Baseball's Smartest Teams Are Winning Differently
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE The teams finding an edge in baseball are not always the ones spending the most.
Mike Petriello, Major League Baseball's Director of Stats and Research, explores how the Milwaukee Brewers and other analytically driven clubs build winning advantages through Statcast data, player development, plate discipline, and smarter hitter-pitcher matchups. He also breaks down Shohei Ohtani's timing issues, the value of swing-path data, and how technology is reshaping postseason preparation.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Welcome, welcome to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics
- here on the Wharton Podcast Network. This is Cade Massey hosting with two of my longtime collaborators.
- Audie Weiner is here from overseas. We think he is, technically he will be sometime in the next hour.
- Eric Bradlow is here from his office, Huntsman Hall, West Philadelphia. We are going to run a usual format
- this week, which is guests in the first half hour, open lines in the second. We are delighted, especially given the time of
- year, we're delighted to welcome a first-time guest. Mike Petriello is with us. Mike is a longtime employee of Major League
- Baseball, 10 years of Major League Baseball. He is the Director of Stats and Research
- there. He is also, I think of him as a host, leading voice on StatCast, the alternative
- ESPN2 broadcast on Major League Baseball's Sunday night show. Mike has been in and around baseball since,
- I gather, since he came out of, I think, Boston University, 20-something years ago, even
- though he's a leading voice for analytics, he's a history undergrad, so it's going to be
- interesting to hear his journey, how he goes from history to where he is now, but
- he's one of these, like a Seth Walder type, I think of him where he's a communicator of analytics, and it's often the non
- -analysts who are most effective at communicating analytics. We're delighted to have you, Mike.
- Thanks for joining. Thank you guys. It's funny you said Seth Walder. He actually lives in my neighborhood and I
- see him pushing his kids around sometimes on the street and we stop and catch each
- other up on football for me and baseball for him, just to see what's going on in each other's world.
- So I like that. That's a, that's a good comparison. That's amazing. Seth's a, Seth's a longtime friend, for sure.
- He's been on the show many times. Mike, thank you for making time for us right now.
- You've got the championship series going on both sides. What is your life like right now?
- Right at this moment, we're two games into the NLCS, one game into ALCS. Give us a window into Mike Petro's life
- at that moment. Yeah, it's a good question. I think I hold down like four different
- jobs at any given point. So it's like people, I think most know me as a writer, but I actually don't
- end up writing that much anymore. Part of it today is everything is so time sensitive.
- I'm trying to write about like, Hey, what's wrong with Shohei Otani? You know, what does the underlying data say
- about why he's kind of looked like such a mess? And at this point in time may or
- may not get benched for game three. We're not sure. So that's been a big part of my
- day. But I am also the project manager of the Baseball Savant team. So everybody, where we come up with the
- cool stats and we put them out on Baseball Savant. So we had our weekly meeting today.
- So that was like a good 90 minutes of catching up with what everybody's status is
- and what they're going to be working on. There's always cool stuff in the pipeline.
- And then it's also sort of both an internal and external resource for where can I
- find this and how should I use it appropriately? So we have a number of obviously beat
- writers on the ground. And for both series, and they're all great, but you know, they don't all come from
- stats backgrounds. So sometimes it's like, Hey, I really want to tell this story.
- How do I find X or whatever? Uh, and not just me. We have a whole research group here.
- We'll do that. But I help with that too. And then, um, just like an hour ago, I started getting text messages from one of
- the broadcasters on one of the series saying, Hey, I want to tell this story. How do I find this stat?
- So it's like, it's great. It's all wonderful. It just, it's not one job anymore.
- It's a lot of different things at the same time. So Mike, can I just follow up with
- your comment on Shohei Otani? Cause I was going to ask about that. Since obviously you guys at baseball and stat
- cast study things like swing speed, swing, plane, launch angle, et cetera, does this allow us,
- you know, the old question, like maybe there are some things going wrong with Shohei, but
- maybe there are others that are just not, and so, you know, we've, we've said the
- outcomes are poor, but are the underlying fundamentals, what is the data? I mean, maybe I'm sure you guys have
- looked at this. What is the data showing there? Yeah, that's a great question. I'm actually writing about this now that'll be
- published on the site at some point. And I think the way to look at it this isn't exactly Otani specific.
- There's kind of three levels of data, right? There's all the public facing data, what people
- can find on baseball, savant and fang graphs and all this kind of stuff. There's some amount of internal data that I
- have access to that we can't put out publicly. And then there's also what the teams have.
- And I, even I have no idea. I mean, I have a rough idea of what it is, but I can't get to
- it. Right. I'm certainly not, you know, taking Otani into the batting cage myself and putting sensors on
- his body and see how he's moving. Whatever, all the stuff the teams do, they keep that very close to the vest.
- As you can imagine, specific to Otani. Uh, it's funny. I'm obviously the data guy.
- It's just looked bad. Right. And so I want to say, well, why does it look bad? Why does maybe the most talented player who
- ever lived, uh, look this bad. We have some anecdotal evidence, obviously that he's
- been injured. He's probably not fully healthy. I'm not a doctor, obviously. Uh, but you know, that's a good starting
- point. We know he missed time. We know it wasn't great in September. Anyway, what the data said, uh, is that
- he's late. He's late on everything. His timing is off. I expected to find that his bat speed
- is down and that's not actually true. That was a surprising finding to me, because
- one of the things that I'll have in this article is, um, if you just look at fastball velocity over 95 miles an hour
- through the middle of August, like his, his last home run was on August 18th through
- that point. Uh, and I don't have the numbers in front of me. It was like two 80 with a four
- 50 slug or something. And since then two months, he has one hit. One hit on pitches, 95 or above, which
- is really bad in the playoffs where every fastball is like 95 or above. So anyway, the data I have that I'll
- be able to show is his bat speed. Isn't slower. Uh, but his late swing percentage is the
- highest it's been in the 24 months we have this data. His attack angle is the lowest in the
- 24 months that we have. This data is attack direction. So angle direction is pull opposite field, right?
- He's more opposite field oriented than any month we've got this data. And I think a lot of people don't
- think of all this as a timing metric, but it really all is because one of the reasons you can have a very low
- attack angle. So that's the direction of the bat at the point of impact is not you're swinging
- down. It's you're, you're making contact at the wrong time. Like if it's behind you and you haven't
- gotten to the peak of your swing, your attack angle is going to be lower, uh, just because of the timing aspect of it.
- And I think that's been a really tricky thing for everyone to kind of, you know,
- wrap their heads around. Uh, but yeah, long, long story short, his timing is all sorts of messed up.
