to Terry Bradshaw like oh look number
- people do exactly that. That's ex That's exactly an enterprise that some people take.
- >> Well, I I guess you'd have to use You could not use raw numbers to do that comparison.
- >> K. Do you know what the the most number of touchdowns thrown by a quarterback in
- a season is? >> Well, I don't I could >> I do. Of course you do. >> But that's No, no, no. That's my point.
- You know, you know the maximum number of home runs hit in a season. You do. >> I think we probably even know, you know,
- when the last time someone hit 400 in baseball. I think we know each row has the most number of hits in a season at
- two. >> I've got a great to say it maybe. >> Okay. Well, this is this is actually an
- interesting philosophical question. How we prize that >> for in a big one for B.
- >> No, I I was just saying even even baseball has ones like for example, here's one that just recently happened
- like you know yesterday. George Springer that that I I think is is a total but is
- not really comparable over baseball history. George Springer is now tied for third all time in terms of postseason
- home runs. >> I mean players for many years and it was good, >> right? And and the playoffs have
- expanded. Could you like Here's a here's a fun little like exercise. The other five top postseason home run hitters.
- They're almost all recent dudes because playoffs have expanded. playoffs have expanded and that makes it comparable.
- I'm going to throw out one thing about baseball that makes really it's not uh but but baseball is unique among
- professional sports that it is both a team sport and an individual sport. You cannot really genuinely say that about
- the other sports that there's a genuine individual sport component to it. when a
- pitcher >> typical quarterbacks in football. >> Um, yeah, when when a pitcher faces a
- batter, that's a one-on-one and it's uh and and over the course of the season, you get statistics that are highly
- individual. You don't have to worry about offensive linemen and and defensive coordination and schemes and
- that and both basketball and football and hockey that drive those those lack of comparisons because you don't know
- the millu and it matters so much. So I think also partly maybe it is to Jane's point also because there are so many
- baseball games >> like to make the sport I'll call it maybe more interesting we have to be
- able to look backwards look forward compare this person to that person I mean I I think I actually think more
- during baseball games in other words of thinking about the historical relevance or the rarity of what I'm seeing because
- it dramatically is required for me for the entertainment So that's amazing. This is this is
- exactly what I'm curious about is that this is a philosophical question like what do you value in the sport? I would
- have thought I'm not saying it's wrong. It's just like this is eye opening to me. You'd have thought it was like the
- quality of play in front of you in the game, the the an arc of a season and a particular team that accomplishes the
- the Red Sox finally winning the world championship or whatever. And Erica said, "No, no, we value the ability to
- compare across errors. We value the ability to think in these about these individual accomplishments in objective
- term like absolute terms. Absolute terms. That's interesting. I think that's is unique about baseball. I mean
- I wouldn't have known that's true but that's that could be true. >> I think second chain it is funny that
- Eric is basically saying baseball there's so much baseball it gets boring. I need to think about these other things
- in order. No, it discreet nature means that these kind of tabulation events, there's always some kind of unique
- numerical kind of thing happening. I do love that about baseball, but kind of I do think we can all agree that this the
- actual kind of onfield game, you know, we would like to kind of get it to a little bit I I think it's maybe improved
- in the last couple years, but we'd like to get it to away from just as far as the fan experience goes away from this
- three true outcome. Let me ask you about that launch angle. Let me ask let me ask
- about that in a way that connects to an event uh which is last night's game seven that we're recording on Tuesday.
- Game seven in the AL was last night and I I turned it on early. I'm on the East Coast. I don't stay up that late to
- watch baseball. So I went to bed and missed most of the action. But if I'm not mistaken, at least the last few run
- events, like maybe all the Mariners and then obviously the big one for the Jays,
- they were all home runs. So everything was home. Well, that was a multi multi run. There's a lot there was a lot of on
- bait. There was a lot of other stuff happening in the game. >> Right. So that's I mean Right. It's like
- those home runs and those moments that's not that's not boring, right? I mean those were all massive moments.