- Well, while we're talking about, um, opposite field, you're like the wizard of these cool stats
- you see populated all around, but I think I saw one that was sourced to you about the Milwaukee Brewers, that they're the only
- team that on average hits opposite field. And every other team is pull oriented to
- varying degrees. What do you make of that? Is that, is that from you? Is that your, one of your stats or,
- or I think I saw it sourced to you. Yes, that was, that was me. I saw someone from it posted the thing
- I had and then later said it was for me. So that, yeah, I wrote about this in August.
- Um, and it's, this is not a stat I invented. I, I think if I have a skill, it's looking at big reams of data or
- leaderboards and having something pop out and saying, oh, that's, that's interesting.
- And it's not so much that they go opposite field the most. It's, um, it comes back to this attack
- direction stat, right. Where you look at it and say, however many degrees pull oriented or however many degrees
- up oriented. So you sack parade ace, right? A dead pull hitter, obviously very pull oriented.
- Um, and what I had at the time, and this was probably like six weeks ago, I assume it's still similar right now, is
- that every team in baseball, all 29 of the other teams on average had pull oriented
- swings at the point of contact and one team did, and it was the Brewers. And I don't think I've ever seen a
- more visual representation of zigging while everyone else is zagging or however you want to define
- that. I really like that for two reasons. Uh, one, it does show you what they do differently, like really effectively in that kind
- of chart. The other thing is, uh, not just the Brewers, also Tampa, also Cleveland.
- There are so many people dying to say, wow, they don't, they don't use data. They're they're old school.
- They've refuted all, everything we know. And they're going back to playing the game
- the way it was in 1979 or whatever. And it's like, I could not be further from the truth.
- But basically what they're saying is we can't beat the Dodgers at their own game.
- You know, we can't play like the Yankees. We're, we're not going to win that way.
- We are going to find different ways to win and we're going to be really good at it.
- And that's exactly what's happened for all of these teams. You know, it's, it's not just making contact.
- It's well, how are we going to make contact in a way that matters? A great stat.
- Um, it's not just that they go oppo the most. They have the highest slugging percentage of all
- every team in baseball when they go opposite field, which I think is really interesting.
- It's just finding a different way to win under the constraints they have of, you know,
- market, payroll, all the other stuff. Mike, you've just sounded like the line for
- a Moneyball movie. If we play like the Yankees in here, the coach's room, we can not beat the
- Yankees out there. That's exactly it. It's almost perfectly okay. Yeah, exactly.
- Can we stay, can we stay on that for a second? Cause the Brewers are. Um, fascinating.
- They've, they've outperformed expectations for 10 years in a row. I think it's the most outperformance we've seen
- in major league baseball. Can you give us some insight into their front office? I'm, I'm relatively naive on this stuff.
- I happen to know a fair bit about like the guardians. I've been, it's kind of the same from
- office for the last 10, 15 years. Love those guys. The Brewers have been under the radar for
- me and they shouldn't be. So can you give us a little bit about what is it about their front office
- that allows them to do as well as they have as a small market club? Yeah, there, there's no good, uh, quantifiable metric
- that I'm aware of for front office size. Like people have tried, but it's mostly looking
- at the press guide and not everybody's titles are exactly the same. So it's, it's sort of hard to know.
- Um, but there has been this screenshot floating around the class, a couple of days on
- social media of everyone in the Brewers front office who has some vaguely analytical title and
- it's like dozens of people, which is really funny. Um, so there, I don't know if it's
- bigger, smaller, like I'm, I'm sure the Dodgers is, you know, they have a huge one
- too, um, yeah, exactly. It's just hard to know for sure. But you know, it's funny what you said
- at the beginning where it's like, we've been underrating them for like 10 years.
- Right. And that's, that's true. And you know, why is that? Like, what do they do that the projection
- systems can't figure out? Number one, I'd argue that like the human eye hasn't figured it out either.
- Like nobody's picking the Brewers to win 103 games every year. And they, they do it anyway.
- Maybe one of these years we'll figure out to actually give them the respect that they've
- clearly earned at this point. Um, but I think it's a little bit about, let me say something else I heard
- last night, Mike, which is fascinating is that I think they've done well in the last
- like eight out of nine years and they can't keep players more than five or six years because then they get signed by bigger
- market teams. So to have the, it's not just that they're 103 this year, it's just the longevity
- of success is just incredible. Yeah. And I actually think that's exactly why the
- projection systems have a pretty hard time with them because you have teams like the Dodgers
- where it's like, I have a pretty good idea where Freddie Freeman's going to do this
- year. You know, I'm not going to be that shocked by what monkey bets is going to
- do this year. Well, now you got these guys in the Brewers. I've generally haven't been around that long.
- Obviously they've got a Christian yellow chair in there or whatever, but it's what projection system
- or human person thought that 30 year old journeyman, Jake Bowers was going to be like
- a top 10 hitter in the national league, you know, like they are, and I think that's why players like to go to places
- like this. Um, people are always assuming every player wants to be in New York and LA and
- certainly many do. Right. But a lot of players want to go where they can get the best opportunity to
- both play and improve. Tampa's great at that. Cleveland's great at that. Uh, Milwaukee's great at that.
- I mean, so many pitchers have gone to these places and figured out how to be better pitchers and improve their careers, improve their
- salaries and all this kind of stuff. And I'm not so naive as to say peril doesn't matter.
- Like, of course it does, but that's also what players want to, they want to go to a place that will help them improve
- their games and be better. And that's, that's one thing these teams are really good at.
- I think it's important that we have a shout out to, uh, Eric Babbitz. Eric was, uh, is the director of player
- acquisition right now for the Brewers. He's been in that role for a couple of years.
- He was one of my, my earliest students in one of the two or three that really got my, our whole sports analytics, uh,
- initiative here going at Penn. So it's great to see Eric's amazing success with the Milwaukee Brewers.
- So that's fantastic for us and the Brewers. Well, if the run continues, we need to
- have a Brewers watch party, Adi. Um, and yes, we do as it goes on. Um, Mike, we talk a lot about development.
- You just emphasize the development aspect of what they do. I'm curious about another aspect of analytics and
- sharp clubs, and that is the day-to -day adjustments and the matchup adjustments and the
- strategy within a series, um, I I'm pretty naive on that stuff. Like, what do you think is going on
- or what do you know is going on as the Brewers prepare for this Dodgers matchup?
- They've been their nemesis for the last few years. They've got a lot of experience with them.