- >> No, no, it's it's it's more that I think you know like again like a team that can
- do both home runs and kind of generate offense in other ways. I think it's more adaptable for playoffs and we've kind of
- already discussed that with the Yankees on the other side of the the equation. I
- think just again for a fan experience, home runs are very fun, but like it's also like, you know, again that home run
- or nothing kind of, you know, like where there's not even balls in play happening. You know, I I think you kind
- of want, as far as action goes, you want people on base. You don't like a bunch of solo home runs is
- >> controlling for the same amount of offensive output less interesting than other ways of
- >> What do we see? What's the What's the most interesting moment that's happened
- in the playoffs? my claim other than Otani setting aside Otani's best game in the history of baseball setting aside
- which is an individual performance grand slam >> the diamond that would that eventual
- performance was makes it so interesting because they walked away with that game easily. It wasn't it wasn't like a tight
- game. It wasn't a wasn't a Springer home run or an Aaron Judge home run. It was a
- it was wasn't a moment. It was a it was a display of of athletic prowess that of
- the likes we probably have never seen of in baseball. Like I think that's a point8 war for Otani for that game.
- >> Well, that's that that's that's assuming that adds that way. That's not possible.
- >> I mean, I don't think I don't think there's any model base. I think that's just sort of what they
- could do the whole show on Otani and game four. That that could happen. But but I'm asking like the how did the
- Phillies get knocked out? The play the last play of the Phillies season. Look, that was an era.
- It was there's no there's like a very far from home run, very far from the three- tree outcomes. A lot of
- interesting things happening to get to that point. But that was a mess. That was a that was
- there was a walk issued earlier in the game leading to a run that was a very bad call. And people point to that and
- go, "How did he blow that?" >> Kade Kate brings up a very interesting point. I agree with you. despite
- obviously I was rooting for the Phillies. That was a beautiful mess. >> A beautiful mess.
- >> You know what I do love that innings you'll never forget and and um >> more base runners play more bang bang
- kind of events where stuff like that can happen is more compelling baseball. I totally agree with you guys.
- So maybe you know what Kate also pointed out to Jane Levy which I think was appropriate was you know it's clear that
- the right answer if there is a right answer is what people struggle with today when they you know program AI
- engines and AI and Shane know this well >> what is the objective function you you're trying to optimize against and
- it's clear that going back to 1920 baseball that's not that's not happening it's not optimal in any way. 25 baseball
- is not optimal. So the question is what else do you bring in to what you're trying to bring to the game? And then of
- course the other question is how much weight do you put on that? And that's the question.
- >> But but you called it a principal agent problem which in a way it is because the
- teams are going to optimize winning period. And people who want to see more entertainment that's not the team's
- enterprise. The league is the one who cares about entertainment. But the problem with that and that Jane was
- abundantly clear is that the league has basically laid down on the job. And it wasn't until they hired Theo Epstein
- three years ago that they made any substantive change at all, which was the only moment in its in MLB's history that
- they made that change. Listen, we are data analysts. And one of the things that that the NFL has done beautifully
- is bring data to the world. And basketball is now doing that. And baseball is so behind in fan engagement
- um in so many areas. And the and one of the things you talked about was just making the game more accessible to
- people and but that involves leadership. I mean without that it's not going to happen.
- >> Yeah. And I I just want to kind of like I I did feel like the conversation with
- her uh was a little I when we talk about fan experience it was entirely at the ballpark fan experience she was talking
- about, >> right? >> You know like oh like the different hoarder for like you know pregame and oh
- the the beers are too expensive blah blah blah blah type of thing. But like I mean you know most of like I
- mean that's I don't I don't think basketball and NFL have grown because of like at the like I mean I think even
- smaller proportion people actually >> it's not peach baskets. It's not peach baskets. We're not going back to peach
- baskets. That's not why basketball's good. It's like come on. >> Yeah. No it's it's sort of like it's got
- to be something about the actual product and viewing product from like a screen because so you know like so much of the
- growth of any sport these days is how we consume it behind a screen. And so I think it's kind of like I think the pace
- of play changes were really productive in that regard. I I wonder kind of what other sort of like quote unquote fan
- experience changes I mean you can tell me because you read the book more closely like she talked about that
- weren't just about at the ballpark. Well, she did talk about she started to talk about that. She she worked with
- this uh or she had some impact and she wrote about um this uh an app that her students uh that discuss this this
- professor Pico she mentions Hanoi I think her name is um who runs a basically a sports tech lab at MIT um
- and uh and does a lot of I she called it sports analytics but but it's more sports tech. They built an app which um
- allows you to for kids to kind of predict what's going to happen next. it called it's called beat the bot but it
- sounded like they were essentially turning the kids into gamblers with not for money but for prizes. Um it's right
- on the spot >> or just trainers for future algorithms how we do these >> days much more oriented in watching but
- I will say that and this is why I don't think she's wrong about the fan experience. So much of my interest in
- baseball was being brought as a child to a game and engaging with the players on
- the field before the game. not only in batting practice, but I'll never forget getting a signed autograph from a player
- in the stands of my was brought there to sign autographs for the players for sign
- my scorecard and that player was was um Bobby Bonds, father of Barry >> just to give you a sense.