- What are they doing differently? What, what did they try to do differently, strategically, tactically in this series?
- What does it even look like? What are the parameters? Yeah, I would say two things have changed
- a lot in the last couple of years. Uh, number one is simply the technology. Uh, you're probably all familiar with the traject
- pitching machine where you could mimic every pitcher's delivery, like actually see those guys on.
- And we had them, we had them on early, a number of years ago. Exactly. Right. So every, every smart team is using that
- now for sure. Um, the second thing is when you think about player matchups, whether it's in the lineup
- or pinch hitting or whatever, it's not just platoons anymore, right? Like for a million years, it was, well,
- you, you bring in the lefty pitcher to face the lefty batter, right? And that's, there's still something to that, obviously.
- Um, but teams are really getting into finding out what the shapes of the pitches are
- and then what the shapes of the swings are, because we can tell you, you can look this up yourself on baseball, Savannah, right?
- Who's got the biggest uppercut swing in baseball. It's Riley green of the tigers.
- Who's got the flattest swing in baseball. Uh, it's either junior camera or a hundred
- Kirk, right? And so you can look at these matchups and say, well, based on the fact that
- this guy's forcing fastball has great vertical rise, I don't think the uppercut guy is going
- to be a great matchup here. So I'm going to go with the guy with a flat swing. Obviously you're not going to take out Freddie
- Freeman because he's got an uppercut swing, like some guys are so great that this doesn't
- matter, but if you're looking for like the small edges and why certain matchups get made,
- it's not just platoon stuff anymore. And I really think, you know, managers get a little misjudged on this now.
- Cause that's all fans can really evaluate the manager on was bullpen usage and lineup decisions.
- And I don't know, did he get really mad if his team loses? And it's, it's based on so much more
- information than there ever used to be. And I think that's really interesting. And that's new.
- That's changed. Can you, can we open the lens a little bit and ask just broadly across baseball
- analytics? You have a whole buffet of these on your Sunday night show. Based on your experience at this stage, what
- do you think in the analytics world is over what weighted over attended to what's underweighted?
- What, what do you think is kind of underappreciated way of looking at baseball? No, that's really interesting.
- I think, um, I think overweighting is like assuming any one single number can tell you
- the answer to all of life's problems, you know, it's like, yes, you want to know
- if fastball velocity, cause that'll tell you a lot about a pitcher and you want to
- know a lot about swing speed, but it's like, you're, you're never, you can get as
- much advanced data as you want and all the smart people in the world, and it will get you closer to the answer, but
- none of this is ever going to get you to like the capital letters answer. And even if you had that, none of
- it matters. If it's like four people, like I was talking about this and it doesn't get to
- the players, you know, it's like you got to have someone who can not only command
- the respect of the player, and that's usually a former player because they've lived the life
- in ways like you haven't, um, but can also communicate it. Like if I come up with some amazingly
- in-depth 80 page document and nobody uses it, well, who cares? Like the whole point here is to win
- baseball games, right? Like that's what all of this is. It's just information. And a lot of it's just scouting tools.
- Like I'm sure a hundred years ago, somebody would have wanted to know what 18 year
- old Ted Williams's bat speed was, and you had to eyeball it. And a lot of this is just quantifying
- that kind of stuff. Yeah. So Mike, let me ask you a question. I noticed in yesterday's game, forget who was
- going to win the game. There was no chance that the Dodger pitcher was going more than five innings given the
- number of pitches the Milwaukee Brewers batters were taking and forcing them to throw.
- And there was one at bat, which might've been the greatest, one of the great at bats I've ever seen.
- I don't know if it was 13 pitches, 15 pitches, and the guy eventually ended up getting a hit, but is there any, do
- you guys report on stats about, I don't know, I mean, just even things that are more obvious about number of swings and pitches
- outside the strike zone or number of pitches taken or something like that. Cause I noticed the same thing when Tampa
- was playing the Yankees. There was no way Max Fried and Garrett Cole were ever going to go more than
- four or five innings in that game. Cause they were at 80, 90 pitches at the end of the fourth inning.
- And to me, that's a skill. Yeah. These guys are Yankees. If you can't tell they're the Yankee gear
- and I'll get my Yankee stuff over here right now, if you'd like me to. Mike, I am a New Yorker, but I'm
- not a Yankee fan. Oh, Mike's a Dodger. Mike's Mike's a Dodger. I thought you were, you were, you had
- a little Dodger career. Yeah, no, I, I am. I am a Dodger fan. Or I was, I guess it's hard to
- still be like a serious fan after working here for 10 years. But yeah, I, I'm still a Dodger fan.
- Um, the Jake Bauer is at bat. I was regretful that I missed it in real time because I was putting my seven
- -year-old daughter to bed in the midst of like six hours of baseball, but I did go back and check it out later.
- Yes. When, one of the things that stood out to me about the Brewers is that they
- don't swing just in general. They had the lowest swing area, I think in baseball this year and one of the
- lowest in the last 10 years. And that's a very analytical thing too. Like you might say, oh yeah, patience.
- We're, we're preaching patience. Like, that's cool. But I remember like three or four years
- ago, like, you know, you know, Cyrus is a good friend of mine. He wrote the athletic, like, Hey, there's a
- lot of evidence that says you should just not swing. Right. Tom Tango, who's one of our senior data
- analysts, it's like, don't swing. And like, that's the push and pull. That's not a super fun way to watch
- baseball. You don't want to go to a baseball game. Nobody swings, but if it helps you win,
- win games, do you think the Brewers care about that in any way? When they're walking the trophy down, you know,
- whatever the street is outside of their stadium. No, they don't care about that.
- And that's, that is a great example of using data to say, Hey, this is going to help us win games.
- Even though it sort of goes against like the popular theory. You know, it used to be like work
- pitches, get into the bullpen. Now it's like, I don't want to get in the bullpen.
- You got five guys who can throw 99, like from different arm slots. Um, but that, that is what the numbers
- show. And they've used that, you know, to great success because Yamamoto, who's like obviously a phenomenal
- pitcher, one of the best post-season pitchers of his generation. I don't think it's premature to say just
- really did not do that well because they, they worked him out. It was really impressive to see.
- Yep. I had to take him out. Was I wrong? I was watching on my phone. Did they actually take him out after that
- at bat? Forget just the, uh, the, um, outcome of the at bat, like he might've been up
- to 35 pitches that inning. So I thought my phone and there was a long pause that they, was he removed
- after that at bat? I don't remember, but there was a great graphic on the broadcast.
- I think the next inning where they showed the time and minutes of that one at bat.
- And it was like twice as long as the entire Dodgers inning at bat, which I thought was fantastic.
- Mike, you talk about the, the Brewers not swinging or plate discipline. Um, you, you, you say that like it's
- a philosophy fine, but you also have to be good at that. Right. And so are some teams just better?
- Are they more serious about how they train plate discipline? Are they, are there different techniques that some
- clubs have? I mean, it's a, it is a skill as well as a philosophy. I think it's, I think it's largely a
- player acquisition thing. It's pretty rare to see a guy in the major leagues massively change their plate discipline.
- That's one of the many reasons why peak or Armstrong season was so phenomenal because he
- actually did it. Like he's a pretty wild swinger there. There wasn't last year that much separating him
- from sedan Raphael of the Red Sox. Right. Both fantastic center field defenders, you know, both
- with some power, but it seems like too much chase and not enough plate discipline.
- And that didn't change for Raphael this year. And he had another up and down season
- and it did change for PCA and ended up having like the greatest season in the history of the Chicago cups.
- And I think that tells you the power of that, you know, swing at the pitches that you can actually put damage on.
- But if you can't, it's not always worth it. Like, I remember talking to a major leaguer
- 10 years ago at this point, and he was the first one who told me, um, and it didn't seem like this was true
- for most guys at the time. He's like, yeah, I'd rather swing and miss than make bad contact before two strikes, obviously.
- He's like, I'd rather, you know, live to fight another day than, you know, have some
- kind of valor in the sense that, well, I made contact, I grounded out. It's like, no, the, the saying here now
- is, uh, you'd rather be, oh, and one than Oh four, one. And I think that's, that's a really good
- way of putting it. Okay. We're going to have to cut you loose here momentarily. Can you give us one thing on the
- way? I'll give us one thing from each championship series that you'll be looking for over the
- next couple of days that you're interested in seeing how it plays out over the next
- couple of days. Yeah. I mean, for the national league, it's obviously like what happens with Otani.
- I don't think the Dodgers are going to be able to win without a fully functional
- show. Hey, Otani. And I don't think they're going to have that. You know, I think people are, or I
- was kind of shocked at how many people thought the Dodgers were going to just walk
- over in Milwaukee. And I guess that's partially because they did exactly that last year, but this just felt
- so different to me. Otani is not at full strength. The Dodger team just feels kind of old
- to be honest. And the Brewers are better than they were. Um, the other series, yeah, American league.
- Uh, I think what I'm watching for is can the, can Cleveland win in the same way that they did in game one?
- Like I favored the Rays. I think most people did and they simply shut down the Rays offense.
- You know, the big three at the top didn't do that much in the bottom of the Rays offense is generally not that good
- Mullins Homer aside. Um, and they did that without Gavin Williams, uh, or Parker Missick, which was really, really
- impressive because that was to me a big disadvantage and they won without their best starter
- on the mound, no disrespect to Foster Griffin, and now they got their best starters on
- the mound. And I think that's a huge advantage for them. And this is an inside joke, Mike.
- It's because they have momentum. They do until they don't. Yeah, exactly. Thank you, Mike.
- All right. That is Mike Petriello, major league baseball's director of stats and research and host of the
- stat cast alternative Sunday night broadcast on ESPN too. Very much enjoyed the visit, Mike.
- Enjoy this time of year. It's a big deal. Go have fun. I can't wait. Thank you guys very much.
- Yeah, absolutely. Mike Petriello. That has been the first half of this week's Wharton Moneyball.
- We still have a half to go. Come back and join us after the break. Welcome back.
- Welcome back to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to the second half of this week's show.
- Cade Massey here hosting with Eric Bradlow, Audie Weiner. Shane Jensen is away this week doing very
- Shane Jensen things. He'll be back. Some combination of us here every week, almost
- every week, 48, 49 weeks of the year, have been for 12 and a half years now. Open lines this half.
- We are just off the lines with Mike Petriello, director of stats and research at MLB,
- been there 10 years, runs that Sunday night alternative broadcast. Gentlemen, well, that was the first time with
- Mike. That was awesome. Anything stay with you? Anything you want to, want to elaborate on?
- Yeah, well, so one of the questions that one of the things you brought up, which
- is super interesting is the, the sort of advanced matchup calculation. So in the old days they would, they
- would just match up lefty and righty. Now it's been a long time since they've been doing just that.
- Now they look at, look at sort of types of pitchers versus types of hitters. But what Mike brought up was the extension
- of that, which on swing plane matchup, which is a, obviously a, a, a highly refined
- technical, but so my question would be is it's one thing to do that. It's another thing to judge whether it works.
- Right. So basically there's effect size calculations in all these things. And he mentioned Freddie Friedman, his effect size
- is so much bigger. He's so much better that you don't, you don't, you don't take him out because of
- a matchup. Yeah. But the other players, you have smaller effect sizes. I'm just curious to know, like, what is
- the effect size of these trajectory match up type things? And so people talk about these things, but
- as, as we, as statistician, I know Eric's an effect size guy. He said that on, on air enough times
- that how do I judge whether these things are really bring advantages relative to the lefty
- righty matchup? What do you need to, what do you need to establish that Adi? Just a thousand, ideally an experiment, but no
- one's ever going to do that. That would be great if we can randomize. This is a hell of a applied stats,
- right? You, you, these guys have to make real decisions on limited data before the effects size
- is established. Adi Weiner, the stats profs satisfaction, right? But they got to go, they got to
- be Bayesian of some kind. They've got to go. Well, no, they got to do some sort of causal inference.
- I mean, essentially do some adjusted regression type model to try to tease out a causal
- effect without actually doing an experiment and hopefully they have adjusted for the things that, that
- matter, like the, the confounding factors of the type of picture, the quality of the picture
- there, the quality of using, well, I don't know this, but here's a question like to
- what extent are baseball clubs with these massive, you know, 30, 40, 50 person analytics staffs,
- to what extent are they waiting for something to be definitively shown before they use it?
- Oh, they don't wait at all. They do it. I mean, you know, one of the things that I always tell my MBA students, we're
- not, we're not approving new drugs that might kill you if you take it wrong. We're talking about business decisions here.
- You go, you know, you do, you do a, or you do B, either of them are, are possibilities, you know?
- So you just have to pick the one. And that's actually something you don't have to
- wait for statistical significance, but before you decide to try this, this technique.
- That is 100% correct. Let me add one, let me add one other thing. You could make an argument that it's not
- just the repetition that Adi talked about that you want to see, but the lack of adjustment.