- >> Yeah, I did want to sort of I I I don't We got a little maybe it was just at the
- end, but I do think having Aaron Judge like crash into like a plexiglass >> like uh like like in hockey that would
- definitely change the fan experience. We'd have a lot of shattered >> she was talking about like what what
- Fenway has with its green monster is a really interesting fly balls to the outfield.
- >> Do you as baseball purists I I most Yankee fans I know hate the Green Monster specific not just because of the
- history whatever but because it's like too whackadoo. It's like, you know, like it change like I mean it really changes
- like the geography of a game in Boston. But is that like like would we want to kind of create like are we going to I I
- would worry we kind of create like sort of like too many kind of weird like >> isn't that what the didn't Astros put a
- flag in center field back in the day? >> Like you know you >> and Monument Park used to be on the
- field >> and was on the field had that weird slope up. I don't know if they still
- have that slope up in center. Well, they have changed the dimensions to make it easier to hit home runs and that is
- definitely something that they've done which is working against some some in some level against um itself. We should
- be um promoting the league should be promoting singles and doubles and triples rather than making home runs
- even easier. Um listen guys, we can talk about this forever. We didn't talk about
- any other sports this week. Our our time has come to an end unfortunately. Um and
- we all have places to go. So, I want to um conclude our show by thanking our our
- our actually our guest sound engineer Aaron Tran was in today. Dion is out. Um and of course uh Marissa Rena, our
- producer, our guest Jane Levy, and of course our my colleagues here at Wharton Moneyball. Have a great week everyone.
- Enjoy your statistics, enjoy your sports, and we'll see you at next week. [Music]
Brief Summary
Jane Levy discusses how analytics have negatively impacted baseball and suggests changes to improve the game.
Key points
- Welcome to Wharton Moneyball. The show introduces its focus on analytics and sports.
- Interview with Jane Levy. The hosts welcome baseball writer Jane Levy to discuss her latest book.
- Analytics in Baseball. Jane Levy argues that analytics have changed the narratives of baseball.
- The State of Pitching. Discussion on how analytics have impacted pitching strategies in baseball.
- Reconfiguring Pitching Staffs. Jane Levy proposes changes to how pitching staffs are structured in baseball.
- Analytics and Baseball's Future. A discussion on how analytics have changed baseball for the worse compared to other sports.
Episode highlights
- Interview with Jane LevyThe hosts welcome baseball writer Jane Levy to discuss her latest book.0:32Oct 23, 2025
- Analytics in BaseballJane Levy argues that analytics have changed the narratives of baseball.“They’ve destroyed the narratives that baseball used to be able to tell.”2:17Oct 23, 2025
- The State of PitchingDiscussion on how analytics have impacted pitching strategies in baseball.“The 100 mph max heave style of pitching is dangerous.”6:31Oct 23, 2025
- Reconfiguring Pitching StaffsJane Levy proposes changes to how pitching staffs are structured in baseball.“They need more arms.”10:28Oct 23, 2025
- Analytics and Baseball's FutureA discussion on how analytics have changed baseball for the worse compared to other sports.“Analytics has worked to the benefit of football and basketball.”27:24Oct 23, 2025
- The Importance of Batting PracticeA nostalgic look at how changes in access to batting practice have affected fan engagement.“They’ve taken that from us. And that has nothing to do with analytics.”28:58Oct 23, 2025
- Making Baseball AccessibleSuggestions on how to make baseball more family-friendly and accessible to fans.“Kids under the age of 10 should get in free with an adult.”32:14Oct 23, 2025
- Make Me CommissionerJane Levy discusses her book on fixing baseball, offering innovative suggestions.“She certainly has lots of ideas.”43:01Oct 23, 2025