- And what I mean by that is let's imagine Adi knows if he pitches with a certain pitch plane that I, the batter have
- a certain swing plane, you're making an assumption, I cannot adjust my swing plane, or I
- don't know your pitch plane. So in some sense for like the analysis is actually a little harder than you might
- think, because I've got variation, good hitters, of course, can adjust their swing plane based on,
- matter of fact, that's what you do when you scout. But, but Eric, I think Mike would say
- that they actually know that as well. They know how flexible a batter is. I'm not disagreeing with that.
- I'm not, no, no, I agree, but that's got to be part of the calculation is all I'm saying.
- And matter of fact, what Adi, what Adi might say, Adi's here, but what Adi might,
- what anybody might say is if your best swing plane is A, no matter what happens,
- if I get you to move to swing plane C, I've won already. And that's my goal. If I could get every batter to have
- to adjust their swing plane based on the pitcher, then I'm going to win a lot more games than I would have otherwise.
- And I think that's a fair way to look at it. Yeah. So the other thing that, that struck me
- when listening to Mike was the traject, now it's amazing. We listened to the traject people years ago
- when they were just peddling their, their, their new brand new, it's everywhere now you can
- watch videos. And basically it looks like you're watching a pitcher throw out of the machine and the
- movement is created to look just like their machine. And the video is to look just like
- the pitcher with his release and release point and all that stuff. So real quickly, I just want to make
- for the listeners who may not know, this is a massive screen, digital screen where the
- image of the pitcher you're trying that you're, that you're mimicking is in the screen.
- And so you see his full windup or stretch or whatever, and delivery, even the delivery
- point is the same as the actual pitcher. And then the action on the ball is modeled to match exactly the action on his
- balls. And you can choose like, is this slider, is this a four seam or whatever?
- It's extraordinary. It's extraordinary to watch. And, and I understand that this is one
- of the reasons why the old habit that I'm sure Eric, you had, and I know I had a coming to a baseball game
- very early in watching batting practice is a no longer functioning possibility because they're all in
- underneath in the traject machine, not in the playing field, taking batting practice the old fashioned
- way. If you think back to some of our old guests, Theo Epstein and Jane Levy, we
- talked about how to make baseball more fun, and that would be to bring that batting
- practice back to the, to the field, but they're doing the traject. So my question would be, how much is
- a traject working, right? So here's a, here's an obvious application of an experiment.
- Have some of your batters randomly assigned to play traject and another to go out and
- play, take batting practice on the field, and over the course of a season, maybe, I
- don't know how much power you would have, see whether or not the traject makes them
- better. I don't know if, whether they want to experiment with that, but they seem to be
- going all in on one approach without, without hedging, right? We Bayesians would spend some, we do some
- mixed strategy until we're sure that one is better, right? Well, this is also the thing where baseball
- has the ability to generate their own data. This was a Billy Beane insight from way
- back at a conference in the early 2000s. They're the only sport that kind of, they
- can generate their own data in their form, in their farm clubs and in a way that's, that's close to real baseball, but doesn't
- have the burden of real baseball. And so you could be putting your minor league teams through exactly those kinds of experiments,
- but for the fact that these traject machines are expensive. So there probably aren't that many major league
- teams who are going to put traject machines in their farm clubs. Guys at a higher level, what's your level
- of, are you, how do you feel about these championship series without the Yankees?
- I mean, as a small market fan, I mean, a longtime Guardians fan and admirer and a relatively new Brewers fan and admirer, I
- am loving that these two teams are up. I know it's early and who knows anything can happen, but the prospect of a Guardians
- Brewers World Series, I know that the NBC or whoever carries it may not be very excited.
- I'd be thrilled with that. I'd be thrilled with either one of those teams winning this thing.
- And isn't it a, isn't it a victory even how well they're performed so far and the Rays, of course, the Rays are known
- as the best analytics shop out there. Isn't this a victory for analytics? I know the Dodgers are heavy on analytics,
- but they've also got the payroll. These other clubs are doing it without the payroll.
- I mean, I wouldn't mind, by the way, I wouldn't mind it being not that I have that much of a horse in the
- race. I wouldn't mind it being Rays Brewers only because those were the two best teams in
- the, you know, during the regular season. And I certainly wouldn't mind them being in
- the world series together, but I do have a soft spot for the Brewers. I think I like the way the club
- is constructed, obviously being a Yankee fan. I hate the Dodgers. So anybody that can beat the Dodgers, I
- would be happy with. And, um, it'd be interesting to see what types of adjustments the Dodgers make.
- Were they to get beaten and beaten soundly in this series? Because, you know, with a $400 million payroll
- capability, it's not like they're going to say, well, it just didn't work this year.
- No, they'll probably, you know, jettison a hundred million and sign a new hundred million for
- next season. You know, one thing you have to ask about the Dodgers is that they've invested pretty
- heavily in stars and stars are almost definitionally old. And you can get pretty easily a tail
- event, which isn't such a tail event, which is a lot of injury. And I think that's what they faced all
- season. And potentially if you say that Shohei Otani is really an injury, which I was wondering
- when we heard, when you talked about that, how often do bad, long, bad stretches of
- a star player turn out to be injuries? And it always seems to be that that's it's often.
- Um, so while we don't know yet, it's an injury. My guess is it is. Okay. Let me explore for a moment, your antipathy
- for the Dodgers. Do you share, Adi? Eric said, of course, because I'm a Yankees fan, I hate the Dodgers.
- Does that go back to our childhood in the seventies? It's all seventies. It's it's I can still name their entire
- team. It's ridiculous. Well, they're easy to hate now, even if you're not a Yankees fan, just cause they've
- won a couple of times in a row and they spend so much money. And they had these special deals when they
- came out of bunk bankruptcy that gives them additional revenue. There's lots of reasons not to.
- They are exploiting every, every advantage they have to, to fullest effect. And by the way, they are investing incredibly
- heavily in analytics. It's not just buying tires. That's right. That's right. Okay, guys, let's shift gears to other sports.
- We are five games in, four games in, five games into the NFL season, six weeks into the college football season.
- Let's stay with NFL first. Anything jump out to you? I mean, we had this morning game, this
- Eagles-Jaguars morning game that ended brutally. It was mid-afternoon here in Israel.
- It was great. I mean, look, the Eagles have done something that's extremely rare in professional sports.
- They've lost two consecutive games where they had over a 95% win probability near the
- end of the game. And that's hard to do. And so you now have to start, you know, obviously there's been a lot of heat
- on the coaching staff. Clearly they deserve a lot of heat for this last game, but even the previous game,
- look, I'd ask Adi, you know, he and Brian Brill wrote the paper on going forward
- on fourth down. Adi, did you run the previous, the Rams game through your guys' calculator where, let me
- just remind everybody, they're up 14, fourth in goal from the two, up 14 with nine
- minutes left in the game, they kick a field goal. They're up 17, more than two scores.
- If you have any sense, since you and Brian have run this calculation many, many times,
- what it might show, or maybe Cade knows what it shows. You're asking about two weeks ago.
- This is not this past week. I'm asking about the Rams game two weeks ago. I'm trying to decide, Cade, which is the
- more egregious Sirianni type of play, because both of them have gotten a lot of scrutiny
- and I'm just trying to wonder which one is the worst decision of the two. Which was the other one?
- Well, kicking the ball into the field of play with eight seconds left and the other
- team has no timeout. Kicking it out the back. They also screwed up their time management on
- the other side. They should have been able to kick their field goal with no time left.
- That's another mistake. They should have been able to run the rest of the clock out.
- That's another mistake. I agree. But Eric, real quickly on that, and I've missed the dialogue on this.
- I'm sure it's been unending, but on the kick or let them return, if I remember correctly, the famous playoff game with the Chiefs
- and the Bills a few years ago, when the Chiefs won with 13 seconds left or something, there was a lot of rhetoric on
- that occasion that had they not kicked it through the end zone, if I remember correctly,
- they would have at least worked through some time while he was returning the ball.
- I mean, talk about a tail event, a guy returning a kick beyond the 30 is a relatively rare event, much less 60 yards
- to the other side of the field. Yeah. I think the thought, I agree with you. I thought, I mean, obviously I've thought about
- that a lot. Like, you know, at least the good news. And by the way, Adi's mentioned a bunch
- of things. One is they should have made the field goal, their field goal, the last attempt.
- Secondly, you could argue about kicking it out of the back of the end zone. Third, if the, this is too much to
- ask as the guys running down the field, let him go five more yards and tackle him with nothing on the clock because no,
- no, I just said that's too much to ask, but I, I might as well throw it in there.
- What the hell you thought you were laughing. Cause you know, you've thought of it too,
- Cade, dismissed it as an impossibility. I got it. Okay. How much time was remaining when he was
- tackled? One second, one second. Oh my God. Adi, they were at the 40. If you let him run two more yards,
- one more, the guy was the last, the last chance. I mean, if he doesn't tackle him, no,
- no, no. There were three guys there. Cade, watch the play again. You could have let him run down.
- Well, you know, never scoring a touchdown there. I want to go back to your first
- question, which is the numbers were nine minutes to go up 14, fourth quarter, fourth and
- two, fourth and goal on the two. Is that what it was? Fourth and goal on the two.
- Goal on the two. And the difference between a 3% between a field goal and going for it.
- It's hard to imagine that it's, it's not very close in either direction. But I don't know the numbers offhand, but
- I will, I will look them up and we can post them to, to our X count or whatever we post these days, the
- delicacy, the vulnerability of your conviction, Eric, is the three scores is so, um, so, so
- stable in nine minutes, nine minutes is a lot of time still in NFL these days. Right?
- So three scores is not quite. On the other hand, it is three scores. That's categorically different than two.
- Yeah. I was just also referring to the number of possessions likely to still exist in that
- nine minutes, as opposed to what the other team's going to do in that nine minutes.
- And of course the Eagles letting the Rams drive 98 yards in one minute and 30 seconds did not help that, but that's that
- you can't think of that necessarily. When you're going. That's what the Rams probably have.
- How many drives have they made? Almost field's length and almost no time. I mean, we saw some last night.
- I mean, they're certain they're fully capable of moving very quickly. But by the way, the, the, obviously the
- talk in football this week was who made the worst decision, Sirianni or of course the
- commanders? No. I mean, there's no question. It's a commander. Commanders. Yeah.
- The commanders is much worse. We don't even need to, we don't even need to belabor that one.
- What about teams around the league? Um, as you know, we're whatever a quarter of the way through, um, anything jumping out
- to you, the, this, this, we had a number of big games this past weekend, the Ravens managed to win without Jackson, um, which
- is a big thing. Even Atlanta's kind of surging a little bit. Um, the Niners got their job done.
- Um, obviously the bills clip, the Rams, the Rams are below 500. I mean, you know, there's such a good
- team going into this weekend. They were top of most people's power rankings. They've only got three losses.
- They could get on a heater, but come on. I mean, two and three for supposedly the
- best team in the league. That's a rough start. It seems to me, and I'm not been paying that much attention to NFL this year,
- that there isn't this kind of like obvious victory for most of the, the teams are
- just compressed. I don't know what that's just a simple anecdotal garbage takeaways.
- Maybe some of the worst teams in the league, anybody can be beating anybody, um, really
- at any time. That's the way NFL feels. We have this, you know, this is kind of the point in the season where you
- realize, oh my God, the teams that we thought were terrible and weren't going to win
- just one over teams. We thought we were decent. The Niners stand out. They're five and Oh, I understand.
- Those are four and one chiefs. Um, the Ravens are four and one chiefs are four and Oh, I mean, there's, there
- are some of the usual suspects are still doing quite well at the top. I mean, so, um, I would think you
- would have to put a lot of probability. If you took the Niners, the Bills, the chiefs, the Ravens, these are a lot of
- the teams people would have picked before the season started, you know, Seahawks are three and
- two, it's not like they're in bad shape. I don't know if I gave you those, which one do we take those five teams
- or the other 27? Well, the, I'm giving you two in the NFC. I'm giving you the Niners and the Seahawks,
- and then I'm giving you the Bills, chiefs, Ravens. I mean, if they are, if they're all
- just worth 10%, which doesn't seem crazy, um, then you got half the, you got half
- the probability. Yeah, no, I, I think I would take those five. Um, but you know, we always know that
- that's the alluring side of the bet. That, that often it's too alluring. Um, okay.
- This coming week, it's a little bit of a less interesting schedule. It seems to me we've got, what do
- we have here? I had it up here. Mindigo. Plus we have scuttle at Denver. It looks like Denver is a night game.
- Yeah. Yeah. Denver better win that game. I mean, I think I, I forget there. Are they two and three?
- That sounds right, but I don't know for sure. Okay. There are the two and three or three
- and two, but they, you know, they just, they just beat San Diego, right? So they've got to pick up another victory.
- I watched a lot of that game. They shouldn't have won that game. They got lucky.
- I mean, something's going on with Justin Herbert. I mean, no kidding. Right. I mean, just a couple of passes were
- like, did I just throw that pass? Like, I mean, directly, directly to Denver. And I mean, whether it's an under throw
- by 10 yards under no duress, he threw one pass in the fourth quarter that was directly to the quarterback of the team.
- Um, it's Owen fires, chargers, uh, said San Diego, obviously Los Angeles. Um, guys, the game next week that caught
- my eye the most is Carolina coming into Philadelphia and only a one and a half point underdog.
- I mean, home field is worth more than one and a half. Even these days that's, that's saying that the,
- that the market thinks Carolina is about as good, maybe a little bit better than the
- Eagles. I mean, God bless Eric Eager and our friends down there in Carolina, but come on,
- really that's where we are. It's not where I'm at. I mean, to me, again, let me go
- back to my 95 plus percent. The Eagles are two plays away from being four in one.
- Like two easy plays. Not like always say, well, if I just pick this one off or something, no, no,
- no. Two easy plays from being four in one. Now they were beaten soundly by the bears.
- We have to count that they were beaten soundly by one of the games. I watched we have to count, but I
- almost think maybe Kate's got a point in the sense that if they were four in one and the only thing we changed were
- quote unquote, those two plays, they still only be a one and a half point favorite.
- Right, right, right. But markets usually see through that. They usually do. Maybe, I mean, Carolina people have been poo
- poo in Carolina for a while. We we've been pulling for him. They finished strong last year, but man, I
- just, that line that, I mean, I, I, I trust markets and I, that line just is eyeopening to me.
- Um, okay guys, let's talk a little bit about college football. College football came through its biggest weekend of
- the year last Saturday. Um, a ton of big games, some big upsets, kind of a prove it day.
- Some teams did, some teams didn't. For example, my long horns, Georgia one, one,
- I think, I think that the success rate, y'all have seen like Parker Fleming's other
- people do this bill Conley, I think does it says how bad did we get beat and it shows the difference in like success
- rate, you know, your team's success rate, offense and defense versus the other teams.
- And mostly when you win the net success rate is in your favor, but there's always
- some teams that get beat despite having a negative success rate, net success rate, and Alabama
- was one of them. I think Alabama was positive. I watched a lot of that game. Did you really go Eric?
- Really? Yeah, I watched college football too. I was going to say some, I mean, I watched a lot of the OUUT game,
- but I'm sorry. Alabama definitely is one of those teams where I now have a, I don't care win
- or loss the way they played. I have high expectations now for Alabama. There's no reason why they can't be one
- of the last four teams standing. Why not? One of the nice things about that for those guys is they haven't felt that way
- for a few years. And I do think that's one of the takeaways from last weekend. I was like, okay, we're, we're, maybe we're
- okay. We lost that game, but maybe we're okay. Maybe we're back a little bit, which is
- great for them. This coming weekend, a couple of big ones, Ohio state and Indiana, the defending champions, Indiana
- are hosting Ohio state. This is numbers four and five in the country. Ohio state is a three and a half
- point. Favorite. A lot of people are like, I don't care that Ohio state lost to Texas early
- on. We still think that's the best team in the country. One of the best teams in the country,
- Indiana. I just can't, I can't, I can't come over a lifetime of shorting Indiana, even after
- what was in the last two years. I'd short them in this game. I can't, especially after Nebraska game.
- Right. I mean, they, they could have easily lost that game. Last question. If Ohio state were to lose that game,
- should I assume they have no more wiggle room, like they can't lose a third game?
- You know, if they can't come into the season, people said, you know, probably the two
- teams that are most able to lose three and make the playoffs are Texas and Ohio state because of the schedules they play, including
- each other. And so I wouldn't take them off the table yet. If their losses are, if Texas proves to
- be worth a damn, which is an open question and Indiana stays where they are, those
- two losses are pretty understandable losses. Um, there's this, there's a sleeper great game,
- which is Notre Dame at BYU. Um, it's a night game and it's, it's only, it is a 10 point line, fair,
- fine. But BYU has proven to be at least on paper, they're sitting over there in the
- big 12, but they're the big 12 and a handful of these teams more than, more than expected competing with each other for the
- best team out there. So Texas tech, BYU, Utah, even Houston's been a little bit in the conversation and BYU
- is riding that mix. So they're made it all the way up to number eight in the country and they're
- hosting that game. By the way, we have our friend and listener. You've all wrote and strike often sends me
- the, the get in price for different stadiums of games around the country. That number, the most expensive ticket this weekend
- is not Ohio state, Indiana. It's not Tennessee, Alabama. It's not Auburn, Georgia.
- It is Notre Dame at BYU. It is out there at BYU. So it's going to be a fun night
- for those guys. Uh, Kate, should I assume the graph you put in the rundown on the right suggests
- that based on power rankings, Notre Dame's number one. Let me see what you're looking at.
- So what we have there is power ranking, AKA best. Notre Dame is the highest on the vertical
- axis. That's the Andrew Percival, Andrew Percival metrics consensus. That's a, that's a consensus of 10.
- Um, people like SP plus FBI, you know, well-established metrics and through week six, Notre
- Dame is number one. That's, that's true. It's tight up there, but yes, Notre Dame
- is the highest, but also the, that doesn't seem to be a shrinkage estimator to me.
- Yeah. It also suggests by the way that you would, maybe Rufus would be someone to put
- a Peabody would be asked about this. But if I look at where, if this is correct, if I look at where Notre
- Dame is and where BYU is assuming the Y-axis is meaningful, there's probably a miss,
- a slight mispricing on that game where Notre Dame looks to be maybe 14, 15 better
- than BYU, but the line is 10. If I had to guess at those numbers, I'd say it's 28 and 16.
- Okay. So that's not mispriced. Those are, the numbers are meaningful, Adi. That's, those are power rankings.
- They are intended to be expected points against an average FBS team on a neutral field.
- And so you should take this. I'm just wondering whether or not you're using in previous years to, to shrink back.
- I mean, Notre Dame has never been in recent memory. Not at least my recent memory, the top
- team. So no, we're not shrinking. We've got priors though. This is, these are all, most of these
- ranking systems have priors of some kind of probably all, how do they work them in?
- So, I mean, do they, do they do it on, I mean, this is where the, this is where the, the, the, the, uh,
- the, I guess the dough gets net if you will, or whatever cooking metaphor you want
- to, you want to properly apply here. Like what's underneath that hood that makes you,
- yeah. I mean, they're, they're not doing, they're not doing formal empirical Bayesian model, at least probably
- none of these 10 are, but they're all, the good ones are estimating the rate at which they, they, they, they work down the
- priors, but it's based on, you know, someone will take a data set, just ask how well do last year's stats predict next year's
- outcome, and then how does that fade over the course of the year as we get new information?
- So that's how Rufus and I have always done, but just to pressure on Notre Dame, Notre Dame was, um, has been quite strong
- the last couple of years and they have been thought of from day one this season as one of the best teams.
- The trouble with them is that they haven't played anybody yet and they don't have that
- many on their schedule. BYU being, I think one of only two serious games, Miami being the other one.
- But there's not much question. I don't think most people have much question. At least the potential is there for them
- to be one of the best teams in the country. Yeah. I think Miami, by the way, maybe the
- one thing surprising on this chart, we can post it on at W money ball. I'm surprised to see Miami as high as
- they are just because at least the narrative around Miami is that they're not as strong
- as in they were, let's say last year when they went to the national championship game,
- um, you know. Well, they, they, they, they lost a lot of guys, but they brought in a great
- quarterback. They basically stole Duke's quarterback, um, in what would have historically been a tampering case, but
- they get away with it these days. But those two teams are both considered from the beginning.
- There's been kind of a seven team group and you can see them there in the power rankings.
- This is Notre Dame, Alabama, Georgia, Ohio state, Miami, Indiana, and Texas. Big questions about Texas now, but that's been
- the group of seven for a while. And, um, nobody really Oregon was up there. There was eight really to begin the season.
- Oregon's drifted down LSU flirted, but keeps them getting knocked down. LSU got beat by Kentucky.
- That was a huge game this past weekend. So there's, there looks to be like a, now, you know, let's say six teams have
- people's confidence right now. Audie, Eric, Georgia, Alabama, Ohio state, Indiana, and
- Miami and Notre Dame. And all of those teams play each other. One was last weekend.
- One is this weekend. And one is about a month from now. Okay, fellas, um, I'll leave the football topic.
- I got an answer for Eric's old question about the Eagles fourth down decision from Ryan
- Brill, who texted me. Um, well, I asked him the question and, uh, um, it did lean the field goal,
- which I believe is what they did. Um, no, they went for it. Oh, they went for it.
- Oh, so Eric, your intuition was correct, but the uncertainties are overwhelm the decision.
- So, um, that's the, it's what we would have called analysts. Have some humility.
- Let the guys on the field make the decision they know best about the little things
- that matter. And part of the, one of the reasons why is if you think about the probabilities,
- the wind probabilities are pushed up around 98, very high nineties. Right. So, um, you're talking about very, very small
- differences, hard to have models that accurate. I see. That's interesting. Okay.
- One last note on the way out. Have y'all ever, I wish Shane was here. I've never noticed this frozen, frozen frenzy.
- This tonight in the NHL is the frozen frenzy. It's all 32 games. All 32 teams are scheduled to play.
- ESPN has a triple header and every, every team's on the ice. They're trying to bring some attention.
- They've got some whip around telecasts. It's a fun night to start paying some attention to the NHL.
- Right now I noticed that they're like five games in some six games in. It's like they have the same number of
- games as the NFL right now. And they're about to blow past them. Well, I think the one notable thing in
- the NHL, I don't follow it as carefully as other sports, but if I'm correct and you guys can correct me, aren't the Flyers
- having a historically bad start to the season? Like, I think they're not only 0-7,
- I think, but I think they've scored like the least number of goals in those seven
- games, like in something like the history of the NHL. Is that right? Is it that bad?
- I knew it was a franchise blow. I didn't know it was a NHL blow. It's really, really bad.
- They won a playoff series last year. What the heck? Yeah, they did. Well, it's early in the season.
- Let's hope something turns, but it doesn't sound very good. I wonder, at some point we'll say, when
- have we watched enough hockey to learn something, and we'll talk about hockey, but we're still
- a little early into that game. Well, why don't we wrap it, fellas, for Mike Petriello, our guest in the first half,
- for Adi Weiner logging in late night from overseas, for Eric Bradlow from his office in
- Huntsman Hall, for Shane Jensen in absentia, this has been Cade Massey, many thanks to Jacob
- Drodnik, our producer, for Deep Patel, the boss lady, and for you guys, the listeners, thanks
- for being with us. Come back and join us next time. Between now and then, enjoy your sports.
Brief Summary
Mike Petriello discusses baseball analytics, focusing on Shohei Otani, the Brewers' strategies, and the role of technology in the game.
Key points
- Introducing Mike Petriello. A longtime MLB employee and analytics communicator joins the show.
- Shohei Otani's Struggles. Mike discusses the underlying data behind Otani's performance issues.
- Brewers' Unique Strategy. Mike explains how the Brewers stand out in their approach to analytics and gameplay.
- The Art of Batting Patience. A discussion on the Brewers' low swing rate and its impact on winning games.
- Dodgers' Aging Roster. Analyzing the Dodgers' performance and age as a potential disadvantage in the playoffs.
- Analytics in Action. The success of teams like the Rays and Brewers showcases the power of analytics in baseball.
Episode highlights
- Introducing Mike PetrielloA longtime MLB employee and analytics communicator joins the show.“We're delighted to have you, Mike.”1:19Oct 14, 2026
- Shohei Otani's StrugglesMike discusses the underlying data behind Otani's performance issues.“His timing is all sorts of messed up.”6:17Oct 14, 2026
- Brewers' Unique StrategyMike explains how the Brewers stand out in their approach to analytics and gameplay.“It's just finding a different way to win.”8:29Oct 14, 2026
- The Art of Batting PatienceA discussion on the Brewers' low swing rate and its impact on winning games.“That's a great example of using data to say, Hey, this is going to help us win games.”17:50Oct 14, 2026
- Dodgers' Aging RosterAnalyzing the Dodgers' performance and age as a potential disadvantage in the playoffs.“I think the Dodgers are kind of old, to be honest.”20:59Oct 14, 2026
- Analytics in ActionThe success of teams like the Rays and Brewers showcases the power of analytics in baseball.“Isn't this a victory for analytics?”29:50Oct 14, 2026
- Eagles' Unprecedented LossesThe Eagles have lost two consecutive games despite having over a 95% win probability.“They've lost two consecutive games where they had over a 95% win probability.”32:26Oct 14, 2026
- Coaching Decisions Under FireScrutiny on coaching decisions as Eagles struggle with game management and play calling.“Clearly they deserve a lot of heat for this last game.”32:35Oct 14, 2026





